*GOD IN THE TALMUD - LIVE Q&A* || _17 September 2024 ; Tuesday_ 0:00:13 Stream begins with Ibrahim, Zakir Hussain, Hashim, and Mansur; followed by introductory discussion 0:03:30 Ibrahim introduces today's subject "The Concept of God in Rabbinic Literature", and the panelists discuss 0:07:49 Brandon, and Mohammad join the panel, and discussion continue 0:25:29 Picture of _phylacteries_ 0:26:16 Article on _Why the Talmud Is the Most Important Text in Judaism_ [[ link : www.algemeiner.com/2017/08/11/why-the-talmud-is-the-most-important-text-in-judaism/ ]] 0:28:32 Ibrahim provides presentation on _God in Rabbinic Judaism_ [[ attributes of God ]] ; and discussion continues along-with _0:28:37__ (01) God cries [[ Chagigah 5b : Jeremiah 13:17 ; I Chronicles __16:27__ ]]_ _0:31:11__ (02) God plays [[ Avodah Zarah 3b : Psalms 104:26 ]]_ _0:32:11__ (03) God sins [[ Chullin 60b : Genesis 1:16 ; Genesis 1:14 ; Numbers __28:15__ ]]_ _0:40:49__ (04) God studies Torah [[ Avodah Zarah 3b : God is viewed as rabi in Judaism ]]_ _0:41:43__ (05) God debates about the Law [[ Bava Metzia 86a ]]_ _0:43:56__ (06) God wears tefillin [[ Berakhot 6a : Isaiah 62:8 ; picture to follow ]]_ _0:44:23__ (07) God wears prayer shawl [[ Rosh Hashanah 17b ; picture to follow ]]_ _0:44:42__ (08) God keeps the Torah, and He breaks it too ! [[ Rosh Hashanah 1:3 ; Pesiqta Rabbati 30 ]]_ _0:46:49__ (09) God studies a Rabbi's book and cites it [[ Bamidbar Rabbah 19 ]]_ _0:48:26__ (10) God was in exile [[ Mekhilta DeRabbi Yishmael, Tractate Pischa 14 : Exodus 24:10 ; Isaiah 63:9 ; Psalms 91:15 ; Genesis 39:20-21 ; II Samuel __7:23__ ; Zechariah __10:11__ ; Shoftim 17:4 ]]_ _0:55:30__ (11) God learns from Moses [[ Numbers (Chukkath) ]]_ _0:56:38__ (12) God looks like Adam [[ Bereshit Rabbah 8 : Isaiah 2:22 ]]_ _1:02:26__ (13) God dances [[ Jerusalem Talmud Megillah 2:4 ]]_ _1:03:21__ (14) God's hands need redeeming [[ Pesikta De-Rab Kahana ]]_ _1:07:25__ (15) Moses overpowers God [[ Jerusalem Talmud Taanit 4:5 ]]_ _1:08:30__ (16) God is judged [[ Shir HaShirim Rabbah 2:1 : Isaiah 66:16 ]]_ _1:09:40__ (17) God asks Abraham to judge him [[ Bereshit Rabbah 49 : Job __34:32__, 41:4 ]]_ _1:11:53__ (18) God becomes impure [[ Shemor Rabbah 15 : Jeremiah 2:3 ; Exodus 12:30 ; Numbers 33:4 ; Exodus 3:8 ; Leviticus 16:33, 16:16 ]][[ Sanhedrin 39a : Exodus 25:2 ; Isaiah 40:12, 66:15 ; Numbers __31:23__ ]]_ _1:17:16__ (19) God is burden [[ Eruvin 22a : Deuteronomy 7:10 ]]_ _1:18:17__ (20) God's power increases/decreases [[ Eikhah Rabbah 1 : Psalms 60:14 ; Deuteronomy 32:18 ; Numbers __14:17__ ]]_ _1:19:12__ (21) God rests [[ Exodus 31:17 ]]_ _1:19:34__ (22) God makes mistakes [[ Bereshit Rabbah 27 : Genesis 6:6 ]][[ Eikhah Rabbah, Petichta : Jeremiah 9:16 ; Hosea __7:13__ ; Jeremiah 10:19 ]][[ Pesiqta Rabbati 30:9-10 ]]_ _Discussion with guests_ 1:29:43 I'm jewish / Ahin [ Jew - from New Jersey, USA ] :: [[ Talmud always has to go acc to Torah ]] [[ long...long....long....discussion on different points ]] 3:03:40 Amir Dadabhoy [ Muslim ] :: _asks if the Jewish people consider only the Torah the revelation given to Moses (as), or the entire collection of books of the Bible_ 3:09:21 Philo Sapience [ Atheist ] :: [[ not relevant to today's topic ]] 3:19:43 Deen Reloaded [ Muslim ] :: [[ requests to do future streams on where the Qur'an corrects the Jewish Bible, and which points the Qur'an agrees wrt the Jewish Scriptures ]] 3:40:29 Jay [ Muslim ] :: _asks how the Jews now can go back to the Torah, and the Injeel when they no longer have the correct Torah, and Injeel_ 4:00:09 Concluding discussion, and hoping to bring Ibrahim again soon ! [[ subscribe to www.youtube.com/@provingislam ]]
If you wanna learn, read the Quran and life of Mohammad in your first language. Listening to other people and believing that what they are saying is foolishness.
