You are right about the hurdles doctors face in India, but sorry to burst your bubble, I am from one of India's leading medical colleges (in Delhi), and almost all of my batches toppers are staying back. You fail to understand that academic advancement and more money are not motivating factors for everyone. A lot of them stayed back for family and friends. US might be better in a lot of ways, but it's high time you stop portraying it as a magical land where all problems disappear. It just has a different set of problems and it's okay to choose what "drain" you want to live in.
Idk abt u but academic advances and money are still pretty big factors Im not doctor ofc but seeing the way doctors are treated in India is quite horrible compared to us I saw on twitter yesterday talking abt how he's seen 11 abuse cases of interns in last week alone In Delhi I've heard things are way nicer There's not much ragging there either (atleast in AIIMS) And delhi colleges don't represent the general situation of medical colleges themself
Common knowledge there's a nurses and other hospital tech shortage in the USA but not all states pay well. In California a nurse can work 4 days a week and make a good living because the Union is stronger than other states.
Brain drain is real. Cities like Kota are such a big example of the dark truth of the education industry. Education has become a business, not a passionate thing over here in India. It used to be like the fact that the intelligent and the determinant succeeded, now every run-of-a-mill dumb person wants to become a Doctor. And that's where Kota thrives from. As someone who studied in Kota, I can confidently say that the atmosphere in Kota is like a black-and-white movie, which is depicted well in Kota Factory. When I joined Allen for the first time, I was given almost the same demotivational speech they gave to the new students in the series. It took me 5 years to clear that depressional trauma. When I received the news of my passing of my final year exams, that was when I felt the happiest that I have ever been in my life. And I am just fed up with the PG competition over here too. If you have to study even harder, and still work your ass off to get a seat, why not just study for USMLE or other FMGE exams instead? That's the mentality of some of us, and I am glad that there are only some of us that think this way. Otherwise, it would be another hell of a competition there too. Anyways, a nice video as always, Dr. Manik! Your channel has always been an inspiration to me to write my own story.
competition is everywhere ; if you’re not meant for it, doesn’t necessarily mean the system is flawed, for a certain extent it is, but if you feel you can’t take it, why join medicine??? take sm bsc course or ba course and live competition free
The best part is work life balance I've just cleared my NEET UG examination and i know how usleess the system is over here I'll surely choose this USMLE PATHWAY OVER INDIAN PG
Me too but bhai wha bhi paise milte hai na md aur ms krte waqt jaise yha milte hai mtlb jitna milega paisa utne me college fee aur rhne khane ke liye ho jyega na us me
Simple statistical fact. India cannot support this exponential increase in Residencies, Doctors will be under employed and eventually be under employed. Mark my words.
Totally agree with you👍🏻 And it’s even difficult for fmg students in India for post grad and with limited seats and reservation. It’s better to do residency in USA or abroad.
@@KeerthiGowda-k6u don’t know what basis you’re saying that fmge students put only 0.666% efforts , is this proved by any experts or any research? Don’t talk shit without knowing. Maybe a few students may not be serious , but not all . There are students who are working really hard to clear fmge and then neet pg. I myself am one of them. Lately, I’ve realised that people like YOU are everywhere. Better not to give a shit😪
*People watch motivational videos whenever they feel low but I watch ur videos whenever I feel low. And I always get the energy and enthusiasm for my destination.Thanks Manik✨*
Sir, I am not a doctor, nor an aspirant of the same. I am in a completely different trajectory, but this is still heavily relatable. Most of Indian systems and intuitional procedure have become like a snail leaching off of the students until they bleed them dry. Due to this people go abroad so that they get leached off when at least getting paid good.
I am one of those rarest individual in our planet who have cleared both UK exams(MRCP UK +Neurology SCE- all First attempt) and finished all parts of USMLE(Step1+Step2+Step3- First attempt). I will say there is a vast difference in study approach and both are unique in so many ways. Especially Step3 USMLE is heavy biostatistics based exam on day 1 and PACES is a pure clinical skill exam on real patients with active illness. MRCP-UK according to me the best Internal Medicine exam in the world which is adequately standardized to the level of PG IM Training however USMLE is overall the toughest exam in the world due to the sheer intensity of exam stipulation such as number of questions in each single hour section of the exam as well as the length of clinical vignettes hence time plays a key role in solving a USMLE question. The BEST!
One point you didn't mention is even after getting admitted in government medical college you have to sign a personal bond with the state bond can range from 20 lacs to 50 lacs if you are not willing to work with the government ...so many Indian doctors have limited choice to go abroad because of those bonds ..
I totally agree with you sir,even for UG we are suffering in 2024,so I have also decided to take a private medical college as there is no option left to me in the current situation, which is kims Bengaluru(so i will be one of your junior), and then i have decided to go for usmle,hope to get guidance from you sir.🙏
80% of Indian population are aborigines and they get 50% only , while for 20% population who are well to do have 50% won't this suffice. How much more do u want ?
Yeah . Indian residency is a joke . People are literally doing menial work which a doctor is not supposed to do plus the toxicity and working hours are insane . The compensation for all this is really poor as well. Can’t wait to start my fellowship in US .
What makes you think ' you r one of the best docs in india " !! 99.99 percent who have left india for usa have been average students & the ones with more money to spare......money plays a bigger role in usmle journey , which most of us cant even think of affording it....india lacks research, india celebrates mediocrity...going to the usa for residency doesnt make you the best doc in india😂😂...come on!!!
USMLE can only be cracked if you are one of the best. Average ones can never get past the exam, bro😅 so it's obvious the brilliant ones are leaving for US. As for the money, well loans are available today and the amount of money even a fresher doctor in US earns, the loan will be cleared in 2-3 years
@@bharatmatakijay3449 bro , I'm afraid ...you aren't well informed in this matter properly ....you won't get loans to clear the exam procedure 😅 from any banks..do your research buddy
@@thestealth293 Well I agree with you on the part that money is required, but only money will not suffice, you got to be a good student to clear the exam. And btw, USMLE is no more the first choice for doctors in India nowadays. European countries, Gulf countries all are welcoming Indian doctors with open arms. It's about having around 2-3 lakhs (which isn't a big amount today) and clearing their entrance test. USA waise bhi jhand desh hai bhai, kaun kab goli maar dega pata nahi🤣 mein toh desh chhodna ho toh Europe yaa Gulf mein jaunga 😅
I'm a doctor. Both my children are doctors, from government medical Colleges. My experience, most of the doctors who go to USA are from private medical colleges who can afford expensive externships and wonderful LORs. So please DO NOT mislead Indian doctors today
This means that you don't have any idea in USMLE and the trend of people going to USA. I can say for sure that majority of the people more than 70-80% of the people take USMLE are from government medical colleges and premier institutes like AIIMS. Please open eyes.
