Orthopedic Surgeon Says Vodka Bottle Could Have Caused Johnny Depp's Injury
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 тра 2022
- An orthopedic surgeon on Johnny Depp's team testified that a vodka bottle thrown at Depp could have caused his finger injury. Depp's orthopedic surgeon also described Depp's finger injury to the jury.
#JohnnyDepp #AmberHeard #LawAndCrime
Listen to Law&Crime's Sidebar Podcast on Apple & Spotify:
Apple: apple.co/3wMgRgB
Spotify: spoti.fi/3wITe7b
Written Coverage & Analysis of Johnny Depp & Amber Heard Trial:
lawandcrime.com/?s=Johnny+Depp
lawandcrime.com/?s=Amber+Heard
Sign Up For Law&Crime's Daily Newsletter! bit.ly/LawandCrimeNewsletter
Watch Law&Crime Network NOW on UA-camTV!
tv.ua-cam.com/users/welcome?...
OTHER WAYS TO WATCH LAW&CRIME NETWORK IN YOUR AREA:
lawandcrime.com/where-to-watch/
READ MORE GREAT ARTICLES FROM LAW&CRIME NETWORK HERE:
lawandcrime.com
LAW&CRIME NETWORK SOCIAL MEDIA:
Instagram: / lawandcrime
Twitter: / lawcrimenetwork
Facebook: / lawandcrime
Twitch: / lawandcrimenetwork
TikTok: / lawandcrime
LAW&CRIME NETWORK PODCASTS: lawandcrime.com/podcasts/
SUBSCRIBE TO ALL OF LAW&CRIME NETWORK UA-cam CHANNELS:
Main Channel: / @lawandcrime
Channel B: / @lawandcrimeshorts
Channel C: / @lawandcrimetrials
Channel D / @lawandcrimebodycam - Розваги
If you notice, all of AH legal teams witnesses are erratic, not clear on their answers, contradictory and very unstable. Even their body language is aggressive. All of JD legal teams witnesses are much more clear, concise, stable and to the point. Body language is kind and engaging. You are the company you keep.
right !
Elaine literally just lost her thoughts and can't find her notes so yeah their brain must be in scrambles maybe something to do with their client :O
Yes, every human being is somehow the company one keeps...
Your vibe attracts your tribe . True it is.
yesssssss😉
When a REAL doctor speaks. A professional
Exactly.... Dr. Curry or Curie was great too.
@@ahmadhafeez7945 yes, she as well. On JD's side, all professionals and class.
now THIS is a professional and EXPERT witness. This man should get praise for his in-depth honest and educated analysis.
This Doctor explained this very well, he was precise, got into detail as how a glass bottle would cut off tip of a finger. Very well done, a big win on that for Depp.
he is the most doctorly looking and sounding surgeon
He is very experienced and professional...
Look at his posture, he looks so comfortable... Like it is another day on his office, explaining their injury to his clients... Dang, that's professionalism.
COULD HAVE CAUSED dumnnuts
he admitted many times that he cut himself up
@@maaz322 and what about the other dude ??
who does this FOR A LIVING
he said there was no way and there is not enough evidence to support such a claim
plus the fact that he never originally said anything about amber cutting him
@@derick3482 But he didn't tho....
All of Johnny’s witnesses are so professional
This Orthopedic surgeon is competent, concise, well spoken, comfortable with his findings. This guy is Truthful. JD knows how to pick good people.
yes he knows what he is talking about, having studied a lot of radiology what he says makes sense
It’s not like he knows how to pick good people. It’s just easy to defend someone who is saying the truth. It’s really hard to defend heard because she is lying
@@22478180 lying* but I agree with u
Jd didn't pick him dude
I think it’s more the fact that it’s easy to sound genuine and talk concisely when you are telling the truth.
As a doctor, this sounds a lot more legit than the other testimony. His use of medical terminology is more accurate too.
W
As a "Doctor" it's not likely you'd use "legit" as an adjective.
@@myname9337 why wouldn’t they? legit is just a shorter word for legitimate, and was used correctly in this sentence
@@myname9337 I didn't know doctors aren't allowed to use the same words everyone else does online - a non professional setting
See how this doctor explained everything and answered all the questions whatever asked for him..Good job Sir👏👏
This is what's called a good doctor and not one of those quacks for hire that will say anything for an easy payday.
