Also, 'Saiki is the lynchpin' - yes! This happens so often with them. It's amazing how often the music is really chaotic, with Akane, Kanami and Misa constantly soloing and never repeating themselves, but Saiki (and Miku) give it a solid foundation, and the whole thing comes across as much more straightforward than it really is. It's some kind of magic trick.
One of my favorite things about Band Maid's live mixes is the panning of the guitars. Kanami usually on the right and Miku to the left. It helps me hear what both of them are doing which is really cool.
I was very happy to get the instrumental as there is so much happening under the vocals that that was the only way I could hear it. Even then the complexity is mind blowing. That they can do this, and Black Hole, live is a tribute to the skill of these ladies.
Eureka! You just explained everything for me. Akane is a robot, a machine, not human. Finally it makes sense… or does it? This whole band has me in Shambles. The Saiki portion is mesmerizing. Seeing her live was breathtaking. As was Misa. As was Kanami. And then there’s Miku, bringer of the Gap. Thanks for this great presentation of my favorite band. I really enjoy your reactions Jon. Thank you!
Another example of Band Maid being a miracle. Yes, Kanami comes up with this wonderful, complex music. But her band mates have the technical and musical chops to execute and make real that music.
How to write a BAND-MAID song, first start with a master piece instrumental highlighting each instrument then add vocals over the top that match perfectly. Easy.....for BAND-MAID.
Thanks Jon--great deep dive, especially comments on the live version. I only notice now Misa's interposition during Saiki's vocals at 25:45. So cool. And calling out post-modernist nonsense! Cheers.
Democracy works well when it is done properly. Band Maid clearly have somebody (Kanami) that has a selection and collection of music on her computer and in her vast brain. Then the arrangement and suggestions go to the experts in their instruments who offer suggestions and insights. The lyrics are provided by Miku or Saiki on occasion. What we have is a perfect democracy. Yes a musical leader but the experts in their field provide a solid platform and back up. Saiki then just improves everything with emotion and charisma that has been built on over the years. Which makes each song a unique experience. No huge egos just a promise to make every effort to make each song as perfect as it can be. Then the live versions just have a charisma that are and continue to be almost hypnotic. You see if only the World Leaders were a band of Japanese Women called Band Maid.
🙏🙏 😢😢 We need BAND-MAID to dominate the world! No freedom to the enemies of freedom! Miku the World Empress, come and save the world with PEACE&LOVE! 🙏🙏😢😢🕊🕊🕊🕊🕊
Giovanni gives me a unsetting vibes.... in a good way. like paying $ to walk through a hunted house to get a jump scared. The instrumental sounds like a whole other song just like the YOLO instrumental. I have easily listen to this song over a 1000 times by now (once going to work once coming home since its release) and I can not not hear Saiki singing in my head. HAHAHA! 14:20 right! she is cool as a cucumber with slight smile knowing she assembled one of the greatest rock bands in the world.
In the live version, considering that she knows what's coming, Saiki looks so incredibly relaxed and casual pulling a few shapes. This is totally masterful and shows her total professionalism. Like an actor getting into character. Just genius. Re. the chaos- I'm convinced that Kanami hears the whole thing in her head, so knows where she intends the arrangement to go- no probs. During the dissonant vocal section Akane is controlling the whole thing in particular Misa.
This song is stratosphere level prog awesomeness and I cannot legit understand how anyone cannot just bask in their musical orgasmic phenomenality. New word. Just accept it.
Scientists have changed the atomic clock to match the double kicks of Akane for better precision than the atom - and yes I think she may be a robot too.
BANDMAID is in no way shape or form just another rock band. BANDMAID is the greatest proper rock and roll band of the 21st century IMHO. It's a crazy statement. Was Mozart the world's greatest composer of his era? He'll yeah! The farther we get away from that time the more clearly we see the immensity of his talent. Few would argue with the above assessment. Everytime I write "IMHO" after BandMaid is the greatest proper rock and roll band of the 21st century I feel like a liar. IMHO my ass! IMHO water is wet. BandMaid rules right now. 66 years old here. The future will prove us right.
P.S. I understand your mistaking Akane for a robot. Actually you are witnessing a rare combination of passion, raw talent and grueling practice. Literally blood, sweat and tears ~ all this nurtured in a culture committed to excellence in everything from making a sword, building a temple or wrapping a rice ball. Thank you for your most excellent reaction/breakdown!
@@chrisegbertky Neil Peart was quoted as saying "I Wasn't TALENTED... But I Was RELENTLESS!" I see a lot of similarities in Akane. Who else would throw their hands in the air and say "Fine, if you want 220 bpm for that song, give me a little time and I will unleash hell!". She has that humbleness, drive to improve and work ethic to succeed just like The Professor.
@@interstellardaveYou are so right in your comparison. Rush was my favorite band until these ladies came along. Technical prowess combined with a humbleness to continue to work to get better in part is the reason this is the best band on the planet.
@@interstellardaveTold someone couple weeks ago that the only two bands that could compare to them in the past 50 years were Rush and Zeppelin and he asked are you comparing them to Zeppelin my response was Yes I Am. If he has any musical sensibilities he will realize it too.
