The Tumbler Or Hone Rolling Sharpener - Which One Is Better?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 19 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 97

  • @lukemwill99
    @lukemwill99 Рік тому +11

    SOMEONE GET THIS GUY A SPONSOR!

  • @gamadmex
    @gamadmex Рік тому +9

    I recently purchased the Tumbler from an IG ad, and I literally just used it for the first time this morning on my Cutco chef's knife. I only made a few passes to test it, and it worked pretty well. But I definitely wish I had seen this video prior to my purchase. You convinced me to look at the Hone. Great review!

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  Рік тому +1

      Definitely check out Hone. The new ceramic is coming out and that will be perfect to use all the time for regular honing

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  Рік тому +3

      Make sure to look at the description as I have a discount code in one of them. I don’t make a dime, just doing to get folks a very reasonably priced good sharpener.

    • @einundsiebenziger5488
      @einundsiebenziger5488 10 місяців тому

      Only fitting. With the Tumbler and Costco knives, you brought two over-hyped, over-priced mediocre-quality products together.

  • @ampelectric
    @ampelectric Рік тому +9

    Tumbler is rocking it because of TikTok I bet there will be some customers that will regret it if they see this video, I will definitely get the Hone

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  Рік тому +1

      Several bought Hone on my live last week apparently. 15k were on the live I did on TikTok. Hone did a great job.

  • @Iamjasonallen
    @Iamjasonallen 9 місяців тому +2

    This video deserves a positive comment. Well done sir.

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  9 місяців тому +1

      Thank you sir, much appreciated!

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  7 місяців тому

      +@Iamjasonallen thank you so much. I really appreciate the comment!

  • @justinchu7641
    @justinchu7641 11 місяців тому +3

    Thanks! That was a really helpful in-depth review. I appreciate the comparison as well as the pros/cons and the detail on all of the features. Very informative!

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  11 місяців тому

      Thank you very much. I have a new comparison with others coming out soon. Hope you subscribe and enjoy!

  • @tomatoman3706
    @tomatoman3706 2 місяці тому +1

    I purchased the hone and pro kit due to your reviews, it should be in tomorrow thank you!

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  2 місяці тому +1

      Awesome. I am releasing a new video on the new 2000 grit and extender that was just released.

    • @tomatoman3706
      @tomatoman3706 2 місяці тому

      @@UkuleleJayBBQ awesome can’t wait to see it!

  • @fredh.9816
    @fredh.9816 Рік тому +1

    Excellent, in-depth review. I was worried that Tumbler wouldn’t work on my small kitchen knives. All its advertising is with a large chefs knife. You perfectly demonstrated how both products work with small knives. Thks

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  Рік тому

      Thank you. Yes the Tumbler is horrible with small knives and has very weak magnets.

  • @BSB1437
    @BSB1437 11 місяців тому +2

    I did purchase the Tumblr AMA I am NOT happy with it! It is very difficult to use. Wish I had seen your video BEFORE I ordered it, but I will be looking for the HONE and purchasing that one. Great video and your explanation was spot on!

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  11 місяців тому

      The HONE is fantastic and now with 4 grits out and a 5th coming, it will be extremely complete. I love the new 3000 ceramic. Now they have 200, 400, 1000, 3000 ceramic and soon adding a 700 which is a great progression in my opinon. Yeah a lot of folks are switching.

  • @GrandpaJeffrey
    @GrandpaJeffrey 10 місяців тому +2

    Been sharpening knives for 50 years, and the Tumbler works VERY well for its intended use. I am sure the Hone does too. Once I bought the additional angle magnet tool for my tumbler i have even more versatility. I was able to do even more. I am not sure this review covers all of the accessories tumbler now has. It should.

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  10 місяців тому +1

      I did a shoot out with Tumbler, HONE and Work Sharp rolling sharpeners few weeks ago. Not sure you watched that one? The Tumbler has been surpassed in nearly every area in testing as was demonstrated. Glad it works for you. Whatever folks enjoy they should use if it works for them. Appreciate your comment!

