@@TheDaftySage A biased or filtered opinion is still useful information if you know the bias. I sometimes read news sources with a very strong bias, with which I do not agree, but I can still extract information out of this.
Yes it is...not only apartments, condos, buildings and shopping centers sitting idle and rotting away but millions of cars are also sitting idle and rotting. People cant afford the payments anymore, jobs are getting scares. Lots of manufacturing have moved to Mexico and now they have become the USA number 1 trade partner. Its what the Chinese get...got greedy, they bully small nations..its karma in the making.😂😂😂
To obtain financial freedom, one must either be a business owner, an investor or both, generating passive income particularly weekly or monthly basis. That’s the key to living a financially stability......
She's based out of HK. She's not allowed to speak freely about the CCP economy. It's against national security laws. _She is the Chief Economist for Asia Pacific at French investment bank Natixis, based in Hong Kong and is an independent Board Member of AGEAS insurance group._
If you're in China "you're not free to tell any negative about China's economy", it's not a secret, it's CCP's directives. China was infamous with being dishonest and fabricating their data.
6 trillion lost from the market. Another 1,5 trillion lost from failed belt and road initiatives. Youth unemployment surging. Foreign companies have all left. Sanctions put on the chip markets from the US. And demographics beginning to collapse. Not to mention the ever tightening of freedoms by the government. Things do not look good for China. We are witnessing an epic economic collapse.
all these naysayers, uk was in decade of negative equity plus so much default. did uk when bust? also if china tank, the whole world go into recession. and usa will b the worse of the lot. that is why usa is exporting war everywhere. they r trying their best to avoid doing a greece
Owning real estate property is a major and sometimes sole retirement-fund investment for over 100,000,000 in China, significantly effecting more people than invest in Chinese stocks and bonds for retirement fund.
You do not know China. Not like Americans, For example if you make $120,000 salary, your monthly income is $10,000, but if you do not have any retirement saving, after retirement your income will reduce to around $3,000 from social security. But in China, most moderate salary people, after retirement, their social security benefit matches their previous salary or even more than their working salary.
Many people in China do not have basic medical insurance, pensions, let alone Chinese Premier Li Keqiang once said that 600 million people in China earn $150 a month. Suffering can be seen everywhere on this continent.
Maybe don’t flex on your wealthiest customers and we wouldn’t be pulling hundreds of billions out of your economy 😂 they forgot you can’t grow without American money.
Although high US interest rates are cutting Russia and China deeply by ensuring international capital markets have no interest in those countries, I assure you that those are merely side effects and not the central purpose of US economic policy. US economic policy is entirely based on domestic issues. and the US Fed has been trying to make it very hard for US businesses and consumers to borrow money to pay just about any price for goods and services. The American Consumer is doing so well willing to buy stuff at pre-Pandemic levels that businesses are strongly motivated to borrow to feed that Consumer appetite so the Fed is preventing that from happening to fight inflation. US economic policy makers are not dreaming up ways to screw up China and Russia, they have their attention 100% on what the US economy needs.
Pulling out business in massive What do you think happened to your country .... USA japan south Korean and Europe business exudos pull out thier business..... World awake on Chinese lies and description
Evergrande is just one of many. The ENTIRE Chinese real estate industry follows the same flawed model. The writing is on the wall. The entire house of cards is falling down.
Garcia should just answer YES or NO whether communist China economy is currently in trouble. She never answered by instead talking nonsense all along .because she is not sure what she is talking about This session of video with Garcia is wasting my valuable time watching. Get lost her
China doesn't measure growth after the year is over like Western economies. The government picks a number, then it's up to the provinces to make it happen, and if they don't, they still report back that they did. It's a fictional number. No country with 5% growth would be seeing all the problems China is suffering right now.
China's economy is shrinking. Property construction and related industries are contracting, exports down, retail/restaurant apocalypse, small manufacturing decimated, mass unemployment, etc. If the economy was growing civil servants across the country wouldn't be taking pay cuts. The CCP lies about everything, especially unemployment and GDP growth.
In the tech sector, you have what’s called employee farming! Giving a highly specialized job to an individual, you had employees at Google (engineers), and all they did was create buttons for people to click on with an app!
@@heroes8844 let's say you wanna sign up for Gmail, you need to somehow click a button to initiate the wizard/process for creating a new email account. Generally, that entire process could be vetted out with just maybe three or four engineers. That have general knowledge on databases, security, front end web. They would have knowledge across those perspective domains. Work together to put that process into place.
The debt in the US isn't really that bad. The interest % we pay on the debt is less than the GDP growth of the country right now. Also a big part of our debt came under Trump, most of which was to help us get through Covid... and if you look at Germany and China, economically we definitely got through much better than they did.
Debt is not a problem as long as you have the ability to repay it. Most people who talk about this number have no clue about economics. The US is the strongest and richest country in the world and no one comes close.