AH lawyers set the bar very low for selecting expert doctors. 😒🤯🤢
JD lawyers soared over that low set bar to exponential and universal proportions. 🌟 🪐 💫 🌎 🌞 ⭐️ 💫
God is with Johnny's team and witnesses. Abba Jesus,
Amen ❤️🙏
@@Anonymous-we4eu true. That's why her witnesses just make fool of themselves.
Just being honest
You can see Johnny reliving that terrible day as the doctor is speaking. He looks down and seems to be disconnected from the courtroom. That makes it so much more real in my eyes. It's really sad to see
Ambers Witnesses: A circus
Johnnys Witnesses: clearly professionals who understand they're in an actual f*cking courtroom
No i have a doubt
Johnny depp had a witness who was vaping on the court call aswell as driving 😂 but yes most of his witnesses are professional
@@coolkidm8414 ah f*ck. I can't lie, I honestly forgot all about the vaping witness. Okay, yeah, got me there, my bad 🤣🤣🤣
True
Depp is a dodgey i don't believe him one bit hope amber wins this case and get 100 million
She's literally on tape admitting she assaulted him. How is she not under criminal investigation?
So are you gonna say this exact same thing under every video?
Because that is court not your House
@@DaiNaSuo lol i wanted to say the same thing xdd
@@DaiNaSuo they’ve been doing it the past month pretty much, The same exact statements. I think it’s a bot. Just report it as spam
OK Team Depp BOT thanks for that!
Honestly I've always believed the story about the vodka bottle causing the injured finger because no one would EVER jump to a vodka bottle being thrown at them to explain that type of injury if they were lying. It's so dang bizarre that it HAS to be true. No one would make that up! It's such an unnecessarily complicated way to lie about a cut/broken finger when there are simpler ways to explain it.
Such a bizarre story to make up.
I love the fact that Johnny's team hires straight professionals, and don't worry about the costs in order to get them here. Everyone of them has been very intelligent and definitely knows exactly what they are talking about
Really he.. it also caught my attention as well it is like a fresh wind (or how do you say it in english) after all the nonsense we heard from team heard 🙈 all that negativity
Remember Johnny raised like 10/15 people for a big part of his life, money has no meaning to him, except that if he has it he uses it for good help only & that’s amazing from him. I’m sure he doesn’t mind paying billions to have him prove his innocence.
The fact that an expert has to explain to a jury that you can’t get lacerations and partial fractures on a finger tip by punching something is laughable I hope these people on the jury aren’t idiots
Unfortunately they are. They are not educated in the least notice how kamala Harris rhe vp follows AH on Instagram.
I saw a video where an attorney who witnessed the trial at first hand explained how the jury was feeling at certain points, and he described them as not interested in AH at all, like they weren't buying any of what she was selling. A video on the channel: The Behavioral Arts
Mikuel Walters Do you mean “can’t” ?
@@smtwd6839 exactly
@@smtwd6839 yeah my bad lol
As a nurse I agree with THIS Doctor's impression of the accident.
As a lonely middle aged man I concur!
No one cares, you’re not an ortho.
@@TheBLGL savage!
@@TheBLGL Aww how Trolley of you. :0
@@richardgoss4777 Good on you. I'm sure Amber is available.
the one thing i have noticed, and im sure im not alone, nearly all of Ambers key witnesses have been combative, dismissive, rude, ignorant and alot of the time proven completely wrong by Johhnys witnesses who have for the most part been calm, collected, not rude in any way nor have they been combative... speaks volumes to be honest
100%
I am a former orthopedic rn of 40 years -His explanation of cause of injury is right on
Amber’s story literally makes no sense, how does the tip of your finger come off by crushing a landline? Sure, you definitely could break it but the tip of your finger for sure wouldn’t come off. You don’t have to be a doctor to figure that one out😭
You probably could actually… but the injury to the flesh of the fingertip would be like a smashed pumpkin, not a slice. It seems obvious to me now that the fractures were from the impact and the sliced tip was from glass. Therefore a glass bottle makes a lot of sense. It’s got the weight and the sharpness to create that injury.
So awful that he has to relive this moment again. 😢
If you did smash your finger tip off with the phone against a wall (probably soft drywall), you would have to do it with one clean blow because you would not be able to hold a tissue after doing that because you would be in so much pain. Secondly, the chance of you just injuring just the one finger tip and nothing else using that much force would be a medical miracle (I would have bought a lottery ticket after that if I was Johnny). Thirdly, there would be a lot of damage to the wall and phone after which I did not see in any of the evidence photos. This still would not explain the precise, small fractures and clean lacerations to the tip of just one finger. All of ambers stories have more holes than a screen door.
