Designing The Witcher 3's Most Famous Quest

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 лис 2020
  • We look at the storytelling techniques used in The Witcher 3's "Bloody Baron" questline with the help of lead quest designer Paweł Sasko and writer Karolina Stachyra.
    Support Story Mode on Patreon: / storymodeon
    Twitter: / storymodeon
    Facebook: / storymodeon
    Instagram: / storymode_on
    Special Thanks
    Paweł Sasko ( / pawesasko )
    Karolina Stachyra
    CD Projekt Red
    Founder-level Patrons
    Sharon Fagen
    Kunal Nayyar
    Directed by
    Michael Tucker ( / michaeltuckerla )
    Producers
    Vince Major ( / vincemajor )
    Wyatt Strain ( / wyattari )
    Michael Tucker
    Writers
    Brian Bitner ( / brianbitner )
    Alex Calleros ( / alex_calleros )
    Michael Tucker
    Editors
    Alex Calleros
    Michael Tucker
    Game Capture Artist
    Wyatt Strain
    Sound Editing
    Graham Haerther
    ----
    Mods used:
    Debug Console Enabler
    www.nexusmods.com/witcher3/mo...
    The Witcher 3 HD Reworked Project
    www.nexusmods.com/witcher3/mo...
  • Ігри

КОМЕНТАРІ • 893

  • @StoryModeOn
    @StoryModeOn  3 роки тому +134

    Supporters on Patreon can watch the full-length interview with Lead Quest Designer Paweł Sasko: www.patreon.com/posts/43988198
    Welcome to Story Mode! What are some of your favorite quests in The Witcher 3? And what games should we look at for future videos?

    • @danielcadewood7247
      @danielcadewood7247 3 роки тому +6

      I really appreciate what this channel is doing and i hope you will continue with many other games, maybe like Fallout new vegas, halo and others

    • @NolanDean
      @NolanDean 3 роки тому

      I would love for you to examine Final Fantasy 7

    • @madhuvatn6793
      @madhuvatn6793 3 роки тому +3

      Red Dead Redemption 2

    • @Greendalewitch
      @Greendalewitch 3 роки тому +6

      Can you do a video about the Witcher 3 Heart of Stone DLC. I personally find the story in that better than the story in the main game. And the story in the main game was awesome.

    • @YMRGUITAR
      @YMRGUITAR 3 роки тому +7

      I would love to hear your take on The Last of Us Part II. It seems pretty polarising on the internet but I thought it was great and the writing was one of the stronger points.

  • @LostCosmonauts
    @LostCosmonauts 3 роки тому +1398

    Fittingly, Karolina's opinion on not liking likeable characters makes her perspective interesting, which in turn makes her a likeable character.

    • @karolinastachyra6574
      @karolinastachyra6574 3 роки тому +281

      :D:D:D Thanks, Erick :) I really appreciate that :) Michael took me by surprise and I was afraid that I was too honest, but comments like that makes me feel that being honest can sometimes be good ;)

    • @rafex987
      @rafex987 3 роки тому +46

      @@karolinastachyra6574 I never thought about it that way, but I absolutely love that take, and there was always something that I greatly enjoyed about these type of characters, but I never could quite put my finger on it, but you explained it perfectly. Witcher 3 storyline to this day still make me tear up just by remembering, it is definitely the game that makes me feel the most, for good and bad. I will forever be grateful for one of the best experiences I will ever have

    • @karolinastachyra6574
      @karolinastachyra6574 3 роки тому +60

      @@rafex987 Thank you! Reading comments like yours warms my heart and encourages me to work and create :) I'm really grateful :)

    • @Buska324
      @Buska324 3 роки тому

      @@karolinastachyra6574 You're just Polish Karolina, ja powiedziałbym to samo :)

    • @karolinastachyra6574
      @karolinastachyra6574 3 роки тому +2

      @@Buska324 Ale to dobrze czy źle? :D

  • @Kikox4
    @Kikox4 3 роки тому +735

    You forgot the most memorable part of that quest: The baron walking with that baby monster

    • @StoryModeOn
      @StoryModeOn  3 роки тому +175

      Who could forget the bizarrely moving sequence with the botchling.

    • @TheMrawesomest
      @TheMrawesomest 3 роки тому +47

      The voice actor truly elevates that part of the quest.

    • @tizkit1
      @tizkit1 3 роки тому +41

      I love the botchling, it's such an encapsulation of Geralt's ethos in the game. Show things compassion first

    • @garydiamondguitarist
      @garydiamondguitarist 3 роки тому +1

      Ah but as anyone who completed the main story knows, even the botchling can have it's own story arc. That's how good the writing is.

    • @notduane7327
      @notduane7327 3 роки тому

      Still creeps me till this day

  • @danielemazzali9810
    @danielemazzali9810 3 роки тому +666

    just read the title.
    It's the cooking pan quest right? it HAS to be that

    • @sagargupta3144
      @sagargupta3144 3 роки тому +35

      nah its the one with the goats

    • @hp2823
      @hp2823 3 роки тому +63

      FOUND DE PAN HAVE YE?

    • @thehoodedvagabum7375
      @thehoodedvagabum7375 3 роки тому +15

      The way they make the pan personality likeable and a interesting backstory was amazing.

    • @thefran901
      @thefran901 3 роки тому +3

      I thought of the one where Roach speaks lol

    • @aestheticporkbun2016
      @aestheticporkbun2016 3 роки тому +1

      It's the sword maker quest.

  • @VitruvianSasquatch
    @VitruvianSasquatch 3 роки тому +1091

    The main quest of Hearts of Stone is sublime. Best in the game, in my opinion.

    • @StoryModeOn
      @StoryModeOn  3 роки тому +91

      I *love* that quest so much. -MT

    • @TheRedname
      @TheRedname 3 роки тому +82

      @@StoryModeOn Would be awesome to see you guys do an analysis of that, as well. Perhaps on the effectiveness of Gaunter O'Dimm as an antagonist?

