3000 day realm did have a behavior pack on it, it may be gone forever, no clue yet, need to wait for this to pass over. If it is messed up though (probably not, considering it was just some torch mod) I'm definitely quitting, I'm getting a PC soon and so are my friends, I'm tired of playing the corporate version of Minecraft, I'm for sure moving to the one with more freedom. Edit! I don't know if we're BACK back yet, but I was just checking out how the game was doing a bit ago, realms work perfect for me again? Like, everything was absolutely fine... For like 8 minutes, then I disconnected. No game breaking stuff anymore though!
I was definitely effected but I’m glad that I didn’t continue a modded world for too long that I was going to initially. It was like a war server that I was making, including Aplok Guns and some other vehicle addons too. After this update it completely corrupted everything, it took me awhile to build a lot of the stuff, but I didn’t go too long with it. But good news with the gun mod you were using in the beginning, made by Gabriel Aplok. He luckily quickly made a hot fix to his gun addon, not requiring any experimental options, bypassing the corruption from the removal of holiday creator features. So that’s nice, knowing that Gabriel Aplok was also active. And the main thing I enjoy doing in Minecraft is simulating battles with guns whenever I crave something modded. But I’m very glad there is a fix and a way for these addons to be good again, obviously depending on the creator.
How can we move forward when this just set us back to Oct 5th 2022? Thousands of people's data is gone, it isn't even about add-ons anymore, EVERYTHING is gone if you used packs
I disagree, the future is brighter than ever. If you've been following the preview changelogs you'd know how powerful the new Scripting API is. If they kept it in, most people wouldn't use the new system.
You are absolutely right. Those who says minecraft bedrock is better than minecraft java are idiots. Because first of all there are no good mods like minecraft java edition And thay are paid.
@@lythough7749Fun fact, no it wasn't! :D Not once on any of Mojang and Microsoft's HUGE platforms that people actually stay up to date on did they ever warn about this! Just on their side social media accounts that barely anyone knows, so no, it isn't like they actually wanted people to know ahead of time
They could’ve easily kept both feature toggles so older mods could keep working but you just can’t modify it and meaning you’d need to use the new components toggle to expand on your mods
This is going to have a big impact. Lots of people that wanna make mods or already have wont wanna learn it, this will limit the amount of mods closing variety types.
The situation is hard to explain because there are people out there defending Holiday Creator Features, and I've gotten some hate or have been attacked for defending and liking custom components more. There is also a ton of misinformation being spread online, most of which come from Reddit. It's honestly just sad. What we can do is notify creators and hope for them to update their work. I know for some, or even most people, learning JS (or quickJS) is hard, but it's gonna be worth it. We have resources online to help people.
If you don't mind me asking, what do you think can be improved upon from HCF to Custom Components? As in what could now be possible in addons that wasn't possible prior?
Even though there are online resources, a lot of creators don't even know about JS and how it works. IMO, the documentation is not that understandable to the average person who just does JSON. If Mojang or someone like you could make it look simple like JSON, I think the learning curve could be easier
Hey Poggy, in the tweet shown in the video you said marketplace-addons are unaffected, but when I started my world yesterday (that only uses marketplace-addons) there were dirt blocks with questionsmarks for every addon-block and entities disappeared completely. So are marketplace-addons affected too? Thank you
This happened to me and I had some other cute decor Addons and that’s what happened I saw smittys new video I cried now until they fix there mistakes I’m not playing because I hardly know how to program them zip files to a mcpack let alone now this I’m done
To be real, I almost cried because I did not know about this at all. Now Addons I worked on for personal and maybe public use are broken. Weapon gone, models I spent time on, all of us creators made amazing stuff that’s just gone now.
And then there are the people who haven't spent a single minute working on anything requiring a drop of effort before in their life, wasting away at their chair, just saying "Cope, just learn custom components not hard." ignorant dickheads, don't understand that it doesn't matter if its hard or easy, we just lost hours of our life working on things we hold a sentimental value for, because Mojang likes to ruin things, and then to have Larry the cocksucker come in and yap about shit they don't even understand fully themselves, is annoying and frustrating.
I chose the wrong time to come back to Minecraft PE💀 First Android 11+ have made it so hard to actually navigate and customise your internal files that it's almost impossible for most games to be customised via adding external mods, and now Minecraft removes the one feature that allowed hundreds of mods to even exist.
