A lawyer's experiences with corruption and bribes
Вставка
- Опубліковано 29 сер 2024
- The story of my friend Advocate Manish and his experience of dealing with corruption in India.
I am a Delhi based lawyer.
You can send me your stories at amish.aggarwala@gmail.com
wa.me/+9199581...
I post regularly on:
UA-cam: / @amishlegal
Instagram: / bettercallamish
LinkedIn: / amish-aggarwala-45978246
7 THINGS MEN SHOULD KNOW BEFORE GETTING MARRIED: STORIES OF FALSE CASES AND LEGAL BATTLES IN INDIA:
www.amazon.in/...
#lawyer #law #court #lawstudent
I want a lawyers perspective on how law differs India vs Overseas. Reaction to a judge judy episode would be fun and insightful. Great work.
First guy who want to judge jurys decision based on facts
Also reaction to Suits.
Is Manish an anagram to Amish? In a sense he is reciting his own experience under the name of Manish😊
Shhh.
;)
@@The_Rising_Dragon it's an open secret mate
@@aatefkamal ok angrez bhaisaab
Manish is Amish and Amish is Manish
Obviously
The helplessness of those in Manish's situation is heartbreaking.
My uncle is Anti corruption bureau high rank official so it makes government process go very smoothly for me with just a phone call. The govt officials turn from arrogant to calm and pleasant person in no time.
Are lower court judges bribed as well ?
@@SilenceSerene Not heard of much about judges being caught. Most people are from land records revenue etc
@@AB-mv1mb i wanted to join judicial services actually and wanted to know how lucrative the job actually is, i felt you are the right to person to ask about it as your father deals with such officers
It's for you only.. but the officers are there to serve normal tax payer folks like us..
It their job.
But they ain't doing it.
Not everyone is as fortunate as you
1:25 Belligerent = hostile
2:05 Extol = praising someone
-an ssc aspirant
*an 0.5
Learning how to speak well from you..such a standard you have set..
I like such a neutral and independent view from a lawyer....otherwise in today’s India...who talks of principles are treated as fools....and who gets the job done thru greasing palms of corrupt one are treated as clever and intelligent.......
Thank you for voicing the issues faced by the common man while engaging with government officials. It is truly disappointing that India is in this state of affairs.
I left practice because of same 😁
Manish = Amish ??? 🤔🤔🤔
I have seen bribes being given right outside cort room!!! Right outside!!
Does this happen in failed states even?
Bribes are ingrained in our so called culture
Many many congratulations sir on achieving 1 lakh....you a an honest person..thank you for spreading legal awareness sir..
Not surprised at all. India's rank is very low in terms of honesty, integrity and social values. But we have another trait as well, we are the most shameless people in the world.
Same case whether it be passport police verification/driving license etc, everybody needs to pay bribes.
Even the postman delivering the passport doesn't hand it over to us without a bribe.
I never had to pay bribes for any of my documents. My first driving licence ( for 2 wheeler ) took some time to get done but once i knew the process, my next licence ( 4 wheeler ) took no time at all. A total of ₹0 paid in bribes. Even passport was smooth.
I had to pay bribe to register a mobile theft.
I've been luck that way. The police officers in my area are super nice. Never had a problem
i bribed 1500 for passport police verification and 100 to postman for delivery
Learning a lot from you
Keep up the great work!
Corruption is a tool you need to know how to use it wisely ✌🏻
it's the ticket to first class. it's our plague, demise of our country, exact reason for the current deplorable state of affairs.
@@parthtool how is it a ticket to first class
Explain
@@mayursable4921 easy man, if you can execute corruption practices properly, you can accumulate wealth tax free and upgrade your life style. Many a gov employees have been able to provide their families with first class living standards. I suppose you havent ever seen corrupt malpractice in action.
@@parthtoolwhatever for?
Absolutely gem of a knowledge .💯
Manish = Amish
Yes, I got that when the video ended... LOL...
Somehow 😅
Small topic of yours speaks a lot sir, I also in beginning felt the same way as manish but as the time passed, things changes a lot
Hope the channel grows.
he just hit 100k
It has already grown. suddenly his subscribers snow balled.
Very true Mr Amish... You have explained the situation with intense clarity of what's happening in your profession.
Just imagine what the common man
has to go through.
I have had a very good education from the best school's and college with the blessings of my parents. While in school I really had bright ideas and dreams and wanted to do my bit for this country.
Fast forward 25 years and I'm sick and tired of the way businesses work in our country. You have to grease each and every palm that crosses your way while getting things done.
The dreams I had in school and college are shattered to tiny bits because I always argued with my father that why he should bribe anyone even when everything is according to law, but the sad reality is he is no more and I am being asked the same question by my children who have grown up today.