    • @phrawga
      @phrawga 3 роки тому +22

      I love that quest but I feel it runs on a bit too long. I never really liked quest in the game where you’re given a problem, and you go to fix that problem, and then you need to fix a problem to fix a problem. That quest and the finding dandelion quest line in the main quest are the two I feel run on Wayyyyyy too much.

    • @rossedwardmiller
      @rossedwardmiller 3 роки тому +19

      I finished the original quest after about 100 hours and decided to take a break and return to the dlc stuff later. It’s like a little present I keep for myself. Any time I want to play new Witcher 3 stuff I have it waiting on my pc.

    • @phrawga
      @phrawga 3 роки тому +9

      @@rossedwardmiller be prepared to sink another 150 hours into the DLCs. Trust me after doing everything in B&W you will never want to see toussant again

  • @Shadow18275
    @Shadow18275 3 роки тому +281

    The entirety of Hearts of Stone is perfect. Specifically Gaunter O'Dimm, one of the best vilians of all time.

    • @azadalamiq
      @azadalamiq 3 роки тому +18

      i like the fact you meet this dude so early in the game, and he just had this "dude up to something" air about him.

    • @BusyAnt1234
      @BusyAnt1234 3 роки тому +5

      G.O.D. actually being the devil is a brilliant trick

    • @blasterelforg7276
      @blasterelforg7276 3 роки тому +2

      make your wishes...

  • @Nick-kb2jc
    @Nick-kb2jc 3 роки тому +57

    My top ten favorite Witcher 3 quests:
    1. The Warble of a Smitten Knight
    2. A Towerful of Mice
    3. Carnal Sins
    4. Possession
    5. La Cage au Fu
    6. The Last Wish
    7. Family Matters
    8. Dead Man’s Party
    9. Scenes from a Marriage
    10. The Isle of Mists
    I really hope this video inspires new players to try the game and experience its magic!

    • @StoryModeOn
      @StoryModeOn  3 роки тому +36

      You know a game is good when you can remember the names of this many quests and be like, “Oh man, yeah. That one was good.” -MT

    • @Nick-kb2jc
      @Nick-kb2jc 3 роки тому +8

      @@StoryModeOn honestly, I could name every single quest in the game and tell you what happens in them. I’ve literally played the base game and expansions over 50 times 😊. Great video by the way. I look forward to more content from this channel. Awesome work!

    • @alonsan3977
      @alonsan3977 3 роки тому +1

      @@StoryModeOn couldn't agree more. The fact I knew the plot for every single quest listed above only proves how strong the writing is.

    • @cchristianjeremy
      @cchristianjeremy 3 роки тому +2

      Scenes from a Marriage 🙌🏻

    • @saishonokaze3462
      @saishonokaze3462 3 роки тому +1

      I really hated A towerful of mice
      Was so boring to me

  • @spinakker14
    @spinakker14 3 роки тому +517

    3:05 "I don't like likeable characters, I like interesting characters" (paraphrasing)
    Hollywood should listen to her. I'm fed up with all the charming, smiling "likeable" characters who cannot make any morally ambiguous choices, or if they do, they have to crack a joke, or the narrative has to redeem them - lest the audience might not like them. It's bad writing because it treats the audience as children who need to be kept happy and have unambiguously good and bad guys for them

    • @brewdaly1873
      @brewdaly1873 3 роки тому +43

      I kinda get where you're coming from, but that isn't necessarily bad writing. It serves a different purpose. If I want a deep story, with complex characters, something that makes me think? Then yeah, I enjoy that ambiguity. But if I just want to relax and escape, just have some fun for a few hours, then I want to see likable characters. Neither is inherently better or worse than the other, they just have different goals.

    • @nicoamarilla2939
      @nicoamarilla2939 3 роки тому +10

      I feel so smart just by reading your guys comments

    • @numpy5135
      @numpy5135 3 роки тому +10

      Seems like you only watch the most mainstream hollywood blockbusters. Nothing wrong with that, but please don't just criticize all hollywood movies because you don't know where to look at.

    • @spinakker14
      @spinakker14 3 роки тому +7

      @@brewdaly1873 you're right, I was being judgemental (in fact these movies could be called well written, since they make a ton of money). Still, I wish these writers made more effort to write complex characters, and that audiences demanded them too

    • @spinakker14
      @spinakker14 3 роки тому +6

      @@numpy5135 quite the opposite, my friend I watch all sorts of movies. But the focus on likeable characters on both sides (because we can read too many professional and audience criticism about the movie "not having likeable characters") is more prevalent among mainstream movies

  • @miss.brun0
    @miss.brun0 3 роки тому +164

    So rare is it to find incredibly insightful, well-composed videos centered on just appreciating story games and how significant their writing is. There’s good ones out there, don’t get me wrong, but many never reach the full potential of the message they’re trying to convey. I just know this channel is going to knock it out of the park.

  • @Luvutoo
    @Luvutoo 3 роки тому +107

    I recall being really disinterested with the bloody baron initially, but when I got to the dancing maid scene I was curious and started paying attention to the story. Absolutely loved this quest towards the end of it, and their approach to quest design worked out so amazingly

    • @StoryModeOn
      @StoryModeOn  3 роки тому +10

      Yeah, cleverly-designed dynamics are a really important part of the storytelling process

  • @aaryanbhardwaj40
    @aaryanbhardwaj40 3 роки тому +21

    I wanted to restart the quest when Anna died and the Baron hung himself, but I decided to live with that choice, since that helped flesh out the game more. Love this!

    • @dr.embersfield1551
      @dr.embersfield1551 3 роки тому +4

      At least the kids survived and you can see them later in Novigrad.

    • @felathar1985
      @felathar1985 3 роки тому +4

      Holy shit. He didn't kill himself iny
      my game. This is shocking

  • @hollowtomato
    @hollowtomato 3 роки тому +5

    The talent of CDPR compared to Netflix is enormous. Paweł Sasko and Karolina Stachyra are simply on another level, when it comes to characters and storytelling. Netflix has the advantage of books which to adapt, but they still fall flat on their faces. Karolina has managed to capture the spirit of Sapkowski's stories and in my opinion, has created a storyline, that matches and even rivals the author's work itself. Great work and thank you for creating the most incredible RPG of all time!

