I had one of these. When the piston gets hot (about 15min in), the resistance goes away. After about 3 months of daily use, the resistance disappeared entirely, so I got a "proper" machine. But it gave me the habit of getting up and working out every day, 15 lbs of weight loss, and the cardio health to keep going. For that reason, I will always love it.
Same. I actually still have this machine and I use it regularly. I also have an older two hand pistol rower i picked up at a fleamarket. I havent been able to get a concept 2 cuz they overprice. For the price of 1 of those i can get 5 of these amazon ones. But i have gone to the gym n try the concept 2 n have done pretty good on there. This cheap machine helped me get back into fitness slowly n helping me recover from injury for me it fits its purposes. Also i notice that abt the resistance i no longer have a 12 level of resistances. I go with u gotta do what i can into u can do better then u do better!!! 💪
Same. I’ve had it for 2 weeks, and I like the workout it gives me. I “row” 4 days a week for 30 minutes, and you’re right, the piston gets super hot! I have to keep cranking the resistance up throughout the workout because if that. The best thing about this machine is that it’s made me fall in love with the act of rowing, which led me here as I research new rowers. 🚣♀️🚣♀️🚣♀️
You’d be right there. I have this machine, and at 5’ 4” with no aspirations to become an olympian rower, it suits my purposes to a T. It’s a light workout with muscle toning in mind.
I have had this machine for about 3 months and bought it for CAD 140. Unless you are 6'8'', you should be good. I am 6 feet tall and this is perfect for me. The built quality so far is good, for the price I paid, I won't be whiney as long as it does its job. I live in an apartment and I do not have enough space for anything larger than this. This sits perfectly in my living area and can be folded and put aside if I have any guests visiting. I think the gentleman should have titled it "This is the CHEAPEST Rower - Worth it if you are taller than 6'1''?" This machine has helped me get an exercise routine as I work from home all week and having this is very convenient. For the people who are looking for a very cheap rowing machine that works, go for it.
Can you get your heart rate above 150 pretty easily with this rower? How high can you get your heart rate? Does it get you really out of breath on max resistance?
@@bmp713 @Brandon it has 1-12 resistance settings. If I do this for 30 minutes on max, I am out of breath and sweat easily. I have never checked my heartrate after or during the rowing so I don't know. For already fit people, 30 minutes on max setting may not be enough, I think that this machine is for beginners who just want a cheap way to workout at home and don't have lot of room to keep a bigger machine. I live in an apartment so this is the perfect size to keep and move when I have any guests. If space is not a problem and you are not a beginner, go for the bigger model from same company. The OP of this video has a review for that on his channel.
Just to put this review in perspective,,, I'm a 5' 6" woman (with 'normal' size 8 foot lol) and I'm loving this machine and I use it more like a weight training machine (using slower motion at higher tension setting) than for cardio (faster motion at lower tension). Besides being super quiet, I found I got an incredible workout (my leg and butt muscles were sore after the first short tryout),,, especially if engaging my core muscles. The tension adjuster is also easy to reach from a sitting position so no need to get up to change it. While it may not be a 'pro' machine with a digital meter which calculates your full range of motion, most of us don't need or use that, as it's clear without it if we're getting that. Oh,, and to RESET the digital meter, just hold down that big red button for a couple of seconds. Easy, peasy :)
Thank u for this review lady. I was thrown off a bit about his review but one thing I noticed is he is rather tall. Which does matter. My machine is supposed to be here Tuesday so ...im hoping for ur success.
I am 68 and quite out of shape from years of letting a bad back heal. I just want to GET ME MOVING, engage as many muscles as possible in ONE exercise, not take up a lot of space and something that someone on social security can afford. I USED to be 5'6" so this is VERY HELPFUL to let me know that it is probably the EXACT MACHINE that someone like ME needs ;-D
Can you get your heart rate above 150 pretty easily with this rower? How high can you get your heart rate? Does it get you really out of breath on max resistance?
I love this cheapo. It does the job and doesn't cost the earth. I'm 6ft and find it ok. The resistance does go a bit but it's hydraulic and hydraulic things need attention from time to time and re-oiling is one of those jobs you keep on top of.
@@bmp713 Yes I could straighten my legs all the way. The resistance wasn't very good on mine but I think i was just unlucky and got a dodgy machine. Evenso saying that, If I go on it for 30 mins then yes I'm out of breath and sweating. Using this machine and cutting out certain foods and eating bananas instead of having crsips etc I managed to lose 3 stone in 3 months.
@@bmp713 I kept some foam from packaging and put that under the back and front stands. It was really quiet and didn't disturb anyone in our house. If you can't get foam I suggest you try cardboard.
Can you get your heart rate above 150 pretty easily with this rower? How high can you get your heart rate? Does it get you really out of breath on max resistance?
...i'm 5-10 and this has been a great find ...only around $85 and works great ...sure spend more if you can but for this price it is very solid and a good workout...plus good size for my condo
Can you get your heart rate above 150 pretty easily with this rower? How high can you get your heart rate? Does it get you really out of breath on max resistance?
Not all of us are top form athletes. I am a 60 year old female, I use this machine in 30 minute clips at a high resistance. (no piston problems) It gets my heart ticking (cardio) and compliments my vertical leg press and olympic bar. This is an essential part of my home gym even though I don't get a "full stroke", I feel great afterwards! I love this cheapo!
I love this cheapo too. 😅 This will just be an experiment for me so I definitely don't want a big expensive one. & if I like it & keep liking it, I'll slowly get fancier & fancier one's but for now I just need this cute little thing. ☺️
So this is pretty much a BS video since he's too big for the machine. What he should've done was gotten a smaller assistant To truly demonstrate the machine
Im 1,90m and my girlfriend bought it. I love this little thing for short sessions and warmup. If you don't have space, its great to do something in a short time, maybe while watching news on TV. For me it is worth the money. Better than doing nothing.👍
A person your size would not normally use this machine. Show the steps with a woman about 5’ 5” weighing about 130 lb. I bought one of these and so far I’m loving it. With your size, you just make it look ridiculous.
