When I first played this game, I hated Mary with a passion because she killed Garry. I ended up ignoring her completely. But then my friend and I started making an Ib movie and I got the role of Mary. After trying to act like her and thinking what she would be thinking, I began to feel sorry for her. She's actually a very sad character.
Hey! I wanted to let you know I used your lyrics to sing my version here 「Music Box // Orchestra」 Puppet ( Mary's Theme from Ib )【Jayn】 Thank you for writing such awesome lyrics, this is one of my favorite RPG horror covers ever. * u *
Just to clear a few things up: 1. Mary is comparing Garry to her father solely because they're both "adults" in her eyes. 2. The reason why she tries to leave Garry in the "house" is because that's the only way to leave the "house". In the game, it's explain that to leave, (spoilers I guess) she needs to take someone else's place. Ib was needed because she would need someone to stay with, and Ib was the only child in the "house" at the time, as shown in one of the endings.
I played it a long time ago, but wasn't it like heavily implied that Garry is the painter whose works are displayed there? In that case he'd literally be her father
31 people were blinded by their tears and meant to click the like button but they accidentally hit the dislike button and then they died in despair once they realized what they did was wrong.
Mary is a lonely girl... Anyone can become like Mary... Provided they suffer the same experiences that forces one to desperate measures. Mary is forced to resort to such because of that world, and of desperation. A human will forcibly do anything, no matter how cruel, to achieve that ending. Though gruesome, this is, in the truest sense, proof of Mary's humanity. Her naivety, cruelty, childishness, and even more, the sadness and loneliness of her very self... depicts a human soul. A human is defined not because he or she is human, but rather by one's personality.
That's pretty deep. But still do remember that Mary is not and cannot be a real person, she is merely a painting. Ib and Garry had no choice but to burn her or else she would have killed them. She is insane and just like the other animate creations. Maybe if she haven't snapped she would have lived.
I remember when I burned Mary, and I said ''HAHA!! BURN, YOU IDIOT!!'' Now, I'm like ''WHY THE HECK DID I DO THAT D':" I did the ending where she gets to stay with Garry and Ib, ''FOREVEEEERRR..''
Iwan says I suppose the game-maker wasn't a sadist to force the players to watch the whole process of burning. Plus, "the sea of fire" actually means THE FIRE EVERYWHERE. A LOT OF FIRE. Idk what you wanted to prove with your comment.
MrSoundlessVoice I never wanted to prove anything. I just want to share my opinion. o.O Anyway, she spontaneously and violently combusted into ashes. Poor Mary, indeed. She doesn't deserve that.
One: You have an amazing voice. It fits the song so perfectly in a way that makes the song hauntingly beautiful. Two: do you know the notes to the song? I would love to play this for my school talent show?
Welcome to my world that's painted with sadness 歡迎來到某幅悲傷的畫的世界 There's no light of sun There you can't hear any sound at all 這裡沒有陽光 聽不見所有的聲音 Here I'm waiting silently for you, father 我在這默默的等你 爸爸 Why you were so cruel to left poor Mary alone?你為什麼這麼殘忍的留mary一人? lalala...(間奏) Please take me away, I desperately promise to be a good girl, to be worthy of your love 請帶我走 我拼命承諾我會成為一個值得你愛的好女孩 I don't need the paint books, the dolls and the dresses, 我不需要圖畫書 娃娃和洋裝 Just tell me, why you've left your pictures and gone? 只要告訴我為何你留下你的畫離去 lalala... (間奏) Who are you, stranger with a red rose in your hand 妳是誰?手中握著紅玫瑰的奇怪之人 I liked you from the first sight, I wanna be your friend, Let's play 從第一眼看見就喜歡上妳 我想成為妳的朋友 我們來玩吧! I've never asked for this place that's called my home, 我從不說這地方就是我的家 But hope, you will be staying with me until the end 希望妳能留下來陪我到最後 lalala... (間奏) Please, don't be scared of me I'm a good girl 拜託妳別怕我 我是個好女孩 I just want to be with you to forget my sorrow 我只是想和妳一起就能忘了我的悲哀 I'm tired of being the puppet of this world 我已經厭倦了當這世界的人偶 Oh, tell me, why do you want to go with this man? 告訴我 為何妳想和那個男人走? lalala... (間奏) Is he your true knight in the shining armor? 他是妳穿著閃亮盔甲的騎士? Who'll sacrifice himself just for your sake with no fear But then 他沒有恐懼的為了妳犧牲自己 但是 Why he resembles the one, who created This gallery and picture, that gave me a birth? 為什麼他像是一個人創造了這些作品給了我出生 lalala... (間奏) MY TEARS ARE FALLING, WHY IT'S SO PAINFUL? 為什麼我的眼淚正痛苦的落下? I DID NOTHING WRONG, SO WHY DO YOU HATE ME SO MUCH? 我並沒有做錯什麼 為什麼妳這麼恨我? THIS BURNING CANVAS BECAME YOUR CRUEL ANSWER 這燃燒的畫布正是妳殘酷的答案 AND NOW FLAMES UNSPARINGLY KISS ME GOODNIGHT. 現在火焰正毫無保留的侵蝕著我 lalala... (間奏) Welcome to her world that's lying in ashes... 歡迎來到躺在灰燼中的她的世界 There's a sea of fire, There is no way to run at all... 那有一片火海 沒有任何地方可逃 She only wanted to be with her father... 她只是想要和她父親一起 But little Mary is melting in her abyss alone... 但是小mary融化在她的孤單深淵中 "I'm coming, father..." 我來了 爸爸……
I've always liked Mary, I never understood why people hate her so much, she just wants people to talk to so she is seriously the most hated character of everyone I know who knows this game, I'm just the loner that loves her.
