What Happened to Minecraft Content
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 січ 2024
- UA-camrs used to earn money so that they could make videos, but now they make videos so that they can earn money
Minecraft content is unbearable.
In todays video I talk about the repetitive nature of Minecraft videos on UA-cam. Minecraft content used to be different and original depending on who you watch, but now it's all just 100 days, minecraft hardcore, and worse versions of Dream manhunts.
Songs used in order:
SNEAKO TYPE BEAT - KANYE WEST (not an official song)
Gusty Garden Theme - Super Mario Galaxy
Beginners Theme Suite - Rogerl Neills
Star Festival - Super Mario Galaxy
Beginners Theme Suite - Rogerl Neills (again)
Sweden - C418
Mice on Venus - C418
Sweden - C418 (again)
Irl shots were recorded on Sony a6400 with a 35mm prime lens - Ігри
taking off the paper bag when i pass mr beast in subscribers
Edit: this video is getting so much more attention than I could have ever expected. Thanks to everyone who comments and watches the video all the way through!
you have 500 subscribers and mr beast has only like 200m idk what the m means so you have to take it off now
blud idk how math works but i think you’ll make it before tomorrow
@@eugene_is9537m is for Million
My brother does videos that are like the old minecraft videos. His names @manofmenx
good job. keep it up!
It's sad what has become of not just Minecraft content, but much of the gaming side of UA-cam content in general.
I agree
hi shyguymask
I couldn’t agree more, it feels like no matter the space, the genre, or game, there is always going to be a formula people will make and follow. Minecraft is arguably one of the most extreme examples of this, but even for content like Halo, rust, other survival games, even TF2, there is that formula that people follow because it gets them views, even if they may want to make something different.
aren’t you the pvz guy?
@@Caffi_UK he was
then he got infected by the curse
Hardcore minecraft video starterpack:
- The guy inexplicably has full netherite tools and megastructures already built
- Title is either 100 DAYS IN X or I BUILT THE BIGGEST X IN MINECRAFT
- Subtitles change for every word (bonus if they vibrate around the screen a bit)
- Overly enthusiastic F5 intro
- Terrible one color skin with some smiley or channel name written on it asymmetrically
- Same 3 songs
- Every time they build something there's an edit with a few frames of every block being placed
- Fake discord friend reaction
- SHEEEEESH LEEEET'S GOOOOOO
You just described wunbaw lockdown life, carvs and probably more in a few examples 🤣. But you are right
You described every Minecraft UA-cam video nowadays
Also there is not a single picosecond where they don't speak
@@EepyPandi here's where I recommend my fav hardcore content youtuber, Eqlipse. Minimal subtitles, no fake friend reactions, good skin, no fake excitement, and the draw of his videos come from the difficulty of the mods he plays, not silly things like 'I built 100 netherite beacons in hardcore'
You forgot the part in I BUILT THE BIGGEST X IN MINECRAFT (it was in my hardcore world)
Dude this is exactly what I did last year. I was trying to make the same videos as everyone else because I wanted to make money, even though I said I didn't, I knew I did, I just wouldn't admit it to myself. From mid 2022 - mid 2023, I made one video because nothing was getting views and I didn't want to put in the time anymore, as I had been for years at that point ant saw nothing from it. Thats when I decided to just switch it all up and make videos I WANTED to make. I basically changed from doing the stale challenge video, to videos where I just chat with the viewer about a certain topic I want to speak on with Minecraft gameplay in the background. That was the best decision I ever made because I instantly started making more videos, but making them when I felt like it and it really took this pressure off me that I didn't even realize was there. Not to mention the fact that I got a lot more views and subs from these videos and still do when I upload. Imo, this happened because I wasn't competing with the highest Minecraft youtubers anymore, I wasn't TRYING to compete with anyone anymore really. Its been great to just take a step back and carve out my own little cave so to say that I can enjoy while everyone else is scrambling for crumbs basically. I enjoy the fruits of my labor, not in the form of money (yet) but in the form of likes and comments that I can reply too and have fun discussions with people who enjoy my content. Its great, and to anyone else, if you feel stuck making content, just take a step back, it might be the best choice you ever make!
On an underrated video, another underrated youtuber comments.
Success on UA-cam is correlated with establishing your own identity on the platform. If you try to imitate others, chances are you'll just get lost in the sea of cookie-cutter content. People who want the kind of content you make just end up watching a few of the thousands of other channels producing it. But if you make something that doesn't really appear anywhere else, your odds are a lot better because you'll have a much better chance of catching wandering viewers who are looking for that thing.
You earned a subscriber :)
This right here might as well give me the inspiration I need to write short stories and upload them as audiobooks here on UA-cam. Thanks!
Exactly, i think what you need to have fun doing youtube and grow is an identity that people can relate to or atleast get to know. If i watch X's 100days in Minecraft challenge, they tell me what they did in those 100 days kinda like a diary and afterwards Y's & Z's 100 days challenges do the same, they have no personality. One built a cooler base, one made a redstone contraption, but in the big picture it doesn't matter.
