'If I Were An Indian, I’d Be Wary Of A Pakistani PM Bearing Peace'

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 22 тра 2024
  • At the recently held Raisina Dialogue in New Delhi, SNI’s Deputy Editor Parul Chandra chatted with Dr C.Christine Fair, an Associate Professor with the Peace and Security Studies Program at Georgetown University in Washington DC. Dr Fair is an authority on political and military matters in the subcontinent and the author of several books. She told SNI that her most recent work ‘In Their Own Words: Understanding Laskhar-e-Tayyaba’ delves into the mind of this terror outfit through its writings and the role it plays within Pakistan. She also held out little hope for peace to prevail between India and Pakistan, noting how the Pak army sabotages such initiatives.
    #India #Pakistan #sniwire
    For other stories visit: www.sniwire.com
    Facebook profile: / sniwire

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,1 тис.

  • @priyankankumar6406
    @priyankankumar6406 5 років тому +679

    "Here's the Pakistani military strategic culture :"
    "It's got an ARMY, that can't win a War..."
    How Savage is that ...😂😂👌

    • @basitkhan3767
      @basitkhan3767 5 років тому +9

      Priyankan kumar i dont care about your information that from where and when yo get that.
      But you people dosnt want any logical information rather than gaining from some pro indian websites or from your lier media.
      About wars let's take a look.
      Conclusively, India lost an equal scale of territory to us in 1948 war (today's Azad Kashmir). So we're kind of even now.
      India claimed the whole J&K, on the basis of Instrument of accession by the then ruler of J&K, Hari Singh, right after Partition of India. Pakistan rejected it and invaded J&K with full strength. Pakistan successfully defeated the Indian forces and captured 40% area of J&K Valley. Indian forces lost the battle in J&K, and to stop the invading forces of Pakistan, seeked the help of UN to save rest of J&K Valley, . Or in other words if India was dominant in 1947 war, it would have taken all of the J&K valley under its control, which is legally part of India as per the instrument of accession (at least as per Indian claims), rather than intervening UN for cease fire and ultimately giving up 40% area of “Integral part of India”, which is under Pakistan control as of to date, in form of Azad Kashmir and Gilgit-Baltistan.
      In 1965, Pakistan successfully invaded IOK, and defeated all Indian opposition there, India was not able to defend J&K from Pak forces, India lost the Battle in J&K, and to subvert the attention of Pakistan from J&K, it invaded International borders of Pakistan, but could not successfully capture any of Pakistan’s major City as a negotiating tool to get Kashmir valley freed from Pakistani Militants. Instead India suffered heavy losses from retaliatory of Pakistan on international borders as well. Specifically in Air battle. whilst PAF had an air superiority over IAF in ratio 1:4. Indo-Pakistani Air War of 1965. India got the Indian occupied Kashmir freed from Pakistan backed forces, finally by seeking USSR intervention, which ensured to relieve Indian occupied Kashmir from Pakistan, and was handed back to India. Tashkent Declaration.
      1971- A Transparent clean sweep victory of India- But at the same time formation of Bangladesh is more internal political failure of Pakistan, rather than Military victory of India or in other words if Zulfikar Ali Bhutto (Perspective candidate of PM from west Pakistan) would have allowed Sheikh Mujibur Rehman (Perspective candidate of PM from East Pakistan) to form Govt, which was his legal and constitutional right, India would have no way able to put Bangladesh on worlds map.
      In 1999, Pakistan invaded successfully Indian Occupied Kashmir from Kargil sector. Captured its key peaks and blocked only national highway NH-1 connecting the three parts of J&K Valley Srinagar (Kashmir valley), Kargil (Drass) and Laddakh (Leh)-India was NOT able to push back Pakistani intruders, and instead of in this attempt India suffered heavy casualties Kargil War. Even got short of coffins for their killed soldiers Kargil coffin scam. India again lost the battle in Kargil sector, and was NOT able to get their peaks back from Pakistani intruders and seeked help from US and Israel, to get this job done. Foreign relations of the United States.
      So India has lost all the wars from Pakistan, except the Indo-Pakistani War of 1971.
      Not to forget the multiple times smaller size of Pakistan from India, in geographical area, population, economy, and consequently in military size and strength.
      I hope it serves.
      Proof of coward indian soldier.
      ua-cam.com/video/C9czRHRGEHc/v-deo.html
      ua-cam.com/video/Q02_NtuM0AI/v-deo.html
      ua-cam.com/video/3j7WY0rUdxE/v-deo.html

    • @zeeshan8918
      @zeeshan8918 5 років тому +39

      Your 12 tanks are still in Sialkot that your army left and run 😂. O Bitch Please

    • @plantingpakistan5914
      @plantingpakistan5914 5 років тому +4

      1948 mai Kya huwa tha bc... Kashmir Sirf Hamarey pathanoun nai tor diya 😂😂

    • @funhub3527
      @funhub3527 5 років тому +1

      Ab lr kr dekho
      Pta lg jae ga

    • @satyamevjayate1601
      @satyamevjayate1601 5 років тому +51

      @@basitkhan3767 Pakistan divided equally into Bangladesh and porkistan..... So equality achieved ??😋