  • @WilHenDavis
    @WilHenDavis 9 місяців тому +1

    I recently bought a Tumbler plus a Tumbler strop, and then saw this video, returned the Tumbler (kept the strop) explaining why I was returning the Tumbler. Tumbler were as good as their word, and refunded my $$ (including shipping). I ordered the Hone and it arrived A WEEK BEFORE I expected it!!! Thanks again for sharing your video! (BTW I gave Tumbler a fair review as far as their service/customer-support is concerned) 😊

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  9 місяців тому

      Sounds good! Lot’s of versatility with HONE and now the two new items coming out are really going to be fantastic. Should be getting my hands on them in a few weeks to test.

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  8 місяців тому

      +@WilHenDavis 👍🏼

  • @roberth7754
    @roberth7754 Рік тому +2

    Wow! I have been researching tumbler vs horl, but after seeing this great info video, now it’s for sure horl vs hone. Thank you!

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  Рік тому +1

      I completely agree but I think Hone takes it with the innovative interchangeable diamond discs and their holder. That is just wow.

    • @godstormm
      @godstormm Рік тому +2

      I am pretty sure Horl also has interchangeable discs. At least when I am looking at Horl 2 it does.@@UkuleleJayBBQ

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  Рік тому

      @@godstormm they do at 4x the cost of Hone

  • @luizgalaviz1176
    @luizgalaviz1176 9 місяців тому

    Thanks for the review and helpful info in your comment responses, helped make decision. I just received my order, one for me and one for my son. Also appreciate your discount code.
    Am curious if the change in grit on the #1 disc to what seems like 50% of what it was, is normal. I only sharpened 3 larger knives and a pearing knife.

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  9 місяців тому

      Hi Luiz, my pleasure, that's great you are getting him into maintaining his knives. What a great dad! ;-). Yes in my comprehnsive "How to Video" I talk about the grits. That is common with everya disc, diamond stone, or other coated stones. When you first use it, they will sound REALLY rough on like the 200, 400 and a little less on the 700. The finer the abrasive the less you experience that feeling but it still occurs. Totally normal. A few new accessories coming out soon so hope you subscribe to my channel as I have a lot more videos coming out this years on many different things with the HONE. Cheers!

  • @webbbusby
    @webbbusby 9 місяців тому +1

    Loved this review!

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  9 місяців тому

      Thanks a million! Appreciate the feedback.

  • @racerx192
    @racerx192 10 місяців тому +1

    I wish there was a discount code to pass along before Christmas.😊

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  10 місяців тому

      Try UKULELEJAYBBQ and see if that works. There was a code in my other HONE videos too which might work. Keep in mind it ships from where it's assembled in Canada and my experience is everyone is waiting about 2 weeks to get it so not sure it would make it to you for Christmas but if for you, it could be a late Christmas present ;-)

  • @shawnhenry4997
    @shawnhenry4997 Рік тому +1

    Another really good video, this channel is fantastic.

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  Рік тому

      Thanks so much for your support. I really appreciate it!

  • @bill2uok753
    @bill2uok753 3 місяці тому

    I think for any roller sharpening tool that has ball bearings and Neodynium magnets will be a winner.

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  3 місяці тому

      Depends on how they do the bearing, what materials are used to hold the bearings and many other factors that need to be tested, but that's a good start for sure.

  • @wg5768
    @wg5768 3 місяці тому +1

    Hone for the win!

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  3 місяці тому

      @@wg5768 agree!! They really nailed it.

  • @michaelpahk6325
    @michaelpahk6325 Рік тому +1

    Dò you have a video on the WorkSharp rolling knìfe sharpener?

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  Рік тому

      Yes I do, and I am releasing a comparison of three rolling knife sharpeners very soon including Home, Worksharp and one other.

