"Two the most stupid kings of Poland in history? John III Sobieski and me myself. We both have foolishly saved Habsburgs from total catastrophe..." Tsar Nicholas I of Russia
Comrade Ivan Ivanov Ivanovich Maybe he was a king of something similar to Poland but he wasn't king of the polish people. Probably that's why they overthrowed him ;)
+yoda 222, you have a very intrusive habit of speaking for all of Poles, as if Poles have one opinion for all. You can not know how the Poles of that time thought. The presence of the rebels only spoke of the presence of dissatisfied, nothing more.
My own family in long term hails from both Russian (Minsk governorate) and Austrian (Galicia and Lodomeria) partitions, partially from Hungary too, and there's still deep sentiment for Habsburgs (more specifically, Franz Joseph, I even have his portrait hanging in my home) not only in my family, but many other "Galicians", with "good old" Emperor being namesake to restaurants, his portrait on the mineral water and his monuments and streets still existing in some towns (while all Tsarist and german Kaiserlich traces being all removed from "their parts" as early as 1917/18), so it might seem odd that I side with Tsar on this one. Still, I'm legalist. As much as Russian and Prussian rule was and is commonly viewed in ery bad light, objectively Nicholas and his successors were formally kings of Poland, and Austrian gratitude to Russia for 1848 was best shown in Crimean war...
Poland: *save's austria from the ottoman empire* Russia: *save's austria from hungarian rebels* Austria: *Im about do something called a “pro betrayal move”*
It's great you included the Slovaks. The Slovaks were fighting on Austrian side because they had been promised autonomy and after the victory they were betrayed by Kaiser. Most of the mappers and historians forgot even mentioning this.
Actually more Slovaks fight alongside Hungary. The Austrian government was autocracy and monarchy system. Hungarian rebel government was democratic. Austria support minorities in Hungary because at the time there was not minority rights is Hungary. Hungarian government gave rights to minorities to late as Austrians and Russians push their forces deeper to Hungary. Hungarian Revolution was in deed international. As it was one of most successful revolts of 1848. At the Hungarian side fight volunteers native in today Italy, Austria, Germany, England, Poland, Romania, Slovakia, Ukraine and many others who fight for freedom. At the end Austria give up their promises for autonomy to everyone. Only Hungarians gain autonomy under Austria installed government.
@@LegoRomania28 No minorities had basic rights in the world in the 15. or 19. century. Now it's the 21. century and Hungarians have less rights then Romanians in the 13. century. Hungary had the first mirority law in 1848 in the world... From 1568, yes, 1568 all religions were free to practise. By the way Romanians were only immigrants. Romanians, Slovakians and Sebians are very primitive people.
@@LegoRomania28 shut up commie... We are from asia its right... But we are as European as your gay ass is... Yes we have rights having transilvania cause we were the first real kingdom there... But you romanians always so agressive... Atleast you know its not mongolia... Could you atleast not see us as poops in your pants? We have the rights to live here cause we are in this region atleast as long ago as your country...
@@williamtang899 but romania wasn't fascist all time, he turned against fascism and fough for communism so basically commie is right to call him... But yeah fascist is good enough
It's not very good because if Russia didn't help Austria, Hungary would've won in the war and it would've been free. Therefore the Austro-Hungarian monarchy wouldn't exist and They wouldn't go to war with Serbia because they don't have land acces to them and WW1 wouldn't start in 1914.
Yes, but WW1 would never happen, which is a good thing. That also means WW2 would have never happened. WW2 was the result of the Treaty of Versailles. And if there was no WW1, there would be no Treaty of Versailles, which also means no WW2.
WW1 would happen anyways but 1-3 years later. The tension was rising in europe especially because of the balkans and the new weapons they wanted to test out. The question is who would've started and who would've won the war? One of the USA's reason to go against Germany was because of they were the "agressors". And without Hungary Austria was weaker and Hungary wasn't a supporter of Germany.
Do all of you really think that WW1 would not start? It was clear in 1914 that a war will break out and what should Hungary do after this Independence? They had a terrible economy and also Russia could attack Hungary later or Austria and what is then better?
Not only that but they had an elite core of Hussars and artillarely matching Austria's, In fact this was one of the VERY few times in history where a rebellion HAD aritlerry superriority. Hungary had close to 200k Soldiers before Russia entered the conflict, wastly outnumbering the Austrian armies that could be deployed. Entire Towns turned all their efforts into manufacturing weapons, Bells were melted for cannons and fresh recruits joined the army by the thousands, And Legions of foreign revolutionaries joined the cause. Austria would have been grinded against the Alps had Russia stayed out.
Well idk If i should be happy or sad that Hungary lost On one hand its good cuz Transylvania Isnt Hungary On the other hand it is bad cuz Transylvania Isnt Romania
@@kingdomoftransylvania5744 Romania should grant autonomy for Transylvania, and then they could do whatever they want. Join Hungary, be an independent State, whatever.
@Andrei LOL Transylvania is hungarian land, Szeklers live there. They CLAIM to be Hungarian, they're proud to be HUNGARIAN. Other than that, Romania's economy is a failure, GDP is low, you guys have the biggest corruption in Europe. Szeklers are oppressed, they got their rights cut down, get lower payments. This is not about brainwashing my friend, they just want to be apart of Hungary. Oh and yes, we did horrible things in WW2, but at least we remained loyal to our allies. Romania betrayed it's allied nations SIX times under SIXTY years. This is world record
Юлиан Гантман and don't mention ww1. basically all the idiot countries that fought hungary: romania, serbia, and Russia, got attacked by good old Austria hungary and started ww1. if hungary would have won there wouldn't have been ww1 or ww2.
The crimean war was a stupid war that Russia and Austria could never win so Austria was wise to stay out of it. They should have started with a Balkan war instead of going directly to Constantinople because they knew Britain and France wouldn't tolerate that.
Máté Ambrus Mate, you are originally Croat. Almost all of Hungarians are originally Croats, Serbs, Slovaks, Slovenes or Germans and just a little percent Ugrofines.
@@Zonie because of the holy Alliance they had to help or would break the Alliance. Also this alliance was *against* Revolutions so Russia had to help because of this.
