Islamic System and Sharia | Context of the Debate | Part 1

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 8 лют 2018
  • Dr. Taimur Rahman explores the points of divergence between modernists and traditionalists regarding Sharia Law.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 243

  • @WorldOfMountains
    @WorldOfMountains 2 роки тому +2

    تیمور رحمان یار آپ کا طریقہ کار بہت خوبصورت ہے کہ بڑی ہمدردی سے کسی کو برا لگے بغیر اس کی جہالت کا اعتراف کرایا جائے اور پھر اس جہالت سے نکلنے پر آمادہ کیا جائے۔

  • @xposurecity5316
    @xposurecity5316 2 роки тому +2

    Dr.Shb Ap jaisy logo ko dkh or sun kr khushi hoti or umeed paida hoti ha Slamat rahin ❤ ❤ ❤

  • @imtiazhrz2074
    @imtiazhrz2074 3 роки тому +9

    The whole summarization of the video is, Shariah means rules manifest by God through various revelations and jurisprudence means interpretation of Shariah rules by Human through self-conscience and varied level of apprehensions. There are five major school of jurisprudence in Islam including Hanfi, Malaki, shafi hanbali and shia school of jurisprudence. Until 13th century jurisprudence and interpretation of Quran and Sunnah had almost halted and Ijtihad was no more considered requisite which is the interpretation of sharia rules according to any specific time interval or needs

  • @humayunzahid5979
    @humayunzahid5979 3 роки тому +5

    There are two terms used in Islamic laws. Had and tazeer. In field of tazeer legislature has authority to make laws under umbrella of basic religious injunctions. But in field of had punishments have been told through revealed text...

  • @madhukarjadhav2405
    @madhukarjadhav2405 11 місяців тому +1

    Great explanation,
    it will help Muslim society to be clear about sharia and life economics. Help the society to differentiate the economics and dharma.
    Respect your clarity and scholarship
    Madhukar Jadhav

  • @ghulambrohi8637
    @ghulambrohi8637 6 років тому +24

    بہت خوب سر آپ کے لیکچر نہایت آسانی سے سمجھ میں آتے ہیں اور یہ کہ چھوٹی چھوٹی کلپس ہیں دیکھنے میں وقت نہیں لگتا

  • @muhammadaurangzaib4509
    @muhammadaurangzaib4509 2 роки тому +2

    ماشاءللہ،آپ کی گفتگو بڑی علمی ہوتی ہے

  • @justujuesubhenau2369
    @justujuesubhenau2369 4 роки тому +1

    شکریہ آپ نے ہم جیسے لوگوں کے لئے آسان اور قابل فہم انداز میں ان موضوعات کا انتخاب کیا جن ہر محض ایک طبقے کا اجارہ دارانہ نقطہ نظر مسلط کیا جاتا رہا ہے۔

  • @atiqahmad2018
    @atiqahmad2018 4 роки тому +2

    ایک انتہائی بہترین جدلیاتی تجزیہ۔ بہت عمدہ۔

  • @ahmednaeem5729
    @ahmednaeem5729 2 роки тому +1

    آپ کے طریقہِ بیان پر نزاکت قربان جاۓ...

  • @raykazii
    @raykazii 5 років тому +2

    Brilliantly explained. Thank you sir

  • @Anonymousinfatuation
    @Anonymousinfatuation 5 років тому +2

    Thank you Sir. I am a new follower of your videos

  • @springseason8404
    @springseason8404 2 роки тому +1

    I salute your contributions in v log. Indians are more here with great knowledge but language is a problem.I learnt the concept of marxism from you.I am a scholar in sialkot.

  • @azharbabar.com1
    @azharbabar.com1 2 роки тому +2

    Informative 🌹
    Thank u sir

  • @khoslapp
    @khoslapp 4 роки тому +4

    Thanks for very informative lesson.

  • @Ruppconsultancy
    @Ruppconsultancy 5 років тому +1

    Thanks. Please be continue sir

  • @WaheedRiaz
    @WaheedRiaz 4 роки тому +1

    Sir ap ki Falsafa per 114 lecturers kamal hain....good Weldon

  • @Shake0913
    @Shake0913 3 місяці тому +1

    I love your videos because you mentioned the reference from book 😁

  • @ishaqnabi5791
    @ishaqnabi5791 3 роки тому

    Boht khoob Dr sahb. Boht kuch clarify hua ye video dekh k.

  • @TasshayyoAli
    @TasshayyoAli 6 років тому +2

    Salamat raho. Banatay raho videos.

