Top 50 Greatest Singer-Songwriters of all Time

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 24 бер 2022
  • Thanks for watching! Please consider checking out some other content on my channel, I have many music related videos, and upload a new video every Friday.
    Most Streamed Album On Spotify Every Year Since 1962
    • Most Streamed Album On...
    Top 50 Best Selling Albums Of All Time
    • Top 50 Best Selling Al...
    Top 25 Most Viewed Rock Songs on UA-cam
    • Top 25 Most Viewed Roc...

КОМЕНТАРІ • 393

  • @glede9377
    @glede9377 2 роки тому +73

    Roger Waters is so underrated. Rolling Stone didn't even put him in the top 100. Also where is John Fogerty?

  • @MidosujiSen
    @MidosujiSen 2 роки тому +78

    When it comes to music, Brian Wilson is the best. Dylan for lyrics and Lennon/McCartney for both.

    • @michaelwomack5769
      @michaelwomack5769 2 роки тому +5

      Dylan’s lyrics far outshine L/M. Also I would argue melodys too. However, Dylan popularized writing lyrics, before Dylan, the Beatles were singing about 18 year old girls and holding their hands.

    • @michaelwomack5769
      @michaelwomack5769 2 роки тому

      @@MidosujiSen Just the way he pronounces phrases and words, I feel like the lyrics and music tie together more than Lennon/McCartneys do

    • @noahsart6254
      @noahsart6254 2 роки тому +3

      @@michaelwomack5769 I believe that that’s an oversimplification of the Beatles’ lyricism

    • @michaelwomack5769
      @michaelwomack5769 2 роки тому

      @@noahsart6254 It’s just the plain story. Bob Dylan popularized the idea of writing your own songs, as well as having good lyrics.

    • @lzeb4730
      @lzeb4730 Рік тому +1

      @@michaelwomack5769 LOL absolutely not Bob has nowhere near the amount of great melodies as the Beatles. Not even close.

  • @Luke-1296
    @Luke-1296 2 роки тому +31

    How can you not have Barry Gibb and Jeff Lynne on this list.

    • @msog99
      @msog99 Рік тому +3

      Exaclty

    • @RolandBarrett-tc3sb
      @RolandBarrett-tc3sb Рік тому +1

      Yup

    • @noonetime8478
      @noonetime8478 6 місяців тому +2

      they always ignore barry gibb and his brothers all these years. They were great songwriters, both their music and lyrics are superb. Another one thats unbelievable is gilbert o sullivan, what a tune smith

    • @gaygay7708
      @gaygay7708 3 місяці тому

      Especially Lynn

    • @kociankids338
      @kociankids338 3 місяці тому

      ELO's never on any of this guy's lists. I think he's never heard of them, or he's crazy.

  • @emre_7575
    @emre_7575 2 роки тому +45

    3 of the 4 Beatles members in Top 30. Talking about the best band ever.

    • @bentons647
      @bentons647 2 роки тому +13

      George still should’ve been higher

    • @Fox101st
      @Fox101st Рік тому +9

      Ringo after reading this be like : "No more peace and love"

  • @lynnehackett7799
    @lynnehackett7799 2 роки тому +25

    Where is Barry Gibb of the Bee Gees? Extremely underated artist

  • @oneironaut.indigo
    @oneironaut.indigo Рік тому +24

    Sting, David Bowie and Robert Plant are some of my favorite song writers along with Lennon and McCartney

  • @DayTripperrr
    @DayTripperrr 2 роки тому +22

    George Harrison needs to be higher

  • @zizikikalishvili9482
    @zizikikalishvili9482 2 роки тому +43

    A guy who wrote and sang - “Boh rhap”, “We are the champions”, “Somebody to love”, “Don’t stop me now” “Killer Queen”, “Crazy little thing called love”, “Love of my life” isn’t even in top 50...

    • @goldbrickstudios6903
      @goldbrickstudios6903 Рік тому +2

      I know how is that possible.

    • @tyrannosauruszeppelin2205
      @tyrannosauruszeppelin2205 Рік тому +3

      Killer Queen and Crazy Little Things Called Love aren't great songs. Bohemian Rhapsody is the one true masterpiece Mercury ever wrote.

    • @frankkolton1780
      @frankkolton1780 Рік тому +1

      Lightweight pop shite, that's why.