  • @taruntripathi
    @taruntripathi 5 років тому +521

    Give this woman a medal👍

    • @najafstar
      @najafstar 5 років тому +1

      sure give her two lol . just ask her what lashker means lol . The trouth is lashker control a mafia who were killing shia and sunnies and those were funded by isriel and india . lol she know my cap lol ( this make my day )

    • @elvissolo3083
      @elvissolo3083 5 років тому

      yes a very tight medal around her neck so she stop talking bs

    • @manjus9219
      @manjus9219 5 років тому

      *gold medal

    • @stormpilot7477
      @stormpilot7477 5 років тому

      Give a medal up her arse.

    • @1mikon
      @1mikon 4 роки тому +1

      Honorary Indian citizenship should be given to her..

  • @taruntripathi
    @taruntripathi 5 років тому +615

    She has more balls than most Indian politicians other than Modi.

    • @47_10
      @47_10 5 років тому +63

      For me Modi is not a politician, he is a leader.

    • @Nomi-em8dq
      @Nomi-em8dq 5 років тому +18

      @@47_10
      Gandu leader sala

    • @47_10
      @47_10 5 років тому +42

      @@Nomi-em8dq pappu mutra pee liya kya?
      Ek aisa leader jisska loha Videsh ke logo ne maana, Jissne Doklam mei China ki gaand faad di, Jisne Pakistan ki kutte se bhi buri halat kar di, Jisne India ko world's fastest growing economy bana diya (according to Moodys and IMF) wo leader gandu? Chutiyape ki bhi had hoti hai.

    • @tarzangos
      @tarzangos 5 років тому +28

      Pakistanis are wetting in their pants because of Modi. We feel your pain.

    • @rajashekarreddy9859
      @rajashekarreddy9859 5 років тому +7

      Lollll

  • @NitzVision
    @NitzVision 5 років тому +180

    She's the iron lady. Not pesudo liberal

    • @MohitKumar-nf3qz
      @MohitKumar-nf3qz 5 років тому +2

      i thought Indira Gandhi was iron lady, dam man, leftist taught me wrong history. fuck leftist

    • @humanvoice369
      @humanvoice369 5 років тому

      What we need is an 'Iron Liberal'

    • @MohitKumar-nf3qz
      @MohitKumar-nf3qz 5 років тому

      @@humanvoice369 liberals are not more than a junky. they deserve shit nothing else.

  • @SANJAYKUMAR-yd4oe
    @SANJAYKUMAR-yd4oe 5 років тому +228

    After a long time someone is talking with Logic... Hats off to the lady

    • @kidding77
      @kidding77 5 років тому +1

      Any one talking against Pakistan will sound u intelegent and logical bcaz ur mind has been poisoned. Nothing new ppl stop using own brain

    • @A_PROUD_INDIAN810
      @A_PROUD_INDIAN810 5 років тому +5

      @@kidding77 you should go to google and read the history of you country or as many say 'the colony of china',you people are intellectualy challenged!

    • @satyamevjayate1601
      @satyamevjayate1601 5 років тому +2

      @@kidding77 she speaking truth not against Pakistan .... She told Lashkar is don't attack in Pakistan and in India they are not bother about HINDU OR MUSLIMS

    • @stxfdt1240
      @stxfdt1240 5 років тому

      @swarup mitra They targeted us bengali hindus in particular.

    • @SandeepKulshrestha
      @SandeepKulshrestha 2 роки тому

      But one should be ready to face the truth. She doesn't like right wing politics in India either

  • @PUDINAENTERTAINMENT
    @PUDINAENTERTAINMENT 5 років тому +104

    Pakistan army threatened her """"gang-r*p*""""(whole regiment).
    Brave lady. Great respect for her.
    God bless her and her family!

    • @AnkitSharma-wo3ei
      @AnkitSharma-wo3ei 5 років тому +13

      US should have nuked Pakistan after Osama. Half of the world's problem would be solved.

    • @PUDINAENTERTAINMENT
      @PUDINAENTERTAINMENT 5 років тому +5

      @@AnkitSharma-wo3ei ,, bro ,, nuke is not the solution.
      To change mentality of 6th century through the glass of modern science is the solution.

    • @PUDINAENTERTAINMENT
      @PUDINAENTERTAINMENT 5 років тому +3

      Everybody should watch the videos of Respected Sir , "Pushpendra Kulshreshtha".

    • @jonheidenreich7234
      @jonheidenreich7234 4 роки тому

      @@AnkitSharma-wo3ei USA is a pussy so is Israel and piggies Bharat

    • @RizwanAli-hp9jb
      @RizwanAli-hp9jb 4 роки тому

      And she pulled her skirt up and said whose first.