  • @Junaidkhan-bc5ns
    @Junaidkhan-bc5ns 2 роки тому +2

    Islam ka maaashi or siyasi nizaam khaskar hazrat umar(R.A) kai zamanai sai aik behtareen nizaam hai,agar apko kisi cheez kai barai mai ilam nahi hai is ka yeh matlab nahi kai woh cheez wajood he nai rakhte

  • @ziafarooqigilgiti8418
    @ziafarooqigilgiti8418 6 років тому +6

    thanks sir . your valueable lectures are as guide for us . Salute to you from Gilgit Baltistan

  • @globalwatch3295
    @globalwatch3295 3 роки тому +5

    Good series of lectures.
    Dr. Khalid Amin
    principal
    Govt. College,
    Chunian

  • @khaqanqamar9356
    @khaqanqamar9356 4 роки тому +7

    Hello sir I like your lectures spatially on philosophy. I am an Urdu poet .i want to know about modern philosophy

  • @47humza
    @47humza 5 років тому +3

    Could you record lectures on establishments judiciary ? If you don’t afraid ?

  • @ayesharubab4785
    @ayesharubab4785 2 роки тому +1

    Sir u are matchless person

  • @TechWorld-so3uk
    @TechWorld-so3uk 5 років тому +2

    Great effort sir.

  • @tactics7127
    @tactics7127 3 роки тому +6

    I have no words to describe your eminence.

  • @aneesahmed1818
    @aneesahmed1818 5 років тому +4

    i have learned a lot from you sir

  • @ej8530
    @ej8530 3 роки тому +1

    Is there an English version of this series?

  • @mohammadjoharali1227
    @mohammadjoharali1227 5 років тому +1

    nice explanation hotta hai sir aap ka , aabhi pura nahi suna

  • @quttubiftikharpirzada725
    @quttubiftikharpirzada725 5 років тому

    Slam sir ap ka Nizam e welayat pai kia opinions hai

  • @sherlarik3296
    @sherlarik3296 4 роки тому +1

    Sir political science k lye koe youtope suggest kro?

  • @iqrashehzadi3036
    @iqrashehzadi3036 7 місяців тому

    how to contact with you

  • @Blue-Grass786
    @Blue-Grass786 6 років тому +3

    Thanks for presenting these valuable lecturers.

  • @sympathy26
    @sympathy26 2 роки тому +1

    I learn from your lecture. India

  • @DearZainOfficial
    @DearZainOfficial 3 роки тому

    Sir books bh recommend ki krain or apni favourite books bh btaya krain

  • @zohebalikhan7404
    @zohebalikhan7404 4 роки тому +3

    PLz share a translation in english, thanks.

  • @muhammadrizwankhan5727
    @muhammadrizwankhan5727 5 років тому +2

    Sir plz plz plz publish lectures on political science for css

  • @mohammadyaqoob9824
    @mohammadyaqoob9824 4 роки тому +2

    in true islam" namaz means system ensuring equality in providing security and safety of honour, wealth and life of all is equal; roza means, every man and woman are bound to have war training to fight in the days of wars. zakat means share happiness and sorrows with each other; hajj means stage a jihad against who attack a muslim state. a muslim is who believe on equality with aiman on Hazrat Muhammad PBUH as messenger of God and God is alone.

  • @shahjahanmemon1959
    @shahjahanmemon1959 6 років тому +6

    Hats off to you, Comrade. More power to you!

  • @mnetech749
    @mnetech749 3 роки тому +4

    u should read Maulana Modudi books, islam guides in detail about politics, these 04 fiqh were not developed to govern khilafat system, expand ur vision.

  • @khalilkhan194
    @khalilkhan194 2 роки тому

    Sir ur method ..MashAllah ❤👌
    Plz give me a heart

  • @zahirkhan7631
    @zahirkhan7631 Рік тому

    sir . Any books regarding this debate ?

  • @mohammadjamal72
    @mohammadjamal72 4 роки тому +7

    I disagree on certain points.Not every kind of Ijtihad is prohibited and shariah deals with eco,IR as much as it deals with society.
    Muhazirat e Fiqh a must read book

  • @aamirhussain5982
    @aamirhussain5982 2 роки тому

    Thanks sir.... Appreciate

  • @abdullahzubair7389
    @abdullahzubair7389 4 роки тому +1

    Salam Sir, much agreed. The revival of practice of Ijtihad is necessary, but the question remains that who is deemed worthy of interpreting the religion in accordance with modern needs. Moreover, Muslims are bound by faith yet divided by sect and geographical barriers. Keeping this in mind, what is the geographical jurisdiction of Ijtihad conducted in Saudia or any other country? Insight and opinion is appreciated. Thanks...

