Did Woman Run Over Husband with Truck and Let Him Die in Snowbank? | Lori Ann Phillips Case Analysis
Вставка
- Опубліковано 13 лис 2023
- This video answers the question: Can I analyze case of Lori Phillips?
Support Dr. Grande on Patreon: / drgrande
Subscribe to the Bella Grande Media Podcast: / @bellagrandemedia
Dr. Grande’s book Harm Reduction:
www.amazon.com/Harm-Reduction...
Dr. Grande's book Psychology of Notorious Serial Killers: www.amazon.com/Psychology-Not...
Check out Dr. Grande’s merchandise at: teespring.com/stores/dr-grand...
References:
caselaw.findlaw.com/court/wi-...
www.courttv.com/news/wi-v-lor...
embed.documentcloud.org/docum...
People need to understand that she was driving a raised suspension Dodge Ram in the snow do y'all understand how easy it is to run over something and not notice it especially in deep snow. That's specifically what it's designed for
Understand? People? On the internet? This is where people make snap judgements based on their own bias on the first 15 seconds of the video make comments and then don't finish it.
@@hardtakeofftochè
Yeah, I drove an F250 last year and it's like a tank.
She also could have thought she ran over a snowbank
It's VERY jarring when your rather large husband tries to strangle you. I know from experience. It puts you in shock, otherworldly feeling. I totally understand her movements that night. You are reacting out of base survival, in altered mental state. Add alcohol to that, it's just a mess. I hope she can just go live her best life now, and be happy -single fr.
Assuming that's what really happened. Someone with the capacity to murder their spouse has the capacity to lie.
@@theSemiChristwhat does this even mean? 😂
@@poindextertunesIKR?!!
@@poindextertunes Lori claimed he tried to strangle her but there were no witnesses and her husband is dead and unable to refute her story so it's possible she is lying about him strangling her. I think @theSemiChrist stated it perfectly, I'm not sure why you were unable to understand him or her.
It’s pretty easy to believe her story when the victim is dead, no?
Even if she felt a bump while backing out she may have thought it was a snow pile
Exactly
When I realized that Lori's husband was jealous/violent/abusive, it occurred to me that she may have felt her life was in danger; you argued for something similar by the end of the video. Thanks, as always, Dr. Grande.
Even though the topics are dark, Dr. G'S voice is soooo soothing 😊
Dr Grande's use of puns is par excellence, another episode from the good Dr, to see me through the dark November nights. Hi to everyone, keep yourselves warm and safe
Hello to you Jane Frost 🩷
@@MEL2theJ thank you, hope you're having a lovely time, whatever time it is for you. Hugs and good wishes
@@janefrost1856 Sending you hugs back 🤗
@@janefrost1856..yeah the Doc is getting more agile with his use of situational cliche and directed pun,, woulda been cool if your username was HollyFrost,, do a Christmas cliche but oh well,, guess Be Cool Ms Frost will have to do 👍...
The dive bar puns were top tier
The man lost all credibility in my eyes when he put her in a chokehold. The third party testimony about him makes me feel sick. Violence, especially domestic violence, is unacceptable.
Doesn’t justify being murdered
Yeah I think she saw danger and went into pure flight mode so didn’t register what a person in their logical mind would register as running over something. Just pure panic mode.
@@realeyesc9385 True, but it does add a mountain of reasonable doubt to the charge of murder.
@@realeyesc9385 But it justifies being killed in self defence.
it doesn't mean you can just kill somebody because they supposedly have a history of domestic violence. What third party testimony? A bartender intervening in an argument they're having? That's like nothing.
I think he slipped under the truck as she was leaving but she did not know it. I watched her whole testimony, which was consistent and included things she could have lied about so she appeared very genuine. If she's really guilty she better head to Hollywood, she'd be the greatest actress ever. The jury got it right and found her not guilty.
Small correction: When they got home, Mark went inside to put her wedding ring in their safe and Lori went in after him to quickly grab her contact case and glasses from the bathroom. Lori got back in the truck and Mark ran out to get his stuff. That’s according to her testimony anyway.