Perhaps she is just misunderstood. I hated her at first but after I played the game a few times I began to love her. It's a shame that she's a bit...strange.
Tye-Dye Lizard Who knows? Now that I think about it, Mary kind of reminds me of myself...minus the who psycho thing. Maybe one of these days Mary will find somebody to end her loneliness. Sorry if I have offended you or anything.
Nhi Huynh You didn't offend me ^w^ She kind of reminds me of Angelica in the Rugrats Theory, not the show. She didn't know how to handle real people since 'fake' things always listened to her and when the 'real' things didn't, she became violent .-.
The whole point of the game is that " all you need is a friend to guide your way through fear and lost " I think garry is almost a father to Ib. Ib was so scared and lost and i can tell as she is a 9 year old. Mary just wanted a friend because she was trapped so long, Mary didnt know that she couldnt escape, even when she took places with someone from outside. She likes all her friends coming to live with her, but she wanted to escape herself. Garry would even give up his rose for getting I'bs back. They were together untill the end. Garry, I could tell would be a good father. I know its not this kind of love, but they have a friendship/father love.
I find it interesting how most people tend to hate Mary, but if you look in her room *where she kept her picture frame* she just wanted to make friends, and get out... Not matter what, only 2 people at max can get out of that the Fabricated World together~
I'm so alike her but her pain must be so much. I myself have been locked into my house for as long as 8 years if I can remember, not knowing true light of nature and people's hearts. She, being locked into her own dimension, have finally met with genuine souls which she soon tries to befriend and they only ended up hating her, forgetting her existence, destroying her world, introducing to her greater loneliness. IMAGINE HOW MUCH PAIN SHE FELT JUST MEETING HER FIRST FRIENDS THAT JUST WANNA GET AWAY FROM HER AND SHE DOESN'T EVEN KNOW WHY!!!!!!
Lifestorytime! My turn!!! I were sitting on a bench at the school PE. Then the teacher told me, You! Go play the game! I told him that my leg hurt, even if it didnt. And he allowed me to sit there. Liek if u cri evritiem, bettr than phoenixnoobs stry..
I like your accent - it sounds exactly like how I imagined Mary would sound. The lyrics are also really touching. As for Mary, I never really liked her, but I feel sorry for her and her world of death and pain. She will never be forgiven for what's she done, but she deserves at a least bit of pity. I prefer Ib as my favorite character, though.
She is considered the "bad" guy in the game, but really, she just wanted to be loved and didn't want to be alone anymore. She's a lot like Ellen in that aspect (Witch's House). Ellen had a more... drastic.... way of attaining her goal, but really, she didn't want to be all by herself and unloved anymore. So yes, she is, but she had a reason for doing what she did.
if Garry really was Guertena's descendant, as implied in this song, then Guertena was more messed up than I thought. He basically traded his real kid for the child he painted. With the whole exchange thing outlined in one of the books, as well as the fact that Garry had the impossible blue rose while Mary had perfectly normal yellow rose, he rejected reality and substituted it with his own. the titular character Ib is basically just a bystander in this twisted ritual.
Just imagine... Being created and being stuck in a place that has only fellow paintings and no one new to see, nothing ever changing, never aging... I would be insane like Mary was considered to be if I'd gone through that. I still have to say that she kind of needed to be killed in the story so that she wouldn't have to go on for an eternity longing to meet her father who would never come back.
Poor Mary... :( I know that she can't go out (even if there is an ending where she leave..), she is a painting and she must stay there but imagine an ending where Garry & Ib don't burn her but just tell her they like her. She vanished and she go back in her canvas. And after leaving the guertena's World, Garry & Ib come back to the Gallery to see Mary, she would be so happy (and she deserves it) ! That would be a real Good Ending. Thank you for the video, that's amazing ! You are amazing :)
First time I heard this song was when you uploaded it. It has been a few years if I recall I have your singing version in my phone and still can't stop listening. You did an amazing job.
I was introduced to Ib by my ex. When I look back, he wasn't that different from Mary. Y'all are probably thinking "Aww, he felt trapped and need a way to escape from it, finding part of that escape in his partner" well there's that, but also manipulation and the violent stabby impulse when his true self slipped out so :)
MY FEELS! Mary is my favorite character from Ib, so to see her portrayed as something other than a one-dimensional villain makes me feel so mushy inside... and your voice! The music! Everything is so beautiful. I think I'm crying now.
Mary's my least favourite character of the trio, but I can certainly agree she's more than just a generic villain. I wish they could have all gotten out.
Adding to this, it also helps in explaining why Garry was sucked into the painting too. I mean Ib probably because Mary wanted a friend, but why Gary? It's not like it sucked in people at random, seemingly, or just everyone. So why them? Maybe it's like they were chosen moreso than otherwise. And your great-great grandson theory is good too adding, just only a bit in the song who knows otherwise but, it said "why he RESEMBLES" so it's not like they look exactly the same, just similar.
