Modi Government is Abusing the Law, Hurting the Poor by Targeting NGOs, Social Movements
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 чер 2024
- In this episode of Central Hall, Kapil Sibal speaks to Harsh Mander, Colin Gonsalves, and Rahul Narayan on the weaponisation of laws like the FCRA to target institutions and individuals who have dedicated their lives to helping India’s poor.
Join The Wire's UA-cam membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters, and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews
In the darkest hours of democracy 😮😮
A profoundly insightful, and interrogative discussion augmented with intellectual depth and facts which illustrate the trials, tribulations and challenges faced by NGOs in New India where they are being looked upon with suspicion, suffer trepidation and vilified.
A great video with good explanations.
Mr. Sibal among the other interviews or discussions that you had on this platform, this stands out, unique and so pertinent, but sadly not noticed even by the intelligentsia. Thnk you
Kapil sir, you taken a real discussion on Indian rural condition, appreciate to shown kind heart towards poor and needy society.
Good to see you bhaiya 🤗
Grateful to you sir for exposing the truth. It shows your sensitiveness to towards the poor and marginalized.
Insightful... Thank you sirs...
Now internet banking is available you can transfer money from anywhere.So what is the proplem accont with SBI.. only frud ngo have problem.
Too much control through one Bank
Excellent and relevant interview Mr Kapil. Continue your good work.
Excellent insightful conversation.
New job started to Blame India and Indian😅
Blaming Modi is not blaming India ....Samjhe , andh bhakt ? 🤣@@devimishra1780
Kapil your new role of penal discussion on very important public issues is really appreciated. One suggestion is if you do or translate such discussions in Hindi also masses will be enlightened
Successive governments have tried to enforce Hindi language to prevent citizens from understanding human values from a worldwide perspective. Very sad 😢
we need it in all regional languages of the country. not just this issue but anything related to our country and its well being needs to be spread.
Great conversation which gives clear message but not palatable to those with rabid disposition
Does people with rabid disposition include the rabid dogs ? (Jest Kiddin')
Yes, you just keep barking!!
Tamilnadu nuclear power plant agitation, Naramada bachao abhijan etc are examples.
What examples?
@@pipipupu5104Anti-Development
Very nice discussion. I have learnt many things from this discussion
Many NGOs which we’re doing good work in Southern states had to go back lock stock and barrel because of revoking of FCRA licenses…. They don’t do good and they don’t let others do ….. this has been from ancient times… as per mythology also people ensured that even Bhagwan Ram also punished people of lower caste’s if they attempted to educate themselves…. Im proud that one School boys association whom I’m aware of took over a special children home from Norwegian NGO before moving back lock stock and barrel … they were involved in helping almost 5000 tribal people who were poor ….in Andhra Pradesh….the courts have equally played the role of catalyst by being mute …. Our corporation s run trusts in their family names primarily to divert the CSR funds … and make ground for entering politics and readily have yes men for spreading their views…. Fairness word is not there in the dictionary of the present system….
where did Uget the junk..of bhagwan ram punishing lower caste..
@@stallionspirit1576 good question!!! Read various versions of Stories of Shambuka killed by Bhagwan Ram ….
@@superjrao7161 uttara khand..was an extrapolation..it is not part of the original valmiki ramayan...so read it as a story...not a fact..hello??...
..agar lalu, hemant, kejriwal, mulayam, Stalin, udhav Thackeray's ,Azam Khan, mukthar ansari, yakub memon jaise gareeb parivar ke liye hi case ladte hai hmare panelists..nahi toh foreign funded NGo ke liye case ladte hai Jo conversion aur urban naxal ko finance karti hai😅
Koi bhi kuch bhi bata dega, tu maan jayega?
@@burgerbobbelcher aacha 10 saal me kaun saa case sibal nahi lada jiska Maine naam liya hai ... Jab jankari nahi hai toh bich me bola mat karo...pura list ginaa dunga kaun saa case yeh log lada hai aur kiska case lada hai including subramanian swamy ka bhi case sibal abhi laad raha hai
@@kumarrishabh9574 Gina na. Specifically, share evidence of NGO's forcibly converting people or promoting naxalism. If you have none, shut up.
