I prefer side by side because the French door version still need to bend the knee to the ice queen to get frozen items. With side by side, I keep frequently used items on top. Also, I noticed those french door with ice maker/crushed ice often have issues with either water leak and frozen/stuck icemaker. I think logically with a mixed temperature environment (ice maker and regular refrigerator together), there's a difference in temperature. That might create that froze up issue and not able to make ice. I could be wrong if their insulation is good.
Excellent point of view!!. he said sometjing important for me too about the air inside the side by side. Maybe the side by side without the ice maker installed inthe door is a better choice for me, like the New whirpool or Ge, I think.
I algo have a side by side Maytag zig zag door wich worked very very good since 2003 until today!!. But i have to buy another refigerator because is too onda and the model was discontinued.
My new fridge I chose has top freezer, the shelves sit higher (less bending) going from bottom freezer 21cubic to 17 cubic, just me. The model is slimmer, not so wide. I think a good choice for my year round cottage. My son is giving me a small chest freezer he no longer needs. That way I can stock up for the Winter.
Those old Amana fridge are solid. We actually just shot the video about repairing older fridges and used Amana as an example ua-cam.com/video/ysNNmsvDxlI/v-deo.html
I was recently at several relative's houses and they all had the French door type fridge. I put ice in my drinks several times a day and having the ice maker down in the pull out drawer is a pain! The drawers were full for Thanksgiving and really heavy to pull out for me. Also, it reminded me of a chest freezer, which I hate---digging through your food in a big chest to find the frozen corn or a package of hamburger is annoying to me I'll stick with my side by side--ice in the door so you don't have to open the freezer for ice and I have the individual freezer shelves categorized for chicken, pork, beef, and other frozen foods with the frozen veggies in the door shelves. We bought an extra freezer shelf to accommodate our system.
When the ice maker is in the fridge ican tellyou t does not work and ruined my floor I will never ever get another one Ice goes in freezer and you think about that it makes sense to have the ice in the freezer. Not being smart or rude I wish I had not got the ice machine in refried cost me big bucks
It seems that the freezer on the bottom is better, and having the rest of the food higher up makes it easier to get into. Lower back problems inferred.
disagree. NOTHING is convenient about a French door bottom freezer section. With a side by side, you can keep frequently used items at a handy height in both compartments. everything is easier to organize and access. I had a sxs for 15+ years, new house had French doors and I hated it. Went back to sxs and am so happy. I cook a lot, many leftovers and ingredients in both compartments, the side by side is SO much more practical. The ice maker is also much smaller, simpler. A door-mounted ice maker in the fridge section is far less optimal, and they fail a lot.
1:02 I notice that the fridge is installed against a wall that is deeper than the appliance. In my experience, that limits the angle you can open the door, and restricts access to the storage drawers.
Thanks, for the comment Winston& And you are right it may be the issue. However for the French door fridge if there is a room between the cabinets and appliance it will not limit the access just because the way the door is designed
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 Hey, you missed one type of common fridge, freezer on bottom, refrigerator on top. It is like the reverse of the last model you showed.
Nine years ago I bought a freezer bottom, KitchenAide. Only one minor repair, a leaking tube. At the same time bought and never had any repairs on a Maytag gas stove, Bosch dishwasher and Maytag washer and dryer. Simple designs and electronics seem to have fewer problems.
Hi Keith, yes, you are absolutely right. Simple design works better and KitchenAid and especially Bosch are famous for making simple but reliable appliances
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 ...and which one would be more reliable and repairable in case that it fails? What about Whirlpool? KitchenAid and Whirlpool come from the same parent company.
I know. I have a fridgerator that has a freezer that doesn't work anymore. However, I can do without it. Better to hang on to the piece of junk I have now rather than spend well over $1000 for another piece of junk.
2:30 the door next to the wall seems like the handles get in the way. Currently have a 2004 Kenmore Elite Fridge. I have done many repairs over the years myself: 2 dual inlet valves, 1 ice maker, 1 freezer fan, 1 freezer thermistor. Eventually we will have to replace. It is top freezer with ice maker in freezer and water in door. They don't make this type any more with water in door. If you get top freezer we need to find a countertop ice maker with water hose connector and water dispenser.
We had a side-by-side, it broke, we got a Bosch French-door. I hate it. It wants me (right handed) to always open the left door first and close the right door first, (pain in the neck with several things in hand) on threat of buggering the little flapper that pivots to seal the inter-door gap (reputed expensive repair). I tried to compensate by moving all the most-used items to the left side, a task complicated by the fact that the ice maker and thru-the-door water dispenser (which I like a lot) live inside and occupy a lot of space on that left side. I’m almost looking forward to the thing crapping out so we can try something else.
Hi Harley, thanks for watching and thanks for the comments. Typically we assess the fridges how reliable they are. From my experience they are extremely reliable. When it comes to the user experience you shared - well... the world is not perfect and even Bosch fridges can be further improved :)
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 I would suggest fix one to be putting that flapper gadget on the left door. Then the 80% of the world that is right handed wouldn’t have to try to retrain themselves and their families. We could put the rarely used stuff under the ice maker and live on the right side. The Bosch reliably pisses me off every day. And if I were designing, that left door with the gadget would become narrower, and the right door wider, with the crisper drawer widths made accordingly
Thank you my Canadian friend. This was a very informative video, which I believe was the intent. I, like you believe that simple is better. Keep up the good work!
Thank you. I have saved this video to my file that I am gathering for the plans we are making for a new kitchen. I appreciate your clear explanations. And I have just subscribed to your channel.
As a domestic refrigerator repairer 40 years experience, I’d definitely say French door refrigerator are the most difficult to repair, can take an additional hour of repair time to repair the most basic issues, therefore EXPENSIVE $$$ to repair, therefore not recommended by me, Freezer on top or on the bottom my best suggestion, Side by side, not so convenient. But A large, pigeon pair, separate refrigerator, separate matching freezer is a fantastic option for a large capacity if that’s what you are after
Thanks for the comment! From user experience perspective French door still the best. Repairing wise we don't see much difference in cost when we repair the French door fridges
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 interesting, I’m finding with some of the French door refrigerators they have multiple evaporators, (up to 3) with shut off valves for regulation and so many sensors, (Electrolux) then the least favourite of mine the Samsung beasts, ooooow 😤 with ice buildup which can take forever to defrost and no real %100 fix . Anyhow, nice to chat with you matee, 👍🇦🇺
We actually shot a separate video regarding the Samsung fridge issues. This issue with ice build up is simply poor insulation issue. Look at this video and it may help you to fix Samsung fridges ua-cam.com/video/VCAgGEC-PUU/v-deo.html
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 thanks dude, I’ll have a look and compare notes 👍 Out of interest though (please take into consideration that I haven’t seen your video yet) have you re checked the Samsung refrigerator after a year or so to check on the success of the modifications you made ? Over the years I tried several factory based mods without great results, unfortunately I’ve given up on Samsung 🤷🏻♂️ But I’ll definitely check out your video and give it a try Thanks 👍🇦🇺
I have a side by side with 4 doors, that's the best fridge that exists YOU ALL HEAR!! side by side with 4 doors, fridge at the bottom and refrigerator at the top. So much space and so much better space distributed than all 3 presented in this video
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 I was looking at a quad door Bosch 800-series, but so doggone expensive! What are your thoughts about ice and water through the door? Also, what about standard depth versus counter depth?
Yes, it is expensive but it is worth it. Ice and water through the door is very common configuration. You just need to make sure that the ice maker is located in the freezer compartment and not in the fridge. Depth doesn't really matter as long as the product is good in general
Hi, Garrick, Thanks for the video. Very enlightening. The GE PFD28BYNFS model was recommended in an earlier comment. Yes, we’re considering this one. My concern is that it was mentioned to stay away from water and ice and is dispensed through the refrigerator door and this model does that. What problems should we expect? We’ve had 2 GE profiles. The first one was great. With the 2nd one (a side-by-side), I’ve had to defrost the refrigerator every 2-4 weeks for the last tears. Question #2: what are your thoughts on Electrolux ERMC2295AS? I hear this unit is very noisy. My GE Profile is very quiet, except when the refrigerator freezes. Question #3: because my family wants a water/ice dispenser on the outside, what are your thoughts on the Bosch B36CD50NS? Is this a quiet running unit? Question #4: maybe I should ask, which refrigerator with an outer water/ice dispenser do you recommend? Many thanks for your reply!! M. In Texas
Hello Margaret from sunny and chilly Calgary! Thanks for watching and thank you for your questions! A1: Yes, the water and ice dispenser in the door is not ideal however this recommended model is a good one. We do not recall lots of issues with that except probably the noisy level (some customers find it a bit noisier). A2: This is ultimately a fancy model but too new on the market to have a lot of issues. Not sure if it’s a good one or bad. A3: This one is a great model but sometimes it has issues with electronic miscommunication which is a complicated thing to solve in case it’s not under a warranty A4: For this budget, you also can face a look at Fisher & Paykal models. They are solid done and will not let you down.