Poor Mary. I'd have to agree with a lot of people with the fact that Mary is so misunderstood. Sure she wasn't the best moral wise( I mean she does try to kill Gary by plucking all of the petals of his flower in alternate endings of the game. Also she does act a little crazy when we find out who/what she really is), but she just wants to live in the real world because it's boring( and a bit scary to most of us) in the art world. She also wants to be in the real world with Ib because she sees her as a friend she really wants to be with. As well as to be with her father. But in the true ending she gets *burned alive*, left to burn into ashes all alone. :'( I believe the reason she tries to go to the real world with Ib( and leave Gary behind) is because in order for her to leave the art world and go into the real world, someone *has* to be left behind( plus she doesn't know this, but she also needs to be with someone from the real world in order to actually go there) I'll admit that this is kinda sad, but I didn't write the game's story and how everything in that world works. I just wish that there was a way for everyone to get a happy ending. Including Mary. :'(
It's not even about the dates (they are kinda weird anyway) it's more about knowing something about art. It was said that Guertena started creating abstract art before it was popular (what a hipster BTW :P), and abstractionism emerged in the twenties or even earlier. He would be Garry's or Ib's great-grandfather.
Even if Mary was the one turning out to be the bad guy in the trio, she was my favorite, even if she was evil, all she just wanted was friends and to see what the outside world was like, when you get the ending with Mary leaving the world and into the "Real World" she cannot escape, for she is a painting, and paintings do not belong in the real world with people.
i am listening to this for months and didnt get bored of it yet. Your work is amazing and so is your voice. i liked better with the crying tone at the end. Thank you very much for this masterpiece. my fav theory is that garry is guertena son(similar hair color) and he was originaly locked up by his father in the painting world when he was a kid. the artist draw mary so she keep company with garry instead of letting him out.i think garry is the one who created the blu doll for mary or something(notice the doll love blu and always want to play with garry) when Guertena died garry was able to leave and he lost his memory to come back years later when rich poeple collected all the artist works and setup the Gallery. mary herself disliked him and didnt act on it so they dont know she is a painting but instead asking IB about him later.She warned IB about some of the bad ideas like destroying the manniqan head, she cared about her. she didnt care when he was traped in the doll room losing his memory after reading a book about her. but instead she freaks out when he remembered later. i know its messy every where but i like to believe it that way
The fact that you could only choose to save one just made the game so great in my opinion... Bring the very kind man back to the world where he came from, or bring the girl who never got to live into a new life.
Mary has got to be my favorite character from the game because of the fact that, in my opinion, she's a deeper character than the others. She only wanted love and everyone hates her because she tried to be a good girl....
Mary is a good girl. The reason why she acted like that is because of being alone for so long. Like a princess surrounded by obedient dolls in her castle. Her hatred, her loneliness, and her smile and laugh is more than enough proof of her as a human in my opinion. Think, if you were put in her place, you know your father and you've been left all alone for soooo long, what would you do in her place? I would do the same.
Actually....she tried to take Ib's rose away so SHE ALONE can go to the real world...that's why she asked Mary whether she would rather go back to the gallery with her or Garry. (people who don't know the story fully should shut up...) Nice song though!
I feel so sorry for Mary. I don't get how anyone could truly hate her. She is a little girl who has been a little girl for many, many years stuck in that crazy world. All she wants is to be a real girl... A bit like Pinocchio, I suppose.
Lets do this Vocaloid wise, I thought it would be cool. Mary is Rin Kaito is Gary Meiko is Ib The painter aka the father is Len Okay lets pretend they are not in a gallery that's evil and stuff, lets go back to Daughter of Evil and pretend that Rin and Len was born born again in a different time period like this one. Rin and Len were noble to each other, and Len was her brother however Len dies and Rin becomes depressed and made her own little wonderland maze in the basement of the mansion they live in. And her family becomes really cruel to her, so she invites people down in her wonderland and Meiko and Kaito were there to tour the mansion but Meiko and Kaito doesn't meet until they are in the maze. Like the gallery, there are monsters, and traps so Kaito is attacked by one of the monsters, and he was going to die without any medical attention so Meiko finds things to heal Kaito. And there, Meiko and Kaito meet. Afterwards, they meet Rin and she starts to dislike Kaito a little because she thinks she know him before. Even though the Daughter of Evil Rin was sorry for what she has done, a little part of her might have been in love with Kaito. So, lets say Mary Rin gets a voice from Daughter of Evil Rin that Kaito is the person who rejected her proposal and now Mary Rin wants Meiko out of the picture so she can live happily ever after with Kaito. (Mary wants to leave the gallery, and live happily ever after so that's why I put Rin wants to be with Kaito)
I really like Mary. I feels sorry for that they burned her painting. Ok, she is a bit crazy, but she is definitely my favorite character in the game. I wish that all of them could have survived...
Who else wouldn't be crazy with no one to talk to for many years.. no sunlight. no sound, no nothing, just a bunch of lifeless dolls, paintings and statues and left by her creator, makes u feel left out and unwanted.. Crazy or not I kinda understand Mary's loneliness. .__.
It’s been a wile since I saw IB (I watched a complete game play with the true (?) ending where IB and Gary reunite) and I really like Mary, she was a very good antagonist, yet she was so lonely and sad, I was literally so sad when she died in the route I saw, and never have I even liked an antagonist like her, IB is such a good game aaaa-
This is beautiful. :3 And I agree, Mary is sorely underestimated. I don't know why so many people hate her, she's my favorite character. Probably because I can relate to her so much.
