Demi Lovato - Heart Attack (Nikki Williams Demo)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 вер 2024
  • Demi Lovato - Heart Attack (Nikki Williams Demo)
    / demilovatoofficialchile

КОМЕНТАРІ • 563

  • @DAngeloWallace
    @DAngeloWallace 5 років тому +3125

    why didn't they keep the dubstep, 12-year-old me would have rocked out to that

    • @LGSN96
      @LGSN96 5 років тому +164

      Wow I did not expect to see you here. Hello my melancholic monotone king

    • @habits8695
      @habits8695 5 років тому +58

      Because Demi asked for it to be removed. Mitch Allan (producer of the song) said that in an interview.

    • @dlailoukq
      @dlailoukq 4 роки тому +16

      There is a version with demi with dubstep part :) you can look it up

    • @TheTrixster690
      @TheTrixster690 4 роки тому +2

      @@dlailoukq What's it called ? I'm looking for it and no progress.

    • @knorenknor3493
      @knorenknor3493 4 роки тому +3

      D'Angelo Wallace yall were 12 when this was released?

  • @bigw2743
    @bigw2743 4 роки тому +996

    She says "shave my legs" at 0:37 for anyone who, like me, was struggling to find it after seeing so many comments about it.

    • @MidnightHunter
      @MidnightHunter 4 роки тому +2

      Thank you! :D

    • @PastelFeathers
      @PastelFeathers 4 роки тому

      Thanks!😜😂

    • @mariahbd8365
      @mariahbd8365 4 роки тому +5

      WXLTER P_CKL_S ohhhh thanks. One of the most liked comments said "shave my legs at THE END" so I was skipping to the end of the song lmaowhdhe

    • @bigw2743
      @bigw2743 4 роки тому +1

      @@mariahbd8365 I just couldn't find it at all

    • @ihavetwoturtles8166
      @ihavetwoturtles8166 4 роки тому +1

      @@bigw2743 omg thank that was so sweet, i was really struggling.!!

  • @nicholasbert4475
    @nicholasbert4475 5 років тому +2059

    I like Demi's version but wow, this demo sounds amazing. My wig left my head after that dubstep break

    • @kwameocran2246
      @kwameocran2246 5 років тому +9

      💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀

    • @anthonycff
      @anthonycff 5 років тому +8

      Hahaha!! This comment 💀 😂

    • @OYJluv
      @OYJluv 5 років тому +12

      Its flat compared to demi's. Demi handles very well the chest notes and makes it sound fuller.

    • @nicholasbert4475
      @nicholasbert4475 5 років тому +24

      @@OYJluv Yeah I know, but I meant the dubstep break, it really slaps! Deserved to be on the final version

    • @MKMK11114
      @MKMK11114 4 роки тому +5

      Go get me some glue, I will fix ur wig to your head so it never jumps off

  • @melfromhell
    @melfromhell 6 років тому +4090

    COWARDS, they should've kept "shave my legs" in the final song. y'all act shook but it's not like it isn't the damn truth

    • @ohcar0line
      @ohcar0line 6 років тому +96

      PREACH IT

    • @Angiepremo
      @Angiepremo 6 років тому +47

      AMEN!!

    • @Avosmari
      @Avosmari 6 років тому +24

      Thank you 🙏

    • @NeonAnt
      @NeonAnt 6 років тому +7

      Honestly
      XD

    • @jayv7006
      @jayv7006 5 років тому +19

      Women are supposed to shave their legs regardless, so it's good they changed the lyric in the final version.

  • @angioddl2828
    @angioddl2828 9 років тому +2907

    'SHAVE MY LEGS' I'M CRYING

    • @diegocardcaptor
      @diegocardcaptor 8 років тому +25

      +Angio DDL I'M DYING

    • @crystalclown96
      @crystalclown96 5 років тому +92

      r0bz1985 lmao damn, chill

    • @taym1698
      @taym1698 4 роки тому +15

      @@r0bz1985 never

    • @gleamingfae
      @gleamingfae 4 роки тому +31

      @@r0bz1985 I'd rather not spend 20 dollars on new razor blades and shaving cream every month and also purchase a new razor which is also around 25 bucks. I'll pass.