This Really pissed me off whem this first came out because ive been Hosting a Heavily organized and well made SCP Facility on minecraft that used Mods that relys on holiday creator features ive been doing these for 3 years and we have over 200 people in the community This is just a massive setback for my Community Especially when i was about to roll out one of the biggest updates for my Facility. And add some new departments and add a massive expansion to my facility. This caused us to lose about 10-20 people Since i had to pause Hosting the facility to make a new facility since our previous facility is filled dirt blocks with question Marks now. (I hate mojang)
Addon Creator here, anyway the removing of Holiday Creator Features was having more changes in addons and they add javascript on it but it doesn't replace many kinds of stuff they only improving via custom components. Apparently addons are being saved but blocks and items are in different format in example version 1.16.0 which is stable format to blocks and items but if you're on 1.16.100 which is experimental you can upgrade it to bigger versions where it's stable like 1.20.80 or 1.21.20 which is the best stable version format and it has lots of components. Here's the tip for addon creators please choose at least 4 components such as collision_box, geometry, material_instance and loot because these are the stable and learn some by adding traits and states, but not all addon developers are interested in javascript but it's time to move on tho>
That’s exactly what I’m saying but no one has given me a clear and REASONABLE answer. They are a multi billionaire company that should be able to do these things
@@gorilla_gorl several games have multiple options tho. It should be for what’s best for the addon creator, not something that people are lazy for doing. These bonus optimizations would ultimately allow players to have access to different ways to create stuff and see what best suits them
@@gorilla_gorl I understand that continuing to support the old system would make things too complicated, but I think that ideally they could keep the toggle in for compatibility and develop the game as if they removed it
Yeah honestly this hit hard. I code my own bedrock mods. Really threw me off and half my old projects i was proud of dont work anymore Though it does seem like it will be better in the future
This is the straw that broke the camels back, me and my friends switched to unreal engine 5 to make our game because it will at least be a working product by the end of it lol
Hey, I wanted to say thank you for the information personally I was thinking about like switching over the Java completely but then I just learned to now that most add-ons just need to be updated. All my friends were telling me false information like that won’t work anymore and all that, they don’t exist after a couple updates or something
This is literally the whole execute command reworked again. The time when maps developers are disappointed that the execute commands is completely revamped with better and improved features. They say it was Soo simple back then, but that was the point. It was too simple that less features and possibilities can be made from a simple feature. That's why they had to improve it, unfortunately some people gave up fixing all command blocks in their maps that use the old execute command, I don't blame them. It took me a while to fully understand how the new execute command works, i understand the pain that going through all those lines of codes just keep it alive for future updates isn't easy. Since I'm an add-on creator myself.
I only learned the new execute command so I don't get the pain, but I do understand its not hard to just make another command equivalent to that of the execute but just updated. But Mojang is filled with bums
The answer is to honestly just stick with an old version through a third party launcher and mod away, with outside tools if it has to be. New official features and compensation through the market place may seem spicy, but they clearly have no issue breaking mod support in random ways at random times, simply because they can't be bothered to playtest their developer option-changes before shipping updates.
I made a scripting template that lets people make HCF-like block and Item events with ease. If you have any add-ons you made that needs updated and you don't wanna learn scripting, I suggest using it.
Aton more usually don't go pass 1.12.2 due to the changes in the games code straight up making the mods broken entirely needing the developer to code the entire thing from the ground up
Yeah My second favorite addon to play stopped working. Luckily my Favorite addon wasn’t affected. Also I know the new feature will make it better and easier but why not keep and have both.
What Poggy is saying is like saying Fortnite should remove creative since they have creative 2.0(UEFN) because it pushes people to make better things. I think people should have the option to take the easier route even if it isn’t as good
They said about the changes on the pasts changes logs so the option was there but nobody said anything useful all just jump into the, "mojang Is removing addons millions must boicot the mob vote" train ,instead of doing... Something useful
Holiday Creator Features exist because it was a experimental thats why it has a warning, the reason it is remove is because all of the components that the Holidays Creator Features supported are stabled and doesn't cause much bugs on further updates, and thats why they add versioning on addons so us or other addon creators can use stabled components
If you're a creator using experimental features for what you'd considered a released project, don't. This is exactly why. These features are not in stable, beta, alpha, preview, none of that. Experimental is not always guaranteed to remain the game. Please avoid using experimental features and stick with stable features if your project aim is to be released for players to play. Experimental is great for literally experimenting with possibly incoming features but is not guaranteed to be merged with stable. This is why marketplace content is unaffected as marketplace partners are not allowed to use experimental features. I blame Mojang for a lot of stuff, but this isn't on them imo (hot take)
THANK YOU! I thought I was going crazy! I every time i booted an experimental world up, it very clearly warns players about this! Did everyone think mojang was joking?
Wait so if we’re forced to use .json that means we’re able to use the RTX packs from PC I mean all I had to do is make a .json file for SEUS shaders and it worked for my series x
Got my entire worth of work faded like ashes in a second. I was soo excited to go back to Minecraft after school, and this is how I literally got greeted
I think they should've given a warning in the game itself, something like "Holiday Creator Features have been replaced by Custom Components - some add-ons relying on HCF might be broken and need updating."
There's literally a notice when you turn on any experimental toggle where it might get removed in the future updates. Doesn't matter if it's there for 4 years, there's still a chance, and here it finally happened. Relying on experimental features is also a mistake in this case. Most add-on creators don't give information about what an experimental feature is or they themselves consider the consequences of using it.
even worse, custom biomes (despite being an option in experiments for bedrock edition) have been broken for around 4 years, since the caves and cliffs updates.
So do i understand this right, that the addons I officially bought in the official minecraft store aren't working anymore in the payed official realm-server? I spend the last weeks to customize my own realm to come to this point? That can't be real
@@hehasnolips1371 Careful with whatchu post 🙏🗣️🗣️🙏 the COCK is watching 🤞🤞🐔🐔 and he ain’t take NO prisoners 🙅♂️🙅♂️🤫🤫 keep them cheeks TIGHT before they are WRECKED
So, Umm, I am the developer of the more tools addon haven't been active for over a year and it's not just about the complexity of the add-on but also how big it is. For example i have a lot of items and blocks that broke and that will take a lot of my time to fix everything. And since I was not active lately I don't know most of the stuff that's possible to do with the new scripting method. The microsoft documentation is trash at best even though I know java script is not to much use without proper documentation from mojang.
@@Smitty058 don't worry I am managing to update it however I started before 1.21.2 and it's still not fully working. It's in a working state atm so it's fine for me but, I'm sorry for other people's add-ons.