    • @giuseppinocarciofo
      @giuseppinocarciofo Рік тому +2

      @@tyrannosauruszeppelin2205 I don't like crazy little thing called love too, but the other songs the guy mentioned are absolutely masterpieces, killer Queen too, he belongs for sure in the top 50

    • @osazenomwan
      @osazenomwan Рік тому

      I think, john deacon was a better songwriter in that group

  • @sherwintavarez8539
    @sherwintavarez8539 2 роки тому +20

    It was a good list, I liked how you included a bunch of different genres, I would’ve added Thom Yorke from Radiohead and Frank Ocean

  • @_c_p0wers_07
    @_c_p0wers_07 2 роки тому +55

    You should’ve put Hendrix or Freddie Mercury in this list

    • @sherwintavarez8539
      @sherwintavarez8539 2 роки тому +29

      Hendrix is more of a guitarist than songwriter, I’m not saying he bad or anything but nobody thinks of him as a songwriter

  • @aonlyandonlytheonlythatonl4247
    @aonlyandonlytheonlythatonl4247 2 роки тому +40

    My top 10
    1.John Lennon
    2.Bob Dylan
    3.Paul McCartney
    4.Neil Young
    5.Chuck Berry
    6.Paul Simon
    7.Roger Waters
    8.Brian Wilson
    9.David Bowie
    10.Robert Plant

    • @kaitlyng8968
      @kaitlyng8968 Рік тому +1

      Mine would be along the same as you except that Paul would be my favorite then John then Bob

    • @datname1939
      @datname1939 8 місяців тому +1

      Ik this is about to be a controversial asf statement. But R Kelly is the best song writer ever. Just look up his body of work. He's at least top 5 and dude can't even read.

    • @aonlyandonlytheonlythatonl4247
      @aonlyandonlytheonlythatonl4247 8 місяців тому

      @@datname1939 I don't know him, but it sounds really amazing
      There are actually a lot of amazing songwriter but underrated like Peter Hammill

    • @datname1939
      @datname1939 8 місяців тому +1

      @@aonlyandonlytheonlythatonl4247 he wrote a few of Michael Jackson's songs like 'you are not alone' and 'cry'. As well as 'I believe I can fly', 'I am your angel' Celine dion, 'the worlds greatest', 'fortunate', 'life', 'bump bump bump', 'busted, 'contagious ', 'i need an angel', 'I look to you' by Whitney Houston, 'if I could turn back the hands of time', 'step in the name of love' And the list goes on.

    • @aonlyandonlytheonlythatonl4247
      @aonlyandonlytheonlythatonl4247 8 місяців тому

      @@datname1939 Never knew this before
      thanks for tell me

  • @thirdhandlv4231
    @thirdhandlv4231 Рік тому +23

    Paul wrote and sung Here,There and Everywhere and Helter Skelter...
    I think that is all you need to know he is the best.

    • @mostafamahmoud5524
      @mostafamahmoud5524 Рік тому +3

      Hey jude , yesterday , Eleanor Rigby , may be I am amazed , let it be and blackbird.

    • @villainousappetite8841
      @villainousappetite8841 Рік тому +2

      Keep on riding him.
      No point knowing anything when its an objective fact that Bob Dylan literally shits on Paul McCartney in the songwriting department.

    • @thirdhandlv4231
      @thirdhandlv4231 Рік тому

      @@villainousappetite8841 Lol how many retarded takes are you gonna throw at me?

    • @mostafamahmoud5524
      @mostafamahmoud5524 Рік тому +2

      @@villainousappetite8841 But Paul McCartney is far better musician and singer than bob Dylan.

    • @villainousappetite8841
      @villainousappetite8841 Рік тому +1

      @@mostafamahmoud5524 Of course Paul McCartney is overall a more talented musician than Bob Dylan but this list ranks in terms of songwriting and as good as a musician Paul is, he is NOT a better lyricist than Bob Dylan, the songwriter of the millenium.

  • @fudgemonkeyz69
    @fudgemonkeyz69 Рік тому +5

    Sufjan Stevens.
    Bro can make you weep with just a guitar, it’s crazy.

  • @LuciensMusic
    @LuciensMusic Рік тому +3

    I'm inspired by so many writers past and present, when I hear something great that Ive never heard before I usually freeze in my tracks,lol

  • @petewingnut6827
    @petewingnut6827 Рік тому +8

    What about Barry Gibb? Not just for The Bee Gees but loads of other artists too.