  • @artandsoul860
    @artandsoul860 3 роки тому

    First time watching your video sir..

  • @rimshaaaiza9407
    @rimshaaaiza9407 3 роки тому +1

    Love from India 🇮🇳❤️

  • @PASHAAMU
    @PASHAAMU 4 роки тому +3

    Sir, I saw your lecturers on the history of philosophy on-media and elements, but they were not complete. How can I reach those complete videos.

  • @MSbabasayee
    @MSbabasayee Рік тому

    Holly Quran is higher rewards thanks forgiveness upon each other

  • @waheedkhan4517
    @waheedkhan4517 6 років тому +8

    Sir kindly one lecture on your journey about your struggles

  • @IjazKhan-qf2gg
    @IjazKhan-qf2gg 6 років тому +1

    tashakkur !!!sir

  • @blackwhite3159
    @blackwhite3159 Рік тому

    Allama Iqbal ny wo os point KY liyen Nahi farmaya , isko thorda bataiye mere Pas details Hain

  • @adeelzahid8940
    @adeelzahid8940 Рік тому

    Great video all time ❤️

  • @abdullahkhan43
    @abdullahkhan43 4 роки тому

    Rest of lecture is best

  • @abdullahgulzar2253
    @abdullahgulzar2253 3 роки тому

    Sir law ke liye koi acha sa channel batiye.

  • @piotrdoomisiewicz1555
    @piotrdoomisiewicz1555 4 роки тому +6

    Can somebody add english subtitles? Plox

    • @falsifiablerussell854
      @falsifiablerussell854 4 роки тому +2

      Piotr Dołomisiewicz I will soon

    • @mcboat3467
      @mcboat3467 3 роки тому

      @@falsifiablerussell854 where?

    • @nabeelk
      @nabeelk 3 роки тому

      There are already in english language as well.

  • @Gill0017
    @Gill0017 Рік тому

    Like ever healthy analysis...

  • @adeeljamal6846
    @adeeljamal6846 5 років тому +14

    I appreciate your efforts of sharing your knowledge on the subject. I ask you to take my point of view in a positive manner. I am hopeful that you will reconsider a part of what you said.
    You said that "sharia and fiqh' primarily deals with social matters and acts of worships. Most of the writings can be found on the issues of ethics etc."
    I suggest you to further your knowledge about Islamic sharia, legal rulings and matters of Ijtehaad by learning in the supervision of learned scholars like you did in the case of political science. This is not even close to reality. To quote an example from innumerable other examples,; there is a famous book called "Hidaya" written by Burhan-ud-deen Almurghani consisting of four volumes, one volume deals with 'Ibadaat' (acts of worship) and the other three deals with matters within society, economy, politics, relationships, obligations of muslims etc. Islam has given the principles for economy and politics in the light of which we can work on details, but to say that it is not enough, is incorrect. The absence of details should be seen as a 'flexibility', Islam has extended for legislation according to local customs and society that are in congruence with Islam, and not to be seen as deficiency. For example, In Islamic economic system, Interest-bearing transactions, gambling and speculative transactions are forbidden but all other modes of businesses excluding these are permitted with few other exceptions like 'Gharar'. Within this framework, the different schools of jurisprudence stipulated further rules and details that can be included to form a detailed ordinance governing the corporate, economic and banking activities.

    • @quamrulhassan8205
      @quamrulhassan8205 4 роки тому +6

      Bhai separate state and religion. Reduce military expenditures. Go for proper statistics and election. Introduce freedom of speach and pro-people education. Aur uske baad ALLAH ka naam le kar mar jayie. Upka mulk ka tarakki milenga, up ko Jannat v. Sharia sun-sunkar kaan paak giya. Lagta, Allah musalmano ka baap ka jagirdari hai.

    • @zundubi
      @zundubi 4 роки тому +5

      Quamrul Hassan that is your beginning of losing the track. Islam is not a religion it’s a way of life.

    • @zundubi
      @zundubi 4 роки тому +3

      Adeel Jamal he’s mixture of all western Ideologies with Indian History تڑکا can’t get to the simple and straight point on Islamic System.

    • @bravosix8171
      @bravosix8171 4 роки тому

      @@zundubi You are right.......

    • @namrasartajkhan661
      @namrasartajkhan661 2 роки тому

      @@quamrulhassan8205 how religion and state can be separated?
      There are two possibilities about the religion, either we accept it as the revealed religion or reject it. If we reject it then practicing it in our personal lives or claiming it as our religion would be nothing more than stupidity but if we accept it with all our senses and then rejecting it's role in managing the state when it already commands would be exceeding it's limits and again would be equal to rejection.
      Either we are Muslims or not, what's the middle terminology??