Austrian Empire was not really that strong. They lost to Silesia to Prussia, when Prussia was still far from a powerhause. In fact they only survived the Turkish invasion, thanks to Polish help. Same thing with 30 years war, Swedish Army dominated Austrians on almost every battlefield. Austrians were just lucky, in most cases their allies did all the work for them. It was like that in the I World War too, Austria would be anihilated by Russia if not for Germany.
Well... Not really. This video contains two wars happened in the same time, when Italians say 'first independence war' they don't mean the Hungarian revolution, they just mean the Italian front
At least eighteen years later came the Compromise when Austria recognised Hungary as her equal and which was followed by peace, prosperity, cultural, scientifical and technological development for almost half a century.
And then Austria dragged Hungary into World War 1 and it was all for nothing. Hungary wasn't really an equal. In military and economy things Hungary didn't have a word....
The Hungarian Diet is the single largest reason the Austro-Hungarian Army was so bad in the war, they refused to fund the Common Army. Hungary could have refused to take part in the war and it wouldn't have happened.
@@Whatareyoudoinnhere We were under the Habsburgs and Ottomans, they controlled us during this period. What could we have done between two occupying powers?
Brate, svaka ti cast na ovome sto radis, a radis ga kvalitetno! I daj Boze da ima vise nasih sa ovakvim kanalima. Podrska i sto bi rekli, imas jos jedan 'sub'. :)
was that revolt caused because of the harsh habsburg rule upon the hungarians compared to the ottomans ( since it happened like 4 years after hungary was given to the austrians ) ???? and i don't want a religious answer please,i want the facts
I don't know, we hated both the Turkish and Habsburg rule. The Turks may have been much worse, many people died, that time destroyed the Hungarian economy and population for centuries. We just wanted to be independent from both of them.
,the vast majority of population didn't care who ruled them as long as they were fair,which the habsburgs weren't and the ottomans were,they gave them complete religious freedom and tolerance and lowered taxes,not to mention protection and an amazing administrative system,so maybe your right in the later stages of the empire but not it's golden age
The Turkish rule was a catastroph for Hungary, it ruined it maybe till this day, decreased the population, ruined economy. Like communism in East Germany. We had fought with the Turks for centuries bloody battles. Maybe you know the costum of ringing the bell at noon. It originated from a great battle in 1456 (Nándorfehérvár, now Belgrad), where Hungarians and other Europeans stopped them despite their great overpower. They still have a very different culture, imagine how it was then... And people paid taxes for 3-4 authorities.
@@panzerofthelake3437 You have to update your maps, heavily. You are still staring at the ones from 1250s, unfortunately. We are in 2022, press fast forward on your atlas
@@paulungureanu937 most of you guys in Transylvania are basically Hungarians but speaking a neo latin language, look at your name also, it gives away your ancestry.
I‘ve heard that in hungary you usually don’t clink glasses because some austrian officers did that every time they executed an hungarian revolutionary should I feel bad as an austrian clinking glasses all the time?
Föl-föl vitézek a csatára, A Szent Szabadság oltalmára! Édes hazánkért hősi vérünk, Ontjuk hullajtjuk nagy bátran míg élünk! ENG: Rise-rise soldiers to the battle, For the protection of Holy Freedom! We give our heroic blood to our sweet Homeland, Which we shed with great courage until our death! /Klapka March from 1849
1848 march 15 was a very big event. But unfortunately the Hungarians lost the battle. Since then every year all the children in the school wear special uniform and a badge called kokarda. It is a governmental holiday. It help me remember that if I wish to fight for independence it will take a long time. And I will have to fall but I can't loose hope to achieve it. It is the spiritual independence we are fighting for. And for the restoration of our lost home country . We 💕You
Лол, а почему они должны были вас поддержать в Крымской войне? Это была исключительно ваша война из-за ваших амбиций и характера задиры по отношению к Турции.
Maci You know that Bohemia kicked Hungarian ass everytime we fought right? And that Austrians controlled Hungary 100 years longer than Bohemia right since 1526? Size doesn't matter as most of Hungary was empty fields with no industry at all, meanwhile Bohemia was the industrial hearthland of the Austrian empire. Prague was a capital of the Habsburgs for 100 years meanwhile Hungary's most important asset was shit shoveling serfs. 30 years war plundered and ruined Bohemia and killed 50% of population so it was possible for the Austrians to hold on to power. Look up Hussite wars to see how we treat Austrians and Hungarians when we're at full strenght.
Maci We have been fighting Germans for 1200 years, look up all the battles from 800-1100 and 1400-1620. It was always Hungary that allied with Austrians to fight us like in 13th century. It is said in Czech lands that the conflict with Germans is basically the foundation of Czech nationality. What Bohemian lands were under Hungarian control? Since basically the 9th century, Bohemian (Czech) borders remain virtually the same.
@@booperdooperproductions2545 Nobody gives a flying toss about a Texan's cheap subjective and biased opinion about medieval matters, way before the Republic of Texas barely dared to walk the Earth. What matters are the treaties signed and enforced nowadays between the governments of Romania and US. Both nations were Allies in World War One, some nations won that war (Romania & the US, amongst them), others lost it (your friends from Hungary and Russia). Sad, so so sad, but nobody cares anyway Romania won that war, fact. Transylvania is Romania, fact. Get over it, however emotionally difficult might be for you, fact. I prefer to live in the present and build a strong partnership between US & Romania in the 21st century. It is rather daft trying to debate on or 'fix' issues that pertain the distant past.
toaritok What makes you say that? I doubt there would've been a civil war within Hungary with Russia and Romania interfering. Hungary wasn't the Ottoman Empire that was capable of collapsing at any moment.
Hungarians didn't wanted to join to the WWI, but when it was forced together with Austria, named as Austria-Hungary, Hungarian opinions didn't matter to the emperor.
Martin Madarász I love the "what if..." questions.They don't solve anything or don't explain anything neither.Ww1 would happened either way.Don't you think you "75-80%" is a liiiiiitle bit too much?
Hungary has had some many revolutions that you need to specify which one it is using the date. Kinda like how there has been tons of treaties of Paris so the year needs to be specified.