  • @korbendallas416
    @korbendallas416 2 роки тому +14

    Pete Townshend. Almost all The Who songs + many solo works.

    • @bowtieguy377
      @bowtieguy377 Місяць тому +1

      Agreed. He did not write that many "Hit Singles" per se, but his great songs have been played on album oriented radio forever. A big omission to be sure.

    • @korbendallas416
      @korbendallas416 Місяць тому

      @@bowtieguy377 👍

  • @RolandBarrett-tc3sb
    @RolandBarrett-tc3sb Рік тому +1

    This is a great list! Yes, there are a lot of people that could easily fill in any of these spots, but the majority of these are on the mark for me.

  • @lucashernandez4345
    @lucashernandez4345 Рік тому +7

    And where are Pete Townshend, Axl Rose, Barry Gibb, Mick Jagger, Noel Gallagner, Thom Yorke, Roger Waters, Freddie Mercury, Robert Plant and Jeff Lyne....??? They should be here definitely ...

    • @CalebthegiganticMariofan
      @CalebthegiganticMariofan Місяць тому

      Pete Townshend: just backup vocals
      Axl Rose: not that good and only singer
      Barry Gibb: I guess he’s just not a Bee Gees fan
      Mick Jagger: just singer
      Noel Gallagher: not good and doesn’t sing
      Thom Yorke: untalented loser
      Roger Waters: idk why he isn’t here
      Freddie Mercury: just a singer usually, and didn’t write all of their hits
      Robert Plant: just singer
      Jeff Lynne: uh idk
      Also if ur complaining about all of those other people who some are just singers should’ve mentioned Morrison, singer for the best band ever

    • @danieleingusci8384
      @danieleingusci8384 5 днів тому

      Plus Elton John, Jackson Browne, Crosby Stills & Nash, Kate Bush, Carly Simon, Frey/Henley., Buffy Sainte-Marie...

  • @postfrozone9745
    @postfrozone9745 2 роки тому +9

    Your channel is so underrated

  • @peytonthepianoman
    @peytonthepianoman 2 роки тому +45

    Wait... Guys where's Freddie???

  • @shawnmcgregoric2960
    @shawnmcgregoric2960 2 роки тому +8

    According to both McCartney and John Lennon themselves, they believed that the song Yesterday, 'was mediocre' at best. Which is surprising 'cause like, it used to be the most covered song in YT...

  • @mikakoskinen1684
    @mikakoskinen1684 Рік тому +8

    1. Bob Dylan. He got even Nobel literature prize. Academy say there is not any songwriter, who could get that most prestigious prize.

    • @mostafamahmoud5524
      @mostafamahmoud5524 Рік тому

      McCartney was awarded by America president himself who can get more prestigious award than that. He also has Guinness records.

    • @anthonypalmer6374
      @anthonypalmer6374 8 місяців тому

      @@mostafamahmoud5524 Dylan got an award from the president also..

    • @ariasvictoria3829
      @ariasvictoria3829 6 місяців тому

      Let me remind you that songwriting is not only lyrics.

  • @hannejeppesen1809
    @hannejeppesen1809 2 місяці тому +1

    As others mentioned, where is Bono, Pete Townhsend, John Fogarty, and I will add 2 of my favorites, both wrote some incredible lyrics, Robbie Robertson of The Band, and Jim Morrison of The Doors.

    • @guitartommo2794
      @guitartommo2794 Місяць тому

      Yeah many missing…Freddie Mercury and lyrically Mark Knopfler is up there with Dylan.

  • @devinroshan2422
    @devinroshan2422 Рік тому +16

    anybody who wants good songwriting in this gen of music should listen to Taylor Swift's Albums not just her very famous singles but her incredible albums! especially folklore, Evermore, red, or speak now. There're so many hidden gems in her catalog u will not regret it

    • @gacwasanthi4568
      @gacwasanthi4568 Рік тому +3

      yesss she the only hope in today's big artist's music in my opinion

    • @Ok-tl1dv
      @Ok-tl1dv Рік тому +3

      I regretted😢

    • @lucashernandez4345
      @lucashernandez4345 Рік тому

      Zzzzz

    • @unicamentejoao5676
      @unicamentejoao5676 5 місяців тому

      ​@@Ok-tl1dvListen to "The lakes"," All too Well","Tolerate it" ,"This is me Trying" .
      You probably just listen those more generic and commercial songs that tend to be singles....

