I like the way tanpura player Shri Jayant Naidu is appreciating the singing, he has been accompanying artist all South and North for years, true music gets true appreciation...
This is just too beautiful! I listen to this almost everyday. Hamir kalyani is one of my favorite ragams and T.M Krishna sir has beautifully brought the essence of this Raga in just 30 min. This honestly brought me tears. His knowledge is so powerful and inspires everyone. His music not only reaches the carnatic singers or the people in the carnatic field but also any commoner can feel the emotion of this ragam. Thank you for this 🙏😭
Singing is undoubtedly par excellence. One observation about TMK is, how he engages with PAKKAVADYA team. During whole concert, he connects with whole team. Incredible.
I am a Tamilian. But none of the words in the song I could comprehend. On the contrary,, my heart stood still from the beginning to end of T.M. KrishnA's Hamir kalyanai. Ushered me inTo trance. Violin and Mruthangkam superb.
The exchange of hameer kalyani between you and the violinist is more enjoyable. Mr. Perumal murugan would have forgotten all the humility he underwent after hearing this concert
slumdogmusic tmk is more known for the controversies he kicks up than for his art.he is mediocre.and these days we have so much of a dearth of maestros in Carnatic music that even tmk is regarded a maestro.
I think you are confusing his possible mediocrity (I don't have an opinion on that) in the various controversies he is in the middle of with his mediocrity in music. He is truly an amazing musician.
It is extremely delightful to see such beautiful give and take between artistes. Beautiful and symbiotic performances of rāgam and thānam by both Krishna and Akkarai. And not to mention Vijay Siva's befitting accompaniment on the Mrudangam.. Beautifully set composition. There is no T.M. Krishna there. There is only music. And then there is pure bliss into which T.M. Krishna and the accompanying artistes coalesce... ❤
And if interested, please watch this interview madam. She lived in Delhi ,she was interested in music and she couldn't attend concerts. Starting at the age of seven, she heard recorded concerts and cassettes and practised to reproduce what she heard before a proper training in violin. Thanks and regards.
Because the beauty of the music and the artform has little to do with what is essentially an exclusionary tradition that has done little to actually expand the boundaries of this art
Because taste differs & some folks are more aesthetically inclined than technical mastery. I did not feel the beauty of this gorgeous ragam in this rendering. His performance is more technical & like lecture demo atleast for me. Not to mentions issues with sruthi, diction & frankly singing talent
@@prakks the thing with singing is no one really listens to correct the singer. So unless you're an expert technically, you wouldn't waste your time doing that. Not that it's a bad thing though
Superlative! A joy to see the empathy between all on stage, as well as hear something to cherish and remember! I am absolutely foreign to Carnatic music and languages, but, nevertheless completely enthralled by TMK's singing and AS on the violin. Hope to see and hear them many more times.
Awesome krishna sir.I am from A.P.westgodavari,Penugonda.we are very lucky to have A Gandarva T.M.K with us.I am a deepest fan of you.In your singing any raaga stands as mile stone.violin sister subbalakshmi excellent following.
Pl. read the above remarks. Enjoy the concert. Also read the introductory remarks by 'Sangeetha Kalanidhi' Sri T.M.Krishna. Also read the above remarks. - "M.K.Subramanian."
எனக்கு திரு TMKன் கொள்கைகளில் ஒப்பில்லை. அவரின் சொந்த விருப்பு/வெறுப்பு அவரின் தேர்வு. ஆனால் இப்படி ஒரு எளிய கவியை எடுத்து அதற்கு ஏற்ற ராகமுடன் உயிர் கொடுப்பது மிகவும் பாராட்ட வேண்டியது. இப்படிப்பட்ட முயற்சி இவ்வித இசையை பரப்புவதில் பங்கு வகிக்கும் என்பதில் ஐயமில்லை. இசையை ரசிப்போம் - இறையைக் காண்போம்.
I have listened to very less Carnatic Music, However Raga Kedar has been one of my favorites. I literally felt Kedar in this particular rendition. On an emotional level, I hardly feel there is any difference in the two genres.