  • @TheMrawesomest
    @TheMrawesomest 3 роки тому +352

    The wedding quest in the Hearts of stone DLC is magnificent and a lot of fun. Just walking around and chilling.

    • @jon-umber
      @jon-umber 3 роки тому +37

      It's also fucking hilarious.

    • @solidaritytime3650
      @solidaritytime3650 3 роки тому +12

      KING OF THE SWINEHERDS!

    • @nicktaylor897
      @nicktaylor897 3 роки тому +4

      apart from that FUCKING PIG QUEST

    • @suc125
      @suc125 3 роки тому +1

      I loved HoS, all the main quest were diverse, all of them fun and interesting, great villain, Olgierd was an interesting character, and it was a compact intensive experience, as it lasted like 10 hours

    • @ashyzup
      @ashyzup 3 роки тому +3

      One of my favourites! It's really fun. And of course it's with best girl Shani. 😊 The whole HoS dlc is amazing!

  • @ziad9533
    @ziad9533 3 роки тому +64

    Karolina Stachyra's method of writing characters is so great ❤, actually the bloody baron is the first quest that's really got me into the gloomy witcher world.
    Great job Karolina 👏

    • @karolinastachyra6574
      @karolinastachyra6574 3 роки тому +25

      Thank you :)

    • @ziad9533
      @ziad9533 3 роки тому +7

      @@karolinastachyra6574 you deserve the best 😍😍

    • @capnphoenix
      @capnphoenix 3 роки тому +2

      Completely agree. I just started playing The Witcher 3 about a week ago (no idea why I waited so long to play it), and while I was having fun and mostly enjoying the story at first, I wasn't too immersed in it. It was just a fun story game for the first day or two. Then when I did this quest, and especially as I progressed it and had to deal with the Crones, that all changed. I noticed the dynamic characters, I realized that "Oh shit, I better watch what I do from now on if I want things to turn out well," and now I'm completely and utterly immersed in the game. Such a brilliant quest line and game.

    • @justamanofculture12
      @justamanofculture12 3 роки тому

      @@karolinastachyra6574 you're an amazing person & writer karoline. Your gig to create interesting characters is amazing. I hope to see you in future CDPR projects.

    • @karolinastachyra6574
      @karolinastachyra6574 3 роки тому +1

      @@justamanofculture12 Thank you! It's especially important for me because it flows from The Man of Culture ;)😁

  • @stuartdenton8537
    @stuartdenton8537 3 роки тому +14

    "Where the Cat and Wolf Play..." is a quest that caught my attention and stayed with me. I got properly drawn in to helping the little girl.
    The end of "Possession" also sticks with you (baby in the oven)

  • @Synystr7
    @Synystr7 3 роки тому +146

    Karolina Stachyra is lit, fam.

  • @jonalmaraz9101
    @jonalmaraz9101 3 роки тому +102

    The whole Faustian story of "Hearts and Stone" is a prime example of storytelling through player choice, and even expression. That would be another great topic if there were another Witcher video. Love you all, Story Mode team!

    • @brianbitner
      @brianbitner 3 роки тому +2

      Thank you!

    • @rapapa6697
      @rapapa6697 3 роки тому

      Hearts of Stone story is actually based more on legend about Mr. Twardowski rather than Faust.

  • @666ironsant
    @666ironsant 3 роки тому +437

    this comment is for the algorithm gods to bless this chanel.

    • @TheThirdPew
      @TheThirdPew 3 роки тому +5

      here's another

    • @nationalsarcasticsociety1312
      @nationalsarcasticsociety1312 3 роки тому +2

      There is only one algorithm god, and it's called the algorithm lol

    • @GaaMacgfx
      @GaaMacgfx 3 роки тому +1

      Blessed be the algorithm

    • @District1991
      @District1991 3 роки тому +2

      Well the almighty algorithm pulled me in. VERY surprised to see just two videos on this channel, definitely subscribed.

    • @ireadandplay636
      @ireadandplay636 3 роки тому

      hahahaa yes

  • @mezzanoon
    @mezzanoon 3 роки тому +58

    Man, CDPR's writers seem divinely inspired. Would absolutely be floored to see a video on Disco Elysium. ZA/UM has the only writers I feel exceed CDPR in that amazing human insight they both have.

    • @jon-umber
      @jon-umber 3 роки тому +7

      Notifying the woman that her husband had died in Disco Elysium was one of the best written scenes I have ever seen in a video game, no exaggeration.

    • @emilbrandwyne5747
      @emilbrandwyne5747 3 роки тому +1

      @@jon-umber well I guess you gotta convince scene wise if you cant offer voiced lines.

  • @vengefulcat5343
    @vengefulcat5343 3 роки тому +47

    I would love you to make a video on Hearts of Stone storyline, particulary Olgierd-Gaunter dichotomy. The Witcher has a great cast of grey characters, true, but I think that these two are perfect example of showing not just shades of grey, but shades of black. It also amazingly resonates with one of the most important maxims of the game - the one about lesser and greater evil.

  • @IbrahiemLegoFilms
    @IbrahiemLegoFilms 3 роки тому +477

    This game is a ridiculously amazing masterpiece, and tbh it's ruined most games for me

    • @fermin7c1
      @fermin7c1 3 роки тому +51

      Yup most other games, and just about all made in north america, are pandering shitty social commentary with nothing to say. Too selfminvolved instead of trying to tell a complex story with real depth. Look at what happened to the last of us.
      The third act of the witcher , after you find siri and their relationship starts to progress in real time is really just the best story telling in any games, with all the interacting and choices with very real consequences.

    • @IbrahiemLegoFilms
      @IbrahiemLegoFilms 3 роки тому +4

      @@fermin7c1 You're so Goddam right lol,I I can't wait for Cyberpunk

    • @awsomeboy360
      @awsomeboy360 3 роки тому +7

      @@fermin7c1 Come on, Rockstar games give us Red Dead 2. Mass effect, Spiderman, God of War. All of these games are really good.