    • @itsbrutalbunny
      @itsbrutalbunny 4 роки тому +9

      I’m assuming you never shaved your legs before 😂

  • @FreyTheAnimal
    @FreyTheAnimal 4 роки тому +2237

    shave my legs > paint my nails

    • @wawanamelinda3975
      @wawanamelinda3975 4 роки тому +46

      correction, >>>>>>>

    • @SoraJack
      @SoraJack 4 роки тому +107

      Painted nails sound more catty though. And more stereotypical.

    • @mariokarter13
      @mariokarter13 4 роки тому +26

      They probably thought it fit better. And it's generally frowned upon to have repeating parts (pre-chorus/chorus/post-chorus) significantly change because it becomes harder to remember. Is this the first chorus? The third chorus? It's easier if it's just "The chorus." Legs & Heels / Nails & Perfume vs. Nails & Heels / Nails & Perfume

    • @03dontbotherme
      @03dontbotherme 4 роки тому +2

      Oh my god.. imagine the boyfriend shaving the gfs legs .. yikesss

    • @CompleteMuffin
      @CompleteMuffin 4 роки тому +37

      this is what Demi Lovato got writing credit for lmao

  • @rockerdude8289
    @rockerdude8289 8 років тому +1868

    This version has a dubstep part, which makes it more unique.

    • @EclesysGalaxy
      @EclesysGalaxy 6 років тому +109

      yeah, this version is less repetetive and more creative, to be honest

    • @waiskuxx
      @waiskuxx 6 років тому +56

      Eclesy's Galaxy Completely disagree, it's worse. It uses the same chorus loop for the Pre chorus. Making the chorus less of a chorus, it's repetitive.

    • @rollingapples6579
      @rollingapples6579 5 років тому +9

      W R Yea the pre-chorus needs to be tuned down

    • @Dash120z
      @Dash120z 4 роки тому +22

      the dubstep part sounds generic af glad Demi removed it

    • @TheMurrmursonbottle
      @TheMurrmursonbottle 4 роки тому +10

      Not really, so many songs in the 2010s started inserting random dubstep in their tracks that it really doesn’t set it apart from other pop songs of our time

  • @Aliejha
    @Aliejha 4 роки тому +862

    she kind of sounds like Demi but less dramatic

    • @AtLeastITriedGames
      @AtLeastITriedGames 4 роки тому +50

      You mean "less interesting"... lol
      The end chorus boring as hell

    • @kbg12ila
      @kbg12ila 4 роки тому +65

      @@AtLeastITriedGames actually this sounds better. Her voice is less ott. Demi over emotes.

    • @natashahart25
      @natashahart25 4 роки тому +30

      @@kbg12ila hard disagree

    • @diogo9262
      @diogo9262 4 роки тому +22

      @@AtLeastITriedGames demi is sings kinda cringe

    • @womanlikedemi7993
      @womanlikedemi7993 4 роки тому +17

      @@diogo9262 your grammar is kinda cringe.

  • @jackspedicey2.011
    @jackspedicey2.011 5 років тому +712

    i officially stan this version. thank you, UA-cam algorithms.

  • @sweetjoker0813
    @sweetjoker0813 6 років тому +702

    sis that dubstep drop snatched my weave clean off

  • @OKzs
    @OKzs 10 років тому +1359

    Nikki wrote this by herself & did a great job, Mitch only produced it, hence he was listed as a songwriter, she did not want to use it because by the time she was ready to record her album it was 2 years later, this was song was shopped around and Demi picked it up, they clearly used some of Nikki's vocals on Demi's like in the chorus, that electronic part at 0:08 and the big note at 2:27 and the whole bridge too. Anyway, they both win, Demi gets a big hit and Nikki gets tons of money for the songwriting credit

    • @DaneTrotter
      @DaneTrotter 9 років тому +93

      The layered harmony was all Demi in her version, what are you talking about?

    • @kalakalachuchu
      @kalakalachuchu 9 років тому +9

      Dane Trotter i know right hahaha

    • @GeorgeHasratian
      @GeorgeHasratian 5 років тому +63

      OKzs The big note in the official version is sang by Demi for sure!!! They are both very talented but there’s no reason Demi would put a different vocalist’s high note!