There are gamakas which are the very soul to the south Indian music traditions. If you listen to a lot of Carnatic music or even Carnatic based movie songs you can clearly feel the Hindustani music and the presentation is very different. Even this ragam is not exact Kedar but that's the best we can relate to.
The rendering is good. The raga is one of my favourites. Curious to know if a new genre is emerging in Indian Classical Music by the name of "protest sangeetam, and TMK is its pioneer."
Jayashankar Rajagopalan I’m more curious to know if politics in hampering the arts and artists, which is giving rise to the non-existent new genre you mentioned. Also, Music has been used as a form of protest since years by the way. Including music pieces against British in India and against the Saudi in Pakistan. Arts served and serve to be the utmost subtle means of expression and education for or against anything correct or wrong
No to worry about protest and support. That is all human nature and prevailing here on the earth. Music is divine, a good rendition of raga reaches its destination where there is no room for protest. The meaning of the words have a divine meaning and it does not have the purported meaning the singer may have in mind before singing the songs. Once the singer is immersed in the song, there is one purpose and that is different
It is close Manu. But there are distinct characteristics which make Hamirkalyani different. The suddha madhyamam, for instance. And the various prayogams involving either or both madhyamams.
The problem is the difficulty of having two each of the ears and eyes. They see and hear the same all the time. Should use one set to see the person and listen to his music.
ravee mahadevan we can't be blind to all the non sense and gimmicks he is indulging in Chennai. In the name taking music to the masses, he has taken music to the dogs.
Ram krishna, my PAttee ( grandmother, here) used to tell me and I quote her in tamizh " patarathAna, veli-vasaley ninnu pAdu. Aadu, mAdu, paravai, anEka jeeva jalangalum kekkattum. The lord's pic with his music and the cows in tango always had an importance to me because it conveys much more than what meets the eye. And ear, if you may. Krishna took it to the cows. If TMK has really been successful in imparting it to the dogs, as you mentioned, from the confines of the Sabhas, I for one, would be the happiest. They respond much better than many of the twin legged creatures. His music? We all know he excels in it when he needs to. So much for that. And to conclude- English, sometimes, is a lousy way to communicate an idea. I am sure the dogs would agree. I put this discussion to rest. You may respond, troll, abuse or insult and sign out if you so wish. I would appreciate all that with a 'Namaskaram, Periavar'
That's true of the average Carnatic rendition, as compared to its Hindustani equivalent, most of the time. There's a sense that a lot more goes on in each phrase, right from the moment the aalap sets off for us.
Define meditative. The hamir Kalyani of Carnatic music is NOT kedAra of Hindustani tradition, although it might have common origins with it. Listen to some compositions of hamir kalyani and you'll come to know that like dvijavanthi, it has been shaped into a strong carnatic raga even while retaining aspects of the Hindustani lakshanas. I have uploaded venkata shaila vihara rendered by same musician. Observe the rendering of the composition, which has strong carnatic phrases of hamir kalyani. ua-cam.com/video/OMj5Xib3tdc/v-deo.html
Bhargav, Gaurav, good observation. Yes the rendition has a strong carnatic touch to it. TMK is a carnatic musician! And indeed same goes for Venkata saila vihara.
@@bhargavram3480 @UCrZJW7XJD6PTGdo-Kh16rlA @UCIbtvt76iNdQO0APU8Krm4A While we are on the topic of Kedar/Hamir Kalyani, I would like to draw your attention to another near-perfect rendition of Hindustani Kedar by Kishori Tai ua-cam.com/video/wmyrgqdyWR8/v-deo.html. I liked it very much, thought you would like to hear it too.
@Shreyas K Don't even bother with such people sir. He/she will not change. We can only suffer such people because they are the loudest. I am pretty sure someone will see my surname and assume that I'm talking with a hidden agenda. I've stopped commenting below such statements just because of this reason. I can't even remember how many people have insulted me and my family for appreciating or defending TMK. I can't remember how many people said that me and my parents were 'rice bag converts' and that I shouldn't be listening to Carnatic music. I have given up completely. There is no hope. I sometime pop online like this on the comments section just to warn people not waste time arguing with these people.