Poor Mary, so much people hate her while I, personally, can connect with her. To be trapped in such an insane world without a friend, I would kill to get out too....
Что-то нет тут совсем русских комментариев... ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) Я вообще случайно щас наткнулась на этот кавер, просто бродила по миру Ютуба. Очень понравилось, голос шикарен как всегда, правда я не узнала его сначала.)0 Так что спасибо за кавер, это полетит в плейлист .D
Actully, she perfectly know why they are there and that she have to kill on of them to get out, she didn't care if they where real or not, and it looked like she liked the place, and the place liked her. AND in one of the new endings you can see that she is kind of telling the galleria what to do ( Well, untill she is out ) but i still like the song alot :D /Plz no hate ^^
@@MrSoundlessVoice if you sang it, then your voice is extremely beautiful! ❤️, sorry if you din't understand what i said i don't really good at English speaking
The video game "Ib" deserves an anime.
***** I already seen it. But iI want the one thats like the other.
TRUUEE
Or manga
That’s so true 💕 I would love to see Ib adapted into an anime.
@William King its called ib
When I first played this game, I hated Mary with a passion because she killed Garry. I ended up ignoring her completely. But then my friend and I started making an Ib movie and I got the role of Mary. After trying to act like her and thinking what she would be thinking, I began to feel sorry for her. She's actually a very sad character.
whats the game's title?
@@enaisberrios7482 The game is called “Ib”. I recommend you play it, or at least watch a let’s play on UA-cam of it!
Yeah..
she is a very tragic character indeed.
Hey! I wanted to let you know I used your lyrics to sing my version here 「Music Box // Orchestra」 Puppet ( Mary's Theme from Ib )【Jayn】 Thank you for writing such awesome lyrics, this is one of my favorite RPG horror covers ever. * u *
thanks a lot! you've done it great) And thanks a lot for your arrangement of Friend from Majo no Ie, I've used it for my lyrics of it)
Ok
:]
Yoooo
Just to clear a few things up:
1. Mary is comparing Garry to her father solely because they're both "adults" in her eyes.
2. The reason why she tries to leave Garry in the "house" is because that's the only way to leave the "house". In the game, it's explain that to leave, (spoilers I guess) she needs to take someone else's place. Ib was needed because she would need someone to stay with, and Ib was the only child in the "house" at the time, as shown in one of the endings.
I played it a long time ago, but wasn't it like heavily implied that Garry is the painter whose works are displayed there? In that case he'd literally be her father
@@bipbapboop1140 where was it implied?
My tears flow itself.
I.....I understand the loneliness of Mary.
I do too~ It
Being alone for God knows how long is hard to cope up with (if thats me)
haha loser
31 people were blinded by their tears and meant to click the like button but they accidentally hit the dislike button and then they died in despair once they realized what they did was wrong.
Quite a logical explanation, if I do say so myself.
in 2018 it’s 72 heartless people
Make that 80. :0
2019 there are 87 heartless people!!!!
91!oh the humanity!
Mary is a lonely girl... Anyone can become like Mary... Provided they suffer the same experiences that forces one to desperate measures. Mary is forced to resort to such because of that world, and of desperation. A human will forcibly do anything, no matter how cruel, to achieve that ending. Though gruesome, this is, in the truest sense, proof of Mary's humanity. Her naivety, cruelty, childishness, and even more, the sadness and loneliness of her very self... depicts a human soul. A human is defined not because he or she is human, but rather by one's personality.
That's pretty deep. But still do remember that Mary is not and cannot be a real person, she is merely a painting. Ib and Garry had no choice but to burn her or else she would have killed them. She is insane and just like the other animate creations. Maybe if she haven't snapped she would have lived.
Thank Satan I'm not human...she deserved to die and I'm glad she dead.
I remember when I burned Mary, and I said ''HAHA!! BURN, YOU IDIOT!!''
Now, I'm like ''WHY THE HECK DID I DO THAT D':"
I did the ending where she gets to stay with Garry and Ib, ''FOREVEEEERRR..''
I'm halfway in between saying, "Awww, so cute!" and saying, "Holy crap that's creepy..."
How about "Aww, so creepy!"
(don't mind me I just woke up)
Jill Hustead lol
to me it shows how she saw this place and shows u how she has slowly going crazy. beautiful. her sad side
Actually, there was no "sea of fire" surrounding Mary. She evaporated almost instantly.
Poor Mary. I like her.
Iwan says Try to burn a big picture and look at it, please.
Plus, I hope you know what metaphore is.
Thanks.
MrSoundlessVoice I'm talking about the in-game reality :/
Iwan says I suppose the game-maker wasn't a sadist to force the players to watch the whole process of burning.
Plus, "the sea of fire" actually means THE FIRE EVERYWHERE. A LOT OF FIRE. Idk what you wanted to prove with your comment.
MrSoundlessVoice I never wanted to prove anything. I just want to share my opinion. o.O
Anyway, she spontaneously and violently combusted into ashes. Poor Mary, indeed. She doesn't deserve that.
Iwan says yes she did.
One: You have an amazing voice. It fits the song so perfectly in a way that makes the song hauntingly beautiful. Two: do you know the notes to the song? I would love to play this for my school talent show?
+Hatsune Miku lol I'm after the same thing as you, but for a different reason.