Hey Namita mam , the harsh reality is , you and your kids are not capable to crack all steps of Usmle..... Usmle is not a joke.It is not only game of externship and LORs, it requires 25+ hours examination and 6+2 years hardwork patience & perseverance.
A good bulk of doctors are leaving India every year and looking at the conditions of doctors in India, this number is only going to increase. But USA is no more the top choice for doctors wanting to settle abroad. There are European countries as well as Middle Eastern countries which are giving great opportunities to doctors from India. Many are also going to certain African countries. The choices are a lot at this point, specially considering the fact that MD/MS/DNB are being recognized by majority countries abroad. So if someone wants to leave, USA is no more the best option, according to me.
Hi Dr Madaan, glad to see u doing well. Noticed in the video that u displayed a job offer u had got in Hershey. Is Hershey an underserved area ? I thought Indian citizens/IMGs should serve in underserved areas for 2-3 years after residency. Or have they changed the rules? Edit : Hi Dr Madaan.. awaiting ur reply :)
I don’t get the concept of reservation at PG level that too 60% and i am sure its going to increase by the current government for votes…At UG level its fine we somehow fight and get the seat but it gets very difficult at this stage…Rather than putting so much of hardwork and time its better to prepare for USMLE
Reservation in Higher Education and Cost - USA and other countries select only by Merit & no cost involved - The Residents get $ 4-5 K from which they CA live & learn - after Board certification 3 years of underserved area work with very good pay
The very fact that you can afford an exam of 10-15 lakh rupees after doing mbbs from a private college. You are in no position to say that something unfair is being done to you in name of reservation. Your parents already “bought” a medical seat. 90% of those reservations kids don’t have this much money to afford a private medical seat or attempt usmle . It’s very easy to criticise system on your country when you are not used to struggle because your rich parents gave you a very protected environment.
Buying a private MBBS seat and completing course alone makes upto 50lacs and to spend for usmle journey another 25-30 lacs , so whole sum of one crore . If both parents are doctors then definitely some one can take such huge risk in life , a middle class people can't afford for loans to pay for their future uncertained journey. Very misleading ,unless u have good bank balance u can't afford to take such risks.
Exactly. Mostly above average and average students go to usa most toppers are still in India. None of the top 25 students from my college went abroad, only few average ones.
@@dr_adityabhaskar But I am saying that facts and figures favor India. Indian medical tourism is now a 22 billion dollars industry and only expected to grow. We can work hard here also and get a good life, though work life balance is a big issue here
Hello good afternoon sir I am fmge student i have done my MBBS FROM RUSSIA PLEASE PLEASE MAKE A VIDEO HOW A FMGE STUDENT CAN GET INTO USMLE PLZ PLZ 😢😢😢
What's the use of cutting of technology when the country is run down with all time gun violence, racism specially now agianst indian, with high housing prices , foods . I am not saying that usmle is bad its way above our neet pg. But nonetheless working in a another country has its fair share of struggle and dangers. Specially in us now
The pain I went through for my ug seat as a general category really helps me be decisive for my future where I don’t want to go through that again. I’m studying in karnataka too btw :)
Could you please share a little about the penn state family medicine program ? I’m an American citizen who is doing mbbs in India and I’d prefer to go back to Philadelphia for residency
India is good not so bad but usa also has a darkside Moving to usa better option but for that u should financial stable Without money usa is bad option and residency very hard to match
Dude, please stop increasing the competition… You've cleared your way, and now you're posting videos which are going to make USMLE competition similar to NEET-PG. It will make life hell. Please, Manik Bhaiyaa, don’t do this. 😢
@@codingtiger290 its pretty easy nowadays lol. Most AMGs want to do surgical and interventional internal medicine now. Leave fam med, int med and psych to the imgs, they'll get replaced anyway by midlevels and AI
If you are coming here to criticise India let me tell you India is still economically weak as compared to america .... usa can spend billions on healthcare , india can't which ultimately lead to delays , corruption , unethical practices , insufficient medicines, non existent research..... we can either crib about it or work to repair it
I love India and it's people. The issue so that the currently political system doesn't support such developments and therefore I want to give you the advice that I give to my younger brother, take care of yourself before anyone else
India has money... just check and compare budget allocations for healthcare with other countries.. bottom line.. our govt just doesn't care about doctors.. be it conducting a single exam properly or making our work areas safer
@@manikmadaandon't give false information to young people...American comes to india for cheap treatment..America is going bankrupt and it is stupidity to go America now.
Bro overburden are US doctors too . Only the reservation point is valid . Else everything is almost same in every region of doctors . They are also underpaid when compared with dollar and the amount of tax that US govt take is impeccable .
Before criticising India know about china where salary of specialist is only 100000 per month. Why to complain with USA or any nation. Definitely we need to improve but it seems you are much full of hatred towards India . I am gen category neither I have money to go USA nor I will work there I love my nation I will stay here .
I just have a doubt, that what if not matched ,than what after that, because we are giving 1 to 2 years of time to this exam and money too,and if still not matched than it would be quite demotivating ,plz tell me and guide me if you can
I didn’t get matched this year. Start working on your plan B after you submit your application. Keep in mind to get in the states you should have a very good profile or a strong connection. I have seen ppl with below avg scores and profiles getting matched due to connections.
same question i am an old graduate preparing for steps ,investing time money and energy and this fear of not matching into residency just bothers me so much
@@STstars101hope you match in the next cycle mate . Improve your cv & establish contacts as much as you can , pour in some money & go do paid observership...hope you succeed in this journey! Don't forget to help me get fellowships later on !! 😂
Make an interview with Sahin Isha , west bengal rank 5 (2014) , Medical College Kolkata, currently in USA if I'm not wrong, doing PG in Internal Medicine.