Péter Kovács Not really it would have just taken longer to capitulate Hungary and Austria would probably collapse earlier into World War One because they nearly recovered from this and if the war went on longer it would have been worse so that would have caused Austria to collapse in 1916 or 1917 and this would have caused checzoslovakia to be created because the chezoslovak legion would have still been in Siberia or on the eastern front so Hungary would be bigger and thus retain control of Slovakia Transylvania and Voidvdina and Austria would keep Control over Slovenia so that means Yougoslavia might or might not exist.
Of course Jelačić and Croatians had big part in all that! The matter is that we looked to ourselves then as allies and friends and now as foes. But then different situation and different time it was then.
@@boiwhatdahellboi9180 first of all, this battle was not lost, but more so it was a draw. Second of all, you are refering to a Wikipedia page written by a hungarian, who's sources are hungarian books written by hungarians.
@@marcoadmiralis_1497 Fuck all old minded stupid people in all over the world like you :) We have people as stupid as you in Turkey and fuck them too. Or maybe you should fuck each other and the other normal people can live in a better world MORON.
@Alex C Romanians pushed to Budapest hungary pushed to chechoslovakia and France wanted treaty what means hungary need to get ouf of chechoslovakia and they thought that Romania Will withdraw their army too but they didn't
The hipocrisy of Hungary was that it wanted independece for itself yet denied the same to Croats and Slovaks for an example. I'm not a fam of Habsburgs but it was a good thing they've won.
The Habsburgs were hyprocrites too They promised more autonomy for Slovaks, Romanians and Serbs if they fought against us, Hungarians, then backtracked on it after the revolution, and didn’t bother to give them any special rights once Austria-Hungary was established. They also didn’t bother to help Russia in the Crimean War, despite them saving their empire in this war of independence. I would say they were jerks as well.
@@PeterPeter-pr2hiis is true, had Austria followed a federal model as suggested by the Romanians, it wouldn't have collapsed. There could have been a Romania past the Carpathians east and a Romania within the broader federal Austria, comprising the Dutchy of Bukovina and the Principality of Transylvania, maybe as far as Partium (Banat, Crișana, Maramureș). Romanians had been robbed of rights, Hungary knew this and it was quite convenient, but as a result only those which let go of their faith or were sent as border guards gained their "privileges". You have to aknowledge that Stephan Ludwig Roth and the Transylvanian demands were quite reasonable. Supplex Libellus Valachorum and the later memorandum were laughed and scoffed at.
@sticlavoda5632 The problem with the Hungarian part of Austria-Hungary was that the ruling party featured mainly nobles who were pretty backwards, and didn’t exactly know how to run a modern state. This was a problem with the Austrian part too, but less so, as they treated the minorities with more autonomy compared to Hungary. I will acknowledge as a Hungarian that we rather undeservingly stripped the rights of many minorities and treated Hungarians more favourably, which is rather unfair if you consider that many fought with us in this war of independence in order to establish an independent state, and when that was kinda achieved in 1867, we turned our backs on them. However, you will have to acknowledge that -my nationality aside- the empire didn’t treat its minorities nearly as badly as most other empires did in this era. The Ottomans massacred and genocided Armenians, the Russians heavily oppressed all their minorities (the Circassian genocide was also going on), and the French and the British often treated their colonies extremely horribly, with the French suppressing any revolution against them very heavily, and the British putting the Boers in concentration camps. King Leopold of Belgium was also responsible for 15 million deaths in the Congo Free State. Austria-Hungary, in comparison, was just rather backwards and didn’t give as many rights to their minorities as they wanted to. However, there was still social mobility, a lot of individual rights (just not too many collective ones), and they weren’t technically treated as second-class citizens, just sadly happened a lot in practice. Not exactly glorifying the empire’s past, but I have a feeling that we would have eventually reformed if WW1 didn’t come along.
In some way they did, Poles supported Hungarians in this war, Józef Bem is considered a national hero in Hungary and he was on of the leaders of the uprising.
We must mention the romanian leader Avram Iancu, who participated and helped the austrians to stop the hungarian revolutionaries who were trying to steal transylvania!
It's a partly false map. First of all it does not show that by the middle of 1949 the whole Hungary was liberated from the enemies' occupation. Hungary defeated the Habsburg Empire and its allies. That was the reason why Austria had to ask for help from the Russian tsar. Secondly the Hungarians weren't rebels, we were freedom fighters. Or were the Serbs "rebels" during the WW2 when they fought against the Germans? Because the Hungarians were fighting against the Germans - as we called the Hasburgs. Thirdly the Hungarian revolution and freedom fight of 1848-1849 was not only "one of the revolutions" of that time. Because the other revolutions in fact were nothing compared to the Hungarian revolution. We were influenced by the other European revolutions, but the Hungarian revolution lasted 10 times more. All the other nations gave up, only Hungary persisted until we defeated the Austrian Empire. So the Hungarian revolution was not only one of the revolutions. It was the only glorious and victorious revolution of Europe in 1848-1849. Fourth: The Hungarian revolution was victorious even if it was ended (but not defeated for ever) by the Russian army. Because the Russians left Hungary in a few months, and Austria remained alone with Hungary again. So by 1867 Austria had to accept all the objectives of the Hungarian Revolution. That was the Austrian-Hungarian arrangement, what finally created the Austro-Hungarian Monarchy. Without the Hungarian victory of 1848-1849, never would have been conclude the deal of 1867 between the Habsburgs and Hungary.
Jelacic was a traitor, betrayed Croatia and stood for Habsburgs. It was also called Jelasic's the myrmidon ban. He suffered a complete defeat in the Battle of Pázozd.
@@kiszeg Says the Hungarian. First of all you betrayed Croatia and you abolished the Pacta Conventa, annexing Croatia as Hungarian province. Second of all Ban Jelacic wasnt in favour of Austria but he fought for his country and stood up against Hungarians
![Yugoslav wars [1991-1999]](/img/n.gif)
"Two the most stupid kings of Poland in history? John III Sobieski and me myself. We both have foolishly saved Habsburgs from total catastrophe..." Tsar Nicholas I of Russia
Smok I wouldn't są that tsar Nicholas was a king of Poland. We don't accept him. ;)
yoda 222 Accept him or not, he ruled Poland
Comrade Ivan Ivanov Ivanovich Maybe he was a king of something similar to Poland but he wasn't king of the polish people. Probably that's why they overthrowed him ;)
+yoda 222, you have a very intrusive habit of speaking for all of Poles, as if Poles have one opinion for all.