BAND-MIAD as a proof of the existence of God... Hmmm... Glad you said this. Because I was always saying the same thing. Moreover, they not only prove the existence of God, they also demonstrate the meaning and purpose of life. I remember I had a 'satori' moment somewhere back in 2020, while watching the Line Cube Shibuya Blu-Ray. Somewhere after 20 minutes or so I realised what is meaning of life: it is TO CREATE BEAUTY! That's what BAND-MAID is doing, and that's what each living thing in this universe must do. And then recently Saiki wrote the same in her lyrics for Forbidden Tale, complaining about copyright maniacs and other people who try to silence the artists for various ideological reasons: *Erasing the names of us, who passionately and tirelessly pursued beauty.* *How can you feel any joy in doing that? Can their story ever find peace?* -- *passionately and tirelessly pursued beauty* -- That's what all great artists are doing. And BAND-MAID holds the torch high!
Two completely different songs that just happen to be the same song, lol! I think of Miku's jaw dropping when Kanami handed her this and said, "Put lyrics to this, okay."
Miku claims Akane is half human, half gorilla. I believe she's half gorilla, but the other half has to be robot. Although... could a robot be so musical?
![BAND - MAID / Corallium LIVE at Shibuya Eggman [REACTION/ANALYSIS!!]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/gHFF-gzJ4kA/mqdefault.jpg)
![BAND - MAID / Corallium LIVE at Shibuya Eggman [REACTION/ANALYSIS!!]](/img/tr.png)
![BAND-MAID / Catharsis DOUBLE Reaction!! [Studio + ACOUSTIC LIVE!!]](/img/n.gif)
I've long believed that all three versions of this incredible song are necessary to fully appreciate it. So top marks for taking that approach.
Also, 'Saiki is the lynchpin' - yes! This happens so often with them. It's amazing how often the music is really chaotic, with Akane, Kanami and Misa constantly soloing and never repeating themselves, but Saiki (and Miku) give it a solid foundation, and the whole thing comes across as much more straightforward than it really is. It's some kind of magic trick.
One of my favorite things about Band Maid's live mixes is the panning of the guitars. Kanami usually on the right and Miku to the left. It helps me hear what both of them are doing which is really cool.
I was very happy to get the instrumental as there is so much happening under the vocals that that was the only way I could hear it. Even then the complexity is mind blowing. That they can do this, and Black Hole, live is a tribute to the skill of these ladies.
Eureka! You just explained everything for me. Akane is a robot, a machine, not human. Finally it makes sense… or does it? This whole band has me in Shambles. The Saiki portion is mesmerizing. Seeing her live was breathtaking. As was Misa. As was Kanami. And then there’s Miku, bringer of the Gap. Thanks for this great presentation of my favorite band. I really enjoy your reactions Jon. Thank you!
Kanami - hey Akane we might need to record a drum track for this. Akane - no problem, I can play the second complicated snare/tom rhythm with my feet.
Another example of Band Maid being a miracle. Yes, Kanami comes up with this wonderful, complex music. But her band mates have the technical and musical chops to execute and make real that music.
How to write a BAND-MAID song, first start with a master piece instrumental highlighting each instrument then add vocals over the top that match perfectly. Easy.....for BAND-MAID.
Thanks Jon--great deep dive, especially comments on the live version. I only notice now Misa's interposition during Saiki's vocals at 25:45. So cool. And calling out post-modernist nonsense! Cheers.
Democracy works well when it is done properly. Band Maid clearly have somebody (Kanami) that has a selection and collection of music on her computer and in her vast brain. Then the arrangement and suggestions go to the experts in their instruments who offer suggestions and insights. The lyrics are provided by Miku or Saiki on occasion. What we have is a perfect democracy. Yes a musical leader but the experts in their field provide a solid platform and back up. Saiki then just improves everything with emotion and charisma that has been built on over the years. Which makes each song a unique experience. No huge egos just a promise to make every effort to make each song as perfect as it can be. Then the live versions just have a charisma that are and continue to be almost hypnotic. You see if only the World Leaders were a band of Japanese Women called Band Maid.
🙏🙏
😢😢
We need BAND-MAID to dominate the world!
No freedom to the enemies of freedom!
Miku the World Empress, come and save the world with PEACE&LOVE! 🙏🙏😢😢🕊🕊🕊🕊🕊
Giovanni gives me a unsetting vibes.... in a good way. like paying $ to walk through a hunted house to get a jump scared.
The instrumental sounds like a whole other song just like the YOLO instrumental. I have easily listen to this song over a 1000 times by now (once going to work once coming home since its release) and I can not not hear Saiki singing in my head.
HAHAHA! 14:20 right! she is cool as a cucumber with slight smile knowing she assembled one of the greatest rock bands in the world.