Sir I am a chartered accountant from India then went on to get international degrees like:- CPA,CIMA,ACCA,CFP and now, I am working in hedge fund (earning in 6 to 8 digits annually, varies on basis of performance but 750,000$ is minimum) I can guarantee CA having no reservation is what made CA a good course and engineering and medical institutions should look how ICAI keeps cost at 20000/- and also provides library with free meals in each district of India (having multiple libraries in Laxmi Nagar, highly dense area) so,engineers and doctors are creators of economy and CA are facilitators. It’s quite disheartening the engine of healthy economy is in drain because of reservations……mind you there is no reservation in CA because CAs of politicians then will leak your financial info so this keeps CA protected from reservation.
Private practice for doctors in cities in India is competitive, but come to inter area where I am and here the gynaecologist is earning 10-12 lakhs per month.... And cost is living is real really low compared to usa or eu, just that plus you can expand into business ventures like crazy with minimal competition, just that if you are hell bent on living in metros, you won't earn much.... This is not so in usa or eu, also you spend far more number of years Just in hospital training in western countries than in in India that when you earn youre actually too old. Usa work life balance is bad, eu is best, in india if you are in job it's bad, but if you have chain of clinics or are owner, it's completely on you, so students and doctors should have a clear view, in usa as an Indian you will only get internal or family medicine whether you like it or not and that too after lot of uncertainty, getting others isn't impossible but very very difficult... And you'll mostly have to live in underdeveloped part of usa not the better once. Add to that the loneliness and having money but no time and people to spend it on, with your hair turning grey, 2 lakh initial savings isn't that rosy, if you consider the freedom of practice and untouched business opportunities here in India. Yes, if you can save 6 lakh and above in usa per month it's a good option... Am a doctor in odisha, India. Mbbs only... And it's just my opinion. Also those who really want quality of life should choose Germany instead of usa pg, eu is far better to live and raise kids than usa, at any point of time also social security benefits are just awesome. And it's very very easy to get into eu than usa or even neet pg in India. All the best
Toxic and unsupportive working environment , overtly streched duty hours many of which comprises of mundane activities, and many institutes in India is just incapable to expose the post graduate students to latest skillset and interventions to their concerned domain, these are mostly the reasons due to which almost 1200 pg residents are compelled to drop out from pg course inspite of hefty seat leaving bond amount. If there were no seat leaving bond amount, I can say that more than 50% of pg residents wd hv left from the course. These r some snapshots of pathetic state of affairs of doctors in India. Lastly work life balance is a cruel joke 😂😂 in India.
Can graduates of Russian medical schools give USMLE. A lot of Indian students go to CIS countries and Russia for their Medical education. Is that qualification eligible for USA.
Good evening doctor. In the beginning of your video you mention you did your ug in Kim’s Bangalore. I would be extremely grateful if I could get a honest feedback regarding the college from you. Please
You have said in your previous video about AMC, Where you can still earn more than US If that’s the case, doesn’t Australia seem better for doing residency
I think both are great. US is more streamlined with USMLE, but AMC is a bit vague. I am working on new videos on AMC to clarify the pathway further for students
@@manikmadaan thank you for the reply I graduated this year and I find many in the same boat as me as which pathway to choose better USMLE and AMC. It would be very much helpful if you could also add about the chances of getting surgical specialities in Australia
@@manikmadaan yes pls it will be helpful🙏.. cant choose btw the two but the only thing is in amc if we get job after clearing 1st part i am getting more inclined towards giving amc but after that i dont know how is it is better than us or amc is better in future .😞 on the other hand usmle is such a big process one has to go through fear of wasting my money what if i fail to clear even one of steps them pls guide 🙏
Hello sir my college name is there when I search in wdoms but when I go in sponsor notes nothing occurs ! It’s written still operational ! So what should I do I do ? M I eligible for the registration !
I know many students who do not get good rank in neet pg but still manges to get good clinical seats through usa usmile .competition is stiff in india than usa and many of them who cannot compete here in India go abroad
USMLE is tough , competition and unnecessary reservation doesn't make it tough , it is the failure of indian exams they only see your rote learning not even clinical questions!
You mean remains doctors in India are not best , that not true there are some doctors who are better than them but due to financial ,family issues stay in India.
Vai woh sabk aur bhi jyada hita hya, AMAN TILAK ka channel me dekh ki, waha par ek neurosurgeon ne bola tha, bhai ro doge sallery sunke.🙂 That's America not India 😂
@@SagarPramanik1 reality esa nhi hai bro ,depends up o the place ,working place,in india also few doctors earns 20 to 30 lks per month but not all doctors
Dont get into the trap and dont say best of the brains going ohtside. In my batch best of the brains are here only. And after u see situatiin in canada, dont leave ur country anything can happen in future. Apna desh apna hi hota hai. U never know what will happen in future so its better to stay in our own country. Plus i understand people earn more there but what abiut social life? You will never be known by anyone, no respect, no relatives, no family. Living alone in world , going to cafe and living with a cat is not everyone's dream though.
Exactly who make memes on these things could not understand that in the end we have to live our lives and why we should not choose better for us. Hectic pg exams ug exams already frustates out too much and if you fail then we all well know how even parents start to become toxic like relatives
Sahi baat hai. India me log theke waale ko namaste karenge, respect denge. Par agar sath me doctor ka clinic hoga to koi b nahi puchhega. Indian me ek problem aur hai, log khud se hi Google search kar ke apna ilaj karna shuru kar dete hai. Fir jab thoda time k baad case kharaab ho jata hai to doctor k paas jate hai. Fir agar result utna positive nahin aayega to doctor ko picheey se galat bolenge. Apni galti nahi dekhenge na us medical store wale ki jo tukke marte hai ilaaj karne me. India me medical field is very tough in the upcoming years. Also India's gdp expenditure on medical field is very low. Sir ne AYUSH doctors ki baat kari starting k pointers me. But kuch ayush doctor bhi responsibility lete hai. Inko bhi apne respective state medical boards se register hona padta hai. Apna clinic chlane k liye CMO,DI etc. se permission leni padti hai. They come under biomedical waste act, pollution acts, and all other medical acts. They are regulated. I want to add ASHA wrkr program. Aap isse kaise ignore kar sakte hai. 10-12padhi hui asha worker pcm, albendaxole, etc. provide kya prescibe bhi karti hai unofficially. COVID TIME pe hmne dekha hai. Aur shayad auron ne bhi dekha hoga jb azithr, pcm vit c zn etc otc ki tarah bik rahe they. Congratulations to you sir ki aap USA me ho. There is no work life balance in india in medical field. And the indian doctors are highly low paid. Compare the annual income of India's top doctor with that of other professions. Example with acting, cricket, software, hardware, automobile, engineers. They all earn more than doctors. I have seen doctor fee in india in private from 50-500 per patient in opd. And more than 80% of them are complicated or self-doctor, via Google. Good luck sir for your future.