    • @randybanks1504
      @randybanks1504 5 років тому +40

      Why would Demi need someone to hit her high notes? Did you not hear her first 2 albums

    • @identityloterry
      @identityloterry 5 років тому +23

      The BiG NOTE was totally Demi! It's wayyyy more powerful than in this vers! There's no big note in this demo!

  • @pierocardenaspimentel6662
    @pierocardenaspimentel6662 5 років тому +115

    6 years later, thanks UA-cam

  • @TheNraveles
    @TheNraveles 6 років тому +544

    THEY SHOULDVE KEPT THST DUBSTEP PART. That sounded so good wtf

    • @YleneP
      @YleneP 5 років тому +29

      TheNraveles ahead of its time

    • @ljb5163
      @ljb5163 4 роки тому +15

      Danna Banana the thing is a lot of songs had dubstep parts around this time but i still prefer it.

    • @fucker661
      @fucker661 4 роки тому +2

      No

    • @mariokarter13
      @mariokarter13 4 роки тому +2

      By the time this demo was made Dubstep was already halfway out the door.
      It's not a good look for your lead single to be DOA.

    • @juanpablo.a
      @juanpablo.a 3 роки тому +1

      @@mickeymouse220 They’re basically talking about the whole instrumental but mostly this part here 2:33

  • @Peter-sy2jo
    @Peter-sy2jo 5 років тому +228

    I adore the final version of the song but I think they should’ve had an extended version with the dubstep on the album as a deluxe track! That would’ve been sick!

  • @MaryMajikku
    @MaryMajikku 9 років тому +399

    they sound very similar. both have beautiful voices! no wonder demi picked up this song! :)

  • @bakoziel6909
    @bakoziel6909 4 роки тому +519

    So basicly she did all the work for Demi, even layed down runs.....

    • @username8448
      @username8448 4 роки тому +235

      That's how it generally works, singers who don't write their own stuff basically just cover songs that are given to them

    • @mike-sm2oy
      @mike-sm2oy 4 роки тому +60

      Yes, some songs they write and some they buy

    •  4 роки тому +112

      Demi writes most of her songs, this was one of the exceptions. She didn't change the song's structure drastically because she thought it wouldn't be respectful to the original songwriter.

    • @retro527
      @retro527 4 роки тому +50

      @ bullshit

    • @iwilitu6591
      @iwilitu6591 4 роки тому +24

      André Tostes that's not how it works lmao

  • @q.q4027
    @q.q4027 5 років тому +1759

    I like Demi but I think this sounds much lil bit better than Demi’s version. It sounds natural and not like she’s screaming.

    • @DaKotaArielCristally
      @DaKotaArielCristally 4 роки тому +13

      Sebastian Mateo agree

    • @theblitz1687
      @theblitz1687 4 роки тому +129

      you may not like demis tone but shes definitely not screaming. in fact nikki was a having a bit harder time with the higher notes

    • @zhang3967
      @zhang3967 4 роки тому +82

      @@theblitz1687 her chest notes are shouty, very obvious and can be annoying. But it's her technique so..

    • @theblitz1687
      @theblitz1687 4 роки тому +36

      i guess she does get a bit shouty at certain live performance but i dont think heart attack studio is one of them, her belts sounds full and resonant to me. what i dislike about her is she lowers her lyrnx too much for my taste.
      ua-cam.com/video/yxkOvo-Miyc/v-deo.html this is one of her best mixed note.
      now that i think about it i get your point, its a preference thing i suppose, demi could be considered more shouty compared nikki i guess :D but still that doesnt mean demi shouts, its just the lower lyrnx and big open sound kinda of technique

    • @ferdioktavian8593
      @ferdioktavian8593 4 роки тому +32

      it called belting not screaming

  • @musicdude92
    @musicdude92 5 років тому +55

    That dubstep part was fire!

