RE2 vs. RE4: Which is Better?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 17 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 100

  • @mathewyoungblood2357
    @mathewyoungblood2357 Рік тому +434

    They are both the best at what they do. Re2 best classic survival horror game. Re4 best action survival horror game.

    • @Gryphondork.
      @Gryphondork. Рік тому +5

      I think re3 has the best mix of survival/action

    • @Leon_S._Kennedy
      @Leon_S._Kennedy Рік тому +14

      ​@@Gryphondork. classic re2>classic re 3 in my opinion

    • @Gryphondork.
      @Gryphondork. Рік тому +4

      @@Leon_S._Kennedy well tbf Re2was very new with way more locations, new characters, was longer, and was more focused on survival horror even though both are scary asl. I really liked the dodge mechanic and decision making in 3 though. It felt very fresh. Not to mention Nemesis at that time was by far the most intimidating enemy in the RE franchise. I think most people would agree that 2 is better though due to it actually feeling like its own game. 3 to me feels more like an expansion to 2. I think we can all agree CV was the ACTUAL Re3.

    • @FIREDAN075
      @FIREDAN075 Рік тому +1

      ​@Daman hell no, it may be bad remake, but it is better then Re5 and Re6 definitely

    • @Leon_S._Kennedy
      @Leon_S._Kennedy Рік тому +3

      ​@@FIREDAN075 re 3 remake was one of the worst remake of all time
      People love shit on re 6 and re5 but they are great game
      Gameplay carried re 6
      Wesker carried re 5 best villain in the series

  • @jackjax7921
    @jackjax7921 9 місяців тому +33

    Both have insane replay value. The director of RE 5 also directed both of these games. Are you ready for Re 5 Remake?

    • @lightningmonky7674
      @lightningmonky7674 6 місяців тому +3

      I am! Same for 6! As I've never played any RE games this remake series has been an amazing adventure for me, I still hope they re-remake RE1 cause I just cannot play with that camera

    • @se3627
      @se3627 6 місяців тому +3

      Yasuhiro Anpo is a good director, Revelations 2, which he directed, is one of my favorites, but honestly he seems very lost in his decisions. RE5, for example, tries to be RE4 at all costs, forgetting even its very good ideas, such as the events of Lost In Nightmares being a DLC and not the game's introduction. RE2R has a fantastic setting, but they forgot the simplest thing about the game, the coherence of the stories, making it worse than its 1998 version, which delivered two stories tied together. RE4R only became more successful because it went through the hands of M-Two, and was directed by Tatsuya Minami, friend of Shingi Mikami and producer of RE∅, in addition to the game's production at M-Two being under Hiroyuki Kobayashi, the same of RE4OG, more due to creative differences, the game went to division 1 practically ready, and Yasuhiro Anpo himself stated that he took many things ready, such as the knife parry being made just to fight Krauser, and he ended up putting it in entire game. in RE5, many of the positive things came much more from Kenichi Ueda, also the director of RE5. I'm not saying that it's bad, but he himself said that many of the project's new features, whether mixing the original's scenarios, climate changes or things like that, were done in the final stretch of production, and even considered postponing the project with weeks to go. release due to the immense number of bugs. Ultimately, I hope that in the next Remake, which will most likely be RE1, if he is the director, he will have a better direction for the project than wanting to reinvent the wheel and bring new features that often seem forced, as was the case in certain 4 things that you feel were implemented at the last minute. But if it's to be guessed, RE1 Remake should come in 2026 directed by either Tatsuya Minami or Yasuhiro Anpo, but it should already be made by M-Two.

    • @se3627
      @se3627 6 місяців тому

      ​@@lightningmonky7674Man, RE5 and RE6 are still extremely modern, there is even a mod for RE4 on PC that leaves the game with gameplay similar to RE6 and practically identical to RE5, even changing weapons in real time and walking and aiming is also allowed. But RE6 Remake is already crazy, maybe the remake of 6 could come in 2037, since I only believe that Capcom will release 5 Remake in 2034 due to the original game's 25th anniversary on that date. The next Remake will most likely be RE1 in 2026, in 2027 there should be a Spin Off, most likely Revelations 3, in 2028 the Remake of RE∅ should come out, as on that date the game celebrates 25 years, and in 2029 Resident Evil 10 , since a new RE comes out every 4 years, so if the 9 comes out in 2025, the next one comes out in 2029. And finally, in 2030 the remake of CODE: Veronica should come to celebrate the 30th anniversary of the original game. The Remake of 5 should only come after that date.

