The "circle" that you wanted or thought was going to happen in "I know the end" *does* sort of exists. The end melody is DVD menu. The album blends and can be played in a loop! Great review/ reaction.
Great reaction video - you're the first reactor to correctly get Graceland Too on first listen. - and it was written for and about her friend and bandmember from Boy Genius - singer/songwriter extrordinare Julien Baker who has been in rehab and has a few great albums out of her own. Julien Baker and Lucy Dacus (also from Boy Genius) are singing the beautiful harmonies during that exceptional outro.
If you loved "Graceland Too," you really have to listen to Boygenius, which is the musical "supergroup" made up of Phoebe Bridgers, Lucy Dacus, and Julien Baker. I believe the harmony in "Graceland Too" is with Lucy or Julien. They put out a self-titled EP with lots of *gorgeous* harmonies and wonderful songwriting. Also check out Lucy Dacus' album Home Video, especially her song "Please Stay," which is kind of a parallel to "Graceland Too." I believe there has been some speculation that Please Stay and Graceland Too are about Julien, who I think has struggled the most (of the three) with depression/mental illness....but it could be referring to other friends too (and themselves). Lucy's song "Thumbs" is incredible, too. Oh and finally, you'd probably like a lot of Mitski - my favorite albums are Puberty 2 and Be the Cowboy.
@@FernStone I'm v glad to know it's growing on you, phoebe has another album called ‘stranger in the alps’, if there's ever enough recommendations in the future for u to do it it'd be really amazing to see ur reaction to it, but if not you should give it a listen regardless, it came out before punisher and it's nice to see phoebe's mindset and influences from back then ☺️
honestly you're right. it's going for a full circle. the outro of I Know The End is the intro of DVD Menu. so the 'The End' is 'The Beginning'. so welcome, to the Punisher.
i know this video is so old but it actually DOES go full circle!!!! listen to the strings in dvd menu and then the melody at the end of i know the end. they match up!! such a cool little addition
I know the end is truly an experience!!! Loved this reaction It would be interesting to see you react to the lyrics and production on fetch the bolt cutters by fiona apple and sevdalizas albums! Love your channel!!!
i only recently started watching music reaction videos on youtube, but your vids have to be my favorite! theres something about the formating of them and they way you speak about the music that works really well
btw I don't know if you know a band called ‘The Japanese House’, they have an album called ‘Good at Falling’ and it's one of the best artworks I've ever heard so far and I've heard soooo many hahaha, probably the most unique experience I've had, hope that maybe u can react to it one day ^^
Your beautiful understanding of the lyrics is so refreshing because Phoebe truly knows how to gut a person with her storytelling. And watching you almost live inside the instrumentals while the songs are playing made me pick up things I missed in them, despite listening to this album over and over! Beautiful video. Doesn't feel like an ordinary reaction video
Hey Fern!!! I decided to give this album a try after I saw you posting your reaction and I really, really enjoyed it a bit more this time. Soccer Mommy - Color Theory, would be a great reaction too!
Awesome reaction! You picked up on a lot of things! Chinese Satellite is my favorite and it always gives me the chills. You should listen to Boygenius (it's Phoebe's project together with Julien Baker and Lucy Dacus-the two additional voices in Graceland Too harmonies) and Julien Baker's latest album Little Oblivions. (It did actually come full circle. Listen to DVD Menu again, it's got the same melodies as I know the end).
Hey I love your reactions a lot!! I’ve been watching music reactions for years and remember when my favorite youtubers were at your subscriber count and I think you will have a lot of success too! Keep going pls:)
Just for this video ... But maybe some other times too ...Sometimes it's just nice to stand up ! Where ever I can find a good spot for lighting and a surface haha !
Hello Fern. About you videos being blocked or otherwise hindered, there is this paragraph about fair use under copyright disclaimer: *Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. ALL RIGHTS BELONG TO THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS* Its worth looking into. Love from Norway.
Yes , this is why I can dispute a claim … which I always do . So I tell the label that places the claim I am just reacting to and reviewing the song for educational purposes and it falls under fair use . However the label decides whether they think it is fair use or not . If they don’t, then my video is demonetised. If I then further appeal their claim and they still don’t agree they can take my video down and I could get a copyright strike ( if I get three , they take my channel) . So if you upload a video and it’s blocked straight away then you can do all these things but it’s more risky if the label doesn’t agree . The recent artists I did before AURORA didn’t accept my dispute, instantly ! Hence why I edited the Aurora video more as I was very cautious . Just a human reaction . It’s all a lot more complicated then people think and when people constantly compare reactors it’s frustrating, because copyright hits us all in different ways . From now on though I’m always going to try uploading before editing it too much ! I only didn’t one time out of caution because of recent frustrations . People are so so quick to judge and anger . But I’m fine with it 😂😂 💕💕
@@FernStone You have nothing to apologize for. Some artists and their labels are very quick to use the ban hammer. Aurora, as far as I can tell, are quite lenient. So, I think you are quite safe with her. Anyway, love your work darling.