Agreed! I'm 5' 1" 175 and I think this would work just fine for me (just finished setting it up and got it for a steal @ $26). I read plenty of reviews on Amazon before getting it and I think for the price I paid it'll work just fine for getting some sort of workout in once a day
@@melanifaith I am 5’5” & love it. I have been using it for about five months. It actually provides a decent workout & has assisted with me losing weight.
I think this is a great starter rower for normal sized noobs. I am a normal sized noob. I paid $50 for it I have always wanted a rowing machine, but can't afford a nice one. I would recommend it for beginners of normal size. 😁
@bmp713 my partner is 6 ft and they are pretty cramped on it. If you can afford a better machine I'd do that. Unless you can get it cheap like I did. Hope that helps you 😊
I would love to see a video done on this machine with a person who is shorter and a better fit for this rower...Its very obvious its not going to work for someone tall like you are...Its a cheap rower but might work for a senior or shorter person whose not into fitness like you are... I realize it doesnt have the bells and whistle like the more expensive but would it work for someone who is not into fitness but just want some movement for senoirs whose not active..
Well, I’m 5’7” I guess it could work for me. I want to get a Concept but let be honest, I’ve never worked out on my life, owned treadmills, bikes, etc and ended giving all of them away 🙄 so I prefer to spend $100 on this and see if it works for me. Then I’ll upgrade. 😹🤞🏻
I think you have the right idea! This machine is goodnuff’ for people like us and if we surprise ourselves and really become fitness buffs, then we can upgrade.
If you still have this machine, i'd be interesting if you could try to remove the rubber stop on the seat's back/rear position. Should allow you to stretch your legs fully. And in you know someone with a welder, have the arm extended by 4-6 in, so you can do a full stroke. Just to know how you'd like it, if it fits you. I know it's still kinda crap, but it's compact and silent. 2 big factors when you live in a small apartment..... It would still be a lot better that having zero concept2 rowers, right...??? Like the used to say about cameras: The best camera, is the one you have with you.... Likewise, I'd argue that the best rower is the one you can afford and have room for. Not the fancy one still sitting in Amazons warehouse...
This is a fine machine for the price,its about managing expectations.What do you expect for 80 bucks ? Most of the complaints here are due to this guys height. I'm 6'1" and it fits me pretty well. and the thing i like most is that unlike any other rower i can stand it up and stick it in a corner. am i going to replace it eventually with something "nicer"? yes. but for the time being and for the price, it gets the job done.
I think it's good for maintenance fitness for shorter people. I also believe it's for 20min max sessions as the hydraulic gets hot. I would recommend this for people who just want to do a little cardio and low impact fitness. It's not for athletes. Just the average Jo on a budget.
Can you get your heart rate above 150 pretty easily with this rower? How high can you get your heart rate? Does it get you really out of breath on max resistance?
I considered lower end rowers before I decided to go for the concept 2, but all over the internet id encounter reviews for the cheaper rowers saying they were poorly made or that they broke quickly, and just get the concept 2 instead. Its a lot of money, but the concept 2 is the whole package, great build quality, excellent monitor with loads of useful metrics. There is a reason professional athletes use it, its the best.
@BynieBani Sunny is one of the top brands in rowing machines. If you go on their website, you'll see they have several rowers that have the same quality and features of the Concept 2, depending on your budget.
pelleper “Same quality” might be an overstatement. I’ll tell you the model I have has a very basic display monitor. I have seen others with details similar to a concept 2 on the Sunny website
@@420Bassist The pm5 isn't a technical wonder but it works. It's the overall quality that is hard to beat. It's the most popular rower in competition, that says a lot.
Separating out the specific parts and tools for each of the seven step assembly process steps was brilliant on the part of the manufacturer. For the price, I am impressed at how sturdy this ua-cam.com/users/postUgkxvObaTzoHoHQLL4lHbJQmExHqsrZQm-f7 unit is and it does go together easily. Well, I was puzzled at first at Step 5 and maybe the instructions should mention that rail #62 needs to be tilted upwards a little to get the rail to fit into the main part #44. I like it that the rower can be stored vertically in a really small amount of space, but be forewarned that this rower is top heavy and for safety you'll need at least two bungee cords to keep the unit upright, attaching them to something; in my case to a third garage door. I have had this unit only a short time, and I will post an update once I've had it for a year. As for working your legs, I have to admit that I'm mainly rowing for upper body strength and I use other forms of exercise for leg strength (like walking fast, biking, or using a trampoline. But if you pull as far forward as possible, then you can give preference to your legs for the first 4 feet or so of travel. I also admit to not taking the two electronic connectors apart at Step 7. I simply inserted the two batteries while the other parts remained connected. By the way, there is plenty of resistance here, even in the lowest resistance settings. Kudos to Sunny Health & Fitness !
Ok so some of you may laugh at me and what not. I bought that same machine few years back and i still use it. That machine was made for a beginner and for most 5'5 of height. They have another one that the back piece extends out for people slightly taller. For a beginner it does help at least to build up go a routine or get basically ideas for it. The thing abt the seat 100% truth the fabric did rip and teared up at the bottom after 2months of using it. I still have it and i still use it on n off. The concept 2 is a very wonderful machine n yes top of the line but it's also hell of expensive it's only minor flaw is the amount of $.
Thanks, Vanessa! Again, your info gives me courage that this machine would be fine for a beginner and someone who may never get beyond that beginner point, considering my age and health limitations. ;-D
@@vanessa8282vr I got one at about 50% more in cost but still affordable. It is PERFECT for those of us who just need to MOVE a little more than what we have been doing! And the one we got is long enough that my 6'3" tall son can use it, also. ;-D
What about for a 40 year old 5’4” 180 lb non athletic woman who just needs to move and knees can’t handle a treadmill too much but also needs resistance training at home?
You too big for the machine. The rower is for normal sizes people. It is not meant to compete with the Concept 2 but if you need to get a good 15 to 20 min workout in your daily routine, this inexpensive rower can work. If your into high end rowing the $1400 concept 2 if not. $ 79 may be a good deal
Can you get your heart rate above 150 pretty easily with this rower? How high can you get your heart rate? Does it get you really out of breath on max resistance?
I recently trash picked this machine BY (not IN) a dumpster. I believe this is a beginner machine which suits me fine, especially since I’m a foot shorter than this guy(5 foot eight). My machine appears to have been little used and it works fine. What I like about it is that it keeps track of the “total count” of repetitions since the machine was new. That’s like a car odometer keeping track of every single mile since the car was new. I like that! To reset, hold the red button until you see all zeros. But does anybody know what the “scan” function is about?