Not impressed with either the host or the interview with economist Alicia Herrera. I'm sure she's bright but the discussion had no dept and was contradictory at times without explanation. She said she feared for China's inflation woes. A couple minutes later, she feared for China's deflation prospects. You can't have both at the same time. Maybe she's talking about different parts of China's economy? No one can know because it wasn't explored. She also never discussed specifics like what reforms she favors. She like many other economists don't describe the contradiction between China's usual GDP growth and the incredible freeze and devaluation of many of China's economic sectors including retail, export manufacturing and of course the real estate property market. Maybe the high tech industry is holding up the overall national GDP figure on its own but maybe not. Basically, this Al Jazeera episode is no better than, and could be considered inferior to others reporting on the same topics.
Inflation from importing goods at higher prices for food and energy and raw materials and deflation caused by nobody buying Chinese goods so manufacturers have to drop their prices. China have not had much of a charm offensive, more like a beligerance offensive to its biggest trade surplus customers and its near neighbours, it's economy has 57 Trillion USD of total debt and is in a pickle as property it's main economic driver has gone kaput and it will not return to the levels it was, it requires a reset to 10 to 15% of GDP and not 25 to 30%, also housing prices need a major reset downwards, it has not reached the bottom, prices are rigged higher by CCP legislation. The stock market is being rigged by CCP manipulation by imposing strict rules on how people access their capital and it is directing Chinese companies to buy and hold stock, it's not leaving the market free, it has also been manipulating it's currency to keep it at a certain level, local governments need a new funding model and that doesn't even exist yet. China is a big avoid for investors, its cheap but for a reason, Japan has better prospects than China that's why Chinese citizens are buying the stock in vast numbers!?!
China is embarrassed of its historic failings. Look at the math- USA 300yo v China 4000yo China is nothing without the world. Chinas marketing is also plain and stupid.
3:47 I think this misses the point. Many of those people never planned to move in. Real estate is the traditional "investment" in China. Of course, the collapse of real-estate values will be devastating.
@@maxpower8429 Country gardens executives took massive pay cuts, as high as 96% so they don't get their butts in prison. Plus country garden's ceo and biggest shareholder transfer a lot of their personal shares to a charity controlled by family members. Yes, the left hand is passing to the right hand money... Sneaky sneaky...
China economy will not be in serious trouble in compared to the west. Why? Because it’s a mix of state owned companies and private companies. Most of the state owned companies are in good shape and they control the key part of economy like banks, insurance , utility plus many important major industries. Remember, China has over billions of population. Only two countries in the world can say that. China already lifted many poor in years ago. Middle income are growing to few hundred millions. Not to mention about more super rich and mega rich. China also has the most foreign reserves including gold in the world. When we said China is trouble why China still have growth , maybe not as much in the past, compared to most countries including the west is negative growth ? China is now under going a transformation to high end industries and building up a domestic market. To me as a business man. I think some correction is good. The world can’t keep growing without stopping. Rocket high real estate prices is not good for business. A stable growth is much better. Over borrowing and expending crazily also not right. The world economy is not good and it’s affecting each other. It’s important for US and China working together peacefully. It definitely good for everyone on the planet. By provoking , sanctioning and decoupling are not going to work!
Slashing bank reserves to release cash is "kicking the can down the road" and will sharpen the imminent collapse. It doesn't placate overseas investment, just allows the leaders to grab that cash, take it out of the country to set up their exile.
While I am no economist or politician, looking at both areas simultaneously, this is what I see: there are those who knew the effect that the tariffs and the collective pullout of so many international companies would have. However, it will reach further than just China. With this nation being the second largest economy in the world, what effect will all this have globally? The global effect is the objective.
Host: so, AI is the problem? Interviewee: No, the interest is. Host: ok, so are you telling about AI?! Interviewee: NO, interest. Host: ok, ok, AI. Got it 🙄😏
Yea because they saw the foundation china was putting down. All the sudden the foundation started to shake. While I understand what you mean, we have never seen china's economy behave this way before. This is pure evidence of the problems whereas before it was just conjecture. China released this data itself and even then we all know they like to paint over their numbers to make it seem less disorderly
Unfortunately this lady has underestimated the challenges in China's banking sector, the relative poorness of average Chinese GDP per capita vs Japan at the same stage. Moreover, the key difference is that Japan did not suffer from political divergence with Western economies, China does, so its overhangs with ine child policy, massive debts, ageing demographics amongst other concurrent policy conflicts means it is even worse than Japan in rhe late 80s.
Yup Japan didn’t suffer policy divergence they just weren’t able to withstand US sanctions on chip exports and the plaza accord. Those are the 2 major factors that economist miss when talking about China’s economy. Because China withstood US sanctions their economy will be able to grow on innovation and new tech sectors, plus with BRI, China’s exports do not just go to the west they include other countries and with the sanctions on Russia you have basically handed the Russian entire market on a dinner plate to China. With China being the number one car exporter and BYD sales exceeding Tesla, plus Huawei Mate 60 pro and the Chinese own domestic plane in production, China has plenty of growth industries.