Welcome to my world that's painted with sadness 歡迎來到某幅悲傷的畫的世界
There's no light of sun There you can't hear any sound at all
這裡沒有陽光 聽不見所有的聲音
Here I'm waiting silently for you, father 我在這默默的等你 爸爸
Why you were so cruel to left poor Mary alone?你為什麼這麼殘忍的留mary一人?
lalala...(間奏)
Please take me away, I desperately promise to be a good girl, to be worthy of your love
請帶我走 我拼命承諾我會成為一個值得你愛的好女孩
I don't need the paint books, the dolls and the dresses, 我不需要圖畫書 娃娃和洋裝
Just tell me, why you've left your pictures and gone?
只要告訴我為何你留下你的畫離去
lalala... (間奏)
Who are you, stranger with a red rose in your hand
妳是誰?手中握著紅玫瑰的奇怪之人
I liked you from the first sight, I wanna be your friend, Let's play
從第一眼看見就喜歡上妳 我想成為妳的朋友 我們來玩吧!
I've never asked for this place that's called my home, 我從不說這地方就是我的家
But hope, you will be staying with me until the end 希望妳能留下來陪我到最後
lalala... (間奏)
Please, don't be scared of me I'm a good girl 拜託妳別怕我 我是個好女孩
I just want to be with you to forget my sorrow 我只是想和妳一起就能忘了我的悲哀
I'm tired of being the puppet of this world 我已經厭倦了當這世界的人偶
Oh, tell me, why do you want to go with this man?
告訴我 為何妳想和那個男人走?
lalala... (間奏)
Is he your true knight in the shining armor?
他是妳穿著閃亮盔甲的騎士?
Who'll sacrifice himself just for your sake with no fear But then
他沒有恐懼的為了妳犧牲自己 但是
Why he resembles the one, who created This gallery and picture, that gave me a birth?
為什麼他像是一個人創造了這些作品給了我出生
lalala... (間奏)
MY TEARS ARE FALLING, WHY IT'S SO PAINFUL?
為什麼我的眼淚正痛苦的落下?
I DID NOTHING WRONG, SO WHY DO YOU HATE ME SO MUCH?
我並沒有做錯什麼 為什麼妳這麼恨我?
THIS BURNING CANVAS BECAME YOUR CRUEL ANSWER
這燃燒的畫布正是妳殘酷的答案
AND NOW FLAMES UNSPARINGLY KISS ME GOODNIGHT.
現在火焰正毫無保留的侵蝕著我
lalala... (間奏)
Welcome to her world that's lying in ashes... 歡迎來到躺在灰燼中的她的世界
There's a sea of fire, There is no way to run at all... 那有一片火海 沒有任何地方可逃
She only wanted to be with her father... 她只是想要和她父親一起
But little Mary is melting in her abyss alone... 但是小mary融化在她的孤單深淵中
"I'm coming, father..." 我來了 爸爸……
I've always liked Mary, I never understood why people hate her so much, she just wants people to talk to so she is seriously the most hated character of everyone I know who knows this game, I'm just the loner that loves her.
Perhaps she is just misunderstood. I hated her at first but after I played the game a few times I began to love her. It's a shame that she's a bit...strange.
Nhi Huynh She's not strange she's lonely...! D:
Why does no one love Mary from the beginning....? ;-;
Tye-Dye Lizard Who knows? Now that I think about it, Mary kind of reminds me of myself...minus the who psycho thing. Maybe one of these days Mary will find somebody to end her loneliness.
Sorry if I have offended you or anything.
Nhi Huynh You didn't offend me ^w^
She kind of reminds me of Angelica in the Rugrats Theory, not the show. She didn't know how to handle real people since 'fake' things always listened to her and when the 'real' things didn't, she became violent .-.
Tye-Dye Lizard You have a point.
I truely never liked Mary, but i do feel bad for her.
......
Mary (ib) yay it's mary!! can I be your friend? I promise to be nice!!
Alexa King Of course you can be my friend! *hugs*
Yay!! *hugs back* I only have a couple friends and they are all on the internet.
*smiles* Well, you just got another one friend. Do you like dollys?
The whole point of the game is that " all you need is a friend to guide your way through fear and lost " I think garry is almost a father to Ib. Ib was so scared and lost and i can tell as she is a 9 year old. Mary just wanted a friend because she was trapped so long, Mary didnt know that she couldnt escape, even when she took places with someone from outside. She likes all her friends coming to live with her, but she wanted to escape herself. Garry would even give up his rose for getting I'bs back. They were together untill the end. Garry, I could tell would be a good father. I know its not this kind of love, but they have a friendship/father love.
I find it interesting how most people tend to hate Mary, but if you look in her room *where she kept her picture frame* she just wanted to make friends, and get out...
Not matter what, only 2 people at max can get out of that the Fabricated World together~
♩♫♪"Here I'm waiting silently for you, Father. Why you were so cruel to left poor Mary alone?"♩♫♪ ♩♫♪ ♩♫♪ ♩♫♪ ♩♫♪ ♩♫♪ ♩♫♪
I'm so alike her but her pain must be so much. I myself have been locked into my house for as long as 8 years if I can remember, not knowing true light of nature and people's hearts. She, being locked into her own dimension, have finally met with genuine souls which she soon tries to befriend and they only ended up hating her, forgetting her existence, destroying her world, introducing to her greater loneliness. IMAGINE HOW MUCH PAIN SHE FELT JUST MEETING HER FIRST FRIENDS THAT JUST WANNA GET AWAY FROM HER AND SHE DOESN'T EVEN KNOW WHY!!!!!!