    • @awsomeboy360
      @awsomeboy360 3 роки тому +1

      @@techmontc8360 Sure. But I'm just saying these games are in their own ways good.

    • @gabriel897100
      @gabriel897100 3 роки тому

      The only game that has come close to the amount of entertainment that I got from TW3 (I may get hate from this) is assassins creed odyssey and is now looking to become valhalla. I have spent so many hours in those games and haven't got bored yet

  • @alessandrodegaetano1825
    @alessandrodegaetano1825 3 роки тому +10

    I was really lucky to have a little talk with Karolina few years ago and I was completely blown away by her humbleness. Besides that deep and complex masterpiece of Bloody Baron, she wrote the marvelous Dead Man's Party and the last stunning quest in the Hearts of Stone DLC. Such a great talent. I hope she will achieve the same greatness with Techland and will get the credit she deserves.
    Pawel is another talented guy, as well as the whole team of CD Projekt Red (love you guys!).
    Great video Story Mode 😍 I look forward to seeing the next analysis!

  • @mattlocke2279
    @mattlocke2279 3 роки тому +22

    When people talked about the reverence they had for the Bloody Baron quest I always thought they meant "Family Matters". Seeing the botchling for the first time was horrifying.

  • @AxiiBoss
    @AxiiBoss 3 роки тому +95

    This Game man Absolute Top Notch Storytelling and Amazing characters and an amazing video explaining why that is.

  • @YourBestBudy
    @YourBestBudy 3 роки тому +14

    The bloody baron questline is my absolute favorite, your comments along with the designer commentary have only made me appreciate it so much more. Since everyone is plugging their hopes for what you'll cover next, I would absolutely love one on the original Portal, it's what got me into storytelling construction in every medium. Or even a comparison between Portal and Portal 2!

  • @LauriLippmaa
    @LauriLippmaa 3 роки тому +39

    I've been a fan of LFTS for years and this Story Mode is a fantastic welcome. After the special announcement, I immediately started watching the Witcher video. I love the game, I loved the Bloody Baron storyline and it's an absolute gem to get this (relatively) in-depth dissection of how it was conceived by the creators. As a screenwriter and storyteller myself, I immensely enjoyed it. Thank you Michael for your great work over the years!

  • @Noemo2000
    @Noemo2000 3 роки тому +48

    I like how he JUST made the notice of the new channel and it’s already got so many subscribers ... sign of a devoted audience who has seen quality content and trusts this will be as well!

    • @strange144
      @strange144 3 роки тому

      I feel like he already announced this once a couple of months ago? Either that or I'm ahving the worst case of Deja Vu, lol.

    • @deaththekid428
      @deaththekid428 3 роки тому

      @@strange144 He did mention it before

    • @Noemo2000
      @Noemo2000 3 роки тому +1

      Yeah, I recall him saying they were going to make this new channel, but I don’t believe it was available at the time of the announcement.

    • @TheBeastBandit
      @TheBeastBandit 3 роки тому

      It’s on Nebula I believe. Some may be coming from there, some (like me) were salivating at the mouth to have even a scrap of Nebula content on UA-cam. If this is what I can expect from this channel, I’m so here for it.

  • @Victim815
    @Victim815 3 роки тому +6

    I've played this game a long time ago and never fully appreciate the storytelling it had. This helped me understand what I missed and I now want to play it again through a new perspective.

  • @ptolemy008
    @ptolemy008 3 роки тому +12

    When the baron died, I had to restart the whole game coz I don’t save games manually unless I am done playing for the day. I just had to save him and give him a chance to redeem himself.

  • @beachednarwhal9683
    @beachednarwhal9683 3 роки тому +170

    The Last Wish was my favorite quest but that might just be because I simp for Yennifer

    • @COHOFSohamSengupta
      @COHOFSohamSengupta 3 роки тому +1

      Structurally it was awful because it basically it involves doing the same thing over and over.. Structurally & narrative wise Curnal sins or Hearts of stone was wayy better

    • @itsflowerside
      @itsflowerside 3 роки тому +20

      @@COHOFSohamSengupta it’s a short, plot-heavy, side quest, of course it’s not gonna be a paragon of “structure.” it’s not meant to be.

    • @marinatedweasel5424
      @marinatedweasel5424 3 роки тому +16

      As a bart the troll simp I disagree with this statement

    • @uncledoctor6920
      @uncledoctor6920 3 роки тому +2

      Dude Yennefer is sooooo bad for Geralt.

    • @wzdzysawzninosyn4905
      @wzdzysawzninosyn4905 3 роки тому +17

      @@uncledoctor6920 she literally sacrificed herself for him. Yeah, what an awful person

  • @TheProphegy
    @TheProphegy 3 роки тому +7

    The Witcher 3 for me has the best quests of any game. The best soundtrack by a MILE. The best character development. Such a beautiful narrative. I felt so empty inside when I beat it and realized my time with these characters was over.

  • @garrytalaroc
    @garrytalaroc 3 роки тому +14

    There's something in The Witcher 3's quests that makes your heart feel something. It's something that you can't feel in other games.
    That is why I can't wait for their next project Cyberpunk 2077.

  • @cdncowguru
    @cdncowguru 3 роки тому +22

    I've never even played any of The Witcher games but I love Michael's videos! This was super interesting and makes me really appreciate the immersive and interactive storytelling style of video games! Looking forward to future videos!

    • @sparkplug5129
      @sparkplug5129 3 роки тому +2

      Play em now. At least the Witcher 3. You won’t regret it

  • @justagoose7741
    @justagoose7741 3 роки тому +2

    You should make a video about Outlast and how it was so effective at being actual horror, I found Outlast to be so immersive that it was genuinely thrilling, a feeling a lot more difficult to achieve than in the medium of film.
    As for TW3, this video was so comprehensive of the storytelling strengths of the game that it's hard to suggest more quests to talk about in a different light, but I think a strength you didn't mention (that could still be explored in a video) could be world-building and immersion. The music, the NPC chatter ranging from sobbing to gibberish, the architecutral and cultural differences from Toussaint to Velen, the references to the book, etc... and of course the thematic cohesion even in the smallest of details, I found all of these to bring TW3 to a whole new level of world-building in videogames.
    As always, great video!