Even hearing that right away one starts to figure the differences in the bottle and landline, the landline doesn’t make sense with the pictures of his finger. Like isn’t it it obvious! These people are a joke!
My husband dropped a washing machine on his finger and didn’t break the skin.
@@GirdsHerStrength my dads left hand middle finger tip past the knuckle but just to the nail bed was smashed off at work when machinery framework came unsecure while he was doing maintenance. The bone was split or shattered in a sense. The flesh was I guess you would say squeezed off like when kneading and dividing dough . Coworkers tried to find the finger tip to no avail. The surgeon pulled the remaining tissue around the remaining bone, the partial nailbed was then located on the rounded tip of his finger providing some protection. But he says it still hurts constantly and that happened over 40 years ago. So I had no problem believing JD story.
If I caused another person such a horrific injury I would feel terrible and would try to avoid discussing it at all costs... Amber seems to really enjoy going over the fine details of the pain she inflicted...I swear she gets a kick out of it ..like shes so tough! She must feel powerful in a sick way.... It's shocking... Evil evil eviillll woman...
She smiles proudly, very frequently when her viciousness is being described and it’s downright creepy.
She’s a filthy disgusting liar 🤥!!!
She definitely needs some mental help
She’s an Unhinged Narcissist. My ex never apologized for the injuries he caused me. I have a 3 inch titanium plate attached to 3 vertebrae in my neck. It was always MY fault he hit and punched me.
@@BeegirlsHoneyHouse She is proud of her handiwork. She loves to relive the high she got from her attacking Johnny. Thank god he got away from her when he did. I’m being very serious.
Yes, this doctor finally said exactly what I was going to say. A heavy crushing blow (heavy vodka bottle), followed by the shattering bottle lacerating the flesh.
Give this woman a beer... thank you!
The weight of the bottle and the fact of it being a crush injury would be enough to cause the comminuted fracture and the soft tissue damage. At the same time as Dr Gilbert said, the bottle broke in part because of the force and because it hit the marble bar. It would break into bigger pieces rather than splinters because bottle glass is of necessity thicker. That's why there are no pieces in the flesh but on the floor
Yes. Exactly!
Ó the pain
Aturd forgot science, eyewitnesses and common sense will prove her wrong.
She said "I just want him to leave me alone" but she's the one that started all of this, johnny didn't want to bring it out in the public he begged her not to. She is delusional.
💯
Which also contradicts All the MANY TIMES we’ve listened (and watched) her BEGGING HIM TO STAY. BEGGING HIM NOT TO WALK AWAY OR LEAVE.
She is a relentless and unremorseful LIAR.
I think it's funny she said that all she wants is for him to leave her alone...she forgot to say....and 100 million dollars.
@@reneaaragon7886 right 🤣 she's a 🤡
The good sis really thought a few years of throwing that coked-out community coochie & was worth her walking away with multiple LA penthouses, cars & 50k in monthly expenses (10k specifically for clothes & entertainment AKA drugs) until whenever. 🤦🏾♀️ Funny thing is, had she used some acting skills instead of gaslighting techniques, he most likely would've taken care of her financially. She was sloppy, greedy & vengeful. Period.
The fact that this finger incident can be argued but the evidence backing that Amber admitted to doing it and apologized for it, can’t be submitted is ridiculous.
100%
Why wasn’t it allowed?
@@amy109 I saw another comment that said it was because one of the people in the recording passed away.
Hold on, what? She did admit to that? Is that true?
@@Wissle yes, she practically did because she was trying to apologize and say didn't mean to.
so many lies, i can’t imagine talking to that woman let alone living with her, i would lose my mind and she’d be smirking and laughing through it all
And probably spending all your money
Probably why Johnny worked so much. Only time he was safe is when he was away without her.
And recording it.
For what it's worth I think outstanding and gifted people like Johnny channel emotion in their art, a beautiful blend of love, humour, joy, sadness and so much more. They have an amazing emotional range. I think ink that renders them very open and makes them very vulnerable to manipulation and exploitation
@@nelle9118 well that bits obscene really isn't it.
This doctor's testimony is just *chef kiss* can we talk about how this doctor is very calm, clear, and eloquent. Whereas the "doctor"(s) that Amber got was chaotic and unclear and unstable and really unprofessional.