India has merit based exams. Usa works on networking. The backbencher in your class may get the best college just because his daddy knows someone. Talk about inequality
@@snape1596 yes heard the same thing from some sc st candidate that upper caste get good colleges because their parents have political influence but he himself did not qualify the exam.
@@mrrockbottom Actually even they know that a significant no of people from upper caste struggle in getting into colleges and then jobs, due to financial constraint and reservation policy. Even they know that the present generation who are actually suffering has nothing to do with casteism. But, then they will still justify with every illogical logic because they know how important reservation is for them.
if you enjoyed this one, consider subscribing. it's free :)
Nooo
dont you have problem with j1 visa
brain drain is much better than brain in drain 💯
Wow kya baat bol diya vi tune .it's a quotation
Rajiv Gandhi
Promote brain drain beacuse quality of life matters
Promote brain drain beacuse quality of life matters
I can't agree more 😊ekdumsahi
60% caste reserved seats , Rest 40% also include majority private colleges
Imagine preparing for NEET as an general candidate
Indian education system☕
30% for girls in neet??
Ye jyada ho gaya
There's no reservation for girls in Neet.kashmir aur rajashthan m Sayed dete hai par 30% nahi.juth mat spread kiya kar
what about ews reservation??
@@pranav_755 What's cutoff for sc and st and what's cutoff for EWS?
You are right about the hurdles doctors face in India, but sorry to burst your bubble, I am from one of India's leading medical colleges (in Delhi), and almost all of my batches toppers are staying back. You fail to understand that academic advancement and more money are not motivating factors for everyone. A lot of them stayed back for family and friends. US might be better in a lot of ways, but it's high time you stop portraying it as a magical land where all problems disappear. It just has a different set of problems and it's okay to choose what "drain" you want to live in.
Idk abt u but academic advances and money are still pretty big factors
Im not doctor ofc but seeing the way doctors are treated in India is quite horrible compared to us
I saw on twitter yesterday talking abt how he's seen 11 abuse cases of interns in last week alone
In Delhi I've heard things are way nicer
There's not much ragging there either (atleast in AIIMS)
And delhi colleges don't represent the general situation of medical colleges themself
Common knowledge there's a nurses and other hospital tech shortage in the USA but not all states pay well. In California a nurse can work 4 days a week and make a good living because the Union is stronger than other states.
Brain drain is real.
Cities like Kota are such a big example of the dark truth of the education industry. Education has become a business, not a passionate thing over here in India. It used to be like the fact that the intelligent and the determinant succeeded, now every run-of-a-mill dumb person wants to become a Doctor. And that's where Kota thrives from.
As someone who studied in Kota, I can confidently say that the atmosphere in Kota is like a black-and-white movie, which is depicted well in Kota Factory.
When I joined Allen for the first time, I was given almost the same demotivational speech they gave to the new students in the series. It took me 5 years to clear that depressional trauma. When I received the news of my passing of my final year exams, that was when I felt the happiest that I have ever been in my life.
And I am just fed up with the PG competition over here too. If you have to study even harder, and still work your ass off to get a seat, why not just study for USMLE or other FMGE exams instead?
That's the mentality of some of us, and I am glad that there are only some of us that think this way. Otherwise, it would be another hell of a competition there too.
Anyways, a nice video as always, Dr. Manik! Your channel has always been an inspiration to me to write my own story.
competition is everywhere ; if you’re not meant for it, doesn’t necessarily mean the system is flawed, for a certain extent it is, but if you feel you can’t take it, why join medicine??? take sm bsc course or ba course and live competition free
@@Mishti23269 s h u t . if people took care of their health. there would be no need of healthcare.
Already there's too much competition in USMLE and PLAB too... all the best matching a residency
@@reginageorgetownuni Thanks, my man.
My logic is that I have to fight wherever I go. Why shouldn't I try for the FMGE/USMLE route first?
Paper leak is also responsible for this
The best part is work life balance I've just cleared my NEET UG examination and i know how usleess the system is over here I'll surely choose this USMLE PATHWAY OVER INDIAN PG
Yes bro same❤
Me too bro,I am a neet ug 2024 survivor too 😅.will also choose usmle pathway for sure
Me too but bhai wha bhi paise milte hai na md aur ms krte waqt jaise yha milte hai mtlb jitna milega paisa utne me college fee aur rhne khane ke liye ho jyega na us me
@@CineverseWithRaj u will get 4.5 lac per month during md
@@titly1175 let's just agree USA UK AUS IS BETTER THAN INDIAN PG IN ALL TERMS
Simple statistical fact.
India cannot support this exponential increase in Residencies, Doctors will be under employed and eventually be under employed.
Mark my words.
Totally agree with you👍🏻
And it’s even difficult for fmg students in India for post grad and with limited seats and reservation. It’s better to do residency in USA or abroad.
Exactly
Son i know you fmge people how you get degree and ur knowledge u put 0.666%effort exam compare to Indian exam like u expect seat in pg 😅😅
@@KeerthiGowda-k6u don’t know what basis you’re saying that fmge students put only 0.666% efforts , is this proved by any experts or any research? Don’t talk shit without knowing. Maybe a few students may not be serious , but not all . There are students who are working really hard to clear fmge and then neet pg. I myself am one of them. Lately, I’ve realised that people like YOU are everywhere. Better not to give a shit😪
*People watch motivational videos whenever they feel low but I watch ur videos whenever I feel low. And I always get the energy and enthusiasm for my destination.Thanks Manik✨*
Sir, I am not a doctor, nor an aspirant of the same. I am in a completely different trajectory, but this is still heavily relatable. Most of Indian systems and intuitional procedure have become like a snail leaching off of the students until they bleed them dry. Due to this people go abroad so that they get leached off when at least getting paid good.