I do think it’s plausible that she couldn’t see very well in that truck because it was so high up and probably didn’t adjust the seat. She hardly ever drove it and couldn’t find the lock button. Given the snow piles along their driveway and how quick she hit the gas, the wheels may have spun and she thought she was hitting snow. Especially since she was likely intoxicated and in a fight or flight state.
Right on, sister. I've been in fight-or-flight mode, and it drowns out my other senses. Your take is spot-on.
Yes, I think you've got it right.
This may sound like a tall order but can you please do an overview on Chris Chan?
imo you can tell she could easily lie because how cold she is on the stand and her eyes in the mugshot. I just don't believe her at all
@@missywink1504 No man could drive a pick up truck over a woman and not know it, but a woman could drive over a man and not know it.
Hello Dr. Grande. Another excellent analysis. You really drove the point home about her abuse from that violent man.
So many questions! I wonder what she sounded like on the 911 call? What does his family think of the result of this case? I feel like she was probably "buzzed driving", and maybe tapped him, not realizing how bad she struck him. Maybe she thought he could stand up, but he was too drunk to get up? Did they perform any kind of toxicology on her even though it was hours later? Excellent observations to ponder Dr. Grande.
They were drinking in the bar from 5:30-10:30, so they were probably more than just “buzzed.” 🍻
you can hear the 911 call, it was part of the trial so it's online .. her husband was obviously quite dead when she found him in the snowbank so she didn't attempt cpr (even the emergency people that responded didn't if I remember the testimony correctly) .. as far as drinking goes, heavy steady drinkers, they even owned a party bus (I'm not criticizing them, just explaining the lifestyle) edit: no blood alc for her but yes on him, he was drunk, the levels were part of the ME testimony, she admitted to being quite drunk and avoiding the police on the road because she would have a DUI - hope this helps
911 call is in its own video on Law & Crime Trials. I just finished watching the whole trial, of you have any questions and don't want to sit through the whole thing yourself.
Doc, pls look into the killer of 8 yr old Chad Choice of Tyler, Texas. The murderer sent Chad’s body parts to his parents in the yrs following the murder. I’d love to hear your opinion on him
How awful
Those poor parents
Cannot imagine the horror of losing a child and then being tortured!!
Eww. How sadistic 😢That poor child and family
That sounds like organized crime-sending a message of some sort. If not, how utterly terrifying! Well, still, how utterly terrifying!
Wow! I lived on Golden Ave in Tyler. It's got to be the most overpopulated City I have ever lived in!
I live close to Tyler and I know Chad's mother. Her brother, Chad's uncle, is believed to be the killer.
Sad but true, she probably saved either her own life or other women’s lives.
The wife could be killed any second in that man's hands. He is a pure dangerous person. She should have been long out of the relationship if it was safe to do so. I sense her profound fear in those moments that night. She was lucky she had an armor of a new truck that was a barrier between her and him.
Please elaborate on your "pure dangerous person" theory. Because someone is big, they are "pure dangerous"? In my experience, as a 6'6" person, we get picked out much like racial minorities as "potential for trouble" so what you see as "pure danger" I see as "implicit bias" against someone based on appearance. It's a person's mind that is dangerous or not, without the brain, ain't nothing happening at all.
@@hardtakeoff Thank you for pointing it out. I do not know at all his physical features. I don't have any theory either. I judge completely by his actions and mental states during those violent moments that warrant him as a dangerous person. I would not spread bias based on female or male's physical features and differences. I would never pick you out as a dangerous person even if you were 7' tall, without exhibiting those concerning/frightening characters.
I don't believe she showed any evidence of abuse. she said he broke down a door once but no photos of it
@@reneegardner2286 Yes, we wouldn't have all information about this case and other ones. She admitted he was a caring person when sober. Most dangerous events occurred after he became intoxicated, or intoxication can make him a killer.
I hope everyone who sees this has a great day.much love to you all❤
Well i saw it lol im watching this video before i head to work so i appreciate the comment :)
Have a terrific Tuesday to you too!