Most of JD's team experts were calm. They are very professional and competent and they don't have to lie to provide reasonable testimony so that adds up. AH's experts are fraud so they are very agitated and defensive when they talk, there's the difference.
@@shindehoshi4470
Truth 😘
yeah, when you just tell the truth there's no stress to explain the situation. When you create a lie tho, it's in fact so stressful, that you need to make up something and be consistent to your 'imaginary' story, in which AH's team lack of.
Why did Rottenborn get away with saying that Amber didn't claim to know how Johnny's finger got injured? She clearly testified that "while he was smashing the phone, Johnny severely injured his finger, cutting off the top of it."
"Tell the world, Johnny, tell them, 'Johnny Depp, I, a man, I'm a victim too of domestic violence'. And see how many people believe or side with you" ...
I have a feeling that statement will be used by Johnny's team in closing arguments
This case should have been closed after they heard her say that!!!
I believe you Johnny.
Tell the world? Malicious compliance engaged.
You go johnny
Her legal team is grabbing to every little straw they can at this point now . The funny thing is that makes them look more and more disrespectful and rude.
It does. Like they’re flailing.
It makes them look desperate
🙌🙌🙌 yes they are desperate at this point
Why did Rottenborn get away with saying that Amber didn't claim to know how Johnny's finger got injured? She clearly testified that "while he was smashing the phone, Johnny severely injured his finger, cutting off the top of it."
lol
This doctor is extremely well known in NY and he and his partner actually repaired the hand of a microsurgeon who was their mentor after he had a particularly grisly and career ending accident.
Dr Gilbert actually performed two different finger surgeries on me on two separate unrelated instances. He is excellent. Impeccable.
Ok yeah we believe YOU 😒
@@DensilGrant What?? 😂
@@DensilGrant ?
Thank you; I appreciate learning more, take care👍🏽🇺🇸💙⚖️🌎
I have a rising suspicion that he's dr strange
I love at 7:30 after the ortho surgeon says “ulnar aspect of the finger” you see JD looking at his hand making a mental note of the proper anatomical terminology lol
More than Justice, we want healing
We want both.
Lock her up!! For lying under oath
@@lidibethcruz5850 bruh amber doesn't need to go to jail come on that's too much I mean she didn't do it because she just wanted to or anything she's just mentally unstable what she needs isn't jail but be admitted to the asylum I would be worried for the innocent ppl who r in jail for being falsy accused at the hand of injustice to be with her , at least in the asylum she's already tagged as a psychopath 🤦🏻♀️
😘😍🤗
@@lidibethcruz5850 I sure wish when the verdict has been read the judge will turn around and charge Amber with perjury!
I highly respect the competence of this Orthopedic Surgeon. Based on his wide medical practice/experience, his testimony is above-board. Details are scientifically accurate; never used any irrelevant words; not leaving any chance or doubts in his competency in his special field. His description on the difference between a cut caused by a glass and another object is definitive and precise. Only an experienced and competent doctor can give such an undisputable observation. Wish all doctors are like him.
Orthopedic surgeons are pretty smart it's a competitive specialty and he looks aged as well probably the more senior position
I'm surprised we didn't hear the infamous '15 minuted of fame' line
The video ended before AH's cross-examination began. However, now that Morgan Tremaine has demonstrated a way to respond, Elaine &co might be less keen on that question (though AH's team seem to have very little other than attacking the witness).
Best Wishes. ☮
Johnny looks fabulous!! 🤩 such a unique stylish man!
Good luck 🤞🏻🙏🏻 🍀 Johnny.
Mountains, mountains of evidence! What do you have to say, Amber? He cut his own finger after 10 MDMA pills and 20 lines of coke while hitting you with a bottle?
@@VR-vo2pv she admitted it?
@@VR-vo2pv she admitted it oinkster 😆
@@SuperFlashDelirium exactly!!
@@VR-vo2pv Stop spreading misinformation! Go listen the rake where she admits to cutting off his finger and how she didn’t mean to when Johnny confronts her about it!
Well the man is obviously an Olympic athlete
When a bottle is thrown and makes contact with another hard surface there’s no telling the pattern in which it’s gonna break and which piece of glass is gonna cut through the skin and at which angle. A bottle was thrown at a man, the man’s finger is cut and the bone fractured, there’s glass and drops of blood on the floor, a bloody tissue on the floor, why do we need experts to do the math??