  • @marclapuz5753
    @marclapuz5753 Рік тому

    As turning 19 next month I love the Beatles so much

  • @Crisz23
    @Crisz23 2 роки тому +20

    I think billie joe armstrong, jim morrison, bono/the edge and eminem deserve a spot in this list but anyway good list

    • @PunkMarioBros
      @PunkMarioBros 2 роки тому

      I agree with Billie

    • @Golden_Eye464
      @Golden_Eye464 2 роки тому +6

      Would agree if it wouldn’t have said Singer-songwriter. Eminem for example is my favourite songwriter but can’t sing at all

    • @shomershabbos6291
      @shomershabbos6291 2 роки тому

      I agree with anyone but billie, good singer, decent song writer, but none of them are worrh mentioning in an all time list, maybe a 90's 2000's list, maybe

    • @sherwintavarez8539
      @sherwintavarez8539 2 роки тому +3

      Rap is a completely different type of songwriting, they don’t have to worry about chords or melody, just lyrics, and Eminem lyrics are nothing even close to Mariah Carey’s lyrics

    • @krisskora3348
      @krisskora3348 2 роки тому

      @@sherwintavarez8539 you need therapy😂😂

  • @adnin_hasanat_alfi6330
    @adnin_hasanat_alfi6330 2 роки тому +4

    Kurt cobain,george harrison,lennon/McCartney,chris cornell.

  • @atharvagautam7820
    @atharvagautam7820 2 роки тому +6

    What about Roger Waters?

  • @mcalbums9640
    @mcalbums9640 2 роки тому +10

    You could put Freddie Mercury

  • @amelajusic4479
    @amelajusic4479 2 роки тому +21

    what abt freddie mercury?

    • @garrus7221
      @garrus7221 2 роки тому +8

      Exactly guy wrote more hits than some of these guys combined!

    • @bestvocalsbyvocalists849
      @bestvocalsbyvocalists849 2 роки тому

      Ikr

    • @OnlyGoodMusic_
      @OnlyGoodMusic_ 3 місяці тому +2

      @@garrus7221 what is the argument? everyone in the top 10 made more hits than freddie

  • @efeaybars2504
    @efeaybars2504 2 роки тому +13

    sorry but its a bad list. where is mercuy, plant or morisson?

    • @TheManInMeOfficial
      @TheManInMeOfficial  2 роки тому +20

      Yes, all three of those people were songwriters, but pretty much always wrote songs with their bands and the rest of their bandmates are credited on the songs. For example, Jim Morrison did not write songs using an instrument, and the other band members would contribute to his lyrics and melodies helping to form the actual song. Every individual on this list is a songwriter on their own, and had successful solo careers. Not trying to discredit Jim Morrison, Robert Plant, or Freddy Mercury whatsoever, it’s just not the type of songwriter this video is meant to portray.

    • @DaveBallOW
      @DaveBallOW 2 роки тому +2

      Freddie Mercury's doesn't write particularly good songs

    • @scar5536
      @scar5536 2 роки тому +3

      @@DaveBallOW He wrote a ton of good songs on the 70's, the 80's was pretty hit or miss

    • @tomate454
      @tomate454 2 роки тому +2

      @@DaveBallOW what??? Bohemian rhapsody? Dont stop me now,it’s doesn’t have to be political or philosophical to be good,he was a incredible songwriter,he could easily be in the top 20 ,memorable songs with meaning ,many of them are sadly not that well known ,that’s why people only think of the mainstream stuff

  • @joshrimmer9487
    @joshrimmer9487 2 роки тому +1

    Finally some respect for harry chapin

  • @asvj
    @asvj Рік тому +3

    Taylor Swift😘😍❤

  • @gushickey1954
    @gushickey1954 2 роки тому +5

    Joni should be higher

  • @noahsart6254
    @noahsart6254 2 роки тому +3

    Thanks for at least putting him on but John Mayer’s got to be higher

  • @eddames9839
    @eddames9839 6 місяців тому

    What's the criteria used for the ranking???