  • @animalunae
    @animalunae 3 роки тому +9

    The Bloody Baron quest will stay with me for the rest of my life.

  • @BatemanPatrick2
    @BatemanPatrick2 3 роки тому +6

    I would love to see more videos on the storytelling in Witcher 3. The main story in Blood and Wine has to be my favorite questline. One moment in particular stands out: the meeting between Geralt, Anna Henrietta, Detlaff, Regis and Orianna. There's so much tension and dramatic irony in that scene.

  • @Sant182
    @Sant182 3 роки тому +11

    My favorite quest was Equine Phantoms, I cried at the end.

  • @TheProphegy
    @TheProphegy 3 роки тому +2

    The Bloody Baron quest blew me away because of how beautifully drawn out it was and having to travel across the world and the lengths you go to wrap it up. Such great moments in that quest.

  • @turovartiainen
    @turovartiainen 3 роки тому +2

    What an interesting video. This storyline is a standout in what I generally consider to be the best written RPG/adventure game in history.

  • @BIadelores
    @BIadelores 3 роки тому +21

    One thing to note: You can actually save Anna AND the children (or rather prevent the children from ever being taken to Crookbag Bog to begin with) by completing the tree spirit quest (And freeing it) BEFORE you go to Crookbag Bog (I think the cut off point is when The Crones task you to kill the spirit? But I'm not sure). Doing this makes it so that the kids never make it to there, which results in Anna not getting cursed into a Water Hag and you get the same ending as if you would've otherwise killed the spirit. That said the village does still meet a gory end so it's not the clean choice it sounds like, there is NO way to save the village without killing the spirit, but it's somewhat the least bad choice, at least from the perspective of the player who has grown attached to the Baron's storyline and the children but not so much the village.

    • @Spazticspaz
      @Spazticspaz 3 роки тому +2

      That's actually the story ending i got accidentally on my first play-through, because I was exploring the whole map and not doing the actual story first, lol. Plus if you follow the questline you realize the people of that village weren't completely guilt free, either.

    • @gracenote108
      @gracenote108 3 роки тому +1

      That doesn't work. The tree spirit will just take out the village but won't save the children. If it did, the children would end up in the school in Novigrad.
      The spirit will only save the children only if Geralt (the player) is aware of the children.

  • @Peasant_of_Pontus
    @Peasant_of_Pontus 3 роки тому +5

    Heart of Stone DLC has my favourite quests. Every single one is top notch, from the frog prince through the 3 impossible tasks to the final showdown. The story easily surpasses the main storyline of the base game in terms of complicated characters and ambiguous choices.

  • @emiliano8669
    @emiliano8669 3 роки тому +1

    The witchers getting drunk at Kaer Morhen made me smile during the whole mission

  • @MrEffectfilms
    @MrEffectfilms 2 роки тому +1

    Karolinas approach is something every writer should take to heart. Don't obsess over making your characters likeable, focus on making them interesting. As long as they're interesting your audience is more likely to appreciate the character regardless of how likeable they are.

  • @KoongYe
    @KoongYe 3 роки тому +5

    The one where you go inside a painting was cool, along with one with a tone of spoons.

  • @JT-nd6qp
    @JT-nd6qp 2 роки тому +2

    This is a really engaging video that offers a good vertical slice of what W3 is all about. I wanted to give my non-gamer mom and sister an antidote to the awful Netflix show (which they watched purely for Henry Cavill) and show them what they're missing, so I showed them this and some exploration of Beauclair. They were quite impressed. Hopefully they'll think twice before making fun of me for playing videogames now.

  • @pokemonmaster0079
    @pokemonmaster0079 3 роки тому +29

    I really like the spoiler rating in the bottom right hand corner.

