India's "CASTE SYSTEM" Is A Colonial Imposition
Вставка
- Опубліковано 24 вер 2024
- From Episode 39 of #AskAbhijit.
WATCH FULL EPISODE: #AskAbhijit 39: Indian History ► • #AskAbhijit 39: Indian...
SUBSCRIBE ► www.youtube.co...
SHORT CLIPS CHANNEL ► www.youtube.co...
------------------------------------------------------------------------
SUPPORT THE CHANNEL
------------------------------------------------------------------------
►UPI (G-Pay/PhonePe/Paytm): abhijitchavda@icici
►PayPal: paypal.me/Abhi...
►Become A Member on UA-cam: / @abhijitchavda
------------------------------------------------------------------------
JOIN #AbhijitChavda
------------------------------------------------------------------------
★Discord: / discord
★Twitter: / abhijitchavda
★Instagram: / theabhijitchavda
★Facebook: / theabhijitchavda
★Website:
★Email Inquiries: inquiries.chavda@gmail.com
------------------------------------------------------------------------
#AskAbhijitPodcast
------------------------------------------------------------------------
★Spotify: open.spotify.c...
★Apple Podcasts: podcasts.apple...
★Google Podcasts: podcasts.googl...
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
#AskAbhijitChavda #Abhijit #Chavda #AskAbhijitShow
I asked my father how much a Brahmin used to take to conduct vedic rituals in 50's or 60's , my father told me everyone was poor and Brahmin used to take 1.25 rs to conduct Puja .. same was the case of Potter and same was the case of lohar .. everyone was same only works were divided or maybe I come from himachal that is not very cast centric society like up or bihar .. but that thing was thought provoking for me ..
Even the economical status of brahmins and sudras are samr, Still Brahmins didn't eat in homes of potter and practice untouchability
Nope not everybody was poor everybody was rich so nobody actually took money for their work rather they had a lot of wealth inherited from family and also land and animals rest of the people had occupation which they did at minimal cost
Actually it's not about a normal Brahmin. It was always about those Brahmin directly under the king. There are many stories where Brahmins are shown dirt poor. It was all politics of the Brahmins in power that changed caste system and solidified their superiority.
@@shashankdevineni6969 it's not true
@@gauravmeena8750 many matang do't eat in valmiki home bro
Let's read thousands of years old history.
Emperor Shantanu married Satyavati, the daughter of a fisherman. His son became the king, so Bhishma did not marry, Bhishma vowed to remain childless for life.
Satyavati's sons later became Kshatriyas, for whom Bhishma remained unmarried for life, would they have been exploited?
Ved Vyas, who wrote the Mahabharata, was also a fisherman, but became a Maharishi, he used to run the Gurukul.
Vidur, who is called Maha Pandit, was the son of a maidservant, became the General Secretary of Hastinapur, Vidur Niti, written by him, is a great book on politics.
Bhima married the forest dweller Hidimba.
Shri Krishna was from the family of milk businessmen,
His brother Balram used to do farming, always kept the plow with him.
Yadav has been Kshatriya, ruled many provinces and Shri Krishna is revered by all, gave a book like Gita to the world.
* Vanvasi Nishadraj used to study in Gurukul with Ram.
His son Luv Kush studied in the Gurukul of Maharishi Valmiki who was a resident of the forest.
So it is the matter of Vedic period, it is clear that no one exploited anyone, everyone had the right to education, anyone could reach the post according to his ability.
Varnas were only on the basis of work, they could be changed*, which is called the Division of Labor in Economics today.
Talking about ancient India, the Nanda dynasty, which ruled India's largest district Magadha, was a barber by caste.
The Nanda dynasty was started by Mahapadmanand, who was the king barber. Later he became the king, then his sons too, * later all were called Kshatriyas.
After that the Maurya dynasty ruled the whole country, starting with Chandragupta, who was from a peacock-rearing family and a Brahmin Chanakya made him the emperor of the whole country. The country was ruled by the Mauryas for 506 years.
Then came the rule of the Gupta dynasty, which ran horse stables and traded horses. The Guptas ruled the country for 140 years.
Except for the 36-year rule of Pushyamitra Shunga, * 92% of the time, in ancient times, the rule in the country belonged to those who are today called Dalits backward, so where did the exploitation come from? There is nothing exploitative here either.
Then begins the time of medieval India, which is from 1100-1750, during which Muslim rule was mostly in most places.
Finally the Marathas emerged, Baji Rao Peshwa, who was a Brahmin, made the Gaekwad, a cow herder, the king of Gujarat, the Holkar of the shepherd caste, the king of Malwa.
Ahilya Bai Holkar herself was a great devotee of Shiva. He built many temples and Gurukuls.
Mira Bai who was a Rajput, her guru was a tanner Ravidas and Ravidas's guru was Brahmin Ramanand.
There is no point of exploitation here.
Dirt started in the country from the Mughal period and things like purdah system, slave system, child marriage start from here.
From 1800-1947 there was British rule and from here casteism started. Which they did under the policy of divide and rule.
In the book "Cast of Mind" by British officer Nicholas Dark, you will find how the British increased casteism, untouchability and how selfish Indian leaders politicized it in their own interest.
In the history of these thousands of years, many foreigners have come to the country who have written books on the social condition of India, such as Megasthenes wrote Indica, Fahien*, Hue Song and Alberuni among many others. No one wrote that anyone was exploited here.
Yogi Adityanath who is not a Brahmin, Mahant of Gorakhpur temple, Uma Bharti of backward caste has been Maha Mandaleshwar. Birth based caste system was brought to weaken the Hindus.
So be proud to be an Indian and save yourself and others from the conspiracy of hatred, malice and discrimination.
* Share this post as much as possible ... Connect those Hindu brothers who consider themselves separate due to Mughal, English and Congress conspiracy and create hurdles in Hindu unity. The goal is to connect them as well.