  • @durgaprasad4
    @durgaprasad4 5 років тому +237

    I'm big fan of Christine fair👍 she is the best analyst on South Asia

    • @p2mg
      @p2mg 5 років тому +1

      @Maqbool Rabbani lul...you are from pakistan i guess. where does your country stand in front of India? no one even listens to you...lol

    • @p2mg
      @p2mg 5 років тому +1

      @Maqbool Rabbani lol talk about Gandhi, what about Jinnah? He ate pig meat which is banned in Islam.
      So, when I talk stats you say everything is wrong and whatever you say is correct. This is another bullshit mentality of the pakistan. They will never accept the truth. Dude, do not tell me all about India's history as I know much and proud of it. Do not forgot your pakistan is a cut out of India so basically pakistan is like a son to India. Do no teach Father how to make babies.
      Under Muslim rule we were richest? I know you might have read that in your book in school because all it writes is fake content. India was rich way before Islam came to India, so go read some history from authentic books/source and not from pakistan school books.
      Look at this video from pakistan itself and not India:
      ua-cam.com/video/ebRki8sPM80/v-deo.html
      Please also watch part 2.
      Again as per the stats which I shared, Pakistan has more poverty than India as records show it. So let that settle into you while you read this.

    • @p2mg
      @p2mg 5 років тому +1

      @Maqbool Rabbani lol jinnah ate pig, see below:
      m.dailyhunt.in/news/india/english/the+samaja+english-epaper-samajen/jinnah+relished+pork+in+breakfast+here+are+11+unknown+facts+about+most+controversial+figure-newsid-87386851
      We are stopping beef exporters, slowly we will do it, do not worry. But more than beef export, you should stop terrorist export, please do that first before calling others. We are coward on killing minorities? Do you know Muslim population has increased in India and on the other hand Hindu population in Pakistan has decreased, almost nill since independence. So, who is killing minorities cowardly? Please read the Yemen operation which Indian Army did recently. Even USA was afraid to come to Yemen to rescue it citizens, but only India went there and rescued all. LOL, talk about coward, real coward people were seen in 1971 when almost 1 lkh pakistani soldiers surrendered.
      Our leader is ill? Have you forgotten surgical strike, please watch URI. Now, please do not say that where is proof. No country shows proofs of its military operation. Our PM has a wife if you do not know it, lol.
      Aur bhej kya bhejna hai sabka reply karta hu tuje aur pakistan ki aukat dikhata hu. All time beggar state.

    • @ashtonbailey3970
      @ashtonbailey3970 4 роки тому +1

      Prasad p v
      And she said India lied about the damage on Balacot & the F-16... so do you accept that India lied?

    • @ashtonbailey3970
      @ashtonbailey3970 4 роки тому +1

      TheIronMan987
      She is an idiot who says things just to sell her books & get paid interviews...of course something’s she says are right.. like exposing India lies & fake news

  • @sasmac1829
    @sasmac1829 5 років тому +192

    She is bluntly telling the truth

    • @manteshsharma3863
      @manteshsharma3863 4 роки тому +3

      @Vidya Sagar Rao she has been working in Pakistan, doing workshops, attending conferences talking everything she's talking in video ways before she released her books.
      She's not just selling her books, she's doing what she's been doing for entire of her life. That is "decoding Pak military and it's explicit use of terrorism to reach it's political objectives without getting into a real war that they know they'll lose anyways".
      And even if she's selling books, what's wrong in reading them when you're getting first hand information that no govt or agency or even media provides so articulately.

    • @shaukatbasit4357
      @shaukatbasit4357 3 роки тому +1

      Of course, she is an Indian lobbyist and gets paid to spew venom against Pakistan. By the way, she has a Pakistani army colonel boyfriend for almost 5 years before she was kidded out from Pakistan.

    • @mateen1979
      @mateen1979 3 роки тому

      She also told the truth that IAF was fucked by PAF. Believe her on that issue also

    • @humanbng7123
      @humanbng7123 2 роки тому

      @@shaukatbasit4357 lol you still can't take the truth 🤦🏻‍♂️
      Get out of that Pakistani media brainwashing

  • @rikbhattacharya5019
    @rikbhattacharya5019 5 років тому +29

    I'm following dr. Prof. C.F for quite a few years now, she is so honest that it hurts some people. I appreciate her tremendous depth of knowledge in her field, very few people have this kind of understanding or thought.

  • @sanjeevjoshi5555
    @sanjeevjoshi5555 5 років тому +74

    "Would the Americans put pressure on Pakistan?" Duh!!! Come on!!! What kind of a stupid lame question is that! For God's sake we are not a weak namby-pamby country! It time India learns to manage this on its own!! It's big enough and strong enough and efficient enough to do it!!

    • @ravi28948
      @ravi28948 5 років тому +3

      India can manage Pakistan on it's own but before that India will have neutralize (not literally) the anti India lobby (tukde tukde gang, left liberals, fake seculars, award waapsi gang etc etc) so that they don't raise head for 25 to 30 years.