  • @moonstruck180
    @moonstruck180 9 років тому +417

    Something to remember...there is a reason they call it a demo...while Nikki's version sounds like it is finished, (because she is a vocal master and everything has a decent balance) it is not. This was made to be enough to get the point across to the record company, which they weren't interested in for Nikki, because they wanted to go a different direction. Obviously, since the record company wasn't wanting to get behind it, Nikki's work stopped there to focus on other songs. No improvements or changes made to her version mixing or vocally, because at this point the song was dead. As the rumors are floating around say, (which are 100% true) Nikki started from scratch writing the song, and quite a bit of the lyrics (most in fact) we hers, and of course all of the vocal parts. When Demi heard the song and took it over for her album, she took it to the next level because it was already to go and she as an artist has a lot of power in the industry. She is a known artist who picked a song they wanted to do, the label of course approved (because they knew the song would be a hit), it's a done deal. (Note ,that this doesn't work for artists in the developmental stage as Nikki was) During Demi's taking over the track, she kept all of Nikki's Background vocals, added her own lead parts as well as some of her own BG vocals (like the higher notes that everyone keeps talking about that Nikki could easily have done), changed a few words, cut out the dub step part, etc. All in all though, this song says a lot about who Nikki is, and that makes it her song not matter what, because that is her soul for everyone see, well, hear.

    • @theblitz1687
      @theblitz1687 4 роки тому +14

      just to clarify, demi sang all the bg and harmonies herself in her version. proof is the videos on youtube showcasing filtered vocals

  • @goodmusic4731
    @goodmusic4731 4 роки тому +93

    This sounds like the final version instead of demo. It sounds so clean. I love it

    • @theactualtruth4951
      @theactualtruth4951 3 роки тому +22

      yeah it just needed to be properly mixed and mastered and then it's a SMASH HIT. Can't believe she really gave this song away, this is her biggest hit.

  • @MiaMore.
    @MiaMore. 6 років тому +117

    One of the best demo versions for song that I've heard thus far! I personally prefer Demi's voice, as it is in my opinion richer, stylistically versatile and more powerful. Plus my favorite part of the song is that very high note Demi added in the last hook.

  • @esdeeh
    @esdeeh 6 років тому +96

    She has a phenomenal voice😍

    • @corypalmer5495
      @corypalmer5495 4 роки тому +6

      She should have kept this song for herself. I love her voice

  • @benco_tomas
    @benco_tomas 10 років тому +164

    I just love that chorus of this version! (beats and effects) :D

  • @SamuelEspera
    @SamuelEspera 4 роки тому +14

    The *“shave my legs”* part was so unexpected and amazing!

  • @Blknamor
    @Blknamor 5 років тому +44

    I love her voice. Second I like how this version isn’t as rushed through. It’s a lot more fun and has a retro vibe

  • @k_jrin28
    @k_jrin28 4 роки тому +29

    This demo could totally pass off as a remix of Demi’s LFNKSNFKNSF

  •  3 роки тому +13

    Holly shit this demo sounds as good as the actual song.

  • @Drehgab
    @Drehgab 4 роки тому +22

    2:30 Demi added an extra layer of vocal here that Nikki hadnt

    • @BigBrainBryan
      @BigBrainBryan 4 роки тому +7

      *I get what u mean, but I don't think it's an "extra layer"...i think Demi just took the last note up higher than Nikki did*
      Nikki went: "flaaAaaAaaames"
      ...and Demi went:"flaaAaaAaaAAMES!"
      ...hopefully that makes sense 😅

    • @luizbalthazar3156
      @luizbalthazar3156 4 роки тому +3

      @@BigBrainBryan In fact, from what I heard in the Demi version, it has a less melodic line than in the demo in that part

  • @lucaseduardomenezes3418
    @lucaseduardomenezes3418 6 років тому +284

    Demi should keep the instrumental like this, is a lot more catchy and attractive though. In all the interviews, she said she was intending to do less electronic music and so... So what Neon Lights is doing on the record girl? You're totally wrong.

    • @knorenknor3493
      @knorenknor3493 4 роки тому +11

      Lucas Eduardo Menezes no the dubstep was trash sjsjs

    • @lucaseduardomenezes3418
      @lucaseduardomenezes3418 4 роки тому +4

      @@knorenknor3493 dubstep was trending at the time

    • @theactualtruth4951
      @theactualtruth4951 3 роки тому +1

      Demi should have never been on this song in the first place. Nikki's is better

    • @thebadassbxtch
      @thebadassbxtch 3 роки тому +2

      @@lucaseduardomenezes3418 which is why she didn’t keep the dubstep breakdown on the demo track? The song would’ve aged horribly.

