Hi ... Greetings from India .. I regularly watch Black hole ... Thanks for creating such a great platform... Kudus for bringing good topics for discussion. This session's subject is universal and is not only restricted to Hazara. The lecturer was very objective towards the subject and had great skills in articulating the topic. Thanks to Dr. Hoodbhoy and his team for making this happen. 👍
I'm Hazara I miss my Baluchistan I miss my childhood memory Quetta due to terrorisms activity I left my beautiful city Quetta. untill I live in this world I will love my city Quetta.
Thanks The Black Hole for organising a talk on this important topic. As a Hazara, I appreciate all the effort that has been put in. I have thoroughly enjoyed the previous Black Hole talks. I must say however that on this occasion I found the talk difficult to listen to. Despite the best efforts of the host to keep the discussion on topic, the conversation was far too broad covering the general issues facing minorities in Pakistan (important as they are); the discussion sheds very little light on the specific plight of the Hazaras. No doubt the speaker is knowledgeable on global events, there are no mentions of specific events in the modern history of Hazaras. I also find the speaker's narrative that Hazara persecution is a result of Pakistani state's schemes to homogenise the society and suppress dissident voices a bit problematic. Although, it may well be the cause of current political strife in Pakistan, I don't see how it applies directly to Hazaras, since Hazaras are the most compliant and patriotic Pakistanis.
Very well said sir “children who go the madersas are the victims of the failure of the state because the state failed to provide modern education to them”…… what a tragedy 😢
Muslims ko Mogoles ne Abbasy govt as Islamic state khatam ki thy is le Pak n Muslim in kckhelaf hungay west kesay ho kyunkeh west ne e to Mogoles ko hire kia aur islam ko safafh e hasty se metanay ki koshesh ki aur phir West ne e apnay e logun maslan Turks se Islamic govt of muslim shru krai phir 1918 k baad yahodyun ko Israel bana k de dia aur turkey khatam ker dia to yeh sub is le hay k Islam muslims nei waqt k mutabeq talem aur mayiashat nhy rakhtay aur latest education n jobs hur citizen ko bela rung o nasal dain to west ki tarah koe masla na ho phir class status albata hoga jiss k pass jitna paisa utna high class mager is per islam paisa apny jaga lekan asal chez kirdar hay yehny brabry k mowaqay dena
Hazara will never see peace until we get rid of Pashtonism and Afghanism. I lost family members in Ghazni who were killed just beacuse they were hazaras. The Afghans took over thier land later. we had water wells which they wanted but we refused later they came with thier pashtun taliban cousins. funny thing is that person was ghani lover
Intelligent people still exit in Pakistan. But always biased against India. You are correct about hazara community. But donot see the progress muslim community has made in india.
Let's see how many European immigrants Pakistan integrates in it's society. This man is complaining about Denmark and Sweden, muslim immigrants have demarcated no go zones in those countries. Why can't you people sort your problems out on your own?
Ignored, undermined, oppresed an at times persecuted. But things are changing, though slowly. Civil society in Sindh ss well as in Pakistan is fighting back.
@@amjadnazeer4448 I hope u r right but I think it's to late. All non Muslims, who are still left in pakistan should leave for india, it is only solution for them in the long run. U never know when Muslims would turn on non Hindus.
I just say thanks for highlighting this issue ,I wish one day again I sit on tadas of Quetta with my pashton,Baluch ,Punjabi friends and laugh
Hi ... Greetings from India .. I regularly watch Black hole ... Thanks for creating such a great platform... Kudus for bringing good topics for discussion. This session's subject is universal and is not only restricted to Hazara. The lecturer was very objective towards the subject and had great skills in articulating the topic. Thanks to Dr. Hoodbhoy and his team for making this happen. 👍
I'm Hazara I miss my Baluchistan I miss my childhood memory Quetta due to terrorisms activity I left my beautiful city Quetta. untill I live in this world I will love my city Quetta.