    • @VotiveNutria
      @VotiveNutria Місяць тому +1

      @@lightningmonky7674exactly what I’ve been saying. I’m not used to that stationary cams.

  • @CaliJose209
    @CaliJose209 9 місяців тому +30

    In re2 he's the new guy who is trying his best and in re4 he just doesnt give af 😂

  • @djghost09
    @djghost09 Рік тому +116

    I like how in re 2 Leon is walking while holding his gun like a cop should and in re 4 he is an ex cop and just walks with the gun in one hand

    • @imfuckingclown3302
      @imfuckingclown3302 11 місяців тому +7

      Because Leon in RE4 is Agent not a cop

    • @evilsaii
      @evilsaii 10 місяців тому +4

      there is some points when walking with a pistol he’ll go back to holding it. only for a quick sec tho

    • @Nf_X4-115
      @Nf_X4-115 9 місяців тому +5

      Re2 leon is a cop in training re4 Leon has gone through far more training that most didnt survive..

  • @ej38
    @ej38 Рік тому +61

    i realized the crosshair is much bigger in Re2 compared to Re4 , just so in re4 aiming is way easier which shows how Leon training after the Raccoon city incident improved his skills

    • @barebarekun161
      @barebarekun161 11 місяців тому +4

      It was the other way around for me, RE2R aiming was much smoother than RE4R.
      While on RE4R the aiming feel feels clumsy.
      and not precise enough.

    • @TekPlayzGames
      @TekPlayzGames 10 місяців тому

      I have an easy time aiming in both games, though I do prefer 2's aiming since I'm more used to and skilled at it.

  • @ItsSpeedyVR
    @ItsSpeedyVR Рік тому +198

    You can definitely see how more action pack re4 is trying to be, although I’m more a re2 fan

    • @emmabailey6028
      @emmabailey6028 Рік тому

      Ye

    • @idk_eon
      @idk_eon Рік тому +9

      re2 is just straight up nostalgia man i miss those days roaming around the whole RPD i love that game more than re4

  • @iams1635
    @iams1635 10 місяців тому +9

    21 year old Leon vs 27 year old ptsd Leon, both are great, and I love how they aged him up!

  • @joyobrien9939
    @joyobrien9939 Рік тому +29

    RE2R is the best 3rd person RE game there is in my opinion. Its just not as flashy or action packed as RE4, which is what i like about it.

  • @josephgarcia4302
    @josephgarcia4302 Рік тому +16

    Both are very good in the same way the ogs were re2 was always scary never action i loved it both games and re4 always more action with a bit of creepyness too it i like that the new one could also capture that as well both amazing games

  • @anthonyhawthorne3450
    @anthonyhawthorne3450 Рік тому +6

    Man I've done re2 nearly 100 times and I still go back for more. As much as I enjoyed re4 I never found them action games something I can go back to. I just love good ol survival horror

  • @sylee1411
    @sylee1411 Рік тому +11

    Re2 still the best for me so far. The physics so damn good than others. Best re series

  • @standardmax4373
    @standardmax4373 Рік тому +2

    Both amazing games. The trouble with comparing them is they're almost different genres. Re2 is strictly survival horror with some action elements. Re4 starts the same way, but by the time you reach the castle in act 2 you're basically in for an action experience. I love them both for what they try to do. The knife parry really makes you feel like a badass Leon, though. And Mercenaries mode caught me a lot more than the extra scenarios mode in re2.

  • @BlackThief843
    @BlackThief843 Рік тому +9

    TBH both are good but obviously re4r is best although I am still the fan of re2r Ada

  • @thebigcj517
    @thebigcj517 8 місяців тому +1

    Leon s kenndy 2 little cat & Leon 4 Big fish

  • @rodrygerr
    @rodrygerr 8 місяців тому

    GOAT Character in videogames

  • @the.bloodless.one1312
    @the.bloodless.one1312 Рік тому +9

    RE4 Leon’s eyeballs always looked fucking WEIRD to me

    • @Dukesparrow1999
      @Dukesparrow1999 10 місяців тому +8

      I mean bruss must not have been able to sleep after all that shit in Racoon City so he kind of looks so tired

  • @Dukesparrow1999
    @Dukesparrow1999 10 місяців тому +1

    IMO both are great at what they do
    RE2: Survival Horror Reimagined
    RE4: Action Horror Reimagined
    Both appeal to modern audiences as they do to players that played the OG versions of both

  • @mb-md3wj
    @mb-md3wj 10 місяців тому

    I'm new to the resident evil franchise. I've played re4 remake and I had so much fun with it. Now I'm playing re2 at first I was feeling iffy, but after playing for a couple hours I'm having a blast

  • @highlightedlegend7533
    @highlightedlegend7533 Рік тому +3

    Both are sick. Re4 is a bit too long so I just mainly play re2 more but I can't pick.