Thank you and the same to you. 😊
Thank you!! And the very same from me to you and all in this “community.” 🙏🏼💕🙂
The puns. You never miss a beat, Dr. Grande. ❄️
Hi Dr Grande, good morning from Southern California. Excellent analysis. The jury found Lori not guilty. Fine, I have no problem with such.
As always I learn something new from your videos.
Dr Grande should be charged for that glorious pun assault at the end😂
That string of ice puns was epic.
The mystery of the non-melting wax cactus candles behind Dr. Grande.
I’ve been watching these candles & realized they aren’t real fire.
The disappointment.
I think it's an AI generated fake background.
I live near that town and remember reading about the case in the newspaper. Alcohol and domestic violence, trucks and snow are not a good combination.
Sounds like it was an accident but Lorri wanted to sleep off her intoxication before reporting it.
Agreed 💯
Wanted to fake that she didn't know what happened even though she murdered him
@@BkBk-gy6vr exactly
Oh my Dr. Grande!! I didn't think that I could love you anymore after your analysis of the book banning shenanigans! I was wrong!
I can only hope to one day be as clever, intelligent, and humorous, as you sir! I absolutely love you and I thank you for the much needed laughs!! #fanforlife !
Another great narrative. Loved the ending with all the word play on "cold shoulder, ice, snowed under, etc." ❄⛄
I also think she didn't really register that she hit or injured him like that. Mix together alcohol, arguing, violence and fleeing it is plausible she did not hit him on purpose or did not mean to kill him.
This case should have never gone to trial. It's clearly a case of a battered, choked, & terrified woman trying to escape her drunk & homicidal husband. Lori accidentally ran over him while trying to save her own life. I was in a similar situation with my alcoholic ex- husband. He choked me so hard that his entire palm print, including his fingers, left bruises on my neck. My boss saw this black & blue handprint on my neck the next morning at work & intervened.
My peer specialist calls her ex her "Wasband." 😂
I'm glad you got out of that situation. My mother did too. I have no idea what she experienced, though, because she almost never spoke of it. I think I learned what little I know from my brother.
I agree!
Thank you to your boss for possibly saving your life. I too have been choked and abused. I agree with you and believe Lori was in survival mode, which likely caused her brain to only focus on escaping and everything that occurred during those escape moment were a blur.
Should be in jail the rest of her life
It’s IMPOSSIBLE to RUN OVER SOMEONE IN YOUR DRIVEWAY and NOT KNOW it.
In the movies people fly "thousands of feet" when hit by a vehicle???? Man, I want to see those movies! LOL
"Wheeeeeeeeeeeee!!" 😂
This was almost the perfect storm. Something awful was going to happen that night, considering all of the alcohol consumed. Mark seemed to be an angry drunk and I know how that is. My mother was one. They're Jekyll and Hyde. Lori was afraid that Mark was finally really going to hurt her. Her fear was all-consuming. If she hadn't been so afraid of Mark, to the point of panicking & needing to get away, Mark would still be alive. He was 240 lbs & quite a bit taller than her. He was raging that night, accusing her of wanting to sleep with another man. Had she not been so afraid, she wouldn't have sped away from the house and stayed away. And Mark would still be alive.
Given Mark’s history of abuse, he is fortunate he lived as long as he did. Lori gave him many chances over the years and he refused to change.
She had many chances over the years to leave him. She stayed, enabled his behavior and murdered him in cold blood. Both are at fault.
It didn't seem like they were married that long, if they married in 2018.
Your extended riff on ice and snow made me do a spit-take. Thank you as always, Dr. Grande, for your balanced overview of a less than happy couple.
Having been in volatile situations like this I feel there's a very good chance that it was an accident that happened in all the chaos. On the other hand....
Thanks Dr. Grande for another analysis & staying at the top of your grind. I appreciate you very much.
I’m so early! Dr. grande, I love your videos
The Dive Bar is a chain, at least here in western PA. It's not a dive bar, instead overpriced chain food
Wow I’m here early enough to see the ppl who try to get the top comment by commenting something super general and cringe before they even watch the video. It’s like the hours just before sunrise and you hear the first birds start chirping but the birds are strange internet folk.
Omg I’m one of them now….