    • @africanfartingfrog
      @africanfartingfrog 6 місяців тому +1

      This guy's personal opinion, like every such list

    • @guitartommo2794
      @guitartommo2794 Місяць тому

      The criteria that gets people complaining that better songwriters aren’t on the list… like Freddie Mercury, Jeff Lynne, John Fogerty and Mark Knopfler…damn I fell for it.😊

  • @TedBonkers
    @TedBonkers 4 місяці тому +2

    top ten is almost perfect, id put brian wilson at 4

  • @IzikWilliams99
    @IzikWilliams99 Рік тому

    🏆🎬

  • @jackrenolyds933
    @jackrenolyds933 Рік тому +4

    Madonna LOL

  • @topmore5200
    @topmore5200 2 роки тому

    Finally Madonna!!! YAS I love her.

  • @MokaTelevisiIndonesia
    @MokaTelevisiIndonesia Рік тому +2

    Paul Mc Cartney,,, Best Man,,,

  • @parsarazavi6545
    @parsarazavi6545 2 місяці тому

    Robert plants ❤❤

  • @DaveBallOW
    @DaveBallOW Рік тому +3

    But where is Jeff Lynne?

  • @flaviojosefo7130
    @flaviojosefo7130 2 роки тому +3

    Dolores O'Riordan

  • @chinelo1048
    @chinelo1048 2 роки тому

    Good list

  • @Lilylouie27
    @Lilylouie27 2 роки тому

    Harry Chapin appreciation!

  • @Sc00T668
    @Sc00T668 Рік тому +2

    I'm sorry but how is Axl rose not on this?! Man literally wrote the greatest rock ballot in history (novmeber rain) and estranged they're so relatable!

  • @gregsinn261
    @gregsinn261 8 місяців тому

    How can this list not have Jackson Browne, Bob Seger, John Prine, Glenn Frey/Don Henley, Roger Waters/David Gilmour, Robert Plant/ Jimmy Page, Pete Townshend.

  • @hengolanski7405
    @hengolanski7405 2 роки тому +2

    Thom yorke?

  • @OnlyGoodMusic_
    @OnlyGoodMusic_ 3 місяці тому

    I'm surprised to see Michael Jackson here, the song you used is "beat it" from the album Thriller, an album of 9 songs, where MJ only wrote 4!

  • @msog99
    @msog99 Рік тому +4

    Jeff lynne???

  • @rocklob069
    @rocklob069 Рік тому +2

    I was worried I wouldn't see billy joel

  • @matteodinenno
    @matteodinenno 2 місяці тому

    Paul McCartney, John Lennon, Elton John.

  • @jimbrew4529
    @jimbrew4529 8 місяців тому

    I grew up in the 60s and 70s pop/rock scene, so appreciate Dylan, Wilson, McCartney etc. But I also realize Irving Berlin was more influential than most on this list, with only a couple exceptions.

  • @Garetschuurman7
    @Garetschuurman7 Рік тому +3

    W

  • @mikewidyk4186
    @mikewidyk4186 Рік тому +2

    Crap list if there’s no Barry Gibb!
    How can you omit him? 🤷‍♂️
    He wrote many hits, including 20 that reached # 1!

  • @kaitlyng8968
    @kaitlyng8968 Рік тому +15

    Paul McCartney is the greatest songwriter of all time

  • @richiemays8225
    @richiemays8225 Рік тому +3

    Mariah Carey at 20 is CRAZY

    • @codywalsh2075
      @codywalsh2075 Рік тому

      She should be in the top 5

    • @lucashernandez4345
      @lucashernandez4345 Рік тому

      ​@@codywalsh2075 I disagree, she is better as a singer. But I appreciate her.

    • @codywalsh2075
      @codywalsh2075 Рік тому

      @@lucashernandez4345 well nobody asked you

  • @stepladder3257
    @stepladder3257 2 роки тому +3

    Morrissey should be here even though he is Morrissey

  • @marlondayao6084
    @marlondayao6084 Місяць тому

    Ray Davies of The Kinks should be on the list

  • @marcelgomesz
    @marcelgomesz 2 роки тому +2

    top 25 songs of david bowie when?

  • @md4933
    @md4933 2 роки тому +3

    Sting was alright, but let's get real, Newcastle's finest has to be Alan hull (lindisfarne)..Even sumner would admit that.

  • @TorstenHawkins-Asp
    @TorstenHawkins-Asp 5 днів тому

    Stevie nicks, Lou reed, Joni Mitchell, bob Dylan, George harrison, David Bowie, John Lennon, Paul McCartney are one of my favorite songwriters of all time, but I don’t listen todays music only 60s 70s 80s and 90s with grunge rock, art and alternative rock😂

  • @Atixon0fficial
    @Atixon0fficial 7 місяців тому +1

    I think that Damon and Noel deserve a spot on this list Noel is an immaculate songwriter and Damon is Damon.

