It was a good reasonable question. The EU will not trade freely and openly with Scotland. Rubbish if the majority of Scots wanted independance you would have had it when you had a vote. Which showed the majority of people wanted to remain a member of GB.
UK EU trade has decreased by over £80B since Brexit Scotland still maintains a Trade surplus even if Scotland was to join EFTA Scotland would secure a future. As your comment is complete Propaganda in terms of any future trading relationship with the EU block you have to accept that not one parish in Scotland Voted to leave the EU. England has done nothing post Brexit for Scotland Economy or wellbeing.
@@vincescotian8083 Your data isn't showing any proof of your asserted figure. You also failed to show how and when a separate Scotland could join the EU,given we have never been a member country as we were in EU as Part of the UK. Finally, you omitted to say that approximately one third of snp members voted to leave.
You cant argue with those who think they have freedom of thought yet repeat everything their flawed idealogical leaders state , it doesnt matter its complete pie in the sky conjecture they believe it as it makes them feel they have someone in power who loves them
They have had all the tools they needed to encourage trade and improve the economy . It is the spectre and uncertainty of independence that has frightened off potential investors in Scotland. Swinney is wrong ….dead wrong .
Hes had a fabulous 2 weeks going round the country, did he mention all the millions that are missing. Austerity does that mean money thats been pocketed.
Don't know why they need more care workers they have already lost what it is, 2,600 elderly died in care homes. Due to this government and their DNRs. Im sure my dad was one of them. Never forget😢
Wonder why they are teaching primary school kids about genders. Why would you do that. Whats in it for them. Any answers SNP supporters. Can you explain, please. Im confused.
Why are they having to hand back nearly a half a billion £s to the EU which should have been used for the benefit of the Scottish people, perhaps they were hoping that no one would notice and forget about it.
@@EdwardLowe-qv6yk no Tory’s have ruined the nhs , economic mid management, wages stagnant and child poverty up last 14 years …. Will vote to get them both out
"The SNP has it's difficulties, that's why I'm here, and we are getting out of those difficulties." Yes John all those SNP MPs who lost their seats certainly have got out of their difficulties.
What he blithely ignores is that the last Scottish Election, (Nicola Sturgeon's words during the hustings) wasn't about independence but getting Scotland through covid.
Alright for Swinney with his £800 silk shirt with stiff white collar attached, and he wasn't even a Hedge Fund Manager. Maybe it was bought on the £58000 Taxpayers credit card we hear less about.
It'll happen if labour get in. They want to bring in 1000s of Palestinians. There will be Mosques everywhere. Maybe we could build more churches. I'll bet they won't
Scottish primary schools appoint children as 'LGBT champions' and are being encouraged to 'ask pupils if they are gay, lesbian or trans Daily mail online
Whats wrong with the barnett formula where Scotland get a great deal never hear snp mention it swinney was hopless before that salmond had to come back mind he was known as honest John why did he delete the texts he knew he was meant to keep also shows hes weak look at the Matheson affair 11000 grand roaming charges impossible 1 game 120mins max and he tries to back him
we are not all ignorant snp children, there are more people in Scotland that hate the snp and will never forgive them for what they have imposed on our great country, snp are despised by many Scots. GB.
Brilliant, you doing the deleting of different opinions, typical cult member. Remember to keep taking that Buckie and unicorn juice mix.!! And Matheson is still a self confessed LIAR and THIEF.!!
You getting the thought police to delete my comments.?? Keep quaffing the Buckie and unicorn juice mix. And Matheson is still a self confessed LIAR and THIEF.!!!!
He’s an absolute liar! About migration 🙄🤡🌍
Sharia incoming
Just answer the bloody question?
😂😂😂😂
Dream on John Swinney. What has the SNP done for Scotland other than bring it to its knees.
What a pathetic bunch. Never want to be questioned on anything do they?
Only questions that he has set up will be asked, what an a*sehole.
They are desperate to join EU expansion.
Amazing how they jump to applaud the new 'leader' like sheep'?
They are indi supporters
Cult
Bahhhh humbug
@@andrewrobertson3737 delinquents inn the snp support and all of snp members, idiocy in the extreme.
Do Sheep applaud anything?
I’ll be happy when I don’t need to hear them ever again because they don’t have a clue
Yes they do they are doing what ever their Real Masters tell them to Do
I counted nine...9.. "nows".... and still he answered the question with total untruths and nonsense.
It was a good reasonable question. The EU will not trade freely and openly with Scotland. Rubbish if the majority of Scots wanted independance you would have had it when you had a vote. Which showed the majority of people wanted to remain a member of GB.
UK EU trade has decreased by over £80B since Brexit Scotland still maintains a Trade surplus even if Scotland was to join EFTA Scotland would secure a future. As your comment is complete Propaganda in terms of any future trading relationship with the EU block you have to accept that not one parish in Scotland Voted to leave the EU. England has done nothing post Brexit for Scotland Economy or wellbeing.
