Instead of leaving the human to bleed to death, why didn't Carlise just turn them? If he started turning these people, surely Aro would have gotten sick of all these new and unwanted newborns and would have just stopped leaving bodies for Carlisle. He clearly has no problem with vamps he creates killing others, otherwise he would never have turned anyone, so that can't be the reason. Perhaps these people were ugly, as he only seems to turn people "too beautiful to die."
happened. You mean to tell me that Didyme never cried out when Aro was ripping her apart and none of the others came running like what the heck is going on here? Unless of course he ripped her head off first. But still nobody ever asked how an outside vampire got in to the castle in the first place and killed only ONE (keyword there) vampire and split without notice by the other volturi. and they never found out who did that? I was so hoping you would go off about that one and i was
I cant believe that you didnt go on about the fact that Aro killed his own sister in order to keep Marcus in the coven. Man when i first heard about that i went off. As much as me and my sister disagree and fight i wouldnt kill her over some man for absolute power. And thats another thing how in the hell did Marcus or Caius for that matter never figure out that it was Aro that killed Didyme I dont understand that one. The vampires in that novel dont sleep so they all were wide awake when it
I find it funny how Meyer says humans can't destory them, but the volturi are 'protecting' vampires from the human technologies that COULD destory them. So while Meyer is saying one thing she shows another. Meyer, pick and choose between them you can't pick them both.
The best I can think of for the "(vampire)" is that Meyer wanted to emphasize the whole "your eyes are red if you're vampiric" bit. Why she didn't give his pre-vampiric eye color like she did with the Sparkletastics... eh, fuck it.
It's true Aro cannot rule benevolently, and that Meyer's vampires are animals. However, if the Cullens took over and Carlisle ruled I am willing to bet (ten dollars) the vampires would abruptly stop being animals.
Super-pedantic correction that I have to make as a Classics major: "Sulpicia" is pronounced "Sulpikia." There are no soft C's in Classical Latin. Awesome commentary, though, so I won't begrudge you a pronunciation error.
(I know this is kind of weird, but I like playing these rants as background "music". I love your voice and the rants themselves. Which is why I'm doing another comment.) Not to defend Carlisle or anything, but maybe SMeyer just forgot (which yes is a STUPID oversight) to say that Carlisle tried to save the dying humans, but Aro didn't let him save them. But then SMeyer kind of shoots herself in the foot with the whole "he left on good terms" thing.
I think SMeyer wasn't intending to make Aro look "perfect" when she described as with that onion skin and filmy eyes. After, beauty equals goodness, right? All the main evil Meyerpires are either ugliesh (James was plain and average looking) or feral looking. Yes! Thanking you for pointing that one rule out. That was the thing that just boggled my mind in the last video. You know, I'm pretty sure that's why Chelsea's not in charge: because she's not a man.
It was a villainous action, but it also showed inconsistency in his character. This guy would kill his own sister to keep a dude with a rather lame power around, but we later found out that a vampire with a useful ability was allowed to leave after finding his True Love. If Aro's supposed to be a ruthless and pragmatic villain, why not kill her as well?
You know, that kinda just showed that Aro is a better lover than Carly (Carlisle) as he actually ASKED Sulpicia if she wanted to be a vampire. He ASKED!
I love these videos. While I have no problem looking at Michael Sheen, you're right in thinking that the fact The Volturi, the "major" players in the series, didn't get a single illustration save for the Clock Tower reveals carelessness on the part of the author. Hell, even JK Rowling wrote those supplementary texts and while they were a small detail in overall part, it helped make the world she created more real and interesting. Most of all, it showed she cared about her creation.
Aro in my planned spitefic when confronted by the Celestial Bureaucracy: OK, we'll pass the law banning vampires from eating humans, just don't murder us all! * whisper * Caius, shut up before you get us all killed! Aro when the Celestial Bureaucracy got caught in a war with demons: Y'know what, maybe I can let the law NOT pass... No, Caius, you may NOT try to gather our forces to try and destroy the Bureaucracy. Aro when the Celestial Bureaucracy won the war and came back to see how that law is going: OKAY, I PROMISE WE'LL PASS THE LAW, JUST DON'T MURDER US- CAIUS, SHUT THE F^CK UP OR ELSE I'M GONNA KILL YOU BEFORE THE BUREAUCRACY DOES!