You can not know how the Poles of that time thought. The presence of the rebels only spoke of the presence of dissatisfied, nothing more.
My own family in long term hails from both Russian (Minsk governorate) and Austrian (Galicia and Lodomeria) partitions, partially from Hungary too, and there's still deep sentiment for Habsburgs (more specifically, Franz Joseph, I even have his portrait hanging in my home) not only in my family, but many other "Galicians", with "good old" Emperor being namesake to restaurants, his portrait on the mineral water and his monuments and streets still existing in some towns (while all Tsarist and german Kaiserlich traces being all removed from "their parts" as early as 1917/18), so it might seem odd that I side with Tsar on this one.
Still, I'm legalist. As much as Russian and Prussian rule was and is commonly viewed in ery bad light, objectively Nicholas and his successors were formally kings of Poland, and Austrian gratitude to Russia for 1848 was best shown in Crimean war...
Poland: *save's austria from the ottoman empire*
Russia: *save's austria from hungarian rebels*
Austria: *Im about do something called a “pro betrayal move”*
Why the fuck does everyone in this comment section speak English so awfully
@@user-fv1lc2qm3e because were not from a english country
@@Eplpsyy I'm not either
ConnorRDM well everyone’s english isn’t the same Some are good and some are awful
ً why the fuck are you being so salty
Only kids from 1848 remember this
It's great you included the Slovaks. The Slovaks were fighting on Austrian side because they had been promised autonomy and after the victory they were betrayed by Kaiser. Most of the mappers and historians forgot even mentioning this.
Actually more Slovaks fight alongside Hungary. The Austrian government was autocracy and monarchy system. Hungarian rebel government was democratic. Austria support minorities in Hungary because at the time there was not minority rights is Hungary. Hungarian government gave rights to minorities to late as Austrians and Russians push their forces deeper to Hungary. Hungarian Revolution was in deed international. As it was one of most successful revolts of 1848. At the Hungarian side fight volunteers native in today Italy, Austria, Germany, England, Poland, Romania, Slovakia, Ukraine and many others who fight for freedom. At the end Austria give up their promises for autonomy to everyone. Only Hungarians gain autonomy under Austria installed government.
@@LegoRomania28 No minorities had basic rights in the world in the 15. or 19. century. Now it's the 21. century and Hungarians have less rights then Romanians in the 13. century. Hungary had the first mirority law in 1848 in the world... From 1568, yes, 1568 all religions were free to practise. By the way Romanians were only immigrants. Romanians, Slovakians and Sebians are very primitive people.
@@LegoRomania28 shut up commie... We are from asia its right... But we are as European as your gay ass is... Yes we have rights having transilvania cause we were the first real kingdom there... But you romanians always so agressive... Atleast you know its not mongolia... Could you atleast not see us as poops in your pants? We have the rights to live here cause we are in this region atleast as long ago as your country...
@@paytay You are clearly dealing with a Romanian fascist, not a Romanian communist.
@@williamtang899 but romania wasn't fascist all time, he turned against fascism and fough for communism so basically commie is right to call him... But yeah fascist is good enough
0:45
>tfw your rebels get rebels
Dani ivan actually
The romanians who were majority in Transilvania, side with the emperor and that mogyors
Name 1997 wasn’t the majority in that time foul.
Alien it was LMAOOO
Alien not in the land of the szekelys but in the rest they were the majority
Name 1997 not really. Hungarians put out the absolute population by 58%. And lol, wikipedia, with false informations😂😂😂😂
Russia made a big mistake cuz they help to Austria....
It's not very good because if Russia didn't help Austria, Hungary would've won in the war and it would've been free. Therefore the Austro-Hungarian monarchy wouldn't exist and They wouldn't go to war with Serbia because they don't have land acces to them and WW1 wouldn't start in 1914.
Yes, but WW1 would never happen, which is a good thing. That also means WW2 would have never happened. WW2 was the result of the Treaty of Versailles. And if there was no WW1, there would be no Treaty of Versailles, which also means no WW2.
WW1 would happen anyways but 1-3 years later. The tension was rising in europe especially because of the balkans and the new weapons they wanted to test out. The question is who would've started and who would've won the war? One of the USA's reason to go against Germany was because of they were the "agressors". And without Hungary Austria was weaker and Hungary wasn't a supporter of Germany.
You guys imply Russians had some kind of magical precog so they could know what would happen later on? lmao
Do all of you really think that WW1 would not start? It was clear in 1914 that a war will break out and what should Hungary do after this Independence? They had a terrible economy and also Russia could attack Hungary later or Austria and what is then better?
Hungary could win if russia doesn't even helped austria because Hungary had more troops then austria
Not only that but they had an elite core of Hussars and artillarely matching Austria's, In fact this was one of the VERY few times in history where a rebellion HAD aritlerry superriority.
Hungary had close to 200k Soldiers before Russia entered the conflict, wastly outnumbering the Austrian armies that could be deployed. Entire Towns turned all their efforts into manufacturing weapons, Bells were melted for cannons and fresh recruits joined the army by the thousands, And Legions of foreign revolutionaries joined the cause. Austria would have been grinded against the Alps had Russia stayed out.
Well idk If i should be happy or sad that Hungary lost
On one hand its good cuz Transylvania Isnt Hungary
On the other hand it is bad cuz Transylvania Isnt Romania
@@kingdomoftransylvania5744 Romania should grant autonomy for Transylvania, and then they could do whatever they want. Join Hungary, be an independent State, whatever.
@Andrei :) Believe me, they don't want to be apart of Romania.
@Andrei LOL Transylvania is hungarian land, Szeklers live there. They CLAIM to be Hungarian, they're proud to be HUNGARIAN. Other than that, Romania's economy is a failure, GDP is low, you guys have the biggest corruption in Europe. Szeklers are oppressed, they got their rights cut down, get lower payments. This is not about brainwashing my friend, they just want to be apart of Hungary.