Imagine you are at a party talking to a dude and he only goes on and on about how he did that, and then he did that. You would just think "cool stuff" but you don't really get to know the person in a sense of what they like, what they dislike, what are their hobbies. This is what 100 days challenges are to me in comparison to the old let's plays.
In let's plays people needed to talk constantly so there wouldn't be many quiet spots in the video. Usually to fill that space they talked about stuff from their lives or gave opinions on certain matters, which made the videos more enjoyable. I watch a youtuber group which did a lot of minecraft content in the 2010's, adventure maps, smp and hardcore with 15min hardcut videos. In those 15 minutes they talked about a plethora of things, recent world events, game news, politics, anything that came to mind. And that made it more engaging.
Being different and having a personality kinda gets lost in all these videos.
UA-cam is truly just a reflection of why people say 'Minecraft isn't fun anymore.' As you demonstrated so well (great video, really underrated), Minecraft is a sandbox game, the one rule being they are no rules, and yet the community has made a set of rules for themselves that they so strictly follow.
Instead of rushing through the game to create the largest mega base, the most OP armor, just do what YOU want to do.
Explore the (kind of) amazing new updates, big or small, take your dog on an adventure, build and experiment, and create your own story.
Great video though, this is really well made, I wish you luck in the future!
Maybe it’s simply because either creativity is punished, or they weren’t ever / aren’t creative anymore.
@@fujinshuCreativity isn't punished. If it is, you wouldn't have seen channels like TrixyBlox, Lowresbones, Flowstate and a bunch of other awesome channels who are slowly but surely growing. Other formats are not completely obsolete too. I've seen Let's Play channels achieving 5 digit sub counts everyday. It's not that creativity is punished, it's that some formats are just significantly more rewarded. What we can do as a community is to watch and promote your favorite creators that you think deserve more recognition.
although it got shat on, dreamsmp’s style to write stories and make a whole new minecraft system (three lives then you become a ghost) was fun to see and even tho some of it is cringe and i dont watch them anymore yet i still look at the videos and the story as a whole with happiness and slight nostalgia. i wish people experimented with the system more like they did ( there might be old-school people that did that i forgot or just dont know bcuz i was raised with arabic-speaking mcyts not english ones :(.. )
Unfortunately that's how humans work. Always making rules, never fully free.
thats basically what 100 days videos used to be
I can’t believe I can say with confidence ‘back in my day there was no long-play we had multi season series to watch an episode every week’
Yeah I remember those times. Back in 2012 my tiny laptop couldn't run Minecraft so I had to use my brother's desktop PC but only had about an hour a day because of school, so when I wasn't playing or doing homework, I was watching a survival series or subscriber-made maps, it was so much fun.
That's why I stopped watching Jacksepticeye. Suddenly all his videos were an hour long
Unfortunately I think those times on UA-cam are both long past and still here. The issue is, those who try to incorporate the spirit of older content are buried under the massive influx of users on the site. Channels like your own are extremely well executed but are criminally under rated because the algorithm scoffs in their face. UA-cam itself is no longer about passion. The internet is not longer about passion. It’s a harsh but sad truth. Though even though content made with heart is burried, doesnt mean it is not there. Going on to the search options, and going to “newest upload” is a great way to still discover content of passion.
Yep, doing youtube as a career will no longer allow you to do what you want unfortunately most of the time. That because of the rise of youtube shorts and TikTok which lowered the attention span of most kids considerably making it pretty much borderline impossible to get good retention rate without over editing to the extreme to have a video reach thounsand of views easily because as soon as it gets past you own UA-cam viewers it will get buried so no opportunity for a career without going for metas.
So personally I run my channel like it was a small hidden cave on the sea of popular UA-cam videos and if anyone finds it they are free to join and experience an authentic UA-camr.
I grew my channel at first using trends like 100 days, but I saw most of my real growth when I used my own ideas. My mod videos were the first of their kind and I used simple editing and gave little to no incentive to watch until the end, yet they were extremely successful.
I think the real problem is people aren't creative enough, if you make something unique, original, and objectively entertaining, you will grow. and if you're not growing, keep innovating until you do- not by adding more subtitles or more intense music, but by inventing new ideas.
omg you have 0 shorts on your channel. that's a first
I don't like 100 days or hardcore videos, but I recently watched one where 3 people were all surviving together. Honestly, it was a breath of fresh air.
That sounds interesting, can you link that?
It's gonna be shit soon
@@Jekuma i think it's 100 hours hardcore
@@Jekumahere
ua-cam.com/video/dQw4w9WgXcQ/v-deo.htmlsi=C8t-PPT2gUeQWUWj
sounds like captainp33n (jardon, petezahut, xeen) but i might be wrong
When I watch smaller channels like yours, it brings me more channels to my recommended who actually care more about the quality compared to the quality and I haven’t seen 100days videos in my feed in months. It really is hard to find the people who has this same passion now but when you find that group you just keep finding more and more and it’s made me appreciate Minecraft more than ever
Same, I get recommend small Channels constantly, and its such good content. Its Like Im Part of a UA-cam Secret society
Please tell me some of these underground channels
@@TauTauofSkalga one I really like is gengarjuice69! He does beta 1.7.3 content and it’s really reminiscent of old-school Minecraft videos
@@TauTauofSkalga found out about RailgunMC. Im more like a survival player but their bedwars videos actually hit after a long day.