  • @rottensquid
    @rottensquid 3 роки тому +5

    I love this game, and I love Michael from Lesson's from the Screenplay, so this is a real match made in heaven.
    As for my favorite quest, I think it's the main story quest of Blood and Wine. Going back and exploring the world of the Witcher, I realized more deeply the genius of ending the game with a quest that perfectly bookends the very first Witcher story. In that first chapter, titled "The Witcher," Geralt meets Renfri, a former princess born during an eclipse. A renowned sorcerer appeared and declared her "the curse of the black sun," an evil spirit who would bring disaster to her kingdom. Her parents gave him permission to study her in all sorts of torturous ways, and she was treated with fear and revulsion, eventually being exiled to protect the kingdom from the effects of the curse.
    Geralt meets her in a town where she has now tracked the sorcerer, determined to get her revenge on him. But the sorcerer treats her mission of revenge as proof of the curse's truth. Meanwhile, Geralt finds himself attracted to Renfri, and after they hook spend a night together, she asks him to use his friendship with the sorcerer to help her assassinate him. Geralt decides not to interfere, but finds himself unable to remain neutral when Renfri's band of bandits take townspeople hostage, threatening to kill them if the sorcerer doesn't surrender himself. Of course, the sorcerer doesn't consider the lives of villagers worth his own, and Geralt must defeat and kill Renfri's band to free them. Renfri would rather die than give up her mission of revenge, and Geralt ends up killing her to stop her.
    One could read the story as proof positive that Renfri truly was the evil spirit the sorcerer labeled her. Or one could see his actions making her into the monster he wanted to see. As for Geralt, remaining neutral rather than choose the lesser evil only brought about greater evil. He learned that neutrality was never a possibility. One way or the other, inaction only helps evil.
    The Witcher 3's Blood and Wine expansion is the end of Geralt's history. It's the tale of Silvia-Anna, the lost princess of Toussaint. She too was born under a black sun, and like Renfri, her bitterness over her exile, and the abuse of those who exiled her, lead her to a quest for revenge. The adventure leads Geralt face to face with Detlaff, a tempestuous higher vampire whom Syanne manipulated into doing her dirty work, to assassinate the four knights who abused her while taking her from the kingdom, as well as her sister, the Duchess Anna-Henrietta, who gained the throne when Syanna was sent away. But to me, what's most interesting isn't the battle with Detlaff, though his complex motivations are fascinating. It's Syanna herself, whose actions, though intended only to exploit one vampire and murder five people for personal reasons, ultimately spiral out of control when Detlaff, learning of her duplicity, takes his rage out on the entire Duchy.
    Once Geralt defeats Detlaff, the player must ultimately decide the fate of Syanna. It falls to Geralt, as the objective outsider, to advise Annarietta how to judge the situation, and Syanna what to do with her rage and her failure. And here lies the real genius of the quest, and how it perfectly bookends Geralt's choice in the short story that introduced him all those years ago. His life has taken him full circle to a do-over opportunity. Renfri and Syanna are basically the same. Both were princesses whose lives were destroyed by this supposed curse. And bear in mind, there's been no evidence the curse even exists beyond Renfri and Syanna's unquenched anger. And such anger needs no more explanation than their parents' and advising sorcerer's the belief in the curse, and how they treated her because of it.
    So how does Geralt decide? It depends on the player. Some look at the devastation to the Duchy's capital city of Beauclair at the hands of Detlaff, and blame Syanna's scheming and manipulation of a dangerously sensitive vampire. Those players believe justice must be done. However, if Syanna has survived this far, advising Annarietta to administer justice has disastrous results. Even if you condemn Syanna face to face, and expose her final plan to murder her sister, Annarietta can't bring herself to sentence a just punishment. Her lingering love for her sister takes precedence, and she asks Syanna for forgiveness. But Syanna doesn't forgive, and murders Annarietta with her own hairpin.
    However, if you omit Syanna's plan to murder her sister, and advise both sisters to seek forgiveness, they embrace, and begin some kind of healing process.
    Bottom line, this ultimately becomes a decision between justice and forgiveness. The death of Syanna may be just after all that she's done, but no one profits by it, least of all Geralt. On the other hand, giving Syanna the opportunity for forgiveness, both for herself and the wrongs done to her, offers an opportunity that justice lacks. It may not redress the wrongs Syanna has done. But then again, justice here is nothing but revenge on revenge. Only compassion and forgiveness bring the chance of healing.
    That's my favorite quest.

  • @adityasivaram6175
    @adityasivaram6175 3 роки тому +8

    3:05 "I don't like likeable characters. I like interesting characters." That is the best storytelling advice I've heard in a long time. You don't make excellent characters like Heath Ledger's Joker, or Christoph Waltz's Hans Landa, or Andy Serkis' Gollum, by making them likeable. They are conflicted, and relatable, and have an overall sense of humanity. It's what makes them likeable. They become likeable by themselves, if you put your heart and soul into making them believable, and interesting.

    • @John-996
      @John-996 3 роки тому

      yeah its not all about being likeable but interesting.

  • @lexib671
    @lexib671 3 роки тому +4

    I sobbed at the end of this quest. One of the most memorable moments in the game for sure.

    • @mkproductions5608
      @mkproductions5608 3 роки тому +1

      Lol i stumbled upon the tree spirit before getting to this part of the quest so i freed the spirit and at the end of the quest anna lived i got lucky i guess 😂😂

  • @grasielgrasel7510
    @grasielgrasel7510 3 роки тому +6

    I always wanted a channel with some good video essays about games like this one. Thanks, Michael

    • @StoryModeOn
      @StoryModeOn  3 роки тому +4

      Also be sure to check out Game Maker's Toolkit!

    • @Danysian
      @Danysian 3 роки тому +1

      Errant Signal and Noah Caldwell-Gervais are two other good ones!

  • @BlizzyFoxTF
    @BlizzyFoxTF 3 роки тому +2

    Already guessed what quest it is before clicking. Was too heart broken when I got the bad ending. I realized the mistake I made and it felt truly my fault. Super memorable moment in a game full of highlights.

  • @AnnoyingEdu
    @AnnoyingEdu 3 роки тому +3

    I totally forgot how HUGE the Bloddy Baron quest line was... wow. Great to have sme insights form the poeple that actutally wrote the quests. It explains why so many quests in the witcher 3 are not written in the standard rpg-quest-format.

  • @Paul_Hardy
    @Paul_Hardy 3 роки тому +8

    Putting aside the story and characters that make this game fantastic, it's hard to believe that it's over 5 years old. It looks like it could have been released yesterday.

  • @vvscut3933
    @vvscut3933 3 роки тому +2

    Everything they said I experienced in that quest, the game is truly one of my favorite RPG’s

  • @yairsofer8933
    @yairsofer8933 3 роки тому +4

    The king is dead long live the king is one of my favourites! It's the first quest we see my favourite fictional couple doing their thing. The actors OOZE chemistry and the writing is sublime as good as the books. Any quest with Yen and Geralt is a win in my book and are my favourites.

  • @Thehackerguy2000
    @Thehackerguy2000 3 роки тому +1

    The sub plot feels like a tutorial for what’s to come in the next. Unintended consequences are present throughout the game’s quest and it prepares you for later story bits, but it only feels like a tutorial after you’ve finished the whole game. It’s incredible after all these years n all the bloody Barron videos on UA-cam you still find something new about this quest line.

  • @petronellataube2986
    @petronellataube2986 3 роки тому +8

    i tried searching and it was pretty hard to find this channel without the announcement video on lessons from the screenplay. Commenting so that others find the channel!

  • @hamjoy3602
    @hamjoy3602 3 роки тому +32

    Story Mode is about to tie LFTS for my favorite channel.

  • @yaboyjay7202
    @yaboyjay7202 3 роки тому +18

    Sad to have found out that Karolina is no longer at CDPR 😭

    • @Alice89chan
      @Alice89chan 3 роки тому

      After December, do you wonder why she left?