Hi. I love your videos, great explanations. I have a 4-door french door Samsung RF31FMESBSR. The fridge works fine, the freezer wont freeze at all. Replaced the fridge evap motor freezer fan works. Still the freezer does not cool, below 18*C. I have had 2 techs out and they do something, the common stuff, and leave. Frustrated. Any suggestions?
Hi Al, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. It sounds like sealed system issue which should be covered under the warranty. I would suggest replacing the evaporator to start with.
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 oh no! I have a Haier 4 door refrigerator on order from Costco! Freezer on bottom. My other choice was a Frigidaire of the same design, but there were things I liked better with the Haier. Paid for 5 year warranty with Costco. Costco does not sell the Frigidaire, and no local stores have it on display, so was hesitant to buy the Frigidaire from online only. There are some bad reviews on both of these, where they had problems cooling, and compressors went up within 2-3 years.
Hello, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. We would recommend GE models if you are looking for some budget options. If you are ready to pay a bit more take a look at Bosch and Blomberg. And if you want to go wild then Liebherr would be your best option.
Hi Gary, thanks for watching and it is a good question. Beko is not common in Canada so we can't say anything about that brand. However Beko is manufactured by the same company as Blomberg and we would recommend Blomberg. Let me know if it helps.
Very informative, very helpful, especially, understanding the science (cooling) and reliability factors. Now, we are looking to purchase a GE model, freezer on the bottom with French doors, if possible.
Hello Genaro, thanks for watching and thanks for your comment. If your budget is limited please look at GE. if you are ready to spend more your choice would be Bosch and Bloomberg
I've not seen a freezer that fits what I want. The side by side has too little space, the bottom freezer isn't that great for people who can't bend to reach it and the normal top freezer it's the same bending but I do go into the freezer often so that one works best. Wished there was a french door similar to that.
I agree completely with this man on how awful side by side refrigerators are. However my appliance repairman (repairs all types of kitchen appliances) who repaired my upright freezer told me to AVOID buying french door refrigerators because they have 2 motors? or 2 compressors? or 2 something something which means twice the chance of something breaking. He said to go with freezer on top or a side by side since both have been made for decades and manufacturers worked the bugs out. He also said to stay away from foreign brands. After my "made in USA" lemon of a Whirlpool dishwasher, I don't know what to make of that. This video appliance repairman at the end of the video only mentioned the top freezer, side by side and French door but did not mention bottom freezer. Big complaints about French doors is that stupid meat drawer which forces people to open BOTH doors to access or the French door that forces you to open both doors to open any drawer OR having to use your hand or your shoulder to keep one or more of the 2 doors OPEN while you are rummaging around in the refrigerator trying to find something. I have read thousands of all type of refrigerator reviews pro and con. I have a very narrow 24" wide bottom freezer which I can now now replace with any width refrigerator I want after a kitchen remodel. I have not decided yet. I do NOT want a side by side. I do not want a freezer on top. I like the idea of a French door or a bigger bottom freezer refrigerator but am leery of a French door since my repairman said to avoid them. I wish this repairman said which MANUFACTURERs to avoid and which to buy. Even if someone wanted a Freezer on Top...there is no manufacturer which makes anything decent - they are all cheap looking and very basic inside.
Hi Mile, thanks for watching, and thanks for the comment. Extra functional parts make the system work easier means less pressure, however, extra electronics make the system less reliable. In my own opinion still, French doors fridges are the best option but only if it’s as simple as possible. That's why we can't recommend Samsung or LG and even shot a separate video about the issues with Samsung fridges. ua-cam.com/video/VCAgGEC-PUU/v-deo.html So I would recommend GE as a budget option for a French door fridge and Bosch would be your second choice if you are ready to spend some extra $$.
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 What do you mean by "simple"? I am willing to spend the extra money if it means the French door refrigerator will LAST a long time without repair. I could care less about having a water dispenser or ice maker - in fact I would prefer to have neither. Is not having an ice maker or water dispenser in a refrigerator what you mean by getting a "Simple refrigerator"? Or, does simple mean something else?
Hi Mike, when we say simple we mean that you should not be looking at Samsung fridges that have lost of fancy built in electronics and missing on the main part of the fridge - keeping the food cool and fresh. From that perspective Bosch, Blomberg or Liebherr would be your choice. All these brands do is keeping the food cool and fresh. Nothing else!
Hi Ron, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. Typically GE fridges are reliable and we do recommend them. With regards to the white paint on the stove - I have never seen any issues with that.
Thank you for this video. What is your opinion about Fisher Paykel refrigerators? If choosing between Whirlpool brands vs GE, which of those do you prefer for reliability and no headaches? I don't want any water or even ice maker. I have a great RO system and if I want ice, I will buy a countertop ice maker.
Hello and thanks for watching! Fisher & Paykel are really good fridges however before buying it please check what kind of warranty you are getting and who will be servicing your fridge in case something goes wrong. Not every appliance repair company can service Fisher & Paykel. With regards to Whirpool vs GE go with GE. It is more reliable and easier to service.
My freezer top Kitchenaid is still running after 30 years. Sadly they don’t make this model anymore. The new French doors basically have water and ice features taken up 1/3 of the space.
Thanks for the video. Your opinion is very important. I notice the door at the bottom in some of that appliances are not very stables. As for example in some models of Ge. Others like the profile GE brand are very stables. But i saw the new Frigidare refrigerator and i like it design very much, what is your opinion about that model? I appreciate your answer. (The model that i saw was an independent Refrigerator). the freezer, they sell apart. (Each one is apart). I like this model a lot. Thsnks!!
Good afternoon, Garrick! Thank you SO VERY much for responding! I greatly appreciate you taking the time to respond with your professional opinion. Do you have time for another question? We currently have a GE Profile, side-by-side, PSS26PSTBDSS (15 yrs). Ice accumulates in the refrigerator on the wall behind the vegetable bin. Do you know what causes this and is there anything we can do (besides replacement) to stop/address this? Last December a GE certified repair person replaced the control board and defrost heater. The "repair" lasted 1 month and we're back to defrosting about every 2-4 weeks. The "repair" was about as effective as leaving the unit to defrost on its own! Thank you for your time and comments!! From hot-n-sunny Texas! (101 today; will feel like 106!!)
Hi Margaret, It’s 💯 auto-defrost system issue . It’s hard to say which component failed but it looks like tech replaced two most expensive parts and in general his approach was reasonable. However I would recommend you to call this tech back cause it must me under the repair warranty or request another tech to run the diagnosis of the fridge for you.
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 I Hi, Garrick, Well, I called. No sympathy there. To bring out a technician, it will cost $109. 😫. The warranty was good only for 30 days. I didn’t have an issue until 31 days later. Get this, before the technician had left my house, he said, “Don’t call me again.” Before I buy my next refrigerator, I will see who will do the servicing. Thanks for all of your help, Garrick! m. 😎
that's sad. We don't do that kind of things to our clients. Anyway, thanks for watching and thanks for the questions. We have more videos to come that will help the home owners with maintaining home appliances. Stay tuned.
Thank you for honest reviews. I have a Kenmore 27cu ft side-by-side, about 15 years old. I had to replace the compressor starter twice now. Is there a good universal starter that is better than the OEM starter?
Hi Ronda, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. We recommend using only OEM parts and that's what we do when we fix appliances for our clients
Due to science it's been known for decades that a freezer on top is the most reliable fridge but people don't want that design. There is a reason why you find freezers on top in apartmens they also have the longest warranties because they don't break his offer.
Thanks, Rusty, for watching and for the comment! You are right freezer on top is thge most reliable type of fridge, however as I explained in my video it is alway the most user friendly design as you are facing all the time the section of the fridge which you don't use that often
Hello Fizah, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. More likely the issue is with a drain line. It’s clogged for some reason and defrosted ice is flowing inside of the compartment. You need to partly disassemble the fridge to have an access to the evaporator area to find and defrost the drain line.
Hi Cat, thanks for good question! It’s one of a best option only in case there are two compressors. If unit has only one compressor with a dual evaporator system I would not recommend buying that. I hope it clarifies! Garrik.
Hi J C. Thanks for watching and thanks for the question. on the budget side we would recommend looking at GE. If you are ready to spend more look at Bosch and Blomberg
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 I'm on a budget and I'm considering getting a GE refrigerator top freezer model. Had a Frigedare freezer top model only lasted 10yrs(probably the average life span). From Albuquerque,NM. Have read( from product reviews) that some GE refridgerators are on the noisy side.
Thank you for your excellent video. Have you had any customers having issues with their Samsung 580L Top Mount Freezer with Twin Cooling Plus SAM-RT18M6211SG? I am looking for new fridge and this model layout seems to meet my requirement but the brand's reputation has left me thinking, whether it's a Go or No Go. Thanks for your help.
Hello Poh Lin, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. We even shot a separate video about the common issues with the Samsung fridges. ua-cam.com/video/VCAgGEC-PUU/v-deo.html Any Samsung fridge is not recommended
LG also has good layout, same as Samsung, not reliable. Problem compressor, dead on 2nd year. Leaking compressor on 7th year. Refill coolant. I don’t even hook it with water outlet cos we don’t need the water n ice functions. I use it as a basic fridge. I love it has almost 30 cf and without water dispenser.