    • @ManpreetKaur-we4fx
      @ManpreetKaur-we4fx 4 роки тому +2

      Actually India has been already doing that. Something else that people don't understand is that, its not that India is weak, its just that India is smart. They are being very patient with this whole Pakistan ordeal and avoiding war, because unlike Pakistan we have an actual economy to run. And look where it has gotten India? India is the fastest growing economy in the world while Pakistan is stuck with an economy worse than even lawless countries like Somalia. 👍🏻

    • @neelamshettye689
      @neelamshettye689 2 роки тому

      In her one of the videos she criticized us government too

  • @Blackfire970
    @Blackfire970 5 років тому +14

    She is so informative, intelligent and honesty very much like Subramanian swamy. Lots of Love and respect for her

  • @soumyakanti17
    @soumyakanti17 5 років тому +55

    I have read almost everything that Prof Fair has ever written. I have learnt so much thanks to her research. Looking forward to reading this book too.

  • @30moheb
    @30moheb 5 років тому +19

    Love and respect from Afghanistan to fair, she is really fair.

  • @brigdrsurendermohansharma3031
    @brigdrsurendermohansharma3031 5 років тому +22

    She is right and that is why Zia had to go as he was about to sign peace for ever with Rajiv Zia was killed by his Army colleagues. Peace with India will weaken Pakistan Army and hence the proxy war In Kashmir and terrorism all over.

    • @comictube1831
      @comictube1831 4 роки тому

      What’s your take on Rajiv murder?
      As we know Zia is killed by America with the help of Pak politicians

  • @ripudaman8
    @ripudaman8 5 років тому +95

    Only solution for peace is Pakistan's dismemberment which India should focus on ! Create internal & external circumstances for it like Ronald Reagan did with soveit union & be prepared to loose some battles to win the war

    • @victorverma7459
      @victorverma7459 5 років тому +6

      Agreed, wipe out pakistan as we know it.

    • @ripudaman8
      @ripudaman8 5 років тому +8

      @@victorverma7459 wipe out not by war but by smart moves to fast forward its collapse!

    • @drsober5730
      @drsober5730 5 років тому +3

      Hahah..
      Dear every body did that in last 10-15 years but look Pakistan is stonger than ever.

    • @ripudaman8
      @ripudaman8 5 років тому +6

      sober rubbish India's policy with Pakistan has always been defensive ! All wars were started by Pakistan, ik gujral destroyed India's intelligence networks in Pakistan! Now after the surgical strikes & appointment of ajit doval things r beginning to change

    • @basitchaudhary8217
      @basitchaudhary8217 5 років тому +1

      @Mr K 👍👌

  • @rajeshranjan5463
    @rajeshranjan5463 5 років тому +85

    She tells the truth about Pak coward army all example she explained is correct

    • @HamzaKhan-bc5xq
      @HamzaKhan-bc5xq 5 років тому

      But llzz don't hate normal.people in Pakistan
      We want peace

    • @Angrypatriot_1
      @Angrypatriot_1 4 роки тому +1

      @@HamzaKhan-bc5xq we hating on government not normal people.

  • @rcv3208
    @rcv3208 5 років тому +38

    Khangress must see this

  • @Napoleon4778
    @Napoleon4778 5 років тому +3

    This was at the Raisina Dialogue, Taj Hotel, New Delhi on 8 Jan 2019.

  • @151samm
    @151samm 5 років тому +5

    Exactly one month later terrorist attack happened in India it's like isi watched this video...

  • @justgrass3812
    @justgrass3812 5 років тому +13

    Her views are on point, yes i agree there won't be any peace, as Pakistani army won't have anything to fight after that, even though Indian and Afgani will continue to suffer looses , India will keep growing it's economy, keep upgrading its defense and keep getting stronger, so as our friend Afghanistan, when Pakistan finally come to realizing it will be too late, they will be surrounded by big players, isolated by international communities, it will be like cat and mouse fight. long live INDIA & AFGHANISTAN

    • @tajulariffin1979
      @tajulariffin1979 4 роки тому

      INDIA MUST GO OUT FRM KASHMIR. THE PEOPLE OF KASHMIR DON'T WANT TO BE PART OF STUPID HINDU INDIA COUNTRY. PLS UNDERSTAND THE KASHMIR PEOPLE DESIRE. PLS HOLD REFERENDUM UNDER THE U. N SUPERVISED IN THAT TERRITORY IF INDIA BRAVE ENOUGH. DON'T FORCE PEOPLE OF KASHMIR TO PART OF HINDU INDIA STATE.

  • @djoys7738
    @djoys7738 5 років тому +21

    Knowledgeble author on South Asia. Army which canot win war is understandable but its army which donot work. Does its duty through terror groups. Remember every war ends with pak army running away leaving dead n injured behind & pm seen begging in washington to stop war. Pathetic army of failed state.