    • @yaboyjay7202
      @yaboyjay7202 3 роки тому +7

      @@Alice89chan Techland (the company currently working on Dying Light 2) offered her the position as lead narrative designer

  • @gngnome
    @gngnome 3 роки тому

    As others have pointed out, the most memorable sequence was the walk back to the castle in the middle of the night with the Baron & his stillborn child turned Botchling.
    The reason I think why this is so memorable is for how well it marries gameplay and story and is crafted in a unique atmosphere. You're going from one point to another as escort and fighting enemies but it's the story & atmosphere that keeps you immersed and in fully the know what you're doing and why you're doing it. This is the sequence where the Baron truly stands out as the father carrying a burden.

  • @1957DLT
    @1957DLT 3 роки тому +1

    Wow, Karolina and Pawel are responsible for so many of my favorites quest lines in Witcher 3. The first time I played the Bloody Baron quest I got the horrible ending and I swear my shock did not wear off for two days. I went online to research what the heck I did wrong and found out about the choice/consequence with multiple endings...then I knew I was in for one really wild ride playing W3. It is a credit to the writing that the entire Bloody Baron questline is one I look forward to on replays.
    The Hearts of Stone quests Dead Man's Party and especially Scenes From A Marriage are two others that I look forward to as well. Iris is a tragic character that sticks with you long after Geralt tells her she will be remembered.
    In Blood and Wine, the quests La Cage au Fou/The Hunger Game and A Knight's Tales seem lesser at the outset but open into far richer scenarios by their ends. I have much love for all of the Blood and Wine dlc, it being such an awesome kiss goodbye to the Witcher fans.
    Enjoy your re-play of Witcher 3, Michael. And thank you for this video.

  • @Kvh47
    @Kvh47 3 роки тому +1

    The character design in this game is unrivaled. there is no other game out there that comes even close.

  • @Vokkss
    @Vokkss 3 роки тому +2

    There will never be a game like this one ever again.

  • @Porcheg
    @Porcheg 3 роки тому +3

    Everything with Regis is incredible. The best character in the entire game imo.

  • @educampsrocks
    @educampsrocks 3 роки тому

    For real, these two people wrote all of the best quests in the game. They are such great writers and I respect them so much. I played this game down to every corner because I loved it so so much. Fantastic video. Would love any more Witcher content

  • @oilrigpistol
    @oilrigpistol 3 роки тому

    So many quests and characters in this game were amazing, but one character that particularly stuck with me was the ghost Vlodomir and when he possessed Geralt. It was so fun to see usually stuck-up Geralt (I don't mean that in a bad way at all) so fun and energizing and how he managed to woo Shani as Vlodomir. It was so fun to wreak havoc as Geralt at the wedding and say that everything that went wrong was Vlodomir's doing! Ah great memories this game has given me!

  • @MadeinHell2
    @MadeinHell2 3 роки тому +3

    I actually didn't finish W3 because life got in the way, and when I tried playing it again (over a year later) I was bad at the game, and didn't remember where I was.
    This definitely makes me want to replay it but the early game can feel like a lot of busywork with the inventory management and stuff like that.

  • @seanypdesign
    @seanypdesign 3 роки тому +4

    So happy you decided to take this further into its own channel. This video was amazing and I'm SUPER excited for more!

  • @nspinicelli
    @nspinicelli 3 роки тому +2

    I agree that this quest is the most memorable quest in gaming history. Shocking, dark, real. Like the Empire Strikes Back of video games.

  • @supimbob12
    @supimbob12 3 роки тому

    There is no better trailer for the new Cyberpunk game than "we're the people who made the Bloody Baron". Years later, I still watch anything I see about this story line; an absolute masterpiece of story telling and a shining example of what video games bring to the table that no other medium possibly could.

  • @yasm1376
    @yasm1376 3 роки тому

    This approach is the core element that made the Witcher series' storytelling so good and memorable.

  • @PaweSasko
    @PaweSasko 3 роки тому +205

    • @StoryModeOn
      @StoryModeOn  3 роки тому +36

      Thank you for chatting with us and sharing such great insights! Looking forward to when we can do it again :)

    • @JonasLekevicius
      @JonasLekevicius 3 роки тому +12

      Thank you! I'm used to hearing developers talk about their games using non-specific platitudes, and was very delighted by how detailed and specific your answers were. So much to learn!

    • @d26k164
      @d26k164 3 роки тому +3

      You created a masterpiece

    • @popularsensai
      @popularsensai 3 роки тому +3

      So yeah, just wanted to ask, who thought of having the frying pan quest in white orchard?? It was beautiful :)

    • @shotsfiredandmissed9068
      @shotsfiredandmissed9068 3 роки тому

      hey man, congratulations for a job well done!

  • @warddeboer7674
    @warddeboer7674 3 роки тому +1

    im only 5 minutes in, but this level of quality is amazing. Love that you chose this topic as well! and the interview with the actual designers.
    what an upload!

  • @Poss1
    @Poss1 3 роки тому +2

    Very well done! "The Bloody Baron" was an excellent first choice. I would love to know more about the thinking behind the "Beauclair's Wild Kingdom" side quest. There have been years of discussion on the decision itself, Geralt's character-nature vs "My Geralt," where responsibility can fall, ends and means... a lot of real life issues.
    As for other games to explore: Prey 2017's story is a rich one that unfolds really well. Thanks for your work.

  • @Mauro0
    @Mauro0 3 роки тому +4

    You forgot about the most important interaction with the bloody Baron.
    The Gwent CARD!!!!

    • @TheRedname
      @TheRedname 3 роки тому +1

      How about a game of gwent?
      *_nodding_*

  • @minimatamou8369
    @minimatamou8369 3 роки тому +1

    this is SO GOOD ! Thank you for this video and this channel which immediately skyrockets into my "must stop everything and watch now" kind of subscription !

  • @TheRatchetnclank
    @TheRatchetnclank 3 роки тому +1

    Excellent analysis of probably my favourite gaming questline of all time. Can't wait to see what else you do with the channel.