The existing economic data is completely different from what you said, and the world today is also completely different from the 1980s. The West is no longer a force that can completely dominate the world.
Yes it’s in bad shape. The real estate market has overbuilt by 1 billion homes and the ones that people bought have not been completed. They build the ones they don’t need skimming money and making these houses very unsturdy to get free money from the buyers that already paid. It’s a scheme. There is no demand for anymore houses to be built though maybe forever. The government can’t bail it out even though they will try. The real estate market won’t recover possibly ever. This is only one of the 10 things going on in China that is catastrophic for the economy. If you have any money anywhere in China, get it out now while you still can.
many commentators here waiting and desperately hoping the chinese economy collapse. But these people will be disappointed. To judge a country economy, a few negative factors will not collapse an economy. Real estate is important but not dead sentence. If it is, the chinese government sure will bail them. Which country does not face problems? most important is the overall development and government policy.
If China cannot get to $25,000 per capital when their market was full steam ahead, what makes her think that they can do it with economic slow down and real estate disaster? Some Chinese are paying mortgages for housing that will never be built, thanks to the country's poor housing and banking policies.
Surgeon,38 years in active practice, last 7 years between 3 to 4 jobs, 2 of them active surgical practices between Southern California and northern New Mexico, the other two for consulting,quality review.
They were really pushing the AI question based on....what exactly? Dude started by saying he isn't a business analyst lol. This whole segment is garbage
Foreign investors should be paid back first and made whole plus interest. The people in China that paid for homes and will never receive it, too bad for them.
China solve the homeless issue for the world. All we need to do is have a 1 way trip to send all homeless from every country to China for permanent residency...
This trend of investing in physical assets started with SE Asia and later moved on to the Gulf, where sporadic investments were made into real estate sectors, sparking the geospatial led investment planning revolution. Later, other economies tried to catch up, but, we saw how excess supply can lead to shareholder value destruction.
China's 40 year turnaround story is being discussed by the West as a miracle. Would China flounder because of a property problem which in many ways is intentional to keep property prices down? China has seen the flaws of high property prices in Hong Kong and Singapore and would not let this to happen in China, leading to fake economic growth but real hardship to the average citizens. Economic growth led by inflating property prices and stock prices is an economy on steroid. Not real growth. America's 1% economic growth was hailed as rock solid by western analysts. And this is coupled with a 5% inflation which would make the American economy super rock solid. And the same group of analysts dismissed China's 5% growth as a collapsing economy, even when inflation is nearly zero in China. What would the same analysts describe India's 6% growth? Collapsing faster than China or super solid like America's 1% growth?
China is maturing economy while US is matured ..US grew 3.3% last quarter despite many 'analyst' predicted a recession... annual used growth of 2.1% is good...January jobs figure was stellar to say least...same is not about China.. china's market there is outflow of cash...and hude debt Isreal estate sector......China is said to slow more
You believe Biden's 3.3% when US is sanctioning n cutting trades with so many countries, when Boeing n Apple are not selling well? Any fake growth came from a stock market fed with steroids. China in debt? It's reserves are more than $3 trillion. US no debt? Heard of $34 trillion n growing rapidly?
@@redbeansg it beat all recession expectation by analyst may be you are in parallel universe where Russia is a economic superpower he he....US economy is resilent
The Chinese government already has a lot of policies on these issues, which have been implemented in many cities. Are you still here yelling, "No, it's going down"?
Wrong. Europe's birthrate is terrible, yes, but it's demographic steady because their population is supplemented by a huge immigration intake from Africa and Asia. China has one of the worst immigration intake in the world and also has one of the largest exodus of national citizens in the world. Europe brings in over 3 million LEGAL immigrants then there are millions that flood in illegally per year.
Not true. Yes, the birthrate in all developed and most large nations is at a rate that doesn't support population stability and on its own will result in a shrinking population. But, that ignores the fact that China is setting all sorts of records for a declining birthrate, latest reported is 1.2/couple. Most developed nations are about 1.6 and to maintain a stable population number about 2.1 is needed.
@@tonysu8860 Sorry, Tony what happen for local Chinese governments to get more funding from the Central Government in Beijng would routinely over count the amount children in their class rooms.
@@tonysu8860 The Central Government of Beijing say they over counted by about 100 million Chinese below the age of 40 years old. You now declining fasters then the Jews that were being killed off in Holocaust during World War II.
If you ask western economists , China economy always in trouble , always collapsing it already said for almost 20 years now. CHINA JUST KEEP GOING AND KEEP GROWING , THAT WHY CHINA CAN SPENT 10 TRILLION DOLLAR ON BRI DEVELOPMENT FOR 20 YEARS AND WILL DEVELOPE MORE IN FUTURE.
LOL China GDP grew by 5.2% LOLOLOL ya right. Says who ? Oh China. Next tell us Russia's GDP.
IMF
We should not forget that she lives in Hong Kong and thus has to choose her words carefully.
Ok, but why go do an interview like this then.