so Stephanie basically designed her villain to be Doofenshmirtz Evil Incorporated except you know he actually has a goal (and a REAL protagonist) and as you've already said these idiots are the Volturi who DON'T DO ANYTHING
The way Carlisle acts reminds of the bystander who watches a kid (dying human) by a bully (Aro) but does nothing. Meyer's whole "Oh he doesn't eat people so therefore he's a good guy, he's a saint!" falls flat on it's face when he doesn't do anything when presented a bleeding human. (And turning them in to a "vampire" doesn't count)
It's the most common glue we use over here at the states. It's got a lot of different types, including woodwork Elmer's glue, but the common type that they use is just white glue in elementary school, and when you get it on your hands and it dries, it leaves a thin film that can be peeled off like peeling skin after a sunburn.
23:10 or so- Objection. Carlisle probably couldn't bring himself to actually move for fear of what would happen if he did. The rest is all fine, but I can buy that he didn't have the willpower to help them.
Your notion of Chelsey/Chareon as the puppetmaster controling all the Volturi is fantastic and far too clever for S.M. to comprehend, let alone use. "What can you bring to Evilcorp?" GENIUS - this is very Eddie Izzard worthy! I love your perspective on this rubbish.
Aro is an onion. Layers. You know. On a more serious note, though, here's a question: why the hell does he have long hair? That's not period-appropriate.
Perfection! I adore the MST3K reference, and not having any interest in these books - although I was honestly horrified by the first film (nightmare fuel) - I'm really enjoying these videos. Thank you!
Instead of leaving the human to bleed to death, why didn't Carlise just turn them? If he started turning these people, surely Aro would have gotten sick of all these new and unwanted newborns and would have just stopped leaving bodies for Carlisle.
He clearly has no problem with vamps he creates killing others, otherwise he would never have turned anyone, so that can't be the reason.
Perhaps these people were ugly, as he only seems to turn people "too beautiful to die."
You know you fail hard at writing when your villains are more heroic than your "heroes," and your heroes are more villainous than your "villains."
happened. You mean to tell me that Didyme never cried out when Aro was ripping her apart and none of the others came running like what the heck is going on here?
Unless of course he ripped her head off first.
But still nobody ever asked how an outside vampire got in to the castle in the first place and killed only ONE (keyword there) vampire and split without notice by the other volturi. and they never found out who did that?
I was so hoping you would go off about that one and i was
I cant believe that you didnt go on about the fact that Aro killed his own sister in order to keep Marcus in the coven.
Man when i first heard about that i went off. As much as me and my sister disagree and fight i wouldnt kill her over some man for absolute power.
And thats another thing how in the hell did Marcus or Caius for that matter never figure out that it was Aro that killed Didyme I dont understand that one.
The vampires in that novel dont sleep so they all were wide awake when it
I find it funny how Meyer says humans can't destory them, but the volturi are 'protecting' vampires from the human technologies that COULD destory them. So while Meyer is saying one thing she shows another. Meyer, pick and choose between them you can't pick them both.
The best I can think of for the "(vampire)" is that Meyer wanted to emphasize the whole "your eyes are red if you're vampiric" bit. Why she didn't give his pre-vampiric eye color like she did with the Sparkletastics... eh, fuck it.
It's true Aro cannot rule benevolently, and that Meyer's vampires are animals. However, if the Cullens took over and Carlisle ruled I am willing to bet (ten dollars) the vampires would abruptly stop being animals.
Carlisle saw a defenseless person and didn't change them without their consent? How mushrooms what is this world coming to!?
Super-pedantic correction that I have to make as a Classics major: "Sulpicia" is pronounced "Sulpikia." There are no soft C's in Classical Latin.
Awesome commentary, though, so I won't begrudge you a pronunciation error.
(I know this is kind of weird, but I like playing these rants as background "music". I love your voice and the rants themselves. Which is why I'm doing another comment.)
Not to defend Carlisle or anything, but maybe SMeyer just forgot (which yes is a STUPID oversight) to say that Carlisle tried to save the dying humans, but Aro didn't let him save them.
But then SMeyer kind of shoots herself in the foot with the whole "he left on good terms" thing.
the whole world revolves around the Cullen coven
I loved Aro in the movie, his actor was totally in on the joke and hilarious the whole time :D
I think SMeyer wasn't intending to make Aro look "perfect" when she described as with that onion skin and filmy eyes. After, beauty equals goodness, right? All the main evil Meyerpires are either ugliesh (James was plain and average looking) or feral looking.