Not to mention there’s audio recording in which multiple people discuss the injury, how it happened and Amber throwing a tantrum I didn’t mean to hurt him.
cause Johnny is a male victim. if it was Amber's finger that got cut, we wont be discussing this..
I’ve been waiting for all these exerts to just say that, when glass shatters there’s no telling which direction pieces will go..
The audio wasn't allowed.
there are multiple texts showing him saying that he cut his own finger...what is this magical world you people live in called?
@@andrabook8758 so you going with word play when you have all this other evidence? Im glad Im not living in your world. I also hope you never find yourself at the receiving end of a bottle that causes injury and then have to go around in circles having to prove it.
I hope that the jury notices the difference in quality between Johnny and Amber's expert testimonies. Every single on of Amber's experts comes off a biased, combative, and arrogant. And each time they are cross examined they give vague answers, refuse to admit the limits of their expert opinion, or are laboriously forced to walk back their claims. Meanwhile all of Johnny's experts are calm, professional, and to the point. They always have a clear explanation and evidence for their conclusions (notice how Johnny's team is submitted 90% of the demonstratives in the case). And they always handle cross way more confidently and without backing down on their claims.
And the quality of his lawyers
"You didn't get punched; you got hit. I'm sorry I hit you like this, but I did not punch you. I did not f---g deck you. I f---g was hitting you. I don't know what the motion of my actual hand was. But you're fine. I did not hurt you. I did not punch you. I was hitting you." -Amber Heard
"I use donate and pledge to mean the same thing even though no one else on the planet does" ~ Amber Heard
But on the stand she said she would never hurt Johnny and has never assaulted him. I wish Camille had stopped her right there and pulled up that recording again but she did a great job anyway
@ Treason University
wow!! I've recently started listening/watching this case. Did she really say that in a recording?? It makes absolutely no sense!!
@@estrellitavazquez3295 yup, she didn't know she was being recorded.
I once dropped a bottle on my foot. The bottle shattered and left a huge slice on the top of my foot. I remember thinking how weird it was that this bottle could almost bounce off my foot then the shattered pieces fly off but leave such a perfect single slice. It happens.
And did you find it bled a lot? I have had glass cuts to my feet and they bled profusely and made it very uncomfortable to walk for days. Her claim she was barefoot in glass doesn't add up to me as there is no blood evidence in the house and there's audio recording of her stomping around the next day (I don't think the jury have heard that though).
Actually glass cuts are usual very clean cuts unless the glass is very thin and shatters into small pieces and would leave a lot of small cuts on ur skin with some shattered pieces that will stick to the skin, and a thin glass wouldn't break ur bones or shatter them so that's obviously a thicker bigger glass. that's not something that only a doctor can determine, basically anyone with common sense can and I have studied RE in University which has nothing to do with medical studies yet AH brought an expert talking no sense shamelessly with his title on the line for her... I wonder how much he got paid to put his reputation on the line like that....
I live in Bavaria. At the beginning of the Pandemic lockdown I dropped a ceramic saucer on my foot. I use them to feed my cats. I never felt the cut to the top of my foot. I never felt or even noticed all the blood. I was too busy trying to get it cleaned up because I was frightened one of my cats would eat the food that had been on the saucer. My youngest son heard the crash and came down. He saw puddles of blood from each step I took. I had a 1 inch slice across the top of my foot. You could see the bone. I remember thinking. That is going to hurt. My son drove my to Emergency. There wasn't any ceramic in the slice but there had been ceramic all over the floor. I had 5 stitches inside and 5 stitches outside. Later that evening. I was right. It hurt.
@@dmarcouxbeatty374 Now that is really painful and traumatic. When I was a child we had this house brick that served as a door stop. Accidentally dropped it on my foot one day. Serious injury to big toe loads of comings and goings to the GP surgery. Very kind and gentle man. Toe survived.
Honestly the story of the vodka bottle being thrown at him and shattering and cutting off the tip of his finger is so bizarre that it HAS to be true. It would be WAY too complicated to invent that story on the spot just to explain an injury. No one would go to THAT much trouble to explain this injury away when there are much easier explanations to come up with on the fly.
"I didn't throw the bottle at him, I just sent a harmless glass object shaped like a bottle in a projectile to defend myself from him going to kill me with a minigun." Amber could've said that.
