So important for beginners to start to learn by ear and build that foundation that will help down the line, learning to separate the notes that you hear in order to build the chords of a song, and listening for little intricacies and such.
Great advice. Older players remember having to work out songs. Having that skill, even in an imperfect way, also helps when we're learning songs with today's resources.
Your impression is spot on ,you have a natural ear for Keith's nuances. Sometimes tough for people to duplicate. I often wonder if people can hear what I hear..
Some background: Recorded October 5, 1974, according to a YT interview with Mick from this past week. Mick dubbed maracas onto the track recently (from same interview). Per Felix Aeppli, song was composed by Keith and the players on the original session were KR: guitar, vocals; Jimmy Page: guitar; Ian Stewart: piano; Rick Grech: bass; Bruce Rowland. Overdubs followed in November 1974. You can read Felix account of the track here: aeppli.ch/Stones/TUGKeithUp.pdf - Felix has the session (incorrectly) as October 15, 1974. Wondering if Mick's vocal is contemporary as well. It sounds really good whenever he recorded it. Maybe MJ wrote most of the lyrics recently, too? Love the channel!
That Mick interview I mentioned is here: ua-cam.com/video/hM0L8vfKeN8/v-deo.html. I'm taking the session date off the tape box which flies by at some point in the video.
Joel Fragomeni Strange if it was recorded in 74 that they would release it with Goats Head Soup & not wait for some future It’s Only Rock N Roll deluxe edition.
You're doing a hell of a job...not working by black lines and notes on paper but by jamming on the track and finding the feel of the song.... For me...that's Rock'n'roll!
The song is very Houses of Holy - Page did the heavy lifting in the studio. Keith laid the riff and Mick remastered it for 2020 - this is all Page influence and most probably for Ronnie Wood's solo album. Either way who gives a fuck its a killer track. Been listening to it all day and its been in my head ever since I heard it. Rock on chaps
Dude, you are amazing! And I never knew Jimmy played the solo on "One Hit (to the Body)". Also thanks to you, I can recognize he's playing his B-bender. That's about as good as my ear gets.
I just endorsed your channel on a Marty music recommending the “for you blue” lesson. I have never done that with another UA-camr but you deserve that.
Ronnie was not there. He was on tour, that’s for sure. Keith was living there for a few months. Yes it looks like this for Ronnie’s album. Even the recording was done for IORR, that album came out maybe 2 weeks after this recording with Jimmy Page about 17 or 18 of October 1974. This recording seemed to be done October the 5th of 1974
This track sounded very Barbarian-esque to me. I have to believe that Ronnie had some sort of involvement in the song. Great tutorial, thank you for all of your videos.
Yes you got the dates right, from what Mick was saying . And yeah I've got my own album to do was recorded in Ronnie's basement . Alot of talent showed up including David Bowie , Keith Moon, Mick Taylor and now we know Page was there too. Keith is on most those tracks singing backing vocals and playing guitar. Mick is also on "Can you feel the fire" and I think I hear him in the mix of "Am I grooving you". Fantastic album. That band "The new barbarians " was great . Willie Weeks , Ian Mclagan and Andy Newmark.
Good job, Mr. Tufnel. Definitely after GHS, maybe for IORNR, but you are probably right, for Woody's album. My only question is whether there was any overdubbing done to it - new vocals etc like they have done for some of the Exile bonus tracks. You are correct - Page's work was restrained which suits the song perfectly. Imagine the -ahem- substances that must have been flowing at that session in '74 with Keith, Jimmy and Ronnie. I'm getting a contact high from just listening to it. Keep up the excellent work!!!!
Great ear! I couldn’t even notice the low G note playing til you pointed it out. Though you can make the argument that even though Keith is playing in open G it’s better to play in standard since the main riff is only the middle 3 strings, and then you can play full minor chords on the chorus.
Great , thank you. Altough guitar playing is abracadabra to me...... I don’t have it in my fingers.😜🤪 But like the song already better by your playing 😎😀👊🏻👊🏻
Man is this growing on me. Thanks for the lesson. It sounds very Ronnie Wood to me. With the bass line echoing Hot Stuff. Cant seem to find out who’s drumming. Not Charlie but don’t see it listed anywhere.