Will this ever change....I do not know
No bro now things are even worse no wonder why people are in que to get PR in other countries.. corruption is everywhere but here it's on another level
Thanks for this great video. Why don't our courts have audio-visual camera systems that can help restrict corruption to some extent? The DUI guy posts the videos of his clients in the court room.
The answer is simple, money.
Or the lack of it to be specific.
Gujarat high court proceedings are live telecasted on youtube , check it out.
In a court even the chair ask for money.
*And that manish is mr. Amish himself. Nice storytelling though.*
Thanks a lot Amish Sir
Appreciate the truth brother
This is one of the most awaited video .👍
You are a fabulous orator !!
A Manish needs to survive this corrupt world. Manish does what is best for him.
Thank you for the insight
Respected lawyer, I am an accused in a cheque bounce case with a very large MNC. Now using their influence they are getting dates after dates not giving in the evidence. It's been almost 7 years and the complainnant being show-cause twice by the court . Can you please tell me how to get quick dates from the court, so that I can prove my inocence
Ask the judge for it.
Request the judge for shorter date whenever they say next date.
Policing system or the bureaucracy in general is inherently corruptible. We're sold an idea of 'ideal system' but only those who deal with it or are part of it for that matter know keeping up integrity & principles is hard, let alone facilitated.
PatalLok has this dialogue. It goes like "Door se dekhne mein ye system ek kachre ka dher lagta hai, lekin andar ghus ke dekho toh it's a well oiled machine. Har purze ko pata hai ki usey kya karna hai aur jo purza kaam nahin karta, usey badal diya jata hai."
Do you look into U.P. cases? My mother is fighting a case against my father's family for 20 years now for her jewellery and her part in the property of my father who died due to cancer in 1999. Since then, the case is going and still she has to go to court. I have already lost hope but she still wants to keep going. She told she won once but the Father's side challenged again.
This is the pathetic condition. Even if you win the case,they can again go to Court on one or other ground to delay the Exicution.The case may be dragged on for years.
Hmm...very true 👍...very insightful and meaningful...the short answer of the long story is...GET THE JUSTICE DONE BY ANY MEANS IN FAVOUR OF THE CLIENTS IS THE PRIORITY...WELL.. ITS THE RESULT ORIENTED APPROACH... IF THE MECHANICS OF JUSTICE IS LIKE THAT....THEN... WHY TO WORRY MUCH ABOUT BEYOND THE SYSTEM... means...GET UP...STAND UP... GREASE THE PALM...AND FINALLY FINISH THE TASK...AND RELAX 😌🙌😎... BUT....
REMEMBER NO INNOCENT PERSONS SHOULD BE PROSECUTED AT THE EXPENSE OF THE WHIMS AND FANCIES OF THE RICH PEOPLE WHILE USING BRIBE OR ANY CORRUPT MEANS...MEANS ETHICAL TREATMENT SHOULD BE PROPORTIONATE TO THE JOB....
PLEASE FIND OUT HOW MANY UNSCRUPULOUS LAWYERS HAVE JOINED HANDS WITH CORRUPT POLICE , POLITICIAN AND CRIMINAL NEXUS. IN FACT LAWYERS MUST TAKE UP THE RESPONSIBILITY OF CLEANING THIS SYSTEM .
Sir please make a short video on challenges faced by criminal lawyer as compared to a civil lawyer
Hello sir, Can you please do a quick video on the rules for carrying a self-defense weapon in India. For example, Whether we can carry a knife or not, or if so what would be the dimensions of it or Can we carry a telescopic baton or not.
I guess government doesn't pay good salary that's why government officials can't afford chai paani on their own...
Even if they get paid they will do the same, this pursue of money never changes
Bhai tune achcha wala mic leliya humare liye😎
Falls in the same situation many a times..
Job verification
Passport verification
Others..
Manish eventually drops the N from his spelling and interchanges the position of the M and the A.
The guilt of moving to the dark side and making peace with he himself murdering his own ethics and also overcoming the despise for the corrupt cops... one day makes him share this on the internet.. albeit in the third person narrative.
If you can't beat them, join them!
5:36 other government officials (Judge)😂😂
You look like actor more than lawyer.. because your expressions and talking style is really good
Don't why those who follow shortcuts & do unethical practices are always on safer side and they grow fastly. Be it an MNC employee or an advocate or a govt employee. Morals & values now seem to be just lessons of the book over the papers.
Manish later clears civil judge exam and becomes a judge. Now the real challenge starts for police.
I thought the same
@@sekumar123 even assistant public prosecutors are recognised and respected by police.
@@balajibabud1223 Still police holds a lot more power, can encounter them and call it suicide.
Sir plz make a video on cyber crimes and the consequences....
