3 iron vs 5 Wood Which One is BEST?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 вер 2024
  • Should you carry a 3 iron or a 5 wood? Know which one is right for you.
    Shop 7Diamonds Here ▶ bit.ly/7Diamon...
    Use Code: MRSHORTGAME
    USE CODE: MRSHORTGAME
    Subscribe to our Newsletter Here ▶ bit.ly/33abas3
    PRIVATE MEMBERSHIP ▶ members.mrshor...
    More Gear Here! ▶ www.amazon.com...
    Please Subscribe ▶ bit.ly/2FaDvFG
    FOLLOW ME:
    Podcast ▶ bit.ly/2krE0T0
    Instagram ▶ / mrshortgame
    Twitter ▶ / mrshortgame
    Website ▶ www.mrshortgame...
    ⚠️ Disclaimer: Some of the links in this description are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links you'll help support the channel at no additional cost to you. Win/Win! Thanks!

КОМЕНТАРІ • 64

  • @llama5357
    @llama5357 Рік тому +6

    Recently saw your video for the "Rule of 3's" and tried it out on the course today. Shot a 71 and broke par for the first time ever! Thanks a ton for the help!

  • @mrsusan893
    @mrsusan893 Рік тому +5

    3 iron is more consistent for me than a hybrid. I can hit the 3 iron high, low and shape it left or right. I've given hybrids a go but I just tame them.

  • @vitamind2387
    @vitamind2387 Рік тому +3

    I have both a 3 hybrid and 5 wood, best decision I ever made. Now, I have both a 5 wood and 3 hybrid which some might say is a waste of space because the yardages are almost the same but I love it. My 5 wood is great off the tee and fairway. The 3 hybrid is going about the same distance but it launches great out of the rough. Basically I use my 5 wood when I have a clean lie and my 3 hybrid is the rough “get out of jail” card. Also, my 5 wood is great for high launch but if I need to keep the ball down for a punch or out of the wind I grab the 3 hybrid.

  • @lens7859
    @lens7859 Рік тому +3

    Just added a 7 wood , as a senior golfer it helps tremendously ! My lowest iron is now the 5.

  • @Golfadddict
    @Golfadddict Рік тому +6

    5 wood lands softly. Excellent and straight off the tee. Much more versatile,e off the deck 😊 :-)

  • @ralpho58
    @ralpho58 Рік тому +10

    Hey MSG, should you have compared the 3 iron with a 3 hybrid? You’re hitting the 5 wood 30 yds further than the 3 iron. What about distance gapping.

  • @sfink16
    @sfink16 Рік тому +2

    I'll have to try a 5 wood. Currently I use a 3 and 4 hybrid, and a 3 wood. 40 years ago I used to use a 1 iron off the tee, 2 iron, and 3 iron. I lost a lot of distance over the years.

  • @bonolomodisetv
    @bonolomodisetv Рік тому +2

    Great advise, thanks Matt. Been wondering why I struggle with my 5 wood, I’ll need to practice more of my 4 iron 👌🏽

  • @claytonpetree527
    @claytonpetree527 Рік тому +2

    The manufacturers have really mislead us, IMO, with the jacked lofts. This season I have 300 forged in the bag with the shorter irons bent weak. So 3-49* PW. Plus I can still play 56/60 AND a 5w AND a 3w driver, and putter. The new crap is set up so you have to play a gap and the lofts are too close 4-G, IMO. I really enjoyed your video on the bag setup...

  • @fretless05
    @fretless05 Рік тому +1

    I actually replaced my 4i with a 5W. For me, it was all about club-head speed (or lack of it) and gapping. My 4i just didn't go enough longer than my 5i and the 5W was just easier to hit at a good distance to bridge the gap between the irons and 3W.

  • @TheBigBananaaa
    @TheBigBananaaa Рік тому +1

    ❇️ I recently put a 2 iron 20 degrees in the bag ✅ and I also still have a 5 wood ❇️ I play a windy 🌬️ golf ⛳️ course and the shaft needed a change to get the flight and dispersion right ✅ I put in a Ventus VeloCore ❇️

  • @TaroZak
    @TaroZak Рік тому +1

    Just got my G430 5 wood in and it’s amazing. Launches super high and lands soft. 220-235 club

  • @GRIFFIN-TACTICAL7667
    @GRIFFIN-TACTICAL7667 Місяць тому

    I feel like the 3 iron does have a place due to the fact its very work able and pefect for windy days when you need to stay below the wind.