More believable then half the crap she’s come out with tbh
@@VR-vo2pv and Did you run around the house painting murals and nasty words to your beloved with your bloody finger?!
It was Johnny's fault because he put himself in the way of the bottle. That upset me because he made the bottle break
@@rudirestless Oh dear. Talk about blaming the victim. Very sharp comment.
I support Johnny Depp, that situation on the stairs was attempted murder.
Attempted murder by rainstorm to be precise
@@lukasjed5725 - I think she's meaning that AH's actions were 'attempted murder'. As she was the violent one - with both her sister and JD it seems.
@@lukasjed5725 he meant amber attacking johnny, not the incident with kate moss. Jennifer howell said that whitney told her, that shes afraid that amber was gonna kill johnny after that stairs incident (which was twisted by amber claiming it was johnny who went nuts) but they cant use this testimony because it will be objected as hearsay.
@@lukasjed5725 Scamber attacked Johnny on the stairs.
@@jicojicojic2083 yeah they couldn't use it in the testimony because it's all hearsay but I r ad that the declaration email she made to Whitney heard was deposed as evidence and the jury will have access to it
As an OTA hearing an orthopedic Dr. Speak about the injury so clearly and precise is satisfying n I can even come up with a good rehabilitation plan of care lol
Amber's team is making it easier their witness is proving Johnny was telling the truth.
so JD is missing glass fragments in his injury, but AH could walk on glass with bare feet with no issue. no surgical help with glass fragments stuck in her feet required. sure
She has super healing apparently.
Ugh i feel for Johnny. U tell he's feeling that injury and reliving it over and over.
It’s so hilarious to watch this trial knowing the truth; it is strangely entertaining
“You can close your eyes to the things you don't want to see, but you can't close your heart to the things you don't want to feel.”
- Johnny Depp
Exactly
JD needs to make a movie with this everything he shared about his childhood family and his life I hope his friends and family support him truly until the end
My guess would be he would like to put this ALL behind him.
A masterclass in how to legally review and diagnose cause of injury.
Everytime I hear or see anything about his finger it makes me cringe. That had to be EXTREMELY painful.. And not just that day but multiple surgeries after.
yeah i feel really bad the bro no joke
I can see, in my mind, exactly, how this injury occurred. Those vodka bottles are heavy, and the glass is thick in places. It could easily have done this. Denying it, is pure folly!
👍
This doctor was precise and explained it all well.
I have watched about 80% of the trial live and the rest recorded after the fact. I definitely feel that Depp's team has the more professional, level headed and truthful witnesses; without-a- doubt.
The way Johnny Depp described that he felt burning like pain afterwards matches that glass would have caused it.
And maybe vodka in the wound
@@sillylilysallykaye4917 that too I thought of that as well once he say that
Yes. Even I felt the same when I had a similar injury on my index finger caused by a falling bottle which was way smaller than a vodka bottle. It caused a sever laceration wound on the tip of my finger and yeah, even the bottle was shattered and no pieces of it found inside the wound. I can totally agree on what Mr Depp claims.
I had a freak accident when I was a kid with a perfume bottle slipping off my hand and when it hit the glass counter it exploded all over the store. Everyone was terrified, somehow my thumb was cut presumably a glass would have had to bounce back and cut it. It was deep but my nail was okay. There was no glass anywhere one me. Weird things can happen. They weren’t there.
*on
When Johnny described the feeling of the blood dripping I knew exactly what he was talking about. I thought water was dripping.
@@asseenonmiriam9601 exactly
You can edit comments on UA-cam. I just did (see the word edited) lol
Justice for Johnny. Healing for the both of them.
Ah has now claimed he slammed it in a door, punched something, did something with phone, and cut it off himself.
Jd - has maintained since day 1 about bottle incident exactly same story every time.
Real professional doctors - this could have only been caused like jd described
Why is this still being discussed???
"I didn't make him lose his finger, I just threw a bottle that flew against his finger and his finger happened to fall off."
Something that seems to get overlooked is how painful and upsetting this horrible injury must have been to JD. Bone was exposed. Fingers esp finger tips are highly sensitive. Must have been shocking and traumatic.
He really said there is no way to know definitively. He said it could have come from the bottle. Let's keep it to what is said as a whole. Justice for Johnny!