@@burgerbobbelcher toh ngo ki itni faat kyun Rahi hai audit karwane me ...kaun saa kaam karte hai garibo ka Ghar bana de rahe hai?? Paani supply kar rahe hai ?? Road bana Rahi hai ? Kaun super speciality hospital khol kar rakhi hai ngo ne jaha pe free ilaaz ho raha hai ? Kaun sii ngo school khol Rahi hai ?? Aur Jo ngo yeh sab kaam karti hai unko government khud fund deti hai toh ..alaag se foreign funding ka paisa kya karti hai NGO ... Foreign funding ka paisa ka hisaab Dene me kyun faat Rahi hai Ngo ka... Aur bhaiii sunnn local news paper padha kar ..pata chal jayega ki conversion ka ground reality...lutygen aur eliteism ka editorial padhega toh kabhi real India nahi delh payega
@@kumarrishabh9574Audit karwane mein adani ki bhi fategi. Audit ka matlab janta hai? Jab puri power unke haath main hai, koi excuse leke jail bhej rahe hain. Chutiya banaya jaa raha hai tum bhakton ko.
Appreciate Kapil Sir for conducting this rich conversation ❤
Excellent discussion
FCRA should bring some yr ago
The conversation is moto Of these so called NGO😢
Abuse of Law must be challenged in the courts of law
Rahul Gandhi talk about disintegration of India abroad. You lie.!
Colin Gonsalves' Human Right Law Network was getting funds from Sacandinavian countries who by law levy tax to fund Christian organisations.
Public Interest Litigation in the hands of foreign funded NGOs and mass movements seeded by them created an ecosystem to create anti Hindu and anti Indian State activities, supporting msoists, Kashmiri, Naga, Tamil etc ethnic separatists.
The Wire, owned by Siddharth Vardarajan an US national is itself has conflict of interest and its funding was itself ultravires to foreign ownership of media back then when the portal was first set up during UPA regime and later Congress govt altered rules for increasing permissible limit of foreign ownership of media.
Though Modi govt do not want to directly antagonise USA, which is actually the ultimate controller of Christian missionaries and NGOs which are used by deep state of USA as its foreign policy tools to destabilise or control host societies through Total Cultural War. This hesitancy of Modi Govt is the reason that the Wires is still alive but definately hemmed.
Very interesting discussion which is touching Indian masses and deep poverty in India.
An absurd law against humanity.
Nothing wrong in MPs giving info to the Home ministry about their programs abroad but only thing we need to think about is how to defend the rights of the MPs if the Home ministry abuses its power by denying a genuine trip which has no harm to the country. Finally we should never forget the great peom of Tagore mentioned by Shri.Harsh Mander. That is the spirit with which India needs to go forward into the future and hopefully Oneday my country will become that heaven of freedom. Thank you..!!🙏💐🙌
Ngo’s can approach govt and ask for facilities who will extend facilities as they are doing of free ration, water housing etc. Only we don’t need resources from the likes of George Sorus funding for all other activities then true welfare!
Very good conversation. I liked his recitation of Rabindranath Thakur s poem at the end which is very relevant today.
Which NGO stop .
Who is working against INDIA
Kapil Sbal on The Wire..
Ths means The Wire was always a Congress Funded Media..
Wonderful people
Mr. Sibal,
I have been watching your programmes with keen interest. We all know about the problems that we face.. Politicuan have let down people. There is no hope from Constiution either. Then what is the solution. How can we rescue people from miseries. I have no hope in the elections. I am amazed how and on what basis people choose their representatives.
Please through a light on this. Thank you.
Yes, NGOs are important in social service sphere, but every action should be transparent, because of the conversion mafia. These conversion mafia after converting the innocent people again leave them to their fate.
Just like we are demanding transparency for election bonds, what's wrong if NGOs are also transparent regarding their donors?
Same rules should apply to every organization.
I feel these kind of discussion should happen in Hindi so that it reaches the Hindi Heartland if we have to bring any meaningful political change
Also in Marathi, Kannada, Bengali, Gujarati, Tamil.
sahi kahaa...fraud NGO logon ki baatein...sabko pataa lagni chahiye..lol
Why not ban all Foreign contribution including political parties, all religious activities
@@tobiasjulian becoz NGOs..already have a history of working against the nation!