  • @donaldcruse3402
    @donaldcruse3402 7 місяців тому +1

    Ann Wilson.

  • @Accam570
    @Accam570 4 місяці тому

    Hank Williams ❤

  • @parkyboy427
    @parkyboy427 Рік тому +7

    How is Noel Gallagher not there writing songs like wonderwall, don’t look back in anger, live forever and countless more

  • @DanielBurke-wg2hv
    @DanielBurke-wg2hv Рік тому +1

    Bob Gaudio? Barry Gibb? John Fogherty? Burt Bacharach? Pete Townsend? Keith Richards and Mick Jagger? Also, I love Johnny Cash, but I think a good amount of his hits were penned by other people.

    • @guitartommo2794
      @guitartommo2794 Місяць тому

      Re Burt B…I think Hal David wrote most of lyrics.

  • @noureddinejadyani5008
    @noureddinejadyani5008 Рік тому +1

    What about Tim Buckley?! I'm so surprised!

  • @HoratioJames
    @HoratioJames 10 днів тому

    Wheres Townsend and Daltrey?

  • @chasebriscoefan14
    @chasebriscoefan14 Рік тому +1

    Where is John Mellencamp, Steve Earle, John Fogerty and John Prine

  • @dennischeng4391
    @dennischeng4391 Місяць тому +1

    Brian Wilson should be in top 3

  • @Computerdude123
    @Computerdude123 6 місяців тому

    What about Ray Davies or Pete Townshend?

  • @liuhuichuan
    @liuhuichuan 2 роки тому +1

    The field of vision is a bit narrow, only English singers are in the video, and there are excellent singers in other languages all over the world.

    • @shomershabbos6291
      @shomershabbos6291 2 роки тому

      Yeah but like it or not, english is the unofficial language of the world, and just for the record it isn't my first language

  • @jeromegigon6184
    @jeromegigon6184 2 місяці тому

    And what about Michael Stipe?

  • @andrewsagai1987
    @andrewsagai1987 Рік тому +1

    Since john lennon write imagine hes number 1 for me

  • @hanspetermeier3653
    @hanspetermeier3653 2 роки тому +1

    Unfortunately the English speaking world is so limited. Have you ever heard e.g. of Ludwig Hirsch (Austria) or Fabrizio DeAndre (Italy)?

  • @shomershabbos6291
    @shomershabbos6291 2 роки тому +9

    I know it's hard to put together such a list, but this seems too personal, i mean taylor swift is here and freddy mercury isn't?

    • @canwehit1kvidswithoutanysu153
      @canwehit1kvidswithoutanysu153 Рік тому

      Ikr

    • @asvj
      @asvj Рік тому +3

      Taylor deserve to be here. She's in the top ten for me. Madonna should not be in this list.

    • @sdey893
      @sdey893 5 місяців тому

      ​@@asvjthat's just your terrible taste, doesn't mean she deserves to be here

  • @anthonymagkno
    @anthonymagkno 2 роки тому +2

    Jeff Lynne?

  • @777tims
    @777tims 2 місяці тому

    But only one of them received the Nobel price....So no doubt he is the best songwriter ever...Bob!

  • @melomanomexico6549
    @melomanomexico6549 2 роки тому +5

    i think this kind of videos should say "Greates singer songwriters of all time IN ENGLISH" the world is gigantic, for example in spanish there are a lot of better than most of your list

    • @charlotteholmes3056
      @charlotteholmes3056 2 роки тому

      Agree.
      I am from Brazil, and we have amazing singers/ songwriters as Raul Seixas, Renato Russo, Cazuza.
      If Renato Russo doesn't decide only write his lyrics in Portuguese he could reach internacional sucess.
      A true genius. Saddly he died so young.

    • @luisfd70
      @luisfd70 2 роки тому +1

      Cerati está entre los mejores.