@@user-vt1ce8xv8o yeah Railgun is actually entertaining but his upload schedule is bad 😂
I think you might be seeing the forest for the trees. Countless UA-camrs are still uploading Minecraft videos they want to make, there’s far more Minecraft content that’s genuine and heartfelt and maintaining those nostalgic experiences that were popular on UA-camr 8+ years ago than there is Minecraft hardcore 100 day megabuld challenge content. It’s just damn near impossible to find it because the algorithm doesn’t want to show that content to you. The problem isn’t that creativity is dead, it’s that creativity is hidden. UA-cam only wants to show you what’s popular, and like it or not this is what’s popular, so this is what UA-cam’s going to promote and try to convince you Minecraft UA-cam’s become.
If you want to find that genuine and creative Minecraft content, maybe search for Minecraft and filter the results not by recommended, but by upload date. Watch some of the recent uploads, the ones with shitty thumbnails with 2 views. You’ll find what you’re looking for, and maybe watch enough of it and the algorithm will recognize that’s the side of Minecraft you want to see
theres literally only three kinds of minecraft videos on youtube now
1: hardcore 100 days
2: tutorials on how to make good looking/gigantic bases
3: redstone tutorials
The irony isn't lost on me with this video, how so many people these days are making videos like this, complaining about minecraft content's lack of originality.
Life is a cycle. One day the trend will shift, one day something else will be popular, and there'll be a new generation of people who miss the 100 day hardcore trend.
1:20 how to never stop being sad
omg i though the exact same i wondered if anyone commented that
this reminds me of a youtuber a love to watch called dallasmed65, he has a survival world that is nearly 10 years old and for some reason I just want to keep watching his videos. Unlike everyone else, he doesnt try to make all these giant projects, he just does what he likes and enjoys. Another thing that I like about him is that he doesnt use mending and doesnt exploit villagers and doesnt build these giant farms.
the real minecraft player
dallasmed65 is fr the best minecraft youtuber rn
The entirety of Minecraft content being 'stale' can be represented by looking at your channel's most recent videos:
1. You make a point in this video that Minecraft videos are constantly using the same topics over and over, and you encourage people to return to what makes them feel creatively empowered.
2. You have playthrough videos posted on your channel, I imagine you made these to feel creatively empowered. However, they don't really have any views, making UA-cam completely inoperable from a business standpoint. That's fine if that's your goal, but many people look to UA-cam as a dream career, and a career kinda has to make money. If you stop making money you stop being able to upload once life gets serious with a family. Then Minecraft content is almost exclusively reserved for people who have the most free time, aka kids and people in gap years.
3. You post this video, which ironically enough is a trend. There are many other Minecraft essay videos talking about the exact same things. You did a trend, got views, got subs, and then your next video you post reflects the same 'niche' as this video.
4. Welcome to the club! You are now doing the thing you talked about not wanting to see on UA-cam.
As a side note, I do also hope that we as creators can continue to evolve the niche and move past the current trends.
Bro watched one video of mine and thinks he knows everything about me 💀
@folivore The only opinion I gave about you was that you possibly posted older videos to feel creatively empowered, everything else was objective truth.
I hope you didn't misinterpret my comment as an insult, I never intended it to come off that way. I hope you continue to make innovative contributions the MCYT community!
I think that a major factor that comes into play here with this increasingly energetic editing and megalomaniacal concepts (I could not find a better term to use, I just mean that with every video the challenges grow more and more extreme) is the current "culture" on the internet, one that values quick, loud abd stimulating content. This cycle is caused by short attention spans, which causes others' attention spans to deteriorate even further. Also another thing to note is that the audience of these challenge videos are, let's be real, kids. And not all children can appreciate the finer details of a good minecraft video, they come here to entertain themselves and watch their favourite internet funny men scream through their microphones. And such content watched from a young age can undoubtedly have an impact on the development of a person.
But well, the question is, what can ya do?
The reason why short for content became so poppuler is because of its addictive nature , thats what made TikTok so poppuler and poisonus .
This is actually one of the reasons I really admire creators who make things like the Life Series- they follow trends like hardcore minecraft but they keep the individual passion and energy that builds fandoms. Fantastic video, dude, I’m looking forward to see you in my recommendations again :)
Yes, you can still be creative while make formulaic content. It's not as black and white as a lot of people think.
I really enjoyed this essay since it's something that I resonate a lot with. Although I think it unintentionally takes a hit at videos that DO have that substance you want to see revived in Minecraft content.
While there is so much to this game and what it has to offer on UA-cam, I wouldn't entirely blame the creators for doing what they have to in order to get seen. UA-cam as a platform thrives off of watch time, so without making unique or engaging content in any way, there is a very low chance for those videos to get "picked up" by any algorithm. I've seen some truly talented and insanely creative creators use trending ideas to their advantage and make some of the best videos ever.