My Samsung bought new in 2008 has lasted 14 years & recently developed water in the crisper drawers, about every 5 days, not much, I can wipe up with 3-4 paper towels. I can live with that but it’s 21 cubic & way large for my needs. I have a chance to buy new top freezer, fits my needs, on sale for $779.00 with tax and 3 year warranty came to $990.00. I would buy another Samsung, bottom freezer but they start at $1500.00, uh, the price wasn’t in my budget.
Hi Scott, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. If you are low on budget look at GE fridges, if you are ready to spend more then Bosch and Blomberg would be your best choice
Love your videos and your honesty. I thought that I had decided on a brand to buy, but servicing in my rural area is difficult. However, Electrolux/Frigidaire does have service here. Any thoughts about their French door, 36“ fridges? Is there really any difference between the two names, beside the price?
Hi Joseph, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. Electrolux and Frigidaire is the same manufacturer and the fridge you are referring to is good in general. No major glitches
Hi Donna, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. You would need to defrost the drain line with a steamer. Something like that will be helpful www.amazon.ca/Bissell-39N7H-Steam-Shot/dp/B00Q7WYLI2/ref=mp_s_a_1_17?crid=3LYO9IJ56S82U&keywords=steamer&pscroll=1&qid=1657461514&sprefix=steamer%2Caps%2C121&sr=8-17&wIndexMainSlot=25
Hi Don, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. IKEA doesn't manufacture the fridges. They just have a contract with someone who does that for them. As far as we know they have a contract with Whirlpool and Whirlpool makes all the appliances for them. If it didn't change then yes you can consider them. But if they switched to Samsung or LG then I would recommend just look for something else. On their website they don't say who the manufacturer of their appliances is so you may need to look on the label inside the fridge and it should tell you that. Or simply ask the sales rep at IKEA.
Hi Kasi, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. Out of these three I would stick with Bosch. F&K are great as well but more expensive. Beko is yet to be launched in Canadian market so we don't have much experience with them however their parent company produces Blomberg fridges which are highly recommended.
Hi. We bought a new lg Model#: LRMXS3006S. If the freezer door is open for more than 5 seconds we hear a humming noise for a couple seconds after closing it. I'm assuming it's the compressor. This doesn't seem normal to me. Thoughts?
Hi Adam, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. It actually can be normal in case it has R600 refrigerant or if it could be evaporator fan kicks on. You better call manufacturer in case this unit is a new one do they might fix it under the warranty in case there is something wrong.
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 Thank you for taking the time to reply. Yes we called to report it and LG will be sending out a tech. I just wanted another unbiased opinion in case the tech said its no big deal.
Hi, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. The quietest fridges I’ve seen are Electrolux or Blomberg , the louder fridges are the ones using the R600a refrigerant, however within next few years it will be phased out so all most of the fridges will be quite as long as they are designed properly
I have the Frigidaire French doors with freezer on the bottom. I would not recommend. Ice developed on the outside of refrigerator in the back near the icemaker. The back of the refrigerator is rusty. I periodically use a steamer to remove the ice. It's my first and last Frigidaire appliance.
Hello Ka Cr, thanks for watching and thanks for the comment. To be honest, Frigidaire is a good manufacturer. The issue is that an ice maker chamber is located inside of the fridge compartment. Usually, this design itself causes that kind of issues. Samsung fridges all have that issue with ice-maker located inside the fridge compartment and not inside the freezer compartment. Even if you buy another brand with the same ice maker location, more than likely, you’ll experience pretty much the same issue.
Thanks for watching, Gurpreetpal and thanks for the question. I am sorry but I am afraid I will not be able to recommend something specific for this space and you will need to explore what is available on your market. However my general recommendation would be to look at GE (this is a good budget option) or Bosch (this is more expensive one).
Hi Garrik, so my family wants to buy a new fridge because we hear the simpler the better. But we still want a french door. And at least an ice maker thats not on the doors but in the freezer itself. We are also conisdering a top freezer fridge as well as long as it has an ice maker. What are some things to keep in mind? Is Frigidaire a good brand for either of these types of fridges? Are there any other recommendations you could possibly give?
Thanks for watching and thanks for the question, Robin. That's the issue with side-by-side. The box of frozen pizza will fit extremely tight. That's why French Door is a better option
You missed a huge downside to french doors, if you want a water/ice dispenser (which is important for me). fd fridges have a big, bulky ice maker in the fridge section. That is bad, more prone to failure. a sxs has a smaller, more efficient ice maker in the freezer compartment where it belongs. far more reliable. everything is easier to organize and more accessible in a sxs. and they are less expensive than comparable fd models. and yes, i use my freezer a lit more than twice a week!
Thank you for great informative video. I stopped at french door bottom freezer no water or ice maker i need, I am in new york in terms buying choices. I saw previos comments regarding bosh and other brands. What other brands and model would you reccomend in terms price quality and waranty time. Thank you
Hello R A, I am glad our video was helpful. if you are looking for more budget models then Bosch you can take a look on the brands manufactured by Whirpool (Whirpool, Amana, MayTag, KitchenAid). and the brands that you should NOT be considering at all are Samsung and LG.
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 thank you again for your hep. I was looking at beko it is Turkish brand very popular in Europe have you ever dealt with it? also GE brand any recommendation?
we don't deal much with beko as it is not distributed in Canada. However, beko is produced by the same company as Blomberg so it is a good one. And GE is a good choice. Nothing fancy with that brand but it is reliable.
Garrik Everything you have just mentioned I have had problems with!!!, And now just the compressors went out they wanted charge me $800 to change it to a $100 compressor and yet this is supposed to be covered under the 10 year compression warranty what a rip off, My unit's 6 years old it's always had problems with the ice maker ever since I got it I was waiting for the class action lawsuit to combut right now I've got to buy another refrigerator can you tell me what is good, Or better yet who has the best warranty parts and labor that's what I'm looking for now!!!
I am going to get AGE refrigerator that's what it looks like as well I'm consumers report but then again consumers report is what led me to this nightmare that I am experiencing right now I must say it is the 1st time consumers report led me down the wrong path But yes G that warranties are better I know that and with my American Express card it doubles the warranty that's why I'm waiting to see about the mission I'm dealing with right now but I know I do want change it refrigerator
Freezer once or twice a week??? Maybe 3-5 times a DAY if not per MEAL for us. I actually have a French door in house, side by side on garage, and two upright freezers in garage . But I live in country.
I have a Samsung counter depth refrigerator. Nothing but problems. Had it for 8 years. First top ice maker stop working. 2 bottom freezer always freezing up. 3 now top refrigerator freezer up. I put it manually in defrost a couple times a week. I’m done with it. I’m tired of taking it apart every couple of months defrosting it. What’s the most reliable counter depth refrigerator out right now?
When I bought it I remodeled my kitchen I got the Samsung. So I put my old GE refrigerator in garage for extra refrigerator still run’s like a champ. Probably had it for about at least 18 years.
Thanks, Chuck for your question and watching the video. Design: as simple as possible Country of origin: German stuff the most reliable Budget wise: GE would be your least expensive option (you are 100% right - they last forever) and Bosch would be your more expensive option
2 days ago, i got GE 19.1 cu. Ft (GTE19jtnrww). Only 1 temperature setting knob controls top & bottom. Problem is on recommended setting, bottom is at 43F & top is at 14F. Not acceptable.Why could that be. Is Frigidaire 17.6 cu. Ft (#FRFG1723AV) better overall (reliable refrigerant & well oriented main control board)?
If i decide to buy a side by side GE instead of french with the botton door, botton( i dont like that design, )what is the best model? Also, you can recomiend me another brand too. I need to know so i can make a good decision.
Hello sir.Thank you this video was helpful.Soon I will be buying a brand new fridge.I'm not looking for a huge,super fancy(just me using it) but my main concern is noise. I'm super sensitive to unnecessary noise,the fridge I have now is so bad at times,I'm ready to smash it to bits (its a Maytag). I've been trying to gather information on noiseless fridges.Is no noise even possible?I scrolled through your videos but saw nothing on the topic. Brand suggestions that are reasonably priced?Thank you.I'm a new subscriber.
Hello Kye, Thanks for watching and thanks for the good question. The best way to go is to inquire this information from the store/manufacturer cause usually they don’t like to post it online. The other thing is cooling agent in the system. I found newer R600a systems are noisier comparing to traditional R134a. It’s very complicated to say which brand is noisy and which is not just because there are good and bad models in each manufacturer. Generally we would recommend GE to our clients as a budget option. They have much less bugs and glitches than other budget options.
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 thank you for your reply.I will continue to watch your videos and learn.I was dreading watching videos about appliances because I didn't think I'd understand but you break it down and explain in a way that's easy to comprehend. Glad I found you!
Hi Shawn, Garrik is here and thanks for the good question. It depends on your pocket but general rule - I recommend to buy as simple as possible with no horns and whistles. At the end of the day you need your food to stay cold or frozen - that's it. In terms of the brands I would recommend Bosch, Blomberg and Liebherr however those ones can be on a bit pricey side, still it is worth it. And you should stay away from Samsung - we repair tons of them and they can go down in 2-3 years from the time of the purchase.
i was looking for brands i know that last. if you can afford . Bosch is a great brand but pricey. when i purchased mine i tried to remember the brands that still performed in the 80’s like electrolex . i couldnt find them. once i got my Frigidaire frig installed. i realized it was made by electrolex made in mexico. not america but not china either.