You are right 👍
Amazing bhai :) Please write an article on medium, etc. so that your thoughts stay forever and easily found for quoting some where when needed
@@jameammarijr.2248 thanks for suggestion. Will consider it.
Agree to a lot but wasn't Karna denied education because of his caste.
@@TaoriRohan No. It's half true.
Karna was denied of education, but not because of its caste. He couldn't recieve it because of he was not from royal family.
If your tution teacher don't teach children from your mohalla, will it be counted as casteism??
Please make a separate video on the battle of 10 kings
Dasrajna War
What does that mean ??
Mai 10 kings ka matlab samja nai .
@@bharatam3850 the battle of 10 king
Game of thrones
Yes please
If West created caste system it was after 15th century , how can Sri ramanujacharya challenge oppressions of higher caste in 12th century on lower caste people for not providing education ?
Read book by Ambedkar untouchability
He won't answer this
In Every society discrimination is their, even today,
A rishkoy pullers boy cant study in Dhirubhai Ambani school... Its not discrimination, its reality of life...
@@BpositiveDoctor why do sanatanis are so proud of themselves if it is just like other societies?
There light have been discrimination but not in the same way the current scholarship potrays. And moreover Ramanujacharya or any other so called "social reformer" never went against varnashrama dharma but considered it the best form of societal division, be it Buddha or Chaitanya or anyone for that matter. This point is cleraly discussed in the one of the books which Abhijit sir has reccomended - Western Foundations of Caste System - 5. Were Shramana and Bhakti Movements against the Caste System by Martin Farek.
If caste system was brought by Britishers,then y is it present in Nepali society?. I have seen caste based discrimination in Nepali society also .Nepal was never ruled by Britain.
Britishers also ruled North-East, but here we don't believe in such evil practice.
Because you are non Hindu
This answer about muslim rajputs and dalit rajputs cleared many of my questions! Thankyou sir!
Remember Some Disagreements could be there but ancient indians didn't kill each other due to disagreements as they accepted multiple ways to seek, The genocide of more than 15 cr hindus(also artificially engineered famines) changed properous indian's mindset with rigidity and in this structureless poor society was generated discriminatory caste system with English laws as in these 800 yrs there was death of old Indian institutions by invaders through burning universities or eating up funds ,which is totally against scriptures as they mention importance of every sect,Will Durant also talked about indian genocide, go read how Indians used to live as one through Dharampal's The Beautiful Tree,Brichabili tila inscription etc and try to read ancient texts from orignal sources. When we read any texts in Indian language translation we will know every art & culture embraced unity in diversity in which everything has a deep symbolic spiritual meaning..Its stated in English meetings that they had to Works hard years and years to divide indians because they all had fluidity and unity in their roles as varnas was not a system rather an observation of qualities(gunas) of a human to do occupation and all the indian kings throughout history had different family backgrounds...in ancient India there is no single evidence of genocide due to internal conflicts whereas other parts were full of conflicts(for e.g. certain westerns used to torture their people in brazen bull or tortures in hammer of witches), after transfer of power first internal conflict was chitpawn bhramin masacare ,also every community descendent represent all indians due to fluidity in past ,Every community in India is poor as its some invaders who became rich by stealing over 45 trillion $
I disagree with you ... Castesism was case even in ramayana mahabharat you can't blame Britishers for all things.
I appreciate your neutrality
give a proof of castesism from the original ved vyas mahabharat and valmiki ramayan
@Raj kumar bhatt i think you need to read original texts written in native languages
@Raj kumar bhatt did you read the one written by maharishi ved vyas if yes then you would have know that karan was student of guru dhrone
No. There was class supremacy. There was supremacy of lineage (Kula). It was not caste or jathi.
It is same as western society. Or Chinese society.
These British brought their European Feudal System into India and started calling it Caste System, even the word "Caste" comes from Spanish "Casta".
Nowadays many people think they can be called "Brahmins" without reading a Single Scripture! (Although, that is predicted in Book 12 of Bhagavatam)
Not Spanish but Portugese
@@anondutt25 Same thing, both are Ricebags
Its Kaliyugam bro.
can u pls give me the verse number
@@nayan7207 its one of prophency of kal yuga
I urge everyone to read J Sai Deepak g book
INDIA THAT IS BHARAT
Most of questions like these will be resolved in yr mind after reading this Book !!
Read Gulamgiri by Jyotibha phule
@@toxicevilking2945 phule was a british lapdog he's irrelevant
His book uses is very complex language
How come British settled untouchables outside of every villages in India?
😂
Just like British listed and documents every caste ,all the caste that found today has being documented by Britisher they divided work and given to their bootlicker Indians Princely states
😂
Untouchable were those who people who were against British that why they made them into Untouchable category so that they never rise and always deal with problems with their own religious people
Check meenakshi jain and rajiv malotra about caste
It is also important to know that The so called Caste system was also how European interpreted The indigenous cultures of North and South America's during their Colonization missions. They imposed their own limited understanding of other cultures on Indian society and academic texts.