  • @sanaullahkhan9781
    @sanaullahkhan9781 Рік тому

    Sir please make video on two nations theory.

  • @s.soomro6300
    @s.soomro6300 3 роки тому +5

    Sir culture is one thing and Deen is other thing.

  • @shershah8749
    @shershah8749 5 місяців тому

    Plz make a public debate with Qaiser Ahmad Raja

  • @shaintajraisani
    @shaintajraisani 6 місяців тому

    I am interested to hearing your thoughts on the book of Ahmet Kuru titled “Islam , Authoritarianism and underdevelopment , can you share that ?
    Besides, when I was an undergraduate student of business administration , I realise that we are stuck in past in such a way that , we have forgotten, islam is not stagnant religion ,but modern Muslim needs modern solution .
    And sir , our students will require a bit of time to understand this simple fact , so what you are doing will be take time to get internalise . But I really enjoy your arguments .

  • @noumanarshad9247
    @noumanarshad9247 5 років тому

    How we elect president in Islamic voting

  • @ramishrana4776
    @ramishrana4776 4 роки тому +1

    sir make a video on ibne khuldoom muqadima plz plz

  • @shabeerhurr2994
    @shabeerhurr2994 6 років тому +3

    nice sir mASha ALLAh

  • @khizarhayat6300
    @khizarhayat6300 4 роки тому +1

    سر جی آپ نے کہا کہ ائمہ اربعہ نے اکانومی پہ نہیں لکھا براے کرم فقہ کی کوئی بھی کتاب دیکھ لیں اس میں کتاب البیوع موجود ہے جوکہ معاشی نظام پہ روشنی ڈالتی ہے اگر چہ اس میں جدید مسائل کی زیادتی کی اہمیت کے مدنظر اہل علم کام کر رہے ہیں

  • @learningwithrajveerbaby1943
    @learningwithrajveerbaby1943 3 роки тому +9

    This is the main problem that one cannot be open totally and Express freely his ideas related to religion. I can guess that you are trying to defend too much rather than criticize openly.

  • @blackwhite3159
    @blackwhite3159 Рік тому

    Islam aik mukamal zaptai hayat hai . That's it , liken main apky dil or dimag se nikli in tamam bataon pr apki izzat karta hn Sath ilmi ikhtilaf BHI .

  • @nazajoi1854
    @nazajoi1854 5 років тому

    Hi sir i am baloch from balochistan .....sir app plz balochistan kay histtey and north koriya kay baray bathain

  • @Nj01993
    @Nj01993 4 роки тому +1

    Please include videos in English

  • @hassnatahmed3175
    @hassnatahmed3175 5 років тому +1

    good sirrr
    elegant

  • @shahjahan6994
    @shahjahan6994 5 років тому +2

    gorgeous sir

  • @alamgirqambrani291
    @alamgirqambrani291 4 роки тому +4

    Dr. Taimur Rahman sb I have one observation about play list of Mix - Socialism vs. Capitalism: in this we do not find any sequence
    like Numbering Lectures or part wise, they are random. it breaks the sequence of your great lectures to hear. I hope it will be resolved in,
    upcoming series . Thanks

  • @anasmehmood9720
    @anasmehmood9720 3 роки тому +4

    We need debates like these.

  • @factswithmk1692
    @factswithmk1692 2 роки тому +1

    Sir Plz once must read the ideology and the concept of Imam shah waliullah regarding Islam. Imam shah walliullah gave a complete system of islam. And the edge is that the Birth of Imam shah walliullah is on the " junction Badshahat & and start of industrial revolution"
    And must must go through the academia of moulana ubaidullh Sindhi Bcz the late sindhi is very rational Islamic scholar . Hazrat sindhi solved out all these complexities of traditionalism and modernism or liberalism. Sir if U once go through hazrat sindhi's school of thought your concept regarding islam ( old concept) will be clear.
    I must appreciate your effort sir..
    May Allah Almighty Bless u 🌹🌹🌹🥰🥰

  • @sabiruddinsiddiqui8683
    @sabiruddinsiddiqui8683 3 роки тому

    ابتدائی مکالمہ بہت اچّھا ہے. امید ہے شریعہ اور فقہ پر آپکا لکچر دلچسپ ہوگا. شکریہ!

  • @shaheenplusatoz5590
    @shaheenplusatoz5590 2 роки тому +1

    سر بس صاف کہ دے کہ اس کی کوئی خارجہ پالیسی نہیں ہے بس اخلاقیات پر زور دیتے ہیں

  • @generalinformation9796
    @generalinformation9796 4 роки тому +6

    You are a great teacher..