    • @JamesPlaysGames-tm5oe
      @JamesPlaysGames-tm5oe Рік тому

      So you never played a long game or something?

    • @highlightedlegend7533
      @highlightedlegend7533 Рік тому

      @@JamesPlaysGames-tm5oe Nah. I played lots of long games. But for a resident evil game, re4 feels just a bit stretched out. But hey, no game is perfect and i love re4. The Resident Evil series is very unique but I just think the remake should of been slightly shorter.

    • @anthonyhawthorne3450
      @anthonyhawthorne3450 Рік тому

      Re2 is short and sweet🤟

  • @frantic1987
    @frantic1987 Рік тому +6

    No doubt RE 2 is the best of The BEST.

  • @kem8337
    @kem8337 11 місяців тому

    Leon looks accurate in RE2.. but he looks like Chucky in RE4

  • @imjustgooder8898
    @imjustgooder8898 Рік тому +15

    I dont get how re4 models look worse than re2s

    • @GhostlyFilm
      @GhostlyFilm Рік тому +1

      RIGHT

    • @Murderdroneslover1
      @Murderdroneslover1 8 місяців тому

      It is because of the dirt on Leon and how gritty the re2 was than Re4 is. And we really don’t know if this is max settings on graphics.

  • @igotbusybees
    @igotbusybees 11 місяців тому +2

    2 is the best remake by far

  • @andreahueck6207
    @andreahueck6207 4 місяці тому

    I like RE2 because it’s more horror centric. Re4’s action focus made it feel more grindy and it really wasn’t scary.

  • @brianlaudrupchannel
    @brianlaudrupchannel 10 місяців тому

    Both different and great games

  • @masterfrank629
    @masterfrank629 10 місяців тому

    Resi 2 takes its roots more in depth by incorporating the classic style and gameplay but Resi 4 is just pure action king of bliss its on another level and i cant even begin on where to appreciate it completely

  • @AliNayini
    @AliNayini Рік тому +5

    Interesting how re2 remake has used mocap and re4 remake hasn't!

    • @RacoonCityPizza
      @RacoonCityPizza Рік тому +4

      RE4 Remake did use mocap...the entire game is...

  • @TheHyper-v5k
    @TheHyper-v5k Рік тому +4

    resident evil 4 remake

  • @lightningmonky7674
    @lightningmonky7674 6 місяців тому

    I love both but re4 is just more my style, I love feeling like kicking ass despite the stacked odds. Same reason I love dead space and the new Alan Wake

  • @audrivalentin4451
    @audrivalentin4451 10 місяців тому +1

    I'm just mad they nerfed my storage box in re4😤😤😤

  • @luisb.garcia8493
    @luisb.garcia8493 11 місяців тому

    Re2 slow motion run: Dammm leon run the tyrant its behind you run..
    Same for re3 remake: with fun running carlos lmao

  • @Ash_williams278
    @Ash_williams278 9 місяців тому

    i like leon’s clothes in 2

  • @bigmanliam
    @bigmanliam 6 місяців тому +2

    What is this goofy ah slay music 💅

  • @TekPlayzGames
    @TekPlayzGames 10 місяців тому

    I much prefer RE2 remake, but both of these remakes are amazing. But to me, Claire's Campaign in RE2 on either Standard or Hardcore can't be beat.

  • @artusanctus997
    @artusanctus997 Рік тому

    Well, RE2R has many of the mechanics seen in RE4R except for the knife parry and the melees.

  • @free_palestine_8481
    @free_palestine_8481 Рік тому +1

    Rookie Vs expert

  • @이승철-p4p
    @이승철-p4p 10 місяців тому +1

    both of them are fun, but i prefer re2...it's more horrifing.

  • @syedbokhari4960
    @syedbokhari4960 Рік тому +1

    Bro, they don t run they just jog

  • @Mrleahey
    @Mrleahey Рік тому

    RE4 any version, any day

  • @MR.fachaxd
    @MR.fachaxd Рік тому +1

    Both

  • @finnandjake6653
    @finnandjake6653 Рік тому +1

    OG RE4 will always be better

  • @Donnydoostuff
    @Donnydoostuff Рік тому +2

    I enjoy re4 more just because there is more action, my adhd brain needs something to do at all times

  • @PresidentEvil2
    @PresidentEvil2 Рік тому +1

    2

  • @leonscennedy9764
    @leonscennedy9764 Рік тому

    For everytime 4

  • @glasshalffullofwhatever3106
    @glasshalffullofwhatever3106 10 місяців тому +1

    Re4rm..they had more time to refine the cosmetics of REengine, movement and mechanics felt smoother, more enemy variety, upgrades ect....Mr. X stalking you thru the RPD in 2 was epic though...