Lol these retxrds enslaved the rest of the world. The British Enslaved Indians in their rule how can we at that time say it's our fault
Yup like the number of crime in caste based cases raised dramatically during colonial period
But before Mughal invasion or sultanate invasion or even during their period
There isn't so much recorded cases of caste system crimes
Yes only Some Disagreements could be there but ancient indians didn't kill each other due to disagreements as they accepted multiple ways to seek, The genocide of more than 15 cr hindus(also artificially engineered famines) changed properous indian's mindset with rigidity and in this structureless poor society was generated discriminatory clan system with English laws as in these 800 yrs there was death of old Indian institutions by invaders through burning universities or eating up funds ,which is totally against scriptures as they mention importance of every sect,Will Durant also talked about indian genocide, go read how Indians used to live as one through Dharampal's The Beautiful Tree,Brichabili tila inscription etc . When we read any texts in Indian language translation we will know every art & culture embraced unity in diversity in which everything has a deep symbolic spiritual meaning..Its stated in English meetings that they had to Works hard years and years to divide indians because they all had fluidity and unity in their roles as varnas was not a system rather an observation of qualities(gunas) of a human to do occupation and all the indian kings throughout history had different family backgrounds...in ancient India there is no single evidence of genocide due to internal conflicts whereas other parts were full of conflicts(for e.g. certain westerns used to torture their people in brazen bull or tortures in hammer of witches), after transfer of power first internal conflict was chitpawn bhramin masacare ,also every community descendent represent all indians due to fluidity in past ,Every community in India is poor as its some invaders who became rich by stealing over 45 trillion $
@@4thwall880 , Mughals were using brute force,for them,we were kafir..they did not had devide and rule policy,they were more about killing and raping and converting that is why they don't give damn about Varna..but British were more interested in raping society mentally..
Regards of the Spanish caste system it wasn't based on their interpretation of native American culture but more of a infograph of 'new people' that live in the new world since race mixing started. It was also to show the social hierarchy of the Spanish empire in the new world
I don't know. Why our history tells us about mughal and british.
Why our history don't tell about :- chhatrapati shivaji full history, maharana prataap full history, bappa rawal history, and ahom kingdom history.
Jassa Singh Ahluwalia and also Hari Singh Nalwa who conquered and brought Peshawar into india after 1000 years
There were untouchables in Indian society even before the British came to India
Evidence
Evidence
@@franky7388 Because it is not fact. Last Anglo Maratha war was fought in 1817. Mahatma Phule started schools for dalit in 1840s. some very short period to create caste and discrimination all over India.
Search the name: 12 th century basavanna
@@eakalaivan839discrimination exists everywhere.
So isn't the reservation also discriminatory
I'm a dalit and I've had people "shooing" me when i just tried to use their tap water in my village and heard many cases from my family how they would throw away utensils used by us and even use gangajal.
If this system is only thrown upon us by britishers only a century ago then why it is so deep rooted into our society?
I don't know that. But I can assure you that in most of cities now caste is not important. Urban hindus use caste only for marriage. And within next 15-20 years caste will disappear in every corner of India.
Being a dalit I 100 percent agree with you brother
I live in bhopal people here still believe in caste atleast people whom I met believe in caste
Even women were not treated well in the past, we still have issues like child marriage, dowry, people killing the newborn girl child. But the society is changing with time and we can see improvement. Similarly this too will go away. We anyway have reservations, string sc st act. You can always find cases of discrimination but just see the improvement. And this is the real world, people will be discriminated, just the parameters will change. Money, status, influence, power.
@@beonmouth5821 file a case if they have caused you trouble.
@@mr.nobody5244 my family already did
when you don't want to accept your mistake you re-frame and re-label it and impose it on someone else. just a dogmatic people. fuck the reality .
Do you have any solid proof of your comment before giving any accusation ?
@@arjyachatterjee6874See the Puri Shankaracharya video , Varna is really by birth or karma/Guna , you will get the idea that Varna is also by birth and his views on temple entry for dalit and practice of untouchability 🤡. Hinduism without caste system is nothing
Why was karna discriminated against during the time of mahabharata if the caste system was not intrinsic to our social system?
He was a kshatriya by all his gunas but the discrimination was based only on birth.
Karna was discriminated because he was non aristocrat not because of caste
If it was western why is it common in rural India
Who the fuck is that guy asking did british educate india😂😂😂😂😂
British educate Bharat
Is like , Missionaries opening Hospitals
😂😂
Rahul Gandhi 🤣
the person who said why the surname of dalits and rajputs are same in gujarat- he called them Dalits on the basis of SC category that has been given by the govt. having SC ST category doesn’t make someone tribal or dalit , secondly categories given by the govt in many parts of india is on the basis of geographical region and the people who were poor or living in backward villages, because same things you’ll find in MP in malwa-nimar region , there also you’ll find ST people and to some extent SC people are having the same lineage of kshatriyas but they are not put in general category solely on the basis of the region they are living in.
SIR MY QUESTION IS KALIA , MINHAS , MANHAS , PATIAL , KOUNDAL OR KUNDLAS ARE A SURJ VANSHI GOTERS , PLEASE ANSWER ME IN A REPLY
Few Disagreements could be there but ancient indians didn't kill each other due to disagreements as they accepted multiple ways of seeking.The genocide of more than 20 cr hindus(also artificially engineered famines) changed properous indian's mindset with rigidity and in this structureless poor society was generated discriminatory caste system with English laws as in these 800 yrs there was death of old Indian institutions by invaders through burning universities or eating up funds ,which is totally against scriptures as they mention importance of every sect,Will Durant also talked about indian genocide, go read how Indians used to live as one through Dharampal's The Beautiful Tree,Brichabili tila inscription etc . When we read any texts in Indian language translation we will know every art & culture embraced unity in diversity in which everything has a deep symbolic spiritual meaning..Its stated in English meetings that they had to Works hard years and years to divide indians because they all had fluidity and unity in their roles as varnas was not a system rather an observation of qualities(gunas) of a human to do occupation and all the indian kings throughout history had different family backgrounds...in ancient India there is no single evidence of genocide due to internal conflicts whereas other parts were full of conflicts(for e.g. certain westerns used to torture their people in brazen bull or hammer of witches), after transfer of power first internal conflict was chitpawn bhramin masacare but also every community descendent represent all indians due to fluidity in past hence in the end its the indians who die ,Every community in India is poor as its some invaders who became rich by stealing over 45 trillion $ .Some europeans destroyed education system of India and copied Indian science as in earlier years they didn't had decimal system or even couldn't compute simple multiplication through there numerals but later on since 1700s they copied and corrected as we can see before 1700s there is no history of collaborative work in europe ,people are so engrossed in their agenda that they can't research themselves and will just want spoon feeding by their Colonial masters
I am from south karnataka, I belong to ST caste, but my ancestors were landlords...clearly caste system was done to divide us
There were no Muslims or British when Manusmriti were written, when Ramayan was written , and also there were a Chinese traveller to India during Gupta dynasty mentioning about lifestyle of shudra in ancient time.