While some of my stuff still works, it got rid of some super cute granny decor I had and other food mods and I’m super sad because they really added to the aesthetic of my world 😭🤚🏽
I do not have much problem about the removal of the holiday experiment but mainly problem of mine right now is realm connectivity problems and addons importation on realm, it's really kicked me in the butt😂
The best way I can understand this is when Minecraft updated the commands, from the old Execute to the new one, how people where upset and mad (as was I) but after some time I grew to LOVE the new execute cause all of the new things you can do
Just like custom component I prefer having this and having really good add-ons that might won't have any limitations from bedrock anymore than add-ons made in json that are very limited (also u can do thing only using vanilla features) while it's totally different with custom component written in JavaScript
@@20Eclipse03 the only issue with the argument is the execute command was a much simpler thing to do, it can work exactly the same by just adding an "at" and a "run" this is a much more complicated thing to fix
It extremely pisses me off, i watched a tutorial didnt understand and do the steps in the tutorial for 1 hour and after successfully putting the mod i see its not working in mc and then i see minecrafts new update changes🙁
Is there a way to fix it for Xbox? How is the new option better then Holiday Creator it seems like no one explained what they can do better now but they say its better. How?
Its better because custom components are made using the javascript api instead of pure json api, and since javascript is actually a programming language and have its features u can do stuff much more freely
I get "There a temporary Network probelm every time I try to boot up minecraft" and I don't know why, ever since I got some more mods it started doing it
I’m still mad that Mojang removed the holiday creator feature just because the furnitures foods and plushies in my smp are unknown blocks and broken and ruined!
Dude, now the war between the Bedrock and Java player communities is getting hotter since this update... Java players are becoming arrogant and pretending to be the winners because Bedrock has been ruined by Mojang.
I had maps that were planned to be used for upcoming videos, and I will admit this does make me mad, but at the same time, it feels like this was just another questionable choice. It’s funny to how Mojang did mention they planned to make Bedrock and Java one and the same, but so far, they haven’t really done a whole lot. Overall, I am disappointed, but that’s well to be expected at this point. 🙄🤦
@@Smitty058what makes it worse is that I didn't back up the world so not only did all my custom items and armour disappear but the world got corrupted due to some experimental errors from experimental required addons so it won't open and downgrading Minecraft also doesn't work so... Yep.. no recovery. So probably until More addons use this new scripting API I might stick with Java for a while.
I’ve quit Minecraft, hopefully you will all do the same, they always make poor decisions, addons is what enhances the experience of Minecraft. And all they had to do was add something new, it wasn’t necessary to remove and replace that feature. They always make poor decisions, and this is the final straw!
EVERYONE I FOUND A WORK AROUND UNTIL THEY FIX THEM THERES A PACK THATS SUPPOSED TO ADD EXPERIMENTAL FEATURES TO EDUCATION WITH THE CREATOR FEATURES INCLUDED
ok so, Meaning that Mods like Create mod, RLCraft, TacZ or VPB, Etc will work on Bedrock Sooner?? if that happens, Holy shit im giving this crown to both Mojang and Microsoft for being W
its crazy to think 4 years ago i put my friend in the discord and later its in discord memes 2. Cool seeing you a long bit later remember joining your mincraft worlds when you would stream.
I swear to god if mojang.... No,MICROSOFT! If you don't bring back those components, this might will be the end of mc bedrock, not only addons also realms and servers. And also Some of the addon creator is mobile user cannot even use java components because no device is available You setting your foot on the grave Microsoft. Remember mc is very popular so be ready if the player counts are lowering drastically
Hey quick question, if I were to replace my Xbox with the Series X I know I’d lose the skin packs I downloaded but would I also lose the worlds I downloaded as well? Or maybe if there’s a way to save those worlds then install them back into the console? I have a world that I downloaded and over the years me and a friend have built a lot of our own big builds, and I really don’t wanna lose them just because I have to upgrade my console.
To be honest here with my own opinions This is almost a great thing because most of the time I'm confused what experiment toggle to use, AND addons that doesn't even need experiments still work, and to be in fact we are technically pushing limits to bedrock modding
When will Mojang FINALLY fix bugs or unsatisfactory features instead of listing new things in every new update when in reality they've never done anything about the old issues, if anything they just keep piling more and more
I make addons and what people dont realise is. The fact these mods are now scripts. They will work for PC players but anyone on console are buggered basically. They cant run scripts otherwise it’ll crash their game.
i’m surprised no one is talking about rolling back versions. windows users shouldn’t feel effected by this situation at all as they can simply roll back to version 1.21.10 where Holiday Creator features are still present
As someone who has modded since 1021 and has a folder of over 13gb of giant modded worlds for me and my friends that we played on until the update, this is realy annoying.
I've been working on a mod for like 5 months, added 200+ blocks, mobs and items, i was almost done with the mod then they do this. God damn it Microsoft
Were you effected by this modding change? If so… my apologies.
3000 day realm did have a behavior pack on it, it may be gone forever, no clue yet, need to wait for this to pass over.
If it is messed up though (probably not, considering it was just some torch mod) I'm definitely quitting, I'm getting a PC soon and so are my friends, I'm tired of playing the corporate version of Minecraft, I'm for sure moving to the one with more freedom.
Edit! I don't know if we're BACK back yet, but I was just checking out how the game was doing a bit ago, realms work perfect for me again? Like, everything was absolutely fine...