We've had our top freezer econo model for nearly 15 years. It works as well now as day one. We have friends with a bottom freezer, French doors, top-of-the-line model, which cost a FORTUNE, and they've had nothing but trouble. K.I.S.S. folks...works every time.
Thanks for watching and thanks for the comments. I am pretty sure that your friends own Samsung or LG so I am not surprised they have issue after issue.
Nice Video. Very informative. Can you please tell me what will be the best French door model in 33" wide design and counter depth. I can't go really high in price but want something with water dispenser outside. What will be the best time to buy. I want to buy full package for kitchen. Please suggest, I live in Chicago.
Hello Amarjeet, thanks for watching and thanks for the good question. In terms of brands we would recommend I suggest looking at Bosch, Blomberg and Liebherr. Bosch should be on lower price range side than another two. And Samsung would be the brand you should be careful with as they have quite a few glitches in the design and things can go wrong with Samsung easily. In terms of timing here in Calgary, AB we actually observe the shortage of the supply - you need to wait for the appliance you have chosen to be delivered. This is due to ongoing pandemic and longer time in production and transportation of the appliances. So timing doesn't really matter at this point and you need to look at the best solution that fits your needs.
Hi Layan, thanks for the question and those ones are also good. They have less space inside and opening one big door may not super convenient if your kitchen is tight. But other than that it is good option too. And that type of model usually is not as pricy as French door one and if you go with makes like Whirlpool or Amana they will last forever. You may want to want another video that we have just posted on repairing older Amana fridge - freezer on the bottom. ua-cam.com/video/ysNNmsvDxlI/v-deo.html
My wife was excited today when she thought my old basic white fridge was tore up because the door was not closing all the way. She wasn’t happy when I said ah I fixed it! It’s just a bottle of ketchup keeping it form closing all the way. She’s really wanting new stainless appliances but my old ugly white stuff like my fridge has worked fine since I bought the house at least 18 years ago. Only issue is the ice maker drips in the freezer which ends up freezing and doesn’t ever leak out. I’m afraid if I buy a new one it’s going to be a piece of junk.
Thanks for watching and thanks for the question. You are right to the certain degree. These days you can still find a reliable fridge for any budget. but if your 18 years old works fine keep it and cherish it :)
What refrigerant is used in new fridges, old ones used R12 sealed system last for years low pressures. Had Hotpoint 25 years still ran fine. Made in Mexico & China not good. Sealed systems warranty 1 year maybe,shows how well companies stand behind product. Most R12 fridges freezers 5 years sealed system. Today obsolescence.
Hello Luna, thanks for watching and thanks for the comment. Well, nowadays we still use R134a and finally switching to R400 series and R600. And the warranty is the same as it used to be 5-10 years for compressor and sealed system components. As for the quality, I guess that’s not a surprise for anyone that things getting cheaper to produce so more people can afford it. However, there are still good models you can find. In other words, you get what you are paying for.
I’m moving to Montana and will not have reliable repair people near by. What French door fridge should I buy for reliability and is 36 inch the most common measurement on fridge?
Hi Vic, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. The brand that you should stay away from is Samsung - generally not very reliable. And depending on your budget you can look at GE (low budget), Bosch (medium budget), Blomberg & Liebherr (high budget). Yes, 36 inch is a typical measurement but you better check with the place you will be living as it may differ
Hi Lil, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. Unfortunately, overcomplicated and overpriced nowadays but used to be one of the best makes. Sorry for the bad news
Feels like its a hard decision to choose a brand for me. I do want a french door but unable to decide on the brand to get a reliable, energy efficient fridge. Any suggestions and/or tips on brand choosing ?
Hi Darrel, if you are looking for the budget option you may want to take a look at GE. However if you are ready to spend a bit more you may want to check Bosch and Blomberg. Sorry for the lat response
We have fridgedaire FGH2869LFA.ice maker and water work but freezing behind ice container and drain is frozen.Allowed to thaw and water drains to bottom pan
Hi Lynne, thanks for watching and i am glad it was helpful. With regards to the brands we would recommend Bosch, Blomberg, Liebherr. They are on higher price side but they worth it. Also i can tell which brand we would NOT recommend - Samsung fridges are not super reliable. Let me know if it helps.
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 No, I hadn't read this comment before I commented that I was considering Bosch. I'm refitting my kitchen completely, going with mostly Bosch, but seriously considering a Thermador (also a Bosch product) cooktop.
I pray the gas ranges and not as bad as the refrigerators yes I screwed up and bought one I didn't know a little bit after I bought the new range the refrigerator started going Bad
Thanks for watching and thanks for the question! Freezer at the bottom is not a bad option. It is similar to French door ones but a bit smaller. From usability perspective it is quite convenient as well. Just keep in mind that the door is wider so you will need more space to open it. And in terms of potential repair it is easy to handle. Freezer on top is usually very basic model and it is hard to use as you always need to bend to get things in and out but freezer on top is inexpensive option. Let me know if it clarifies.
I prefer side by side because the French door version still need to bend the knee to the ice queen to get frozen items. With side by side, I keep frequently used items on top. Also, I noticed those french door with ice maker/crushed ice often have issues with either water leak and frozen/stuck icemaker. I think logically with a mixed temperature environment (ice maker and regular refrigerator together), there's a difference in temperature. That might create that froze up issue and not able to make ice. I could be wrong if their insulation is good.
Good points! thanks for the comment!
Excellent point of view!!. he said sometjing important for me too about the air inside the side by side. Maybe the side by side without the ice maker installed inthe door is a better choice for me, like the New whirpool or Ge, I think.
I algo have a side by side Maytag zig zag door wich worked very very good since 2003 until today!!. But i have to buy another refigerator because is too onda and the model was discontinued.
This has been the best video I've seen on this subject so far! to the point and direct! I like that. thanks for your help.
Glad it was helpful! Thanks, Christine!
Sure tight budget but for my needs the freezer on top works best for me. Two person household. Side by side and French door is superfluous.
Thanks, Paul, for your comment. Yes, sure for the household of two freezer on top will work perfectly.
My new fridge I chose has top freezer, the shelves sit higher (less bending) going from bottom freezer 21cubic to 17 cubic, just me. The model is slimmer, not so wide. I think a good choice for my year round cottage. My son is giving me a small chest freezer he no longer needs. That way I can stock up for the Winter.
We have an Amanda fridge with freezer on the bottom which is around 20 years and so far, so good!
Those old Amana fridge are solid. We actually just shot the video about repairing older fridges and used Amana as an example ua-cam.com/video/ysNNmsvDxlI/v-deo.html
Things built twenty years ago are fine...maybe I will consider a used refit. Lol
I was recently at several relative's houses and they all had the French door type fridge. I put ice in my drinks several times a day and having the ice maker down in the pull out drawer is a pain! The drawers were full for Thanksgiving and really heavy to pull out for me. Also, it reminded me of a chest freezer, which I hate---digging through your food in a big chest to find the frozen corn or a package of hamburger is annoying to me I'll stick with my side by side--ice in the door so you don't have to open the freezer for ice and I have the individual freezer shelves categorized for chicken, pork, beef, and other frozen foods with the frozen veggies in the door shelves. We bought an extra freezer shelf to accommodate our system.
Hi Vickie, thanks for watching and thanks for the comment. If you use the ice maker so often then it makes sense to stick with the side-by-side one
When the ice maker is in the fridge ican tellyou t does not work and ruined my floor
I will never ever get another one
Ice goes in freezer and you think about that it makes sense to have the ice in the freezer. Not being smart or rude I wish I had not got the ice machine in refried cost me big bucks
Thank you for your feedback. I’m looking to replace my fridge and am thinking about side by side.
Thank you for labeling each section of your video.
Glad you like them!
It seems that the freezer on the bottom is better, and having the rest of the food higher up makes it easier to get into. Lower back problems inferred.
Thanks, Jeff for watching and for the comment. Yes, bottom freezer is also a good option!
disagree. NOTHING is convenient about a French door bottom freezer section. With a side by side, you can keep frequently used items at a handy height in both compartments. everything is easier to organize and access.
I had a sxs for 15+ years, new house had French doors and I hated it. Went back to sxs and am so happy. I cook a lot, many leftovers and ingredients in both compartments, the side by side is SO much more practical. The ice maker is also much smaller, simpler. A door-mounted ice maker in the fridge section is far less optimal, and they fail a lot.
1:02 I notice that the fridge is installed against a wall that is deeper than the appliance. In my experience, that limits the angle you can open the door, and restricts access to the storage drawers.
Thanks, for the comment Winston& And you are right it may be the issue. However for the French door fridge if there is a room between the cabinets and appliance it will not limit the access just because the way the door is designed
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 Hey, you missed one type of common fridge, freezer on bottom, refrigerator on top. It is like the reverse of the last model you showed.
This was very informative!! All your reasons for each one makes so much sense.