Personally, I was able to find the fine line between "MrBeast-ification" and passion in my craft, which for most is kind of hard when UA-cam shoves numbers and Up/Down arrows in your face pretty much telling you that your video sucks or that you've struck gold and now you have to make that content forever. This is probably one of the biggest struggles for most creators and is why so many people are quitting their existing channels to find something else more fulfilling.
Also, I understand the struggle with not really seeing the content you like within Minecraft, but to be real UA-cam's "Don't Recommend Channel/Not Interested" buttons work like a charm. I've only really been getting suggested Minecraft video essays/Alpha Minecraft content ever since I started blocking out the videos I don't want to see. Minecraft is one of the largest genres on this platform as a whole, so there is definitely content to your liking out there, it's probably just hidden underneath a very poorly done title and thumbnail.
sorry for the yapping! this is a good video, I just think it's unfair to group such a large sum of creators and say their content is 'unauthentic' just because some people have non-aligning intentions with content creation... That being said, it's all Notch's fault for selling Minecraft to Microsoft.
the problem is the algorithm. You need a flashy thumbnail, people who watch for a while, people who come back, unique content that strays from trends is a high risk with a mediocre reward, people would rather not take that risk. why risk losing your job for lower views, even if it's for a close community. 500 loyal subs isn't paying the bill any more then 500,000 unloyal subs.
Ironically this is like the 20th video I've seen talking about this exact subject
There no way that this edited in such a good way video only got 77 views! (As of rn) I hope to see you grow in the future, and I agree with everything you’ve said in this video.
this was really enjoyable to watch, goodjob on making this
I love you pissnburg
I see a small, yet passionate guy whose really putting a lot of heart and care into the videos he creates. Really dig the editing style. Keep doing what your doing man, and hone your craft.
I've been feeling the same thing for a long while now. Ever since LukeTheNotable's hardcore videos and LifeSteal SMP videos, people have just been chasing the popularity and milking its views for as long as possible. There are very few that actually pour their heart and personality into their videos.
I've been making a vanilla series lately. It hardly gets any views at all, and when I see creators of various sizes create vanilla series which perform really well, it's hard not to let that affect me. This video nails how to not compare to others or be so desperate for views, because I daresay for most people who make UA-cam videos, it didn't start out of a desire for views, but out of a desire to be creative and make content you're proud of. That's how it is for me, anyway. This video is a great reminder of that ❤
This is a great video, it does feel like Minecraft YT content is getting narrower and narrower. I still have many creators (lots of hermits, mogswamp, etc) that I love for unique content, great personality, and real heart. So many thumbnails miss that, and so many videos just feel like clones.
This video made me reflect at how Minecraft UA-cam content became more saturated and repetitive, back then content was purely original from mod showcases and survival series even survival with mods, it wasn't just 100 days it was years of gameplay that possibly made thousands of childhoods and it's really sad seeing that Minecraft content nowadays are just the same but with different stuff, and it's not only long videos but also the shorts suffer from the same thing. This was a nice video, the best for you Folivove
This hit me right in the feels. This was so good. Thank you. I miss trying recrate stampys world on my xbox 360 or making hunger games maps with my friends. It was always a blast.
seriously, such a great video man. I think this feeling you have for the state of minecraft content is a shared one alot of people have and I think theres a shift happening right now for that content that feels like you're on a journey with someone just playing instead of finding whatever "strategy" there is to glue a viewer to the screen for those 10 minutes of meaningless content. People want real people
ive had these ideas of combining hardcore gameplay with 2d animations, ik hardcore is saturated but i still enjoy it alot. each episode will take a looong time cuz animating isnt easy and i got a bad habit of quitting everything so im kinda scared to start it. And on top of that i wanna spread my content to other games, do art content, and music stuff, but then my channel wouldnt rly have an ''identity'' and just be filled with random content. if i wanna do it i gotta think of a way to connect them all, n i have no clue.
anyways, luved the video, good editing and narrating. rare to find channels like this, subbed
Hardcore with animations would be super cool! I don’t think it’s necessarily a problem to do the same things as everyone else if you can find a genuinely unique twist like that to make your content special
this is honestly why i'm switching to being more of a general content kind of guy. im gonna make whatever i feel like but in my own unique style and with my humor implemented and my personality implemented. Whether its fortnite, minecraft, horror, etc it'll be whatever I play with my own style added onto it. I hate the new style (which I imitated because I felt it was the only way to success) and people should really start being unique. The little kids that watch them really don't care about the creator but rather that one specific video or the editing.
