Ep 254 - Can India's Army Keep Up with the Changing Threat Landscape? | Lt. Gen. Raj Shukla

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 3 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 62

  • @chaudharyamod1
    @chaudharyamod1 23 години тому +1

    Gen Raj, the case made by you for national security in this video is very comprehensive and pragmatic.
    I hope the people in power heeds to many suggestions made by you.

  • @ckcariappa
    @ckcariappa 11 годин тому +1

    Wonderfully nuanced conversation on Military Modernization! Gen. Shukla is a rare type of intellectual - one who can combine strategic and tactical expertise, can think of operational nuances and as well as broader narratives and constraints. Really enjoyed this conversation!

  • @malashukla9292
    @malashukla9292 9 годин тому +1

    Brilliant analysis
    Nuanced and exhaustive

  • @saths
    @saths 3 дні тому +13

    One of the most thoughtful and thought provoking conversations I've come across. Gen. Raj Shukla is such an intellectual military man. And kudos to Kamal, as host, for a brilliant job of moving the conversation along. Well worth the time watching this session.

    • @ckcariappa
      @ckcariappa 3 дні тому +1

      Indeed!! Thank you for watching! Do share this episode with your friends and family. 🙂🙏

    • @KamalMadishetty
      @KamalMadishetty 3 дні тому +1

      Thanks a lot 🙏

  • @gauravsoni942
    @gauravsoni942 2 дні тому +3

    Have seen the General closely. His vision is far reaching and sets the temper right for future ready armed forces. Some great takeaways
    1. “National Security is a fused endeavour”
    2. “Unconventional war is an academic parlance ”
    3. “Now is the War of talents and entrepreneurialship “
    4. “Need to fuse Saraswati and Lakshmi with Durga”
    5. “Change adaptations in form of OFB reorganisation, Aatmanirbhar Bharat, Inspace etc in the last 10 years are remarkable”

    • @ckcariappa
      @ckcariappa 2 дні тому

      My favourite - "Capacities take decades to generate, intentions change overnight!" :)
      Thanks for watching! Please do share this content with your friends and family.

  • @Amitsharma-i1o
    @Amitsharma-i1o 2 дні тому +4

    1- 12 crore population of Delhi became a gas chamber where Indian youth aspiring IAS ,strategist 3tc. All are getting asthma and thinking to become super power quite a rosy red dream. Internal power building leads to external power projection. Hope India gets what's needs to be done first.

    • @ckcariappa
      @ckcariappa 2 дні тому

      Thanks for watching! Do share this episode with your friends and family.

  • @jay1947100
    @jay1947100 10 годин тому

    Excellent.. Always great to hear gen raj shukla sir.. Jai hind 🙏

  • @rajthakur5337
    @rajthakur5337 3 дні тому +10

    General Sahab is a very intelligent and far sighted person. Should be in Modi’s think tank cabinet. Jai Bharat.

    • @ckcariappa
      @ckcariappa 3 дні тому

      Indeed! Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

  • @suchbol-u2s
    @suchbol-u2s День тому +2

    You content is very good. Release vedio in part.

    • @ckcariappa
      @ckcariappa День тому

      Thank you! Glad you liked it! Yes, we will release video in parts.
      Please share this content with your friends and family!

  • @georgekuruvilla9978
    @georgekuruvilla9978 2 дні тому +4

    Greetings from a senior citizen living long years abroad.....I wish to interact with Gen. Shukla.....so far unsuccessful to find his own UT chnl/podcast......kindly advise, BRgds, Bobby/GK

    • @ckcariappa
      @ckcariappa 2 дні тому +1

      Hello Sir, you can reach out to Gen. Shukla on Twitter - x.com/Gen_RajShukla.
      Thanks for watching, do share this episode with your friends and family.

  • @niraj2020
    @niraj2020 3 дні тому +6

    Despite many heavy weapons we don't have own fully functional GPS. Navic still not fully operational. Cyber security, don't have own apps, social media apps, own operating system, servers, firewall, data localisation etc. Next we still not done fully 100% capable in small arms, ammunition, drones, anti drone, military Robots and many area. No proper safe keeping place for arms, ammunition, soldiers, vital installation underground similar to Iran and their prixies. Jet engine technology yet to develop. All projects are delayed and getting more expensive and no development of alternative system. Peace time modernisation and basic fundamental needed to be strengthened

    • @ckcariappa
      @ckcariappa 3 дні тому +1

      Thanks for watching! Pls share this episode with your friends and family.