Lifestorytime! My turn!!! I were sitting on a bench at the school PE. Then the teacher told me, You! Go play the game! I told him that my leg hurt, even if it didnt. And he allowed me to sit there. Liek if u cri evritiem, bettr than phoenixnoobs stry..
wow this really fits with mary's new ending 'a painting's demise' like holY CRAP YOU BASICALLY PREDICTED IT ;O; perfection
I like your accent - it sounds exactly like how I imagined Mary would sound. The lyrics are also really touching.
As for Mary, I never really liked her, but I feel sorry for her and her world of death and pain. She will never be forgiven for what's she done, but she deserves at a least bit of pity. I prefer Ib as my favorite character, though.
She is considered the "bad" guy in the game, but really, she just wanted to be loved and didn't want to be alone anymore. She's a lot like Ellen in that aspect (Witch's House). Ellen had a more... drastic.... way of attaining her goal, but really, she didn't want to be all by herself and unloved anymore. So yes, she is, but she had a reason for doing what she did.
if Garry really was Guertena's descendant, as implied in this song, then Guertena was more messed up than I thought. He basically traded his real kid for the child he painted. With the whole exchange thing outlined in one of the books, as well as the fact that Garry had the impossible blue rose while Mary had perfectly normal yellow rose, he rejected reality and substituted it with his own. the titular character Ib is basically just a bystander in this twisted ritual.
Just imagine... Being created and being stuck in a place that has only fellow paintings and no one new to see, nothing ever changing, never aging... I would be insane like Mary was considered to be if I'd gone through that.
I still have to say that she kind of needed to be killed in the story so that she wouldn't have to go on for an eternity longing to meet her father who would never come back.
Me: *sings the song in an art gallery*
People: *stare at me and slowly back away from me*
xD
Yep :/ i did that really they where like,, she is scary...
Wow. Did they ran?
No, They where just looking at me like im a crazy bitch XD
xDD
Poor Mary... :( I know that she can't go out (even if there is an ending where she leave..), she is a painting and she must stay there but imagine an ending where Garry & Ib don't burn her but just tell her they like her. She vanished and she go back in her canvas. And after leaving the guertena's World, Garry & Ib come back to the Gallery to see Mary, she would be so happy (and she deserves it) ! That would be a real Good Ending.
Thank you for the video, that's amazing ! You are amazing :)
First time I heard this song was when you uploaded it. It has been a few years if I recall
I have your singing version in my phone and still can't stop listening. You did an amazing job.
It's hauntingly beautiful...
My favorite ending in ib is Sacrifice & Promise of Reunion , :3 their beautiful
Hey that's my favorite to!
cool =w= brofist ? :3
OMG HI! I WILL GIVE YOU A BROFIST TOO!
c: okay , let's brofist =w=
*brofist*
I just had to reply to your comment because i saw "brofist" and went into total awesome overload.
I was introduced to Ib by my ex. When I look back, he wasn't that different from Mary.
Y'all are probably thinking "Aww, he felt trapped and need a way to escape from it, finding part of that escape in his partner" well there's that, but also manipulation and the violent stabby impulse when his true self slipped out so :)
Hey ! I'm glad to hear Mary's real voice ! ;)
It's so beautiful that I was sure it was her voice !
MY FEELS!
Mary is my favorite character from Ib, so to see her portrayed as something other than a one-dimensional villain makes me feel so mushy inside... and your voice! The music! Everything is so beautiful. I think I'm crying now.
Mary's my least favourite character of the trio, but I can certainly agree she's more than just a generic villain. I wish they could have all gotten out.
a sacrifice for freedom... this made the story amazing... and without Mary, the story is nonsense...
Adding to this, it also helps in explaining why Garry was sucked into the painting too. I mean Ib probably because Mary wanted a friend, but why Gary? It's not like it sucked in people at random, seemingly, or just everyone.
So why them? Maybe it's like they were chosen moreso than otherwise.
And your great-great grandson theory is good too adding, just only a bit in the song who knows otherwise but, it said "why he RESEMBLES" so it's not like they look exactly the same, just similar.
I'll be damned I finally found the original.
Your painting was destroyed, but you live on in our hearts. Your free of your painting, you exist in all of us. :)
"I Did Nothing Wrong"
...You tried to kill Garry because he was afraid of you.
She was talking with her father before she kills Garry
Kafra She did? How did I miss that?
Nagi It does not appear in the game but in the music otherwise im pretty sure it does
Tears Have Been Shed Today..... Your Voice Matches Mary Characteristics, The Rhythm And Everything Else!
This burning canvas became your cruel answer, now flames unsparingly kiss me goodnight..~
She is talking about the time when he sacrificed himself for Ib.He truly did that with not fear, for he knew it was the right thing.
Poor Mary. I'd have to agree with a lot of people with the fact that Mary is so misunderstood.