But he did say that it couldn't happen the way Amber said though.
something to learn here - if someone chucks a bottle of booze at you and cuts off your finger - time to leave that person
Nobody is talking about how callous one would have to be to continue to slam someone they supposedly love after they literally broke the tip of their finger in blind rage. She has something seriously wrong with her to have no remorse and just leave him alone.
100%
Narcism is an awful mental illness. No empathy, inability to tell the truth, self absorbed, no social graces, that is why they mirror people. Not to mention in Amber’s case she has multiple mental illnesses.
This was a great person. He actually helped him! Not some made up person . Either way we ALL HER THE RECORDING OF THAT NIGHT WHERE SHE IS SAYING SHE IS SORRY FOR HURTING HIM. ALL THE PEOPLE LOOKING OR THE FINGER TIP. HEARD IS A PSYCHOPATH .
I really dont understand what are the reasons or legal technicalities nobody can submit the recording where Amber admits she threw the bottle at Johnny for this trial.
Isn't that the one with more people on it that didn't consent to being recorded? Or was that a different one? There's a few that were left out due to various legal verification issues.
I believe it’s because someone in the video has passed on. I guess without consent, they can’t use it. I’m surprised they didn’t get consent from the family members? Maybe they tried and were denied
I believe people in recordings have to be present for testimony and cross or it’s “hearsay” as silly as that sounds w a recording.
Well, one person whose in it is dead and can’t testify about it, for one.
She got lucky
Honestly, this lawyer is very good with his sleek and smooth questioning
Johnny’s witnesses are so credible and professional !
I hate that he has to relieve this trauma. Poor man 😢❤️
I'm curious why team AH has remained silent on the 'gift' of the knife incident and didn't pursue it in the same repeat manner as everything else they get stuck on.....then again....
The best witness for last. Calm, measured, no emotion, factual, respectful.
I just came here to say that I have had a major laceration to the flesh on my right hand that was caused by glass and not one shard of glass was in my wound. My laceration was down to the bone on my right index finger knuckle.
Ejem...how did the attorney didn't noticed that the pictures taken by Amber in 2015 are not original when the expert testimony said that were taken with an Iphone X ... that didn't exist until 2017?
Can someone here contact Johnny legal team to expose this blatant FACT???
That's perjury by the supposed expert. Lying in court without consequences seems as easy as a Sunday morning...
Wow I saw at the other experts testimony it was IPhone 6 did they see that? The error?
@@rachelmartineau8102 Who cares what others said. This expert said that: Perjury.
Poor judge should jail half Amber's so called "experts" and herself...the jewish Psychiatrist of the other day should be at least banned from the profession after going against APA rules.
What king of country is the US???
im just flabbergasted in the stark differences in each persons experts and how they present and explain themselves.
I said elsewhere that it's almost like Amber's witnesses and "experts" are versions of her own personality.
# flabberglasted
This dr is to the point and uses very clear explainations...the other dr couldnt even reapind to questions this i a true expert who is just stating facts about the injury
As a woman, my heart goes out to Johnny, I wasn't a a fan of him, never watched any movies of him, but boy, after following this trial, I have huge respect for the man, he's an angel on this earth. I sincerely hope & pray 🙏 justice goes his way. Heard needs to be reprimanded & served her own justice for accusing Johnny in the wrong putting his good character & name in disrepute, charged for committing perjury in a court of law, which was plain to see with her different versions of events, as a woman I'm disgusted that another woman is capable of such a despicable act. God be with you Johnny 🙏 love, light & peace ❤️ xx
He's no Angel, very human with human flaws, but I don't think he's a wife beater
@@noodlebrains2689 I agree with you, but in comparison to Heard he is an Angel, no human being is perfect.
Kate Moss destroyed her whole testimony from the staircase in 3 minutes
If you have a piece of garlic and you wanna take off the skin quickly…you crush it against a hard surface with a blunt object. Resulting in the garlic being crushed and broken into pieces and the skin coming off.
7:07 the moment he looks at his fingers and inhales 🥺
Suport from Serbia...Gooo Johnny!!!
I really dislike Rottenbum, not just because he's Heard's attorney. He's a weasely, snarky, passive aggressive person. He's like the office snake that nobody likes. Only an opinion 😀
Just like her
Agreed..
Great username
I feel so triggered when I listen to him.
Fingers can move independently when holding to any surface. At the time of the impact one never knows which finger will suffer the damage. It dependes on the position of the fingers on the time on the impact. It’s a matter of split seconds.