  • @cadefoster9279
    @cadefoster9279 Рік тому +1

    I need your advice and experience on wether to get a Hone or a Chef’sChoice Trizor 15XV Professional for my Shun knives. I also have a few german lesser quality knives.
    thank you

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  Рік тому +1

      I Cade. I do not like those spinning disc models for a lot of reasons. For manual sharpening of 15 or 20 degree blades, HONE is great. They have 200, 400, 1000, just released their 3000 ceramic grit which I would use on my Shun (I love Shun btw) and will do so once I get the 3000 in hand. They are also going to release some other grits as well so you can incrementally start where you want and go up in grit on a nice gradual increase rather than a huge jump.
      Those electric pull throughs like the Trizor take a lot of metal off if you are not careful and I have seen people ruin the edge by holding it too long or not pulling through evenly and then the blade is not even. You also get the fixed grits and the ceramic wheel which keep in mind you get metal build up (you'll see the black) and cleaning it is a pain. The HONE you just pop out the disc, give it a wash/dry and pop it back on. The Trizor will sharpen faster but speed isn't my motivation, it's getting that nice razor sharp edge. Keep in mind once your knife is sharp, you'll only need to use the 3000 ceramic every few uses and it will keep that blade aligned and sharp for months most likely. Most people don't realize (I never did at first) that honing and stropping are all you need for a long time. Actually sharpening your blade with a "sharpener" isn't needed regularly so make sure you get a good leather strop like this: amzn.to/3RexKLb and you'll be all set. Hope this helps?

    • @cadefoster9279
      @cadefoster9279 Рік тому +1

      Thanks for the detailed reply!
      one more question please.
      What discs would you recommend me getting for my Shun knives at 1st with he HONE? They are not dull now just not very sharp.@@UkuleleJayBBQ

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  Рік тому +1

      @@cadefoster9279 I would first use the 3000 ceramic and leather strop. It should restore it to really really sharp.

  • @mhherr
    @mhherr Рік тому +1

    I have never been proficient at sharpening knives. After seeing some videos on both the Horl and Tumbler, I purchased a Tumbler about 3 weeks ago (ordered 8-5-23, received 8-12-23) and decided to return it for a refund (8-28-23) even before seeing this product. The deciding factor was cost -- the Horl is $200-$400+ and I couldn't justify it. The Tumbler was $98. And I paid an additional $29 for a strop.
    I'm glad I made the decision. The single biggest problem with the Tumbler is the magnets on the holder base. I could not get it to hold knives securely, especially my German knives with wide base at the tang, and my Dalstrong paring knife which doesn't reach the top of the Tumbler holder. I had a lot of trouble trying to hold both the knives to keep them from sliding on the magnet base and the base itself.
    After watching a different video by Ukelele Jay, I made the purchase for $105 with free shipping. The Hone features are superior to both Tumbler and Horl (not to mention the cost is much lower than the Horl). Looking forward to receiving my Hone sharpener in about 7-10 days. (BTW, I kept the Tumbler strop because Hone doesn't offer one.)

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  Рік тому

      Glad you saw the video. The HONE is a complete system and the larger discs are nice. There are good strops on Amazon in my store that work great. amazon.com/shop/ukulelejaybbq and go to the knife sharpening section and scroll down.

    • @HONE-Knife-Sharpener
      @HONE-Knife-Sharpener Рік тому +1

      We are working on designing our HONE Strop. We would like to offer a 3x8 inch HONE Strop with bamboo wood base and anti-slip pad at the bottom. Providing just a piece of leather like Tumbler and HORL won’t meet our quality standards as the strop needs to be raised from the countertop and should not slip during use due to safety reasons. Our HONE Strop will be available for purchase on our website in a few weeks.

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  Рік тому

      @@HONE-Knife-Sharpener great news and perfect size!

  • @wilavinila5691
    @wilavinila5691 Рік тому +1

    Great review. Thanks.

  • @cerberus2881
    @cerberus2881 8 місяців тому +1

    I have the Tumbler and I liked it until humidity stopped it rolling! The design wasn't thought out very well.

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  8 місяців тому +1

      Agree. Same here. Was ok at first then also got very squeaky. The HONE eliminates all those issues as it's 100% aluminium with ball bearings. Will never wear out. Also has numerous discs and the new AngleMate strips are fantastic. I think it's a fantastic rolling sharpener. Have done dozens of knives with mine, zero issues.