Oh and yes, we did horrible things in WW2, but at least we remained loyal to our allies. Romania betrayed it's allied nations SIX times under SIXTY years. This is world record
And then Austria betrayed Russia in Crimean War. Douches of the century.
Nikolas said: "There are two slavic fools: Jan Sobeski and me."
Why Jan Sobeski? xD
G0TIMAN Battle of Vienna 1683
Юлиан Гантман and don't mention ww1. basically all the idiot countries that fought hungary: romania, serbia, and Russia, got attacked by good old Austria hungary and started ww1. if hungary would have won there wouldn't have been ww1 or ww2.
The crimean war was a stupid war that Russia and Austria could never win so Austria was wise to stay out of it. They should have started with a Balkan war instead of going directly to Constantinople because they knew Britain and France wouldn't tolerate that.
Wow!The Hungarian revolution was so strong that even Austrian Empire was close to collapse!Respect and Greetings from Bulgaria!
Преслав Маринов Thanks. If it weren't for Russia, we could have won.
Máté Ambrus Mate, you are originally Croat. Almost all of Hungarians are originally Croats, Serbs, Slovaks, Slovenes or Germans and just a little percent Ugrofines.
No, Hungarians are Magyars who are from Turanid family like Turks. You can't call Turks as Greeks or Magyars as some Slavs.
@@Zonie because of the holy Alliance they had to help or would break the Alliance. Also this alliance was *against* Revolutions so Russia had to help because of this.
Austrian Empire was not really that strong. They lost to Silesia to Prussia, when Prussia was still far from a powerhause. In fact they only survived the Turkish invasion, thanks to Polish help. Same thing with 30 years war, Swedish Army dominated Austrians on almost every battlefield. Austrians were just lucky, in most cases their allies did all the work for them. It was like that in the I World War too, Austria would be anihilated by Russia if not for Germany.
Wow, nice video. For Hungarian is a revolution and for Italian is First Indipendence War
Well... Not really. This video contains two wars happened in the same time, when Italians say 'first independence war' they don't mean the Hungarian revolution, they just mean the Italian front
Ehm... yes I know it, thank you anyway ^^
You in everywhere we know you are italian.
These were the two greatest wars in 1848/49. Maybe the Hungarian one was the greatest and last.
No! Hungarian is a facke nation!
)
At least eighteen years later came the Compromise when Austria recognised Hungary as her equal and which was followed by peace, prosperity, cultural, scientifical and technological development for almost half a century.
And then Austria dragged Hungary into World War 1 and it was all for nothing. Hungary wasn't really an equal. In military and economy things Hungary didn't have a word....
Neko_ValentinE_Butterfly It actually had. Hungary had just as big of word as Austria.
The Hungarian Diet is the single largest reason the Austro-Hungarian Army was so bad in the war, they refused to fund the Common Army. Hungary could have refused to take part in the war and it wouldn't have happened.
65 to 35% its not really equality, but it is much better than just being a subject.
Tisza himself was hugely against modernization of the army because he believed it would restrict Hungary's equality with Austria.
I love hungary from poland
Łukasz Kwapisz Polak, Wegier dwa bratanki!
Góbi K. Pig Strong 9323 can i ask you ..where comes this sentiment? ok you had kingdoms..maybe same kings as rulers..and?
Boris Práznovský We lived in peace for 1000 years together.
What about Bem József?
Or Teleki?
Góbi K. Pig Strong 9323 i. dont know this names
Boris Práznovský Wikipedia is your friend.
Jozef Bem
Pál Teleki
Loving your videos, please keep them coming :D
Big love to Hungary from Bulgaria!
Bulgaria is one of our best friends :)
Lots of love to you all from Hungary aswell! Wish you all happiness, health and wealth!
TREASON !!!
That's a very awesome video! Good job and thank you!
soo all i learned from these kind of hungary vs xy videos that when hungary wants to face someone theey need to face 545436465 fronts or what ?
Yeah thats basically our entire history :D
@@kristofmagyaros2410 yikes
@@Whatareyoudoinnhere We were under the Habsburgs and Ottomans, they controlled us during this period. What could we have done between two occupying powers?
Brate, svaka ti cast na ovome sto radis, a radis ga kvalitetno! I daj Boze da ima vise nasih sa ovakvim kanalima. Podrska i sto bi rekli, imas jos jedan 'sub'. :)
Pitty that Austria did not give a half autonomy to Serbs, Croats, Slovaks, Italians and Romanians in Transylvánia after the war.
They are Austrians ffs.
They never keep their promises.
As A Hungarian and a C&C Generals fan (in that order) I loved this video.
You're a legend
Great video :)
you are a pro mapper.
1 idea : Hungarian revolution 1703-1711 (II. Rakóczi)
That happened during the War of Spanish Succession, so it can included in a video of the entire war.
was that revolt caused because of the harsh habsburg rule upon the hungarians compared to the ottomans ( since it happened like 4 years after hungary was given to the austrians ) ???? and i don't want a religious answer please,i want the facts
I don't know, we hated both the Turkish and Habsburg rule. The Turks may have been much worse, many people died, that time destroyed the Hungarian economy and population for centuries. We just wanted to be independent from both of them.
,the vast majority of population didn't care who ruled them as long as they were fair,which the habsburgs weren't and the ottomans were,they gave them complete religious freedom and tolerance and lowered taxes,not to mention protection and an amazing administrative system,so maybe your right in the later stages of the empire but not it's golden age
The Turkish rule was a catastroph for Hungary, it ruined it maybe till this day, decreased the population, ruined economy. Like communism in East Germany. We had fought with the Turks for centuries bloody battles. Maybe you know the costum of ringing the bell at noon. It originated from a great battle in 1456 (Nándorfehérvár, now Belgrad), where Hungarians and other Europeans stopped them despite their great overpower. They still have a very different culture, imagine how it was then... And people paid taxes for 3-4 authorities.
In the anniversary of Hungarian Revolution I wish you the very best, Magyars! Be proud of your history and heritage. Love form Poland!
Transylvania is Romanian, get stuffed.