Thanks, Monica! I am glad it was helpful
I love your video, direct to the point with all the information. Thank you!
Nine years ago I bought a freezer bottom, KitchenAide. Only one minor repair, a leaking tube. At the same time bought and never had any repairs on a Maytag gas stove, Bosch dishwasher and Maytag washer and dryer. Simple designs and electronics seem to have fewer problems.
Hi Keith, yes, you are absolutely right. Simple design works better and KitchenAid and especially Bosch are famous for making simple but reliable appliances
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 ...and which one would be more reliable and repairable in case that it fails? What about Whirlpool? KitchenAid and Whirlpool come from the same parent company.
My repair man said Whirlpool which is same company as Kitchenaid.
You just scared my wife from buying one. Thanks man!!
You are very welcome :)
I know. I have a fridgerator that has a freezer that doesn't work anymore. However, I can do without it. Better to hang on to the piece of junk I have now rather than spend well over $1000 for another piece of junk.
I like fridge compartment on top, but with the big door, not french doors. And no water line! Cheers from Lethbridge.
Thanks, Arie!
Which brand would you recommend for the French door style with the freezer on the bottom?
Such valuable information for buyers stressing over frig shopping.
I am glad it was helpful
I don't think "frig" means what you think it means...
Thank you, very informative video. Helped me decided on the French door.
Great! Thanks for watching!
I had a hard time opening the bottom freezer door. Bending and pulling at the store. I prefer side by side now
thanks for the comment, this is an interesting experience
2:30 the door next to the wall seems like the handles get in the way.
Currently have a 2004 Kenmore Elite Fridge. I have done many repairs over the years myself: 2 dual inlet valves, 1 ice maker, 1 freezer fan, 1 freezer thermistor.
Eventually we will have to replace. It is top freezer with ice maker in freezer and water in door. They don't make this type any more with water in door.
If you get top freezer we need to find a countertop ice maker with water hose connector and water dispenser.
We had a side-by-side, it broke, we got a Bosch French-door. I hate it.
It wants me (right handed) to always open the left door first and close the right door first, (pain in the neck with several things in hand) on threat of buggering the little flapper that pivots to seal the inter-door gap (reputed expensive repair). I tried to compensate by moving all the most-used items to the left side, a task complicated by the fact that the ice maker and thru-the-door water dispenser (which I like a lot) live inside and occupy a lot of space on that left side.
I’m almost looking forward to the thing crapping out so we can try something else.
Hi Harley, thanks for watching and thanks for the comments. Typically we assess the fridges how reliable they are. From my experience they are extremely reliable. When it comes to the user experience you shared - well... the world is not perfect and even Bosch fridges can be further improved :)
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 I would suggest fix one to be putting that flapper gadget on the left door. Then the 80% of the world that is right handed wouldn’t have to try to retrain themselves and their families. We could put the rarely used stuff under the ice maker and live on the right side. The Bosch reliably pisses me off every day.
And if I were designing, that left door with the gadget would become narrower, and the right door wider, with the crisper drawer widths made accordingly
Thank you my Canadian friend. This was a very informative video, which I believe was the intent. I, like you believe that simple is better. Keep up the good work!
Glad it was helpful! Thanks, Richard!
Thank you. I have saved this video to my file that I am gathering for the plans we are making for a new kitchen. I appreciate your clear explanations. And I have just subscribed to your channel.
Hi Mary, thanks for watching and I am glad it was helpful!
As a domestic refrigerator repairer 40 years experience, I’d definitely say French door refrigerator are the most difficult to repair, can take an additional hour of repair time to repair the most basic issues, therefore EXPENSIVE $$$ to repair, therefore not recommended by me,
Freezer on top or on the bottom my best suggestion,
Side by side, not so convenient.
But
A large, pigeon pair, separate refrigerator, separate matching freezer is a fantastic option for a large capacity if that’s what you are after
Thanks for the comment! From user experience perspective French door still the best. Repairing wise we don't see much difference in cost when we repair the French door fridges
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 interesting, I’m finding with some of the French door refrigerators they have multiple evaporators, (up to 3) with shut off valves for regulation and so many sensors, (Electrolux) then the least favourite of mine the Samsung beasts, ooooow 😤 with ice buildup which can take forever to defrost and no real %100 fix . Anyhow, nice to chat with you matee, 👍🇦🇺
We actually shot a separate video regarding the Samsung fridge issues. This issue with ice build up is simply poor insulation issue. Look at this video and it may help you to fix Samsung fridges ua-cam.com/video/VCAgGEC-PUU/v-deo.html
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 thanks dude, I’ll have a look and compare notes 👍
Out of interest though (please take into consideration that I haven’t seen your video yet) have you re checked the Samsung refrigerator after a year or so to check on the success of the modifications you made ?
Over the years I tried several factory based mods without great results, unfortunately I’ve given up on Samsung 🤷🏻♂️
But I’ll definitely check out your video and give it a try
Thanks 👍🇦🇺
It all depends on how bad insulation layer has been worn out. After hundreds of similar repairs we have a call back ratio 3-5% in 1-2 years
I have a side by side with 4 doors, that's the best fridge that exists YOU ALL HEAR!! side by side with 4 doors, fridge at the bottom and refrigerator at the top. So much space and so much better space distributed than all 3 presented in this video
Hi David, thanks for watching and thanks for the comment. Are you referring ti the brand new Samsung model wth 4 doors?
I had my heart set on a French door bottom pull out drawer freezer. Then I saw a quad door model. Glad I did more shopping before buying.
Hi Charles, thanks for watching and yes. those new quad door models are good one for sure!!!
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 I was looking at a quad door Bosch 800-series, but so doggone expensive!
What are your thoughts about ice and water through the door?
Also, what about standard depth versus counter depth?
Yes, it is expensive but it is worth it. Ice and water through the door is very common configuration. You just need to make sure that the ice maker is located in the freezer compartment and not in the fridge. Depth doesn't really matter as long as the product is good in general
Which brand quad door did you buy?
@@MollyMiaAndMe Samsung makes the quad door. I'm still using my old fridge.
Hi, Garrick,
Thanks for the video. Very enlightening.
The GE PFD28BYNFS model was recommended in an earlier comment. Yes, we’re considering this one. My concern is that it was mentioned to stay away from water and ice and is dispensed through the refrigerator door and this model does that. What problems should we expect? We’ve had 2 GE profiles. The first one was great. With the 2nd one (a side-by-side), I’ve had to defrost the refrigerator every 2-4 weeks for the last tears.
Question #2: what are your thoughts on Electrolux ERMC2295AS? I hear this unit is very noisy. My GE Profile is very quiet, except when the refrigerator freezes.
Question #3: because my family wants a water/ice dispenser on the outside, what are your thoughts on the Bosch B36CD50NS? Is this a quiet running unit?
Question #4: maybe I should ask, which refrigerator with an outer water/ice dispenser do you recommend?
Many thanks for your reply!! M. In Texas
Hello Margaret from sunny and chilly Calgary!
Thanks for watching and thank you for your questions!
A1: Yes, the water and ice dispenser in the door is not ideal however this recommended model is a good one. We do not recall lots of issues with that except probably the noisy level (some customers find it a bit noisier).
A2: This is ultimately a fancy model but too new on the market to have a lot of issues. Not sure if it’s a good one or bad.
A3: This one is a great model but sometimes it has issues with electronic miscommunication which is a complicated thing to solve in case it’s not under a warranty
A4: For this budget, you also can face a look at Fisher & Paykal models. They are solid done and will not let you down.
Hi. I love your videos, great explanations. I have a 4-door french door Samsung RF31FMESBSR. The fridge works fine, the freezer wont freeze at all. Replaced the fridge evap motor freezer fan works. Still the freezer does not cool, below 18*C. I have had 2 techs out and they do something, the common stuff, and leave. Frustrated. Any suggestions?
Hi Al, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. It sounds like sealed system issue which should be covered under the warranty. I would suggest replacing the evaporator to start with.
Are Haier or Hisense brands any good or should those be avoided too? Thanks for taking the time to make this video! Perfect timing!
Thanks for watching and thanks for your question! And to my opinion you should avoid those two brands
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 oh no! I have a Haier 4 door refrigerator on order from Costco! Freezer on bottom. My other choice was a Frigidaire of the same design, but there were things I liked better with the Haier. Paid for 5 year warranty with Costco. Costco does not sell the Frigidaire, and no local stores have it on display, so was hesitant to buy the Frigidaire from online only. There are some bad reviews on both of these, where they had problems cooling, and compressors went up within 2-3 years.
which current refrigerator model we should buy ? model and make pls
Hello, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. We would recommend GE models if you are looking for some budget options. If you are ready to pay a bit more take a look at Bosch and Blomberg. And if you want to go wild then Liebherr would be your best option.
Practical and informative. Thanks
Glad it was helpful! Thanks for watching!
Very well done. Thanks.
Thanks for watching, Stephen!
Great video! Thank you!
Thanks, Yuko! We are glad it was helpful!