Sir, now some "RESERVED CATEGORY NATIONALISTS" will abuse you as you touched the Reservation point.
I ALSO WANT TO ESCAPE THIS HELL FROM HERE.🙏
I'm reserved category candidate too and I want to go out of here as well Lol
@@RoronoaZoro-ec5gl Bro, had I been from even OBC category leave alone SC/ST I never would have even think of leaving India.
True, some are delusional and depressed that they can't take USMLE or any other chance of getting out of this country.
@@MEMERAOBAMBEDKAR sir I'm from SC category and I'm willing to go out. Please Don't think only unreserved want to go out.
@@RoronoaZoro-ec5gludhae bhik nahi mang paoge bhai jake koi faida nahi.
Same reality in the Philippines. Bad residency training conditions force people to go to UK/Aus/US.
I am one of those rarest individual in our planet who have cleared both UK exams(MRCP UK +Neurology SCE- all First attempt) and finished all parts of USMLE(Step1+Step2+Step3- First attempt). I will say there is a vast difference in study approach and both are unique in so many ways. Especially Step3 USMLE is heavy biostatistics based exam on day 1 and PACES is a pure clinical skill exam on real patients with active illness. MRCP-UK according to me the best Internal Medicine exam in the world which is adequately standardized to the level of PG IM Training however USMLE is overall the toughest exam in the world due to the sheer intensity of exam stipulation such as number of questions in each single hour section of the exam as well as the length of clinical vignettes hence time plays a key role in solving a USMLE question. The BEST!
One point you didn't mention is even after getting admitted in government medical college you have to sign a personal bond with the state bond can range from 20 lacs to 50 lacs if you are not willing to work with the government ...so many Indian doctors have limited choice to go abroad because of those bonds ..
I totally agree with you sir,even for UG we are suffering in 2024,so I have also decided to take a private medical college as there is no option left to me in the current situation, which is kims Bengaluru(so i will be one of your junior), and then i have decided to go for usmle,hope to get guidance from you sir.🙏
what was your rank , i am also considering the same college
Marks should be 590+
samee, scored 599...first attempt, gotta get into pvt med clg and prep that way too....this whole education system is not gud
@@viranthvenkatesh2436is the question paper very easy or your gen of neet ug aspirants very smart cz in our time rarely people used to get above 600
Reservation is 60% now , and congress wanted to increase it more if they would have won
Bro 65% In Neet pg and Even Ini have internal quota now 50% of so called General seats are reserved
I'm from reserved category but also wants to move abroad
Trust me bro 🙏
80% of Indian population are aborigines and they get 50% only , while for 20% population who are well to do have 50% won't this suffice. How much more do u want ?
@@mohanmohan-jr7zf just want a merit based system
Due to paper leak issue in india 😢😢👊🏼👊🏼
Unfortunately this video is now more relevant after the latest Kolkata Doctor case😥😥
i heard about that. It's so sad that our nation still faces these issues
Yeah . Indian residency is a joke . People are literally doing menial work which a doctor is not supposed to do plus the toxicity and working hours are insane . The compensation for all this is really poor as well. Can’t wait to start my fellowship in US .
What makes you think ' you r one of the best docs in india " !! 99.99 percent who have left india for usa have been average students & the ones with more money to spare......money plays a bigger role in usmle journey , which most of us cant even think of affording it....india lacks research, india celebrates mediocrity...going to the usa for residency doesnt make you the best doc in india😂😂...come on!!!
USMLE can only be cracked if you are one of the best. Average ones can never get past the exam, bro😅 so it's obvious the brilliant ones are leaving for US. As for the money, well loans are available today and the amount of money even a fresher doctor in US earns, the loan will be cleared in 2-3 years
@@bharatmatakijay3449 bro , I'm afraid ...you aren't well informed in this matter properly ....you won't get loans to clear the exam procedure 😅 from any banks..do your research buddy
@@bharatmatakijay3449 i disagree
@@thestealth293 Well I agree with you on the part that money is required, but only money will not suffice, you got to be a good student to clear the exam. And btw, USMLE is no more the first choice for doctors in India nowadays. European countries, Gulf countries all are welcoming Indian doctors with open arms. It's about having around 2-3 lakhs (which isn't a big amount today) and clearing their entrance test. USA waise bhi jhand desh hai bhai, kaun kab goli maar dega pata nahi🤣 mein toh desh chhodna ho toh Europe yaa Gulf mein jaunga 😅
Perfect motivation doesn't exist
- 19:14, really
I'm a doctor. Both my children are doctors, from government medical Colleges. My experience, most of the doctors who go to USA are from private medical colleges who can afford expensive externships and wonderful LORs. So please DO NOT mislead Indian doctors today
Please grow up Madam
How many patients have you treated till now?
I am from aiims most of my seniors and many of juniors are settled in USA, they keep cribbing though about USA
This means that you don't have any idea in USMLE and the trend of people going to USA. I can say for sure that majority of the people more than 70-80% of the people take USMLE are from government medical colleges and premier institutes like AIIMS. Please open eyes.
Hey Namita mam , the harsh reality is , you and your kids are not capable to crack all steps of Usmle..... Usmle is not a joke.It is not only game of externship and LORs, it requires 25+ hours examination and 6+2 years hardwork patience & perseverance.
@@HarryConfidewhat do you mean by 6+2 years
A good bulk of doctors are leaving India every year and looking at the conditions of doctors in India, this number is only going to increase.
But USA is no more the top choice for doctors wanting to settle abroad. There are European countries as well as Middle Eastern countries which are giving great opportunities to doctors from India. Many are also going to certain African countries. The choices are a lot at this point, specially considering the fact that MD/MS/DNB are being recognized by majority countries abroad. So if someone wants to leave, USA is no more the best option, according to me.
Can you pls enlighten me regarding the countries which recognize our indian pg degrees?