Yes from all information available it was recorded in 74. Most likely for Woody’s album. Since this would have ended up on Its Only Rock and Roll if it was released I think Mick pushed it to goats head since I seems like it was mostly complete. I do hear some of modern mick on the track but not really during the verses and choruses. I really don’t think there are many nuggets to mine from for Its only rock and roll, unless the release the full uncut Mick Taylor solo on Time Waits for No one. Doubtful.
This is your big moment to wear a conflicting shirt and guitar! It's like a mix of Hey Negrita, Monkey Man, Ron Wood's I Can Feel The Fire, and The Black Crowes Gone and Conspiracy. I think it's a great song. I just don't consider it the Stones, like Memo from Turner. The only Stones thing about it is Mick's voice. Well, according to Mr Fragomeni below, Keith is also on it. And great job, by the way. I forget if you have Dumbo ears or have the master plugged straight into your brain.
C cross is definitely in open g too. And you’re definitely right about the dates. If you listen to the BBC recent radio interview with page and mick on this song, they give all the dates and details about the recording. 1974 in woods basement. They included it on GHS reissue because well it’s near the time period, and they needed new material (awesome song). And doubt the stones will ever do a IORR reissue.
How do you get the guitar in the song to stand out like that? When I listen to the regular version the guitar is much harder to distinguish from the mix.
You think it's the Tele neck bucker? I was thinking a P90 maybe. I could tell it was in Open G right away too. It then became obvious it was in E. I couldn't nail that riff like you did. I thought it was a typical Keef sus chord. Nice work. Page has the houses of the holy album guitar sound going on.
So important for beginners to start to learn by ear and build that foundation that will help down the line, learning to separate the notes that you hear in order to build the chords of a song, and listening for little intricacies and such.
It does sound like something that could've been on Ronnie's I've Got My Own Album to Do, one of my favorite albums
How should I start learning by ear. Seems hard
Great advice. Older players remember having to work out songs. Having that skill, even in an imperfect way, also helps when we're learning songs with today's resources.
Your impression is spot on ,you have a natural ear for Keith's nuances. Sometimes tough for people to duplicate. I often wonder if people can hear what I hear..
That one is a Jimmy Page Dragon Telecaster, what a wondeful guitar and perfect for this song
Really amazing how you can figure this out days after it was released. Awesome to see a collab between these legends, nice job man!
I think Jimmy works really well with them. Would be so cool if he had a guest spot on this next Stones album.
Keith would never allow it. I get the feeling that's why this was never released at the time.
Some background: Recorded October 5, 1974, according to a YT interview with Mick from this past week. Mick dubbed maracas onto the track recently (from same interview). Per Felix Aeppli, song was composed by Keith and the players on the original session were KR: guitar, vocals; Jimmy Page: guitar; Ian Stewart: piano; Rick Grech: bass; Bruce Rowland. Overdubs followed in November 1974. You can read Felix account of the track here: aeppli.ch/Stones/TUGKeithUp.pdf - Felix has the session (incorrectly) as October 15, 1974. Wondering if Mick's vocal is contemporary as well. It sounds really good whenever he recorded it. Maybe MJ wrote most of the lyrics recently, too? Love the channel!
That Mick interview I mentioned is here: ua-cam.com/video/hM0L8vfKeN8/v-deo.html. I'm taking the session date off the tape box which flies by at some point in the video.
Joel Fragomeni Strange if it was recorded in 74 that they would release it with Goats Head Soup & not wait for some future It’s Only Rock N Roll deluxe edition.
Joel Fragomeni vocals are from 74 too. Can’t mistake Keith Richards great harmony vocals from that period of the band! He can’t sing that way now
As a beginner guitarist learning a song and riffs like this seems incredibly impressive and difficult
You're doing a hell of a job...not working by black lines and notes on paper but by jamming on the track and finding the feel of the song....
For me...that's Rock'n'roll!