  • @michaelpahk6325
    @michaelpahk6325 Рік тому +1

    Have you tried ÌMPRESSA Wood lubricant to silence the tumbler?

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  Рік тому +1

      No I don’t use the Tumbler at all any longer. I use the Hone. Much better (all aluminum and steel) never a squeak issue and so many more options for grits and angles.

  • @kieranosgood3297
    @kieranosgood3297 11 місяців тому +1

    Disappointing to be successfully sold on a product (making me not want the tumbler) to realise Hone don't ship to UK yet 😅
    Edit: saw your amazon store, ordered from amazon US - can't wait!

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  11 місяців тому +1

      Awesome thanks! Hone now has 5 grits available from 200 to 3000 ceramic. You will love Hone, they really nailed it. I have a 3 way shootout review coming out soon you will enjoy.

  • @inkyste8078
    @inkyste8078 Рік тому +1

    Ordered one across to Australia, should arrive next month 👍

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  Рік тому

      You ordered the HONE yes?

    • @inkyste8078
      @inkyste8078 Рік тому +1

      @@UkuleleJayBBQ definitely 👍

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  Рік тому

      @@inkyste8078 fantastic. I really like mine

    • @inkyste8078
      @inkyste8078 Рік тому +1

      @@UkuleleJayBBQ looks really good, I spoke with them and they said the ceramic disc should be ready soon too!

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  Рік тому

      @@inkyste8078 yes. They have the 200 grit, 400 & 1000 and will have a 2000 as well. Will be all anyone needs. I got a dull knife razor sharp with the 400/1000. Solid unit!

  • @bradycorr3401
    @bradycorr3401 11 місяців тому +1

    How about a comparison between the Horn and the Horl 2. Both have been compared to the tumbler and beat it by far. But which one is better!?

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  11 місяців тому +1

      I spoke with HORL did not want to provide a unit for testing. A three way shootout is being released in about a week or so (shooting it now) between Tumbler, HONE and Work Sharp rolling knife sharpeners. Stay tuned, it’s an extremely comprehensive video!

  • @GrandpaJeffrey
    @GrandpaJeffrey 10 місяців тому +1

    At 00:45 The statement, “I don’t care what videos show you” is the beginning of a very misleading statement. NOWHERE in tumblers videos does it say you can sharpen a knife in just a few strokes. Any person who knows how to properly sharpen a knife would not even think this would be a case.
    Tumbler clearly states it may take “up to” five minutes to achieve the desired sharpness on a damaged or ill kept knife. However, if your well maintained knife is already at 15 or 20 degrees it may not take long at all to get the benefits of a fine grain 2000 grit sharpener. once I had all of the knives in our kitchen up to snuff the Tumbler does exactly what was claimed to do, and it does it very well.

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  10 місяців тому +1

      “Once up to snuff” as you said is key. That is not sharpening a “dull knive at 1000 on the BESS tester and taking it to razor sharp. For the most part but no one starts sharpening knives at 2000 grit. You are nearing honing range. It cannot compete in my opinion with the the Work Sharp or HONE as was demonstrated in the recent 3 way shoot out. It is underperforming in nearly all aspects based on extensive sharpening with all of these devices. I just report what the tests have demonstrated. Thanks for the comment!

  • @superevman869
    @superevman869 Рік тому +2

    Do you have a link or something to find the hone sharpener because i cant find it

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  Рік тому

      Just added to the description thanks! honesharp.com/products/hone-knife-sharpener

  • @adamyoung9283
    @adamyoung9283 10 місяців тому +1

    It would be cool if the discs had different grits on each side.

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  10 місяців тому +1

      Then you are back to just a single disc. I think this keeps the cost reasonable for the consumer.

  • @ICheat_ILie_ISteal
    @ICheat_ILie_ISteal Рік тому +2

    Rolling sharpener are getting popular... theres 2 Chinese version too.. both Chinese version has 6 different grit. Diamond or whetstone..
    I just want to see a adjustable knife holder....and a 25° and 30°

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  Рік тому

      They already are working on something that will allow you to use the same holder to do other angles 😎 This will also have many to choose from. Should be available soon.