I really liked this video because of how true it is. I went down the rabbithole of content optimization, and it started to just be samey and they didn't really include my personality. I'm slowly trying to rid myself of "optimizing" content, and it's hard, but when people leave comments on my videos that I don't try to optimize, it feels so much better than reading a comment on my optimized ones.
you, my guy, are underrated. we’re all in the same page. same boat. it’s tiring to see these content farm, but that is UA-cam. That is UA-cam… I love how you transition, and then the gameplay, it’s really calming. The video is quick and straightforward. and your voice is soo calming !! keep it up man
Thanks for spreading the word, more people 100% need to hear this message. I think people tend to forget as well that Minecraft UA-camrs tend to set the trends on how people actually experience the game to. Consider Tekkit gaining popularity with the Yogscast Jaffa Factory series and so on. It's a bit upsetting after running servers over the last decade to see that players feel less confident with themselves over time with these massive youtubers building mega-bases with intense design schemes. It feels now standardized for how you should build and experience the game, impeding personal player creativity and in the end seeing less of that players personality come through what they build. I've seen many people now just flat out refuse to build or servers fill with what feels like a competition of UA-cam tutorial mega-bases. Rarely ever seeing people just building something simple and enjoying it anymore.
Thank you! I have been working on UA-cam videos for 5 years and make sure that I enjoy making my videos as much as my viewers enjoy watching them. This video also gave me the best idea ever for a Minecraft series.
I immediately click off a Minecraft video whenever I see those annoying subtitles going one word at a time. It's like having a text all in caps, bold and highlighted. So much visual overload, I can't stand it. I thought it was because I'm older (I'm 30), but I'm glad to see younger people have noticed that as well. The editing, the video ideas and thumbnails are so similar that you can't tell any of those channels apart and it's sad because I'm sure those people have talent and they would probably get a loyal following if they did their own thing. Excellent video and I hope your channel blows up.
I’ve been turning ideas over in my head basically trying to work out where the major trend of Minecraft content even goes from where it is now, so this vid was well timed. Where it is right now is clearly unsustainable, as seen by most of the Hermitcraft members getting burnt out in some way. I don’t think we will ever see the return of the 2012-14 LP style but I do think the next big Minecraft concept (think what LukeTheNotable did for MC content) will be much more lowkey.
Great video, the start reminds me of Sneako's old videos lmao
I don’t even make Minecraft videos anymore, but this video speaks to me. I often would get so stressed about my content and trying to find ways to make it trendy or similar to what everyone else is making that I fail to take the time to genuinely make content I enjoy making. Especially with how I’m trying to brand myself now, I know that not everyone one is going to like my content but I’m ok with that now. I just want to make the videos I want to make and when people love it, it means so much more because they’re liking something I’m also passionate about.
Hey Folivore, youve made some great points. Part of my strife with modern minecraft content is that many creators lose personality in exchange for "epic grand, eye catching stuff". Hopefully, we can see a resurgence in personality-based content instead of idea-based content.
My favourite minecraft youtber as a kid was a guy who just, talked about how to play minecraft.
It was kinda cool. Watching a guy much older than myself learn and discover the game, struggle with some of the same mechanics as me. And he had such a chill vibe, it was like hanging out with the grandfather I never really had as a kid.
Thank you for making this video! Minecraft just hasn't been the same for me and im glad more people are also feeling that. I myself fell for this style of editing, but I'm working my way out of it
Every so often there comes a video that really makes me want to make a new video. This is one of those videos. Amazing
What an incredible video. Just put everything I've been thinking of the mc youtube scene in 1 video. Subbed
This applies not just to minecraft videos but so many other aspects as well. Here's an example: A while back, an electronic music artist that goes by the alias Chime kicked off the popularity of a style of dubstep called color bass. Color bass is a style of dubstep that takes the non-melodic growls and wubs of dubstep and makes them sound colorful by giving them a melody. When this took off in popularity, it seemed like everyone and their mother was making color bass. Yes even me. It eventually got to the point where almost every single artist I listened to had at least one color bass song. Some artists even switched up their whole style entirely to focus on it. However, one thing felt wrong about it all. One of the most popular color bass songs, Rain by Papa Khan, started a trend of remixes of the song. This led to songs that were inspired by Rain, which inevitably led to every original color bass song sounding like a remix of Rain, just in a different key.
I've always missed the old style of minecraft lets plays and old mod reviews, they just seemed so genuine and driven by passion at the time. Seeing the lack of this today kinda makes me want to make these videos of my own, and like you said, keep that one person genuinely entertained.
Im glad someone finally made a video about this it gets painful the longer it goes on
This video is really well done! I think you covered that feeling of originality being lost on youtube. UA-camrs that I gotta say I have respect for are legacy UA-camrs like markiplier,Jacksepticye,Smosh (now that its back to skits) ,and Stampy. People doing things that are not quite as successful as they used to be but refuse to simply give in to the new meta for youtube still finding success. Mark especially is still constantly creating things like a movie,all the “with markiplier” shows that gave actual unique things that use youtube as a platform to express creativity. Its crazy how this aspect of creativity has been lost for the sake of repetitive bland,digestible content.
Damn. I'm not particularly money driven but, this video got me thinking. A lot of the people that inspire me never really saw the lime light, they were independent/underground yet have ride or die fans and become very influential. I find that more people in the underground scenes of music, tv and youtube are more talented than those at the very top.
Wow... I saw a video of yours quite a while back and I'm really glad you are getting some recognition! You deserve it!
i didn't even know you had less than 1k, great video bro. fr.