@@TheDaftySage Well that's how people are😀
@@TheDaftySage A biased or filtered opinion is still useful information if you know the bias. I sometimes read news sources with a very strong bias, with which I do not agree, but I can still extract information out of this.
@pa_2600 🤣🤣😂😂
By that logic, any positive sentiment on China is false and only negative sentiment is true. Right, sheep?
Yes it is...not only apartments, condos, buildings and shopping centers sitting idle and rotting away but millions of cars are also sitting idle and rotting. People cant afford the payments anymore, jobs are getting scares. Lots of manufacturing have moved to Mexico and now they have become the USA number 1 trade partner. Its what the Chinese get...got greedy, they bully small nations..its karma in the making.😂😂😂
She is a chief economist at a bank? Everyone, pull your money out of this bank immediately. 😳
Lmaooo, one property developer fails and US media tries to create negative speculation in China. But 3 US banks fail and no news ahahahahahahaha
To obtain financial freedom, one must either be a business owner, an investor or both, generating passive income particularly weekly or monthly basis. That’s the key to living a financially stability......
Seems like a wildly optimistic analysis from Garcia-Herrero. Time will tell.
Agree my view is a lot more pessimistic. This is just the beginning of the downturn which will last many years.
She's based out of HK. She's not allowed to speak freely about the CCP economy. It's against national security laws.
_She is the Chief Economist for Asia Pacific at French investment bank Natixis, based in Hong Kong and is an independent Board Member of AGEAS insurance group._
all data coming from the ccp or organisms that the ccp can hurt will be complete lies.
Bette than you anti china losers
If you're in China "you're not free to tell any negative about China's economy", it's not a secret, it's CCP's directives. China was infamous with being dishonest and fabricating their data.
6 trillion lost from the market. Another 1,5 trillion lost from failed belt and road initiatives. Youth unemployment surging. Foreign companies have all left. Sanctions put on the chip markets from the US. And demographics beginning to collapse. Not to mention the ever tightening of freedoms by the government. Things do not look good for China. We are witnessing an epic economic collapse.
Says the guy in the UA-cam comments who knows jack about economics lol.
According to the west, China's economy has been in serious trouble for the last 15 years lol
Al Jaljeera is not west 😂
This is a Middle East outlet though
@@ksrawat88 al jazieera is in the same building as the previous bbc its just rebranded for regional taste
all these naysayers, uk was in decade of negative equity plus so much default. did uk when bust? also if china tank, the whole world go into recession. and usa will b the worse of the lot. that is why usa is exporting war everywhere. they r trying their best to avoid doing a greece
why the world go into recession when u can move out of china instead =).
so nobody saw this coming? what about all those ghost cities which accumulated over the years?
everyone looking closely at China saw it coming.
Exactly.......they have been bullying people into accepting this beautiful lie...the lie is now exposed
@@bullpup1337 smart people saw it coming because they know what not to trust.
When they say nobody, they mean people like this woman here.
Stock market is not an indicator for CHINA's economy.
No It's much worse
Owning real estate property is a major and sometimes sole retirement-fund investment for over 100,000,000 in China, significantly effecting more people than invest in Chinese stocks and bonds for retirement fund.
The main property of more than 70% of households is a house
You do not know China. Not like Americans, For example if you make $120,000 salary, your monthly income is $10,000, but if you do not have any retirement saving, after retirement your income will reduce to around $3,000 from social security. But in China, most moderate salary people, after retirement, their social security benefit matches their previous salary or even more than their working salary.
Many people in China do not have basic medical insurance, pensions, let alone Chinese Premier Li Keqiang once said that 600 million people in China earn $150 a month. Suffering can be seen everywhere on this continent.
@@brawhite6157 healthcare in China is free.
@@brawhite6157 What about 27 millions American people without health insurance and accessible into the basic health care.🥸
Maybe don’t flex on your wealthiest customers and we wouldn’t be pulling hundreds of billions out of your economy 😂 they forgot you can’t grow without American money.
Anytime adrian is an anchor, i thumbs down & stop the video. He excessively stutters, which is cringey & unprofessional.
According to Western mass media, Chinese economy has been collapsing last 20 years😂😂😂
@@RobbyCarlyle Well, Gordon Chan's "Coming Collapse of China" was published in 2001.
I'm not sure Gordon Chan represents all of Western media.@@Miya-ub5qn
So this is precisely the reason US is not cutting interest rates yet. China will see a lot more capital outflows in the months to come.
Rates are not even high in the USA. It's also booming here from all the companies moving back.
@@ryanwalters6184Not even high? According to Bloomberg, US Debt Interest Bill Rockets Past a Cool $1 Trillion a Year.
Although high US interest rates are cutting Russia and China deeply by ensuring international capital markets have no interest in those countries, I assure you that those are merely side effects and not the central purpose of US economic policy. US economic policy is entirely based on domestic issues. and the US Fed has been trying to make it very hard for US businesses and consumers to borrow money to pay just about any price for goods and services. The American Consumer is doing so well willing to buy stuff at pre-Pandemic levels that businesses are strongly motivated to borrow to feed that Consumer appetite so the Fed is preventing that from happening to fight inflation.