    • @mubashirkhan1427
      @mubashirkhan1427 5 років тому +1

      Conclusively, India lost an equal scale of territory to us in 1948 war (today's Azad Kashmir). So we're kind of even now.
      India claimed the whole J&K, on the basis of Instrument of accession by the then ruler of J&K, Hari Singh, right after Partition of India. Pakistan rejected it and invaded J&K with full strength. Pakistan successfully defeated the Indian forces and captured 40% area of J&K Valley. Indian forces lost the battle in J&K, and to stop the invading forces of Pakistan, seeked the help of UN to save rest of J&K Valley, . Or in other words if India was dominant in 1947 war, it would have taken all of the J&K valley under its control, which is legally part of India as per the instrument of accession (at least as per Indian claims), rather than intervening UN for cease fire and ultimately giving up 40% area of “Integral part of India”, which is under Pakistan control as of to date, in form of Azad Kashmir and Gilgit-Baltistan.
      In 1965, Pakistan successfully invaded IOK, and defeated all Indian opposition there, India was not able to defend J&K from Pak forces, India lost the Battle in J&K, and to subvert the attention of Pakistan from J&K, it invaded International borders of Pakistan, but could not successfully capture any of Pakistan’s major City as a negotiating tool to get Kashmir valley freed from Pakistani Militants. Instead India suffered heavy losses from retaliatory of Pakistan on international borders as well. Specifically in Air battle. whilst PAF had an air superiority over IAF in ratio 1:4. Indo-Pakistani Air War of 1965. India got the Indian occupied Kashmir freed from Pakistan backed forces, finally by seeking USSR intervention, which ensured to relieve Indian occupied Kashmir from Pakistan, and was handed back to India. Tashkent Declaration.
      1971- A Transparent clean sweep victory of India- But at the same time formation of Bangladesh is more internal political failure of Pakistan, rather than Military victory of India or in other words if Zulfikar Ali Bhutto (Perspective candidate of PM from west Pakistan) would have allowed Sheikh Mujibur Rehman (Perspective candidate of PM from East Pakistan) to form Govt, which was his legal and constitutional right, India would have no way able to put Bangladesh on worlds map.
      In 1999, Pakistan invaded successfully Indian Occupied Kashmir from Kargil sector. Captured its key peaks and blocked only national highway NH-1 connecting the three parts of J&K Valley Srinagar (Kashmir valley), Kargil (Drass) and Laddakh (Leh)-India was NOT able to push back Pakistani intruders, and instead of in this attempt India suffered heavy casualties Kargil War. Even got short of coffins for their killed soldiers Kargil coffin scam. India again lost the battle in Kargil sector, and was NOT able to get their peaks back from Pakistani intruders and seeked help from US and Israel, to get this job done. Foreign relations of the United States.
      So India has lost all the wars from Pakistan, except the Indo-Pakistani War of 1971.
      Not to forget the multiple times smaller size of Pakistan from India, in geographical area, population, economy, and consequently in military size and strength.
      I hope it serves.
      Proof of coward indian soldier.
      ua-cam.com/video/C9czRHRGEHc/v-deo.html
      ua-cam.com/video/Q02_NtuM0AI/v-deo.html
      ua-cam.com/video/3j7WY0rUdxE/v-deo.html

  • @diogenes7419
    @diogenes7419 5 років тому +3

    Jeez she's so blunt..
    am gonna buy her book right away..

  • @anilthapliyal1
    @anilthapliyal1 5 років тому +2

    *She is so... Intelligent & I feel the Government should use her for future plans against Pakistan*

  • @Radiance1324
    @Radiance1324 5 років тому

    Amazing and eye opening interview. Dr. Fair must be interviewed on major Indian and US channels. Great wealth of knowledge on the region.

  • @arjuntomar215
    @arjuntomar215 5 років тому +3

    quoting her line "it have a army that can't win a war , it have nukes that they can't use, so they use these proxies under nuclear umbrella". great conslusion within one line . bow down to your devotion to the study/understanding of south Asia. may god bless you

    • @zeekspy1
      @zeekspy1 3 роки тому

      aww baby happy on the nukes comments. :-D

  • @sanjaybhatikar
    @sanjaybhatikar 4 роки тому +3

    Thank you, Christine. You are the voice of reason.

  • @prithvithegame
    @prithvithegame 5 років тому

    thanks for the vid , it was actually a a really good and informative watch !

  • @artificialization
    @artificialization 5 років тому

    Thanks Professor for the interview. Looking forward for the next

  • @panyaikam9208
    @panyaikam9208 5 років тому +6

    She is such an amazing lady ❤️

  • @YRU6S
    @YRU6S 5 років тому +3

    she was kicked out of Pakistan

  • @geetap4098
    @geetap4098 5 років тому +8

    Wow - sorry Imran and Trumo you’re not getting the Nobel peace prize:)

  • @arsalan208
    @arsalan208 5 років тому +2

    She got kicked out from Pakistan.. what else do u expect from this lady

    • @jaihind5454
      @jaihind5454 5 років тому

      Teri kyo fat rahi hai phir.

  • @123lenu
    @123lenu 5 років тому +13

    Christine Knows more about the terrorists group in Pakistan than India & pak. India should use her extensive experience in counter strategies.