For like 8 minutes, then I disconnected. No game breaking stuff anymore though!
I was definitely effected but I’m glad that I didn’t continue a modded world for too long that I was going to initially. It was like a war server that I was making, including Aplok Guns and some other vehicle addons too. After this update it completely corrupted everything, it took me awhile to build a lot of the stuff, but I didn’t go too long with it. But good news with the gun mod you were using in the beginning, made by Gabriel Aplok. He luckily quickly made a hot fix to his gun addon, not requiring any experimental options, bypassing the corruption from the removal of holiday creator features. So that’s nice, knowing that Gabriel Aplok was also active. And the main thing I enjoy doing in Minecraft is simulating battles with guns whenever I crave something modded. But I’m very glad there is a fix and a way for these addons to be good again, obviously depending on the creator.
@@ShadowTheHedgehog003 I'm Quitting too
@@AlecEditz wait where can i get the gun hotfix? cause thats something i really was looking for
Yeah I was. And I am very sad and mad they better fix this
Mojang really finding ways to make people hate on bedrock💀
it's not mojang it's Microsoft that forced them to do this
Wdym mojang?
@@Plane_Person fr
@@prosans4629 nu uh
Bruh they just changed the way of making addon so it can be way better. Watch the whole video
How can we move forward when this just set us back to Oct 5th 2022? Thousands of people's data is gone, it isn't even about add-ons anymore, EVERYTHING is gone if you used packs
Fr bedrock edition is now nothing but a space of emptiness similar to backrooms at this point
Legit none of my data is gone. DW, people will most likely update their addons with time.
@@alieneddsim hoping that they will bring my favourite berserker addon back or else mojang will loose money
lol look at better on bedrock it’s a pretty good addon without hcf. Future of modding is gonna be better
Me when the experimental feature gets removed because it says experimental: 😲
Bruh they removed the holiday creator features instead of removing/fixing the bugs
Have you not read the changelog for this update? There's dozens of bug fixes and improvements
@@XavierEmeraldsthey'll be broken again at their next update
They did add Creator Components, and they gave us invincibility when loading a new dimension, finally!
@@prosans4629that's how updates work, certain things get broken after time. Be happy the game isn't built on spaghetti code like dead by daylight is
@@XavierEmeraldsLmfao you’re blind as hell, for the past 4 years ive barely seen any major bug fixes
we frl in the dark age of bedrock modding
I disagree, the future is brighter than ever. If you've been following the preview changelogs you'd know how powerful the new Scripting API is. If they kept it in, most people wouldn't use the new system.
@@SuperLlama88888 true but most of my fav mods broke soo
@@stunnawvttz Dw, better mods than your current "favorite" mods will arise in the future.
@@Rizpace tbh my fav mod was a modpack named minesanity
Lets make a new one :) @@stunnawvttz
Microsoft really has ruined this game. Putting all their eggs in one basket. Bedrock is probably the worst version of minecraft developed.
Its best performance wise and for multiplayer me and my friends rather play bedrock since its less laggy but yeah java is better in every other way
You are absolutely right. Those who says minecraft bedrock is better than minecraft java are idiots.
Because first of all there are no good mods like minecraft java edition
And thay are paid.
@abhranilmallick-xj9zb My friend, if Bedrock had the Java's mod capabilities and if we could use jar it would be better also not these bugs
@@benmoore8718 yes you are right.
But mojang is destroying minecraft bedrock edition
@@abhranilmallick-xj9zb there are free mods on mcpedl, modbay, goofy, stop speaking when u don't understand
The update that ruined my work and worlds. Worse than the October 5th update. I call the new update. The day of reckoning 💀
💀
The update was warned for months in advance. It's your fault
@@lythough7749 how is it my fault? 💀 i knew it was coming but like damn it kinda sucks still
@@lythough7749we didn't create those addons you should blame the creators
@@lythough7749Fun fact, no it wasn't! :D
Not once on any of Mojang and Microsoft's HUGE platforms that people actually stay up to date on did they ever warn about this! Just on their side social media accounts that barely anyone knows, so no, it isn't like they actually wanted people to know ahead of time
They could’ve easily kept both feature toggles so older mods could keep working but you just can’t modify it and meaning you’d need to use the new components toggle to expand on your mods
Which is even more confusing and there will be even worse bugs and mistakes leading addons complete disaster
I'd say keep it around for compatability, but say that an add-on is using deprecated features when loading it up.
@prosans4629 you're wrong
This is going to have a big impact. Lots of people that wanna make mods or already have wont wanna learn it, this will limit the amount of mods closing variety types.
That is true, i've been making an addon for about 9 months and now when i'm finishing the sounds and testing it this update came out
@@blocky_road2616i bet that the devs were drunk while making this update
Bruh I spent so much time downloading new mods just to find out they don’t work 😭
Same 😭
Same😭
Glad I didn't update
It works and gets updated every week
Same and I’m pissed about it
The situation is hard to explain because there are people out there defending Holiday Creator Features, and I've gotten some hate or have been attacked for defending and liking custom components more.
There is also a ton of misinformation being spread online, most of which come from Reddit. It's honestly just sad.
What we can do is notify creators and hope for them to update their work. I know for some, or even most people, learning JS (or quickJS) is hard, but it's gonna be worth it. We have resources online to help people.
I think when people's justified rage over years of progress vanishing like it's nothing passes over they'll understand
If you don't mind me asking, what do you think can be improved upon from HCF to Custom Components? As in what could now be possible in addons that wasn't possible prior?