US economic policy makers are not dreaming up ways to screw up China and Russia, they have their attention 100% on what the US economy needs.
@@deerbeau who does that pay to? That just boosts the gdp.
@@ryanwalters6184Yeah, it can only boost the GDP and last forever without consequences. You’re full of bullsh*t.
Pulling out business in massive
What do you think happened to your country ....
USA japan south Korean and Europe business exudos pull out thier business.....
World awake on Chinese lies and description
GDP growing 5.2%..? there is still someone who believes in the ccp numbers??😆😆😆😆
If I look at where the money goes, many people take it elsewhere
China is in big trouble but it isnt collapsing, it will still overtake US in the future due to population size and advanced industry
@@fintech1378 Little Pink. What is the birth rate in China now? How many Chinese really "survived" COVID-19? Obviously you can't even to 10.
Evergrande is just one of many.
The ENTIRE Chinese real estate industry follows the same flawed model.
The writing is on the wall. The entire house of cards is falling down.
Sorry to tell you, the Chinese government has started to solve the problem, very smart way.
But US' housing problem is 100 times worse and yet no mention from you?
Like your momma
@@rogerfaint499
Worse? Not enough inventory is different from oversupply and unfinished highrises.
Garcia should just answer YES or NO whether communist China economy is currently in trouble.
She never answered by instead talking nonsense all along .because she is not sure what she is talking about
This session of video with Garcia is wasting my valuable time watching.
Get lost her
China economy in serious trouble, but the economy only grew at 5.3%😅😅😅. Developed economies can only dream of hitting that level of growth.
Correct me if iam wrong but China is known for cutting the books and not being forth coming about the economy
@@julianbrown3668 yes and they eat unwanted babies as well usually made in a big couldron. And they stir it with a large stick.
@@julianbrown3668 You are not wrong, their economy growth is normally actually higher than reported if measured by PPP.
China doesn't measure growth after the year is over like Western economies. The government picks a number, then it's up to the provinces to make it happen, and if they don't, they still report back that they did. It's a fictional number. No country with 5% growth would be seeing all the problems China is suffering right now.
China's economy is shrinking. Property construction and related industries are contracting, exports down, retail/restaurant apocalypse, small manufacturing decimated, mass unemployment, etc. If the economy was growing civil servants across the country wouldn't be taking pay cuts. The CCP lies about everything, especially unemployment and GDP growth.
In the tech sector, you have what’s called employee farming! Giving a highly specialized job to an individual, you had employees at Google (engineers), and all they did was create buttons for people to click on with an app!
still dont get what u mean. What do u mean create button for people to click? care to give an example?
@@heroes8844 let's say you wanna sign up for Gmail, you need to somehow click a button to initiate the wizard/process for creating a new email account. Generally, that entire process could be vetted out with just maybe three or four engineers. That have general knowledge on databases, security, front end web. They would have knowledge across those perspective domains. Work together to put that process into place.
Is America in debt of upwards of 34 trillion?
Yes. And anyone over there is free to say what they want about it. Are Chinese people free to do the same about their economy?
@@rodders7744 Yes they're so free that they can't even properly define what a woman is. That's what liberty has given them.
What about the debt?
The debt in the US isn't really that bad. The interest % we pay on the debt is less than the GDP growth of the country right now. Also a big part of our debt came under Trump, most of which was to help us get through Covid... and if you look at Germany and China, economically we definitely got through much better than they did.
Debt is not a problem as long as you have the ability to repay it. Most people who talk about this number have no clue about economics. The US is the strongest and richest country in the world and no one comes close.
Natixis lady . Gather she is based in HK ?
Any reason at all to believe she can tell the truth
Likely. Hence she has no balls to say it like it is. Natixis gets to keep their office there 😏
Don’t bite the hand that feeds you.
She keeps going back to Japan haha. If you haven’t noticed Japan is a rich country. China is not.
China is richer than Japan
Per capita? No. Not even close. Japan $33,815. China $12,541---Wikipedia@@alfredhitchcock45
The worst yet come.
US companies moving to Vietnam, India from china..
No more are moving to China. Nobody wants Chinese products in the US anymore
Shirt answer to that title question:
The communists will never tell you the truth.
China will occupy Pakistan,,Maldives 😂😂
Myanmar is next Tibet in the making
China is funding both Military & Rebels.
Umm it's been in trouble.....where have you been?
Drunk or asleep. Doesn't really matter, she clearly wasn't at work.
Not impressed with either the host or the interview with economist Alicia Herrera.
I'm sure she's bright but the discussion had no dept and was contradictory at times without explanation.
She said she feared for China's inflation woes.
A couple minutes later, she feared for China's deflation prospects.
You can't have both at the same time. Maybe she's talking about different parts of China's economy? No one can know because it wasn't explored.
She also never discussed specifics like what reforms she favors.