  • @itschrispretorius
    @itschrispretorius 8 років тому +233

    Oh. Demi kept nikki's beginning part of 'putting my defenses up, cause i dont wanna fall in love' but then added herself cos they sound similar.
    Cute

    • @jacobsmollet1871
      @jacobsmollet1871 4 роки тому +7

      Chris Pretorius it was obviously demi in her version, are you dumb?

    • @sadboistorm2588
      @sadboistorm2588 4 роки тому +18

      Jacob Smollet they clearly kept nikki’s backing vocals.

    • @tearofgod
      @tearofgod 4 роки тому +2

      Well, they sound similar, but not the same. Demi sang the part, but kept Nikki's as a background vocal.

  • @Lacen2007
    @Lacen2007 11 років тому +112

    Demi may have a larger range, but it terms of vocal control, Nikki has her beat. Go watch Nikki live and go watch Demi live. However, Demi does make the sing with her riffing.

  • @itsleobish
    @itsleobish 2 місяці тому +2

    i loveee this version specially the dubstep part😍🔥

  • @jatianno
    @jatianno 2 роки тому +5

    When the dubstep came out, i be like " OMG !"

  • @aleksaranitovic
    @aleksaranitovic 5 років тому +18

    This is the first time I've felt emotion while listening to this song and I knew it for years. Nikki version is soulful!

  • @aslanreaw
    @aslanreaw 5 років тому +134

    2:30 OMG! This brk was amazing! Why isn't in the official version?

  • @jisookomblackpinkkru256
    @jisookomblackpinkkru256 5 років тому +26

    i've always loved demi's singing and this song in general but after hearing this, omg wow this should've been released as nikki's song and stayed just like that!!

  • @verly20
    @verly20 11 років тому +755

    Am i the only one who thinks they both sound the same?

    • @aidam7822
      @aidam7822 4 роки тому +148

      Demi's has a slightly darker, heavier tone.

    • @CrytalMikii
      @CrytalMikii 4 роки тому +5

      yes

    • @elisejackson2854
      @elisejackson2854 4 роки тому +1

      nope

    • @IsomerMashups
      @IsomerMashups 4 роки тому +13

      I'm sorry, but you're deaf.

    • @mizzdizz4419
      @mizzdizz4419 4 роки тому +15

      i dont think they sound the same. Demi's voice is more metallic.

  • @Matth.U
    @Matth.U 4 роки тому +6

    This is actually so much more technically. The creativity in this is mad. ❤️😍😭

  • @theycallmejondoenow
    @theycallmejondoenow 10 років тому +234

    i love this version because it's actually the original. Demi does it justice for sure,but this is Nikki's song. look it up if you don't believe me. haha. it's beautifully sung & written. & quite honestly,they sound pretty similar. don't diss the person who made it because then it wouldn't be what it is now.

    • @booptoyoux3322
      @booptoyoux3322 9 років тому +10

      you're right, I'm doing research about this song and Nikki was the original and wrote it herself but they didn't want to publish it but then Demi helped changing some lyrics and then published the song, this song is Nikki's

  • @secretsoul6882
    @secretsoul6882 3 роки тому +3

    The Demo itself was a bomb... Demi bring something but girlssssss this Demo is sick, Nikki can keep this as her own n be big.

  • @nathanlaney3879
    @nathanlaney3879 11 років тому +5

    I love both versions love Demi's cause her voice is flawless and Nikki has a dubstep feel which i love at the moment

  • @elchikoriko592
    @elchikoriko592 5 років тому +8

    The beat in this song just smashes you.

  • @michaelkevinbelda1298
    @michaelkevinbelda1298 4 роки тому +6

    2:32 omg the dance break. i want to put that dance break into Demi's version. it will sounds like award show performance of her 😭💕

  • @bigredhead888
    @bigredhead888 4 роки тому +12

    It’s crazy how these demos sound so much like the final fingers. Like it makes sense why they do it but still

  • @Officialtun3s
    @Officialtun3s 11 років тому +25

    Nikki did write the song but Demi changed a few lyrics and got the dubstep break edited out

  • @JaviSailorMau
    @JaviSailorMau 4 роки тому +10

    I actually really like the shave my legs part cuz she has a progressive mindset unlike many people commenting.