Even in Ramayan it is mentioned about discrimination, read about Shambuka.
@@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 how many percentage of Hindus following this theory?
@@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 I will feel no shame or belittle, if you kindly explain me the exact verses of that part and also Manusmriti which was not written by British or Mughals.
@@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 Mata ji, I don't know about GDP much, It could be real but that doesn't suffice the argument on equality for lower caste people.
@@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 And Here my point for commenting not to defy my religion or practice. but to the point where you are whitewashing the atrocities and discrimination done by.
I myself faced the discrimination, you won't understand how you feel when an adult throw stuff wash the table because you sat on it and started abusing a 10 years old kid and that too in 21st centuries . Its like someone slapped you for no reason and you are trying to justify the actions.
Pakistani History defends the atrocities and barbaric acts done by Turks, and this so called history teacher doing the same in my opinion.
@@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 until you don't accept the flaws you can't rectify it. Simple, centuries will passed by but this mindset will be there. And you will keep blaming your imaginary enemies.
Caste structures are a more complex thing than. Abhijit is just oversimplifying by blaming caste on colonization. It maye be partly right. But it isn't the complete truth.
@@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 Chutiye ho tum🤣😂
@@halocraze9839 chyu*iya ho Tum 🤣🤣
Bharat had a VARNA system. And the Britishers utilized this system to develop new form of social structure... The word CASTE never even existed in our ancient Sanskrit literature... So try to get your facts right before ba*king like D*GS.
@@halocraze9839 Who exactly?? And can you please elaborate more upon his thoughts... By just randomly saying that a Chinese historian traveled across bharat and randomly came up with a conclusion that caste system existed doesn't makes any sense..
@@halocraze9839During the vedic ages a shudra could have become a bramhin and a bramhin could have become a shudra... The varna of an individual depended upon his or her karma(actions) and gunas(qualities) if you go by the definition of vedas.... Although, rigidity do existed in various parts... But it wasn't a widely accepted practice.
And on the top of everything... Shudra was not a derogatory term at all... Because the entire social ecosystem of Bharat existed upon them. Each varna was intended to cooperate together and contribute into the betterment of the entire society.... The varna system was developed to organize a division of socioeconomic and political duties... It was meant to be a system of social mobility not some blo*dy rigid CASTE system
@@halocraze9839 There exist a concept called ideological subversion.... In which a nation systamatically dismantles the social fabric of the enemy nation through a process of infiltration.... And 200 years is more than enough to dismantle the social fabric of any nation, specially when the enemy is already exhausted and economically broken.. we had to face a long wave of middle eastern coloniality... And throughout this long phase continuous struggle we lost a big portion of our civilisation identity.
And when the Britishers came... They utilized the sociopolitical instability to orchestrate a systematic subversion.
The system has fallen prey to corruption, misinterpretation and misprojection over the centuries, not any less by foreign civilisations, particularly in the colonial period of the British Raj, when jativadand casteism was addressed and highlighted as a problematic element associated with the Dharmic traditions.
Caste system is a British invention until the time of marriage comes and families are looking boys from "good background" savarna caste
This construct has been deep rooted into the thought process of our minds... This is the direct outcome of a systematic ideological subversion, which is the root cause of all problems.... The solution of this issue lies in the systamatic decolonisation of our Samaj.... We will have to systematically decolonise the critical thought process of our young generations... Like the Britishers did in the initial days of colonisation.
Europeans establish this system to divide and rule india. And it worked for sometime. But many revolutionaries worked to spread awareness about this topic like veer Savarkar ji.
Few Disagreements could be there but ancient indians didn't kill each other due to disagreements as they accepted multiple ways of seeking.The genocide of more than 20 cr hindus(also artificially engineered famines) changed properous indian's mindset with rigidity and in this structureless poor society was generated discriminatory caste system with English laws as in these 800 yrs there was death of old Indian institutions by invaders through burning universities or eating up funds ,which is totally against scriptures as they mention importance of every sect,Will Durant also talked about indian genocide, go read how Indians used to live as one through Dharampal's The Beautiful Tree,Brichabili tila inscription etc . When we read any texts in Indian language translation we will know every art & culture embraced unity in diversity in which everything has a deep symbolic spiritual meaning..Its stated in English meetings that they had to Works hard years and years to divide indians because they all had fluidity and unity in their roles as varnas was not a system rather an observation of qualities(gunas) of a human to do occupation and all the indian kings throughout history had different family backgrounds...in ancient India there is no single evidence of genocide due to internal conflicts whereas other parts were full of conflicts(for e.g. certain westerns used to torture their people in brazen bull or hammer of witches), after transfer of power first internal conflict was chitpawn bhramin masacare but also every community descendent represent all indians due to fluidity in past hence in the end its the indians who die ,Every community in India is poor as its some invaders who became rich by stealing over 45 trillion $ .Some europeans destroyed education system of India and copied Indian science as in earlier years they didn't had decimal system or even couldn't compute simple multiplication through there numerals but later on since 1700s they copied and corrected as we can see before 1700s there is no history of collaborative work in europe ,people are so engrossed in their agenda that they can't research themselves and will just want spoon feeding by their Colonial masters
😂😂😂😂😂
One example i would like to give is - Bhilala , which in present time is considered a tribe but originally it was not a tribe but a name given by a British coloniser John malcolm to the Bhil-Rajput lineage, so if you go to gujarat and malwa region you’ll find Chouhans , tomars , thakurs ,rawats ,baghels,darbar,kachwah, and many more included in ST category by the govt of that time.