She like many other economists don't describe the contradiction between China's usual GDP growth and the incredible freeze and devaluation of many of China's economic sectors including retail, export manufacturing and of course the real estate property market. Maybe the high tech industry is holding up the overall national GDP figure on its own but maybe not.
Basically, this Al Jazeera episode is no better than, and could be considered inferior to others reporting on the same topics.
Inflation from importing goods at higher prices for food and energy and raw materials and deflation caused by nobody buying Chinese goods so manufacturers have to drop their prices. China have not had much of a charm offensive, more like a beligerance offensive to its biggest trade surplus customers and its near neighbours, it's economy has 57 Trillion USD of total debt and is in a pickle as property it's main economic driver has gone kaput and it will not return to the levels it was, it requires a reset to 10 to 15% of GDP and not 25 to 30%, also housing prices need a major reset downwards, it has not reached the bottom, prices are rigged higher by CCP legislation. The stock market is being rigged by CCP manipulation by imposing strict rules on how people access their capital and it is directing Chinese companies to buy and hold stock, it's not leaving the market free, it has also been manipulating it's currency to keep it at a certain level, local governments need a new funding model and that doesn't even exist yet. China is a big avoid for investors, its cheap but for a reason, Japan has better prospects than China that's why Chinese citizens are buying the stock in vast numbers!?!
6 trillion out from the stock market in just 3 yrs 😂😂 it will just get worse their wumao so u wait 😂
The Chinese auto industry is doing fine though.
chna auto stocks are tanking!
This is definitely a Pollyanna view of the Chinese economy. Maybe she knows not to say too much.
Yeap, CCP laws are transferrable to Hong Kong now. Talking bad about the CCP economy is breaking the law in CCP China thus in HK as well.
China is embarrassed of its historic failings.
Look at the math- USA 300yo v China 4000yo
China is nothing without the world.
Chinas marketing is also plain and stupid.
3:47 I think this misses the point. Many of those people never planned to move in. Real estate is the traditional "investment" in China. Of course, the collapse of real-estate values will be devastating.
Sad cant get basic facts right. Evergrande was not the largest property develper they were second or third. Country Garden was the largest developer.
What’s going on with that 1? Was happy to hear the evergrand ceo was arrested, what’s going on with country gardens ceo?
@@maxpower8429 Country gardens executives took massive pay cuts, as high as 96% so they don't get their butts in prison. Plus country garden's ceo and biggest shareholder transfer a lot of their personal shares to a charity controlled by family members. Yes, the left hand is passing to the right hand money... Sneaky sneaky...
When China's economy not in trouble for past 30 years? The economists saying this for 30 years
Pls shorten your initial music introduction. It's too long!
China economy will not be in serious trouble in compared to the west. Why? Because it’s a mix of state owned companies and private companies. Most of the state owned companies are in good shape and they control the key part of economy like banks, insurance , utility plus many important major industries.
Remember, China has over billions of population. Only two countries in the world can say that. China already lifted many poor in years ago. Middle income are growing to few hundred millions. Not to mention about more super rich and mega rich.
China also has the most foreign reserves including gold in the world.
When we said China is trouble why China still have growth , maybe not as much in the past, compared to most countries including the west is negative growth ?
China is now under going a transformation to high end industries and building up a domestic market. To me as a business man. I think some correction is good. The world can’t keep growing without stopping. Rocket high real estate prices is not good for business. A stable growth is much better. Over borrowing and expending crazily also not right.
The world economy is not good and it’s affecting each other. It’s important for US and China working together peacefully. It definitely good for everyone on the planet. By provoking , sanctioning and decoupling are not going to work!
America is enjoying economic prosperity
Enjoying with 35 trilyun debt😂😂
@@mimimama-vt9hm 1/3 of that debt was created by trump
When one man is running the show and he is not educated . Same in Russia , Brazil, Argentina...
Slashing bank reserves to release cash is "kicking the can down the road" and will sharpen the imminent collapse. It doesn't placate overseas investment, just allows the leaders to grab that cash, take it out of the country to set up their exile.
Fake news
Does a bear sh** in the woods?
While I am no economist or politician, looking at both areas simultaneously, this is what I see: there are those who knew the effect that the tariffs and the collective pullout of so many international companies would have.
However, it will reach further than just China. With this nation being the second largest economy in the world, what effect will all this have globally? The global effect is the objective.
Yes, because they are tied to the dollar
Yes yes yes!!!😊
Host: so, AI is the problem?
Interviewee: No, the interest is.
Host: ok, so are you telling about AI?!
Interviewee: NO, interest.
Host: ok, ok, AI. Got it
🙄😏
Unwatchable with that music. Looking for another source.
Hello my dear friend! thank you for the cool video! keep filming! I'll wait for new videos
This host with his leading questions! Really going for that 'end of China' sound bite huh?🤣🤣
people have been saying China's economy is in serious trouble for decades now...