  • @Kevin01SH
    @Kevin01SH 7 місяців тому

    I hit my 3i about the same distance as the 5W, but i always tend to use the 3i because i feel i hit it more consistently. Where as the 5W will tend to balloon up in the air and come up short. I'd almost rather want a 2i and ditch the 5W.

  • @niteninja0133
    @niteninja0133 Рік тому +1

    I'm trying to find something to replace my hybrids. I just can't hit them the face is always closed but I can hit my irons perfect and 5 wood fine just not hybrids

  • @phileoness
    @phileoness Рік тому +2

    I must be indecisive. I have 4i , 3h, 3w. I wanted something that was easier, more comfortable, out of rough lies but would still get some height.

  • @trxe420
    @trxe420 Рік тому

    Well I am weird I guess, I have a 2i, a 3H and a 3W, though I am thinking one has to leave the bag I just can't decide what I hit better. Need to get a look at my average angle of attack I guess, great stuff as always.

  • @jamiesloan7259
    @jamiesloan7259 Рік тому

    I play weak lofted irons. I carry a 3i, and a 5w. About a 15 yard distance gap for me. Which is perfect.

  • @bobpegram8042
    @bobpegram8042 Рік тому

    What about a 2 or 3 hybrid? It is kind of in between a fairway wood and a long iron.

  • @pittimps3459
    @pittimps3459 Рік тому +1

    5 wood. I stripe my fairway woods. I’m terrible with long irons. Simple decision.

  • @ticerboska
    @ticerboska Рік тому +1

    I thought 3iron is closer to 7wood not 5wood on distance?

  • @gregschulte2953
    @gregschulte2953 Рік тому +1

    not a good comparison as the 5 wood is much longer (distance) - maybe a 7 wood would be a better comparison.

  • @freakincreeks6055
    @freakincreeks6055 Рік тому

    I think you should use what's right for your swing speed.

  • @thedeeprot
    @thedeeprot Рік тому

    3 iron for me

  • @trusou1
    @trusou1 Рік тому

    I have both in my bag. My 3 iron is about 3 degrees weaker than my 5 wood. My 3 iron is about 21* but my 5 wood is about 18*

  • @chrisdrew6977
    @chrisdrew6977 Рік тому

    Question:
    I play up to a 3 iron ( I strike irons so much better than fairway wood/ hybrid) but what are my options to cover the gap between 3 iron and driver ?
    I have no problem with 3 wood off a tee peg but really can get elevation or direction control off the deck

    • @thedeeprot
      @thedeeprot Рік тому +1

      Gapping wise I personally go from my 4 iron to 19 degree hybrid and then 17 degree hybrid - it's all personal preference though

    • @ethanperkins890
      @ethanperkins890 Рік тому +1

      I'd say get rid of the 3 iron, and move to a lower lofted utility 2 iron. that way your clubs run from 4 iron -> 2 iron -> driver, as long as you can hit the 2 iron off the deck

    • @chrisdrew6977
      @chrisdrew6977 Рік тому +1

      @@ethanperkins890
      Thanks for the input/ advice . I m thinking about trying the Wilson staff utility or Srixon mk2 utility as they both come in 18 degrees loft to cover that gap in lofting .
      Again … thanks for taking the time to read and reply . Appreciated

  • @matthewdubay1180
    @matthewdubay1180 Рік тому

    Which one is best? Wouldnt it depend?

  • @CybekCusal
    @CybekCusal Рік тому

    I go 5i, 4h, 5w

  • @rikclarke4881
    @rikclarke4881 3 місяці тому

    When did you become left handed?

  • @nicktopinoplus8393
    @nicktopinoplus8393 Рік тому

    I have a 3 hybrid sooo both I guess?