Even though there are online resources, a lot of creators don't even know about JS and how it works. IMO, the documentation is not that understandable to the average person who just does JSON. If Mojang or someone like you could make it look simple like JSON, I think the learning curve could be easier
What's that gonna do with my fav add-on of all time😭🙏
Hey Poggy, in the tweet shown in the video you said marketplace-addons are unaffected, but when I started my world yesterday (that only uses marketplace-addons) there were dirt blocks with questionsmarks for every addon-block and entities disappeared completely. So are marketplace-addons affected too? Thank you
Ah… this is getting old… its like every couple months atp…
Something always goes wrong :/
That's Microsoft for you
I use this furniture mod and after this update my world is filled with unknown blocks
Yeah :/
My berserker set and gojo powers are gone:(
This happened to me and I had some other cute decor Addons and that’s what happened I saw smittys new video I cried now until they fix there mistakes I’m not playing because I hardly know how to program them zip files to a mcpack let alone now this I’m done
Microsoft removing the one thing that makes minecraft bedrock edition have some competition with java edition is insane and really stupid
Did u even watch the full video
@Rayen_0 To be honest. No 😂
To be real, I almost cried because I did not know about this at all. Now Addons I worked on for personal and maybe public use are broken. Weapon gone, models I spent time on, all of us creators made amazing stuff that’s just gone now.
I had a whole mental breakdown because well now most of my addons don’t even work
And then there are the people who haven't spent a single minute working on anything requiring a drop of effort before in their life, wasting away at their chair, just saying "Cope, just learn custom components not hard."
ignorant dickheads, don't understand that it doesn't matter if its hard or easy, we just lost hours of our life working on things we hold a sentimental value for, because Mojang likes to ruin things, and then to have Larry the cocksucker come in and yap about shit they don't even understand fully themselves, is annoying and frustrating.
I chose the wrong time to come back to Minecraft PE💀
First Android 11+ have made it so hard to actually navigate and customise your internal files that it's almost impossible for most games to be customised via adding external mods, and now Minecraft removes the one feature that allowed hundreds of mods to even exist.
This Really pissed me off whem this first came out because ive been
Hosting a Heavily organized and well made SCP Facility on minecraft that used Mods that relys on holiday creator features ive been doing these for 3 years and we have over 200 people in the community This is just a massive setback for my
Community Especially when i was about to roll out one of the biggest updates for my
Facility. And add some new departments and add a massive expansion to my facility. This caused us to lose about 10-20 people Since i had to pause Hosting the facility to make a new facility since our previous facility is filled dirt blocks with question Marks now.
(I hate mojang)
@@tiky2841 sorry to hear this
@@Smitty058 your good, not your fault i just wished they wouldnt have removed it.
@@Smitty058I made a fnaf map that I’ve been working on since December the world is 141.2MB I
Same dude I use SCP paradoX and the other mods by the same people
Addon Creator here, anyway the removing of Holiday Creator Features was having more changes in addons and they add javascript on it but it doesn't replace many kinds of stuff they only improving via custom components.
Apparently addons are being saved but blocks and items are in different format in example version 1.16.0 which is stable format to blocks and items but if you're on 1.16.100 which is experimental you can upgrade it to bigger versions where it's stable like 1.20.80 or 1.21.20 which is the best stable version format and it has lots of components.
Here's the tip for addon creators please choose at least 4 components such as collision_box, geometry, material_instance and loot because these are the stable and learn some by adding traits and states, but not all addon developers are interested in javascript but it's time to move on tho>
FRICK YOU MOJANG!
YEAH
HELL YEAH
HELL YEAH
HELL YEAH🦅🦅
HELL YEAH
Mojang should just stick to their shitty little updates instead of screwing up core game features. First the realms, then the redstone and now this
This has ruined almost all my worlds some of them require the addons to work properly so now most of my worlds are basically unplayable
Why can’t they just keep the toggle as well as having the new way of making addons?
That’s exactly what I’m saying but no one has given me a clear and REASONABLE answer. They are a multi billionaire company that should be able to do these things
They had already given a warning months ago. Keeping the toggle would just add more complexity to developing the game.
@@gorilla_gorl several games have multiple options tho. It should be for what’s best for the addon creator, not something that people are lazy for doing. These bonus optimizations would ultimately allow players to have access to different ways to create stuff and see what best suits them
@@SymmYTyea but they were notified months in advance
@@gorilla_gorl I understand that continuing to support the old system would make things too complicated, but I think that ideally they could keep the toggle in for compatibility and develop the game as if they removed it
Yeah honestly this hit hard. I code my own bedrock mods. Really threw me off and half my old projects i was proud of dont work anymore
Though it does seem like it will be better in the future
This is the straw that broke the camels back, me and my friends switched to unreal engine 5 to make our game because it will at least be a working product by the end of it lol
Hey, I wanted to say thank you for the information personally I was thinking about like switching over the Java completely but then I just learned to now that most add-ons just need to be updated. All my friends were telling me false information like that won’t work anymore and all that, they don’t exist after a couple updates or something
This is literally the whole execute command reworked again.
The time when maps developers are disappointed that the execute commands is completely revamped with better and improved features.
They say it was Soo simple back then, but that was the point.
It was too simple that less features and possibilities can be made from a simple feature.
That's why they had to improve it, unfortunately some people gave up fixing all command blocks in their maps that use the old execute command,
I don't blame them.