Yea because they saw the foundation china was putting down. All the sudden the foundation started to shake. While I understand what you mean, we have never seen china's economy behave this way before. This is pure evidence of the problems whereas before it was just conjecture. China released this data itself and even then we all know they like to paint over their numbers to make it seem less disorderly
The CCP has been hiding a failed economy for decades.
hmmm that is a very very very optimistic view of the chinese economy. i’m guessing she’s under orders
It's more likely that she is really incompetent.
She's drunk on Chinese tea. She is probably entangled financially and doesn't dare say what she really thinks.
Let them poor so that they cannot bully. Invest in democratic country like Philippines, India and allied countries.
@pa_2600 Sadly, the only industrial chain the United States can control is Apple.
It is a huge joke for medieval countries like India and the Philippines to call themselves democracy.
West is worried in just 300B, china reserve stands at 4T and US still owes China worth 800B.😁
On the hand, US economy is being supported by massive debts while its equity market is partying
Trump added 1/3 to the countries debt in 4 years
And Biden is adding more. So?@@doughooper9918
Unfortunately this lady has underestimated the challenges in China's banking sector, the relative poorness of average Chinese GDP per capita vs Japan at the same stage. Moreover, the key difference is that Japan did not suffer from political divergence with Western economies, China does, so its overhangs with ine child policy, massive debts, ageing demographics amongst other concurrent policy conflicts means it is even worse than Japan in rhe late 80s.
Yup Japan didn’t suffer policy divergence they just weren’t able to withstand US sanctions on chip exports and the plaza accord. Those are the 2 major factors that economist miss when talking about China’s economy. Because China withstood US sanctions their economy will be able to grow on innovation and new tech sectors, plus with BRI, China’s exports do not just go to the west they include other countries and with the sanctions on Russia you have basically handed the Russian entire market on a dinner plate to China. With China being the number one car exporter and BYD sales exceeding Tesla, plus Huawei Mate 60 pro and the Chinese own domestic plane in production, China has plenty of growth industries.
The existing economic data is completely different from what you said, and the world today is also completely different from the 1980s. The West is no longer a force that can completely dominate the world.
Yes it’s in bad shape. The real estate market has overbuilt by 1 billion homes and the ones that people bought have not been completed. They build the ones they don’t need skimming money and making these houses very unsturdy to get free money from the buyers that already paid. It’s a scheme. There is no demand for anymore houses to be built though maybe forever. The government can’t bail it out even though they will try. The real estate market won’t recover possibly ever. This is only one of the 10 things going on in China that is catastrophic for the economy. If you have any money anywhere in China, get it out now while you still can.
Can you provide the source for the 1 billion overbuilt home figure you mentioned?
Huge problem like your life?
Sweet!
Answer no ,no its not in as much trouble as the United States economy is 😂
That economy is a BIG JOKE LOL
Ever-grande unfortunately turned out to be Short-grande. 😀
Bank of China Ord Attention to stocks will increase
catch 23 - a chinese knock-off of catch 22
Al jazzera really ? You couldn’t get an economist who didn’t have a heavy Spanish accent ?
Yeah, I had to stop listening to her because of that.
many commentators here waiting and desperately hoping the chinese economy collapse. But these people will be disappointed. To judge a country economy, a few negative factors will not collapse an economy. Real estate is important but not dead sentence. If it is, the chinese government sure will bail them. Which country does not face problems? most important is the overall development and government policy.
If China cannot get to $25,000 per capital when their market was full steam ahead, what makes her think that they can do it with economic slow down and real estate disaster? Some Chinese are paying mortgages for housing that will never be built, thanks to the country's poor housing and banking policies.
ประสบคามสำเร็จในการเปิดรับนักท่องเที่ยวยินดีค่ะคนไทยไปเที่ยวเยอะ❤🎉🎉🎉5ปีผ่านไป
Surgeon,38 years in active practice, last 7 years between 3 to 4 jobs, 2 of them active surgical practices between Southern California and northern New Mexico, the other two for consulting,quality review.
Why media kept saying how bad is china and how good is US. Actually it's the reversed how much is US owing? And how much is China's?
They were really pushing the AI question based on....what exactly? Dude started by saying he isn't a business analyst lol. This whole segment is garbage
The host was trying to get her to say China is in crisis and heading into a death spiral. She didn't get the hint 😅
Foreign investors should be paid back first and made whole plus interest. The people in China that paid for homes and will never receive it, too bad for them.
AI plays no role in layoffs in the tech sector. If you’ve ever seen AI attempt to create a snippet of code it’s laughable.
This has everything to do with zombie jobs
@pa_2600 now that's true
You obviously dont work in one of those companies/big tech
your momma@pa_2600
Haha... US unemployment is still 3.7%. "Thousands of layoffs"- when the base is 167 million- is not significant.
Wut???
🤔
The biggest impact of the real estate bust is all the Chinese subjects who have seen their life savings evaporate.
Homelessness is a less of a problem due to the glut of houses. Biden might want to consider moving the San Francisco homeless people there.