The end of "I know the end" gets me every time, its SO powerful and I 1000% cried first time I heard it LMAO
It was so unexpected on so many levels and I loved every moment ! Honestly this album is just filled with talent 💕
One of my favorite albums of all time. There are some lines that i still think about while i’m alone. she’s a SONGWRITER.
17:14 her and mitski do the same thing.
Use their sound SO perfectly... Makes me wanna cry,
The "circle" that you wanted or thought was going to happen in "I know the end" *does* sort of exists. The end melody is DVD menu. The album blends and can be played in a loop!
Great review/ reaction.
Great reaction video - you're the first reactor to correctly get Graceland Too on first listen. - and it was written for and about her friend and bandmember from Boy Genius - singer/songwriter extrordinare Julien Baker who has been in rehab and has a few great albums out of her own. Julien Baker and Lucy Dacus (also from Boy Genius) are singing the beautiful harmonies during that exceptional outro.
Oooh I’m so pleased ! Awww it really is such a gorgeous song , felt very personal to me . 💕
If you loved "Graceland Too," you really have to listen to Boygenius, which is the musical "supergroup" made up of Phoebe Bridgers, Lucy Dacus, and Julien Baker. I believe the harmony in "Graceland Too" is with Lucy or Julien. They put out a self-titled EP with lots of *gorgeous* harmonies and wonderful songwriting.
Also check out Lucy Dacus' album Home Video, especially her song "Please Stay," which is kind of a parallel to "Graceland Too." I believe there has been some speculation that Please Stay and Graceland Too are about Julien, who I think has struggled the most (of the three) with depression/mental illness....but it could be referring to other friends too (and themselves). Lucy's song "Thumbs" is incredible, too.
Oh and finally, you'd probably like a lot of Mitski - my favorite albums are Puberty 2 and Be the Cowboy.
You need to react to her debut Stranger in the Alps! Full folk but even more sad I think
Omg you were actually right! The DVD menu melody is the same as the ending music in "I know the end" before the whisper screaming!
omg ... i've actually only noticed now , that's its the same !!
yes! I'm always so happy to see people reacting to phoebe, thanks fern! ❤️
Awww I'm so pleased ! I really really like this album , each time I hear the songs from it I love them more.
@@FernStone I'm v glad to know it's growing on you, phoebe has another album called ‘stranger in the alps’, if there's ever enough recommendations in the future for u to do it it'd be really amazing to see ur reaction to it, but if not you should give it a listen regardless, it came out before punisher and it's nice to see phoebe's mindset and influences from back then ☺️
@@Pedro-vi9jg I would love to in the future !! I I'm glad I've got a few Phoebe fans here , I was hoping I would !
honestly you're right. it's going for a full circle. the outro of I Know The End is the intro of DVD Menu. so the 'The End' is 'The Beginning'. so welcome, to the Punisher.
i know this video is so old but it actually DOES go full circle!!!! listen to the strings in dvd menu and then the melody at the end of i know the end. they match up!! such a cool little addition
I know the end is truly an experience!!! Loved this reaction
It would be interesting to see you react to the lyrics and production on fetch the bolt cutters by fiona apple and sevdalizas albums! Love your channel!!!
i only recently started watching music reaction videos on youtube, but your vids have to be my favorite! theres something about the formating of them and they way you speak about the music that works really well
That’s lovely , thank you ! 💕😃
Garden song is such an incredible song i will never get over it
Imo Garden song is the worst one in the album
@@ozzie8738 personally the worst song on the album is halloween, i literally never listen to it. it’s not bad, it’s just there.
i think you would like japanese breakfast's newest album btw
btw I don't know if you know a band called ‘The Japanese House’, they have an album called ‘Good at Falling’ and it's one of the best artworks I've ever heard so far and I've heard soooo many hahaha, probably the most unique experience I've had, hope that maybe u can react to it one day ^^
^^^^^^^
yess good at falling is incredible
moon song and i know the end for me personally just.... hits different
Your beautiful understanding of the lyrics is so refreshing because Phoebe truly knows how to gut a person with her storytelling. And watching you almost live inside the instrumentals while the songs are playing made me pick up things I missed in them, despite listening to this album over and over! Beautiful video. Doesn't feel like an ordinary reaction video
Omg I love your videos sm, feels like you’re my bestie facetiming me
Hey Fern!!! I decided to give this album a try after I saw you posting your reaction and I really, really enjoyed it a bit more this time.