@@vincescotian8083 Your data isn't showing any proof of your asserted figure.
You also failed to show how and when a separate Scotland could join the EU,given we have never been a member country as we were in EU as Part of the UK.
Finally, you omitted to say that approximately one third of snp members voted to leave.
@@vincescotian8083 You post utter crap! does lying come naturally to you?
You cant argue with those who think they have freedom of thought yet repeat everything their flawed idealogical leaders state , it doesnt matter its complete pie in the sky conjecture they believe it as it makes them feel they have someone in power who loves them
I see he's got his brainwashed herd in front of him 😅
They have had all the tools they needed to encourage trade and improve the economy . It is the spectre and uncertainty of independence that has frightened off potential investors in Scotland. Swinney is wrong ….dead wrong .
Hes had a fabulous 2 weeks going round the country, did he mention all the millions that are missing. Austerity does that mean money thats been pocketed.
Is this what we have come to ? ffs
If the SNP had a lie box instead of a swear box...eh?
Harps on about 'democracy' whilst casually ignoring the result of the independence referendum.
If I were to agree with the SNP leader then we'd both be wrong!
The reason we're short of social care workers is because there's so many immigrants legal and illegal taking up hospital beds etc
And housing…
Just about sums up the snp pond life.
The SNP has inflicted division and hatred in my country. I will never forgive them.
Tell us again about the good job you did when you were .Education minister ?
@@duncanmackenzie5684 your point is
Me neither
Wakey Wakey
Blame everyone else but not take any responsibility
Surly if we split from the uk we would have left the uk internal market and the eu at the same time as Scotland was not in the eu
Don't know why they need more care workers they have already lost what it is, 2,600 elderly died in care homes. Due to this government and their DNRs. Im sure my dad was one of them. Never forget😢
Big dishonest john ....your finished
We have made wonderful progress so far with SNP. Not.
VOTE REFORM
Walloper
YOU THE SNP WILL BE UNDER THE RULE OF THE EU, NOT RULING YOURSELVES
They should be in prison for their corruption, even just for their stupidity.
That young kid that’s making the noise is also making more sense than Swinneys drivel.
John swinney has the demeanour of a 6 year old trying to be grown up.
Wonder why they are teaching primary school kids about genders. Why would you do that. Whats in it for them. Any answers SNP supporters. Can you explain, please. Im confused.
It's called grooming.
Grooming at a national level and the public have turned a blind eye to these disgusting deviant works.
Aye nae bother spinney
Blah, blah, blah, blah….. it’s honestly like Charlie Brown’s teacher
Why are they having to hand back nearly a half a billion £s to the EU which should have been used for the benefit of the Scottish people, perhaps they were hoping that no one would notice and forget about it.
They’ve probably spent it all on another one of their ‘pie-in-the-sky’, schemes!!
snp out!
Also the tories out
Hes practising for communism.
Should be practicing for the Clink.
Learn how to run Scotland properly first ‼️
Those CLOWNS could not run a bath never mind a country
His month's a' broon!
Wot a pryk.
SNP in chaos and will lose half there seats , Tory’s in Scotland will be lucky to win one seat …. 2 parties in meltdown up here
Then vote Tory to get rid of SNP, it's in your hands.
@@EdwardLowe-qv6yk no Tory’s have ruined the nhs , economic mid management, wages stagnant and child poverty up last 14 years …. Will vote to get them both out
Well done, John x
Truth hurts doesn’t it 🤷♂️🇬🇧🏴
let scotland go and see what a mess they end up in!!!
Yeah let’s let Scotland go. A nation who have fought in the British Army through two world wars for Britain. My family are in this category. Response?
No chance… we’re better off has a United Kingdom.
No worse than we are with England and the tories we want our freedom
Boring boring boring
There is a Reform UK candidate for Inverclyde and Renfrewshire west. Vote Reform
Is there one in North Ayrshire
Its a cult! Pure and simple!😂
Same old, nothing new.
There's that bloody finger pointing again, will somebody tell that man how rude he is.
Liar
I am independent already. We're outwardly facing as GB!
"The SNP has it's difficulties, that's why I'm here, and we are getting out of those difficulties." Yes John all those SNP MPs who lost their seats certainly have got out of their difficulties.
All prays the Scottish that have been chosen to be the sacrificial lamp for diversity, i salute you as the ship goes down
That is new, when did he have this change.?
Cant wait
Independence is coming ❤
Can't waot
Can't wait
Bring back boris
😂😂😂😂 a comedian
we have no need to be part of the EU as a member of EFTA you have automatic trade with the EU without the costs of the EU
Keep having the referendum, until you get independence, and then make sure such a vote to re-join is never had. What a guy!