@Shreyas K at least we still have open minded people like you :) And I can still enjoy carnatic music through UA-cam!!! Just have to remind myself not to look at the comments section if it's a TMK video. Also....May God bless you :)
In FEA curated concerts does he come in lungi to perform? his latest stunt . Does he sing on allah and christ ? Does he perform nerevals with objectionable and unparliamentary words??
FEA, it's time to feature Akkarai Subhalakshmi in a full fledged performance. What a stunningly evocative performer!
We love your violin suhalakshmi want to listen to you more often God bless you swarajyam
Subhu mam..what you hold in your shoulder is not your violin but the soul of carnatic music.hats off you mam and the magic performer tmk...
Absolutely
She's an exceptional vocalist too.
Exactly ❤❤❤
I like the way tanpura player Shri Jayant Naidu is appreciating the singing, he has been accompanying artist all South and North for years, true music gets true appreciation...
அழகிய பாடல் வரிகளை தேனமுதாய் வடித்து ரசிகமணிகளுக்கு விருந்து படைத்த விதம் அருமை👍
This is just too beautiful! I listen to this almost everyday. Hamir kalyani is one of my favorite ragams and T.M Krishna sir has beautifully brought the essence of this Raga in just 30 min. This honestly brought me tears. His knowledge is so powerful and inspires everyone. His music not only reaches the carnatic singers or the people in the carnatic field but also any commoner can feel the emotion of this ragam.
Thank you for this 🙏😭
Well said!
Nothing but devine singing. What an apt accompaniment. Great rendering by both.
Arumai.There are so many beautiful and soulful songs in Tamil literature.If it is in the voice of TMK,
really it is melting our mind.
Singing is undoubtedly par excellence. One observation about TMK is, how he engages with PAKKAVADYA team. During whole concert, he connects with whole team. Incredible.
TMK has brought out complete emotion in the raga Hamir Kalyani. Great singing, equally matched by the accompanists. So peaceful and soothing to hear.
💙
They supernova occurs once in 100 years. TMK is star of India. Once in lifetime of human history.(They say)
Haha
Apparently there's not much of good music you have listened to.
@@AnanthNatyou look as miserable as I assumed you to be. 😂
I am a Tamilian. But none of the words in the song I could comprehend. On the contrary,, my heart stood still from the beginning to end of T.M. KrishnA's Hamir kalyanai. Ushered me inTo trance. Violin and Mruthangkam superb.
@@shrikhar Happens to some people who are still stuck with the Carnatic trinities compositions.
@@shrikhar Could you please give us a rough translation for those who don't understand Tamil? Would be very grateful 🙏🏼🤗
The exchange of hameer kalyani between you and the violinist is more enjoyable. Mr. Perumal murugan would have forgotten all the humility he underwent after hearing this concert
One of the biggest mysteries to me is who are these people who down vote such a beautiful rendition and more importantly why ?
think of them as crows cawing from the trees, or trolls that live under a bridge. They have no appreciation for beauty. They are about making noise.
slumdogmusic
They are simply sadists
slumdogmusic tmk is more known for the controversies he kicks up than for his art.he is mediocre.and these days we have so much of a dearth of maestros in Carnatic music that even tmk is regarded a maestro.
Anyway,he is one of the best singers we have.i wish him all the best.
I think you are confusing his possible mediocrity (I don't have an opinion on that) in the various controversies he is in the middle of with his mediocrity in music. He is truly an amazing musician.
It is extremely delightful to see such beautiful give and take between artistes. Beautiful and symbiotic performances of rāgam and thānam by both Krishna and Akkarai. And not to mention Vijay Siva's befitting accompaniment on the Mrudangam.. Beautifully set composition. There is no T.M. Krishna there. There is only music. And then there is pure bliss into which T.M. Krishna and the accompanying artistes coalesce... ❤
Perhaps Vijay Siva, being the vocalist brother of Manoj Siva, also plays Mrudangam quite well, but this is Manoj :). very well said though!
அர்த்தம் புரிந்து ரசிக்கும் போது அந்த நதியின் வரவை வேண்டுகிறோம். மிக அருமை TMK AND AKKARAI
மீண்டும் மீண்டும் கேட்டுக் கொண்டே இருக்கிறேன் .