Thank you Dr. Gilbert for your very truthful and professional explanation. All this review opens so many emotional boxes for Johnny and my heart goes to him! ❤️
Excellent and very clear!! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Team Depp is always on point. 🙂 Not bumbling idiots claiming to be experts.
This doctor did a very good job of respectfully and concisely rebutting the other doctor on the finger issue. Both of the doctors were credible, but Heard's doctor went a little too far in claiming that he could definitively rule out the vodka bottle possibility.
Never mind all these possible theory of Jonny's finger injury. Amber was caught on audio tape about the finger accident, she was talking to Dr Kipper and Johnny's bodyguards and telling them how sorry she was about the accident. They can assume all they want., but audio tape do not lie!
She a woman so they have to investigate more if she was a man it would have been a different story she would have already been in jail 🤷🏾♂️
Yes we know that, but the jury doesn't get to hear that 😢
@@njtaperchick1 that is the problem. Hope he get the justice he deserve and hope AH need to face the fact she needs help.
Very well explained..
Very good quality testimony from this surgeon. My compliments.
Anyone ever jam a finger catching a football? Imagine jamming a finger with a glass vodka bottle. The injury can happen as johhny described. The glass broke on impact and severed his finger
At this moment we are not sure what the jury is thinking , as an audience we judge what we want to ,what we feel to ,but as jury ,what they believe is imp and what they fell is imp.
They also technically don't have permission to view some of what we can as several recordings were left out of evidence due to people on them not giving consent to be recorded in a private setting.
I stumbled on a youtube channel 'The Behavioral Arts' where the body language analyst interviewed a lawyer who was actually in the courtroom as an audience. His observation of the jury as AH was testifying was very interesting. Also explained why AH keeps looking at the jury.
@@shorea27 when u say that ,what do u think that wud be ? Do u think JD will.lose ? In the end she is way to confident
Indeed we are watching thinking the same judging by the comments. However we are not sat as a jury 🙄
@@Vincent_Beers court is not purely a private event, As per the first ammendment, the general public and press have the right to be in the courtroom. The courthouse it’s self is public property, as it belongs to the municipality/state.
Thank you Doc
For clarifying finger injury
🙂👍
His finger was found in the bar, glass and vodka bottle, and blood found in the bar. Safe to say Johnny's testimony and recollection of events collaborates with the evidence and location of the incident.
Amber has so many GAPING holes in her "story" but to me this is a HUGE one .. to her team a vodka bottle could not have injured his finger without doing any damage to the top of it while according to amber JD Smashed a phone to " smithereens " and his hand as shown in that hospital pic had no bruises or damage to his knuckles or bones !! I mean wth lmao 🤣 😂
Even with gaping holes she might win this, in today criminals and liars always win. Honest people don't win.
@@cindyrussell1581 If she wins it's more likely because defamation is EXTREMELY hard to win when celebrities are involved.
If this was a criminal trial, she'd be screwed but it's not. I think that's the real reason he and his team fought for it to be broadcast. He knows winning is a long shot the way defamation law works but he got the truth put out there for everyone to see and I think that was his primary goal in the first place.
@@JoeyisDREADful I agree, I think it's going to be a hung jury,
I had to laugh when the term “smithereens” was used in the courtroom.
throughout this hearing it seems that this relationship was highly emotional ..he sustand actual injury💯
Amber: Johnny tried to kill Kate Moss
Kate: Johnny literally took care of me after I was hurt
She was literally caught in the act of defamation in her own court testimony.
I’m going to miss these two crazy cats when this trial ends tomorrow.
The situation looks like many others in the world. Other people don't have money to protect themselves ! God bless You
u too
Why does another expert witness for AH, appear to be off chops on ‘whatever’ meds? Money can buy an expert witness, but it can’t buy believability
Brilliant and clear explanation!!
I like the honesty reply of last direct question 13:45. Unless you are there directly witness the time of injury, no one would know. It is only the testimony of the injured person that is viable.
Poor Johnny looking at the tip of his finger. Missing it. 6:22
Amber is a very troubled woman both emotionally and mentally. She simply needs help. After this case is over, I hope she can get the help she needs.
This orthopedic surgeon explained his understanding of the finger injury so clearly and logically!!! He's very right that the bone shattering has more likely to do with a glass bottle exploding on impact! Feels like Amber did throw it at Johnny... That would be horrible of her
I like the way the questions were asked(kudos) and how the surgeon sounds like he could be a professor in his spare time.