@@ukhadunga yeah with that logic there wouldn’t be any reason to have Sheikhs/Ustadhs to learn the religion. Stop clowning around. If you have nothing good to say, keep your mouth shut
@@ukhadungathey provide sources for us which is the proper way to do it, so I don’t see what your problem is. I’ve learnt so much about my deen than I ever did innit”madrasah” or from my parents. May Allah bless them and their families immensely
@@ukhadunga never claimed I “read so much” 😂 And no tbh I don’t have time to study as I worship Allah constantly by fulfilling my duties as a mother, wife and daughter. I spend my day doing sadaqah by obeying Allah and fulfilling my role and its duties. And may Allah grant these brothers jannatul Firdous, I can walk around my house with my headphones on and listen in and gain some knowledge instead of watch useless tv shows or gossip on the phone like some other women. 😃
They take their rabbis and their monks for their lords apart from Allah, and also the Messiah, son of Mary, whereas they were commanded to worship none but the One True God. There is no god but He. Exalted be He above those whom they associate with Him in His Divinity. (Quran 9:31)
Basically everything in their torah is metaphorical and even clear verses have a totally other meaning which has to be explained by later teachers through a broken chain. Sounds like changing the text to fit their whims and desires
Assalamu Aleikum. Zakir Hussein uploads his debates on his own channel and does q & a insha Allah. 19.00 - funny because phylactories are mini kabas because they know Islam is the truth.
Since his birthday until his crucifixion with all the miracles he brings. The choosing people of God don't accept the son of god?How can a God make his choosing people don't accept his son ?however the Christians still suporting them hardly.
*GOD IN THE TALMUD - LIVE Q&A* || _17 September 2024 ; Tuesday_
0:00:13 Stream begins with Ibrahim, Zakir Hussain, Hashim, and Mansur; followed by introductory discussion
0:03:30 Ibrahim introduces today's subject "The Concept of God in Rabbinic Literature", and the panelists discuss
0:07:49 Brandon, and Mohammad join the panel, and discussion continue
0:25:29 Picture of _phylacteries_
0:26:16 Article on _Why the Talmud Is the Most Important Text in Judaism_ [[ link : www.algemeiner.com/2017/08/11/why-the-talmud-is-the-most-important-text-in-judaism/ ]]
0:28:32 Ibrahim provides presentation on _God in Rabbinic Judaism_ [[ attributes of God ]] ; and discussion continues along-with
_0:28:37__ (01) God cries [[ Chagigah 5b : Jeremiah 13:17 ; I Chronicles __16:27__ ]]_
_0:31:11__ (02) God plays [[ Avodah Zarah 3b : Psalms 104:26 ]]_
_0:32:11__ (03) God sins [[ Chullin 60b : Genesis 1:16 ; Genesis 1:14 ; Numbers __28:15__ ]]_
_0:40:49__ (04) God studies Torah [[ Avodah Zarah 3b : God is viewed as rabi in Judaism ]]_
_0:41:43__ (05) God debates about the Law [[ Bava Metzia 86a ]]_
_0:43:56__ (06) God wears tefillin [[ Berakhot 6a : Isaiah 62:8 ; picture to follow ]]_
_0:44:23__ (07) God wears prayer shawl [[ Rosh Hashanah 17b ; picture to follow ]]_
_0:44:42__ (08) God keeps the Torah, and He breaks it too ! [[ Rosh Hashanah 1:3 ; Pesiqta Rabbati 30 ]]_
_0:46:49__ (09) God studies a Rabbi's book and cites it [[ Bamidbar Rabbah 19 ]]_
_0:48:26__ (10) God was in exile [[ Mekhilta DeRabbi Yishmael, Tractate Pischa 14 : Exodus 24:10 ; Isaiah 63:9 ; Psalms 91:15 ; Genesis 39:20-21 ; II Samuel __7:23__ ; Zechariah __10:11__ ; Shoftim 17:4 ]]_
_0:55:30__ (11) God learns from Moses [[ Numbers (Chukkath) ]]_
_0:56:38__ (12) God looks like Adam [[ Bereshit Rabbah 8 : Isaiah 2:22 ]]_
_1:02:26__ (13) God dances [[ Jerusalem Talmud Megillah 2:4 ]]_
_1:03:21__ (14) God's hands need redeeming [[ Pesikta De-Rab Kahana ]]_
_1:07:25__ (15) Moses overpowers God [[ Jerusalem Talmud Taanit 4:5 ]]_
_1:08:30__ (16) God is judged [[ Shir HaShirim Rabbah 2:1 : Isaiah 66:16 ]]_
_1:09:40__ (17) God asks Abraham to judge him [[ Bereshit Rabbah 49 : Job __34:32__, 41:4 ]]_
_1:11:53__ (18) God becomes impure [[ Shemor Rabbah 15 : Jeremiah 2:3 ; Exodus 12:30 ; Numbers 33:4 ; Exodus 3:8 ; Leviticus 16:33, 16:16 ]][[ Sanhedrin 39a : Exodus 25:2 ; Isaiah 40:12, 66:15 ; Numbers __31:23__ ]]_
_1:17:16__ (19) God is burden [[ Eruvin 22a : Deuteronomy 7:10 ]]_
_1:18:17__ (20) God's power increases/decreases [[ Eikhah Rabbah 1 : Psalms 60:14 ; Deuteronomy 32:18 ; Numbers __14:17__ ]]_