Is beko a good one
Hi Gary, thanks for watching and it is a good question. Beko is not common in Canada so we can't say anything about that brand. However Beko is manufactured by the same company as Blomberg and we would recommend Blomberg. Let me know if it helps.
my parents refrigeratpr last over 25 years...no breakdowns,,,now you are lucky if you get 4 yrs
Good point! Thanks for watching and for the comment!
Very informative, very helpful, especially, understanding the science (cooling) and reliability factors. Now, we are looking to purchase a GE model, freezer on the bottom with French doors, if possible.
this is a great option. Go for it!
Our GE is on the fritz, it’s built on the Samsung platform. I wouldn’t buy a GE.
Thank you Sir
Most welcome!
Hi I love your videos. question is, I want to get a French door refrigerator. What brand should I get?
Hello Genaro, thanks for watching and thanks for your comment. If your budget is limited please look at GE. if you are ready to spend more your choice would be Bosch and Bloomberg
I've not seen a freezer that fits what I want. The side by side has too little space, the bottom freezer isn't that great for people who can't bend to reach it and the normal top freezer it's the same bending but I do go into the freezer often so that one works best. Wished there was a french door similar to that.
I agree completely with this man on how awful side by side refrigerators are. However my appliance repairman (repairs all types of kitchen appliances) who repaired my upright freezer told me to AVOID buying french door refrigerators because they have 2 motors? or 2 compressors? or 2 something something which means twice the chance of something breaking. He said to go with freezer on top or a side by side since both have been made for decades and manufacturers worked the bugs out. He also said to stay away from foreign brands. After my "made in USA" lemon of a Whirlpool dishwasher, I don't know what to make of that. This video appliance repairman at the end of the video only mentioned the top freezer, side by side and French door but did not mention bottom freezer. Big complaints about French doors is that stupid meat drawer which forces people to open BOTH doors to access or the French door that forces you to open both doors to open any drawer OR having to use your hand or your shoulder to keep one or more of the 2 doors OPEN while you are rummaging around in the refrigerator trying to find something. I have read thousands of all type of refrigerator reviews pro and con. I have a very narrow 24" wide bottom freezer which I can now now replace with any width refrigerator I want after a kitchen remodel. I have not decided yet. I do NOT want a side by side. I do not want a freezer on top. I like the idea of a French door or a bigger bottom freezer refrigerator but am leery of a French door since my repairman said to avoid them. I wish this repairman said which MANUFACTURERs to avoid and which to buy. Even if someone wanted a Freezer on Top...there is no manufacturer which makes anything decent - they are all cheap looking and very basic inside.
Hi Mile, thanks for watching, and thanks for the comment. Extra functional parts make the system work easier means less pressure, however, extra electronics make the system less reliable. In my own opinion still, French doors fridges are the best option but only if it’s as simple as possible. That's why we can't recommend Samsung or LG and even shot a separate video about the issues with Samsung fridges.
ua-cam.com/video/VCAgGEC-PUU/v-deo.html
So I would recommend GE as a budget option for a French door fridge and Bosch would be your second choice if you are ready to spend some extra $$.
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 What do you mean by "simple"? I am willing to spend the extra money if it means the French door refrigerator will LAST a long time without repair. I could care less about having a water dispenser or ice maker - in fact I would prefer to have neither. Is not having an ice maker or water dispenser in a refrigerator what you mean by getting a "Simple refrigerator"? Or, does simple mean something else?
Hi Mike, when we say simple we mean that you should not be looking at Samsung fridges that have lost of fancy built in electronics and missing on the main part of the fridge - keeping the food cool and fresh. From that perspective Bosch, Blomberg or Liebherr would be your choice. All these brands do is keeping the food cool and fresh. Nothing else!
Very enlightening
GE Cafe White quality? Stoves reliable , Fridge side by side counter depth ? Does the white paint hold up on the stove ?
Hi Ron, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. Typically GE fridges are reliable and we do recommend them. With regards to the white paint on the stove - I have never seen any issues with that.
Great advice thank you!
You are so welcome!
Thank you for this video. What is your opinion about Fisher Paykel refrigerators? If choosing between Whirlpool brands vs GE,
which of those do you prefer for reliability and no headaches? I don't want any water or even ice maker. I have a great RO system
and if I want ice, I will buy a countertop ice maker.
Hello and thanks for watching! Fisher & Paykel are really good fridges however before buying it please check what kind of warranty you are getting and who will be servicing your fridge in case something goes wrong. Not every appliance repair company can service Fisher & Paykel. With regards to Whirpool vs GE go with GE. It is more reliable and easier to service.
My freezer top Kitchenaid is still running after 30 years. Sadly they don’t make this model anymore. The new French doors basically have water and ice features taken up 1/3 of the space.
Same!!! What did you get?
Thanks for the video. Your opinion is very important. I notice the door at the bottom in some of that appliances are not very stables. As for example in some models of Ge. Others like the profile GE brand are very stables. But i saw the new Frigidare refrigerator and i like it design very much, what is your opinion about that model? I appreciate your answer. (The model that i saw was an independent Refrigerator). the freezer, they sell apart. (Each one is apart). I like this model a lot. Thsnks!!
Good afternoon, Garrick!
Thank you SO VERY much for responding! I greatly appreciate you taking the time to respond with your professional opinion. Do you have time for another question?
We currently have a GE Profile, side-by-side, PSS26PSTBDSS (15 yrs). Ice accumulates in the refrigerator on the wall behind the vegetable bin. Do you know what causes this and is there anything we can do (besides replacement) to stop/address this? Last December a GE certified repair person replaced the control board and defrost heater. The "repair" lasted 1 month and we're back to defrosting about every 2-4 weeks. The "repair" was about as effective as leaving the unit to defrost on its own!
Thank you for your time and comments!! From hot-n-sunny Texas! (101 today; will feel like 106!!)
Hi Margaret, It’s 💯 auto-defrost system issue .
It’s hard to say which component failed but it looks like tech replaced two most expensive parts and in general his approach was reasonable. However I would recommend you to call this tech back cause it must me under the repair warranty or request another tech to run the diagnosis of the fridge for you.
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 I
Hi, Garrick,
Well, I called. No sympathy there. To bring out a technician, it will cost $109. 😫. The warranty was good only for 30 days. I didn’t have an issue until 31 days later.
Get this, before the technician had left my house, he said, “Don’t call me again.”
Before I buy my next refrigerator, I will see who will do the servicing.
Thanks for all of your help, Garrick! m. 😎
that's sad. We don't do that kind of things to our clients. Anyway, thanks for watching and thanks for the questions. We have more videos to come that will help the home owners with maintaining home appliances. Stay tuned.
Now for the really important question...which brand do you like the most? Looking at this from reliability.
Thanks for watching and thanks for the question. GE is the budget is tight, Bosch or Blomberg if you can spend more
Thank you for honest reviews.
I have a Kenmore 27cu ft side-by-side, about 15 years old.
I had to replace the compressor starter twice now. Is there a good universal starter that is better than the OEM starter?
Hi Ronda, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. We recommend using only OEM parts and that's what we do when we fix appliances for our clients
Due to science it's been known for decades that a freezer on top is the most reliable fridge but people don't want that design. There is a reason why you find freezers on top in apartmens they also have the longest warranties because they don't break his offer.
Thanks, Rusty, for watching and for the comment! You are right freezer on top is thge most reliable type of fridge, however as I explained in my video it is alway the most user friendly design as you are facing all the time the section of the fridge which you don't use that often
Hey Gary, I'm from Bangladesh. Thank you for your informative video. Found you on a Google search result! Best of luck with life. 😇
Thank you for the video it was really good I personally prefer the French door refrigerator.
Hi Cesar! Thanks for watching and thanks for your comment!
This makes a lot of sense. Thank you.
You are very welcome and thanks for watching!
As long as I have food in fridge I don’t care what model is really 💪🏿🤚
:)))))
Hi is Bosch side by side Side-by-Side 6 KAG93AIEP good or not
My top fridge underneathe the drawer has water on it. What possibly cause the problem? My fridge model is Toshiba GRRF532WE-PGX(22).
Hello Fizah, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. More likely the issue is with a drain line. It’s clogged for some reason and defrosted ice is flowing inside of the compartment. You need to partly disassemble the fridge to have an access to the evaporator area to find and defrost the drain line.
Great video.
Thanks for watching and I am glad it was helpful!
what about the units that claim the freezer and the refrig. are cooled independently?
Hi Cat, thanks for good question! It’s one of a best option only in case there are two compressors. If unit has only one compressor with a dual evaporator system I would not recommend buying that. I hope it clarifies! Garrik.
Do you have a brand recommendation?
Hi J C. Thanks for watching and thanks for the question. on the budget side we would recommend looking at GE. If you are ready to spend more look at Bosch and Blomberg
Thank you for your reply. Is Fisher & Paykel a reliable brand in your experience?
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 I'm on a budget and I'm considering getting a GE refrigerator top freezer model. Had a Frigedare freezer top model only lasted 10yrs(probably the average life span). From Albuquerque,NM. Have read( from product reviews) that some GE refridgerators are on the noisy side.
Thank you for your excellent video. Have you had any customers having issues with their Samsung 580L Top Mount Freezer with Twin Cooling Plus SAM-RT18M6211SG? I am looking for new fridge and this model layout seems to meet my requirement but the brand's reputation has left me thinking, whether it's a Go or No Go. Thanks for your help.