Can you get your heart rate above 150 pretty easily with this rower? How high can you get your heart rate? Does it get you really out of breath on max resistance?
I think you should review something for someone 6'8" and nothing something for average height people. "Normal" size people will find this machine perfect.
Dear Austin, thanks for this review. It confirms my conclusion that the Concept 2 is the most elegant piece of training equipment available -- and pound-for-pound, one of the least expensive.
Austin - the most entertaining yet honest informative video on UA-cam! The best advice though is you don’t have to sell a kidney to buy a brand new rower - I kept scanning eBay and after a few months got a brilliant Concept2 E at a very low price. In 2.5 years I’ve done 1300KM without it missing a beat (just give it some tlc maintenance) 😎
I often disagree with people when they say " it's better than nothing," and I think this is an example where that is true. I'd rather wait and save, or buy a used Concept 2; quality usually ends up being cheaper in the long run as well. Since I've owned one for several trouble free years, that's not a concern though.
@@christopherjackson3455 Yes, you're right, it has to allow you to use proper technique at least. The only other thing though is, if it's like bicycles, there is a certain minimum price point where it goes from a piece of crap that is difficult to work on, to something that not only is more fun to ride, but will last a lifetime. Of course the difference between a $250 bike to a $1500 bike is greater than the difference between a $4,000 bike and a $10,000 bike.
I thought real hard about this back when I was picking out my first rowing machine... I'm glad I went with the concept2, even though it's 15x the price.
What did you do with it after the video? Did you throw it in the dumpster, sell it, or just keep it? Lol. I did think about getting one of those, but it seems like even if you're the right size you wouldn't be able to do the proper row technique due to the way the handle bar moves. So I've just now ended up buying an Opti Magnetic Rowing Machine for £230. It'll arrive tomorrow so I'm pretty excited about it. While still not the best rowing machine you can buy, hopefully it should be good enough for me as I just want to start doing cardio, I'll probably get a cross trainer as well for the variation. Already got some free weights and a bench for building strength and muscle, so it looks like I'll end up with a mini gym once I've got a rowing machine and a cross trainer too. :)
Being 5'8 and 175 pounds, and I no longer enjoy gyms, I use this as part of my home gym circuit workout for 10 minutes along with my weight bench and elliptical. For my height and weight it fits my home needs after a long work day of sitting at a desk.
Can you get your heart rate above 150 pretty easily with this rower? How high can you get your heart rate? Does it get you really out of breath on max resistance?
This looks really stiff und kinda uncomfortable. Even the "rowing" is ... whatever it is ^^. I use the Concept 2 and it is just perfect. It is waaay more expensive, but it is totally worth it.
I'm 6' and I agree most exercise machines and life in general I.e. motorcycles,cars,beds are made for people 5'8. I even have to modify everything to fit me. Let alone 6'8! I stand up all day at work so sitting and rowing sounds fun! I bet if you cut this and lengthen it with square tubing it would be a cool machine!
Hey Austin, that was a pretty diplomatic review, all things considered. I would like to see you review the Hydrow. From what I can tell it's more of a subscription deal, but I wonder how the machine feels.
I'm using the bodymax r70i rowing machine, I find it fantastic and people have reviewed commenting that the level 1 resistance is equal to a level 4-5 on concept, it has 16 levels of magnetic and air resistance and a price of 429-500£, I would love an honest opinion though as I'm fairly new to rowing and can have the resistance on a 7 fairly comfortably however my resting heart as always been good in the 40s bpm so I'd say I'm fairly fit would just like the comparison to the concept :)
I guess, from my personal point of view/experience, that two of the most valuable and affordable "at home" rowing machines are the V-Fit Tornado and its previous version, Artemis. At least here in Europe, they've bene Amazon's choice for quite sometime and a sure hit on the UK market.. give It a try! I got myself a "Tornado" and it's overall pretty good, although a guy as tall as you, would still have some "issue" on it. Cheers 👍
Can you get your heart rate above 150 pretty easily with this rower? How high can you get your heart rate? Does it get you really out of breath on max resistance?
Thanks for this review. I had a hard time finding a rowing machine that would fit my apartment and weight. I had a budget for the Concept2 but literally not enough space in my apartment. Being a single Mom of a 18 month old and working full time does not allow for gym time so I needed something I could do at home. I had about 5 feet available (I'm only 5'9" so the length works for me) and weigh over 250 lbs. I settled on the Sunny Health RW5639 full motion rowing machine. I know it's not the best (I still have my eye on the Concept2) but it is the best fit for my life right now and I will upgrade when I'm able. Any chance you could review the full motion? Thanks again for your content, you were a big part of my starting rowing in the first place! 🙂
@@Breadbored. Yes, it works pretty well for me. You're right, it's better than no machine and I needed to do something. I'm not a professional rower or fitness buff, just an overweight Mom who needed to start moving her ass. It gives me a better work out than making excuses about why I wasn't exercising. 😉 I still plan on upgrading to the Concept2 at some point. I know it's the best. 🙂
J H, Glad you are able to get some use out of this machine, but any rower that does not have a mechanism for storing momentum (such as the flywheel of the Concept II or the water in a WaterRower) is going to be torturous to use on a consistent long term basis. The difference between this and a real rowing machine is like night and day. Also, note, the Concept II will stand up on its end, so only requires about 3'x2' of floor space for storage (to be fair, you will need about 2'x8' when in use).
@@rowhsv Hi there and thanks. I don't have this machine. I have a RW5639 full motion (see original comment). I researched all row machines and wanted to get the Concept2 but I took a tape measure to my tiny apartment and there is not a room where I can use it. Use, not store. I am not trying to be a rower, I am just trying to move in a way that does not cause stress and pain to my joints so that I can stick with moving. As I said, I agree that the Concept2 is the best and will eventually get one when I have a larger living space. Thanks again, the passion that Concept2 owners have for their machine just confirms my plan to move in that direction. 🙂
That video is amazing, man, thanks. I'd like to see more of this until we find the best price/performance machine on Amazon. As a person who is intended to buy his own machine, but can't really spend four-digits, this will be amazingly helpful.