Abhijit Chawda sir....if u really want to know about the caste system go to villages stay there and talk about caste system there you'll get to know the extent of caste system and how deep rooted and rigid it is.Not everything can be gained through books
yeah. but question is "was it so even 1000 years ago?"
@@shubhamkumar-gx5vx In this globalised era where everyone is this world is connected and advent of science and technology with emphasis on rational mind caste system is still in the forefront of Indian society....Imagine 1000 years ago
@@sweetyh3769 Our concern should be who is responsible for our plight.
@@souparnadas3084it's called manipulation of the main topic.
@@Anonymous-ww9se No dear, I think it's the manipulation of history and obviously the mentality of simple indigenous peoples who were never aware of such trickeries.
In bihar , so called upper caste teacher now started to give marks on the basis of caste . generals are given above 80 & sc/st gets below 60 .
so fortunately i pointed it out & make one of the my class teacher suspended by help of "high court ".
after suspension that teacher came to me & said " kitno ko rokega ".
this is how we get justice in democracy !
Any proof?
@@god9761 give me ur number i'll whatsapp u every document from FIR to judgment .
all biharis are treated as shudras by other state
@@kartikey404 it is core basis of disintegration of any country !! ab tum mujhe deshdrohi bhi bologe !! pr agar tum padhe likhe hoge to smajhoge ki ek hi country me agar marzinalised stateko aur jyada push kya jayega to ek din revoluion hoga aur revolution se disintegration hoga !!!
tumne jo baat kahi vo " bharat tere tukre honge " ka smarthan karta hai !!!
I wish that your channel grows very rapidly. These knowledges need to be transferred to the new generation immediately. otherwise the gap can never be filled.
Yes
@@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 yes you are also right
@@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 very right
The genocide of more than 15 cr hindus(also artificially engineered famines) changed properous indian's mindset with rigidity and in this structureless poor society was generated discriminatory caste system with English laws as in these 800 yrs there was death of old Indian institutions by invaders through burning universities or eating up funds ,which is totally against scriptures as they mention importance of every sect,Will Durant also talked about indian genocide, go read how Indians used to live as one through Dharampal's The Beautiful Tree,Brichabili tila inscription etc and try to read ancient texts from orignal sources. When we read any texts in Indian language translation we will know every art & culture embraced unity in diversity in which everything has a deep symbolic spiritual meaning..Its stated in English meetings that they had to Works hard years and years to divide indians because they all had fluidity and unity in their roles as varnas was not a system rather an observation of qualities(gunas) of a human to do occupation and all the indian kings throughout history had different family backgrounds...in ancient India there is no single evidence of genocide due to internal conflicts whereas other parts were full of conflicts(for e.g. certain westerns used to torture their people in brazen bull or tortures in hammer of witches), after transfer of power first internal conflict was chitpawn bhramin masacare ,also every community descendent represent all indians due to fluidity in past ,Every community in India is poor as its some invaders who became rich by stealing over 45 trillion $
I had also the opinion that untouchabilty and other caste oppression were the by products of feudalism. India was transformed to a feudal society in the mediveal period and situation become worse during British period. Riotwari system , mahalwari system, zamindari system made society into different class. Those who served British became big zamindars and owned acres property where ordinary people obliged to do work in these fields because of their low born status
inferiority or superiority is problem whites can never stop i think you should be honest about the cast system i am not sure that it is from the British india have been settled by whites 5000 years ago cast and colourism have been in india thousands of years before the British invaded india
@@sarahjrgensen7753 caste system was always there.. ( but caste based discrimination is different)
I believe discrimination was present even in stone age or when we were apes.... See discrimination is not unnatural thing, diversity is law of nature and as long as diversity exist there will be discrimination... We often tend to be more protective towards our community... So, diversity and discrimination is eternal like good and bad or love and hate...
@@adityashukla517agree to some extent but when a country is invaded the invaders brings toxicity
Yes Some Disagreements could be there but ancient indians didn't kill each other due to disagreements as they accepted multiple ways to seek, The genocide of more than 15 cr hindus(also artificially engineered famines) changed properous indian's mindset with rigidity and in this structureless poor society was generated discriminatory caste system with English laws as in these 800 yrs there was death of old Indian institutions by invaders through burning universities or eating up funds ,which is totally against scriptures as they mention importance of every sect,Will Durant also talked about indian genocide, go read how Indians used to live as one through Dharampal's The Beautiful Tree,Brichabili tila inscription etc and try to read ancient texts from orignal sources. When we read any texts in Indian language translation we will know every art & culture embraced unity in diversity in which everything has a deep symbolic spiritual meaning..Its stated in English meetings that they had to Works hard years and years to divide indians because they all had fluidity and unity in their roles as varnas was not a system rather an observation of qualities(gunas) of a human to do occupation and all the indian kings throughout history had different family backgrounds...in ancient India there is no single evidence of genocide due to internal conflicts whereas other parts were full of conflicts(for e.g. certain westerns used to torture their people in brazen bull or tortures in hammer of witches), after transfer of power first internal conflict was chitpawn bhramin masacare ,also every community descendent represent all indians due to fluidity in past ,Every community in India is poor as its some invaders who became rich by stealing over 45 trillion $
@@sarahjrgensen7753 ,look at things from eyes of mother and from eyes of other women..
Suppose that you have 10 kids,one is doctor,one is scientist,one is Engineer,one is poilet,one is corpenter,one is break layer,one is big businessman,one is motor mechanic,one is teacher and one is uneducated and unemployed.. because of that definitely,they will have different financial and social status..are you going to judge them on basis of their financial and social status and will say,he earn more money so i am going to love him more,hey you don't earn more money so i will not love you..are you going to say it?! ofcourse not because at the end of day,they are your son,you will love them, doesn't matter what but will other women will see them same as you?!they will judge them on basis of their financial and social status.. apply this at varn system...by the way if you will read geeta,you will understand it deeper..i have read it and have gotten why did it turn ugly..