Sure she wasn't the best moral wise( I mean she does try to kill Gary by plucking all of the petals of his flower in alternate endings of the game. Also she does act a little crazy when we find out who/what she really is), but she just wants to live in the real world because it's boring( and a bit scary to most of us) in the art world. She also wants to be in the real world with Ib because she sees her as a friend she really wants to be with. As well as to be with her father. But in the true ending she gets *burned alive*, left to burn into ashes all alone. :'(
I believe the reason she tries to go to the real world with Ib( and leave Gary behind) is because in order for her to leave the art world and go into the real world, someone *has* to be left behind( plus she doesn't know this, but she also needs to be with someone from the real world in order to actually go there) I'll admit that this is kinda sad, but I didn't write the game's story and how everything in that world works. I just wish that there was a way for everyone to get a happy ending. Including Mary. :'(
It's not even about the dates (they are kinda weird anyway) it's more about knowing something about art. It was said that Guertena started creating abstract art before it was popular (what a hipster BTW :P), and abstractionism emerged in the twenties or even earlier.
He would be Garry's or Ib's great-grandfather.
спасибо большое)
ну, вообще это просто вокализы под стиль, не задумывался, что их можно интерпретировать так)
I LOVE YOU MARY! DON'T DIE! oh jeez the feels... it's a mix of painting's demise and any ending where mary burns...
I’m so happy I finally found this version of this song since this is the first version I ever heard of Mary’s song
Because it's my song in general :D
Thanks
I love how the singing slows down as the music box unwinds.
Even if Mary was the one turning out to be the bad guy in the trio, she was my favorite, even if she was evil, all she just wanted was friends and to see what the outside world was like, when you get the ending with Mary leaving the world and into the "Real World" she cannot escape, for she is a painting, and paintings do not belong in the real world with people.
i am listening to this for months and didnt get bored of it yet. Your work is amazing and so is your voice. i liked better with the crying tone at the end. Thank you very much for this masterpiece.
my fav theory is that garry is guertena son(similar hair color) and he was originaly locked up by his father in the painting world when he was a kid. the artist draw mary so she keep company with garry instead of letting him out.i think garry is the one who created the blu doll for mary or something(notice the doll love blu and always want to play with garry) when Guertena died garry was able to leave and he lost his memory to come back years later when rich poeple collected all the artist works and setup the Gallery.
mary herself disliked him and didnt act on it so they dont know she is a painting but instead asking IB about him later.She warned IB about some of the bad ideas like destroying the manniqan head, she cared about her. she didnt care when he was traped in the doll room losing his memory after reading a book about her. but instead she freaks out when he remembered later.
i know its messy every where but i like to believe it that way
This song brings back so many memories, I love it
The fact that you could only choose to save one just made the game so great in my opinion...
Bring the very kind man back to the world where he came from, or bring the girl who never got to live into a new life.
I LOVE MARY! I LOVE THIS SONG! I LOVE MY SELF!
i get chills from 2:06 to 2:15 0.0 just cuz of the lyrics
MrSoundlessVoice.... You sound JUST LIKE ME!!! Come to the gallery so we can be friends forever...
Is Ib a book or movie?
@@Akuma_Homura game
Mary has got to be my favorite character from the game because of the fact that, in my opinion, she's a deeper character than the others. She only wanted love and everyone hates her because she tried to be a good girl....
...I think I killed the replay button, does anyone have a defibrilator?
I just got headphones today. already loved this song. But the headphones give it a amazing little twist. You sir, Have won the internet,
I'VE BEEN TRYING TO FIND THE ORIGINAL FOR FOREVER!
Mary is a good girl. The reason why she acted like that is because of being alone for so long. Like a princess surrounded by obedient dolls in her castle. Her hatred, her loneliness, and her smile and laugh is more than enough proof of her as a human in my opinion. Think, if you were put in her place, you know your father and you've been left all alone for soooo long, what would you do in her place? I would do the same.
I've heard this song so many times and I just can't stop listening to it! ;u;
And I love your accent X'D
I knew Mary was in pain while playing Ib... But I never knew she was in THIS MUCH pain.. I feel really bad, now.. ; - ; Forgive me, Mary...
Actually....she tried to take Ib's rose away so SHE ALONE can go to the real world...that's why she asked Mary whether she would rather go back to the gallery with her or Garry. (people who don't know the story fully should shut up...) Nice song though!
***** She took your rose in one of the endings!
The one where she didn't find her rose before she woke Garry up in the toybox, but then Garry traded his rose to get Ib's rose back. (Garry died)
To the reply about the ending... GARRY NEVER DIED!!!!!!!!!!
Miss Anna he DID die, but to Ib's eyes, it only seems that he is SLEEPING. HE DIES!!!
Rachel Zhang OK!!!! No need to shout! (shout in messages if you know what I mean...)
I have always loved Garry the most, so I was pretty mad at Mary, but she is so cool at the same time! :O
WE'RE GETTING A REMAKE PEOPLE!!!!!
I feel so sorry for Mary. I don't get how anyone could truly hate her. She is a little girl who has been a little girl for many, many years stuck in that crazy world. All she wants is to be a real girl... A bit like Pinocchio, I suppose.
Lets do this Vocaloid wise, I thought it would be cool.