    • @srmohanty7460
      @srmohanty7460 5 років тому +1

      Dont underestimate our analysts

    • @123lenu
      @123lenu 5 років тому +4

      @@srmohanty7460 : no disrespect to indian agencies. ajit doval and his team are doing the best. However CF worked in PAK, she has out of box ideas, though she is emotional, we can learn a bit or 2 from her.

    • @srmohanty7460
      @srmohanty7460 5 років тому

      @@123lenu yeah

  • @letstalk7
    @letstalk7 5 років тому +4

    Now she will tagged as bhakts by some chamchas!!

  • @Dreamcatcher0007
    @Dreamcatcher0007 5 років тому +1

    Woow... so true Ma'am. Look at the situation now.

  • @neerajkumar-ti5zq
    @neerajkumar-ti5zq 5 років тому +4

    Now congress will say that she is frm bjp.. Hahaha

  • @josephfernandez9521
    @josephfernandez9521 5 років тому +5

    Bless you Christine

  • @srikanthmandala6880
    @srikanthmandala6880 5 років тому +3

    She nailed it wow

  • @anilsinha4968
    @anilsinha4968 5 років тому +1

    This is the most blunt interview on Indo Pak relations.

  • @Vikram-mu1lb
    @Vikram-mu1lb 5 років тому +2

    Wow. Bold and strict to the topic. Expert and vry knowledgeable women.

  • @amitabhakassap7339
    @amitabhakassap7339 5 років тому +3

    There can never be peace bet India & Pakistan. The Pak military industry won't allow it.

  • @ZIA5181
    @ZIA5181 5 років тому +18

    She said indian will continue to die,lol

    • @laltopicomedy7691
      @laltopicomedy7691 5 років тому

      take her seriously, unbiased

    • @gabbar51ngh
      @gabbar51ngh 5 років тому +5

      Don't worry east Pakistan liya hai, Baluchistan bhi lenge

    • @bilaltanoli1283
      @bilaltanoli1283 5 років тому +1

      @@gabbar51ngh Pakistan jis trah India ko cheer k nikala hum NY aese hi khalistan b banaengy bhut jldi

    • @gabbar51ngh
      @gabbar51ngh 5 років тому +4

      @@bilaltanoli1283 you guys are begging right now.
      Only reason Pakistan even exists because China is helping.

    • @asthasingh2899
      @asthasingh2899 5 років тому +3

      @@bilaltanoli1283 jaise tumor Ko body se cheer k nikalte hain , Pakistan Ko India se Nikal fenka gya. And Khalistan is a wet dream of Pakistan lol.

  • @raknoknak
    @raknoknak 5 років тому

    Nice interview.. though wasnt expecting the bizzare twist in the end with road fatalities.. completely unrelated :)

  • @SuperVictortango
    @SuperVictortango 4 роки тому

    How intelligent and clear thinking!!! God bless such great diplomatic ND so highly intelligent ppl...

  • @IndianMusic.shorts
    @IndianMusic.shorts 5 років тому +7

    Mam gd work but be safe these Islamic mindset may target you God bless you

  • @laksh1686
    @laksh1686 5 років тому +11

    She knows the real face of our naughty neighbor.........

    • @kashifrana7975
      @kashifrana7975 5 років тому

      India will be overtaken by muslims and christians soon and Hinduism is dying

    • @kashifrana7975
      @kashifrana7975 5 років тому

      @Sai Krishna we took Bangladesh and Pakistan Afghanistan mecca medina Indonesia Malaysia from u and all these were Hindu lands once hahahahahahahahaha and now we will take over India as well. 250 million Muslims in India and growing and inshallah 500 million Muslims by 2050.

  • @ashtonbailey3970
    @ashtonbailey3970 4 роки тому +2

    She is definitely got an axe to grind with Pakistan for being thrown out!

  • @suerayss
    @suerayss 5 років тому

    gosh i have so many questions. the lady just stands there without asking Qs.

  • @kartikeymishra2608
    @kartikeymishra2608 5 років тому +3

    Don't know who is she but saying like congress and leftist..

    • @sunil4958
      @sunil4958 5 років тому

      @TheArcade12 you and Mishra are both wrong. She has spoken up for India and her analysis of the situation is perfect. She's not anybody's stooge. She cannot speak for America too. In fact, she's clear that US should not provide any aid to Pakistan because pakistan cannot be trusted.

    • @sunil4958
      @sunil4958 5 років тому

      @TheArcade12 Indian government hasn't bothered about her but she has done good analysis. I have seen many of her videos and she is very clear that pakistan will not change. She also says Pak is giving India a thousand cuts under nuclear threats but India should not be cowed down by this threat and should retaliate against Pak. Only then Pak will learn. I agree with her 💯%.

    • @sunil4958
      @sunil4958 5 років тому

      @TheArcade12 Doesn't matter which party as long as her support to India helps others in her country to look upon India favourably. Only then support for Pak will come down drastically. Anyway, earlier Reagan and Kissinger we're totally against India. Now US is pro India but still doesn't take Pak to task on terrorism against India. At least, US has stopped giving money to Pak which was ultimately used against India.