Confirmed: It's A.I. AKANE INTELLIGENCE 🦍🥁🔥🧠
In the live version, considering that she knows what's coming, Saiki looks so incredibly relaxed and casual pulling a few shapes. This is totally masterful and shows her total professionalism. Like an actor getting into character. Just genius. Re. the chaos- I'm convinced that Kanami hears the whole thing in her head, so knows where she intends the arrangement to go- no probs. During the dissonant vocal section Akane is controlling the whole thing in particular Misa.
💯 I honestly can't think of words that do this song justice
👍👍👍Three helpings of awesomeness for the price of one reaction👍. What a bargain🤗. 🖖❤
This song is stratosphere level prog awesomeness and I cannot legit understand how anyone cannot just bask in their musical orgasmic phenomenality. New word. Just accept it.
Wait! "Orgasmic phenomenality..." OK, noted. Thanks!
Brilliant song and great reaction / review
So cool to be focused on Saiki for a whole song. She is a Queen on the stage.
Scientists have changed the atomic clock to match the double kicks of Akane for better precision than the atom - and yes I think she may be a robot too.
Not a robot but half gorilla.
Band-Maid doing Band-maid things.
World Peace through BAND-MAID, they rule!
BANDMAID is in no way shape or form just another rock band. BANDMAID is the greatest proper rock and roll band of the 21st century IMHO. It's a crazy statement.
Was Mozart the world's greatest composer of his era? He'll yeah! The farther we get away from that time the more clearly we see the immensity of his talent. Few would argue with the above assessment.
Everytime I write "IMHO" after BandMaid is the greatest proper rock and roll band of the 21st century I feel like a liar. IMHO my ass! IMHO water is wet. BandMaid rules right now. 66 years old here. The future will prove us right.
P.S. I understand your mistaking Akane for a robot. Actually you are witnessing a rare combination of passion, raw talent and grueling practice. Literally blood, sweat and tears ~ all this nurtured in a culture committed to excellence in everything from making a sword, building a temple or wrapping a rice ball.
Thank you for your most excellent reaction/breakdown!
@@chrisegbertky Neil Peart was quoted as saying "I Wasn't TALENTED... But I Was RELENTLESS!"
I see a lot of similarities in Akane. Who else would throw their hands in the air and say "Fine, if you want 220 bpm for that song, give me a little time and I will unleash hell!". She has that humbleness, drive to improve and work ethic to succeed just like The Professor.
For my money they’re better than every rock band that has debuted since 1979. 80’s to now, none touch them.
@@interstellardaveYou are so right in your comparison. Rush was my favorite band until these ladies came along. Technical prowess combined with a humbleness to continue to work to get better in part is the reason this is the best band on the planet.
@@interstellardaveTold someone couple weeks ago that the only two bands that could compare to them in the past 50 years were Rush and Zeppelin and he asked are you comparing them to Zeppelin my response was Yes I Am. If he has any musical sensibilities he will realize it too.
BAND-MIAD as a proof of the existence of God... Hmmm... Glad you said this. Because I was always saying the same thing.
Moreover, they not only prove the existence of God, they also demonstrate the meaning and purpose of life. I remember I had a 'satori' moment somewhere back in 2020, while watching the Line Cube Shibuya Blu-Ray. Somewhere after 20 minutes or so I realised what is meaning of life: it is TO CREATE BEAUTY! That's what BAND-MAID is doing, and that's what each living thing in this universe must do.
And then recently Saiki wrote the same in her lyrics for Forbidden Tale, complaining about copyright maniacs and other people who try to silence the artists for various ideological reasons:
*Erasing the names of us, who passionately and tirelessly pursued beauty.*
*How can you feel any joy in doing that? Can their story ever find peace?*
-- *passionately and tirelessly pursued beauty* --
That's what all great artists are doing.
And BAND-MAID holds the torch high!
Band-Maid is the answer.
Maybe my favorite Band-Maid song. goes so impossibly hard
This song is nuts
Hallucinating .
Okay, so how's your brain, John...
Did anyone else have issues with the video pausing or stuttering? I had to reload the page over 5 times.
No, it ran smoothly.
@wanderleyjesus6772 thank you. Evidently it's my router messing up
@@greylocke100 Have mercy on your router. Listening to Giovanni can ruin even the sturdiest silicon brains.
@@VladimirChupin If my Router cannot handle the Ladies at their gnarliest it deserves to end.
Two completely different songs that just happen to be the same song, lol! I think of Miku's jaw dropping when Kanami handed her this and said, "Put lyrics to this, okay."
😂😂😂poor Miku
@@johancoetser906 I'm sure she would not shrink from the challenge.
@@waynebenedict5785 She complained a few times how difficult it is to write lyrics. But she always rises to the challenge.
@@VladimirChupin The Pigeon won't be defeated and always does her best!
Jon, You're missing a bunch of reactions on your Band Maid playlist.
Miku claims Akane is half human, half gorilla. I believe she's half gorilla, but the other half has to be robot. Although... could a robot be so musical?
Band Maid is better than cowbells!
(Bass) How many band do that ? ... Most Japanese bands. Band-Maid, Gacharic Spin, to name a couple.
Akane = Gorilla
Not robot 😂😂😂
Akane broke your ability to speak
I have to agree. Akane is too precise and too fast to be human.