@@paulungureanu937 Romania is Hungary, get rekt
@@panzerofthelake3437 You have to update your maps, heavily. You are still staring at the ones from 1250s, unfortunately. We are in 2022, press fast forward on your atlas
@@paulungureanu937 you still seem to be scamming tourists and beating the heck out of other people. Get rekt.
@@paulungureanu937 most of you guys in Transylvania are basically Hungarians but speaking a neo latin language, look at your name also, it gives away your ancestry.
I‘ve heard that in hungary you usually don’t clink glasses because some austrian officers did that every time they executed an hungarian revolutionary
should I feel bad as an austrian clinking glasses all the time?
What no. Thats the stupidest thing ever, everyone clinks glasses
I'm Hungaian but I never heard this
@David Szakacs But I live in Hungary-
@David Szakacs yeah I never heard about it...
@@TRWFacty elvileg csak sörrel nem illik koccintani
Great Video!
the soundtracks you use are so metal and fitting
That's the battle theme 5 for China in command and conquer generals
@@hemalkarini2649 and i wonder why he put chinese theme in european war?
Föl-föl vitézek a csatára,
A Szent Szabadság oltalmára!
Édes hazánkért hősi vérünk,
Ontjuk hullajtjuk nagy bátran míg élünk!
ENG:
Rise-rise soldiers to the battle,
For the protection of Holy Freedom!
We give our heroic blood to our sweet Homeland,
Which we shed with great courage until our death!
/Klapka March from 1849
Thank you!
Love that music from C&C: Generals. c:
1848 march 15 was a very big event. But unfortunately the Hungarians lost the battle. Since then every year all the children in the school wear special uniform and a badge called kokarda. It is a governmental holiday. It help me remember that if I wish to fight for independence it will take a long time. And I will have to fall but I can't loose hope to achieve it. It is the spiritual independence we are fighting for. And for the restoration of our lost home country . We 💕You
Interestingly enough, in italian we call them "Coccarda"
@@IlGab02 it is kokarde in german, coquarde in french, kokarda in serbian.
Nothing interesthing about since the word derives from latin.
А потом же эта Австрия предала нас, не поддержав в Крымской войне. Но серия отличная!
Лол, а почему они должны были вас поддержать в Крымской войне? Это была исключительно ваша война из-за ваших амбиций и характера задиры по отношению к Турции.
@@Nick_Avarageлол потому что австрии бы не существовало, если не помощь РИ. Они обязаны были поддержать россиян в Крымской войне
@@Livinginalazyworld Почему это "обязана"? Это была их страна и они могли делать, что хотели.
@@Nick_Avarage тебе знакомо слово взаимпомощь?
@@Livinginalazyworld Да. Но, если Австрия не хотела или не могла - то, в чем их винить?
kösziiii!! :D Thanks :D From hungary :)
You are living in a legend.
Just out of curiosity, what are your sources for the map movements?
In this time, Austria was larger than Germany. xD
Hungary wasn't Austria, Hungary was only occupied by the Habsburgs, that's all I think.
lol czechs were the habsburg bootlickers for how long ? hungary was a huge a kingdom meanwhile bohemia just a tiny bit of austria
Maci You know that Bohemia kicked Hungarian ass everytime we fought right? And that Austrians controlled Hungary 100 years longer than Bohemia right since 1526? Size doesn't matter as most of Hungary was empty fields with no industry at all, meanwhile Bohemia was the industrial hearthland of the Austrian empire. Prague was a capital of the Habsburgs for 100 years meanwhile Hungary's most important asset was shit shoveling serfs. 30 years war plundered and ruined Bohemia and killed 50% of population so it was possible for the Austrians to hold on to power. Look up Hussite wars to see how we treat Austrians and Hungarians when we're at full strenght.
even before austria bohemia had good relations with germans and no lot of your lands were under hungarian control the rest is just lol wtf
Maci We have been fighting Germans for 1200 years, look up all the battles from 800-1100 and 1400-1620. It was always Hungary that allied with Austrians to fight us like in 13th century. It is said in Czech lands that the conflict with Germans is basically the foundation of Czech nationality. What Bohemian lands were under Hungarian control? Since basically the 9th century, Bohemian (Czech) borders remain virtually the same.
respect from Texas to Hungary
your greatest ally in the region is Romania though, be more careful with your ''sympathies''.
@@paulungureanu937 What?
@@booperdooperproductions2545 greatest US allies in Eastern Europe are Romania & Poland. Fact
These two nations being very pro-American, too.
@@paulungureanu937 ok and? the current geopolitical situation has no bearing on my opinion regarding an event centuries earlier
@@booperdooperproductions2545 Nobody gives a flying toss about a Texan's cheap subjective and biased opinion about medieval matters, way before the Republic of Texas barely dared to walk the Earth.
What matters are the treaties signed and enforced nowadays between the governments of Romania and US.
Both nations were Allies in World War One, some nations won that war (Romania & the US, amongst them), others lost it (your friends from Hungary and Russia). Sad, so so sad, but nobody cares anyway
Romania won that war, fact.
Transylvania is Romania, fact.
Get over it, however emotionally difficult might be for you, fact.
I prefer to live in the present and build a strong partnership between US & Romania in the 21st century. It is rather daft trying to debate on or 'fix' issues that pertain the distant past.
Super!
This came up on autoplay, listening at work and I thought I was in china.
Had the Hungarian Revolution succeeded then Hungary wouldn't have lost any of the territory it had before WWI.
Kirby5413 there wouldn't have been ww1
toaritok What makes you say that? I doubt there would've been a civil war within Hungary with Russia and Romania interfering. Hungary wasn't the Ottoman Empire that was capable of collapsing at any moment.
Hungarians didn't wanted to join to the WWI, but when it was forced together with Austria, named as Austria-Hungary, Hungarian opinions didn't matter to the emperor.
Erias Ffs idiot all of the parties wanted war...(even the pacifist socialdemocrats)
Martin Madarász I love the "what if..." questions.They don't solve anything or don't explain anything neither.Ww1 would happened either way.Don't you think you "75-80%" is a liiiiiitle bit too much?
Finally someone made it! Like!
MrRussianMapper Thx for defeated us! Austria would be not able to do it by himself...
I mean, finally someone made a video on Hungarian war of independence...
I knooooooow what you meaaan!