Hello sir. Could you please analyse the incident in Illinois where a 71 year old Joseph Cuzaba killing the 6 year old son of his tenant? As reports sau they were on very friendly terms. I'd love to hear your input on that tragedy.
I have no idea how you didn't manage to break character with your Weird Al Yankovic lyrics at the end of the video. Kudos Dr Grande!
I've been abused by men and I can tell you that it's terrifying not knowing what they'll do next A choke hold??? I've been choked out before and I literally thought I was going to die! In that moment, you are not sane at ALL and I can't blame the woman if she freaked out in fear and ran him over. His behavior is reproachable.
Takes two to tango sweetheart. What did you do to initiate a violent response? Or was he a drug addict? Was he detoxing?
I hate how women start shit then get their ass beat and act like victims. Don't poke the bear.
@@joem3999 You're so funny. NPD? It's that your excuse? Since you're asking for mine and it's none of your business?
@@joem3999So according to you she had to have done something for him to react violently because it couldn't have just been that he's an abusive a-hole, right?! Men like you are the reason women don't speak up enough! You should really watch what you say to people and maybe work on those anger issues that you clearly have towards women!
@@silverkiss37ignore that jerk. Glad you're okay and made it out alive. I, too, have experienced DV by my ex-husband and it definitely wasn't my fault. He was/is a drug addict who gets extremely violent when high or drinking and regardless of what I did/didn't do I was always his target. Thank god I divorced him and moved on. Sadly he's still abusing women when he's not in prison.
@@VictoriaMarch13 Thank you. You hit it right on the spot. The guy definitely acts like an abuser who would tell the woman she "asked for it". FP. I'm so glad you got away. I did too and now I'm free. And it feels really amazing. 💜
Sheesh! This isn't the first case of its kind. I was curious as to Dr. Grande's opinion on if the jury got it right or not?
Thank you again for the analysis 🙏
Great analysis
Is this a different but similar case to one where she and other vehicles came back to house to party more 🤔 or the same one. Remember, two girlfriends drove two cars back to house
@@bubbabroad9051 I was wondering the same thing? The guy was a police officer and he was raising his nephew and niece, right?
I know Dr. Grande covered that case too.
I believe it's a different one? I'm going to look through the archives and I'll get back with you 🙂
@@bubbabroad9051Did Professor Slam Lexus SUV into Police Officer Boyfriend? | Karen Read Case Analysis
@@MEL2theJ thank you!!! I am NOT going crazy
Dr. Grande delivering some killer lines!
Wow Doc as usual you hit the nail on the head with this one. As a woman I don't know what. I would done a case like this . Very scary.😮
Great analysis as usual Dr. Grande. Those puns of yours always send shivers down my spine
Victims of intimate partner violence often return to their batterers. Not guilty, self defense against abusive partner.
As someone who was in a violent relationship, she probably was just in get the hell away mode and probably didn't think she actually hurt him badly when she struck him. Plus, knowing he was also going to be mad that she was trying to leave and hit him (when he was already being violent) probably made her scared to stay and even check. If she was also intoxicated, that probably didn't help. I think the jury made the right decision as well.
This whole case leaves me feeling cold, I don't know why 🥶
Great wrap-up, as usual, Dr. G!!
The way he incorporates puns in the concluding moments of his videos never fails to make me burst into laughter!
Quite a chilling story.
With the compacted snow and snowbanks it's completely plausible she may not have known she ran over him... It's very rough and bumpy when you're driving over snow and ice.
Doc could you please discuss SSSniperWolf copying Azzyland? She literally stole her identity (her Toronto accent, house tour video wearing the exact same dress and mirror). Just like in the move "Sssingle White Female". It's so creepy and disturbing. And she spent 6 years accusing Azzyland to deflect from the fact that she was the one copying. Thanks in advance 🙏
Seconded!
❤Dr Grande! Always look forward to your interesting uploads.
Awesome use of metaphors, Dr. Grande! 😎
I really enjoy and look forward to all your content Dr. All your efforts are greatly appreciated. I hope you and your family have a wonderful holiday season.
ALWAYS tell the cops how you were arguing all night long before your spouse was found DEAD.
Great analysis and final thoughts!