  • @bowtieguy377
    @bowtieguy377 Місяць тому

    This was a nice attempt at a list of "All Time" and is fair in many respects. However, any such list is of course, subjective in terms of inclusion and rankings. However, the list contains some real flaws just in my opinion. First, there are artists on there from today like Taylor Swift. However talented she is, her songs have not stood the test of time yet, through no fault of her own and it remains to be seen if her songs will still be played 50 years from now across multiple generations. She may ultimately be well embedded into the list down the road but now is not the time. and she is not the only one. Then, there are others like Mariah Carey and Madonna, who most or all of their big hit songs that they supposedly "wrote", were written with multiple songwriter partners, which I think disqualifies them from this type of "Songwriter" list. They may have literally just written a few lines of lyrics to these songs, which is often the case. Also, there are some individuals like Lou Reed, that did not leave behind a body of work that was truly memorable to the full general public, other than 1 or 2 songs, despite their share of output The problem with all this is that this leaves off the list full songwriters who did meet the criteria I have tried to describe. To name just a few of these, think of Jim Croce, John Denver, Ray Davies, John Fogarty, Roger Waters, Pete Townsend, Eric Clapton etc. Whether or not you like these omissions and others not mentioned personally, they do meet some real criteria as I have outlined.

  • @samharryful
    @samharryful 4 місяці тому

    Pete Townshend and Freddie missing maybe Noel Gallagher

  • @davidhalsell6354
    @davidhalsell6354 9 днів тому

    Wow, no Mark Knopfler.

  • @MargotRobbieFan1
    @MargotRobbieFan1 Рік тому

    What about John Fogerty ?

  • @markingal8536
    @markingal8536 2 роки тому +4

    John lennon at three? You kidding me?

  • @charlotteholmes3056
    @charlotteholmes3056 2 роки тому +3

    WFH!!!!
    Where is NICK CAVE???
    Any list of great singers/songwriters in incomplet without Nick Cave, from Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds.
    This guy is a genius!!!
    By the way, Leonard Cohen deserved a better position on that list.

    • @SaharMaorLevy
      @SaharMaorLevy 6 місяців тому

      Nick is in 40
      My mom loves him

    • @charlotteholmes3056
      @charlotteholmes3056 6 місяців тому

      ​@@SaharMaorLevyIt is Nick CAVE, not Nick Drake.

    • @SaharMaorLevy
      @SaharMaorLevy 6 місяців тому

      @@charlotteholmes3056 Oh shit
      But my mom loved Nick Cave a lot

  • @shobaaddai6004
    @shobaaddai6004 Місяць тому

    No Patti Smith? Janis Joplin, also maybe somewhat unpopular opinion but if John Mayer is here I think so should Justin Vernon

  • @mauriliopasquinineto
    @mauriliopasquinineto Рік тому

    Where Debbie gibson at The list?

  • @harrybutcher3627
    @harrybutcher3627 2 роки тому +1

    Roy Orbison?

  • @ibeatles232
    @ibeatles232 2 роки тому +1

    where is robert plant

  • @Wqsmh
    @Wqsmh Рік тому

    Townes Van Zandt

  • @georgeknox1822
    @georgeknox1822 Рік тому

    No Gerry rafferty ?

  • @cathyferguson1488
    @cathyferguson1488 4 місяці тому

    Missed Barry Gibb & his bothers..

  • @2011littlejohn1
    @2011littlejohn1 3 місяці тому

    This says the greatest song writers of all time yet apart from one exception, all of these guys were from the 1950's onwards. Some of the most iconic song writers of all time such as Gershwin came from before then and to not be on this long list is not only unjust but betrays the philistine roots and ignorance of the compilers.

  • @aggelosmard491
    @aggelosmard491 Рік тому

    Elliott?

  • @zapdunga12
    @zapdunga12 9 місяців тому +1

    WHAT ABOUT ELTON JOHN? BARRY GIBB? JIM CROCE? NEIL YOUNG? GLEN FREY? DON HENLEY?

  • @c.a.d.w.a5573
    @c.a.d.w.a5573 2 роки тому +1

    George micheal should have been in the list too
    I mean you added micheal Jackson and he isn't a great song writer sure he wrote some good songs but...

  • @Junkyard_music69
    @Junkyard_music69 2 роки тому +1

    Where’s ringo?

    • @lzeb4730
      @lzeb4730 Рік тому +2

      Stop it...

    • @guitartommo2794
      @guitartommo2794 Місяць тому

      @@lzeb4730C’mon Octopus Garden is a classic.

  • @dm10107
    @dm10107 Рік тому +2

    Paul McCartney is the greatest of all time.