So true.... And all these scams, they hurt my emo for the country. Sad to see what is happening
You really motivate on my journey. you are my best 🎉
I'll never forget your contribution to my life where ever i reach 🙌✨️🖤
12:08 in india you dont need that you can prescribe paracetamol ibufren all day being a quack and get called daxab by kids adults and elders
😂 💯
Even if am not Indian, thank you for your explanation, your kindness and most of the explanation and encouragement. I hope to make it as well 🙏♥️
Sir please make videos step by step that would help UG students prepare and to crack USMLE
changing Indian medical landscape one VIDEO
at a time
Great Dr Manik. Ur videos wd be eyeopener of Indian Medical Graduate.
Hi Dr Madaan, glad to see u doing well.
Noticed in the video that u displayed a job offer u had got in Hershey.
Is Hershey an underserved area ? I thought Indian citizens/IMGs should serve in underserved areas for 2-3 years after residency.
Or have they changed the rules?
Edit : Hi Dr Madaan.. awaiting ur reply :)
Awesome video very thankful ❤
Thank you ❤manik,ug residency, confused to. Make a move 🎉it showed some clarity
I don’t get the concept of reservation at PG level that too 60% and i am sure its going to increase by the current government for votes…At UG level its fine we somehow fight and get the seat but it gets very difficult at this stage…Rather than putting so much of hardwork and time its better to prepare for USMLE
If your already post ug
U already make more money than general people
And yet u still get reservation...
I just can feel how important it is to you to flex your scores. Find good friends or family, you wont have to do that.
Reservation in Higher Education and Cost - USA and other countries select only by Merit & no cost involved - The Residents get $ 4-5 K from which they CA live & learn - after Board certification 3 years of underserved area work with very good pay
The very fact that you can afford an exam of 10-15 lakh rupees after doing mbbs from a private college. You are in no position to say that something unfair is being done to you in name of reservation. Your parents already “bought” a medical seat. 90% of those reservations kids don’t have this much money to afford a private medical seat or attempt usmle . It’s very easy to criticise system on your country when you are not used to struggle because your rich parents gave you a very protected environment.
Buying a private MBBS seat and completing course alone makes upto 50lacs and to spend for usmle journey another 25-30 lacs , so whole sum of one crore . If both parents are doctors then definitely some one can take such huge risk in life , a middle class people can't afford for loans to pay for their future uncertained journey.
Very misleading ,unless u have good bank balance u can't afford to take such risks.
Exactly and he is saying his parents made bare minimum😂
Aa gya reservation wala🤡
MANIIIKKKKKKKKKKKKKK.....Become my mentor and my life is yours.
i am here to help. my life is yours
Bullshit India’s best doctors ,
It all depends on whether you want to stay in India or settle in another country .
Dude not every smart brain is quitting India. In my college most of the toppers chose residency in the country, only a handful chose to go abroad.
Exactly. Mostly above average and average students go to usa most toppers are still in India. None of the top 25 students from my college went abroad, only few average ones.
@@PreMal2023 Yepp
Handful with money to spare !!!
Getting some marks more than others don’t make them gods. Ground reality - they also as broke as you. It’s coming from a doctor passed out from MAMC
@@dr_adityabhaskar But I am saying that facts and figures favor India. Indian medical tourism is now a 22 billion dollars industry and only expected to grow. We can work hard here also and get a good life, though work life balance is a big issue here
Hello good afternoon sir
I am fmge student i have done my MBBS FROM RUSSIA
PLEASE PLEASE MAKE A VIDEO HOW A FMGE STUDENT CAN GET INTO USMLE PLZ PLZ 😢😢😢
JFK: ask not what the country has done for you, ask what you have done for the country
Doctors: Ghanta 😂
These type of videos motivates 😃
How do you know those leaving are the "best doctors"?
A lot ❤❤ for your guidance and motivation::;
Plz also make a video on post residency life and practice , opportunities in US for a physician.
Raise your voice against these problems. Leaving your own country is not the only solution.
What's the use of cutting of technology when the country is run down with all time gun violence, racism specially now agianst indian, with high housing prices , foods . I am not saying that usmle is bad its way above our neet pg. But nonetheless working in a another country has its fair share of struggle and dangers. Specially in us now
You can list all the demerits and it's still much better than the discriminatory reservation system we have in India
@@saud4159 No, it's worse in America. Colleges will literally reject you if you are asian (indians are also asians in the US).
The pain I went through for my ug seat as a general category really helps me be decisive for my future where I don’t want to go through that again.
I’m studying in karnataka too btw :)
Keep motivate us.. ❤
This video has really motivated me to go ahead with USMLE prep even more!!!
The best doctors in India, are the ones with experience. Period.
Could you please share a little about the penn state family medicine program ? I’m an American citizen who is doing mbbs in India and I’d prefer to go back to Philadelphia for residency
India is good not so bad but usa also has a darkside
Moving to usa better option but for that u should financial stable
Without money usa is bad option and residency very hard to match
Why is hard to match if you have good marks?
Dude, please stop increasing the competition…
You've cleared your way, and now you're posting videos which are going to make USMLE competition similar to NEET-PG.
It will make life hell. Please, Manik Bhaiyaa, don’t do this. 😢
Brother the competition in usmle is already very high. Many Indians are not getting residencies anymore... even this dude settled for psychiatry
Yes i agree😊
@@reginageorgetownuni He chose psychiatry by choice and it is quite difficult to get into psychiatry as an img.
@@codingtiger290 its pretty easy nowadays lol. Most AMGs want to do surgical and interventional internal medicine now. Leave fam med, int med and psych to the imgs, they'll get replaced anyway by midlevels and AI
If you are coming here to criticise India let me tell you India is still economically weak as compared to america .... usa can spend billions on healthcare , india can't which ultimately lead to delays , corruption , unethical practices , insufficient medicines, non existent research..... we can either crib about it or work to repair it
I love India and it's people. The issue so that the currently political system doesn't support such developments and therefore I want to give you the advice that I give to my younger brother, take care of yourself before anyone else
India has money... just check and compare budget allocations for healthcare with other countries..
bottom line.. our govt just doesn't care about doctors.. be it conducting a single exam properly or making our work areas safer
@@manikmadaandon't give false information to young people...American comes to india for cheap treatment..America is going bankrupt and it is stupidity to go America now.
ANOTHER banger
Yes lol
Totally agree with you..usmle is better option for become doctor…and india have reservation its very shameful…
Hi I m a plastic surgery resident in India. Please help me in preparing for usmle and become a consultant there
totally agree with you ...........
