Unraveling gifted minds | Sameena Manasawala | TEDxPune

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 19 сер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 37

  • @user-bl1sp2qm5u
    @user-bl1sp2qm5u 5 років тому +55

    "Intelligent but had the emotional sensitivity of a five y old. " this sentence describes so much that I felt she was talking specifically about me.

  • @johng6639
    @johng6639 2 роки тому +13

    The worst experience is when your teacher accuses you of cheating to the point of making you cry just because her own mind limitations. Well, you, as a gifted individual, will never forget such event.

    • @AP-oy5ff
      @AP-oy5ff Рік тому +1

      I was challenged in school for cheating in homework, but I fighted back.

  • @bluberrykush3912
    @bluberrykush3912 6 років тому +29

    It is so true that we need to Start teaching every Student to find and develop their unique strengths in stead of cutting off those who doesn't fit in. So many potentially great minds never unfold because they where told they aren't gold if they don't fit in

    • @Hello-zw5xo
      @Hello-zw5xo 2 роки тому +2

      Good point however it comes at the cost of formative reform which people in government offices find uncomfortable and hard to micro-manage, if it acted formalistic it is different.

  • @hauntedshadowslegacy2826
    @hauntedshadowslegacy2826 6 років тому +52

    In one year of Elementary school, I got in trouble for filling out the first few pages of the workbook within a few minutes of receiving it. In another year of Elementary school, I was told 'parasol' wasn't a word even though I knew better. Eventually, I was identified as a gifted individual. The best two years of my life followed, filled with great field trips and unique opportunities. But after elementary school, it was as if giftedness 'wasn't a thing'. I was no longer the special one in class whom the teachers knew they could rely on to help with the other kids. I was no longer the one who was allowed free time to read what I wanted to. Instead, I was the troublemaker kid. I was the 'smart, but just doesn't show it' kid. I was at the end of my rope.
    It took two years after dropping out of that torturer's funhouse that is high school to find out the true source of my struggles. The American education system is an extremely anti-gifted environment. Only the lucky few of us who have supportive parents make it through. And even then, it's typically through alternative or non-traditional schooling.

    • @JJ-kb4ry
      @JJ-kb4ry 5 років тому +5

      HauntedShadowsLegacy it’s not just America. I feel your pain. I felt your pain.

    • @satsukynolife4094
      @satsukynolife4094 4 роки тому +4

      Greetings from Belgium
      It feels like we all go through the same thing

    • @LandonAshworthDirects
      @LandonAshworthDirects 4 роки тому +2

      Wacha doin now?

    • @Andrei-yv8fz
      @Andrei-yv8fz 4 роки тому +9

      This has also been my experience. However, I didn't drop out of high school because I still believed that University would paradise. That turned out to be false. I've spent my entire life trying to find a path that accommodates both my intelligence and invisible physical disabilities. Right now, I'm dropping out of med school after 2.5 years due to boredom, frustration, a complete disregard for ethics by my peers and professors, not to mention the preference of personal biases over science-based thinking. One of the most important things I've learned is that everyone hates the person who actually thinks and comes up with the right answer. The world is full of people who, in all honesty, just want to feel good about themselves, whether or not they're actually doing good. Frustration is the best word for my experience. I miss the gifted program from elementary school.

    • @Hello-zw5xo
      @Hello-zw5xo 2 роки тому +2

      @@JJ-kb4ry Western Europa has less emphasis on enforced mass-education which does slightly help, and less tricks up their sleeve to humiliate alternative thinking.

  • @shettypratik77
    @shettypratik77 5 років тому +4

    Brilliant speech I wish I was fortunate enough to have such a wonderful person in my life

  • @liyahhlii
    @liyahhlii 2 роки тому +2

    In grade school I would finish my work within minutes waiting for my classmates to catch up I often found myself bored and already aware of the knowledge they were trying to teach me, I thought it was a normal thing until I got myself in trouble on purpose one day and I got sent to detention. While I was there I was talking to my teacher and she started asking me a lot of questions & I was very happy to be talking to her because she seemed to understand me. After that day she called my mom and told me I should be put into a gifted class. I was like girl why do I need to be put in gifted & she just explained that my mind was very intelligent for a 7 year old. Even to this day I’m 19 people often mistaken me for being in my late 20’s based off of the way I talk and have wisdom. Still to this day I’m not sure as to how I became gifted but my mom even moved me to a different state to try to help train my mind and grow my giftedness. I played sports played instruments learned a different language, etc. but I still never found what I loved to do until I turned 18 and started doing UA-cam

    • @liyahhlii
      @liyahhlii 2 роки тому +1

      I also struggle with being in the real world. I’ve worked jobs with older people who often times looked down on me due to my age, but was very shocked of how fast I caught on to things that they felt intimidated and has cost me a lot of jobs, I can’t help it though I don’t know how to be “normal”

    • @Hello-zw5xo
      @Hello-zw5xo 2 роки тому +1

      Little bit touching, most canny orientated; desk-ed in front of un-cogitating knowledge gets bored eventually, suggestively terming it was not your intellectual age category: could have been build on by placing progressive fluency in your school system, you also indicate misplacement of environment: agonized by increase in Intel. which is common, it's story as interpreted as is; UA-cam is more suited on punchy elements of stories, wish you the best and good luck trying to make the best out of expelling conditions.