_1:19:12__ (21) God rests [[ Exodus 31:17 ]]_
_1:19:34__ (22) God makes mistakes [[ Bereshit Rabbah 27 : Genesis 6:6 ]][[ Eikhah Rabbah, Petichta : Jeremiah 9:16 ; Hosea __7:13__ ; Jeremiah 10:19 ]][[ Pesiqta Rabbati 30:9-10 ]]_
_Discussion with guests_
1:29:43 I'm jewish / Ahin [ Jew - from New Jersey, USA ] :: [[ Talmud always has to go acc to Torah ]] [[ long...long....long....discussion on different points ]]
3:03:40 Amir Dadabhoy [ Muslim ] :: _asks if the Jewish people consider only the Torah the revelation given to Moses (as), or the entire collection of books of the Bible_
3:09:21 Philo Sapience [ Atheist ] :: [[ not relevant to today's topic ]]
3:19:43 Deen Reloaded [ Muslim ] :: [[ requests to do future streams on where the Qur'an corrects the Jewish Bible, and which points the Qur'an agrees wrt the Jewish Scriptures ]]
3:40:29 Jay [ Muslim ] :: _asks how the Jews now can go back to the Torah, and the Injeel when they no longer have the correct Torah, and Injeel_
4:00:09 Concluding discussion, and hoping to bring Ibrahim again soon ! [[ subscribe to www.youtube.com/@provingislam ]]
Much appreciated! ❤️
ﺟﺰﺍﻙ ﺍﻟﻠﻪ ﺧﻴﺮﺍ
*_Masha'Allah, a brilliant panel that is well-versed on the subject. Barak'Allah feekum_*
I learn so much from this channel. May Allah bless all of you brothers. Please never stop doing these videos. It’s such a great way for us to learn ❤
If you wanna learn, read the Quran and life of Mohammad in your first language. Listening to other people and believing that what they are saying is foolishness.
@@ukhadunga yeah with that logic there wouldn’t be any reason to have Sheikhs/Ustadhs to learn the religion. Stop clowning around. If you have nothing good to say, keep your mouth shut
@@ukhadungathey provide sources for us which is the proper way to do it, so I don’t see what your problem is. I’ve learnt so much about my deen than I ever did innit”madrasah” or from my parents. May Allah bless them and their families immensely
@@specter1019 💯
@@ukhadunga never claimed I “read so much” 😂
And no tbh I don’t have time to study as I worship Allah constantly by fulfilling my duties as a mother, wife and daughter. I spend my day doing sadaqah by obeying Allah and fulfilling my role and its duties. And may Allah grant these brothers jannatul Firdous, I can walk around my house with my headphones on and listen in and gain some knowledge instead of watch useless tv shows or gossip on the phone like some other women. 😃
Thanks for the stream!! BARIKALLAHU FIKUM. 🎉❤
They take their rabbis and their monks for their lords apart from Allah, and also the Messiah, son of Mary, whereas they were commanded to worship none but the One True God. There is no god but He. Exalted be He above those whom they associate with Him in His Divinity. (Quran 9:31)
Basically everything in their torah is metaphorical and even clear verses have a totally other meaning which has to be explained by later teachers through a broken chain. Sounds like changing the text to fit their whims and desires
Jak, I have learned a lot from today’s discussion.Thank you for your time and efforts in making this happen.
May Allah bless all of you 🙏🙏
DawahWise should do a deep dive series on Judaism with brother Ibrahim and other young du'ats
amazing work. thank you!!
Assalamu Aleikum.
Zakir Hussein uploads his debates on his own channel and does q & a insha Allah.
19.00 - funny because phylactories are mini kabas because they know Islam is the truth.
Love to hear more on Judaism theology, interesting for us muslim too!
If you had one thousand years you couldn't grasp the Talmud.
2:47:00 only reason so many was sent there must be because they are rebellious and don't learn a lesson
2:31:00
Is Ibrahim and wesam the same?
2:03:00 Deuteronomy 25 v 11 and 12. word of god?
Around 59:18 brother Ibrahim says something very dangerous. Allah does not look like man.
That's not what he said
Since his birthday until his crucifixion with all the miracles he brings. The choosing people of God don't accept the son of god?How can a God make his choosing people don't accept his son ?however the Christians still suporting them hardly.
I would say the worst heneous thing about judaism is "racism"
Worst is what they write about Allah.
2:6:40 😂😂 you guys do debate.. I eat 😂
Anybody can call himself or herself as jewish...there is a difference between being jewish and a jew
Who cares. They're discussing their scriptures.