Abijit sir's channel is growing like mongol empire. I'm late sir but congratulation for reach 200k milestone.
*Reaching* 😅
Nope...the growth is still not that fast...it needs to grow much faster
Mongol ?
Maratha it is 👍
462K now. just in 9 months his subs doubled
Imagine some outsider running into the country and forcing his ideas of caste (on the basis of varna system) to activate divide and rule theory 😂. See it's high time we should accept there were some flaws in our culture that made outsiders to divide us (Although we were already divided in hell lot of jatis already ) . Still let's not talk about the past and focus on future that how would this caste system could be eliminated from the culture in a counter defence to if in future some other foreigner would like to seek advantage of it. 😅
Exactly!
they changed the aspect of it. varnas existed, castism wasnt. So the turks and then the brits exploited this and then corrupted our mentality
Acc to what I have heard, the fall of the Maratha empire happened because The Mahars(a dalit tribe) sided with the British because they wer fed up of the discrimination and suffering caused by bhramins in the peshwa period.Of course it did them no good. But it kind of makes sense. How else could the spineless british have taken over the maratha empire.
The Mahars fought for both sides in the war. Later the British excluded the Mahars from the British Army on the basis of the racist Martial Races concept.
Lol maratha fall due to lack of leader after died of nana fnadavis
Mahars actually supported Maratha empire during Shivaji maharaj rules,Mahars were warriors and guards of fort!
The Fall of Maratha empire started when it came in hands of peshwas.
@@jithetic__2272um...is it you bro?
In Maharashtra we have this maratha caste which includes everyone and even the Mali or the so called dalit too faught wars during chhatrapati Raj even tho they were not included in kshyatriya caste
Ya I've heard about how the lower Shinde caste gained social clout and came to Kshatriya.
@@dograkhalsa1098
Originally there were two kshyatriya caste in Maratha 1)96k maratha who still are open ,2)kunbhi maratha but they became farmers later and now are obc
I myself have rajput ancestors tho I am maratha
Vishwamitra was born to a Kshatriya family became a Maharishi, Vedvyas born to a fisher family, Kalidas - vanvasi, Valmiki. If there was birth based ‘discrimination’ how did all them-not ‘Brahmins’ by birth-became ‘Brahmins’?
@@Agnosticcc-x3m yeah I think the Varna system initially functioned well at that time but slowly it turned itself into the discriminatory caste system that we know about
@@Agnosticcc-x3m Ya, i think it happened after guptas fell
@@Agnosticcc-x3m well your know that ? in Europe their were untouchable community lived many wiped out and some survived ( last one with document found as cogats ( gothic related ) which became untouchable in Christian rule
@@Agnosticcc-x3m European had many empire but they were all controlled by pops ( what pops say king never denied) tho untouchability also being happened in ancient Arab ancient japan and Tibet
@जय अमर परशुराम yadav abhi Sudra category ke hai par vedo mai khatriya hai , dalito ke bhi vansh ( most ) somva surya hai ( baki alag alag totems bhi hai depends ki vo kis state se or rajya se belong karte ) , soma surya sirf or sirf vansh khatriyo ke liye hi banaye gye hai
The important question is that if "varnas" like Brahmans, shudhras, etc existed thousands of years back, were the Shudhras treated with respect and equality with the Brahmans? The answer apparently is "no".
Exactly 🤣
Then how do you explain about caste discrimination that happened to Karna in Mahabharata
in ved viyas mahabharat karna was student of guru dhrone read origninal texts then form your opinion guys don't depend on serials
“The entirety of the Pakistani army are Muslim Rajputs” 😂😂😂😂 the delusion the Pakistanis face against what they’re lineage is is insane.
How long we will be blaming british If west could abolish slavery, make it equal Playing feild to everyone today .why can't india..we don't want to Remove it.
Why west created this problem in the first place ??
First majority ppl need to be aware of it then we can do ...
@@manojs7027 reservation system based on surname should go away.
@@EDUCATION-c7w True its a mess that hard to clean now, don't know when it will happen ..
Sir I can't stop from praising you your answers are so clear and pin point accurate, it's really commendable ♥️♥️😍
The genocide of more than 15 cr hindus(also artificially engineered famines) changed properous indian's mindset with rigidity and in this structureless poor society was generated discriminatory caste system with English laws as in these 800 yrs there was death of old Indian institutions by invaders through burning universities or eating up funds ,which is totally against scriptures as they mention importance of every sect,Will Durant also talked about indian genocide, go read how Indians used to live as one through Dharampal's The Beautiful Tree,Brichabili tila inscription etc and try to read ancient texts from orignal sources. When we read any texts in Indian language translation we will know every art & culture embraced unity in diversity in which everything has a deep symbolic spiritual meaning..Its stated in English meetings that they had to Works hard years and years to divide indians because they all had fluidity and unity in their roles as varnas was not a system rather an observation of qualities(gunas) of a human to do occupation and all the indian kings throughout history had different family backgrounds...in ancient India there is no single evidence of genocide due to internal conflicts whereas other parts were full of conflicts(for e.g. certain westerns used to torture their people in brazen bull or tortures in hammer of witches), after transfer of power first internal conflict was chitpawn bhramin masacare ,also every community descendent represent all indians due to fluidity in past ,Every community in India is poor as its some invaders who became rich by stealing over 45 trillion $
Thank you for actually providing your sources on this one. People would just call me delusional if I told them this without knowing much about the topic myself. Looking forward to reading those books
The till then Tortoise pace Changeable Caste got 'Cemented' on 'Caste Certificate ' in Post Independent India- which is an extension of British census and enumeration.