  • @raffaelien
    @raffaelien 2 роки тому +4

    WHY DID THEY REMOVE THE DUBSTEP PART ?????

  • @oliviarodrigo3224
    @oliviarodrigo3224 3 роки тому +3

    I like the dubstep drop but it feels oddly timed where as the final studio version feels more smooth and organized.

  • @brendarocha5832
    @brendarocha5832 4 роки тому +4

    this demo cleared my skin

  • @learleanatrimmer2892
    @learleanatrimmer2892 5 років тому +5

    Love this version just as well as Demi's 😍😍😍😍

  • @kamwashere_
    @kamwashere_ 4 роки тому +1

    this is so much better omfg bye demi

  • @chickenontheocean
    @chickenontheocean 4 роки тому +17

    Yall acting like woman who doesn't shave her legs is something that doesnt exist. 😂

  • @DoniJames
    @DoniJames 11 років тому +12

    Mitch and Nikki did an excellent job on writing the song and Nikki did a VERY good job on laying out the vocals but thankfully Demi came and not only edited the lyrics abit but I'm mostly thankful for the vocal arrangement she did on the 3rd verse with the overlapping of the three octaves she displayed on the track. Clearly I would have liked it if this was Nikki's but I'm so happy Demi got her. Best song of her career AND the added notes Demi sang made it so much better. Phew. Love Demi

  • @vautek3749
    @vautek3749 4 роки тому +2

    What a beautiful voice!! ❤❤

  • @xxsharidan98xx
    @xxsharidan98xx 11 років тому +7

    I would really love it if Demi performed this version with the dubstep live.

  • @JordanReynolds13
    @JordanReynolds13 5 років тому +3

    Surprising that the "cry for help" part was in the original, I felt like that rang true for the struggles that Demi went through

  • @skylersfloperachannel6528
    @skylersfloperachannel6528 3 місяці тому +1

    The dubstep made heartattack on extreme

  • @gabriellyfarias5985
    @gabriellyfarias5985 11 років тому +2

    Affz' sem comparações com a voz da Demi né!! omg demi divaaaa qualquer coisa que ela fala,canta,faz,veste, é perfeita! sou bem Heart Attack com a voz da Demi ♥

  • @PockyRedux
    @PockyRedux 2 роки тому

    I’m obsessed with this version now!

  • @Chayenswee1
    @Chayenswee1 4 роки тому +13

    damn. with that dubstep, demo could've had a #1 hit by now.

    • @liquidstone14
      @liquidstone14 4 роки тому

      chayensweet dubstep was well on its way out by summer 2013

  • @neexie
    @neexie 5 років тому +9

    This version is missing the high note at 3:03 that is the trademark of this song!

    • @juliaana4372
      @juliaana4372 5 років тому +4

      cause that’s a demo

    • @squeallymaniac
      @squeallymaniac 5 років тому +3

      It sounds so empty without it lol

    • @TheTrixster690
      @TheTrixster690 4 роки тому

      But it has a dubstep which is better than the high note in my opinion.

    • @linxclpx
      @linxclpx 4 роки тому

      @@juliaana4372 no that's demi

  • @bornofbvb
    @bornofbvb 4 роки тому

    I love this version so much more ...

  • @tayclark42
    @tayclark42 4 роки тому

    I like this version of the song more I remember listening to this song while being sad and my mom came in the room singing it such a good moment

  • @afreakanajepsen2468
    @afreakanajepsen2468 4 роки тому +7

    I miss the *DEMI* era

  • @kian2537
    @kian2537 5 років тому +20

    why now UA-cam???

  • @5ive___
    @5ive___ 6 років тому +68

    “Shave my legs” LMAO!!! Im CRYING RN!😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @ZoeeSavX
    @ZoeeSavX 10 років тому +35

    Demi is a good singer, shame she doesn't write her songs anymore.

    • @DaneTrotter
      @DaneTrotter 9 років тому +29

      She writes most of her songs, just because she hasn't written some of the songs she's recorded, doesn't mean she doesn't write any, ffs.