  • @ranenbhattacharyya136
    @ranenbhattacharyya136 2 дні тому +2

    Fascinating thoughts presented.

    • @ckcariappa
      @ckcariappa 2 дні тому

      Thank you! Glad you liked it. Please do share this content with your friends and family.

  • @RoyJacob5
    @RoyJacob5 2 дні тому +1

    1:11:45 he says come 2028 we should not be embarrassed.. what movement was he referring to?

  • @suchbol-u2s
    @suchbol-u2s День тому +1

    Military need to tell what we need as technology. Many intelligent can find solution . Give them chace.

  • @avinashmattoo6124
    @avinashmattoo6124 3 дні тому +4

    Excellent Sir 👍🏻😎

  • @hemikovsky
    @hemikovsky 2 дні тому +4

    The amateurs discuss tactics: the professionals discuss logistics." India should not even consider starting a war with China because the Chinese military-industrial complex is the largest in capacity in the world, even surpassing the USA. In terms of technology, it is second only to the USA. In the case of a prolonged war of attrition, like the ongoing conflict between Russia and Ukraine, we would go bankrupt trying to sustain the fight and purchase supplies, arms, ammunition, and weaponry. China has already captured a large part of the so-called disputed territory without firing a single shot, and India has essentially accepted defeat without resistance. In reality, China is capable of challenging the USA, while we are not even capable of decisively defeating a bankrupt country like Pakistan.

    • @ckcariappa
      @ckcariappa 2 дні тому

      Thanks for watching! Do share this episode with your friends and family.

  • @TheCourageCowardlyDog
    @TheCourageCowardlyDog День тому +1

    NO
    No army can meet such changing scenario with decreasing manpower & budget
    & Specially when many of these challenges like Bangladesh etc could hsve been prevented by timely intervention via Intelligence or other Operations but govt neglected it deliberately!

  • @visionrayz1398
    @visionrayz1398 3 дні тому +2

    Shuru ke 50 second intro music music video alag se bana liya karo yaar

    • @ckcariappa
      @ckcariappa 3 дні тому

      Noted. Thanks for tuning in, pls share this episode with your friends and family.

  • @ingeborgmalik959
    @ingeborgmalik959 3 дні тому +6

    Many Greetings to Both Gentlemen and in particular Lt.Gen Raj Shukla who is an Authority and every word he says should be listened to carefully.....Genralissmo is a Great Strategist and a Pragmatical Thinking Lt.Gen...a pity he is not at The Helm of todays Chaotic Situation...

    • @ckcariappa
      @ckcariappa 3 дні тому +1

      Thank you for watching! Glad you liked it. Pls share this channel with your friends and family - we have been producing content on subjects of national importance for the last four years! 🙂🙏

    • @ingeborgmalik959
      @ingeborgmalik959 3 дні тому +2

      @@ckcariappa Aye Aye Sir....shall do.....I also watch Gunners Shot....come from a Family with History of serving in Defence Forces,Army as well as IAF...
      Jai Bharat

    • @ckcariappa
      @ckcariappa 3 дні тому +1

      ​@@ingeborgmalik959Wow! Wonderful. Very glad to connect sir.
      Jai Hind!

    • @ingeborgmalik959
      @ingeborgmalik959 3 дні тому

      @@ckcariappa Jai Hind

    • @KamalMadishetty
      @KamalMadishetty 3 дні тому +1

      Thanks a lot 🙏

  • @suchbol-u2s
    @suchbol-u2s День тому

    Ai courts can good idea? Cheque return cases

  • @AntiFragile_07
    @AntiFragile_07 3 дні тому +1

    Please allow the download option otherwise there are 100 videos everyday I will forget to watch it

    • @Bharatvaarta
      @Bharatvaarta  3 дні тому

      Hi, the video is currently under copyright dispute. Once the dispute is lifted, you should be able to download it.