Amish to Manish: you've merely adopted the dark..... I was born in it...molded by it. Jk.😂
Can we not form a collective of honest lawyers who would strive to change this state of affairs? Alone we may ourselves become part of this system, together we may have a chance, albeit a slim one.
Fastest growing youtuber in India
At the end, I realized who Manish was 😅
Manish is now called Anish😂
I am not totally fine following a lawyer how is willing to admit giving bribe is ok ? U don’t have to but i will feel comfortable if u say Manish is not u. I want to believe that but I am confused.
Bhai sad to see your helpless face towards the end of the video 🙈
Tbh this has opened a truly new perspective for me to see bribing in a new light. You can use bribing to your advantage, if the govt. official is corrupt or if you want to get things done fast without much hassle..
Dear Sir, Thank you for valuable talk. Ethical talk......but it's also recorded in the puducherry and tamilnadu regions. But there are no toughest operations due to higher influencers..... That should be streamlined perfectly and ethically. Thank you.
I have known of cases where the "bribe" that is demanded of state level services aspirants is marrying some top govt person's daughter/ niece/ relative. It is not always money that's exchanged.
Of course, a woman civil services aspirant might even have to face a worse situation.
I hope young people trying to get into top jobs understand how complex the process is and aren't in delusion about the world. Be prepared to have your morals questioned at every step of the way. Try not to become jaded though.
Sir, I am a law student I am completely against bribing court staffs but one incident which i would like to share is that i applied for a Certified Copy in the Mumbai MM court, they told me to wait and then the JC asked me to come to the side and told me that i have to pay him something to stamp the CC to make it valid. At that time, i was shocked and i gave in. Till this day i regret giving him money for doing his job, but i have realised they always try to get something out of the lawyers, and as a law student and soon to be a lawyer, what should i do ? Keep giving them the bribe or stop it completely.
Keep giving 😁
dnt pay simple if he doest do it den complain to d dj of that court
I am struggling to get certified copy as I am against bribery
All credit goes to baba ji ka samvidhan. This happens when all power goes to Govt and govt workers.
Sir if possible please make a video explaining cryptocurrency laws and taxation (from mining crypto or profit from early adoption of the cryptocurrency)
He is not a tax advisor.
So what should normal citizens do when the cop asks for bribe ?
dnt pay try to record den file a police complaint or a complaint wid dere seniors
System is the thing
U change the system design it in such a way so the problems diminishes
You exposed the system. God bless you
Absolutely correct ✅
Yeh bandhan to note ka bandhan hai janamon ka corruption hai
We Indians are the most hypocritic people. We criticise those who pay bribes, but when it comes to us or our family, anything goes.
can you make a video on the differences between a Lawyer, Advocate, Barrister, Attorney, Solicitor, etc ? TIA.
They are same profession known by different names in different country.
Whenever someone says "its for/of a friend..."
Its them!
sigma rule 420
I like the comment "little corrupt" now we have measured corruption levels
the pain at the end..
i can relate
Amishji, is it police department only the ones in judicial process who demand and accept "tit bits". What about judiciary? No comments??
he talked bout judiciary through the court staff lawyers are also not good they try to extort money frm the clients and judges they too do it sumtimes but very very few
Giving a tip is opposite to bribe. A tip enhances your self-worth as opposed to giving a bribe, which degrades your self-worth.
At age 17, a policeman confiscated my bicycle for wrong parking. As far as I was concerned the bicycle had been stolen. I went to the nearby police station to lodge a complant. The policeman there showed me my bike, explained the reason thereof but refused to give it back. I suspected that he was seeking a bribe but I pretended to be an innocent lad, dyed-in-the-wool types and played along. I enquired of him of the procedure for getting my bike back. He explained that the matter will go to court after a challan had been prepared in a few days and thereafter when the due procedure is completed, the bike shall be released in compliance of the court order.
I complained that that was ridiculous in a free country and refused to believe him. And insisted on seeing his superior officer. After some reluctance, he said the DSP has the power to issue release order at his discretion.
Where can I meet the DSP? I said.
He's at his bungalow. He replied.
Give me the address of his bungalow, I insisted. As a public servant, he's duty bound to attend to the issue during working hours.
By now, the man was harrassed enough by that stupid boy who refused to get a hint and released my bicycle with a stern warning.
Episode number 2:
Recently my daughter needed police clearance as a part of immigrating to Canada. The SHO police station told her and her husband that the clearance shall be given by CID. Office of the CID was in another part of Mumbai. They requested him to get an appointment over the phone, which he refused. He could have easily done that though. My daughter and son in law suspected that he was seeking a bribe. And they sought my help as to how to give him a bribe. I suggested that you don't suspect him but respect him and meticulously do what he says. They went to the office of the CID, presented the form there and explained the matter. After checking their records on computer, they got the clearance within 5 minutes.
Moral of the story:
Respect, don't suspect.