This was a really interesting watch
adding my own two cents in
As someone who has been a long time fan of mcrp content, and now even does work in that community
It really mirrors the overall minecraft community, there is less well crafted stories with soul like MyStreet, with almost tv levels of quality, it's %90 pure improv, but not the good kind, the kind with soul, it's very cashgrabby, it's less about making higher quality episodes, and more about getting more episodes out
Theres less unique ideas as well, it has to involve whats trendy, like skibidi toilet, garten of banban, or rainbow friends
I think martincitopants said it best in I think his BF4 QnA (he does release more original content but still) "you need to make good videos, when people click on your profile to see more from you they shouldn't be greeted by 1000 Minecraft let's play videos.
It was mainly about starting out as a youtuber, if you want to be successful you might not need the highest quality videos bit they need to have something. I think it's also a result of our lives moving ever faster, even though I don't touch TikTok I'm finding myself often unable to keep interest for things I used to watch hours of tutorials for
(while crouching rapidly, punching the air and bobbing head around) good job
good job, keep it up
(youtube has started to recommend smaller videos more)
Just passing by but I appreciate this video a lot. I think it permeates a lot of gaming. As someone on the grind themselves, I get the number chasing but we lose something along the way. I think as UA-cam continues to become an appealing career, more people come to the platform not to create art but to get paid so it feels inevitable. Hopefully though, the algorithm will continue to reward those viewers who do appreciate something different in the same way that your video ended up on my feed tonight. Keep making stuff that you like!
This is what it’s like for UA-cam I
I’m generally, there hardly any genuine UA-camrs anymore. Great video by the way
This video is so relaxing man. Changed my life, keep it up.
i’ve been watching paul sores jr old minecraft series lately. even though it’s a 40 year old monotone voice man slowly playing and explaining how to do the most trivial things in minecraft (at least nowadays) with a low quality mic, i still love it. it’s just a break from everything.
youtube videos can be a break from real life sometimes, but when they’re all the same and start popping up more and more, it’s no longer a break, it’s just something to keep the dopamine in your mind flowing.
when i watch his videos (often times later at night) it’s like everything good or bad that day just fades away and i become immersed with this 10 year old video. no 0 attention span editing, no canceling, no drama, no “i built the biggest XYZ in minecraft” just a block game
This is a great video and really captures the current landscape of minecraft content. I've been watching Etho for over 10 years and his style inspires so much of what I try to make. I've tried to play the youtube game, but ultimately just making the videos I enjoy that pay homage to the 2012 style of Minecraft is what makes me the happiest.
Nice video, the appreciation of less "optimized" videos really resonates with me
I want Let's Plays back. Just a good 20-40 minutes of mostly uncut content with minimal editing for jokes. I'm always looking for them with every game and I rarely find them.
Damn this really hits hard as someone who started playing Minecraft from 1.5. I miss watching content like Stampy for example where their just having fun experiencing the game, with no pressures. I think platforms like TikTok are to blame also, it’s shortens our attentions spans meaning UA-camrs turn to these crazy editing techniques to keep retention up. I think many of the community have been inspired by some of our elder UA-camrs to start channels, but this overwhelming pressure to replicate previous successes has led to this unhealthy competitiveness in the community. As a content creator myself, I simply want to create building videos cause I want to teach people how to build, it’s what I enjoy. If I earn money from it, it’s a nice bonus but it doesn’t rule my channel. Hoping the community will fix itself soon. :) Great video!
Very true. I think that this new style of hyper edited videos has really put people off even trying to make videos, because even making a simple Minecraft video requires a whole video effects team.
I recently watched a video made by some guy in the internet. Its just footage of him and his siblings/friends gameplay on a "corrupted old minecraft world".
Yet, even though it doesn't have any edits, or pretty quality, and stuff most minecraft videos have. It still manged to entertain me. More than those newer minecraft videos.
I like this video, the intro is able to show how jarring it is to go from creative content to algorithmic entertainment well. The video is able to go directly to the point without feeling forced or rushed for attention. I like how the video in the background is technically subway surfers brain-rot distraction, but it doesn't go all out, and shows how not everything has to be overblown for a engaging video. The video itself is able to remain short without feeling like its lacking information or that somebody's reading their rushed script as fast as possible for their video. I think that importantly the idea expressed about how creators should be able to be content with a small community because that is what is truly genuine is inspiring to a person like me. I hope that any videos that you post in the future will be as enjoyable as this one (please don't take this as stress to continuously improve when you don't really have to)!
One "critique" i have is that i wish you actually displayed the channel page for Ethoslab as a reference for what you were talking about for his content.
Thank you! this probably one of the best comments ive ever recieved on youtube. And yeah, the point about Etho is very valid.