Thank you, Dr. Grande.❤😊
Oh dear, the evils of alcohol.
Getting behind the wheel of a car while intoxicated is most definitely reckless, in my opinion. Granted, she may have been escaping him, but as Dr. Grande said, intoxication is not a defence.
But was her intention at the time just to defend herself, if you wan to get away from torture or murder surely that one is a valid reason to drive drunk versus trying to run away on foot in the snow with a much stronger, perhaps faster guy after you?
@@Iflie 🤦🏽♀️
@@openorwap5412 She didn't do it because she was drunk, she most likely did it because he was trying to harm her. So drunk isn't the defense or that relevant.
She didn't even actually drive of the property it seems.
@@Iflie She could've locked the door (as he was coming around to the driver's side). Then after he was no longer in front of her vehicle, drive away. How do you not know you've ran someone over with your vehicle? Preposterous
@@celeca7 Don't keys work from a distance these days? Couldn't he just have used a back up key to unlock it?
I think if she hadn't knocked him over with the car she would have driven away, but she stayed....because on some level she knew he was neutralized.
I don't think she meant to kill him though, she probably slept in the guestroom with the door locked expecting to find him in their bedroom in the morning.
Oh I've heard this one before. And I always love to get Dr Grande's take on these older cases
This is quite recent as the trial only ended a couple days ago.
@@lizmarie6811 Yeah, he gives the best updates. I didn't know that the trial just finished until now. I remember hearing about this when it first happened
Now, what’s going on? Wow. Thank you for covering so many interesting cases, Dr. Grande. ❤ Your videos are informative and calming. ❤ This world is so unpredictable and distressing, at times, but we look forward to your even analysis to balance things out.❤
Always interesting
Thank you
Love your play on words!!!
just got done hearing your review about the case wherein the bird was speaking about details that seemed to point to the crime, and just wanted to say that you play on words about birds was FABULOUSLY funny and perfectly on spot!! Then, in this one, the play on the snow, frost, cold, ETC., THAT was also funny and well done!! I dont think I ever heard sny others that followed ths sort of review but will keep my ears open from now on... Your 'dead pan humor goes along with your emotionless manner in general, which is fine, manly, and acceptable (I come from a bunch of Germans, who are all soberminded and well...) but it got me wondering if we might ever hear you laugh out loud one day - as in, 'cut loose'? Glad we met your wife - thank you!!😂❤
Honestly my main questions is why were they having dinner at 4.15 in the afternoon
Many people eat around that time, whether by necessity like how early their days begin, busy schedules, or work shifts. ✌️
"..driven show," has got to be one of your best yet!
My favorite part of these videos is the "summing up" where he makes all the hilarious puns :D
After having viewed your older videos I like how you have improved your staging!
You didn't have to go full auto with the puns, ya killing me 😂
All the snow and freezing references left me laughing.😅
Dr. Grande nails it.
This is a clear cut case of self defense. The prosecutor must have snuffed a lot of "snow" to think this was a winnable case.
Guilty of murder
The bar for convicting women is higher
Love your closing remarks. 😉
It's just after 11:00pm and UA-cam just notified me that this video was posted "Now." I watched it and commented four days ago. Just thought that I would let you know Dr. Grande ❣️
Beautiful closing Dr Grande!🤠💕🤪
Dr
Grande I don't know why I enjoy your videos so much. Is the reason because of your coverage and comment of the video or your humor. Not sure. Ceci’
I watched her testimony at trial. The jury absolutely got it correct! She was very believable!
Your snowball puns at the end cracked me up so hard 🤣😅
You are really good at breaking it down ! Being they were both intoxicated and she drove off with door open also taking into consideration she was fearful of him ! I believe it is possible she didn’t know she hit him ! Which as you pointed out is reasonable doubt ! Only 2 people would know the truth and one of them is dead.
How do you do it! That wrap up was pristine.