It helps NOT to know the 'ways of the world'.
Never bribe ANYONE but keep everyone happy by giving tips, greetings, compliments & gifts.
When you bribe someone, you crush your soul.
Its always has been one' s choice whether to go on with the flow or swim against the tide.
If we go with the flow we loose our moral right to criticise our corrupt politicians as we ourselves then is the part of the corrupt system.
Yes, this is the correct way. Benefits first, principles later. No matter how much you hate a person, a mutual ground for co-operation can be created if it's for the sale of benefits.
What about your experience in manish's place??
Hi sir,
I have my sister (a Hindu) who is looking forward to marry a christian man.
This christian man says that she would be free to practise her Hindu faith after marriage but I know how the church puts pressure on the Christian family to convert the Hindu spouse to christianity and gets the non Christian spouse to sign a pre-nup which says that the child borne out of such wedlock would exclusively be required to follow Christianity...
Sir, I don't believe in words and the party can put pressure on my sister to convert which she herself does not want and wants her future children to not have any legal pressure to be brought up like a christian exclusively. She wants her children to have the freedom and herself have the freedom of practice of religion....
Sir, if you can kindly guide us as to how to go about it, I will be very grateful to you.
you can call amish. google his name you will get his office number
if dey put presuure den file an fir againt dem simple n dere is no law which help u in sumthing dat hasnt happened if ur sisters in law in future do anything which u think is incorrect den u can take the legal way always
Very good video
Many times, corrupt person don't even talk about bribe, he just delay your work as long as he/she can.
For me it's too difficult to ask what he is up to. How to ask him. How much you want etc.
Keep it up brother
Surendran Nair, involved in cheque fraud and kicked out of a government job unfortunately one of my uncles, involved in trying to fraudulently asurp my land went to a private night shady classes at an age of 50 and managed to bribe his way into getting an LLB, massive frauds in Kerala, Kottayam
Disappointed!!!.....no matter how difficult it is to work without bribing, you had the power of social media and your followers, you should have told them the way to go around bribing..no matter how difficult and long it may be....atleast this way the cops will have to work their ass off for each person they ask bribe from
Nice man
Sad reality..
The real success of India will be achieved when the government fully reforms the Indian judiciary system to mirror the French system, as opposed to the anglosaxon empire's judiciary system we currently have.
the only way India can advance steadily and swiftly is by humanising the powerful individuals.only law and order can achieve this feat
The Manish is our Amish sir
I'd like to see Manish in person 😂😂
India will be always a sad country if things don't change.
Amish is not Manish right? Or is he? 🤔
We have just been ranked 86th in world corruption index and 53rd in democratic freedom, and I think on the ground things are correspondingly much worse, corruption isn't even a thing of vice in our value system, our deeply flawed education system is to be largely blamed for this
Sir, can u make video regarding legal aspect of showing black flag to politicians.
Government job is becoming scarce in india . If a person gets a government job and if the police asks for some money he should come to an understanding and give some money . The job seeker will be enjoying full government benefits and life is well settled for an government employee .
Ma(n)ish
....khann khann ki suno khankaar , ye duniya hai kala bazar , ye paisa bolta hai , ye paisa bolta hai, ....😊😊
Fast rise from 47k to 101k
Please make a video on traffic stops specifically fundamental rights during such stops like right to remain silent, not stepping out of car (as officer has no warrant to search or arrest and forcing indian to do anything without consent or warrant would be violiation of right to Liberty and moving freely in country), only showing documents when demanded but not handing over documents (at times without reason they impound such docs to harass people)
Corruption is in blood of Indians and not attached to any uniform or job.
ROOT OF CORRUPTION STARTS FROM THE JUDGES, ADVOCATES, JUDICIARY, POLICE AND ALL DEPARTMENTS, EVERY PUBLIC SERVANT IS NOT AFRAID OF DOING CORRUPTION, TAKING BRIBES, THERE IS NO IMMEDIATE PUNISHMENT, NON BIASED TRAIL, DELAY OF JUSTICE MADE EVERY INDIAN PUBLIC SERVANT CORRUPT LAZY IRRESPONSIBLE AND ARROGANT.
so lower court judges and mgistrates also take bribes ?
We need to add layer of Decentralization , Imagine Decentralization media, that has right evidence, Not even the highest power into the govt or system can tamper it ,But doing this has one side effect people will lose faith in the judiciary , alternative all people in systems should be brought under spiritual process compulsorily and should be sent to retreat twice a year.
The burial ground of our beloved system.
Sir if there an any case on me can I become a advocate
So...d moral of d story is, work progresses in courts ONLY when money changes hands.
It is definitely frightening for new advocates. Even before one starts earning, one has to learn who to pay and how much... for getting things move smoothly.
Truth of courts and police system