Hi, thanks for all the nice informal videos. Have you made any tests of "low priced" machines that actually are worth their money? Wish I could afford a Concept, but even used they're too pricey for me. I've been scanning the internet, but it's a jungle out there - and finding a place to try just some out is impossible.
I’m interested in the Schwinn for my other space. Can’t tell if the forward position is made for short arms like Water Rower. Nothing beats my Concept2.
No, sorry. I’m sure this rower is not for you...dude, you’re 6 foot 8 inches. Just as I wouldn’t consider your review of a Toyota Corolla, I can’t use this review.
I am a 68yr old 5ft 6in size 7 shoe blah blah blah. This machine is one of the best economical machine I have had. Its robust enough for a beginner to intermediate user. I certainly am not training for the next camridge boat race. I just want to get a bit fitter, a bit more healthy and to lose a few pounds. I Definately would recommend this to anyone looking for something that fits those catagories. UNFAIR BIASED REVIEW in my opinion.
OK I'll bite .... but l wont chew. Hard to swallow seeing you on this rower .... A honest review indeed. Glad there are other options. Long Live the Concept. Still enjoy learning from your other training videos , well done Training Tall.
Hello, you have really got me interested in rowing and I have decided to get one for home. I have you & many folks saying get the Concept2, but do you have any experience with the Pro-Form 750R? They offer a great program of $39 a month membership to their fitness program and after 3 years ($1404) you own the rower. I like the idea of the interactive videos Pro-Form offers. Any comments would be grateful.
Hey Austin! Short & amateur here! Your videos have come very handy =] I'd like to know your opinion on the SF-RW5622 Magnetic Rowing Machine by Sunny Health & Fitness Have a good one! ;)
I wish you'd have put a smaller person (say, a woman) on this and done the review beside her or something, so we could have seen an average person on it :)
What do you think about the cheap water rowers on alibaba? They sell for $200-$300. They look like they're quality, but I also don't have much experience rowing.
I had one of these. When the piston gets hot (about 15min in), the resistance goes away. After about 3 months of daily use, the resistance disappeared entirely, so I got a "proper" machine. But it gave me the habit of getting up and working out every day, 15 lbs of weight loss, and the cardio health to keep going. For that reason, I will always love it.
Love that it got you into a good habit and routine! Thanks for sharing your experience with the machine!
Wow great job!!
Same. I actually still have this machine and I use it regularly. I also have an older two hand pistol rower i picked up at a fleamarket. I havent been able to get a concept 2 cuz they overprice. For the price of 1 of those i can get 5 of these amazon ones. But i have gone to the gym n try the concept 2 n have done pretty good on there. This cheap machine helped me get back into fitness slowly n helping me recover from injury for me it fits its purposes. Also i notice that abt the resistance i no longer have a 12 level of resistances. I go with u gotta do what i can into u can do better then u do better!!! 💪
how tall are you? and after the first fifteen minutes does it just give up
Same. I’ve had it for 2 weeks, and I like the workout it gives me. I “row” 4 days a week for 30 minutes, and you’re right, the piston gets super hot! I have to keep cranking the resistance up throughout the workout because if that.
The best thing about this machine is that it’s made me fall in love with the act of rowing, which led me here as I research new rowers. 🚣♀️🚣♀️🚣♀️
He looks like if Jim Carrey and Jared Leto had a baby lol
That is funny.
My exact thoughts 😅
Instead of him trashing why it's not good for tall people what about positivity on this machine for short people
Yeah everything is weird becasue it's too small for the giant man
🤣😂😅 omg I was litterally just thinking that !!!! Lmfao!
Give me Concept, or give me death.
In fairness to the machine getting someone of 6 8 to test it is about as useful as getting you to test a size 7 shoe
Haha true! But shoes come in different sizes!!
You’d be right there. I have this machine, and at 5’ 4” with no aspirations to become an olympian rower, it suits my purposes to a T. It’s a light workout with muscle toning in mind.
Its advertised as a compact , foldable rower. Useful for apartments I guess not 6 feet 8 people .
I have had this machine for about 3 months and bought it for CAD 140. Unless you are 6'8'', you should be good. I am 6 feet tall and this is perfect for me.
The built quality so far is good, for the price I paid, I won't be whiney as long as it does its job.
I live in an apartment and I do not have enough space for anything larger than this. This sits perfectly in my living area and can be folded and put aside if I have any guests visiting.
I think the gentleman should have titled it "This is the CHEAPEST Rower - Worth it if you are taller than 6'1''?"
This machine has helped me get an exercise routine as I work from home all week and having this is very convenient.
For the people who are looking for a very cheap rowing machine that works, go for it.
Can you get your heart rate above 150 pretty easily with this rower? How high can you get your heart rate?
Does it get you really out of breath on max resistance?
@@bmp713 @Brandon it has 1-12 resistance settings. If I do this for 30 minutes on max, I am out of breath and sweat easily. I have never checked my heartrate after or during the rowing so I don't know. For already fit people, 30 minutes on max setting may not be enough, I think that this machine is for beginners who just want a cheap way to workout at home and don't have lot of room to keep a bigger machine. I live in an apartment so this is the perfect size to keep and move when I have any guests. If space is not a problem and you are not a beginner, go for the bigger model from same company. The OP of this video has a review for that on his channel.
Just to put this review in perspective,,, I'm a 5' 6" woman (with 'normal' size 8 foot lol) and I'm loving this machine and I use it more like a weight training machine (using slower motion at higher tension setting) than for cardio (faster motion at lower tension). Besides being super quiet, I found I got an incredible workout (my leg and butt muscles were sore after the first short tryout),,, especially if engaging my core muscles. The tension adjuster is also easy to reach from a sitting position so no need to get up to change it. While it may not be a 'pro' machine with a digital meter which calculates your full range of motion, most of us don't need or use that, as it's clear without it if we're getting that. Oh,, and to RESET the digital meter, just hold down that big red button for a couple of seconds. Easy, peasy :)
Thank u for this review lady. I was thrown off a bit about his review but one thing I noticed is he is rather tall. Which does matter. My machine is supposed to be here Tuesday so ...im hoping for ur success.