Even Potter from Harry Potter is same. In India Harry Potter would be Hari Kumbhar.
Jai shree ram 🚩🚩🚩🚩
Unemployment pe vedio banao sir
I really like you , but I like to respectfully disagree with you on this .
1) West did use caste to divide but it did not invent it . Instead let's call Varna
2) in Ramayana lord Rama goes to kill a shudra because he was performing a yagnya .
3) in Buddhist literature it's extensively written about how buddha broke the Sangha concept by allowing all .
There are many more examples like this
and to add more ,with my little knowledge on Mahabaratham Epic, Karnan was not given a chance for the same. Basically who ever devised the idea of caste/division/separation is its eventually to control or direct other human beings which directly or indirectly affects every individuals rights .
@@srinivasanand13 true
@Aditya Gole well , I read enough
many people think Jati-varna ashram & caste are same thing ,
Jati is based on occupation &
Caste is like untouchable look @ what they did in south Africa(apartheid thing)
There were Jaatis and Varna in the Dwapar yug but it all changed when Manu wrote Manusmriti, it clearly shows the ill mentality of that person. Yes caste system has been one of the worst problems in India for so long even nowadays people practice untouchablity, even a talented dalit was not given the chance to study and even a illiterate brahmin was made a mantri in king's court. The punishments to asking the questions are horrible and are mentioned in Manusmriti. Thanks to Dr. Bhimrao Ambedkar ji 🙏🏻 for giving us the rights and power to stand against these people who used to opress us at every step.
Exactly my point. A historical event of burning of manusmriti by Dr. Bhimrao ambedkar also cannot be ignored.
@@uruuu9595 yes
Ambadkar was British spade
Which king will keep illiterate brahmin as minister? Which king will keep intelligent shudra as labor? Only one who wants to destroy himself! Sad but you cannot be unbiased sometimes I feel discrimination was correct looking at Jyotish for what will happen in future that is today...
@@chiragsharma5050lmao everyone was British spade but your own scriptures and even it's continuation in modern day world is something of a conspiracy...okay 👍🏻
Every time I watch your videos... My God...You blow my mind with your knowledge... Absolutely love your thought process...Thanks to your collab with Ranveer...I came to know about one of the best YT channel 💚
Incredible fountain of knowledge. Continue being awesome for decades to come, AbhijitJi. 🙏🕉👍
First Mughal invasion was in 1526.
British invasion started in 1608.
These invaders took advantage of the caste system, caste discrimination and unt*uchability.
Unt*uchability and caste discrimination were already in practice since very long time back.
Sri Ramanujacharya brought a movement as he revolted against the discrimination of unt*uchability and helped the people who were considered as untouchables.
Sri Ramanujacharya belonged to 11th century.
A Chinese Traveller named Fahien wrote about unt*uchability. The practise of unt*uchability had begun during the Gupta period. The Chinese traveller Fahien mentions that 'Chandalas' were separated from society. The advancement of Brahmanism led to the neglect of Buddhism and Jainism.
Gupta period was in 3rd century.
I tend to disagree upon few things,
with my little knowledge on Mahabaratham Epic, Karnan was not given a
chance for the same. Basically who ever devised the idea of
caste/division/separation for many reasons it eventually tend to control or direct other
human beings which directly or indirectly affects every individuals
rights.
Your knowledge should be included in school syllabus because even now these foreign minded divide between our social ladder has given rise to many tragic incidents. We were forced to forget our ancestral knowledge by invaders in order to dominate the citizens of undivided and prosperous India.
2:06
Recommendations me J Sai Deepak g aur Vikram Sampath g kaa book tha✌️🔥🔥
Wow, what an observation
Surprising West ruled most other countries but no casteism anywhere.
Thank you Abhijit sir, this is the most noble task you taken up.
I recall a line from Tagore's Novel Gora.
"I don't want cultureless red-faced hungry animals to speak about our rich culture which is suffering from a disease due to millenium long berberic acts. We have to cure our disease on our own if we have any".
Ambedkar misconstrued. Caste system. 😮
Even if catsteism introduced by British..we can't blame them now..as we became independent nd we have right nd power to remove caste ,like how west removed slavery..it's all fault of people, politicians nd the government.. thank British they made it less to 4..imagine there r more than 4 Castes ...World war 3 would happen in india itself
After India's so called independence. Britishers insured that there agents stays in power like Nehru and Gandhi.
And these agents continued this system for there political benefits.
Britishers are clearly responsible for caste system as they made it to divide indian society.
For that the labelled lower castes should come forward and give out this labels and should demand equality and should accept support only to financially weaker class. Would they do it, no they wont. Who wants an equal competition where you can easily get reservation in low grades.
This political parties feed on SUch issues
If there was no cast based differences in society then why Gautam Budha raised voice against it.
Kb uthai be kaha likha
During British everyone are equally oppressed. But before British it
,Varnashram is prevalent, shudras are oppressed. Karna was oppressed, Eklavya was oppressed .its fine to accept caste system india. India is not any clean country without social evils , not other countries too. Serfdom in Europe,slavery is US Europe everywhere there are divisions
In haryana same gotras are present in so many castes like dahiya is found in jats,ahirs,chamars.kosaliya gotra of south haryana is present in so many castes.there is a Proverb in haryana GOTI GOTI BHAI K KAREGI HASNAYI. Means ek hi gotra k sabhi log bhai hai unko ristedaari nikalne ki jaroorat nhi hai.isi wajah se ek hi gotra mein saadi nhi hoti.
#AskAbhijit
Who are Chandals?
And Who are Namasudras?
I will be grateful to know that, Sir.
@@weaksupremacy3799 who were vedic kings?