  • @HotSizzleTV_
    @HotSizzleTV_ 11 місяців тому

    Both are good but 4 takes it.

  • @robinthebest5278
    @robinthebest5278 11 місяців тому +2

    Leons face on res evil 4 look awful

  • @NightSentinelProductions
    @NightSentinelProductions Рік тому +2

    Leon was unexperienced during re2, which is why is can do sneak attacks or spin kicks.

  • @blakeimoutin9950
    @blakeimoutin9950 8 місяців тому

    Cara, eu sofri nas primeiras horas de gameplay do Re2 remake vsfd, o Leon não parece que sai do lugar, e isso me deixava paranóico quando o mr X tava vindo atrás de mim, nunca parecia que eu ia conseguir fugir dele 😂😂😂

  • @Goodsoup496
    @Goodsoup496 Рік тому +1

    Like re4 was already a masterpiece before and I didn't need a remake people were worried Capcom would make it bad but some how they made re4 even better

  • @CruzHackett
    @CruzHackett 5 місяців тому

    Re4 leon can run faster because he is trained by military

  • @jakemooshian2995
    @jakemooshian2995 Рік тому +1

    Obviously resident evil 4 remake better story and boss fights best capcom game ever I love it so much

  • @bepenho
    @bepenho Рік тому +4

    They are two great games but i think that re2 is most limited in gameplay what makes re4 the best

  • @matteobovo2126
    @matteobovo2126 Рік тому +3

    Resident Evil 2 is better as a RE game.
    Let's be honest, RE4 is just a horror-themed tps with a not so great gunplay. It's not RE and neither was the original. And If I want to play a tps I have plenty of better options.
    RE2 remake is classic survival horror that plays like a modern game. Perfection.
    But now, due to the success of RE 8 and 4, we're back to action oriented RE games, again. Thank you RE community...

    • @manuelgarciajr5308
      @manuelgarciajr5308 Рік тому +3

      I agree that Re2 remake is a better representation of the O.G Survival horror series RE is meant to be. However, I enjoy RE4 remake more. Not sure how you dont think the gunplay is not great. It feels more refined than the RE2 remake imo. Re4 was almost a perfect balance of action and horror. Re5 is where they wemt over board with the action aspect imo.

    • @anthonyhawthorne3450
      @anthonyhawthorne3450 Рік тому +1

      Sad but true. The years on these guys are gonna start crying again as to why it's gone back to action🤑🤤

    • @Rr-rb9uv
      @Rr-rb9uv 9 місяців тому

      “thank you community” just because you don’t like it doesn’t mean we’re not allowed to. There’s a reason why 4 is one of, if not the most popular game of the series. The action and gunplay was amazing, you’re crazy.
      Stop being a baby. If you don’t like how the next game will turn out, then don’t buy it. There’s already multiple horror-focused RE games, go play those

    • @brendanfrost2475
      @brendanfrost2475 9 місяців тому

      Yet it's critically acclaimed and labelled as one of the greatest games in history

  • @sweetygurvinder9522
    @sweetygurvinder9522 Рік тому +2

    It’s is difficult to aim with on ps4 in both games one is slow one is to fast 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @gregk3226
    @gregk3226 Рік тому +1

    re4 was a better remake. re2 shouldve been remade like re1

  • @jaxsonbirch5677
    @jaxsonbirch5677 Рік тому

    Both re2 remake and re4 remakes are the best remakes in the resident evil franchise so far in my opinion although re4 slightly beats re2

  • @ZombiemanTemple
    @ZombiemanTemple Рік тому +2

    RE2R hands down. RE4R is a cheap knock off of the greatest game ever made.

    • @thereddestofthefields2029
      @thereddestofthefields2029 Рік тому +2

      Not true in the slightest

    • @ItsQuackie
      @ItsQuackie Рік тому +3

      Nostalgia blinded you, innit?

    • @Erebus-f7v
      @Erebus-f7v 9 місяців тому +2

      This. Mindless consumers will just swallow anything if the graphics are better

    • @ItsGgg123
      @ItsGgg123 5 місяців тому +1

      Not at all kid