Mary is Rin
Kaito is Gary
Meiko is Ib
The painter aka the father is Len
Okay lets pretend they are not in a gallery that's evil and stuff, lets go back to Daughter of Evil and pretend that Rin and Len was born born again in a different time period like this one. Rin and Len were noble to each other, and Len was her brother however Len dies and Rin becomes depressed and made her own little wonderland maze in the basement of the mansion they live in. And her family becomes really cruel to her, so she invites people down in her wonderland and Meiko and Kaito were there to tour the mansion but Meiko and Kaito doesn't meet until they are in the maze. Like the gallery, there are monsters, and traps so Kaito is attacked by one of the monsters, and he was going to die without any medical attention so Meiko finds things to heal Kaito. And there, Meiko and Kaito meet. Afterwards, they meet Rin and she starts to dislike Kaito a little because she thinks she know him before. Even though the Daughter of Evil Rin was sorry for what she has done, a little part of her might have been in love with Kaito. So, lets say Mary Rin gets a voice from Daughter of Evil Rin that Kaito is the person who rejected her proposal and now Mary Rin wants Meiko out of the picture so she can live happily ever after with Kaito. (Mary wants to leave the gallery, and live happily ever after so that's why I put Rin wants to be with Kaito)
Mary approves. Maybe someone will take note of this and make a vocaloid song of this! Oh and by the way, my name is actually Mary.
-Mary
I really like Mary. I feels sorry for that they burned her painting. Ok, she is a bit crazy, but she is definitely my favorite character in the game. I wish that all of them could have survived...
your voice is beautiful
Those lyrics are REALLY awesome and sad.. ; w ;
OH MY GOD THIS IS THE ORIGINAL I COULD NEVER FIND IT UNTIL NOW
Who else wouldn't be crazy with no one to talk to for many years.. no sunlight. no sound, no nothing, just a bunch of lifeless dolls, paintings and statues and left by her creator, makes u feel left out and unwanted.. Crazy or not I kinda understand Mary's loneliness. .__.
YOU MADE THESE LYRICS?!
And, love your voice~
It’s been a wile since I saw IB (I watched a complete game play with the true (?) ending where IB and Gary reunite) and I really like Mary, she was a very good antagonist, yet she was so lonely and sad, I was literally so sad when she died in the route I saw, and never have I even liked an antagonist like her, IB is such a good game aaaa-
This song is so amazing, so beautiful !
Mary's pain... Omygod.... 😭
It's truly amazing you wrote those beautiful lyrics all by yourself , THATS talent ! :)
OMG, IM SO SORRY MARY! -crys- You just wanted to play and let me be your friend! *sobs*
This is beautiful. :3 And I agree, Mary is sorely underestimated. I don't know why so many people hate her, she's my favorite character. Probably because I can relate to her so much.
Why Did Ib leave me? Why Did She Burn My Canvas. I see my father in the new world...
Fyi a version of this is being played over an ad for Doll Repair - Doll Makeover. Just wanted to make sure they had your permission first.
I know, unfortunately many games just stole this track and don't give a fuck about it(
Never Realize how complete my childhood really is
These lyrics are beautiful and looks at the other side of Mary. Lovely. I'll definitely cover this some time.
Г-н Беззвучный голос, благодарю Вас за эту удивительную песню! Это абсолютно красивой.
I like how this predicts the two new endings
So much feels... I feel.... despair D:
This song is so true though.
I really love her voice !~
Imma sing this ;w;)/ You have a beautiful voisu btw!
Poor Mary, so much people hate her while I, personally, can connect with her. To be trapped in such an insane world without a friend, I would kill to get out too....
Id love to have this on Spotify
Aaahhhh I finally found the original video!! Your voice is so beautiful and I absolutely love this song!! It's one of my favorite songs lol
O mundo precisa conhecer essa música
Hey, guys, there is a happy ending for all of them. :) It's called Welcome to the World of Guertena where all three stay in the distorted gallery. ^^
Что-то нет тут совсем русских комментариев... ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
Я вообще случайно щас наткнулась на этот кавер, просто бродила по миру Ютуба.
Очень понравилось, голос шикарен как всегда, правда я не узнала его сначала.)0
Так что спасибо за кавер, это полетит в плейлист .D
спасибо, только это не кавер. это лириксы, написанные мной.
This is really showing what Mary's feelings are, sad, lonely, and it makes me feel so bad for her. Good job!!!
Actully, she perfectly know why they are there and that she have to kill on of them to get out, she didn't care if they where real or not, and it looked like she liked the place, and the place liked her. AND in one of the new endings you can see that she is kind of telling the galleria what to do ( Well, untill she is out ) but i still like the song alot :D
/Plz no hate ^^
♫ My tears are falling
Oh, why is it painful?
I did nothing wrong
SO WHY DO YOU HATE ME SO MUCH?♫
Wow someone used this cover! ❤️ ✔️
I didn’t USE it.... I wrote it and sang it.
@@MrSoundlessVoice i mean someone used it, not you ofc this is a masterpiece btw 😂😅
@@MrSoundlessVoice if you sang it, then your voice is extremely beautiful! ❤️, sorry if you din't understand what i said i don't really good at English speaking
@@ScarlettUsagi you mean Kiffy? XD
@@PastelBloss lmao yes xD wow i keep seeing you everywhere lol
I loved it!!!!
wonderful voice indeed oh did you know if you combine Mary and Garry's name together you get "Marry" (*evil laughter*)
what are you suggesting
they're suggesting that combining the name of two characters gives you a word in english
Can't stop listening to this. It's beautiful. Most of the mistakes can be taken as poetic, so no worries on that one!
боюсь, я не найду спонсоров хд
You're voice, with that beautiful accent, sounds like it would match Mary perfectly... Wonderful job~