Covid-19 Masks Effect On Body Language with Communication Expert Mark Bowden

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 12 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 105

  • @SouthernLatitudesFL
    @SouthernLatitudesFL 4 роки тому +20

    It wasn't until this mask wearing time that I realize how much I was using lip reading to help me hear. My 2nd language is ASL. I wonder how my Deaf friends feel about the masks as they interact with the hearing. Last night, I saw them organizing a No Masks day. Now, it makes sense.

    • @jenniferbell4571
      @jenniferbell4571 4 роки тому +2

      Southern Latitudes I cannot process spoken words without seeing lips move. Oddly, though, I don’t have a problem processing what I hear in an audiobook. I understand exactly what you mean!

    • @christineh4782
      @christineh4782 4 роки тому +5

      Like Jennifer commented. I do the same. My first thought when masks went mandatory was what about the lip readers? I need to see moving lips to understand what I am hearing. Weird I know. Hopefully masks will not be mandatory much longer.

    • @SouthernLatitudesFL
      @SouthernLatitudesFL 4 роки тому +3

      @@christineh4782 I am seeing where Sept 15th is a No Masks Protest Day, if that interests you. Maybe there is light at the end of the tunnel.

    • @c.c.8902
      @c.c.8902 4 роки тому +4

      Southern Latitudes yep. There's light at the end if the tunnel. I don't wear masks. I'm seeing a few others slowly waking up and doing the same.
      I'm not deaf but I know what you mean about needing lip reading. It's difficult for me to comprehend what people are saying when they're wearing masks bc I can't see the moment of their lips and or facial expressions. Mask wearing is a con. It's a big lie. We're standing up for our rights. No masks!!!!!

    • @LadyLibertyBella
      @LadyLibertyBella 3 роки тому

      Well 7 months late but still in crazy mask world. I have MS and no hearing in one ear with difficulty in the other. Ive adapted over the years to read lips and sign as it occurred slowly over time. However I never realized how much I read lips and body language to communicate until the masks. Frankly it gets really frustrating bc I just can’t understand or hear what is being said most of the time. It’s gotten so upsetting at times I just give up. I’m a very personable and talkative person so it’s been really hard because I’ve basically stopped talking. I’ve noticed myself intentionally avoiding communicating in person. I just don’t want to try after almost a year of this its not worth the frustration and emotional turmoil that occurs when I do. I don’t think people realize how detrimental this is to our personal interactions & connections. Plus peoples body language is off because no one is comfortable. I just pray we will be free of the masks soon.

  • @pandora8478
    @pandora8478 4 роки тому +41

    It’s disconcerting to see someone in a mask. Dehumanising if that’s the right word?

    • @maximusrapturous7195
      @maximusrapturous7195 4 роки тому +5

      It is the right word

    • @christineh4782
      @christineh4782 4 роки тому +7

      In a while we will know why we are being told to be less human to one another. The violence younger generations have been trained to do is already showing.

    • @onlylimited2167
      @onlylimited2167 4 роки тому +3

      Glad someone else said it besides me! I almost start to internally hyperventilate just seeing people trying to have full conversations with them.

    • @fredeemoon6053
      @fredeemoon6053 4 роки тому +2

      Yes dehumanization....

    • @dsoule4902
      @dsoule4902 3 роки тому

      Shah rhrea. Subjugation

  • @carlagportilla9491
    @carlagportilla9491 4 роки тому +17

    I still freak out when I see masked people everywhere. It is like a dystopian film. As Mark says, we are hard-wired to read and recognize facial gestures and react accordingly. I have to accept that I have also been avoiding eye contact, I will make an effort to act differently. I love the idea of the photo badge, I will try it soon. I have always worked in hospitality so smiles have always been part of my normal life. Thanks for the vídeo, I will use as training material for my team.

  • @Amory319
    @Amory319 3 роки тому +8

    I'm genuinely surprised how far I had to scroll down before I came across a video discussing this topic. Something that weighs heavy on my heart all the time surrounding these masks. I'm afraid not a lot of people realize the damaging effect it's having on us physically + mentally

  • @grammamarth6681
    @grammamarth6681 3 роки тому +5

    Masking has stolen from us one of the most healing actions of humankind - smiles.
    Social distancing even more - handshakes and hugs.

    • @dsoule4902
      @dsoule4902 3 роки тому +2

      By design.