I am 68 and quite out of shape from years of letting a bad back heal. I just want to GET ME MOVING, engage as many muscles as possible in ONE exercise, not take up a lot of space and something that someone on social security can afford. I USED to be 5'6" so this is VERY HELPFUL to let me know that it is probably the EXACT MACHINE that someone like ME needs ;-D
I just got mine and this is my intentional use for it. Thanks for the tips. It should be perfect for a 5’4” fairly fit 65 year old woman.
I have this machine as well. I'm also a 5'6 woman, my guy is 5'10. We both use it daily and get a really decent work out. Can beat it for the price!
Can you get your heart rate above 150 pretty easily with this rower? How high can you get your heart rate?
Does it get you really out of breath on max resistance?
I'm 4'10 113lbs I think this would work perfect for me starting off..better than no work out
I love this cheapo. It does the job and doesn't cost the earth. I'm 6ft and find it ok. The resistance does go a bit but it's hydraulic and hydraulic things need attention from time to time and re-oiling is one of those jobs you keep on top of.
Can you straighten your legs all the way? How long does the piston last and is the resistance strong enough to get really out of breath?
@@bmp713 Yes I could straighten my legs all the way. The resistance wasn't very good on mine but I think i was just unlucky and got a dodgy machine. Evenso saying that, If I go on it for 30 mins then yes I'm out of breath and sweating. Using this machine and cutting out certain foods and eating bananas instead of having crsips etc I managed to lose 3 stone in 3 months.
@@bmp713 I kept some foam from packaging and put that under the back and front stands. It was really quiet and didn't disturb anyone in our house. If you can't get foam I suggest you try cardboard.
Can you get your heart rate above 150 pretty easily with this rower? How high can you get your heart rate?
Does it get you really out of breath on max resistance?
...i'm 5-10 and this has been a great find ...only around $85 and works great ...sure spend more if you can but for this price it is very solid and a good workout...plus good size for my condo
Can you get your heart rate above 150 pretty easily with this rower? How high can you get your heart rate?
Does it get you really out of breath on max resistance?
Not all of us are top form athletes. I am a 60 year old female, I use this machine in 30 minute clips at a high resistance. (no piston problems) It gets my heart ticking (cardio) and compliments my vertical leg press and olympic bar. This is an essential part of my home gym even though I don't get a "full stroke", I feel great afterwards! I love this cheapo!
Yeah most of his critiques were related to his massive size. I'm also not going to pay much attention to a 6'8" guy in a ford focus.
I love this cheapo too. 😅 This will just be an experiment for me so I definitely don't want a big expensive one. & if I like it & keep liking it, I'll slowly get fancier & fancier one's but for now I just need this cute little thing. ☺️
So this is pretty much a BS video since he's too big for the machine. What he should've done was gotten a smaller assistant To truly demonstrate the machine
Im 1,90m and my girlfriend bought it. I love this little thing for short sessions and warmup. If you don't have space, its great to do something in a short time, maybe while watching news on TV. For me it is worth the money. Better than doing nothing.👍
A person your size would not normally use this machine. Show the steps with a woman about 5’ 5” weighing about 130 lb. I bought one of these and so far I’m loving it. With your size, you just make it look ridiculous.
💯
Agreed! I'm 5' 1" 175 and I think this would work just fine for me (just finished setting it up and got it for a steal @ $26). I read plenty of reviews on Amazon before getting it and I think for the price I paid it'll work just fine for getting some sort of workout in once a day
Agreed. I love mine!!
@@melanifaith I am 5’5” & love it. I have been using it for about five months. It actually provides a decent workout & has assisted with me losing weight.
I agree
I have it and it works Wonderful
Can I ask does it break down quick? As in start squeaking or anything? And is the seat uncomfortable?
I think this is a great starter rower for normal sized noobs. I am a normal sized noob. I paid $50 for it I have always wanted a rowing machine, but can't afford a nice one. I would recommend it for beginners of normal size. 😁
Do you think this machine would work well for steady state cardio 30+ minutes a 6 foot 2?
Do you think I would be able to extend my legs all the way?
@bmp713 my partner is 6 ft and they are pretty cramped on it. If you can afford a better machine I'd do that. Unless you can get it cheap like I did. Hope that helps you 😊
Am I the only one who was waiting for him to say "AllllllRighty then"? No? Really?
Hahaha
@@trainingtall Said with love, brother...
🤣 Yesss!!
I'm 5' 8". This machine is great.
I would love to see a video done on this machine with a person who is shorter and a better fit for this rower...Its very obvious its not going to work for someone tall like you are...Its a cheap rower but might work for a senior or shorter person whose not into fitness like you are... I realize it doesnt have the bells and whistle like the more expensive but would it work for someone who is not into fitness but just want some movement for senoirs whose not active..
Well, I’m 5’7” I guess it could work for me. I want to get a Concept but let be honest, I’ve never worked out on my life, owned treadmills, bikes, etc and ended giving all of them away 🙄 so I prefer to spend $100 on this and see if it works for me. Then I’ll upgrade. 😹🤞🏻
I would recommend something a bit more quality than this! It doesn't show you any good metrics to track and improve upon :(
I think you have the right idea! This machine is goodnuff’ for people like us and if we surprise ourselves and really become fitness buffs, then we can upgrade.
did you end up getting this rowing machine? i’m looking to start getting into it
This is definitely my plan too. I’m only 5’1 so all the negatives don’t apply 😂 I also have a fitness watch. So that helps.
@@zacfensome9245 yes I did. Used it a couple of times and it worked great.
If you still have this machine, i'd be interesting if you could try to remove the rubber stop on the seat's back/rear position. Should allow you to stretch your legs fully.
And in you know someone with a welder, have the arm extended by 4-6 in, so you can do a full stroke.
Just to know how you'd like it, if it fits you. I know it's still kinda crap, but it's compact and silent. 2 big factors when you live in a small apartment..... It would still be a lot better that having zero concept2 rowers, right...??? Like the used to say about cameras: The best camera, is the one you have with you.... Likewise, I'd argue that the best rower is the one you can afford and have room for. Not the fancy one still sitting in Amazons warehouse...