    • @sunil4958
      @sunil4958 5 років тому

      @TheArcade12 I said I saw many videos and her analysis about Pak is spot on. In this case, it's not 2 lines as you suggest. I haven't seen what she said about China but it's irrelevant here as this is solely about India Pak.

  • @krshnad3130
    @krshnad3130 5 років тому +5

    Wow.... That was quite informative...
    Free baluchistan...

  • @KB-uv7wj
    @KB-uv7wj 5 років тому

    It's people like her who use their brains and research in highlighting serious issues which are facing our world. Everything she said is so believable and true. India has been banging about this for ages.

  • @rahulyelwe106
    @rahulyelwe106 5 років тому

    Last week she was in my class. She presented research paper on Lashkar E Toiba itself. She is really intellectual

  • @indiaindia905
    @indiaindia905 5 років тому +3

    POORKUKOSOSTAN

  • @Raja-Chib
    @Raja-Chib 5 років тому +9

    That lady needs a haircut and a psychiatrist

    • @sayanray8073
      @sayanray8073 5 років тому +1

      Do as u preach .. u need it too ..

    • @manikarnika9690
      @manikarnika9690 5 років тому +1

      @Udayan Mitra true

    • @TheSarge4u
      @TheSarge4u 5 років тому +1

      Focus on the content not her butt size you pervert

    • @Raja-Chib
      @Raja-Chib 5 років тому

      @Krishna well there will be no second chance for you subhuman species. Your ashes will flowing in already polluted yamna river.

    • @nandusimba6774
      @nandusimba6774 5 років тому +1

      Dirty bearded mullahs in even dirtier salwars talking haircuts!!! As for psychiatrist, you have done your country proud by spelling it correct.

  • @rohitbiswas1941
    @rohitbiswas1941 5 років тому +1

    Omg! She predicted the future about setting the watch for the next terror attack after a peace call from Pakistan. She looked over the Pakistan more than us. Amazing!

  • @shreyash225
    @shreyash225 5 років тому +1

    "You can set your watch for a next terror attack.", terrifying but true.

    • @MohanK1074
      @MohanK1074 2 роки тому

      Within few weeks Pulwama happened !

  • @Michael-xn7ld
    @Michael-xn7ld 5 років тому +2

    I have always admired you Christine, not because you speak candidly but its your analysis and to be able to analyze the way you do requires critical thinking, given the scope of knowledge you posses about the different elements in porkistan you must have spent countless hours, why aren't you recognized by the Indian or US government.
    My hats off to you, sweetheart.

  • @shashanktripathi3398
    @shashanktripathi3398 4 роки тому +3

    no comments by Indian muslims against their jihadi brothers in pakistan.

  • @indranilmandal4496
    @indranilmandal4496 5 років тому +1

    Well I have to read every book now

  • @rahulraichand6963
    @rahulraichand6963 5 років тому +1

    I have read her work on south asia.. Amazingly deep

  • @priyamkar5784
    @priyamkar5784 5 років тому

    you are so correct madam.... just after 1 one month of this video being uploaded the pulwama attack happened ....you are right as indian we must be wary of a pakistani PM Bearing peace

  • @SunilYadav-th1wb
    @SunilYadav-th1wb 4 роки тому +2

    Future of India and Pakistan as neighbours!
    They will continue this fight while purchasing weapons from the same countries.

  • @ghufranshareef8384
    @ghufranshareef8384 4 роки тому

    Nalson Mandala was declared a terrorist and 27 years put into the jail, then the same man by same people was awarded Noble price of peace. This is the history of American educated people.

  • @Bruisader
    @Bruisader 4 роки тому

    Doc. Ur discussion with that Pakistani based reporter was awesome. I think that was in U.N. . Salute to u .

  • @shailajaupadhyay3506
    @shailajaupadhyay3506 4 роки тому

    Wow.. perfect analysis.. great job.. 👍🏻👍🏻

  • @TheAaref
    @TheAaref 5 років тому

    An indian anchor interviewing an indian-supported author liked by indians. very good balance!

  • @rjyasir6
    @rjyasir6 5 років тому +1

    Wow! I must say she is very intelligent and very well paid by india.

  • @cmcjss
    @cmcjss 5 років тому

    Wow. What clarity!!

  • @vickywanderer8231
    @vickywanderer8231 5 років тому +1

    She predicted the Pulwama attack.

  • @user-kp5ps7gj8b
    @user-kp5ps7gj8b 5 років тому

    Christine back again.. She always amazes me.. Brilliant understanding of Pakistan and India she has.

  • @sharath1857
    @sharath1857 5 років тому +1

    So even if we have to put up with this to improve our economy, the reason why we improve our economy is to make our defense stronger.So ultimately our military needs to step in at some point, right?