    • @porkfriedrice1530
      @porkfriedrice1530 3 роки тому

      “Handshakes, hugs
      You wanna see me outside, see me with pancakes and drugs.. “

  • @patriciajustice9795
    @patriciajustice9795 4 роки тому +7

    Makes me feel like I cant think clearly, almost physically off balance

  • @EerybodyIsAnnoying
    @EerybodyIsAnnoying 4 роки тому +19

    I tend to have uncontrolable fits of laughter at times and wearing a mask makes me feel less conscious about them happening 😅

    • @evanz2704
      @evanz2704 4 роки тому +1

      Haha, I like you! 🥳

  • @truth8287
    @truth8287 3 роки тому +7

    Better idea than the badges... not wearing a mask

  • @porkfriedrice1530
    @porkfriedrice1530 3 роки тому

    This is why I pull it down when trying to communicate if the other person is comfortable with it

  • @martianleader1
    @martianleader1 4 роки тому +10

    Why do I feel over heated when I wear a mask? At times I can hardly wear it.

  • @christineh4782
    @christineh4782 4 роки тому +1

    I finally learned what modern art is good for! Face framing. 🤣
    Thank you Mark! You have a unique ability to cheer people up just by watching you when you are 'on.' 😁👍

  • @kalayne6713
    @kalayne6713 4 роки тому +3

    Here in Australia, it has been fascinating to note the difference in how we are relating to each other. During and after the terror of the bushfires, just before covid, people were hugging each other, chatting and listening to strangers as well as family and friends, comparing war stories etc. Now, even a shopping trip is filled with fear and suspicion as we eye each other as 'threats' to our health. Few people are wearing masks, but the negativity is contagious even if Australia has managed to contain the virus fairly well. Sadly, a rush by our politicians to open up the economy too quickly, will probably undo a lot of the good isolating has done.

    • @JamesDeWeaver
      @JamesDeWeaver 4 роки тому +1

      I take it that you live in Melbourne?

    • @c.c.8902
      @c.c.8902 4 роки тому

      KA-- interesting comment. Human nature is weird.

  • @suziequeue7187
    @suziequeue7187 3 роки тому +1

    Great video Mark and much needed in today’s upside down world. Love the way you explain technical to simplified situations in everyday life. You ROCK❣️🌻 love the Behavioral Panel vids too 🤯

  • @bandhsilvers1
    @bandhsilvers1 3 роки тому +3

    I dont wear a mask never have and never will force me all you want mafia government

  • @bethmedina9200
    @bethmedina9200 4 роки тому +3

    I think i’m just going to slow blink at people & hope they like cats. 🐱😄

  • @BalancedBlackwood
    @BalancedBlackwood 2 роки тому +1

    I would love to hear your thoughts on how childrens brain maturation has been delayed due to masks.

  • @woesmevrou5673
    @woesmevrou5673 3 роки тому

    Great ideas and really interesting comments. Wearing a mask in public spaces is a legal requirement in South Africa and probably a key cost effective tool as Third wave hits and delay in vaccine rollout persists.
    Isolation often seems preferable: I hate the way my glasses fog up!
    But getting places and being with people is so crucial - walking two terriers even more so - so I mask up partly to avoid arrest or fine and partly because I can claim no medical condition that prohibits my doing my bit to reduce transmission.
    Has had some interesting results: made me aware of making more of an effort to engage at checkout counters or with strangers. Also made me much more sensitive to the eyes of other people! Curiously seems to have promoted connection and goodwill. Perhaps a greater sense of experiencing a shared if uncommon condition.
    Your videos are great! Happy to be considered a fan😎

  • @andyc9979
    @andyc9979 4 роки тому +7

    I've noticed something different when I wear one. I tighten up and feel uptight. I don't know why either. Idk if it's because I can't see as well and have to look down

    • @MarkBowden1
      @MarkBowden1  4 роки тому +7

      It certainly could be because you are constrained. Thanks for the great comment.

    • @sunnynotblind4158
      @sunnynotblind4158 4 роки тому +4

      I 100% understand that. I am so tense and stress filled when wearing a amsk. I also find i am making and holding eye contact longer. Maybe in an effort to have human connection that is normally a smile with a lil head nod. It is like I am saying I see you, hello!