._. He wasn't even born in that time. How could he "defeat" us? xD
MrRussianMapper finally Russia helped somebody.
feedback: you could mark big/important cities
Hungary has had some many revolutions that you need to specify which one it is using the date.
Kinda like how there has been tons of treaties of Paris so the year needs to be specified.
(This is alternate) Russia not join the war = Hungarian Victory!
ironically is that Austrian united all other nations of A-H empire against Hungarians.
Which is easy, when you make lots of promises you´ll never keep.
In real Croatian and Russian forces denstroid Budim
Péter Kovács
Not really it would have just taken longer to capitulate Hungary and Austria would probably collapse earlier into World War One because they nearly recovered from this and if the war went on longer it would have been worse so that would have caused Austria to collapse in 1916 or 1917 and this would have caused checzoslovakia to be created because the chezoslovak legion would have still been in Siberia or on the eastern front so Hungary would be bigger and thus retain control of Slovakia Transylvania and Voidvdina and Austria would keep Control over Slovenia so that means Yougoslavia might or might not exist.
Yeah thats the true
It's a shame that our government supported Austria back then. Support Hungary as a Russian.
Odlicno brate
Well done!
Bojlert cserélnék bontott téglára.
Ádám Jánossy érdekel!
Lmao is that music from command and conquer generals in the background??? One of my favourite games...
love the c&c generals music
When a Serb nationalist mentions Serbian minority, Slovaks and Romanians. But no word of Croats (Ban Jelačić) and Czechs LOL
Of course Jelačić and Croatians had big part in all that! The matter is that we looked to ourselves then as allies and friends and now as foes. But then different situation and different time it was then.
The peasents rekted Jelačič's army
@@boiwhatdahellboi9180 yeah like when the Croatian army entered and liberated Buda and Pest ;) Hungarians lost the war deal with it ;)
@@comes.de.poglizza did you heard the battle of pákozd?
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Pákozd
@@boiwhatdahellboi9180 first of all, this battle was not lost, but more so it was a draw.
Second of all, you are refering to a Wikipedia page written by a hungarian, who's sources are hungarian books written by hungarians.
Friendly Poles, triggered balkans and romanians in the comment section, enter with care. ;)
mostly rumuns and srbs
No one likes romanians (dont care if written wrong)
@@Potato79207 the question is who likes u horty 🤣
@@Potato79207 ask our latin brothers from France about Hungary.... its the best if u want em to be frustrated.....
@@Potato79207 at least they don't lose 2 world wars+ lose small ones
Greetings from Austria!
Wait a second
The city of Venice itself was never taken until 1849, so why that June/Nov 1848 phase where it looks like they got them?
Greetings to Magyarország from Turkey!
fck turkey from hungary :)
@@marcoadmiralis_1497 Yeah thats how hungarians respect to other Peoples. :)
Good job on being such a moron.
marcoadmiralis _ So thats the people why love Romania more than Hungary
@@marcoadmiralis_1497 Fuck all old minded stupid people in all over the world like you :) We have people as stupid as you in Turkey and fuck them too. Or maybe you should fuck each other and the other normal people can live in a better world MORON.
Hungary and Türkiye 💪🇭🇺💪🇹🇷💪
🇭🇺🤝🇹🇷
1:13
Hungary: oh no
good video
Nice!
love austria from pressburg,slovakia
Problem in Central Europe? Call Russia :DD
Tako se to radi! Sjajno odrađeno, momci! :D
Was it another "revolution" sponsored by London City like polish November Uprising 1830-31 and January Uprising 1863-64?
can u make Italian war of independence
Sujedu Srbine odlican video! 👊😁
I love it how Russia comes in destroys Hungary then leaves
Russia come 3 times to destroy Hungary. 1849, 1945, 1956.
1945 and 1956 there was no Russia, it was the Soviet Union, big difference
@@mitak_g3 still majority was russia
Ww3 we (Europa) will win and Not russia
@@mitak_g3 no difference xD In Soviet Union Russia was the only useful country the others were nothing (in these days still not much tho)
Anyone remember that song in Generals? Generals Zero Hour anyone?
Respect fromTurkei
Does Hungary usually celebrate wars they lost?
they are not serbs lol
No, only commemorating the tragic ends.
Albania can't celebrate anything , as they never won .
What do Serbs or Albanians have to do with this
I am a Lion t's just jokes.
0:50:When a Romanian starts talking about how they beated the Hungarians after WW1 show them this clip:Army vs Army and Hungary won.
It was rebels vs army.....
But yes im romanian and i dont like when we start braging about 1919
@@cristiwn4466 ME Not too why cant we be friends
@Alex C Romanians pushed to Budapest hungary pushed to chechoslovakia and France wanted treaty what means hungary need to get ouf of chechoslovakia and they thought that Romania Will withdraw their army too but they didn't
nice video.... buuuuuuuttt it just seems at this point you just completely forgot about ur awesome looked really fun to watch afoe u had going
sorry I mean alternate History, please please finish that series
In this map the Kingdom of Sardinia is too large: you have "annexed" the Duchy of Parma to it
They executed the hungarian government one by one. The french and british told them not to do, but they did it without concequences.
Hungary strong
It was it really was
That's is age of emperors...
You never now who's friends and who's the enemy.....
But still the war the beautiful place to men
Excuse me, but when the last time I was in Hungarye, it did not look so Chinese
(except of the Chinese Restaurants there)
Yeah there is no mention of Ban Josip Jelacic and Croatians side with Emperor. After that Emperor gives Croatia a autonomy.
And the peasents defeated Jelacic's army
What about Croats
command and conquer: generals soundtrack, omg dude,i miss the old good days :(
ME too stupid EA making everything Bad
Bro doesn’t know💀
Nice
can you pls do the greek war of independence
yesss
do it
do it plssss
The hipocrisy of Hungary was that it wanted independece for itself yet denied the same to Croats and Slovaks for an example. I'm not a fam of Habsburgs but it was a good thing they've won.
The Habsburgs were hyprocrites too
They promised more autonomy for Slovaks, Romanians and Serbs if they fought against us, Hungarians, then backtracked on it after the revolution, and didn’t bother to give them any special rights once Austria-Hungary was established. They also didn’t bother to help Russia in the Crimean War, despite them saving their empire in this war of independence.