Bro overburden are US doctors too . Only the reservation point is valid . Else everything is almost same in every region of doctors . They are also underpaid when compared with dollar and the amount of tax that US govt take is impeccable .
Before criticising India know about china where salary of specialist is only 100000 per month. Why to complain with USA or any nation. Definitely we need to improve but it seems you are much full of hatred towards India . I am gen category neither I have money to go USA nor I will work there I love my nation I will stay here .
Any day US for me . I should start studying Godddd. Those standard textbooks i need to solve them
Still the politicians like pappu think that reservation needs to be increased 🙃
Here comes the "MODI BHAKT".
Pappu ko seriously leta hi kon h
@@mridulmathur5932 I don't support Modi ...but I also hate pappu more
bjp is also same
ISRO, DRDO, ISI banglore, HAL all are iitians free but doing great job for India. ISRo not a single iitian there.
I just have a doubt, that what if not matched ,than what after that, because we are giving 1 to 2 years of time to this exam and money too,and if still not matched than it would be quite demotivating ,plz tell me and guide me if you can
I didn’t get matched this year.
Start working on your plan B after you submit your application.
Keep in mind to get in the states you should have a very good profile or a strong connection.
I have seen ppl with below avg scores and profiles getting matched due to connections.
@@STstars101 Good mindset 👏. Hope you to reach your goal insha allah 🎉
same question i am an old graduate preparing for steps ,investing time money and energy and this fear of not matching into residency just bothers me so much
@@him8252your age
@@STstars101hope you match in the next cycle mate . Improve your cv & establish contacts as much as you can , pour in some money & go do paid observership...hope you succeed in this journey! Don't forget to help me get fellowships later on !! 😂
Make an interview with Sahin Isha , west bengal rank 5 (2014) , Medical College Kolkata, currently in USA if I'm not wrong, doing PG in Internal Medicine.
Is it actually worth to invest so many years when ur parents own a nursing home in India. No domestic help
you can always come back
Sir I am a chartered accountant from India then went on to get international degrees like:- CPA,CIMA,ACCA,CFP and now, I am working in hedge fund (earning in 6 to 8 digits annually, varies on basis of performance but 750,000$ is minimum)
I can guarantee CA having no reservation is what made CA a good course and engineering and medical institutions should look how ICAI keeps cost at 20000/- and also provides library with free meals in each district of India (having multiple libraries in Laxmi Nagar, highly dense area) so,engineers and doctors are creators of economy and CA are facilitators.
It’s quite disheartening the engine of healthy economy is in drain because of reservations……mind you there is no reservation in CA because CAs of politicians then will leak your financial info so this keeps CA protected from reservation.
My first name is vikas
And surname is just a joke😂
@@VikasHarami-up8cv so Mr. Harami (cough) which city you currently reside in?
Are you saying CA course has no reservations?
I have no idea about CA, that’s why asking.
@@STstars101no it's safe till now
@@STstars101no its safe till now
Private practice for doctors in cities in India is competitive, but come to inter area where I am and here the gynaecologist is earning 10-12 lakhs per month.... And cost is living is real really low compared to usa or eu, just that plus you can expand into business ventures like crazy with minimal competition, just that if you are hell bent on living in metros, you won't earn much.... This is not so in usa or eu, also you spend far more number of years Just in hospital training in western countries than in in India that when you earn youre actually too old. Usa work life balance is bad, eu is best, in india if you are in job it's bad, but if you have chain of clinics or are owner, it's completely on you, so students and doctors should have a clear view, in usa as an Indian you will only get internal or family medicine whether you like it or not and that too after lot of uncertainty, getting others isn't impossible but very very difficult... And you'll mostly have to live in underdeveloped part of usa not the better once. Add to that the loneliness and having money but no time and people to spend it on, with your hair turning grey, 2 lakh initial savings isn't that rosy, if you consider the freedom of practice and untouched business opportunities here in India. Yes, if you can save 6 lakh and above in usa per month it's a good option... Am a doctor in odisha, India. Mbbs only... And it's just my opinion. Also those who really want quality of life should choose Germany instead of usa pg, eu is far better to live and raise kids than usa, at any point of time also social security benefits are just awesome. And it's very very easy to get into eu than usa or even neet pg in India. All the best
Toxic and unsupportive working environment , overtly streched duty hours many of which comprises of mundane activities, and many institutes in India is just incapable to expose the post graduate students to latest skillset and interventions to their concerned domain, these are mostly the reasons due to which almost 1200 pg residents are compelled to drop out from pg course inspite of hefty seat leaving bond amount. If there were no seat leaving bond amount, I can say that more than 50% of pg residents wd hv left from the course. These r some snapshots of pathetic state of affairs of doctors in India. Lastly work life balance is a cruel joke 😂😂 in India.
Can graduates of Russian medical schools give USMLE. A lot of Indian students go to CIS countries and Russia for their Medical education. Is that qualification eligible for USA.
Yes you can go to us
@@Sritarun911 US doesn't recognize Russian residencies after the ukraine war started.
@@noflexzone2.055are you sure? i am a russian graduate and i cleared step 1 recently
@@noflexzone2.055how do u know?
I chose it because of the high pay, regular work schedules and less chance to get mob lync^d for no reason. 😢
Good evening doctor. In the beginning of your video you mention you did your ug in Kim’s Bangalore. I would be extremely grateful if I could get a honest feedback regarding the college from you. Please
Is there way to get a one on one consultation with you about career guidance???🧠
HI sir I am neet 2024 student and cleared the exam and I am going to attend MBBS this year, who should I prepare for the step 1
You mean how?
What abt reneet tho
First prepare for re neet. 😂😂😂.
@@prakhar2163 stop hoping for reneet it's not gonna happen lol
Very good information, ❤
Does number of neet (ug) drop affect CV that we prepare for usmle?
No...
@@shreyawagh6424 tysm
Kindly raise your voice against bangal doctor rape and murder case 😢😢😢😢😢
Manik Bhai also tell waiver job for change of j1 status as Hospitalist etc how much do they pay to internist or phychatrist
You have said in your previous video about AMC,
Where you can still earn more than US
If that’s the case, doesn’t Australia seem better for doing residency
I think both are great. US is more streamlined with USMLE, but AMC is a bit vague. I am working on new videos on AMC to clarify the pathway further for students
@@manikmadaan thank you for the reply
I graduated this year and I find many in the same boat as me as which pathway to choose better USMLE and AMC.