    • @meganjarvis7970
      @meganjarvis7970 4 роки тому +2

      That’s understandable, it’s not normal for us to be wearing masks all the time- especially healthy people. They call this the new normal - yes this is new, but definitely not normal @ all. Stay well. :)

  • @dsoule4902
    @dsoule4902 3 роки тому +2

    All these months on, I do notice most people will deliberately make direct eye contact-- Searching for humanity

  • @jenniferbell4571
    @jenniferbell4571 4 роки тому +17

    As a woman with Aspergers and a mom of two teens who have Autism, I cannot hear someone unless I can see their mouth move. I suppose it ‘s a processing issue more than a literal hearing issue. I cannot wear a mask because: 1. I am an American - and as such I will not be compelled to do so; and 2. I have horrible sensory issues which precludes covering my nose and mouth. This mask nonsense has caused considerable trauma to the Autism community. Eye contact won’t help.

    • @carlagportilla9491
      @carlagportilla9491 4 роки тому

      I believe reason #2 is more reasonable than your #1 reason. Science is not nationality biased. Anyone can catch the virus, and these two experts give simple and common advice to make our lives easier.

    • @c.c.8902
      @c.c.8902 4 роки тому +5

      Jennifer-- excellent comment. I, too, am disturbed, physically, mentally, emotionally, and psychologically, by masks. I will not wear a mask! Plus, I agree, I'm American. I'm supposed to be free?!?!🇺🇸

    • @lweismann
      @lweismann 4 роки тому

      Preach sister!

    • @lweismann
      @lweismann 4 роки тому

      Carla G Portilla that was a reference to American unwillingness to bend the knee to perceived tyranny.

  • @rich0373
    @rich0373 3 роки тому

    This video made me smile alot thanks Mark 👍

  • @DMB56
    @DMB56 4 роки тому +2

    Mark - how do you think tele work at home is affecting us. We have been doing some work at home and not all great. Seems people are a little snerky and distrustful.

    • @MarkBowden1
      @MarkBowden1  4 роки тому +1

      Here's a series of videos to help with exactly this... ua-cam.com/video/vYwN2LFDeFA/v-deo.html

    • @MarkBowden1
      @MarkBowden1  4 роки тому +1

      Here's a series of videos to help with exactly this question... ua-cam.com/video/vYwN2LFDeFA/v-deo.html

    • @DMB56
      @DMB56 4 роки тому

      We don’t interact on camera. Audio only. It just seems like more distrust etc.

  • @vocalpro
    @vocalpro 4 роки тому +3

    That was great Mark wacha got chase ?

  • @leannemori9688
    @leannemori9688 4 роки тому

    Beautiful painting

  • @macraemorse
    @macraemorse 4 роки тому

    Great video Mark. I had been pondering this question myself. I was in Spain this summer in a big queue with every one in masks except one attractive lady with bright red lips. I realised that I was staring at her and looking around realised I was not the only one. I think there is another video to be made on this subject (the effect of masks on mammalian mating rituals) :) You seem to be spending a lot of time in Canada these days.

  • @vivismith8688
    @vivismith8688 3 роки тому

    It's done just wonders for me as a lip reader I can just ignore people. Not bother answering. Then I ended up having a heart attack by not being able to breathe.

  • @SevasTra1900
    @SevasTra1900 3 роки тому

    Well I've learned that a lot of people have a problem with adaptation. People freak out instead of being creative and thinking of something to overcome problems. I made my own masks with cute prints to liven up the dread. The masks weren't going to be around forever anyway.

  • @oceanjoker3544
    @oceanjoker3544 4 роки тому +2

    Guilty of the eye contact thing. 🖐 lol. Ppl look at me to acknowledge me but i don't, only bc of the pandemic.

  • @kmm_hkg4807
    @kmm_hkg4807 4 роки тому

    Thanks

  • @zovalentine7305
    @zovalentine7305 3 роки тому +2

    I have yet to wear the muzzle.

  • @evanz2704
    @evanz2704 4 роки тому

    Oddly enough, it doesn't bother me at all when people wear masks. I am hyper sensitive to every signal around me (ADHD), and I'm often overwhelmed by the sheer amount of people's non-verbal communication, as I tend to subconsciously be alert and keep track of it all. People wearing masks therefore puts me at ease, as it's less stressful for me. I like it when they wear personalised masks or themed masks. It's just an acessory to showcase some part of ypur personality, like glasses. No need to wear bog standard "Zombie Apocalypse" face masks. Just wear something that makes people smile! 😸

  • @lweismann
    @lweismann 4 роки тому

    Glad I’m an aspie. This has changed literally nothing for me.