I would say they were jerks as well.
@@PeterPeter-pr2hiis is true, had Austria followed a federal model as suggested by the Romanians, it wouldn't have collapsed. There could have been a Romania past the Carpathians east and a Romania within the broader federal Austria, comprising the Dutchy of Bukovina and the Principality of Transylvania, maybe as far as Partium (Banat, Crișana, Maramureș). Romanians had been robbed of rights, Hungary knew this and it was quite convenient, but as a result only those which let go of their faith or were sent as border guards gained their "privileges". You have to aknowledge that Stephan Ludwig Roth and the Transylvanian demands were quite reasonable. Supplex Libellus Valachorum and the later memorandum were laughed and scoffed at.
@sticlavoda5632 The problem with the Hungarian part of Austria-Hungary was that the ruling party featured mainly nobles who were pretty backwards, and didn’t exactly know how to run a modern state. This was a problem with the Austrian part too, but less so, as they treated the minorities with more autonomy compared to Hungary. I will acknowledge as a Hungarian that we rather undeservingly stripped the rights of many minorities and treated Hungarians more favourably, which is rather unfair if you consider that many fought with us in this war of independence in order to establish an independent state, and when that was kinda achieved in 1867, we turned our backs on them.
However, you will have to acknowledge that -my nationality aside- the empire didn’t treat its minorities nearly as badly as most other empires did in this era. The Ottomans massacred and genocided Armenians, the Russians heavily oppressed all their minorities (the Circassian genocide was also going on), and the French and the British often treated their colonies extremely horribly, with the French suppressing any revolution against them very heavily, and the British putting the Boers in concentration camps. King Leopold of Belgium was also responsible for 15 million deaths in the Congo Free State. Austria-Hungary, in comparison, was just rather backwards and didn’t give as many rights to their minorities as they wanted to. However, there was still social mobility, a lot of individual rights (just not too many collective ones), and they weren’t technically treated as second-class citizens, just sadly happened a lot in practice. Not exactly glorifying the empire’s past, but I have a feeling that we would have eventually reformed if WW1 didn’t come along.
nice Battle Realms Musik !
Its actually from the command and conquer generals from the Chinese faction.
Nice map, but the music is clearly more suitable for a map about some China civial wars.
Then the winged hussars arri- Oh wait wrong war
In some way they did, Poles supported Hungarians in this war, Józef Bem is considered a national hero in Hungary and he was on of the leaders of the uprising.
Copy pasted from Wikipedia!
What is the app for do this maps?
Hungary: we want independence
Austria: well yes, but actually no.
1867
Bence Pálóczi Poland Hungary brothers
As usual Austria not being able to finish the job by themselves.
@@practioneroflain1175 they did after the war
At least they are not as bad as the ottomans
Late May 1849
Holy Alliance:
Ah shit, here we go again
So what happened with Sardinia?
Helping Austrians was one of the biggest mistakes of my motherland.
My (Polish) too
Одличан видео!!!
Халва
What is the mus called
Solidarity from Turkey for Hungary
Why would you add a China soundtrack to a video like this one?
vojvodina💪🏻🇷🇸💪🏻
it's called Délvidék
@@timeanagy8495 Српско Војводство
You made a mistake it‘s actually Délvidék 💪🏻🇭🇺💪🏻
@@thedarkness3766 Serbian Vojvodstvo and tamiški banat💪🏻🇷🇸💪🏻
@@thedarkness3766 Serbian dukedom
We must mention the romanian leader Avram Iancu, who participated and helped the austrians to stop the hungarian revolutionaries who were trying to steal transylvania!
Hunfootball Ha. Haha. HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH! LOL!
Ferdinand I chill nigga 😂 actually if these revolutions didn't happen back transvania woul still belong to hungary
hungaryans are more european than land of gypsyes named Romania
Steal Transylvania from what? We aren't romanians.
Hunfootball U mad bro?
Music?
15 march 1948 to 13 August 1849 ?
It's a partly false map. First of all it does not show that by the middle of 1949 the whole Hungary was liberated from the enemies' occupation. Hungary defeated the Habsburg Empire and its allies. That was the reason why Austria had to ask for help from the Russian tsar.
Secondly the Hungarians weren't rebels, we were freedom fighters. Or were the Serbs "rebels" during the WW2 when they fought against the Germans? Because the Hungarians were fighting against the Germans - as we called the Hasburgs.
Thirdly the Hungarian revolution and freedom fight of 1848-1849 was not only "one of the revolutions" of that time. Because the other revolutions in fact were nothing compared to the Hungarian revolution. We were influenced by the other European revolutions, but the Hungarian revolution lasted 10 times more. All the other nations gave up, only Hungary persisted until we defeated the Austrian Empire. So the Hungarian revolution was not only one of the revolutions. It was the only glorious and victorious revolution of Europe in 1848-1849.
Fourth: The Hungarian revolution was victorious even if it was ended (but not defeated for ever) by the Russian army. Because the Russians left Hungary in a few months, and Austria remained alone with Hungary again. So by 1867 Austria had to accept all the objectives of the Hungarian Revolution. That was the Austrian-Hungarian arrangement, what finally created the Austro-Hungarian Monarchy. Without the Hungarian victory of 1848-1849, never would have been conclude the deal of 1867 between the Habsburgs and Hungary.
Haha, to afraid to also admit how Croatians and Ban Jelacic also defeated you?
Jelacic was a traitor, betrayed Croatia and stood for Habsburgs. It was also called Jelasic's the myrmidon ban. He suffered a complete defeat in the Battle of Pázozd.
@@kiszeg Says the Hungarian. First of all you betrayed Croatia and you abolished the Pacta Conventa, annexing Croatia as Hungarian province. Second of all Ban Jelacic wasnt in favour of Austria but he fought for his country and stood up against Hungarians
@@kiszeg Infact he disobeyed Austrian orders, and the imperial court almost took him out of power.
@@kiszeg Also check battle of Mor, including Schwechat.
:'(
So that's how Austria-Hungary kingdom has been formed all because of the aftermath remains of the post-Napoleonic influence in Austria.
248 People who dislike are Hungarian rebels from 1848