    • @andreszamora5891
      @andreszamora5891 9 років тому +10

      Dane Trotter not really, she grabs songs from others and just changes like 4-5 lines thats it...i like demi a lot but i wish she actually wrote the entire song like other artists. if you check at the credits demi is at the very end of each song not at the beginning like it should be, she just co-writes the already written song and changes stuff that she doesn't like...still avery talented girl

    • @DaneTrotter
      @DaneTrotter 9 років тому +6

      Alex REid she wrote warrior and shouldn't come back herself

    • @DaneTrotter
      @DaneTrotter 9 років тому +3

      Alex REid and many other songs

    • @andreszamora5891
      @andreszamora5891 9 років тому +2

      she didn't she had help, look at the credentials, but thats not what i mean, i meant that demi just grabs songs from other unknown artists and changes a few details and thats it, she usually doesn't start from 0.

  • @rkeriadavis790
    @rkeriadavis790 4 роки тому +3

    Tbh i feel like this is what this song would sound like if Taylor Swift sang it

  • @straighft
    @straighft 4 роки тому

    this is gold

  • @parkhae-il9211
    @parkhae-il9211 2 роки тому +3

    Am i the only one who thinks the beats on this one is better than demi's version?

  • @Jprager
    @Jprager Рік тому +3

    I do agree that Nikki sounds more natural with the song, but I think the lyrical changes were for the better, some of the lines here sound so cheesy, especially the “shaving my legs” line 😂

  • @RandomStryder
    @RandomStryder 2 роки тому +3

    I personally prefer what Demi did in the middle-8. I think at the time the dubstep would have been cool but we all know that it would have been lost to time if they'd kept it.

  • @alexisschiffer4830
    @alexisschiffer4830 4 місяці тому

    I love the sound of lower notes and the chorus better than Demi’s, but the latter’s version has a voice made for reaching those high notes in the post-bridge.

  • @roseredmayne
    @roseredmayne 6 років тому +1

    I really love this

  • @andrusca
    @andrusca 5 років тому +20

    They should've kept that dubstep break in Demi's version

    • @TheTrixster690
      @TheTrixster690 4 роки тому +5

      Demi edited out. She didn't want it.

  • @AlexFroot
    @AlexFroot 2 роки тому +1

    Without Nikki creating this song Demi wouldn’t had recreated or written this song .

  • @Earthling108
    @Earthling108 11 років тому +4

    Both versions are amazingly awesome!
    This one has a few extra little beats/musical melodies :) (idk how to say it).
    Nikki sounds a bit less feminine (not in a bad way). I like Demi's slightly better and Nikki also admitted Demi did a better job than herself. The reason being is that Nikki was over these feelings (it was fall 2011 in America) and she thought Demi's feelings for these song was good enough to sing it and I like Demi's voice for it too, but this is also awesome!!!!

  • @k1k1miint
    @k1k1miint 3 роки тому +3

    This version is better

  • @Dashley.lovefron
    @Dashley.lovefron 11 років тому +2

    You rock,girl!!!

  • @septan4168
    @septan4168 4 роки тому +1

    I remember this song is bomb on highschool

  • @starxrays811
    @starxrays811 4 роки тому +1

    Just imagine if she made a music video and actually released this song, it’d be a smash in 2013/2014

  • @alicelockhart5539
    @alicelockhart5539 11 років тому +1

    Ta perfeita. As duas tem um jeito diferente de cantar e ficou bom nas duas vozes :3

  • @theactualtruth4951
    @theactualtruth4951 3 роки тому +4

    should have kept this for herself

    • @Ισαβέλα-ψ7τ
      @Ισαβέλα-ψ7τ 3 роки тому

      i heard they rejected her when she wanted to release it.. not sure why thi

    • @theactualtruth4951
      @theactualtruth4951 3 роки тому +2

      @@Ισαβέλα-ψ7τ wow they were trying to hold her back that's why. They knew this was a hit song. The wanted to make more money off of the song instead of her. Nobody should be able to tell you not to release a hit song you wrote, doesn't make sense.

  • @itkarolina
    @itkarolina 11 років тому +1

    Demi and Nikki, both are great :)

  • @muanteatochhawng5001
    @muanteatochhawng5001 4 роки тому +3

    i prefer Demi Lovato verson

  • @rainyraindrop
    @rainyraindrop 4 роки тому +1

    O: It's crazy how a few changes can make the final version sound like a cover to the demo. In the demo it sounds natural for her to be reaching such high notes, while the final one sounds out of place when you have comparison to this. As well, this I think the first song that I have ever liked that have vocals and dubstep and dubstep empowers the voice. Not only that it was used as a medium to detail the complexity of the situation wtf?