Love the references to cold in the end. 😂
I call alcohol "anger juice" because nearly everyone who consumes alcohol has a level of alcohol consumption which will lead them to do and say things which they never would while sober, and that includes violence.
sounds like you watched the trial, Doc! Lori was very believable on the stand, I think it really made a difference to the case that she testified .. I'm still hoping you will cover that strange Logan Clegg case
Wow Lori needs an Oscar. She was perfectly in alignment with her story. She showed no signs, zero signs of deception. I wish you knew about body language. If you did - you would know that her story made perfect sense. Not one lie. Everything she said checked out. I don't care how intelligent someone is. If they intentionally killed someone, they would not be able to keep their story straight. She loped along telling the truth all the way. And one last thing. Her genuine grief in that camera footage, the way she was when she discovered her abusive alcoholic husband dead was heartbreaking. If she did knowingly do this then by goodness get this woman an Oscar 🎉🎉🎉
Great ending Dr. Grande!!!!
Hi, Dr. Grande. Can you please do a video about the author Marion Zimmer Bradley?
Why is it that other people have to go to prison when accidentally killing others, yet she doesn’t? Because he was being mean?
Drunk or not, I believe that the moment a man gets a lady in a chokehold all his rights - including to life - are gone.
So if a women is stabbing a child and a man then places her in a chokehold, his life is forfeit. I can't even with people like you
What if she is stabbing him?
If she lied about running into her husband, and she was intoxicated, then those point to her guilt. The fact that she didn't move her husband to see if he was okay is also suspicious. How drunk was she? Could he have been saved? What was the police history of his violent behavior, not just her word on the matter? Was a medical exam performed on her to show she was telling the truth about the violence that night? For me, there are more questions than answers. If the police and DA didn't answer any of these questions for the jury, then it's scarcely any wonder she was found not guilty.
Yes 😮 You're right! I wonder if she was examined for injuries and how many times the police were called to their residence
I watched some of the trial and yes, she had bruises on her chest. Those things were looked into and part of the trial. She actually did not know she hit him. She was trying to get away from him.
If mere allegations of abuse are allowed to become a license to kill, that will replace divorce as the way women end marriages.
@MakerInMotion no kidding. The disparity between the sexes being held to the same standards and the reality of the matter worsens.
Never mind that we're supposed to all be the same and interchangeable, now. 🙄
@@MakerInMotion When women make these claims and the evidence strongly indicates murder, they are typically convicted. The key factor here was that there wasn't evidence that 1) she ran over her husband on purpose and 2) that she even knew she had run him over.
The abuse wouldn't have made much difference to the judgement of most of the jurors. There was reasonable doubt because she could have run him over by accident and thought she just hit a snow bank, then not seen his body because of the snow. None of that has anything to do with her husband hitting her.
My understanding was that Lori did went inside the house to retrieve her glasses / contact lenses.
I’m not gonna lie. I’m glad she is not in prison. She WAS in a prison but, no more.
Just a reminder, I'm not diagnosing anybody in this video; only speculating about what could be happening in a snowbank like this.
I don’t understand why people who know that they turn violent when they drink would drink
Very interesting case, there is a lot to it!
Curious how long a person can claim self-defense in a situation where they are not leaving the situation.
It is interesting how many different ways the case can be interpreted.
LOL! Love your closing comments :-) And I agree with your analysis although she may truly not have realized she killed him until she kept checking her security cameras and saw that he didn't move. Regardless, I agree that a jury would not have convicted her because there is enough reasonable doubt and she had every reason to fear for her life.
I’m so glad I live in Madison…the rest of this state is a mess
Alcoholism destroys so many lives
What was his blood alcohol content
lol you with the snow jokes ❤😂
I couldn’t leave my loved one face down in the snow. I don’t often differ with your assessments, but in this case, I believe this woman committed murder and I don’t think it was a spur of the moment situation. Thank you for an interesting observation.
That is called deliberate Murder I would say.
There was much more exculpatory evidence in this case than Dr. Grande gave us. After reviewing all of the evidence, the jury reached the only reasonable conclusion that could be reached: Not guilty. You can review it all for yourself, and you should see what Dr. Grande concluded: the prosecution had a snowball's chance in hell.
Hello Dr. Grande......hahaha regarding the snow ball comment good one! 😊. I agree w/ u ....I'm glad she wasn't guilty.....!
That was a lot of great puns.