  • @mb7626
    @mb7626 3 роки тому +2

    I've been unravelling my gifted mind since my 20s

  • @victoriaryan23
    @victoriaryan23 2 роки тому +1

    Thank you for posting.

  • @Dan-ud8hz
    @Dan-ud8hz 4 роки тому +21

    "I am convinced there is only one way to eliminate these grave evils, namely through the establishment of a socialist economy, accompanied by an educational system which would be oriented toward social goals."
    (Albert Einstein)

    • @Dan-ud8hz
      @Dan-ud8hz 3 роки тому +3

      @julialeite63 Let's weigh mathematical credibility:
      One of the most brilliant physicists who's ever lived, or some whiny anonymous troll in a random UA-cam comment thread?

    • @asimian8500
      @asimian8500 2 роки тому +1

      No.

  • @paryanindoeur
    @paryanindoeur 3 роки тому +3

    Being "gifted" is like making a down payment on a house, then paying the mortgage for 30 years, and only *after* that you *_might_* be allowed to live in the house... but then again you might not. You have to pay either way, and there is no opting out.
    Unfortunately, my parents *never* accepted I was gifted, and still don't. There is some personality conflict there: they tend toward conformist thinking, and are terrified of being exceptional. (Probably an effect of 12 years of pre-Vatican II Catholic School education.) Also, I suspect some pathological attachment (being a first-born son) leading to infantilizing parenting and an unwillingness to allow my personal individuation. (And it does not apply to my siblings.)
    I paid a high price up front, and continue to pay for my differentness, and I have yet to find a way to make it work for me, outside university.

    • @Hello-zw5xo
      @Hello-zw5xo 2 роки тому +1

      That's hard, you've pointed out a common(differentiates somewhat per region) harsh lives exercise, really wish you the best, and hope there won't be pitfalls.

  • @satsukynolife4094
    @satsukynolife4094 4 роки тому +9

    3:57 - 4:05
    That's it,that's the story of my life
    That girl described my existence in a few words
    The things with gifted people is that so many people have this stereotype of the genius anime kid but in reality there are so many different types of gifted people.
    I met a bunch of them and we all look so similar and different at the same time
    Knowing that some gifted people are indeed little know it all with good grades,I really wish I was that type of gifted kid instead of an hyperactive mess who SHOULD BE STUDYING AT THE MOMENT INSTEAD OF WRITING THIS ALXKFKCOKZKCOZKPCVKALS
    ................
    ................
    .................
    ...................
    ................
    .................
    Yeah your just losing your time by reading this

  • @mmmghool
    @mmmghool 4 роки тому +3

    I was expecting her to bring up capitalism any second lol. great talk still

  • @stazang
    @stazang 5 років тому +7

    All children are talented its all about water them correctly @ the right season to get them to bloom. As long as they are born healthy there is no reason they can not be great.

    • @cherryRedStilettos
      @cherryRedStilettos 5 років тому +8

      correct... hoowever gifted brains are measurable different and work differently.

    • @wordart_guian
      @wordart_guian 5 років тому +7

      All kids might be talented but only 2% are gifted (gifted is a relatively rare neural condition that induces a more intense processing of information). And not every gifted kid is wealthy, they are everywhere.

    • @ninanickel3103
      @ninanickel3103 4 роки тому +1

      Brandi Law you are correct

  • @johntrapani1594
    @johntrapani1594 3 роки тому

    The piquant celery premenstrually desert because rice relatively call for a young lumber. reminiscent, careless child

  • @pizzaboynizza1
    @pizzaboynizza1 5 років тому +1

    I loved her speech...but those hips...multi-talented, lol. Luckily guy that’s catches her...don’t let her go!!!

    • @TheAlia1996
      @TheAlia1996 5 років тому +7

      Men can be such simpletons lmao

    • @nimisha6584
      @nimisha6584 3 роки тому +1

      Ew, stop sexualising people! How would you feel if someone said that to you with a leer?

    • @Hello-zw5xo
      @Hello-zw5xo 2 роки тому +1

      Funny and I agree however be little bit careful the impression is not always favorable.