Hello Poh Lin, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. We even shot a separate video about the common issues with the Samsung fridges.
ua-cam.com/video/VCAgGEC-PUU/v-deo.html
Any Samsung fridge is not recommended
LG also has good layout, same as Samsung, not reliable. Problem compressor, dead on 2nd year. Leaking compressor on 7th year. Refill coolant. I don’t even hook it with water outlet cos we don’t need the water n ice functions. I use it as a basic fridge. I love it has almost 30 cf and without water dispenser.
My Samsung bought new in 2008 has lasted 14 years & recently developed water in the crisper drawers, about every 5 days, not much, I can wipe up with 3-4 paper towels. I can live with that but it’s 21 cubic & way large for my needs. I have a chance to buy new top freezer, fits my needs, on sale for $779.00 with tax and 3 year warranty came to $990.00. I would buy another Samsung, bottom freezer but they start at $1500.00, uh, the price wasn’t in my budget.
What are the most reliable brands and quietest running of the French door style?
Hi Scott, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. If you are low on budget look at GE fridges, if you are ready to spend more then Bosch and Blomberg would be your best choice
Love your videos and your honesty. I thought that I had decided on a brand to buy, but servicing in my rural area is difficult. However, Electrolux/Frigidaire does have service here. Any thoughts about their French door, 36“ fridges? Is there really any difference between the two names, beside the price?
Hi Joseph, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. Electrolux and Frigidaire is the same manufacturer and the fridge you are referring to is good in general. No major glitches
I like your slight accent !
Thanks! 😃
Replaced thermostat and drain hole cover. Frooze again.Temp going up in freezer.unplugged ice maker and temp back to 0.What to do?
Hi Donna, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. You would need to defrost the drain line with a steamer. Something like that will be helpful
www.amazon.ca/Bissell-39N7H-Steam-Shot/dp/B00Q7WYLI2/ref=mp_s_a_1_17?crid=3LYO9IJ56S82U&keywords=steamer&pscroll=1&qid=1657461514&sprefix=steamer%2Caps%2C121&sr=8-17&wIndexMainSlot=25
Any thoughts on ikea fridges? I'm looking to get one but haven't seen too many reviews about them
Hi Don, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. IKEA doesn't manufacture the fridges. They just have a contract with someone who does that for them. As far as we know they have a contract with Whirlpool and Whirlpool makes all the appliances for them. If it didn't change then yes you can consider them. But if they switched to Samsung or LG then I would recommend just look for something else. On their website they don't say who the manufacturer of their appliances is so you may need to look on the label inside the fridge and it should tell you that. Or simply ask the sales rep at IKEA.
Whose refrigerator is best?
Fisher & faykal or beko or bosch?
Hi Kasi, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. Out of these three I would stick with Bosch. F&K are great as well but more expensive. Beko is yet to be launched in Canadian market so we don't have much experience with them however their parent company produces Blomberg fridges which are highly recommended.
Hi. We bought a new lg Model#: LRMXS3006S. If the freezer door is open for more than 5 seconds we hear a humming noise for a couple seconds after closing it. I'm assuming it's the compressor. This doesn't seem normal to me. Thoughts?
Hi Adam, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. It actually can be normal in case it has R600 refrigerant or if it could be evaporator fan kicks on. You better call manufacturer in case this unit is a new one do they might fix it under the warranty in case there is something wrong.
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 Thank you for taking the time to reply. Yes we called to report it and LG will be sending out a tech. I just wanted another unbiased opinion in case the tech said its no big deal.
I am glad we were helpful!
GOOD advice
Glad it was helpful!
I'm looking for a quiet refrigerator. Which of these types tends to run the quietest and which is the loudest?
Hi, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. The quietest fridges I’ve seen are Electrolux or Blomberg , the louder fridges are the ones using the R600a refrigerant, however within next few years it will be phased out so all most of the fridges will be quite as long as they are designed properly
I have the Frigidaire French doors with freezer on the bottom. I would not recommend. Ice developed on the outside of refrigerator in the back near the icemaker. The back of the refrigerator is rusty. I periodically use a steamer to remove the ice. It's my first and last Frigidaire appliance.
Hello Ka Cr, thanks for watching and thanks for the comment. To be honest, Frigidaire is a good manufacturer.
The issue is that an ice maker chamber is located inside of the fridge compartment.
Usually, this design itself causes that kind of issues. Samsung fridges all have that issue with ice-maker located inside the fridge compartment and not inside the freezer compartment.
Even if you buy another brand with the same ice maker location, more than likely, you’ll experience pretty much the same issue.
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 thank you so much for that explaination!!!! I love this, it really solved the reason why they have been failing!
Really nice video.
what size and type fridge you recommend for this space 950W 1850H 650D ?
Thanks for watching, Gurpreetpal and thanks for the question. I am sorry but I am afraid I will not be able to recommend something specific for this space and you will need to explore what is available on your market. However my general recommendation would be to look at GE (this is a good budget option) or Bosch (this is more expensive one).
Hi Garrik, so my family wants to buy a new fridge because we hear the simpler the better. But we still want a french door. And at least an ice maker thats not on the doors but in the freezer itself. We are also conisdering a top freezer fridge as well as long as it has an ice maker. What are some things to keep in mind? Is Frigidaire a good brand for either of these types of fridges? Are there any other recommendations you could possibly give?
Hi J D, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. Frigidaire /Electrolux is a good option as well as GE.
Great thumbs up
Thanks for watching!
I’m not sure about the side by side Not that I do it all the time but will a pizza box fit ?
Thanks for watching and thanks for the question, Robin. That's the issue with side-by-side. The box of frozen pizza will fit extremely tight. That's why French Door is a better option
You missed a huge downside to french doors, if you want a water/ice dispenser (which is important for me). fd fridges have a big, bulky ice maker in the fridge section. That is bad, more prone to failure.
a sxs has a smaller, more efficient ice maker in the freezer compartment where it belongs. far more reliable.
everything is easier to organize and more accessible in a sxs. and they are less expensive than comparable fd models. and yes, i use my freezer a lit more than twice a week!
Thank you for great informative video. I stopped at french door bottom freezer no water or ice maker i need, I am in new york in terms buying choices. I saw previos comments regarding bosh and other brands. What other brands and model would you reccomend in terms price quality and waranty time. Thank you
Hello R A, I am glad our video was helpful. if you are looking for more budget models then Bosch you can take a look on the brands manufactured by Whirpool (Whirpool, Amana, MayTag, KitchenAid). and the brands that you should NOT be considering at all are Samsung and LG.
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 thank you again for your hep. I was looking at beko it is Turkish brand very popular in Europe have you ever dealt with it? also GE brand any recommendation?
we don't deal much with beko as it is not distributed in Canada. However, beko is produced by the same company as Blomberg so it is a good one. And GE is a good choice. Nothing fancy with that brand but it is reliable.
Same! Curious what was your final decision ?
Garrik Everything you have just mentioned I have had problems with!!!, And now just the compressors went out they wanted charge me $800 to change it to a $100 compressor and yet this is supposed to be covered under the 10 year compression warranty what a rip off, My unit's 6 years old it's always had problems with the ice maker ever since I got it I was waiting for the class action lawsuit to combut right now I've got to buy another refrigerator can you tell me what is good, Or better yet who has the best warranty parts and labor that's what I'm looking for now!!!
Hi Tim, if you are looking for the budget option check GE fridges. They are solid. If you are ready to pay a bit more you can check Bosch or Blomberg.
I am going to get AGE refrigerator that's what it looks like as well I'm consumers report but then again consumers report is what led me to this nightmare that I am experiencing right now I must say it is the 1st time consumers report led me down the wrong path But yes G that warranties are better I know that and with my American Express card it doubles the warranty that's why I'm waiting to see about the mission I'm dealing with right now but I know I do want change it refrigerator
What about double door freezer on thr bottom?
Freezer once or twice a week??? Maybe 3-5 times a DAY if not per MEAL for us.
I actually have a French door in house, side by side on garage, and two upright freezers in garage . But I live in country.
it all depends of the life style. Thanks for the comment, though
😅
Any specific brands?
I have a Samsung counter depth refrigerator. Nothing but problems. Had it for 8 years. First top ice maker stop working. 2 bottom freezer always freezing up. 3 now top refrigerator freezer up. I put it manually in defrost a couple times a week. I’m done with it. I’m tired of taking it apart every couple of months defrosting it. What’s the most reliable counter depth refrigerator out right now?
When I bought it I remodeled my kitchen I got the Samsung. So I put my old GE refrigerator in garage for extra refrigerator still run’s like a champ. Probably had it for about at least 18 years.
Thanks, Chuck for your question and watching the video.
Design: as simple as possible
Country of origin: German stuff the most reliable
Budget wise: GE would be your least expensive option (you are 100% right - they last forever) and Bosch would be your more expensive option
2 days ago, i got GE 19.1 cu. Ft (GTE19jtnrww). Only 1 temperature setting knob controls top & bottom. Problem is on recommended setting, bottom is at 43F & top is at 14F. Not acceptable.Why could that be. Is Frigidaire 17.6 cu. Ft (#FRFG1723AV) better overall (reliable refrigerant & well oriented main control board)?