Another excellent program ❤️
waoo what a lecture
Thanks The Black Hole for organising a talk on this important topic. As a Hazara, I appreciate all the effort that has been put in. I have thoroughly enjoyed the previous Black Hole talks. I must say however that on this occasion I found the talk difficult to listen to. Despite the best efforts of the host to keep the discussion on topic, the conversation was far too broad covering the general issues facing minorities in Pakistan (important as they are); the discussion sheds very little light on the specific plight of the Hazaras. No doubt the speaker is knowledgeable on global events, there are no mentions of specific events in the modern history of Hazaras. I also find the speaker's narrative that Hazara persecution is a result of Pakistani state's schemes to homogenise the society and suppress dissident voices a bit problematic. Although, it may well be the cause of current political strife in Pakistan, I don't see how it applies directly to Hazaras, since Hazaras are the most compliant and patriotic Pakistanis.
Thanks..
Desh ki progress ke liye ek stable government chahiye.
Very well said sir “children who go the madersas are the victims of the failure of the state because the state failed to provide modern education to them”…… what a tragedy 😢
True
Madarsa is just medium basic problem is kuran and Islam...
Muslims ko Mogoles ne Abbasy govt as Islamic state khatam ki thy is le Pak n Muslim in kckhelaf hungay west kesay ho kyunkeh west ne e to Mogoles ko hire kia aur islam ko safafh e hasty se metanay ki koshesh ki aur phir West ne e apnay e logun maslan Turks se Islamic govt of muslim shru krai phir 1918 k baad yahodyun ko Israel bana k de dia aur turkey khatam ker dia to yeh sub is le hay k Islam muslims nei waqt k mutabeq talem aur mayiashat nhy rakhtay aur latest education n jobs hur citizen ko bela rung o nasal dain to west ki tarah koe masla na ho phir class status albata hoga jiss k pass jitna paisa utna high class mager is per islam paisa apny jaga lekan asal chez kirdar hay yehny brabry k mowaqay dena
Hazara will never see peace until we get rid of Pashtonism and Afghanism. I lost family members in Ghazni who were killed just beacuse they were hazaras. The Afghans took over thier land later. we had water wells which they wanted but we refused later they came with thier pashtun taliban cousins. funny thing is that person was ghani lover
Hazara-Pashtun conflict has its origin in Afghanistan. There in Afghanistan thus conflict is much much longer than in Pakistan.
Stop atrocities on hazara shiate,bharat mata ki jai 🔺️🔺️🚩🚩🔴🔴🔱🔱🙏🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳
BJP policy is to continue a progressive government which will solve the future problem of India.
Will the recording available
It stays
Yes! I am watching on UA-cam 😊
🙏
Intelligent people still exit in Pakistan. But always biased against India. You are correct about hazara community. But donot see the progress muslim community has made in india.
Let's see how many European immigrants Pakistan integrates in it's society. This man is complaining about Denmark and Sweden, muslim immigrants have demarcated no go zones in those countries. Why can't you people sort your problems out on your own?
What about the conditions of Hindus(if any left) in pakistan?
Ignored, undermined, oppresed an at times persecuted. But things are changing, though slowly. Civil society in Sindh ss well as in Pakistan is fighting back.
@@amjadnazeer4448
I hope u r right but I think it's to late. All non Muslims, who are still left in pakistan should leave for india, it is only solution for them in the long run. U never know when Muslims would turn on non Hindus.
All Muslims in India should move to Pakistan Or face genocidal attacks as explained by the expert in chair.
plz in
Pakistanion ma kab aqal aa gi 😭 . Islam ko islamayat tak rakho. Or pakistan ko Pakistani bnn kr Chalao
Danmark and sweeden??? 😂😂😂😂
He is baised to india
Hazaras and Hindus will be finished.
Murderers have no job except killing innocents.
@@kousarabbas687 thats what is being done for last 75 years.