  • @abdulhayee6671
    @abdulhayee6671 5 років тому +1

    Be jijhak apne khayal zahir karte rahe

  • @samson1986
    @samson1986 2 роки тому

    What if we open ijtibah and start working
    More on exploring Islamic political system? Would it sound better to a socialist person?

  • @mudassarmaqbool8509
    @mudassarmaqbool8509 4 роки тому +1

    Excellent Sir

  • @ahmedhumayunrasheed2434
    @ahmedhumayunrasheed2434 5 років тому +4

    Dr. Tahir Qadri good authority on Jurisprudence!

  • @muhammadzulfiqarsahito2835
    @muhammadzulfiqarsahito2835 5 років тому +36

    Well Sir, What I Can Say is People in Pakistan just don't get Facts. You're singing to the cats. Stay safe.

    • @haroonemir3777
      @haroonemir3777 3 роки тому +1

      U r totally wrong every lines r not equal to one another and sir know what's wrong and what's right

    • @muhammadhashir9501
      @muhammadhashir9501 2 роки тому

      Òimijjj888you 788ppto

    • @wajjadsahito3264
      @wajjadsahito3264 Рік тому

      when short minded people get educated they consider themselves better humans in terms of living, eating, wearing and knowledge but actually their mental progress is not more than unknown people

    • @muhammadzulfiqarsahito2835
      @muhammadzulfiqarsahito2835 Рік тому

      @@wajjadsahito3264 But brother, aren't we all lesser humans in eyes of ruling elites??

  • @Bilal-qy2sb
    @Bilal-qy2sb 4 роки тому

    Sir ap teaching line ma hi rhen ya music band churen ap k shan e shayan ni music wla kam

  • @ak-nb3qv
    @ak-nb3qv 4 роки тому +2

    excellent

  • @JournalistRehman
    @JournalistRehman 5 років тому +3

    I am following you comrade.india hyderabad.

  • @AbdulRasheed-iz5hu
    @AbdulRasheed-iz5hu 3 роки тому +1

    سر بین الاقوامی قوانین، کاروبار، معاشی اور اقتصادی نظام اسلام نے بھی متعارف کروایا تھا۔

  • @dahiyaqalbi4124
    @dahiyaqalbi4124 7 місяців тому

    Watching it after 5 years of uploading,
    I just opened the video because the fonts used in thumbnail are in trend nowadays

  • @sherlarik3296
    @sherlarik3296 4 роки тому

    Sir I am student of law pls mjh law k lye b Chanel batao pls sir

  • @syedmujtaba2218
    @syedmujtaba2218 6 років тому +1

    WELL SAID

  • @mohammadyaqoob9824
    @mohammadyaqoob9824 4 роки тому

    my advice for all to also listen modern islamic scholars namely dr. Asar-ul-Islam and Allama Pervez Ahmad to hear true Islam, which has no link with one we are following at present. hundreds of videos of both the scholars are available on youtube

  • @northman7636
    @northman7636 4 роки тому +6

    Islamic system ne Riasat madinah k ilawa konsi riasat ko taraqi dilayi hai. Except that era 1400yrs ago..

  • @wajjadsahito3264
    @wajjadsahito3264 Рік тому +1

    well sir i respect you and learning from your videos but i will say that if we read Quran there clearly mentioned free economic system

  • @abdulhayee6671
    @abdulhayee6671 5 років тому +1

    Sir boht allaa

  • @khalidfarooq5438
    @khalidfarooq5438 Рік тому

    Taimur sahib. Can I see u. I am kalid Farooq basra living in dha. I was anti capitalism I was convicted one year jail as student leader I have written a book علماء کے سرمایہ داری رویے

  • @nizarali1406
    @nizarali1406 5 років тому

    sunat is the devine law shariya is one of the principles of the devine law of the quran and hadith which is modified by people according to their time. but what about tareeqat, haqiqat, matifat?

  • @ishaqbuneri
    @ishaqbuneri 2 роки тому

    Lecturer sahib, Das Kapital, the wealth of nations, our dielectic theory Kay sat sat, Islam ka eqtisadi nizam ( az mulana Hifzorehman Seohari our, Hujjatullah ulbaligha az Shah Waliullah Dehlawe study kar kay es lecture ko phir say replace karkay sahe tajzia pesh karay.Shukria

  • @muzamilkirmani2240
    @muzamilkirmani2240 Рік тому

    As a Political Science student, I want to join a political party, Which party would you suggest me Sir?

    • @afaqjabbar8800
      @afaqjabbar8800 Рік тому

      Mazdoor kisan party will be good. Make a move.