“No, you’re not middle-class!” | Profit Explains

We look at the surprisingly large number of upper-class elite that want to be seen to be a part of the middle-class.
Reporter: Shahnawaz Ali
Editor: Fawad Shakeel
Executive Producer: Umar Aziz Khan
#middleclass #ProfitExplains #Pakistan

[@cyberpros]

There was an article back in 2004-4 called 'The Vanishing Middle Class' by Dawn or Herold, i don't exactly recall. It talked about that there is no middle class, either your rich or poor (struggling in life to make ends meet). But still, its a debatable topic specially for a developing country like Pakistan with limited or no data.

[@whiteocean7555]

1. Extreme poor / Beggers
2. Lower class / poor
3. Lower middle class / low income working class.
4. Middle class / Mid-income working class.
5. Upper middle class / High income working class.
6. Upper class / Trend setters
7. Elite class / 1% Class

[@hanzlasoban6996]

Well said dear 🤗

[@hanzlasoban6996]

AOA bro

[@thisissheraz]

yes

[@hanzlasoban6996]

Messanger py message karo

[@shaziaaslam6104]

Bohat hee impressive talk
True and well searched

[@ahsanasad5421]

Well done young man... I am impressed by your content, material. Highly informative, if you will incorporate latest facts it will further enhance just as the data of World bank. Great work

[@pardesidost-kd5sc]

very good presentation and good effort. please update your numbers 🙂

[@coolmemon56]

Mind boggling conversation:
Income social class in Pakistan.
I can with utmost confidence can claim that the data to define socio-economic classes is greatly flawed. Its so stupid listening to people debate. Whatever the official classification of our government is, its definitely not accurate. The rich people in pakistan is extremely rich and the poor extremely poor. I can with 💯 guarantee say that due to our flawed system and people evading taxes noone shows their real earnings.
7 class system exists around the world and its definitely suited for us. If you start claiming that even a person that has his own house or a car belongs to the elite class, you're definitely not backing up the elite is 1% of our population point. By such a identification of an elite you're basically claiming that atleast or more than 30% of our population is elite; because just look at the real estate buy and transfer figures or new cars registered or sold figures. I definitely believe there exists the untouchables (elite/higher-upper class), then an upper class, then an upper-middle class, middle-class, lower-middle/working class, lower class, extremely poor class.
Until our systems or proper income data isn't in our hands which will only be possible is if we go completely digital and cashless until then, "you're an elite", "no I am not an elite" debate is stupid. Come to Karachi you'll know the ones you consider elite are just upper-middle or maybe even just middle.

[@goosebumpssoundtracks644]

100% agree 👍

[@taqihassan6595]

O bhai easy

[@pardesidost-kd5sc]

100000000 % correct

[@aliasimkazmi]

An interesting take on the whole middle class debate.

[@Anonymous-md4ql]

Shahnawz was working with Podcast speaker Syed Muzamil on PakistanNow, before joining this chennal e.g Profit

[@thebigshift]

Chalo hum ghareeb b apnay apko ameer samjhny lgy hain ye video daikhny k baad. Bht shukria. Kl petrol dalwana hy gari may, takleef hoge. Ameer wo hy jisy petrol dalwatay takleef nae hoti.

[@whiteocean7555]

Rich & Poor is a mindset, not social classes.

[@MrSHAYAAN786]

Agreed 💯

[@umairahmed1809]

Sir what about mehran euro 2 waly?

[@MuhammadAli-cs6ts]

مطلب میں بھی امیر لوگوں میں شمار ہوتا ہوں ،پہلی بار یہ پتا چلا

[@mir3877]

Matlab mein ameer houn?
Mein ameer houn. Mein ameer houn.

[@mohammadyasirkhan2709]

Is khushi main ghareeb na hojana😂😂 tum say upper bhi ameer hain

[@whiteocean7555]

There are 60 Million Pakistanis who have more than 10 million PKR of networth.

[@Bhatti_69]

Can you provide the source plz🙏

[@daniyaldanish8996]

✌🏻✌🏻✌🏻

[@sherazbaig822]

sir meri salary is waqt 24500 rupees per month he me kis class se hu??????

[@DaniyalHassan97]

depends apkay ghar mein baaaki logo ki kia earning hai

[@sherazbaig822]

@@DaniyalHassan97 sir me hi ghareeb hn baaqi 1 bhai manager he 250000 salary he us se chota depart incharch he us ki 70000 he or ussay chotay walay ki apni chemical shop he wo bhi 30 40 hazar tak kama leta he baaqi sab k sab bhai alag hen khana pakana lena dena ana jana sab alag he bas chatt ek he

[@DaniyalHassan97]

@@sherazbaig822 Allah ha sab pay reham farmaye aur hamein duniya jahan ki khushiyan aur dolat ata kare Ameen

[@sherazbaig822]

@@DaniyalHassan97 Ameen beshak Allah bohot meherban he

[@shahbazakhtar101]

This is A grade BS! Sarkar mein taluqat is not and "SHOULD" not be a parameter.

[@EhteshamShahzad]

Why not?
References matter in professional world. Both in Pakistan and abroad.

[@mailing2adeel]

Bhae pind chalay jao har ghareeb apnay apko thekaydar btata hay

[@Mi-ve9yr]

Key bakwas video ha