Soccer Mommy - Color Theory, would be a great reaction too!
I'm ready to see an adult cry. I haven't watched it yet but Phoebe's power is undeniable. This album is so underrated.
Awesome reaction! You picked up on a lot of things! Chinese Satellite is my favorite and it always gives me the chills. You should listen to Boygenius (it's Phoebe's project together with Julien Baker and Lucy Dacus-the two additional voices in Graceland Too harmonies) and Julien Baker's latest album Little Oblivions. (It did actually come full circle. Listen to DVD Menu again, it's got the same melodies as I know the end).
there's moments that gave me LEGIT GOOSEBUMPS and i wanted to cry not bc of its sad lyrics but bc its excellent use of every instrument beautifully🥺
Amazing review!!! This album is so beautiful, is my favorite of all time. Also you're so cute and cool I loved this video❤❤❤
i’m so excited for this let’s go bestie
27:02 I think you might be thinking of bohemian rhapsody. At least that’s what that part reminded me of haha
Amazing reaction!! You’re the best
Love this, love Phoebe, love your reactions :D
I love your reactions!!! Can you react to Phoebe's first album "Stranger In the Alps"?
I’m desperate to react to this !! Will most likely be next year now but I’m definitely going to !
@@FernStone Thanks 🥺 Whenever you want!
This is the best reaction to Punisher.
your patron has taste lol
pleaseeee react to Jubilee by Japanese Breakfast! I think you'd like it
5:05 OMG YES i ADORE Heartbeats by José González ugh and ive been listening to that on a loop recently hahaha wow
Such a beautiful song filled with emotion !
Hey I love your reactions a lot!! I’ve been watching music reactions for years and remember when my favorite youtubers were at your subscriber count and I think you will have a lot of success too! Keep going pls:)
react to carrie & lowell by sufjan stevens pleaseeeee
YAAAAAAAYYYY
❤❤❤
LOVE YOU MWAH
I remember seeing you request this a while ago haha !!! hope you enjoyed
You should react to Jubilee by Japanese Breakfast
pls react to vulnicura
wait i’m literally standing in my kitchen too while watching this
Please react to Sufjan Steven's "Carrie & Lowell" album! 🙏🏽
22:05 she commented early. HAHAHA.
Could you please react to be right back by Jorja Smith? It’s 8 an song album that is amazing
Do you physically see music, or is it kinda like in your minds eye?
great video queen, is this background permanent or just for this video?
Just for this video ... But maybe some other times too ...Sometimes it's just nice to stand up ! Where ever I can find a good spot for lighting and a surface haha !
react to KG0516 By Karol G PLEASEEE
Pls react to grimes
Hello Fern. About you videos being blocked or otherwise hindered, there is this paragraph about fair use under copyright disclaimer:
*Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. ALL RIGHTS BELONG TO THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS* Its worth looking into. Love from Norway.
Yes , this is why I can dispute a claim … which I always do . So I tell the label that places the claim I am just reacting to and reviewing the song for educational purposes and it falls under fair use . However the label decides whether they think it is fair use or not . If they don’t, then my video is demonetised. If I then further appeal their claim and they still don’t agree they can take my video down and I could get a copyright strike ( if I get three , they take my channel) .
So if you upload a video and it’s blocked straight away then you can do all these things but it’s more risky if the label doesn’t agree . The recent artists I did before AURORA didn’t accept my dispute, instantly ! Hence why I edited the Aurora video more as I was very cautious . Just a human reaction . It’s all a lot more complicated then people think and when people constantly compare reactors it’s frustrating, because copyright hits us all in different ways . From now on though I’m always going to try uploading before editing it too much ! I only didn’t one time out of caution because of recent frustrations . People are so so quick to judge and anger . But I’m fine with it 😂😂 💕💕
@@FernStone You have nothing to apologize for. Some artists and their labels are very quick to use the ban hammer. Aurora, as far as I can tell, are quite lenient. So, I think you are quite safe with her. Anyway, love your work darling.
@@maxsteiner1964 Thank you so much !! yes , I'm glad I know now , Thank you AURORA haha !! can't wait to react to her new song :)
god u look so much like frances bean cobain
damn, you were on a roll with great music! (until now lmao)