Spell bound. Is that the right word. Am so in bliss my eyes are welling up. The violonist is Ammazing too. And how they enhance each other. ❤️🙏🏾💐
Hameerkalyani Swaram paattu Super .Pakkavaadyangal Super.Thanks
Excellent rendition of hamir Kalyani .. Akkarai ji takes us to different level . Sheer bliss !!
Yes madam
And if interested, please watch this interview madam. She lived in Delhi ,she was interested in music and she couldn't attend concerts. Starting at the age of seven, she heard recorded concerts and cassettes and practised to reproduce what she heard before a proper training in violin. Thanks and regards.
ua-cam.com/video/NT1fVKXK5q8/v-deo.html
We are so lucky to experience TMK’s sheer musical genius in our times. And Akkarai is the perfect foil for TMK’s unparalleled musical magic.
Excellent rendition. Wow, what an understanding between the singer and the accompanying artists. Thoroughly enjoyed. PRANAMS to all.
Thanks a lot to FEA for posting such heavenly clips !!
How could anyone with basic music sense/ interest disregard such a beautiful rendition!!
Because the beauty of the music and the artform has little to do with what is essentially an exclusionary tradition that has done little to actually expand the boundaries of this art
Because taste differs & some folks are more aesthetically inclined than technical mastery. I did not feel the beauty of this gorgeous ragam in this rendering. His performance is more technical & like lecture demo atleast for me. Not to mentions issues with sruthi, diction & frankly singing talent
@@prakks the thing with singing is no one really listens to correct the singer. So unless you're an expert technically, you wouldn't waste your time doing that. Not that it's a bad thing though
What a brilliant performance.The most talented violinist that I have ever heard.Krishna sir ❤️❤️❤️🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🌹🌹🌹🌹
Krutagnyatalu for this fabulous concert. What a violinist!
Thank you so much for sharing this, such a delightful exploration of an utterly arresting raga
Excellent lyrics beautiful rendition.
This emotional relation between the singer and the violonist have something flamenco
GRT observation...
excellent.. mind blowing krishnaji..😘😘
True homage to Madam Gauri Lankesh, hats off to TM Krishna sir.. God bless you
This too is another enchanting rendition of yours krishna ji
Beautiful theme, entrancing Hamir Kalyani and the violin performance at 14.40!!
One of the finest Hamir Kalyan's I have heard from a Carnatic genre singer.
A very nice compostion and a superb rendering. Enjoyed it very much!
Superlative! A joy to see the empathy between all on stage, as well as hear something to cherish and remember! I am absolutely foreign to Carnatic music and languages, but, nevertheless completely enthralled by TMK's singing and AS on the violin. Hope to see and hear them many more times.
Many thanks.great singing.
Fantastic! Music of Poetry and Poetry of Music....Salutes.
What a rendition! No words
Addicted to your music sir..
A soulful experience,Thanks TMK
What an outstanding rendition of Hamir Kalyan!! Great!!
Only one word : super with cascading sangatis!
Awesome performance. He is at the pinnacle of glory.
Ramya Keerthi he always was and always will
He is not a human being! HE IS A MIRACLE . Same goes for Akkarai Shubhalakshmi-Dr.PV.Jois
The TNS Hamir Kalyani cannot be beaten. It is something else.
Awesome krishna sir.I am from A.P.westgodavari,Penugonda.we are very lucky to have A Gandarva T.M.K with us.I am a deepest fan of you.In your singing any raaga stands as mile stone.violin sister subbalakshmi excellent following.
TNS indeed excels in HK, Brindavasaranga and such.
Pl. read the above remarks. Enjoy the concert. Also read the introductory remarks by 'Sangeetha Kalanidhi' Sri T.M.Krishna. Also read the above remarks. - "M.K.Subramanian."
TMK & Akkarai Subbulakshmi Chemistry. They Mutually never try to be One Up against the Other. Both
Always Receptive Listeners too.
personaly I couldnot agree with TMK ,but I heartly love his music .fantastic
எனக்கு திரு TMKன் கொள்கைகளில் ஒப்பில்லை. அவரின் சொந்த விருப்பு/வெறுப்பு அவரின் தேர்வு. ஆனால் இப்படி ஒரு எளிய கவியை எடுத்து அதற்கு ஏற்ற ராகமுடன் உயிர் கொடுப்பது மிகவும் பாராட்ட வேண்டியது. இப்படிப்பட்ட முயற்சி இவ்வித இசையை பரப்புவதில் பங்கு வகிக்கும் என்பதில் ஐயமில்லை. இசையை ரசிப்போம் - இறையைக் காண்போம்.