    • @Oomph6006
      @Oomph6006 Рік тому +1

      The Tumbler is the chinese version... Its a copy of Horl

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  Рік тому

      @@Oomph6006it’s outdated already and I consider Tumbler obsolete. HONE is state of the are (not HORL buT HONE). Not a knock off. Designed and assembled from the ground up in Canada. 1/3 the price if HORL with more features.
      The Hone Rolling Knife Sharpener - Is It The New King Of Knife Sharpeners?
      ua-cam.com/video/fOE8BW1g4LA/v-deo.html and comparison here:
      The Tumbler Or Hone Rolling Sharpener - Which One Is Better?
      ua-cam.com/video/58-RSgMwf60/v-deo.html

    • @Oomph6006
      @Oomph6006 Рік тому

      @@UkuleleJayBBQ Still Tumbler is a Chinese copy of the German Horl.
      Made in China for bigger profit..

    • @einundsiebenziger5488
      @einundsiebenziger5488 10 місяців тому

      There are* two Chinese versions*, too.* Both* Chinese versions* have* six different grits*.

  • @drrjohn2020
    @drrjohn2020 11 місяців тому +1

    Can I send back my tumbler?

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  11 місяців тому

      Have no idea. I have no affiliation with Tumbler.

    • @WilHenDavis
      @WilHenDavis 9 місяців тому +1

      Read my reply above! I found Tumbler's customer-service to be v.good! Good luck!

  • @Stevedawhoop
    @Stevedawhoop 9 місяців тому +1

    They only ship to us and Canada 😢

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  9 місяців тому

      Bummer, sorry! Maybe a friend in US or Canada can receive it and forward it to you. My friend in El Salvador gets his purchases via a friend in New York so I know it’s possible.

    • @Stevedawhoop
      @Stevedawhoop 8 місяців тому +1

      @@UkuleleJayBBQ I just got it, tho did get taxed twice, almost the same price as Horl2 at the end XP

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  8 місяців тому

      @@Stevedawhoop the governments love to take our money!

  • @einundsiebenziger5488
    @einundsiebenziger5488 10 місяців тому +1

    You always show how something does not work on the Tumbler, then say how it works well on the Hone, but you never show how well it works on the Hone.

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  10 місяців тому +1

      Please see my 3 way shootout video on the Work Sharp, HONE and Tumbler rolling sharpeners. You’ll see it there. Thanks for watching!

  • @mikermj
    @mikermj Рік тому +1

    My tumbler not rolling any more don't know after a month

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  Рік тому +2

      I have heard this happening. The Tumbler is now obsolete for many reasons. Check out the HONE which just came out. I tossed my Tumbler.
      BEST HIGH END ROLLING KNIFE SHARPENER REVIEW. IS THE HONE THE NEW KING ROLLING KNIFE SHARPENER?
      ua-cam.com/video/fOE8BW1g4LA/v-deo.html
      The Tumbler Or Hone Rolling Sharpener - Which One Is Better?
      ua-cam.com/video/58-RSgMwf60/v-deo.html

    • @ICheat_ILie_ISteal
      @ICheat_ILie_ISteal Рік тому +1

      @@UkuleleJayBBQ don't tossed it... Open it up and show us what's inside.

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  Рік тому

      @@ICheat_ILie_ISteal that’s a great idea…need to do that!

  • @rushiwar6107
    @rushiwar6107 2 місяці тому +1

    Maybe look at the horl 2 it’s the German original all the other companies are knockoffs

    • @UkuleleJayBBQ
      @UkuleleJayBBQ  2 місяці тому

      @@rushiwar6107 sorry they are not the original rolling knife sharpener. You may want to watch my video so you can stop repeating what you hear others repeating incorrectly and learn the truth. A U.S. inventor is the original rolling knife sharpener inventor. The original “Rolling” sharpener was never invented by Germans, it was invented by An American DECADES before HORL.

    • @rushiwar6107
      @rushiwar6107 2 місяці тому +1

      @@UkuleleJayBBQ ahh ok thank you