Hey, new Minecraft UA-camr here who’s experience is actually a little different, I began by making a few jokey videos with me and my friends, and then branched out to a few other things. I have one particularly popular video of mine which is just me detailing my own experience in a certain mod pack and having that experience has been fantastic, I love making videos in my own style and focusing on music, sound and storytelling over too much over editing but I definitely see others do what I do with that style and get larger, lots of people want different types of Minecraft content, it’s just finding a means to break through ;). I love your style of content and never change for anyone
It's funny this shows up in my reccomendation feed. After a 4 year hiatus and disappointment with UA-cam, I got into things from the 90's again. Ended up making a 2 hour long Turok 2 special through sentiments simular to yours. It has 50 views, but that's okay.
Thanks for this man,
There's a reason hermitcraft is popular, I watch it for the creators and what they genuinely enjoy doing, and that's why I'll continue to be a loyal viewer.
Thank you so much for making this video! You really put my thoughts into words!! My favourite youtuber is ethoslab, so i entirely agree with what ur saying! Ive never been interested in 100 days videos or anything thats popular now. Im just a viewer, ive never had any interest in starting my own channel and the youtube minecraft is getting more and more boring... of course everywhere there will be youtubers who still have the passion, its sad the algorithm doesnt push it, too... i love finding smaller youtubers , who do something unique, when you feel there passion, it makes the content feel alive. i am a new sub. the editing on this vid was real nice, too, i hate the new style of overedited videos... i am glad to find this video and seieng the comments by the smaller youtubers, i will be checking out their channels too :)
I feel like this has been an issue with UA-cam in general lately and it's why I've mostly seen myself follow smaller channels, the big ones just feel boring and like a cheap copy of each other at this point. I mean I understand *why*, after all when UA-cam is a job you care less about creativity and more about actually surviving, but still it feels like almost any big channel is just running out of ideas at this point, the algorithm is and always has been brutal and changes without notice and massively, and a video you put work into not doing well can be stressful. All of that is to say I understand why It is the way it is but I just wish we got to see more creative content that isn't limited to small channels and audiences. Anyway though, love your style and great vid.
this is why i like creators like zeemyth
original content with special editing
great video for a small channel. i like the editing. keep going you're growing fast !
Another vid complaining about mc content without mention of newgen redstone youtubers lets gooooooooo redstone content we are gooooateeedd!!!!!
I do agree with what has been said.
Myself, was (and still am) in a situation where it is tempting to take notes of the "trends" and how they do their videos, back when I made my first video. Finding a style is very tricky.
However, I settled one where I received criticism from people saying it was a breath of fresh air, more align with the old Minecraft content, or original.
And what have I done? I poured my passion and personality into those videos. Sure it takes me time and effort, but I can say : Those videos I made? I am proud of the results.
I think it's one of the key to defeat the current mindset of Minecraft Content.
This 5-minute video is brilliant, and I completely agree! I'm not a content creator, but I am an avid viewer, and I find it hard to take joy in most Minecraft videos made anymore. I hope many people watch this and realize they may not even should, but they can change and decide to. It could be great.
THIS IS WHAT WE NEED MORE OF, PURE MINECRAFT CONTENT. NICE JOB. PLEASE, KEEP MAKING MORE.
I completely agree with this. I want to start making videos at some point in my life, and I would rather make videos that are unique and interesting, even if just one or two people actually enjoy them, than make videos that are exactly like what everyone else is doing that thousands of people watch. That's why I think Rekrap, Grian, Mumbo, and so many other great creators have content that is actually unique and enjoyable to watch.
I couldn't agree more, my channels are tiny compared to even you (You're doing great btw), but my goal is to be funny, entertaining or informative, not seeking out the veritable fountain of wealth that so many think they'll achieve because in the end I would hate making the same over produced rehashed ideas that everyone has done to death. Since I first fell into Minecraft UA-cam at the ripe old age of 7 in 2013 I wanted to make my own content, I was in awe of how creative of a medium making your own videos were and that awe grew seeing the way animations and story driven Minecraft series became fully fleshed out. Sometimes I feel like maybe I've become jaded or lost that sense of wonder, and while growing older does have the effect of the latter, it's also down to the way the landscape has changed. It's also no longer that same connected rabbit hole I was so used to, now you'd be hard pressed to get all the big creators in the same Discord call compared to when a skype, teamspeak, or xbox party chat sufficed. beyond that fans now are so ride or die on their favorite creators, even one small critique will get you blasted. All around I think what you and other smaller creators show is that underground little dogs are likely more real for lack of a better word than the big fish and hopefully soon that will change, I'm not holding my breath (Because let's be real I'll be more Oxygen starved than a Pufferfish), but if the algorithm ended Let's Plays maybe, just maybe some tweak will take us out of these dark ages and let original unique ideas thrive again, it wouldn't fix the fans and it wouldn't make every creator besties with each other, but it would make things feel fresh again instead of the same idea filling the trending page. TLDR: Sorry for the novel
great video man, i really hope this blows up soon.
this actually made me think, even though most of the minecraft videos i watch are mod reviews and modding videos as im a lot into mods, i do like to sometimes watch videos of the popular formats, but you deffinetly earned a sub from me, even though i dont really sub to anyone on the first video i see by them.
This is not only a great analysis on minecraft content (something I haven't cared for for half a decade now), but a beautiful thesis on how the obsession with the algorithm has made creators aware of the notion that they need to aim for the lowest common denominator, thus decreasing the overall quality of our content. You earned a sub!