Great comment, thanks.
The amazing headless guitarist
The song is very Houses of Holy - Page did the heavy lifting in the studio. Keith laid the riff and Mick remastered it for 2020 - this is all Page influence and most probably for Ronnie Wood's solo album. Either way who gives a fuck its a killer track. Been listening to it all day and its been in my head ever since I heard it. Rock on chaps
I'm gonna guess Jimmy Standard, Keith Open G
Real master with humour .Enjoyed to see him.
Shirt noticed. Greetings from Nederland=the Netherlands 🇳🇱. Love your channel! Keep on rocking 👊🏼
Dude, you are amazing! And I never knew Jimmy played the solo on "One Hit (to the Body)". Also thanks to you, I can recognize he's playing his B-bender. That's about as good as my ear gets.
Nice Telecaster, sir , and nice cover too
It's always a mystery to me how this is all sussed out. I have a tin ear so I am just in awe. It's aural alchemy
Same here. My ear is terrible and I know it. "Man needs to know his limitations" Dirty Harry.
A deep bow for the shirt JJ😎Great tutorial as always!! Grtzz from Nederland
I just endorsed your channel on a Marty music recommending the “for you blue” lesson. I have never done that with another UA-camr but you deserve that.
such a great ear, awesome tutorial, didnt try to play it but really enjoyed the progress of learning it by ear.
Ronnie was not there. He was on tour, that’s for sure. Keith was living there for a few months. Yes it looks like this for Ronnie’s album. Even the recording was done for IORR, that album came out maybe 2 weeks after this recording with Jimmy Page about 17 or 18 of October 1974. This recording seemed to be done October the 5th of 1974
I really like Richards funky/reggae riffs. Great song!!!!
Nice shirt dude, I love it!
Well, nice job you did and ehhh....stunning T-shirt :-) You got a lot of fans in Holland!
Noord- of Zuid Holland? Nederland verder niet?
Cheers from Texas
As soon as this song came out I was hoping for a video from you soon
Greetings from the Netherlands James! Keep up the good work!
I love a riddle. You make me better. Great exercise!
As always - many thanks! All Stones are always appreciated!
This track sounded very Barbarian-esque to me. I have to believe that Ronnie had some sort of involvement in the song. Great tutorial, thank you for all of your videos.
Awesome, I’m watching it now at 3:30am , incredible!
Fantastico James... and a great Keef riff that...
Awesome job Jimmy Jimmy!!!
You have an Exceptional Ear for Accurately figuring these songs out and especially the Alternate Tunings.......
Thanks James, awesome job! Had my fingers cross you would jump on this one real soon.
Thanks James James but it's just one more big hit by the greatest band in the world!
Rolling Stones forever!
Thanks for this lesson really helped me out!
Yes you got the dates right, from what Mick was saying . And yeah I've got my own album to do was recorded in Ronnie's basement . Alot of talent showed up including David Bowie , Keith Moon, Mick Taylor and now we know Page was there too. Keith is on most those tracks singing backing vocals and playing guitar. Mick is also on "Can you feel the fire" and I think I hear him in the mix of "Am I grooving you". Fantastic album. That band "The new barbarians " was great . Willie Weeks , Ian Mclagan and Andy Newmark.
Good job, Mr. Tufnel. Definitely after GHS, maybe for IORNR, but you are probably right, for Woody's album. My only question is whether there was any overdubbing done to it - new vocals etc like they have done for some of the Exile bonus tracks. You are correct - Page's work was restrained which suits the song perfectly. Imagine the -ahem- substances that must have been flowing at that session in '74 with Keith, Jimmy and Ronnie. I'm getting a contact high from just listening to it. Keep up the excellent work!!!!
man, what do you use for recording these videos? sounds way better than my interface! lol
Great ear! I couldn’t even notice the low G note playing til you pointed it out. Though you can make the argument that even though Keith is playing in open G it’s better to play in standard since the main riff is only the middle 3 strings, and then you can play full minor chords on the chorus.
Excellent James, idea & execution
you are an extremely good player.
Best Version on UA-cam............