    • @waiskuxx
      @waiskuxx 4 роки тому

      This sounds messy as fuck. Even for the time dubstep was outdated it was slowly phased out around April 2012. It’s so unappealing.

  • @MrSkinnyJeanz3
    @MrSkinnyJeanz3 9 років тому +145

    I want to hear her perform this live. Nikki would straight up annihilate Demi. She's a vocal beast.

    • @juandabests
      @juandabests 9 років тому +18

      Not really !

    • @MrSkinnyJeanz3
      @MrSkinnyJeanz3 9 років тому +17

      Daniel Arcila Nikki sounds like she has a higher tessitura than Demi, and is just a better belter, meaning all those high notes and runs would be done with the strain, hoarseness and shouty-ness that Demi performs Heart Attack with

    • @knaxor
      @knaxor 9 років тому +32

      MrSkinnyJeanz3 But that's what makes Demi, Demi. That hoarse rasp is what I love about her. She puts a rock edge on almost everything that she sings. Though Nikki is an amazing singer too, I don't think she has the unique touch that Demi brings to the table with this song.

    • @backup8991
      @backup8991 6 років тому +21

      Imagine being this delusional 💀
      Demi’s vocals would destroy her.

    • @MsVamPireChic
      @MsVamPireChic 6 років тому +11

      ....have you even heard Demi sing this song live?

  • @igorgallo44
    @igorgallo44 4 роки тому

    Demi best

  • @bebaios
    @bebaios 4 роки тому +2

    I love Demi from the bottom of my heart, I love Demi's version from the bottom of my heart....but this one...a lil more eheh
    Those dubstep sounds are drug for my inner preadolescent ears

  • @nicollehernandez8078
    @nicollehernandez8078 11 років тому

    I have the CD (DEMI) and in the credits of Heart Attack, the song is written by Mitch Allan, Jason Evigan, Sean Douglas, Nikki Williams, Aaron Phillips and Demi Lovato :)

  • @annyra_a
    @annyra_a 4 роки тому +2

    now the " shave my legs and wear *high heels*" makes sense

  • @user-tk7hg6ty5q
    @user-tk7hg6ty5q 4 роки тому +1

    demi definitely did this justice.

  • @hyperspaceoddity7805
    @hyperspaceoddity7805 6 років тому +5

    Holy shoot this version is amazing. The beat is much more unique and the singer doesn't throw her voice around like Demi did.

  • @BiancaAngellini
    @BiancaAngellini 11 років тому

    Meu Deus, na VOZ DA DEMI É BEM MAIS PERFEITOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

  • @pqtaobia
    @pqtaobia 4 роки тому

    omg, amazing!!

  • @mozamr
    @mozamr 3 роки тому +1

    this demo is amazing tho

  • @ToniArcelinni
    @ToniArcelinni Рік тому +1

    This makes me wonder how would sound if Sia sang this and I love it

    • @AlexFroot
      @AlexFroot Рік тому

      Hun Nikki wrote the song not sia

    • @ToniArcelinni
      @ToniArcelinni Рік тому +1

      @@AlexFroot did you read what I wrote? I said I wonder how would sound if Sia SANG this song... I said it 'cause something in Nikki's voice reminds me of Sia. I know Nikki's work. Please, pay attention before playing smart and correcting comments you didn't even bother to understand the context.

  • @natashabalduino5900
    @natashabalduino5900 11 років тому +1

    Ficou legal, gente. E a batida depois de "and i burst into flames" ficou MUITO foda :)

  • @MrBen101199
    @MrBen101199 4 роки тому +3

    Demi's version is more powerful 💕

    • @AlexFroot
      @AlexFroot 3 роки тому

      This song is about a breakup - Nikki Williams explains why she gaved it up to Demi

  • @rhys-christianmobsby4578
    @rhys-christianmobsby4578 2 роки тому +6

    It’s a testament to Demi’s talent that they are able to take the inflections and intonations from the original demo and translate into their own vocals 🙌🏼