The problem is adherence to legal provisions,what a ridiculous stand.
Why should anyone abroad give us money here unless they have an axe to grind?
Then why is the BJP taking money from foreign shell companies electoral bond.
Karni aur kathani mein bohut farak . Why don't kapil Sibil donate his huge accumulated wealth to the poor of this country.
Marvelous, superb, out of the blue, courageous and above all the ability to work against tremendous pressure has been your hall mark. Please continue with this outstanding videos. Thank you very much for the whole bench of 'THE WIRE'
❤A civil discourse
I think this discussion group has blinders on, either intentionally or perhaps unknowingly. I would rather think it is intentional because they are smart people.
The question is not what the NGO wants to do on paper but actually what is the real unsaid interest of these very rich church groups are. Using poverty and dire economic status of the poorest of the poor to proselytize has gone on too long and to the detriment of the core interests of the people.
There is clear obvious malintention of these church and Islamic based NGO groups. We absolutely need a strict oversight of their activities and allow them to work with honest intent and not with ulterior motives exploiting extreme poverty.
Let this group honestly say that these NGOs and their parent funding church or Islamic group really work for alleviating poverty or in fermenting Problems and religious dissent.
Please explain how the whole of NEastern India have all converted away from their cultural roots to Christianity. It’s all due to church and their proselytizing missionary zeal.
The atmosphere of the country is stifling to say the least.
God bless u good samaritan.🙌🙌🙌
Liars(lawyers) make lot of money . Whether they win or lose the case .
What’s happened to Nidhi Razdan? I personally felt that the team comprising Kapil Ji and Nidhi brought a freshness to the program and the topics were well chosen.
Wishing you all the best for the future 👏🏽
We know Manishankar ayyers daughter NGO
Whe she can not give audit report
They are not NGOs but fronts for nefarious activities like the Wire.
There used to be films and books documenting poorty of India, and winning accolades and prizes elsewhere. Kapil Sibal is doing something similar. He does only Modi bashing.
❤❤❤
It is an excellent, rich discussion but shows a depressing situation in India.
the depressing situation..eliminated extreme poverty in india...
@@stallionspirit1576 really… we did not know this important statistics. BTW reliable media gives another story… but good if India is more richer and prosperous and educated and has better choices at grass root level. Am all for it..this is what govts are chosen for not for making temples or churches or mosques.. 😀😀😀
@@rachnagupta8346 if you dont know..google..itz easier than listening to wire liar..lol
@@rachnagupta8346 itz temples..dat made india..the richest (35-40% of world GDP) by miles...for thousands of years...u have no idea!
50% (@Bottom of the food chin):Its is not 7 cr, it is 723 cr
People lost mostly confidence in the judiciary
Foreign contribution is for Political party's and not for the poor.😅😂
Iam going to vote bjp after this discussion
Yes right
See how corporations behaved when Russia Ukraine conflict started…
Modi ne inki kya halat kar di kabhi patrakaar bante Hain kabhi NGO chalane layak chhod Diya ek samay tha Kapil sibal Puri supreme court chalate the Sarkar ke sath milkar😂😮
Apko desh ki aur wahan ke pichade logon ki barbadi pe hassi aa rahi haain?
80 Crores poor Indian are getting free Ration for last 3 years and still continuing.
This number is more than total populaton of whole Europe.
I wonder how a pastor working for children hostels, runs to various countries including Nepal and very rich, if he is not skimming funds.
As the saying goes with respect to these guys: The dogs howl but the (Modi) caravan marches on.
Very useful conversation. But the most disturbing thing that I gather from the learned participants is that aggreived people these days don't have that much faith in the juduciary as it used to have a decde or so back for redressal.
yes sandeshkhali incident tells that
क्या सेटिंग कर जो वकील लगातार मुकदमा जीत कर मुकदमा जीत कर भरी पैसा कमा रहे थे अब वो सब नही कर पा रहे है। मोदी को गाली दे रहे है।?
Conversion mafia...
There is not even over conviction.Its a false narrative.