Nice! Jimmy Page is playing a very cool guitar fill behind Kieth's main guitar rythm. From the solo it sounds like Page is playing a tele as well.
Great , thank you. Altough guitar playing is abracadabra to me...... I don’t have it in my fingers.😜🤪 But like the song already better by your playing 😎😀👊🏻👊🏻
Duuuuuuude! Thanks! Killer shirt!....Funky!
Wow... way to go.... nice disection and reconstruction! Amp setting or pedals involved?
Man is this growing on me. Thanks for the lesson. It sounds very Ronnie Wood to me. With the bass line echoing Hot Stuff. Cant seem to find out who’s drumming. Not Charlie but don’t see it listed anywhere.
Another commenter, Joel Fragomeni, lists the drummer as Bruce Rowland
Mick said something about Ginger Baker but then took it back
Great tune, GREAT JOB James!
I think Keith is in G and Jimmy in standard tuning
Yes from all information available it was recorded in 74. Most likely for Woody’s album. Since this would have ended up on Its Only Rock and Roll if it was released I think Mick pushed it to goats head since I seems like it was mostly complete. I do hear some of modern mick on the track but not really during the verses and choruses.
I really don’t think there are many nuggets to mine from for Its only rock and roll, unless the release the full uncut Mick Taylor solo on Time Waits for No one. Doubtful.
Love your reference to spinal tap with the pic of Nigel Tufnel... the only question I have is does your amplifier go up to 11?
Well, it's one louder.
That’s how ya do it!
Great song! Thanks for breaking it down, man.
Great job James!!! But i hear some little variations on Keef riffs during the song....it's not the same riff
Thanks for the content 👌🏼
You're on the day!
Your a music mechanic.......well done!
COOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Love the tshirt james.
I wish you were my guitar teacher
Derpetology 101 he’s my virtual guitar teacher lol
the suspension of the g is a usual give away, great vid bro 👍✌️
Yo u are the best I love it thanks
This is your big moment to wear a conflicting shirt and guitar! It's like a mix of Hey Negrita, Monkey Man, Ron Wood's I Can Feel The Fire, and The Black Crowes Gone and Conspiracy. I think it's a great song. I just don't consider it the Stones, like Memo from Turner. The only Stones thing about it is Mick's voice. Well, according to Mr Fragomeni below, Keith is also on it. And great job, by the way. I forget if you have Dumbo ears or have the master plugged straight into your brain.
kudos for the t-shirt . playing topnotch as always...
Cool video! Nicely done!
Great job! ✌️🎸🇨🇦
C cross is definitely in open g too. And you’re definitely right about the dates. If you listen to the BBC recent radio interview with page and mick on this song, they give all the dates and details about the recording. 1974 in woods basement. They included it on GHS reissue because well it’s near the time period, and they needed new material (awesome song). And doubt the stones will ever do a IORR reissue.
How do you get the guitar in the song to stand out like that? When I listen to the regular version the guitar is much harder to distinguish from the mix.
You think it's the Tele neck bucker? I was thinking a P90 maybe. I could tell it was in Open G right away too. It then became obvious it was in E. I couldn't nail that riff like you did. I thought it was a typical Keef sus chord. Nice work. Page has the houses of the holy album guitar sound going on.
Great job!
Killer tune!!
As a Page solo, it definitely has some houses of the holy esque feeling,
Leuk shirt!!! Nice shirt!!!
I need tabs for this
I hear a tiny smidgen of "Whole Lotta Love" in there
Nice shirt greetings from "Nederland"
Where does goats head rank on your list of top stones albums? It’s not been very high on my list. But this song helps.
Great shirt.
no surprise it’s open g if it’s keith.
What is the tunning?
👍
Looks like a Page, replica fender
Not a Fender, it’s from Crucible Customs.
SOS un crack!
The main riff?
Is that jimmy pages telecaster?
Yes, but he said I could use it. Honest.
“New” like Tattoo You.
I was right!!! Not a hard guess though
The Netherlands national team were never as good as Holland but by no means were they worse than the Dutch.