It’s Noel, I was previously misinformed. This is the original demo. What you have on the japanese import is Noel’s re-recording of parts using the Verve’s equipment to have something credible for the japanese CD. That’s the leading theory anyway. This version is structurally very different from that version
This is definitely Noel. The only thing that’s confusing me is this version sounds slightly different in places to the official release (ie Noel saying d’reckon we’ll be able to do it or what?, also some guitar parts, then the ending. I wonder if the official release was edited to sound more like the final released version?
This must be the 3rd demo as i've heard the other 2 i've heard is Noel and his acoustic guitar during a soundcheck in Japan and the other one he recorded in Wales using The Verve's gear as they had the day off.
@@jaggass oasis had a habit of releasing things with false details of venue etc. Having just listened to both demos again I’d say the official release was recorded using the verve’s gear and it sounded much more like the final version, I just think they took the first part (talking before the song starts) from this Maison Rouge demo and edited it in before the song starts on the official release?
@@alexedge5265 The final wasn't recorded using The Verve's gear as Noel presented that demo to the rest of Oasis who then re recorded it and played it much faster. However the demo at Noel recorded in Wales sounds better than the final version.
I think Noel has a great voice. He’s not quite singing probably because it’s a guide vocal on a demo but I do prefer his voice to Liam’s. Don’t get me wrong Liam has a wicked rock star voice which is unmistakable, but i do prefer the smoothness of Noel’s voice.
If you cant tell this is noel thats worrying
The date its right indeed?
Plus; fucking great! More one subscriber.
A cross with the Small Faces and a bit of Tumbling Dice ?
Not even close
I can't understand, is this Noel or not?
It’s Noel, I was previously misinformed. This is the original demo. What you have on the japanese import is Noel’s re-recording of parts using the Verve’s equipment to have something credible for the japanese CD. That’s the leading theory anyway. This version is structurally very different from that version
It’s noel
This is definitely Noel. The only thing that’s confusing me is this version sounds slightly different in places to the official release (ie Noel saying d’reckon we’ll be able to do it or what?, also some guitar parts, then the ending. I wonder if the official release was edited to sound more like the final released version?
This must be the 3rd demo as i've heard the other 2 i've heard is Noel and his acoustic guitar during a soundcheck in Japan and the other one he recorded in Wales using The Verve's gear as they had the day off.
@@jaggass oasis had a habit of releasing things with false details of venue etc. Having just listened to both demos again I’d say the official release was recorded using the verve’s gear and it sounded much more like the final version, I just think they took the first part (talking before the song starts) from this Maison Rouge demo and edited it in before the song starts on the official release?
@@alexedge5265 The final wasn't recorded using The Verve's gear as Noel presented that demo to the rest of Oasis who then re recorded it and played it much faster. However the demo at Noel recorded in Wales sounds better than the final version.
I think Noel has a great voice. He’s not quite singing probably because it’s a guide vocal on a demo but I do prefer his voice to Liam’s. Don’t get me wrong Liam has a wicked rock star voice which is unmistakable, but i do prefer the smoothness of Noel’s voice.
He shines acoustically!
Nah
Way too slow
1.25 speed.
Not good. Thank God Liam sang this! 🤣