This is a fine machine for the price,its about managing expectations.What do you expect for 80 bucks ? Most of the complaints here are due to this guys height. I'm 6'1" and it fits me pretty well. and the thing i like most is that unlike any other rower i can stand it up and stick it in a corner. am i going to replace it eventually with something "nicer"? yes. but for the time being and for the price, it gets the job done.
you're 6'1 and this works? damn i feel re-assured as i'm 5'9 and was concerned i'd be too tall for this!
I think it's good for maintenance fitness for shorter people. I also believe it's for 20min max sessions as the hydraulic gets hot. I would recommend this for people who just want to do a little cardio and low impact fitness. It's not for athletes. Just the average Jo on a budget.
Can you get your heart rate above 150 pretty easily with this rower? How high can you get your heart rate?
Does it get you really out of breath on max resistance?
I considered lower end rowers before I decided to go for the concept 2, but all over the internet id encounter reviews for the cheaper rowers saying they were poorly made or that they broke quickly, and just get the concept 2 instead. Its a lot of money, but the concept 2 is the whole package, great build quality, excellent monitor with loads of useful metrics. There is a reason professional athletes use it, its the best.
I realized pretty early on in my researching buying a rower that it's go big with the concept 2 or go home.
@BynieBani Sunny is one of the top brands in rowing machines. If you go on their website, you'll see they have several rowers that have the same quality and features of the Concept 2, depending on your budget.
@@420Bassist Same quality as a concept 2?
Show me.
PS, I can't find any sunny rowers in any gym I've been to.
pelleper “Same quality” might be an overstatement. I’ll tell you the model I have has a very basic display monitor. I have seen others with details similar to a concept 2 on the Sunny website
@@420Bassist The pm5 isn't a technical wonder but it works.
It's the overall quality that is hard to beat.
It's the most popular rower in competition, that says a lot.
@@420Bassist no thanks.
So I just wanna confirm that as long as you’re not as tall as this guy the rowing machine should be good for you right?
If this doesn’t prove that you can’t trust Amazon reviews, nothing will.
100%%%%%%%!!!!!
Amazon is the only company I trust for unbiased reviews. Let’s hope they keep that way.
If this doesn’t and can’t not prove that you can trust amazon then you can’t cannot trust amazon reviews then I can’t see what will.
Separating out the specific parts and tools for each of the seven step assembly process steps was brilliant on the part of the manufacturer. For the price, I am impressed at how sturdy this ua-cam.com/users/postUgkxvObaTzoHoHQLL4lHbJQmExHqsrZQm-f7 unit is and it does go together easily. Well, I was puzzled at first at Step 5 and maybe the instructions should mention that rail #62 needs to be tilted upwards a little to get the rail to fit into the main part #44. I like it that the rower can be stored vertically in a really small amount of space, but be forewarned that this rower is top heavy and for safety you'll need at least two bungee cords to keep the unit upright, attaching them to something; in my case to a third garage door. I have had this unit only a short time, and I will post an update once I've had it for a year. As for working your legs, I have to admit that I'm mainly rowing for upper body strength and I use other forms of exercise for leg strength (like walking fast, biking, or using a trampoline. But if you pull as far forward as possible, then you can give preference to your legs for the first 4 feet or so of travel. I also admit to not taking the two electronic connectors apart at Step 7. I simply inserted the two batteries while the other parts remained connected. By the way, there is plenty of resistance here, even in the lowest resistance settings. Kudos to Sunny Health & Fitness !
Perfect for my 2k time trial
LMAO!
Ok so some of you may laugh at me and what not. I bought that same machine few years back and i still use it. That machine was made for a beginner and for most 5'5 of height. They have another one that the back piece extends out for people slightly taller. For a beginner it does help at least to build up go a routine or get basically ideas for it. The thing abt the seat 100% truth the fabric did rip and teared up at the bottom after 2months of using it. I still have it and i still use it on n off. The concept 2 is a very wonderful machine n yes top of the line but it's also hell of expensive it's only minor flaw is the amount of $.
Thanks, Vanessa! Again, your info gives me courage that this machine would be fine for a beginner and someone who may never get beyond that beginner point, considering my age and health limitations. ;-D
@@sherryashberger5979 i am just now seeing this. Hello, idk if u got it or not but i am glad i was able to help. Stay focus😎
@@vanessa8282vr I got one at about 50% more in cost but still affordable. It is PERFECT for those of us who just need to MOVE a little more than what we have been doing! And the one we got is long enough that my 6'3" tall son can use it, also. ;-D
I took off the handle and use my seated row attachment on my lat machine. Much better than the skateboard I used to sit on and row!
What about for a 40 year old 5’4” 180 lb non athletic woman who just needs to move and knees can’t handle a treadmill too much but also needs resistance training at home?
You too big for the machine. The rower is for normal sizes people. It is not meant to compete with the Concept 2 but if you need to get a good 15 to 20 min workout in your daily routine, this inexpensive rower can work. If your into high end rowing the $1400 concept 2 if not. $ 79 may be a good deal
I had an el cheapo pump action rowing machine for years, wore it out. It was better than nothing. Have a Concept 2, now, which I really like.
Glad you could get a C2!
I had this one for several years and it still holds up. Just not as smooth as it used to be. Good starter.
Can you get your heart rate above 150 pretty easily with this rower? How high can you get your heart rate?
Does it get you really out of breath on max resistance?
I recently trash picked this machine BY (not IN) a dumpster. I believe this is a beginner machine which suits me fine, especially since I’m a foot shorter than this guy(5 foot eight). My machine appears to have been little used and it works fine. What I like about it is that it keeps track of the “total count” of repetitions since the machine was new. That’s like a car odometer keeping track of every single mile since the car was new. I like that!
To reset, hold the red button until you see all zeros. But does anybody know what the “scan” function is about?
Can you get your heart rate above 150 pretty easily with this rower? How high can you get your heart rate?
Does it get you really out of breath on max resistance?
I bought a Concept 2D Pm5 and it's the best thing I ever bought. Greetings from Barcelona!
EXCELLENT! Glad you love your rower!
I think you should review something for someone 6'8" and nothing something for average height people. "Normal" size people will find this machine perfect.
Dear Austin, thanks for this review. It confirms my conclusion that the Concept 2 is the most elegant piece of training equipment available -- and pound-for-pound, one of the least expensive.