Harsh Mandher says , quote " ... in history, will be written as the most cruel period of mankind, due to the sheer level of hunger and malnutrition "... unquote ... the period he is referring to is the 60 years of Khangress party in power since 1947 ... !! ... the same political party and Khandaan for which Kapil Sibal worked for most of his life ... !! ... The Khangress party and the Nakli-Gandhi Khandaan is a Curse, a Cancer on the people of India since 1947 ... !!
Harsh Mander ❤
Congress Janata ke mudde tabhi uthati hai jab vah vipaksh mein rahti hai 60 varshon Tak soi hui thi kya ham Bhagwan se Kamna karte hain Congress sadaiv vipaksh mein hi rahe tabhi Janata ke mudde uthate rahenge
NGOs are there to make money for themselves
What an echo-chamber ! People who have been ministers, members of the highest policy making bodies and Supreme Court lawyers minting obscene fees, grieving about the marginalized! And they talk as if they don't have any accountability...only others.
The Hindi speaking belt psychologically look at the English speaking educated citizens as something that represents the British and colonisation. This is mainly because we Indians always put down people not knowing English and vernacular speaking are looked down upon. No wonder they have revolted and BJP has taken advantage of this .
You know your position
Retraction of Aadhar Card and GST is enough to bring back the scaling up of India to pre 2014 level. The joke is not that -that for recieving a ₹100 is required to go through so called KYC but ₹10, 00,00000 electoral bond illegitimate dealing with political party and the facilitator (here it is SBI) is on record clueless about the same as prayed to the honourable SCI!
But please find solution
Sir you should conduct these interactions in Hindi
Also in Punjabi, Tamil, Bengali, Gujarati and Kannada.
Ask all these to declared their asset , these are the people fighting for decades for poor and trible are in same conditions but they get rich..😂
Aakar Patel should also have been included. Anyway, very informative episode!
👍
Kapil good show keep it up
Court fixer ki practice bandh hone vali hai isi lie youtuber ban ne ja Raha hai
As a couple, my partner and I were donating money to one global NGO called World Vision which carried out some charity work in India. We were sponsoring education of a girl child called Laxmi from Rajasthan for good 4 years. Then one day all of a sudden we got assigned another child in Africa. Over the years we had developed a bond with the child in India. Although we had not met her in person, we saw it as way of giving back to our country. Upon investigation we were told that some FCRA rules were changed and it was becoming difficut to get money into India. We were very disappointed. I can only imagine how disappointing it must have been for Laxmi and her family. She had access to good education and probably nutritious meal but her chance at all of this was taken away by this government. Although our dontation is still going to a girl child, and she too is a sweet kid but the government should not engage into all this red tape. I am very dissapointed the Supreme courts have held up the governments point of view. And if they permit political dontations by foriegn organizations then they should permit donations in this case too.
Ghanta ,,, u were only aiding conversion
trustable story bro
@@deec2564 I honestly dont care if you believe me or not.. Just letting you know.
NGO wala mudda itna jyada important hai aur iski kisi channel pr baat nahi hui. Sarkar ne badnam kr ke NGO yehan se bahar nikal di. wo jo kaam krti thi uski keemat koi normal middle class wala smajh hi nahi skta, aur Jinke liye wo kaam krte the wo section ki awaaz kahin kisi platform pr nahi ha, Sarkar bhi kuch nahi krti unke liye aur jo kr rahe the unko rok dia, Isse kiska bhlaa hua pta nahi
All 4 are great criminals, talking about poor sitting in a AC room with wearing high level brand clothing and after million dollars dinner 😢
Kapil sir keep atleast 5 prodigies ready.
Look at our railways. From where they were they have come to this sorry state. They have reduced the no of second class coaches. They are concentrating only on vande bharat and high end trains,where the price tag is high. How will the poor yravel? By bullock carts? This country has already become a country for the rich. The rich are with b.j.p exactly because of this. We want a welfare state,socialism and justice. Kick this govt out in this election. The one percent can go to hell.
🎉🎉🎉🙏👍
It's all about supporting govt
If pro govt no cancelling license
Else face to cancellation causing harms to people
Funding coming to NGOs from abroad should be stopped. This is a threat to the integrity and sovereignty of the country.
Even after listening to this conversation, your opinion would have altered.
@@rahuljadhav5599 😂😂 lmao
But the foreign funding given to political parties is okay?