Beautiful. Just Beautiful.
Beautiful rendition
TMK shines with Hamir Kalyani
Wow What A Tanam......
By the way.....Is it teesra Nadai Aadi Talam ?
yes it is
Excellent concert.
Sir beautiful ❤❤❤
Supper sir thanks tamilnadu
Extraordinary!!!!
One and only TMK!
Those who can enjoy this can enjoy Hindustani classical music also " Kanare Nand Nandana ii Hey Dhuk banjana parama Niranjana ii Kanare.."
I have listened to very less Carnatic Music, However Raga Kedar has been one of my favorites. I literally felt Kedar in this particular rendition. On an emotional level, I hardly feel there is any difference in the two genres.
There are gamakas which are the very soul to the south Indian music traditions. If you listen to a lot of Carnatic music or even Carnatic based movie songs you can clearly feel the Hindustani music and the presentation is very different. Even this ragam is not exact Kedar but that's the best we can relate to.
Saint TMK
This performance seems to me to have more of a Carnatic feel to it.
Im pretty sure this is a carnatic concert :)
Very nice.Pakka vaadyam are also excellent.
I am TM Krishna fan.
Very nice hamir kalyani.
great singing sir
That" P M M G m R S" at 28:54😁😁👌👌
Time FEA mentioned Akkarai Subhalakshmi in the title along with TMK, no?
The rendering is good. The raga is one of my favourites. Curious to know if a new genre is emerging in Indian Classical Music by the name of "protest sangeetam, and TMK is its pioneer."
I would definitely support it,if such a genre existed though.
Jayashankar Rajagopalan I’m more curious to know if politics in hampering the arts and artists, which is giving rise to the non-existent new genre you mentioned. Also, Music has been used as a form of protest since years by the way. Including music pieces against British in India and against the Saudi in Pakistan. Arts served and serve to be the utmost subtle means of expression and education for or against anything correct or wrong
With his musical genius alone he can reach the pinnacle. Unfortunately he has taken the path of controversies to gain only notoriety.
No to worry about protest and support. That is all human nature and prevailing here on the earth. Music is divine, a good rendition of raga reaches its destination where there is no room for protest. The meaning of the words have a divine meaning and it does not have the purported meaning the singer may have in mind before singing the songs. Once the singer is immersed in the song, there is one purpose and that is different
Too good...🙏🙏🙏
Speechless!!!
Aalap is allmost feels kalyani raagam..
It is close Manu. But there are distinct characteristics which make Hamirkalyani different. The suddha madhyamam, for instance. And the various prayogams involving either or both madhyamams.
Akkari Subhalakshmi mam super namikkunnu njan
Beautiful ❤️ can someone please provide a translation to the lyrics? Even if it's a basic one, it's okay :) Would be very grateful 🤗🙏🏼
"sh"ollil? please... such beautiful lyrics...
Waaaahhh
Superb
Which song is this can i have the lyrics... mesmerized
TMK the best.
Only Passion Enjoyment Music nothing else.
Super
TMK a genius .what an Hamirkalyan.
Anybody here after Malargalea Malargalea song?
🙏🌹🌹🌹💝
TMK fine!
🙏🙏🙏
This is set in Thisra jati, if I'm not wrong
Tisra nadai or tisra gati.
Jaati has a different meaning.
Hameer kallyani super music tharappi
Thenamuthu
Thanks FEA, for making Tmk "sing". You have achieved something which no one could get out of him.
RAM KRISHNA what's the problem?
What a brilliant alapana wow great thanks a lot hear him
The problem is the difficulty of having two each of the ears and eyes. They see and hear the same all the time. Should use one set to see the person and listen to his music.
ravee mahadevan we can't be blind to all the non sense and gimmicks he is indulging in Chennai. In the name taking music to the masses, he has taken music to the dogs.