We will never stop ❤
@@Heather-zk5eu never stop hating, that's true.
Who has ever asked to rejoin ?
@@Heather-zk5eu rejoin what?
What he blithely ignores is that the last Scottish Election, (Nicola Sturgeon's words during the hustings) wasn't about independence but getting Scotland through covid.
How can 1man talk so much rubbish
Alright for Swinney with his £800 silk shirt with stiff white collar attached, and he wasn't even a Hedge Fund Manager. Maybe it was bought on the £58000 Taxpayers credit card we hear
less about.
His next suit will have birdies foot prints all over it
Not a cult though...
Liz truss for Scotland lol
Lol
Except thats not what happened. Typical sun making up lies.
They did boo 😅
Slavers some pish baldy git
Heckle rather than Boo'ing.
@@blackislepeastoo she probably forgot her puberty blockers this morning 🌈
Swinney snps swan song bye bye
Ano ruined their chances years ago
His shiny head is blinding the media.
His heed doubles as a solar panel 😆
@@soapmc5412 pity the heed doesn’t say resign.
SNP - beyond satire…
If snp have there way. We will be like Ireland with planes full of immigrants landing by the hour. They will replace us within a weak.
Agree
It is happening in Scotland but not to the extent of Ireland 🇮🇪 🏴
It'll happen if labour get in. They want to bring in 1000s of Palestinians. There will be Mosques everywhere. Maybe we could build more churches. I'll bet they won't
Bawbag
Ive not heard a single answer with any substance or any measurable figures/performance
Scottish primary schools appoint children as 'LGBT champions' and are being encouraged to 'ask pupils if they are gay, lesbian or trans
Daily mail online
If Scotland gets independence is the snp going to start blaming Brussels for their failure
No, they'll still blame the English. They can't help it. The delicious bitterness is fuel to them.
Of course!!!
It's Boris's fault, had to be someones not krankie, dumza or swinehunt.
Everyone gushing over him is actually quite sickening. Proper cult
Hes DELUDED beyond belief
Independence but we want to take orders from EU😆👀🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧
What’s the chance of getting the ferry on the water
He's a joke.
Tripe, balderdash and rubbish! I detest SNP and everything about them!
Stage set
Rubbish 😊
Whats wrong with the barnett formula where Scotland get a great deal never hear snp mention it swinney was hopless before that salmond had to come back mind he was known as honest John why did he delete the texts he knew he was meant to keep also shows hes weak look at the Matheson affair 11000 grand roaming charges impossible 1 game 120mins max and he tries to back him
Didn’t try… he backed him all the way!!!
Top ranker
This man was sturgeons number 2
Wake up your not that stupid
Or has the cult had you and your cash
Hes not called honest john for nothing
I think the UK will have something to say about the oil and gas
Kicking about 😂😂😂
Can the SNP booing tell us where the EU £450million is...as they want it back...
The gathering?? There can be only one.:::
JS to his credit started off well. I never watched the rest because I think he is a weak politician punching WWWAAAAYYYYYY above his weight
He is a headcase
Great' let's get rid of the Scotch B'stardes and keep OUR money south of the border!
we are not all ignorant snp children, there are more people in Scotland that hate the snp and will never forgive them for what they have imposed on our great country, snp are despised by many Scots. GB.
Can't wait for the scots to be their own Country once again
And the English ones
And the English ones and the tories
And the English ones and the tories
Well lets pray and hope its no in yr partys pocket just heard snp mp to be searched Dry bath what it's called Scotland everywhere money is involved
🥱
❤
Laugh! Union Scotland v's Scotland freedom! :)
@@alexanderhendry5819 Laugh, vote 2024 :)
Like I just said, still quaffing the Buckie and unicorn juice mix.!!!
And again Matheson is still a self confessed LIAR and THIEF.!!!
Still quaffing the Buckie and unicorn juice mix.!!!
And Matheson is still a self confessed LIAR and THIEF.!!
Brilliant, you doing the deleting of different opinions, typical cult member.
Remember to keep taking that Buckie and unicorn juice mix.!!
And Matheson is still a self confessed LIAR and THIEF.!!
A while since we heard from you Karen.
"The Scottish Sun" union! :)
Still quaffing the Buckie and unicorn juice mix I see.!!!
Oh.!!! and Matheson is still a self confessed LIAR and THIEF.!!!!!
Just keep quaffing the Buckie and unicorn juice mix.!!
Oh.!! and Matheson is still a self confessed LIAR and THIEF.!!!
You getting the thought police to delete my comments.??
Keep quaffing the Buckie and unicorn juice mix.
And Matheson is still a self confessed LIAR and THIEF.!!!!
All corrupt wear expensive collarless white silk shirts.
Och! He looks OK - for an Old Tortoise, that is.