It took me a while to fully understand how the new execute command works, i understand the pain that going through all those lines of codes just keep it alive for future updates isn't easy.
Since I'm an add-on creator myself.
I love the new execute. Never going back
In Java, they did have the option to just not update.
@@miimiiandcobedrock is on the conversion and for the video.
I only learned the new execute command so I don't get the pain, but I do understand its not hard to just make another command equivalent to that of the execute but just updated. But Mojang is filled with bums
No way this guy is still complaining about when they changed the execute command 😅
The answer is to honestly just stick with an old version through a third party launcher and mod away, with outside tools if it has to be. New official features and compensation through the market place may seem spicy, but they clearly have no issue breaking mod support in random ways at random times, simply because they can't be bothered to playtest their developer option-changes before shipping updates.
so basically we should be mad that they made holiday creator features in the first place
I made a scripting template that lets people make HCF-like block and Item events with ease. If you have any add-ons you made that needs updated and you don't wanna learn scripting, I suggest using it.
My idea is to downgrade Minecraft to the last version where we had the “holiday creator feature” and then we might get the toggle
I’m not sure if it will work on Xbox, it’s just an idea
Good idea
I think this wouldn't be an issue if version downgrading was a thing. A lot of Java mods never get undated past 1.8, to my knowledge.
Aton more usually don't go pass 1.12.2 due to the changes in the games code straight up making the mods broken entirely needing the developer to code the entire thing from the ground up
Yeah My second favorite addon to play stopped working. Luckily my Favorite addon wasn’t affected.
Also I know the new feature will make it better and easier but why not keep and have both.
What Poggy is saying is like saying Fortnite should remove creative since they have creative 2.0(UEFN) because it pushes people to make better things. I think people should have the option to take the easier route even if it isn’t as good
They said about the changes on the pasts changes logs so the option was there but nobody said anything useful all just jump into the, "mojang Is removing addons millions must boicot the mob vote" train ,instead of doing... Something useful
@@LivingBones-v2qtalking fact
Exactly. but Mojang is a greedy ass company to busy trying to make Minecraft cute then updating their game lol.
Nice how they used to give Addon makers official modding APIs and now a few years later ruin everything.
They're forcing us to switch to java
@@prosans4629 Thats dumb from a buisness perspective that cant be it.
They're bringing good stuf and then just removing it making the game look bad
@@prosans4629 bedrock brings them more money so that makes no sense.
@@prosans4629 Not Java Edition, but Javascript.
Holiday Creator Features exist because it was a experimental thats why it has a warning, the reason it is remove is because all of the components that the Holidays Creator Features supported are stabled and doesn't cause much bugs on further updates, and thats why they add versioning on addons so us or other addon creators can use stabled components
If you're a creator using experimental features for what you'd considered a released project, don't. This is exactly why. These features are not in stable, beta, alpha, preview, none of that. Experimental is not always guaranteed to remain the game. Please avoid using experimental features and stick with stable features if your project aim is to be released for players to play. Experimental is great for literally experimenting with possibly incoming features but is not guaranteed to be merged with stable. This is why marketplace content is unaffected as marketplace partners are not allowed to use experimental features. I blame Mojang for a lot of stuff, but this isn't on them imo (hot take)
THANK YOU! I thought I was going crazy! I every time i booted an experimental world up, it very clearly warns players about this! Did everyone think mojang was joking?
Agreed
Might try and see if there is a way to convert packs automatically.
Bro might clutch for the community
Well any success
Wait so if we’re forced to use .json that means we’re able to use the RTX packs from PC I mean all I had to do is make a .json file for SEUS shaders and it worked for my series x
I don’t think rtx works but deferred rendering works for now
that changes nothing
Got my entire worth of work faded like ashes in a second. I was soo excited to go back to Minecraft after school, and this is how I literally got greeted
They jusut want people buying Marketplace addons dawg at this point just buy java not Those stupid ass minecoins😭🙏
I think they should've given a warning in the game itself, something like "Holiday Creator Features have been replaced by Custom Components - some add-ons relying on HCF might be broken and need updating."
There's literally a notice when you turn on any experimental toggle where it might get removed in the future updates. Doesn't matter if it's there for 4 years, there's still a chance, and here it finally happened.
Relying on experimental features is also a mistake in this case. Most add-on creators don't give information about what an experimental feature is or they themselves consider the consequences of using it.
I can’t catch a break, it seems like every single week at this point.
even worse, custom biomes (despite being an option in experiments for bedrock edition) have been broken for around 4 years, since the caves and cliffs updates.
So do i understand this right, that the addons I officially bought in the official minecraft store aren't working anymore in the payed official realm-server? I spend the last weeks to customize my own realm to come to this point? That can't be real
Yeah basically, unless you're lucky like some people
nahh surely they work if they're from the marketplace💀
They work if they are from
the marketplace
@@Redlava ofc they work
Thank you guys!
Meanwhile... in Java, people are still maintaining and improving their mods for Minecraft 1.4.5 and 1.12.2 .