Ram krishna, my PAttee ( grandmother, here) used to tell me and I quote her in tamizh " patarathAna, veli-vasaley ninnu pAdu. Aadu, mAdu, paravai, anEka jeeva jalangalum kekkattum. The lord's pic with his music and the cows in tango always had an importance to me because it conveys much more than what meets the eye. And ear, if you may. Krishna took it to the cows. If TMK has really been successful in imparting it to the dogs, as you mentioned, from the confines of the Sabhas, I for one, would be the happiest. They respond much better than many of the twin legged creatures. His music? We all know he excels in it when he needs to. So much for that. And to conclude- English, sometimes, is a lousy way to communicate an idea. I am sure the dogs would agree. I put this discussion to rest. You may respond, troll, abuse or insult and sign out if you so wish. I would appreciate all that with a 'Namaskaram, Periavar'
@14:18 self reminder
This is true improvisation.. not trained phrases.
Is that a violin or a viola?
It's a violin.
Unless your question was rhetoric...
Looks like mimicry...cry
Sheer mockery
With due respect to his singing , his mannerisms are very funny
Einstein.. Vivekananda.. Gandhi.. tmk.. etc happens once in a blue moon
Haha
Laughing still.
People go overboard.
Let's think of he might have been in the limelight but for his political activities.
Kedar. Only less meditative.
That's true of the average Carnatic rendition, as compared to its Hindustani equivalent, most of the time. There's a sense that a lot more goes on in each phrase, right from the moment the aalap sets off for us.
Define meditative.
The hamir Kalyani of Carnatic music is NOT kedAra of Hindustani tradition, although it might have common origins with it. Listen to some compositions of hamir kalyani and you'll come to know that like dvijavanthi, it has been shaped into a strong carnatic raga even while retaining aspects of the Hindustani lakshanas. I have uploaded venkata shaila vihara rendered by same musician. Observe the rendering of the composition, which has strong carnatic phrases of hamir kalyani. ua-cam.com/video/OMj5Xib3tdc/v-deo.html
Bhargav Ramv.....very....fine.
.
melodious.music
...
Bhargav, Gaurav, good observation. Yes the rendition has a strong carnatic touch to it. TMK is a carnatic musician! And indeed same goes for Venkata saila vihara.
@@bhargavram3480 @UCrZJW7XJD6PTGdo-Kh16rlA @UCIbtvt76iNdQO0APU8Krm4A While we are on the topic of Kedar/Hamir Kalyani, I would like to draw your attention to another near-perfect rendition of Hindustani Kedar by Kishori Tai ua-cam.com/video/wmyrgqdyWR8/v-deo.html. I liked it very much, thought you would like to hear it too.
He is busy in watching lady. Sir you must hear karnatic music by Alathur brothers
@Shreyas K Don't even bother with such people sir. He/she will not change. We can only suffer such people because they are the loudest. I am pretty sure someone will see my surname and assume that I'm talking with a hidden agenda. I've stopped commenting below such statements just because of this reason. I can't even remember how many people have insulted me and my family for appreciating or defending TMK. I can't remember how many people said that me and my parents were 'rice bag converts' and that I shouldn't be listening to Carnatic music. I have given up completely. There is no hope. I sometime pop online like this on the comments section just to warn people not waste time arguing with these people.
@Shreyas K at least we still have open minded people like you :) And I can still enjoy carnatic music through UA-cam!!! Just have to remind myself not to look at the comments section if it's a TMK video.
Also....May God bless you :)
Comment is in poor taste. If you have a point to make, maybe not try to disrespect the artists next time.
And all you could notice is the man watching the lady, not his rendition. How very convenient 🤓
Lol people with petty minds make petty comments 🤣 caught red-handed
In FEA curated concerts does he come in lungi to perform? his latest stunt . Does he sing on allah and christ ? Does he perform nerevals with objectionable and unparliamentary words??
Actually he did sing on Allah and Christ. Which was kinda cool.
What's wrong in wearing lungi or dhoti!? Both are typical south Indian male attire!!
Yov 🙄
🙏🙏🙏🌹🌹🌹🙏🙏🙏