@@ashishvlogs7680 political parties are not involved in relogious conversion unlike the people in the video.
@@pipipupu5104Congress tmc etc are conversion pro parties
Dear Panel … you are discussing mindset… lot of affluent class people have similar mindset…. And they are the actual fund mobilizer for this system
Nice meaningful discussion.
Charity starts from home, please donate 25% of your total worth to poor and needy , stooges of foreign cabal will be INCARCENETED in June 2024 and Sabki KURKI HOGI
Please don't shoot the messenger.Agreed he has his flaws. But what about the facts discussed . Needs a lot of search for data.
@@tobiasjulian bhai kya facts hai ngo the to kya kaam kiya gareebo ke liye ngo ese bahut se bane hai jisme money laundering bhi ho rahi thi uska kya bhai 😮
Foreign fundings are used to break Inda too.People running NGO is becoming rich but people are still the same as such the government must take action on the money coming to convert Hindus to Islam or Christianity.You must show how are you changing life of people.
Why have the NGO's over the last 75 years of their operations , not been able to rid the country of all the ills that they are talking about. They have only converted the religion of these marginalized people and built churches , while they still continue in abject poverty. So what is the use of having these NGO's
these NGOs...are all wolves ..in sheepz clothing!
Government of India is also trying but unable to solve for all citizens.
Many Districts Collector depend on NGO for extending Govt schemes nhsrcindia.org/sites/default/files/2021-07/Guideline%20for%20NGO%20Involvement%20under%20NHM.pdf
Wohi to bhai natieeza kya hai in ngos ka bhai ek kaam karke government ko ngos banane chahiye or government registration ngos hone chahiye fcra license ke Saath Taaki kli fraud na ho 😊
hi kapil ji , political parties getting funds from off shore companies via electoral bonds , but NGOs cant , why not ?? it is RSS policy to stop foreign funds .
Hindi me vartalap karo to aap ki sari baat pure desh ko samajh ayegi or vote bhi ayegi.
He should also converse in Punjabi, Marathi, Tamil, Kannada, and Bengali.
How is all this relevant today when 80 crore ppl are getting free rations and 50 crore are getting 5lac free insurance?
#Islamophobia in India
That's Quranophobia 😂😂😂
EX-MUSLIM SAHIL ❤
Now no one is gonna buy that peaceful narrative.😂
Wer the money come from to NGO is it use for betterment ment for people give the clarification to government declaration is ther
If it s doing for negative perpouse then government should stop this give the audit reports
Wud have been nice if they got a person with an opposing point of view as well. Just shows a one sided view that we cannot be sure of
How is it abusing the law ?
They are choosen by India to create and enforce the law.
Political parties get elected by the people, NGOs are just weapons of missionaries and enemy country.
Election se pahle har haal me electoral bond ka details aana chahiye warna koi fayda nhi 🙏
Strength of Democracy is not in the power of opposition but in the strengthening of the human rights, freedoms and dignity which is lacking in India especially for the poor and this problem is acute for the dalits and the minorities now.
Also religion and conversion is a personal matter of the people. I think this accusations of false conversions will stop if the pastors give baptism to only those who give their consent in writing. Also whether to become a Christian should be a matter of choice rather than forcing people to believe in Christ. After all it's one's own choice to decide for themselves if they want to accept Jesus as the only way for salvation or to fall into judgement by Him.
Aren't RSS and Hindutva organizations threatening the sovereignty and integrity of India by targeting the minorities in India or by branding them as foreigners? Moreover aren't these organizations funded by the NRIs from abroad? So even these foreign funds must be stopped by the Supreme Court or allow funds for all. This is a sheer misguided judgement by the SC.
Absolutely true sir 💯 full power to you all lovely people out there 🙏 keep rocking this planet ✌️👍👌🤘👊🌀💗💫🕊️✨
Such an important topic with the learned minds garnered only 21K views . It should be seen by in millions
Please translate in Hindi for larger audiences
Great conversation
Correction needed on 10:01. He might have misspoken about the bottom 50%.
Mr Kapil Sibal you are forgetting what your party's yuvraj use to do while visiting abroad and that mani iyer too🤷♂️ why arent you quoting them?