Im so sad Smitty i had over 50 mods😞
Womp womp
@@hehasnolips1371 go back to see skibidi toilet and lanky box little boy, you are not cool 😂
@@hehasnolips1371 Careful with whatchu post 🙏🗣️🗣️🙏 the COCK is watching 🤞🤞🐔🐔 and he ain’t take NO prisoners 🙅♂️🙅♂️🤫🤫 keep them cheeks TIGHT before they are WRECKED
@@hehasnolips1371most clean hearted rip_luffy player
@@hehasnolips1371nah you fatherless motherless and most sane lankybox watcher shut up you aint cool
I made a whole pokemon mod that took 3 years to finish and they ruined it
So, Umm, I am the developer of the more tools addon haven't been active for over a year and it's not just about the complexity of the add-on but also how big it is. For example i have a lot of items and blocks that broke and that will take a lot of my time to fix everything. And since I was not active lately I don't know most of the stuff that's possible to do with the new scripting method. The microsoft documentation is trash at best even though I know java script is not to much use without proper documentation from mojang.
As a Minecraft Addon/Map maker
I actually love the removal of HCF, people really needs to learn more about scripting.
@@flappyblock have you read my comment?
Dang that’s unfortunate I know many people who love your addon
@@Smitty058 don't worry I am managing to update it however I started before 1.21.2 and it's still not fully working. It's in a working state atm so it's fine for me but, I'm sorry for other people's add-ons.
While some of my stuff still works, it got rid of some super cute granny decor I had and other food mods and I’m super sad because they really added to the aesthetic of my world 😭🤚🏽
I always played mods with my friends and now i gotta wait for Poggy (mostly) to post
My stuff updates minutes after a new Minecraft release drops.
@@XxPoggyisLitxX Coolllll 🔥🔥
@@XxPoggyisLitxX I'm definitely subscribing too btw
@@XxPoggyisLitxX I love your Better on bedrock mod it's my favorite too
@@XxPoggyisLitxXhey poggy can you convert minesanity to cc?
First they redesign villagers which caused mods that replace the OG villagers to do nothing, now they remove holiday features? Man this is bull crap
I do not have much problem about the removal of the holiday experiment but mainly problem of mine right now is realm connectivity problems and addons importation on realm, it's really kicked me in the butt😂
Both are main problems
Can Mojang not just keep both the Holiday Creator Features and add the custom components?
The best way I can understand this is when Minecraft updated the commands, from the old Execute to the new one, how people where upset and mad (as was I) but after some time I grew to LOVE the new execute cause all of the new things you can do
Cool, but this also removed thousands of people's data, so no, still shit
@@jamstheshapeshifter so did the conversation of the old Execute to the new one, I lost a world of 3-4 years
But I would much rather have the new execute ANY day of the week (sorry hit send to soon) ^^"
Just like custom component I prefer having this and having really good add-ons that might won't have any limitations from bedrock anymore than add-ons made in json that are very limited (also u can do thing only using vanilla features) while it's totally different with custom component written in JavaScript
@@20Eclipse03 the only issue with the argument is the execute command was a much simpler thing to do, it can work exactly the same by just adding an "at" and a "run" this is a much more complicated thing to fix
It extremely pisses me off, i watched a tutorial didnt understand and do the steps in the tutorial for 1 hour and after successfully putting the mod i see its not working in mc and then i see minecrafts new update changes🙁
Is there a way to fix it for Xbox?
How is the new option better then Holiday Creator it seems like no one explained what they can do better now but they say its better. How?
Its better
Its better because custom components are made using the javascript api instead of pure json api, and since javascript is actually a programming language and have its features u can do stuff much more freely
Thank you Smitty !
This is why I never update as soon as it comes out😊. I always wate
Good move
Wait
Couldn’t they just have kept holiday creator features as an option instead of deleting it?
i am glad that i turned off auto update for my games on the xbox and wait for addons for the new change and then i will update
I get "There a temporary Network probelm every time I try to boot up minecraft" and I don't know why, ever since I got some more mods it started doing it
Thats why java players always say negatove thing about bedrock. Microsoft is ruining bedrock minecraft..
By improving it?
Everytime I try to make a world it doesn’t let me for some reason I can’t even click it
PLEASE MAKE A TUTORIAL ON HOW TO FIX SOME ADDONS
I’m still mad that Mojang removed the holiday creator feature just because the furnitures foods and plushies in my smp are unknown blocks and broken and ruined!
Why did you use a f*cking expiremental feature?
@yswnova you're a loser.
@@yswnovabecause add-ons need them
we can still have our custom skins right?
Yes mine work
Mine are fine but I did see hundreds of people claiming theirs disappeared
Skins should still work
As long as you have an account your skin will remain safe
okay thank you guys
Most of my addons are working so I think some creators found out to make their mods work without Holiday Creator features
Bro how long is this war gonna go on 🙏 🙏
Dude, now the war between the Bedrock and Java player communities is getting hotter since this update... Java players are becoming arrogant and pretending to be the winners because Bedrock has been ruined by Mojang.
@@FenderosterCreeps666if mojang really hate bedrock then why don't they replace it with java mobile💀
@@prosans4629 they don't make it because Minecraft Java is not supported on devices with C++ programming such as mobile devices..💀
@@FenderosterCreeps666now their game is getting infected, the launcher broke yesterday
As long as they need to replace old, outdated features with new ones.
I had maps that were planned to be used for upcoming videos, and I will admit this does make me mad, but at the same time, it feels like this was just another questionable choice.
It’s funny to how Mojang did mention they planned to make Bedrock and Java one and the same, but so far, they haven’t really done a whole lot.
Overall, I am disappointed, but that’s well to be expected at this point. 🙄🤦
Did a server with my friends on a massive medieval modpack with over 50 Addons... All gone in one update.