If i decide to buy a side by side GE instead of french with the botton door, botton( i dont like that design, )what is the best model? Also, you can recomiend me another brand too. I need to know so i can make a good decision.
Hello sir.Thank you this video was helpful.Soon I will be buying a brand new fridge.I'm not looking for a huge,super fancy(just me using it) but my main concern is noise.
I'm super sensitive to unnecessary noise,the fridge I have now is so bad at times,I'm ready to smash it to bits (its a Maytag).
I've been trying to gather information on noiseless fridges.Is no noise even possible?I scrolled through your videos but saw nothing on the topic.
Brand suggestions that are reasonably priced?Thank you.I'm a new subscriber.
Hello Kye, Thanks for watching and thanks for the good question. The best way to go is to inquire this information from the store/manufacturer cause usually they don’t like to post it online.
The other thing is cooling agent in the system. I found newer R600a systems are noisier comparing to traditional R134a.
It’s very complicated to say which brand is noisy and which is not just because there are good and bad models in each manufacturer. Generally we would recommend GE to our clients as a budget option. They have much less bugs and glitches than other budget options.
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 thank you for your reply.I will continue to watch your videos and learn.I was dreading watching videos about appliances because I didn't think I'd understand but you break it down and explain in a way that's easy to comprehend. Glad I found you!
I am glad we are helpful!!!
What refrigerators brands should I buy and which brand should we stay away from?
Hi Shawn, Garrik is here and thanks for the good question. It depends on your pocket but general rule - I recommend to buy as simple as possible with no horns and whistles. At the end of the day you need your food to stay cold or frozen - that's it. In terms of the brands I would recommend Bosch, Blomberg and Liebherr however those ones can be on a bit pricey side, still it is worth it. And you should stay away from Samsung - we repair tons of them and they can go down in 2-3 years from the time of the purchase.
So which is best brand that isn’t too high??
@@Hillbillydaddy11 hitachi
i was looking for brands i know that last. if you can afford . Bosch is a great brand but pricey. when i purchased mine i tried to remember the brands that still performed in the 80’s like electrolex . i couldnt find them. once i got my Frigidaire frig installed. i realized it was made by electrolex made in mexico. not america but not china either.
GE or Bosch
Have you worked with GE, LG, or Samsung refrigerators? I was thinking about getting a GE top freezer what you think
Hi Lidy, thanks for watching and for your question. GE is a good choice. LG and Samsunng - stay away
LG Brand or Liebherr brand??? Which is best
Liebherr for sure
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 I am from India.. buying in india is good??? Liebherr??
Liebherr is Liebherr everywhere :)
We've had our top freezer econo model for nearly 15 years. It works as well now as day one.
We have friends with a bottom freezer, French doors, top-of-the-line model, which cost a FORTUNE, and they've had nothing but trouble.
K.I.S.S. folks...works every time.
Thanks for watching and thanks for the comments. I am pretty sure that your friends own Samsung or LG so I am not surprised they have issue after issue.
Nice Video. Very informative. Can you please tell me what will be the best French door model in 33" wide design and counter depth. I can't go really high in price but want something with water dispenser outside. What will be the best time to buy. I want to buy full package for kitchen. Please suggest, I live in Chicago.
Hello Amarjeet, thanks for watching and thanks for the good question. In terms of brands we would recommend I suggest looking at Bosch, Blomberg and Liebherr. Bosch should be on lower price range side than another two. And Samsung would be the brand you should be careful with as they have quite a few glitches in the design and things can go wrong with Samsung easily. In terms of timing here in Calgary, AB we actually observe the shortage of the supply - you need to wait for the appliance you have chosen to be delivered. This is due to ongoing pandemic and longer time in production and transportation of the appliances. So timing doesn't really matter at this point and you need to look at the best solution that fits your needs.
Great video! What do you think of the bottom freezer (with a regular refr. door)?
Hi Layan, thanks for the question and those ones are also good. They have less space inside and opening one big door may not super convenient if your kitchen is tight. But other than that it is good option too. And that type of model usually is not as pricy as French door one and if you go with makes like Whirlpool or Amana they will last forever. You may want to want another video that we have just posted on repairing older Amana fridge - freezer on the bottom. ua-cam.com/video/ysNNmsvDxlI/v-deo.html
My wife was excited today when she thought my old basic white fridge was tore up because the door was not closing all the way. She wasn’t happy when I said ah I fixed it! It’s just a bottle of ketchup keeping it form closing all the way.
She’s really wanting new stainless appliances but my old ugly white stuff like my fridge has worked fine since I bought the house at least 18 years ago. Only issue is the ice maker drips in the freezer which ends up freezing and doesn’t ever leak out. I’m afraid if I buy a new one it’s going to be a piece of junk.
Thanks for watching and thanks for the question. You are right to the certain degree. These days you can still find a reliable fridge for any budget. but if your 18 years old works fine keep it and cherish it :)
Pro's versus Con's on a ice maker incapsulated on a door versus one inside the cabinet. In terms of reliability? Thanks. Very informative video.
Hi Dale, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. I would need both models so I can take deeper look and answer your question
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 GE profile PVD28BYNFS vs FRIGIDAIRE PRMC2285F. Thanks ❗❗❗
The first one seems to be more reliable from technical perspective, however, both of these models are good.
What refrigerant is used in new fridges, old ones used R12 sealed system last for years low pressures. Had Hotpoint 25 years still ran fine. Made in Mexico & China not good. Sealed systems warranty 1 year maybe,shows how well companies stand behind product. Most R12 fridges freezers 5 years sealed system.
Today obsolescence.
Hello Luna, thanks for watching and thanks for the comment.
Well, nowadays we still use R134a and finally switching to R400 series and R600.
And the warranty is the same as it used to be 5-10 years for compressor and sealed system components.
As for the quality, I guess that’s not a surprise for anyone that things getting cheaper to produce so more people can afford it. However, there are still good models you can find. In other words, you get what you are paying for.
I’m moving to Montana and will not have reliable repair people near by. What French door fridge should I buy for reliability and is 36 inch the most common measurement on fridge?
Hi Vic, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. The brand that you should stay away from is Samsung - generally not very reliable. And depending on your budget you can look at GE (low budget), Bosch (medium budget), Blomberg & Liebherr (high budget). Yes, 36 inch is a typical measurement but you better check with the place you will be living as it may differ
Is kitchenaid a good fridge brand?
Hi Lil, thanks for watching and thanks for the question. Unfortunately, overcomplicated and overpriced nowadays but used to be one of the best makes. Sorry for the bad news
I'm looking for fridge, what model would you recommend? budget 3-4.5k$( counterdep) 21-26cb
Hi Roman, thanks for the question and we would recommend you looking at Bosch and Liebherr. Blomberg would be not a bad option as well
open freezer once or twice per week? I open mine several times a day
:)
Feels like its a hard decision to choose a brand for me. I do want a french door but unable to decide on the brand to get a reliable, energy efficient fridge. Any suggestions and/or tips on brand choosing ?
I'm looking for a new fridge , what brand would you say has the best over all reliability ?
Hi Darrel, if you are looking for the budget option you may want to take a look at GE. However if you are ready to spend a bit more you may want to check Bosch and Blomberg. Sorry for the lat response
We have fridgedaire FGH2869LFA.ice maker and water work but freezing behind ice container and drain is frozen.Allowed to thaw and water drains to bottom pan
Hi Donna, I've responded on your question in another line
really like your explanations. Do you have a brand or a model that you think is the best refrigerator? we are looking to replace ours. Thank you
Hi Lynne, thanks for watching and i am glad it was helpful. With regards to the brands we would recommend Bosch, Blomberg, Liebherr. They are on higher price side but they worth it. Also i can tell which brand we would NOT recommend - Samsung fridges are not super reliable. Let me know if it helps.
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 No, I hadn't read this comment before I commented that I was considering Bosch. I'm refitting my kitchen completely, going with mostly Bosch, but seriously considering a Thermador (also a Bosch product) cooktop.
Bosch and Thermador are both really good!!!
ice maker is more reliable and gives less problems with side by side because it's in the freezer side.
I pray the gas ranges and not as bad as the refrigerators yes I screwed up and bought one I didn't know a little bit after I bought the new range the refrigerator started going Bad
that's too bad!
Thank you very much for responding chief I appreciate your videos enjoy them
Thanks for watching and staying with us, Tim!
Great vid. Is a freezer on bottom worse than freezer on top??????????????. you inferred the top freezer was better.
Thanks for watching and thanks for the question! Freezer at the bottom is not a bad option. It is similar to French door ones but a bit smaller. From usability perspective it is quite convenient as well. Just keep in mind that the door is wider so you will need more space to open it. And in terms of potential repair it is easy to handle. Freezer on top is usually very basic model and it is hard to use as you always need to bend to get things in and out but freezer on top is inexpensive option. Let me know if it clarifies.
@@techvillappliancerepair3825 Thanks for all that info. Certainly gone off the side by side.