  • @Ms-ux8rb
    @Ms-ux8rb 5 років тому +1

    Hope Bakha, Rajdeep, Sagarika and others listening abt Pakistani Peace gesture

  • @prateekkolurmatada8679
    @prateekkolurmatada8679 5 років тому

    She literally said Prime minister Imran khan is irrelevant..his power is nothing against the militant group 😂

  • @nivv3726
    @nivv3726 4 роки тому +2

    Please do not the forget the number of road accidents in america compared to 7/11.
    Road accidents don't justify any terror of any form

    • @stuarthastie6374
      @stuarthastie6374 4 роки тому

      Niv V India would do well to spend on roads and traffic cops. And I force a practical Highway Code with high fines. All would benefit.

  • @drrajmmc
    @drrajmmc 5 років тому

    Wow what a speech. Bold and right to the point

  • @GurjinderSingh12390
    @GurjinderSingh12390 4 роки тому

    She hesitated to answer when she was asked why doesn't usa intervene b/w two countries to settle for peace.

  • @anchornaturals
    @anchornaturals 4 роки тому

    That was a brilliant discourse. Thank you Professor.

  • @IrfanMatloob
    @IrfanMatloob 5 років тому +1

    I was thinking she has knowledge but after listen to her my conclusion is she knows nothing at all. Ground reality is completely different.

  • @gautammalik9316
    @gautammalik9316 2 роки тому +1

    The only woman speaking out the reality of Pakistan Catherine thank you so much for exposing this rogue state we r in debited to you

  • @mukeshkumar-hi9xt
    @mukeshkumar-hi9xt 5 років тому +1

    rightly pointed by a western writer which is already known to major think tank, forces etc. in India (except some political parties) for quite some time regarding flawed peace overtures made by pakistani PM.

  • @PawanKsaini80
    @PawanKsaini80 5 років тому

    Wish any of our bloody Netas have such understanding of dynamics and guts to say it.

  • @kshis13
    @kshis13 5 років тому

    I think being an American, from miles away, she has totally understood and clearly pointed out the malaise in our government.

  • @thecrabpulsar
    @thecrabpulsar 5 років тому

    The professor is talking plain, straight facts without sugar coating words. I hope Indian govt can learn from her research and experience dealing with Pakistan.

  • @priyadarshisamantasinghar9911
    @priyadarshisamantasinghar9911 5 років тому

    I have personally never liked an American of their so called 'jis taraf barish us taraf chatri' policies.....but I have become a fan of you ma'am! Concise, precise, to the point and factual! Thanks!

  • @soumyakantaskp5723
    @soumyakantaskp5723 5 років тому

    She exactly says it. Right after 1month of her interview there happened pulwama terror attack. The Pak army won't allow peace between both countries

  • @igniteindia6437
    @igniteindia6437 4 роки тому +1

    ISI it cell is pissed off by this video all the pigs are in the comment section 😂😂

  • @sanjaynenwani6974
    @sanjaynenwani6974 5 років тому

    Mam There is distinctive difference between a car accident victim n Terrorist attack victim.

  • @shivaayaum9577
    @shivaayaum9577 5 років тому

    It needs guts to accept the truth and even more, to elucidate it....She has them all

  • @Prasannakumar-yk7bf
    @Prasannakumar-yk7bf 4 роки тому

    Christine Fair dodged the question about what Americans can do to pressurise the Pakistani Army.

  • @deka0014
    @deka0014 5 років тому

    The last argument was so stupid that it discredited her completely.

  • @gazzy2012ga
    @gazzy2012ga 5 років тому +1

    Who's watching this after the PAK airforce shot down 3 IAF jets ? 😂😂😂😂😂

  • @arkaprabha.chakraborty
    @arkaprabha.chakraborty 5 років тому

    She went to Pakistan, I am stunned. She is Brave.

  • @nitovatorsnitj
    @nitovatorsnitj Рік тому

    Christine Fair is one of the most genuine analyst. She do have reservations about Indian RW as well, but she has genuinely taken sides with India.

  • @DEEPAKKumar-uh3iv
    @DEEPAKKumar-uh3iv 5 років тому

    Always pleasure to hear from you mam, 👏👏👏👏

  • @sanjitswain4991
    @sanjitswain4991 5 років тому

    Very blunt & honest reaction .

  • @virginiaplain100
    @virginiaplain100 5 років тому

    Talk about timing. This shows up in my recommended feed, days after the #Pulwama attack.

  • @hemanthkothari8658
    @hemanthkothari8658 4 роки тому

    Really appriciate the depth of her knowledge

  • @zeeshansaikia5662
    @zeeshansaikia5662 5 років тому

    So true. Indians were gonna die but sad part is that we don't have a permanent solution, any answer for that.

  • @markluma98
    @markluma98 5 років тому +2

    Christine is bang on with her observation about the peace talks getting interrupted by terror attacks ! Its a set pattern because the Pakistan Army doesn't want any peace talks. They just want status quo which is in best interest for them as it keeps getting them military/ financial aid from US !

  • @vikaspanchal8015
    @vikaspanchal8015 5 років тому +1

    I always love to listen her views. She is a well learned lady and great author. She is a gem 😁

    • @faisalsohail5424
      @faisalsohail5424 3 роки тому

      Vikas Panchal not well learned it’s well scripted