Totally agree! :)
Damn, for a minute I thought I was watching the young Jim Carrey selling rowing machines. Nice channel.
Austin - the most entertaining yet honest informative video on UA-cam!
The best advice though is you don’t have to sell a kidney to buy a brand new rower - I kept scanning eBay and after a few months got a brilliant Concept2 E at a very low price. In 2.5 years I’ve done 1300KM without it missing a beat (just give it some tlc maintenance) 😎
Haha thank you, Steve! That's a lot of meters you've put in, man! Glad it's holding up well!
I'm 5' it works really well for me. I love it !!!
I often disagree with people when they say " it's better than nothing," and I think this is an example where that is true.
I'd rather wait and save, or buy a used Concept 2; quality usually ends up being cheaper in the long run as well. Since I've owned one for several trouble free years, that's not a concern though.
Buy it nice or buy it twice.
@@christopherjackson3455 Yes, you're right, it has to allow you to use proper technique at least.
The only other thing though is, if it's like bicycles, there is a certain minimum price point where it goes from a piece of crap that is difficult to work on, to something that not only is more fun to ride, but will last a lifetime. Of course the difference between a $250 bike to a $1500 bike is greater than the difference between a $4,000 bike and a $10,000 bike.
I thought real hard about this back when I was picking out my first rowing machine... I'm glad I went with the concept2, even though it's 15x the price.
Good call!!
Do you normally buy things that are to small for ya? 😊
What did you do with it after the video? Did you throw it in the dumpster, sell it, or just keep it? Lol.
I did think about getting one of those, but it seems like even if you're the right size you wouldn't be able to do the proper row technique due to the way the handle bar moves.
So I've just now ended up buying an Opti Magnetic Rowing Machine for £230. It'll arrive tomorrow so I'm pretty excited about it. While still not the best rowing machine you can buy, hopefully it should be good enough for me as I just want to start doing cardio, I'll probably get a cross trainer as well for the variation.
Already got some free weights and a bench for building strength and muscle, so it looks like I'll end up with a mini gym once I've got a rowing machine and a cross trainer too. :)
Need someone who isn’t 8ft 20” to review it honestly.
IT WILL NOT GIVE YOU ANY RESULTS. You will use it once or twice, and it will gather dust. Guaranteed
Being 5'8 and 175 pounds, and I no longer enjoy gyms, I use this as part of my home gym circuit workout for 10 minutes along with my weight bench and elliptical. For my height and weight it fits my home needs after a long work day of sitting at a desk.
Can you get your heart rate above 150 pretty easily with this rower? How high can you get your heart rate?
Does it get you really out of breath on max resistance?
This looks really stiff und kinda uncomfortable. Even the "rowing" is ... whatever it is ^^. I use the Concept 2 and it is just perfect. It is waaay more expensive, but it is totally worth it.
Totally worth it - I agree!
I'm 6' and I agree most exercise machines and life in general I.e. motorcycles,cars,beds are made for people 5'8. I even have to modify everything to fit me. Let alone 6'8! I stand up all day at work so sitting and rowing sounds fun! I bet if you cut this and lengthen it with square tubing it would be a cool machine!
People baulk at the price of the Concept 2, but you're literally getting the same equipment that Olympians train on.
That is an argument I haven't thought of but you are SO right!
Like the average person needs that .....along with the price tag that goes with it! Lol
Hey Austin, that was a pretty diplomatic review, all things considered. I would like to see you review the Hydrow. From what I can tell it's more of a subscription deal, but I wonder how the machine feels.
I wil see if I can get my hands on it!
Lol I don't know if they changed it or not, but I am 180 and it works somehow
No kidding haha
I'm using the bodymax r70i rowing machine, I find it fantastic and people have reviewed commenting that the level 1 resistance is equal to a level 4-5 on concept, it has 16 levels of magnetic and air resistance and a price of 429-500£, I would love an honest opinion though as I'm fairly new to rowing and can have the resistance on a 7 fairly comfortably however my resting heart as always been good in the 40s bpm so I'd say I'm fairly fit would just like the comparison to the concept :)
I'd love to check it out! I'll look into it!
I guess, from my personal point of view/experience, that two of the most valuable and affordable "at home" rowing machines are the V-Fit Tornado and its previous version, Artemis. At least here in Europe, they've bene Amazon's choice for quite sometime and a sure hit on the UK market.. give It a try! I got myself a "Tornado" and it's overall pretty good, although a guy as tall as you, would still have some "issue" on it. Cheers 👍
I really want to check it out!!
Can you get your heart rate above 150 pretty easily with this rower? How high can you get your heart rate?
Does it get you really out of breath on max resistance?
Thanks for this review. I had a hard time finding a rowing machine that would fit my apartment and weight. I had a budget for the Concept2 but literally not enough space in my apartment. Being a single Mom of a 18 month old and working full time does not allow for gym time so I needed something I could do at home. I had about 5 feet available (I'm only 5'9" so the length works for me) and weigh over 250 lbs. I settled on the Sunny Health RW5639 full motion rowing machine. I know it's not the best (I still have my eye on the Concept2) but it is the best fit for my life right now and I will upgrade when I'm able. Any chance you could review the full motion? Thanks again for your content, you were a big part of my starting rowing in the first place! 🙂
Do you find it works alright for you? It's probably not the best machine, but if it gets you rowing on a regular basis, it's better than no machine.
@@Breadbored. Yes, it works pretty well for me. You're right, it's better than no machine and I needed to do something. I'm not a professional rower or fitness buff, just an overweight Mom who needed to start moving her ass. It gives me a better work out than making excuses about why I wasn't exercising. 😉 I still plan on upgrading to the Concept2 at some point. I know it's the best. 🙂
I will try to get my hands on it!! Thanks for sharing and the suggestion!
J H, Glad you are able to get some use out of this machine, but any rower that does not have a mechanism for storing momentum (such as the flywheel of the Concept II or the water in a WaterRower) is going to be torturous to use on a consistent long term basis. The difference between this and a real rowing machine is like night and day. Also, note, the Concept II will stand up on its end, so only requires about 3'x2' of floor space for storage (to be fair, you will need about 2'x8' when in use).