China solve the homeless issue for the world. All we need to do is have a 1 way trip to send all homeless from every country to China for permanent residency...
房地产泡沫破裂最大的好处是未来所有中国人不再需要倾尽所有去买房。
The stock market is not the economy!
This trend of investing in physical assets started with SE Asia and later moved on to the Gulf, where sporadic investments were made into real estate sectors, sparking the geospatial led investment planning revolution.
Later, other economies tried to catch up, but, we saw how excess supply can lead to shareholder value destruction.
It's fine. Nothing to see here.
一切正在走向数字化……SWFTcoin、XRP、XLM、XDC、HBAR、ALGO、BITcoin 和 VeChain……The world is going digital soon
China's 40 year turnaround story is being discussed by the West as a miracle. Would China flounder because of a property problem which in many ways is intentional to keep property prices down? China has seen the flaws of high property prices in Hong Kong and Singapore and would not let this to happen in China, leading to fake economic growth but real hardship to the average citizens. Economic growth led by inflating property prices and stock prices is an economy on steroid. Not real growth.
America's 1% economic growth was hailed as rock solid by western analysts. And this is coupled with a 5% inflation which would make the American economy super rock solid. And the same group of analysts dismissed China's 5% growth as a collapsing economy, even when inflation is nearly zero in China.
What would the same analysts describe India's 6% growth? Collapsing faster than China or super solid like America's 1% growth?
China is maturing economy while US is matured ..US grew 3.3% last quarter despite many 'analyst' predicted a recession... annual used growth of 2.1% is good...January jobs figure was stellar to say least...same is not about China.. china's market there is outflow of cash...and hude debt Isreal estate sector......China is said to slow more
You believe Biden's 3.3% when US is sanctioning n cutting trades with so many countries, when Boeing n Apple are not selling well? Any fake growth came from a stock market fed with steroids.
China in debt? It's reserves are more than $3 trillion.
US no debt? Heard of $34 trillion n growing rapidly?
You believe US economy grew by 3.3% when it was reported that it was heading towards recession?@@TheKumbakonam
@@redbeansg it beat all recession expectation by analyst may be you are in parallel universe where Russia is a economic superpower he he....US economy is resilent
You are living in Hollywood or Bollywood?@@TheKumbakonam
Economic investigator Frank G Melbourne Australia is following this informative content cheers Frank 😊
A catch 23! A new one :D
China still imports the most petrol in the world, a good evidence that China economic is still well.
it's become very dependent on other countries for energy, thats true
Capitalism always delivers misery!!
Evergrand is not worth 2 bricks from great wall of China.😂😂😂.
Delusional woman 😂
🎉🎉🎉Congratulations 🎉
It's gonna be worse than Japan. I have no idea what china she is looking at. Maybe she's still financially exposed😹
Maybe you are just dumb
Same get reflected to other countries soon and entire financial system will collapse which will lead to new financial system
Like the new financial system we got after 2008?
It cannot be worst for China as the Chinese had endured and encountered economic hardship before that no one can imagined.
The Chinese government already has a lot of policies on these issues, which have been implemented in many cities. Are you still here yelling, "No, it's going down"?
The reason why China is collapsing is because Germany and Europe demographic is collapsing.
Wrong. Europe's birthrate is terrible, yes, but it's demographic steady because their population is supplemented by a huge immigration intake from Africa and Asia. China has one of the worst immigration intake in the world and also has one of the largest exodus of national citizens in the world. Europe brings in over 3 million LEGAL immigrants then there are millions that flood in illegally per year.
Not true.
Yes, the birthrate in all developed and most large nations is at a rate that doesn't support population stability and on its own will result in a shrinking population. But, that ignores the fact that China is setting all sorts of records for a declining birthrate, latest reported is 1.2/couple. Most developed nations are about 1.6 and to maintain a stable population number about 2.1 is needed.
china is the oldest country on earth (median age)
@@tonysu8860 Sorry, Tony what happen for local Chinese governments to get more funding from the Central Government in Beijng would routinely over count the amount children in their class rooms.
@@tonysu8860 The Central Government of Beijing say they over counted by about 100 million Chinese below the age of 40 years old. You now declining fasters then the Jews that were being killed off in Holocaust during World War II.
You do not know Chinese, their economy will come back strongly
Dream on "little Pink"
The population is dropping 😢
Sir, I wanna tell you something about Myanmar police. Today 14 Myanmar police came to Bangladesh. If you investigate it will be helpful for Rohingya.
China 5% growth is collapsing! US 2.1% growth is resilience.
If you ask western economists , China economy always in trouble , always collapsing it already said for almost 20 years now. CHINA JUST KEEP GOING AND KEEP GROWING , THAT WHY CHINA CAN SPENT 10 TRILLION DOLLAR ON BRI DEVELOPMENT FOR 20 YEARS AND WILL DEVELOPE MORE IN FUTURE.
Delulu
SSsshhhhh...don't wake them. They're having such a sweet dream.@@Ex.zed.