  • @ashleywalls4097
    @ashleywalls4097 Рік тому

    3 hybrid

  • @chrish1585
    @chrish1585 Рік тому

    Why compromise? With the new rules, we can have up to 18 clubs. I have driver, 3 wood, 18° 3 hybrid, 18° 3 iron, 21.5° 4 iron and on down to my 60° lob wedge. The putter rounds out 15 clubs.

    • @fritzkin8733
      @fritzkin8733 Рік тому +3

      What new rule allows 18 clubs in your bag? Did I miss something??

  • @sillway21
    @sillway21 Рік тому

    I only carry a 5 wood no 3 wood in my bag. And I have a 4 iron

  • @steveyb9552
    @steveyb9552 Рік тому

    How about 5 wood vs 3 hybrid...?

  • @ballforegolf
    @ballforegolf Рік тому

    Good Info!

  • @georgefischer8458
    @georgefischer8458 2 місяці тому

    I'm a 5 wood 7 wood then 5 iron guy. Good gapping for my game.

  • @JL-ho1tc
    @JL-ho1tc Рік тому +3

    DON'T EVER call it a 5 metal.. It's a 5 WOOD.
    By saying 5 metal you will confuse new golfers.
    It's a wood, and it will ALWAYS be called a wood..
    So stop saying 5 metal.. It's not a 5 metal...
    a 5 Iron would be a 5 Metal,..
    a 5 Wood is a 5 WOOD.
    Woods, Hybrids, Irons, Putters... That's It.
    Keep It Simple.

  • @swoosh6982
    @swoosh6982 Рік тому +14

    For a lower handicap golfer, none of the above. 2-iron driving iron is the ultimate choice.

    • @edj9961
      @edj9961 Рік тому +3

      1 iron mate, man up

    • @swoosh6982
      @swoosh6982 Рік тому +4

      @@edj9961 Don't need the extra distance mate, gym up

    • @Jimbo-zd8cz
      @Jimbo-zd8cz Рік тому +4

      For a true low handicap golfer, the choice is a 5wood or hybrid if the course conditions are fine 👍🏻 unless you’re playing a links course or somewhere very windy then the 2i is only for your ego. Which is why most tour players have fairway woods or hybrids👍🏻 score over ego

    • @swoosh6982
      @swoosh6982 Рік тому

      @@Jimbo-zd8cz Tour players are extremely accurate compared to scratch golfers they choose a 5 wood for the softer landing. If you're an actual low handicapper, then you should know how much more accurate and easy it is to hit a 2 iron compared to a 5 wood. Cavity back 2 irons not blades though.

    • @Jimbo-zd8cz
      @Jimbo-zd8cz Рік тому +1

      @@swoosh6982 I play a 2i because I play on courses around St Andrews and it suits them off the tee. And have a 5 wood or hybrid to swap in if playing parkland. 5 woods one of the easiest clubs to hit in the bag. And is useful in more situations. Unless you’re playing an incredibly tight or windy course you should have a an easy enough fairway finder shot with 3w or 5w. And there’s no situation where a 2 iron is better than a wood going into long par 5s. Unless you have a very steep swing. fitzpatrick spoke about his fairway woods recently on yt. They are easy to hit, forgiving, stopping power through land angle, and give you a fairway finder off the tee 👍🏻, some “low handicappers” would be even lower if they didn’t have the big egos.

  • @1976axerhand
    @1976axerhand Рік тому

    Fw are better, my 7 wood goes 200 yards.

  • @nicolejacobsen3940
    @nicolejacobsen3940 Рік тому

    For a scratch golfer, like me, I’d rather have a four driving iron and a two hybrid

    • @thetowndrunk988
      @thetowndrunk988 Рік тому +3

      For a 55 handicapper, like me, I’d rather have an automatic club, and a half gallon of scotch

  • @basementbanter366
    @basementbanter366 Рік тому +1

    You lost me halfway with horrible advice 😂

  • @ncnoman
    @ncnoman Рік тому +2

    unrelated to this vid, but thank you Mr Short Game... my wife pulled me out to our backyard net to show me her "new" full swing, she's very new to golf but i asked her what she did to get such a huge improvement in one day (went from swinging like a girl - no offense anyone - to swinging like a golfer!) and she said it was from watching one of your vids! thank you MSG for the awesome content; you may have just saved my marriage😅.