@@rowhsv Hi there and thanks. I don't have this machine. I have a RW5639 full motion (see original comment). I researched all row machines and wanted to get the Concept2 but I took a tape measure to my tiny apartment and there is not a room where I can use it. Use, not store. I am not trying to be a rower, I am just trying to move in a way that does not cause stress and pain to my joints so that I can stick with moving. As I said, I agree that the Concept2 is the best and will eventually get one when I have a larger living space. Thanks again, the passion that Concept2 owners have for their machine just confirms my plan to move in that direction. 🙂
That video is amazing, man, thanks.
I'd like to see more of this until we find the best price/performance machine on Amazon.
As a person who is intended to buy his own machine, but can't really spend four-digits, this will be amazingly helpful.
I will continue the hunt!!
Hi, thanks for all the nice informal videos. Have you made any tests of "low priced" machines that actually are worth their money? Wish I could afford a Concept, but even used they're too pricey for me. I've been scanning the internet, but it's a jungle out there - and finding a place to try just some out is impossible.
Not ye! Looking to get my hands on a machine!
Not me finding this video after I finished building mine lol
I have this and you can extend it to be longer and can lower the slant or make it higher to stop the seat sliding
How do you extend it to make it longer? Would I be able to extend my legs all the way at 6 foot 2?
6 foot 8, 37" vertical leap
I’m interested in the Schwinn for my other space. Can’t tell if the forward position is made for short arms like Water Rower. Nothing beats my Concept2.
I'll have to take a look!
I was going to get this but Im glad I watched this vid. Going to get something more expensive.
Lol. I thought he was going to say the elephant in the room was that he favored Jim Carey :)
Haha I get that a lot!
I bought a cheap magnetic rower. It was on offer so I paid £154 instead of £225. It's no concept 2 but it works.
Do you think that this is suitable for 6'.3" male? Or the leg thing would be in the way too much?
hahaha - You should have saved this one for an April Fools Day vid. You kinda look like the biggest kid in 1st grade on that thing lol!
LOL that would have been a great idea!
6'4 a little more common..... yeah, naaah.
Haha
I am thinking of getting this for my Speediance gym monster and not use the hand/arm part cuz I could use the speediance machine
I love how you can make a million rowing videos but this thing makes you draw a blank lol
Haha I know right?? I just... have no words...
Thank you so much for this. This is exactly the info that I was looking for
No, sorry. I’m sure this rower is not for you...dude, you’re 6 foot 8 inches. Just as I wouldn’t consider your review of a Toyota Corolla, I can’t use this review.
beachz101 I actually fit well in a Toyota Corolla believe it or not! ... Regardless, I would still not recommended this for anyone
what is the recommended minutes to take per day using that machine for total body workout?
I love your reviews!! You are funny too!
You're so sweet, Christine! Thanks!
@@trainingtall of course!☺
my gosh I laughed. I just opened mine and it's just funny seeing someone much taller giving it a try lol
For someone like me that is 5'5 This would be fine.
7:29 lol
Haha thanks my guy... miss u
I have a Stamina 1405. I like it but one day I will get a Concept 2.
I'll have to check it out!
If you have a gut it’s going to hit the handle bars and pop off the counter every few strokes lmfaooo keeps happening to me 🤣
I am a 68yr old 5ft 6in size 7 shoe blah blah blah. This machine is one of the best economical machine I have had. Its robust enough for a beginner to intermediate user. I certainly am not training for the next camridge boat race. I just want to get a bit fitter, a bit more healthy and to lose a few pounds. I Definately would recommend this to anyone looking for something that fits those catagories. UNFAIR BIASED REVIEW in my opinion.
Man i love being 5.8 1/2 baybeee!
Thanks for the info!
Of course! :)
I’d pay good money to watch you attempt a Concept 2 workout of the day on that thing. 😂
Hahaha oh boy - it may not be enough to pay for my lower back operation after this thing wrecks it!
OK I'll bite .... but l wont chew. Hard to swallow seeing you on this rower ....
A honest review indeed. Glad there are other options. Long Live the Concept.
Still enjoy learning from your other training videos , well done Training Tall.
Thanks a ton, Leo! Much appreciated!
not for short people..you won't get the best put of it..but it's a good machine
I honestly cannot get over how big your thighs are omg. Especially for someone super tall. Like man what is the circumference of those bad boys :o
Haha you're kind! I think they are like 36 or 37 inches circumference?
Each leg is 36??? Wow that makes you a real life Hercules thats insane. My waist is only 32......
This thing is comical.
Correct! haha
LoL I bought it. I just don't have space for those gigantic nice rowers.
Uff really? But this "rower" has nearly nothing to do with rowing ^-^
You just spent $80 on a clothes rack.
Hello, you have really got me interested in rowing and I have decided to get one for home. I have you & many folks saying get the Concept2, but do you have any experience with the Pro-Form 750R? They offer a great program of $39 a month membership to their fitness program and after 3 years ($1404) you own the rower. I like the idea of the interactive videos Pro-Form offers. Any comments would be grateful.
I'll have to check it out!!
Hey Austin! Short & amateur here! Your videos have come very handy =] I'd like to know your opinion on the SF-RW5622 Magnetic Rowing Machine by Sunny Health & Fitness
Have a good one! ;)
So glad you like the vids! I'll take a look at it :)
The stepchild of the rowing machine world.
If ash from evil dead and Jim Carrey had a child.
Boy, you're really scraping the barrel to say anything positive about this machine. "The handle grip is foamy and cushy and nice".
haha ikr...
Concept 2 my crush
Anyone who is 4'11 or 5' tried this? just wondering lol
I'm 5'5 and it works great aside from the lower bar. Hits at my groin instead of upper abs.
Oh Becca, I feel ya..I think I am returning mine.
It is an excellent machine for most people Except YOU!!
An “excellent machine” 😂 what a waste of money
I wish you'd have put a smaller person (say, a woman) on this and done the review beside her or something, so we could have seen an average person on it :)
Still would not recommend! There are better options :)
I have a rower with the two rams ok for home and when one is over 77 yo its ok
What do you think about the cheap water rowers on alibaba? They sell for $200-$300. They look like they're quality, but I also don't have much experience rowing.
Sooo....you’re saying that this may be the best rower in history? I had to watch the video (sans audio) at work.
Lmao correct