So sorry it hear this :(
@@Smitty058what makes it worse is that I didn't back up the world so not only did all my custom items and armour disappear but the world got corrupted due to some experimental errors from experimental required addons so it won't open and downgrading Minecraft also doesn't work so... Yep.. no recovery. So probably until More addons use this new scripting API I might stick with Java for a while.
@@misterohnoesgaming4579i switched to pojav launcher and im staying there like forever
Well,i guess i am moving back to 1.16. Have shaders that actually support my device properly,have bunch of addons etc.
I’ve quit Minecraft, hopefully you will all do the same, they always make poor decisions, addons is what enhances the experience of Minecraft. And all they had to do was add something new, it wasn’t necessary to remove and replace that feature. They always make poor decisions, and this is the final straw!
Can you please make a video about addon making in 1.21.2 without the holiday creator features?
Im a addon dev, and this is good change for improving Java script and everyone will not lazy for learning Java script
EVERYONE I FOUND A WORK AROUND UNTIL THEY FIX THEM THERES A PACK THATS SUPPOSED TO ADD EXPERIMENTAL FEATURES TO EDUCATION WITH THE CREATOR FEATURES INCLUDED
what’s the pack
@@miateor i cant remember it specifically but if you look up “minecraft education edition experimental features pack” you should find it
Microsoft is actually making .jar mods to work on bedrock. We'll be seeing ForgexBedrock in a few years!
Wait really? If this happens imma forgive Microsoft, but I’m gonna be pissed if they make the Java mods paid
If this happens, peace will be restored
ok so, Meaning that Mods like Create mod, RLCraft, TacZ or VPB, Etc will work on Bedrock Sooner??
if that happens, Holy shit im giving this crown to both Mojang and Microsoft for being W
For me guns were removed for every Addon I own. It’s crazy.
this going to impact the existance of minecraft bedrock
True
Bedrock problably going to get deleted in 2025 summer or smt
Somebody must protest microsoft for real
0:04 minecraft* not minecrfat
are you correcting the video or the Reddit presented in the video?
No one cares
@@fake_artist89 bro I just correcting
@@fake_artist89 if u not care just ignore my comment bruh
When I was trying to insert the url to the file explorer and it won't work wouldn't load or nothing
ARE YOU KIDDING?! I WAS GOING TO MAKE A MAP BUT NOW I CANT 😐😐😐😐
Minecraft is going down Roblox's path
You still can. You just have to use the new, seemingly better features to make add-ons now.
@@miimiiandco so you're still able to make addons?
its crazy to think 4 years ago i put my friend in the discord and later its in discord memes 2. Cool seeing you a long bit later remember joining your mincraft worlds when you would stream.
Minecraft should already delete bedrock edition. they should know its garbage by now and they just keep making it worse
It's their money machine. That's all that matters.
@@ShadowTheHedgehog003lmao ur clueless
@@yswnovanah he's right
@@Esyve nope Bedrock 2011 in dev and Java since 2009 🙄 Java is the OG
@@Esyve also i played since the Beta 1.2.5 on Java, at that time we didnt even Know what Bedrock is because it didnt exist
I swear to god if mojang.... No,MICROSOFT! If you don't bring back those components, this might will be the end of mc bedrock, not only addons also realms and servers. And also Some of the addon creator is mobile user cannot even use java components because no device is available
You setting your foot on the grave Microsoft. Remember mc is very popular so be ready if the player counts are lowering drastically
Here's a solution for modding
If you play bedrock edition on pc
Then I'd highly recommend switching over to java
You won't regret it
if you're on android, use pojav launcher
I'm actually smiling at this because it means that at least I can make even better mods with JS.
Let's hope one day Mojang will added back they always say this a freedom game and now it look like pay to win game
Hey quick question, if I were to replace my Xbox with the Series X I know I’d lose the skin packs I downloaded but would I also lose the worlds I downloaded as well? Or maybe if there’s a way to save those worlds then install them back into the console? I have a world that I downloaded and over the years me and a friend have built a lot of our own big builds, and I really don’t wanna lose them just because I have to upgrade my console.
To be honest here with my own opinions
This is almost a great thing because most of the time I'm confused what experiment toggle to use, AND addons that doesn't even need experiments still work, and to be in fact we are technically pushing limits to bedrock modding
When will Mojang FINALLY fix bugs or unsatisfactory features instead of listing new things in every new update when in reality they've never done anything about the old issues, if anything they just keep piling more and more
I make addons and what people dont realise is. The fact these mods are now scripts. They will work for PC players but anyone on console are buggered basically. They cant run scripts otherwise it’ll crash their game.
Couldn't they just leave holiday creator feafures with the new one like they did some years ago with "old worlds"? >:I
Basically my world I've been working on non stop for a year just no longer works anymore unless they fixs the mods, its such bs
wow, so thats why my map doesnt work anymore.
i’m surprised no one is talking about rolling back versions. windows users shouldn’t feel effected by this situation at all as they can simply roll back to version 1.21.10 where Holiday Creator features are still present
THE MARKET PLACE ONES IN BEDROCK ARE NOT WORKING
i need you, please
Every world I had was corrupted, even my realms. Crazy how greedy Microsoft can be.
As someone who has modded since 1021 and has a folder of over 13gb of giant modded worlds for me and my friends that we played on until the update, this is realy annoying.
am mad cuz i use my car addon and i play my world and my car is gone and more stuff now i hate mojang
I've been working on a mod for like 5 months, added 200+ blocks, mobs and items, i was almost done with the mod then they do this. God damn it Microsoft