It would be very much helpful if you could also add about the chances of getting surgical specialities in Australia
@@manikmadaan yes pls it will be helpful🙏.. cant choose btw the two but the only thing is in amc if we get job after clearing 1st part i am getting more inclined towards giving amc but after that i dont know how is it is better than us or amc is better in future .😞 on the other hand usmle is such a big process one has to go through fear of wasting my money what if i fail to clear even one of steps them pls guide 🙏
Yes
Hello sir my college name is there when I search in wdoms but when I go in sponsor notes nothing occurs ! It’s written still operational ! So what should I do I do ? M I eligible for the registration !
I know many students who do not get good rank in neet pg but still manges to get good clinical seats through usa usmile .competition is stiff in india than usa and many of them who cannot compete here in India go abroad
Usmile ? What an ignorant person
You forgot to mention reservation.
USMLE is tough , competition and unnecessary reservation doesn't make it tough , it is the failure of indian exams they only see your rote learning not even clinical questions!
@@tab8294 it's better not to judge examiner but be competent with what they ask and get success in that exam .
@@tab8294lol😂😂😂 tough?? USMLE IS EASY
Sir how much do you earn now as a doctor in USA? Plz reply. Thanks a lot.
He earns 65k usd approx per annum as a resident
@@karandeepgill1712 what type of resident doctor he is?
Phyciatrist @@gourabsarker9552
@@gourabsarker9552 psychiatrist
@@gourabsarker9552 psychiatrist
Are clinical rotations mandatory? Can only very good marks in which exams enough for a match
Hi Dr manik Madan can u please tell me whether it's possible to sit for usmle while doing MD in India?
when do people need to start preparing for step 1 ( from first year of mbbs itself or .. )
You missed the 12 number in general surgery fellowships which is Plastic surgery (3 years)
You mean remains doctors in India are not best , that not true there are some doctors who are better than them but due to financial ,family issues stay in India.
600k USD Psychiatry 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Bro where is cardiology neurology , radiology lie?
😂😂😂😂
Vai woh sabk aur bhi jyada hita hya, AMAN TILAK ka channel me dekh ki, waha par ek neurosurgeon ne bola tha, bhai ro doge sallery sunke.🙂
That's America not India 😂
@@SagarPramanik1 reality esa nhi hai bro ,depends up o the place ,working place,in india also few doctors earns 20 to 30 lks per month but not all doctors
Dont get into the trap and dont say best of the brains going ohtside. In my batch best of the brains are here only. And after u see situatiin in canada, dont leave ur country anything can happen in future. Apna desh apna hi hota hai. U never know what will happen in future so its better to stay in our own country. Plus i understand people earn more there but what abiut social life? You will never be known by anyone, no respect, no relatives, no family. Living alone in world , going to cafe and living with a cat is not everyone's dream though.
Exactly who make memes on these things could not understand that in the end we have to live our lives and why we should not choose better for us. Hectic pg exams ug exams already frustates out too much and if you fail then we all well know how even parents start to become toxic like relatives
Sahi baat hai.
India me log theke waale ko namaste karenge, respect denge.
Par agar sath me doctor ka clinic hoga to koi b nahi puchhega.
Indian me ek problem aur hai, log khud se hi Google search kar ke apna ilaj karna shuru kar dete hai. Fir jab thoda time k baad case kharaab ho jata hai to doctor k paas jate hai. Fir agar result utna positive nahin aayega to doctor ko picheey se galat bolenge. Apni galti nahi dekhenge na us medical store wale ki jo tukke marte hai ilaaj karne me.
India me medical field is very tough in the upcoming years. Also India's gdp expenditure on medical field is very low.
Sir ne AYUSH doctors ki baat kari starting k pointers me. But kuch ayush doctor bhi responsibility lete hai. Inko bhi apne respective state medical boards se register hona padta hai. Apna clinic chlane k liye CMO,DI etc. se permission leni padti hai. They come under biomedical waste act, pollution acts, and all other medical acts. They are regulated.
I want to add ASHA wrkr program. Aap isse kaise ignore kar sakte hai. 10-12padhi hui asha worker pcm, albendaxole, etc. provide kya prescibe bhi karti hai unofficially. COVID TIME pe hmne dekha hai. Aur shayad auron ne bhi dekha hoga jb azithr, pcm vit c zn etc otc ki tarah bik rahe they.
Congratulations to you sir ki aap USA me ho. There is no work life balance in india in medical field. And the indian doctors are highly low paid.
Compare the annual income of India's top doctor with that of other professions. Example with acting, cricket, software, hardware, automobile, engineers. They all earn more than doctors.
I have seen doctor fee in india in private from 50-500 per patient in opd. And more than 80% of them are complicated or self-doctor, via Google.
Good luck sir for your future.
Can we do private practice in USA??as an img? If yes thn pls let us know the pros and cons
Yes after getting green card
Only after u pass the USMLE and do the residency in the US.
Sir can Indians get Internal Medicine branch in USA???
yes
@manikmadaan Thank You Sir 😊👍
But in USA there is no work life balance
Sir which is the ipad better for complete 4.4yrs note taken+Usmle including all steps.....and how much storage have this???
Please suggest one?
20k dollars not for middle-class 🥺
Family bhi hoti h india me.. Har koi chodd ke videsh nh bhag sakta. And also usmle expenses are too much. Middle class cant afford.
Dont worry india had more talented doctors then us,
Reservation,less salary,inequality
India has merit based exams. Usa works on networking. The backbencher in your class may get the best college just because his daddy knows someone. Talk about inequality
@@snape1596How do I get into Aiims Delhi if my father is influential?
@@snape1596 yes heard the same thing from some sc st candidate that upper caste get good colleges because their parents have political influence but he himself did not qualify the exam.
@@gauravgairola9449 they think that a upper caste means he has political background
@@mrrockbottom Actually even they know that a significant no of people from upper caste struggle in getting into colleges and then jobs, due to financial constraint and reservation policy. Even they know that the present generation who are actually suffering has nothing to do with casteism. But, then they will still justify with every illogical logic because they know how important reservation is for them.