    • @AntiFragile_07
      @AntiFragile_07 3 дні тому

      Thankyou

  • @suchbol-u2s
    @suchbol-u2s День тому +1

    Can defence dep promote public lid co ,with investment ,order and run by scientists and defence personnel. Public has lot of money to invest. Even 50% sucessful co will change our nation

  • @DeccanPS
    @DeccanPS 3 дні тому +4

    Jabardast❤

    • @ckcariappa
      @ckcariappa 3 дні тому +1

      Thank you! Glad you liked it. Pls do subscribe to the channel and share this content with your friends and family. 🙂🙏

  • @GarudCommando
    @GarudCommando 2 дні тому +1

    Is it Ukraine or USA which is the actual power fighting war in ukrain?
    I think gen Saab knows but doesn't want to say.

    • @ckcariappa
      @ckcariappa День тому

      Thanks for watching! Do share this episode with your friends and family.

  • @RNDixit-me5uj
    @RNDixit-me5uj День тому +1

    Platform Name :- "Bharatvaarta"
    Conversation :- "English" languages
    Thomas Babington Macaulay & Charles Wood are successful in their mission 😅😅
    Aspirations to be a superpower with "colonized mind" is nothing but a sleepwalk race !!

    • @ckcariappa
      @ckcariappa День тому

      Making content for a global audience; English is the most optimal link language. But, we will produce content in Hindi and Kannada, as well. Thanks for watching, do share and subscribe.

  • @suchbol-u2s
    @suchbol-u2s День тому

    Do we need to tell world ,what wewill do what are our plan ?

  • @tejmachhar4903
    @tejmachhar4903 2 дні тому

    The air force doesn't have enough fighter jets and we are not even bothering to procure it on an urgent basis. Our Tejas program is a failure. We are sleeping as a nation.

    • @ckcariappa
      @ckcariappa 2 дні тому

      Thanks for watching! Do share this episode with your friends and family.

  • @suchbol-u2s
    @suchbol-u2s День тому

    Can we spend lot on defence , intelligence? . What is Israel model.

  • @suchbol-u2s
    @suchbol-u2s День тому

    हम बांग्लादेश पाकिस्तान को तो सीधा नहीं कर पा रहे हैं तो चीन क्यों डरेगा
    बंगला देश को तो सीधा करें
    वापस भेजो रोहिंग्या और बंगला देशी बंगाल से

  • @niraj2020
    @niraj2020 3 дні тому +1

    We need DOGE similar to US president Donald J Trump bringing reform in US. From abolishing Personal Income tax simplifying GST, other taxes, abolishing collegium system of selection of judges, judicial and administrative reform and many reform to decolonise, delicence, deregulate, decontrol all sector needed. Despite 2 terms, Modi 3.0 failed drastic reform. For such reform we need to bring Yogi Adityanath as PM only option available now. Modi now became old, tired, retired feel fatigue and lost interest in domestic politics and committed to Bharatiya voters. Now wanted to wear secular pyjama and diluted adulterers Hindutva now.

    • @ckcariappa
      @ckcariappa 3 дні тому

      Thanks for watching! Please share this channel with your friends and family.

    • @lazydaug7147
      @lazydaug7147 2 дні тому

      Yes agree

  • @suchbol-u2s
    @suchbol-u2s День тому

    बांग्लादेश से कह देना चाहिए आपके यहां एक हिंदू देश चाहिए जहां हिंदू शांति से रह सके आपको जगह जमीन देनी पड़ेगी वरना हम आकरले लेंगे

  • @ramtal1125
    @ramtal1125 2 дні тому

    China and Bharat are 2 different political systems and central rule. Unfortunately only looking from narrow viewpoint.

    • @ckcariappa
      @ckcariappa 2 дні тому

      Thanks for watching! Do share this episode with your friends and family.

  • @pratiknaga
    @pratiknaga 3 дні тому

    Bhai ye Sab bakchodi hai . kaam toh Bangladesh me ho raha hai.

    • @ckcariappa
      @ckcariappa 3 дні тому

      Thanks for watching! Please share this channel with your friends and family.

  • @avinashmattoo6124
    @avinashmattoo6124 3 дні тому +1

    Excellent Sir 👍🏻😎

    • @ckcariappa
      @ckcariappa 3 дні тому

      Thanks for watching! Please share this content with your friends and family.