  • @jennsalotti7642
    @jennsalotti7642 3 роки тому

    I wonder how the masking will change the mental state of our next generations. I know my neighbors 9 month panics and cries out when people outside of her family take off their masks.

  • @Youtuber-le9xx
    @Youtuber-le9xx 3 роки тому

    Masks + face shields have ruined my social skills at work, i guess i read, use, facial expressions more than I thought

  • @55937
    @55937 3 роки тому

    Hi, Mark, Kelly Saran here from the university of Michigan. This is excellent. I’m doing a presentation for healthcare providers and execs next fall on meeting with patients and families when there are adverse outcomes. We are meeting on zoom and with masks, of course. I’d like permission to use your clip. Can we chat? Ksaran@med.umich.edu. Btw, I love you on the behavior panel!

  • @annaal7480
    @annaal7480 4 роки тому +2

    I like wearing mask. I feel that people are braver to look at each other now - I live in Germany where people don’t look at each other normally. With masks on people look at me and others more, which to me feels nice. We are paying attention to each other more and it is nice to realise that after all humans are not as withdrawn as I thought.

    • @c.c.8902
      @c.c.8902 4 роки тому +2

      In America, people are much more withdrawn and weary of their neighbors when wearing masks. It's like everyone's a bank robber or something on the psyche.

    • @3leggedsharkkickssurferinballs
      @3leggedsharkkickssurferinballs 4 роки тому +1

      @@c.c.8902 Yeah it's the same here in Aus- especially where I live, where masks have been made compulsory ( the entire state, even the rural areas with ridiculously low population :/ ). I cannot wait for it to all be over.

    • @3leggedsharkkickssurferinballs
      @3leggedsharkkickssurferinballs 4 роки тому +2

      So interesting to see how differently such things play out from country to country; culture to culture.

    • @youcrazycat1
      @youcrazycat1 4 роки тому

      @@c.c.8902 disagree. I dont mind it at all. I'm in a big city. Lots of people dont smoke anyway

    • @c.c.8902
      @c.c.8902 4 роки тому +1

      sausages and plants and goldfish I really like hearing about other cultures too! Cheers to our Aussie neighbors! We have a lot in common. We both escaped the Brits- hahahahaha

  • @Comedy-Cult
    @Comedy-Cult 3 роки тому

    3:58 that’s a pitiful “workaround” - how about taking these masks off

  • @awreckingball
    @awreckingball 4 роки тому +2

    Why don't Muslim women wear a badge with a Duchenne smile on it?

  • @nestorguillen836
    @nestorguillen836 4 роки тому

    odio esa mascaras ya que no me permiten ver el rostro completo de la persona que esta en frente

  • @liomio4980
    @liomio4980 4 роки тому

    If you are an expert in human behavior, I am an expert in the university of the street more than 40 years, and I want you to remember this very well. The mask will be used in this country until the banks are open and the robberies begin because this is the only country on the planet where humans behave like what is an irrational animal...

    • @freyayumang
      @freyayumang 4 роки тому

      You are deranged

    • @liomio4980
      @liomio4980 4 роки тому

      @@freyayumang Maybe it's true but I live with my feet on the ground, people with brains in the ass are the ones who believe that everything is rosy.

  • @nickrich56
    @nickrich56 4 роки тому +2

    Some people don't care to wear a face covering. They should care. SARS-CoV-2 hasn't ended quite yet. Round two could be brutal. When in close proximity to people wear a face covering please and thanks 😷👍

    • @dianedeck9790
      @dianedeck9790 4 роки тому +3

      How about stay 6 ft apart then you dont have to wear a mask

    • @nickrich56
      @nickrich56 4 роки тому

      @@dianedeck9790 that's cool too Diane but when meeting strangers 6ft isn't as reassuring as a face covering ... sorry ...😷👍

    • @c.c.8902
      @c.c.8902 4 роки тому +6

      Nick-- please understand that us asthmatics (and many other issues) can't wear a mask-- we'd get very, very ill. And look at the deep dive research. Masking isn't about health; it's about CONTROL.

    • @exoticcar5482
      @exoticcar5482 2 роки тому

      The problem with your comment is it implies there will be an ending to this, but no, SARS-COV-2 is now with us permanently

    • @nickrich56
      @nickrich56 2 роки тому

      @@exoticcar5482 a year ago those were the recommended guidelines. Today is now and the science has evolved to allow comments like yours to have merit. Where were you and what was on your mind in early 2021?