I love that there is even double doors, most people arent using them or placing them in such way that mobs cant attack it, but we all missed its beauty, the simple creativity behind simple worlds.
Dude your underrated great video im subbing (before 1k quad )
It’s hard to find unique or laid back videos among the current meta.
I sit back and watch a few essay videos because they’re not rly obnoxious and sometimes respect me as another person instead of just a view count. While not all video essays are chill, if I avoid the ones about drama, then its typically not content farming videos.
It’s sad to see what youtube tiktok and twitch are when its just the be funny and loud challenge. I tend to stick to smaller people that are ok with their current state, because they dont have to try to be a content creator, they are just willing to be friends or have genuine discussion
I think civilization videos are a decent exception to this, if there's passion involved in them. Old minecraft videos used minecraft as a tool for creating instead of just a base game, which good civilization videos capture that feeling perfectly
THE HOW TO NEVER STOP BEING SAD REFERENCE AT THE BEGINNING WAS LIKE MUSIC TO MY EARS BRO 🙏🏼🙏🏼
real, it sucks to see not just minecraft content, but content generally has become so stale and repetitive and you articulated it pretty well. there used to be diversity and now everything feels formulaic and ironically, that fast paced style makes me click off faster lmao, also drains any creativity or ideas i've had and i'm sure i'm not the only one who's experienced that, it sucks.
That rollercoaster at 1:01 was from one if the guide books, if my memory doesn't fail me
That’s cray cray how you got 3 guys in suits to agree with you. Good video
Good job, keep it up! :)
This is why whenever i edit any video i play c418-alpha, and only make cuts, transitions, and mild subtitles
i agree honestly back then i used to watch alot of stampy and popMMo and i loved every piece of it but now its just "TRAPPING 100 WARDENS BEC MY FRIEND KILLED MY DOG" or something like that its just sad i wish we could go back
Wow you litterally made the exact type of video you said you wanted more of in the video good job
I started playing in 2011, and honestly, my motivation is at an all time low right now, and I am at a point where I am so burnt out that I cannot even build anything anymore. 100% agree with all of this. 100 Days, playing Beta 1.7.3, Can you do XYZ in hardcore, or those shitty UA-cam shorts or Instagram reels of a billion different builds that all look the same, add nothing new, I just can't watch it anymore. Gaming content is so ridiculously optimised and trimmed that it took away everything unique. It really is all the same.
Amazing video as always
Good job, keep it up.
okay
I rarely get suggested videos by small youtubers, yet typically they have the more unique ideas. People say 'content these days is all the same' and that's just not true, you're just looking in the wrong place.
Using myself as an example, I have almost 40 episodes of my own Minecraft series on my channel. I think it's a pretty unqiue idea, at least, I haven't seen anyone else do it. The videos rarely get above 30 views, let alone 20. My editing is mostly just cuts, some zoom and B&W, and I use background music from UA-cam. My builds are unimpressive and my thumbnails are not flashy. My videos are the kind of videos people say they don't see anymore; people say they want more of. I've kept up the series for over a year for my only 2 constant viewers, friends of mine. I just want to have fun.
I think what people really want when they say MC content sucks nows is for large creators to go back to their old style, their old content. You all know Stampy, DanTDM, SB737, all those guys, I grew up with them, and I'm sure some of you have as well. Now that times have changed, we crave that nostalgic feeling again. We don't want new UA-camrs, we want our old ones back. Or at least be want out new ones to be just like our old ones. Now, obviously the 100 days and hardcore stuff appeals to a lot of people because it's insanely popular. Personally I've never had any interest in it.
I'm not really sure where this comment is going, or if I've made any points. I don't think it matters because probably no one will read this. I'm just tired of people complaining that MC content is all the same now when it's not. I could be wrong though, this is just how I see it. Feel free to reply with your own thoughts.
This was all typed on phone so I'm sure there's a typo/mistake somewhere, so if you want, go ahead and type your * comment. Thanks and have a good day.
I'll check your channel out bud as a sorta creator myself I been showing off my minecraft map that is almost 10 years old over the last year and it's getting about 50 views or so not even trying to make money but I completely understand why it feels like good content is buried un 100 days I loved the og 100 days but now it's a overdone concept and it's boring
was that some beta minecraft i saw? o.o
anyways nice video! modern minecraft and the state of youtube are somewhat depressing, so its nice to take a step back. i certainly recommend most people take a step back and play some older, slower versions. it'll help you gain a different perspective on the game than what's pushed by most influencers. maybe you'll enjoy it more
Yo I love watching your 404 channel series
ive noticed a huge spike in beta minecraft content i think its making a comeback
I agree completely. Even good content creators such as Thomas Innit and Charles Slimecicle’s videos start off way too bombastically, with every inch of the video padded with fantastical music that overplays every moment of it all. Their videos feel like they don’t believe in themselves, like they’re trying too hard, and are scared that if they stop talking for even a second, people will stop watching, and the worst part is, they aren’t wrong.