  • @EnexS02
    @EnexS02 3 роки тому +5

    Please do an episode on Her Story, such a unique way of story telling only possible on interactive media

  • @mr.d3183
    @mr.d3183 3 роки тому +3

    Bloody baron is the best character ever, changing from a violent man to a sad reformed one seeking for redemption from its loved ones

  • @Olorin-gc8zo
    @Olorin-gc8zo 3 роки тому

    I have been absolutely waiting for a channel like this, especially from you Mike. Thanks and great choice for a video. Subscribed to this one now too!

  • @trayzgredner8326
    @trayzgredner8326 3 роки тому +1

    Great work on this awesome game and the best questline ever made.

  • @monserratbarahona8603
    @monserratbarahona8603 3 роки тому +2

    Off to a fantastic start! LFTS is one of my most favorite video essay channels of all time, and it's extremely exciting to see that same level of care and quality be applied towards videogames. Thank you for the great video, and I'm looking forward to the next!

  • @deffarhan6748
    @deffarhan6748 3 роки тому +1

    Great videos! i will keep waiting for more! the Blood and wine DLC story is just amazing! toussaint is just beautiful!

  • @icywinterof88
    @icywinterof88 3 роки тому +1

    Man I cant wait to play this game again. I played it for the first time last year. It's the one game that I cant multitask while playing, it just completely envelops me and takes all of my attention. I love living in that world, even with all of its dark tones. It's just so beautiful.

  • @Cherriheart
    @Cherriheart 3 роки тому +1

    I loved the characterizations of the side characters in this game! Even the npcs involved in random fetch quests. I can go for months without playing but then I always go back to this game.

  • @stevek8124
    @stevek8124 3 роки тому +1

    Great video and I love the new channel! Can't wait to see which game you cover next!

  • @JessDurden
    @JessDurden 3 роки тому +4

    Hi guys, i write scripts, but I want a little change so this channel comes at a right time! I want to write a visual novel as an exercise for dialogue, character development and multiple joined stories. I wish you more than luck with this channel!

  • @paulcourtemanche3549
    @paulcourtemanche3549 3 роки тому +5

    The best part of this quest is playing gwent against the bloody baron.

  • @brandondasher261
    @brandondasher261 3 роки тому +2

    The witcher 3 is probably the most memorable game I have ever played. It is one of my favorite stories across any medium

  • @eklezia2829
    @eklezia2829 3 роки тому +2

    Scenes from a Marriage quest from Hearts of Stone is the best in the whole game in my opinion. Absolute masterpiece. Just like all of Witcher 3.

  • @22lilbean
    @22lilbean 3 роки тому +4

    THIS IS SO EXCITING! I love how you started with the wither 3.

  • @Parrexion
    @Parrexion 3 роки тому +1

    Really cool to hear some of the insight from the developers themselves. Great video!

  • @Warbringer95
    @Warbringer95 3 роки тому

    Beyond Hill and Dale and Dead Man's Party are two standouts for me. Honestly too many to remember them all off the top of my head, so perhaps that's why I remember the expansion quests a little easier, as they're shorter experiences.
    Anyway, excellent video! My favorite game of all time and one of the very best quest lines in the entire game.

  • @timbrown3560
    @timbrown3560 3 роки тому +1

    Great video. Love seeing dev's perspectives and insights

  • @SSaNNEE100
    @SSaNNEE100 3 роки тому

    The first time ever playing through this mission was such a shocking feeling. I remember crying a lot which isnt usual for me in video games, but the cutsecenes were more like a tv series you wanted to watch and know about more how its going to end.

  • @robchuk4136
    @robchuk4136 3 роки тому +2

    This is my jam. There are SO MANY story-based games I can't wait for you to discuss!

  • @rizzen0248
    @rizzen0248 3 роки тому +1

    Its a quest and a game I will never forgot and no other game will ever beat it's insane quality and storytelling. Plus the amount of content from the DLC's could have been a full game on it's own. I love The last of Us, Oblivion, Skyrim, WoW, DayZ, Arma 2 and 3 (Being some of the best gaming years of my life Arma 2 was) But nothing will ever beat Witcher 3.

  • @fabiogarcezc
    @fabiogarcezc 3 роки тому +1

    The richness and quality of your content are simply out of this world. THANK YOU for this, and good luck with the new project!

  • @FoggyFogzmeister
    @FoggyFogzmeister 3 роки тому +4

    Woho! Good luck with this new channel, I for one am definitely looking forward to more! Much love man :)

  • @8Paul7
    @8Paul7 3 роки тому +7

    Wish Karolina still worked at CDP, but her being narrative lead at techland gives some hopes that Dying Light 2 will be fantastic despite Avellone's unfortunate departure.

    • @mathiaspalm553
      @mathiaspalm553 3 роки тому

      Damn she's not at CD Project anymore? :/ Well maybe Dying Light 2 is worthwhile then..

    • @karolinastachyra6574
      @karolinastachyra6574 3 роки тому +9

      I'm not working on DL2, sorry :P we are creating a brand new IP :)

    • @mustafasaidkaya6087
      @mustafasaidkaya6087 3 роки тому

      @@karolinastachyra6574 if you dont mind my asking, you are clearly competent and well-equipped in your field. What was the reason for your departure from CDPR?( I would totally understand if you wont answer it)

    • @8Paul7
      @8Paul7 3 роки тому +1

      @@karolinastachyra6574 Wow, thanks for answer. Here is hoping DL2 still ends up being good, I loved the first one (Poland has become gamedev superpower, hasn't it?). I assume your new IP is the rumored fantasy RPG, which in my view is even more interesting than zombie parkourfest so fingers crossed, can't wait!

    • @karolinastachyra6574
      @karolinastachyra6574 3 роки тому +1

      ​@@8Paul7 Glad to read that, I'll pass the info to DL2 guys :)
      Yes, you are right about new IP :) Natural Movement will still be there, but within a fantasy souse and rich storytelling with many difficult choices and ambigious charackters :)