Yes! Thanking you for pointing that one rule out. That was the thing that just boggled my mind in the last video.
You know, I'm pretty sure that's why Chelsea's not in charge: because she's not a man.
It was a villainous action, but it also showed inconsistency in his character. This guy would kill his own sister to keep a dude with a rather lame power around, but we later found out that a vampire with a useful ability was allowed to leave after finding his True Love. If Aro's supposed to be a ruthless and pragmatic villain, why not kill her as well?
dissapointed about that one.
Maybe thats a topic for Epside ten or eleven depending on whose next in the list.
You know, that kinda just showed that Aro is a better lover than Carly (Carlisle) as he actually ASKED Sulpicia if she wanted to be a vampire. He ASKED!
I love these videos. While I have no problem looking at Michael Sheen, you're right in thinking that the fact The Volturi, the "major" players in the series, didn't get a single illustration save for the Clock Tower reveals carelessness on the part of the author. Hell, even JK Rowling wrote those supplementary texts and while they were a small detail in overall part, it helped make the world she created more real and interesting. Most of all, it showed she cared about her creation.
Aro in my planned spitefic when confronted by the Celestial Bureaucracy: OK, we'll pass the law banning vampires from eating humans, just don't murder us all! * whisper * Caius, shut up before you get us all killed!
Aro when the Celestial Bureaucracy got caught in a war with demons: Y'know what, maybe I can let the law NOT pass... No, Caius, you may NOT try to gather our forces to try and destroy the Bureaucracy.
Aro when the Celestial Bureaucracy won the war and came back to see how that law is going: OKAY, I PROMISE WE'LL PASS THE LAW, JUST DON'T MURDER US- CAIUS, SHUT THE F^CK UP OR ELSE I'M GONNA KILL YOU BEFORE THE BUREAUCRACY DOES!
so Stephanie basically designed her villain to be Doofenshmirtz Evil Incorporated except you know he actually has a goal (and a REAL protagonist) and as you've already said these idiots are the Volturi who DON'T DO ANYTHING
Mervin has a fetish with everything with a black suit and red tie.
She must love Slenderman.
Objection. When did anyone ever try to claim Aro was a Magnificent Bastard?
Ah, so I'm not the only one with a major suit fetish...
The way Carlisle acts reminds of the bystander who watches a kid (dying human) by a bully (Aro) but does nothing. Meyer's whole "Oh he doesn't eat people so therefore he's a good guy, he's a saint!" falls flat on it's face when he doesn't do anything when presented a bleeding human. (And turning them in to a "vampire" doesn't count)
"...possibly because she's a moron."
LOL :D
"Happy chainsaw hour" Sounds like something you and your fellow sporkers would do to the characters in said sporkings.Good show,as always.
So Meyer can't do simple arithmetic, doesn't surprise me.
Okay, I'm Australian, I give up now. What the heck is Elmer's Glue? Is it like the glue we used in woodwork class or something?
If Aro apparently looks like an onion, I'm gonna imagine him as Onionsan.
I'm gonna imagine him as Shrek
Were the not pretty enough for Carlisle? Then again he likes to choose the people he "kills"
It's the most common glue we use over here at the states. It's got a lot of different types, including woodwork Elmer's glue, but the common type that they use is just white glue in elementary school, and when you get it on your hands and it dries, it leaves a thin film that can be peeled off like peeling skin after a sunburn.
23:10 or so- Objection. Carlisle probably couldn't bring himself to actually move for fear of what would happen if he did.
The rest is all fine, but I can buy that he didn't have the willpower to help them.
I like the idea of vampire taxes.
Your notion of Chelsey/Chareon as the puppetmaster controling all the Volturi is fantastic and far too clever for S.M. to comprehend, let alone use.
"What can you bring to Evilcorp?" GENIUS - this is very Eddie Izzard worthy!
I love your perspective on this rubbish.
Aro is an onion. Layers. You know.
On a more serious note, though, here's a question: why the hell does he have long hair? That's not period-appropriate.
Perfection! I adore the MST3K reference, and not having any interest in these books - although I was honestly horrified by the first film (nightmare fuel) - I'm really enjoying these videos.
Thank you!
Well noted!
10:40 Hey, not all animals are as evil and violent as the vampires from Twilight!
Will you do a run down on the Host?