Caste the word is Portuguese in origin
But jathi is 5000yearr old
British for sensus purpose classified them but we practsed endogamy for thousands of years
If it is their creation
You are in power now
Annihilate it no body is preventing you
Don't blame others for our fault
It was introduced by them and we shouldn't blame them ? Good logic😂, the problem with completely eradicating cast discrimination is that it was spread in india so wide over a span of more than 100years while it hasn't even been 100yrs since our independence. And not to mention that even after independence, we were ruled by a bad government until 2014. But since 2014 bjp winning there are lots of improvements and india is going ahead.
@@FAX24See the Puri Shankaracharya video , Varna is really by birth or karma/Guna , you will get the idea that Varna is also by birth and his views on temple entry for dalit and practice of untouchability 🤡. Hinduism without caste system is nothing
@@PopatKaBaap u r the joker here🤡, who tf cares what shankaracharya says, he ain't krishna who spoke bhagwat Gita and neither is he ved vyas who wrote mahabharat, most current time so called sadhu sants are corrupt and don't know shit abt hinduism, British divided india on the base of cast and religion and also manipulated Hindu texts and history to fool ppl, none of the hindu scriptures mentions discrimination or the word 'dallit' , the word dallit is not even mentioned in manusmriti. Get ur facts check kid before commenting bs, u better try reading original hindu texts rather than listening to the so called sadhus who are fooling ppl🤡🤡
Yes sir plz make a dedicated video on this topic nd plz add hindi subtitles so that we can share it with our hindi speaking population.
Ur efforts can bring revolution in the society.
Just like how a criminal will not accept that there’s crime the casteist manuwadi parasatic bania-bamman cabal will also not accept that they practice casteism
Just like you are being a hypocritical moron yourself by trying to be anti caste but giving casteist slurs at Brahmins or Baniyas only (where caste based violence was not also done by them in recent centuries) but keeping mum on Chitapawan Brahmin massacre or Kashmiri Pandit massacre.
Please make a separate dedicated video for this topic. Of course we should go through the resources you mentioned but it would be nice to know it from your perspective.
I researched from Wikipedia that before the Turkic invasion (late 12th century) varna system is india is flexible but after it became very rigid
Both recommended book are written by foreigners and we use it to explain our history. Just read manusmriti and Gita, you will find that how caste system is deeply rooted in India.
See charaksamhita says eat and sleep which is materialistic ,do u believe people idealise it ,rig ved is athesism ,are Hindus athesist ??? During Mahabharat polyandry happened is it accepted ,first time draupadi was openly defamed in court,kings were becoming a mess ,brothers were fighting and bloodthirsty,this is all a representation of what will happen in kalyug so stop that ,so Mahabharata justifies that no one should be denied education based on leniage but talent otherwise dharma would perish ulike dhorna beheaded for karna and the deeds he did due to prejudices
Read the original Mansmriti, not translated, read that and you'll come to know. Kid
Get your facts write
MANUSMRITI TALKS ABOUT ONLY 4 VARNAS BRAHMIN,KHSATRIYA,VAISHYA AND SHUDRA THERE IS NO MENTION OF WORD DALIT.
Ambedkar stated that the Shudras of present day Hindu society are entirely different from Shudras of ancient Indian Society, this statement itself suggest that there was the sinister ploy played by some big gangs and their stooges to distort well defined original Varna system based on Guna-karma with the aim to segregate and divide Indians based on twisted caste taggings.
BhagwadGeet Shri Krishna says:
चातुर्वर्ण्यं मया सृष्टं गुणकर्मविभागशः।
तस्य कर्तारमपि मां विद्ध्यकर्तारमव्ययम्।।4.13।।
Translation: - The four categories of occupations were created by Me (Krishna/GOD/supreme conscious) according to people’s qualities and activities. Although I am the Creator of this system, know Me to be the Non-doer and Eternal.
Here is another pointer. Shivaji Maharaj was born a Shudra, but he became a Kshtriya. That’s why the coronation happened. Chandragupta Maurya was a Shudra ,the founder of Maurya dynasty. But once you take up the professiona of a Kshtriya, you become that. So, there was fluidity in the society.
I have disagreed with Avijit in the past on this issue, but more I read I feel there is lot more shades of grey, and not so black and white.
I want to raise a question if caste is western invention why Basavanna fought against casteism. Do research about Basavanna. I wish, casteism is western invention and what I read was wrong. That's why answer this Acharya
Sc and st is not part of hindu religion, he is untouchable till now for hindu..
Lol😂🤣🤣😂 many sudras ruled india😂🤣😂
Sir caste system is a pre colonial things it was very prominent in india and sanatan society is suffering .
Good example are which are our village which are ancient settlement .you can see the mapping on village the outskirts of village are lower caste and as you come center were higher class live .
Bhai 400 years bhoot hote Hai brain wash karne ke liye
@@franky7388 Exactly Brother people like these will never accepted, but if you read history you will easily get that Caste Never existed in Bharat
Proof??
@@franky7388 Because it is not fact. Last Anglo Maratha war was fought in 1817. Mahatma Phule started schools for dalit in 1840s. some very short period to create caste and discrimination all over India.
@@franky7388 400 years?? British ruled India for 150 years.
Half right half wrong
What's wrong?
Full wrong 😂
@@akshaysharma3809 full right
Yes, he's half right, half wrong: *Rig Veda 10.23.4* "With him is this rains: Indra throws drops of moisture on his yellow beard"
*Rig Veda 10.96.8* "At the swift draught, the Iron One with yellow beard and yellow hair"
*Rig Veda 1.100.18* “Indra attacked the Dasyus and the Śimyus; won the land, sunlight, and water with his white-complexioned friends”
*Rig Veda 1.103.3* “Armed with the thunderbolt, he has gone on destroying the cities of the Dasyus, and augment the strength and glory of the Ārya.”
*Rig Veda 1.130.8* “Indra defends his Ārya worshiper. He consumes the malignant; he tore off the b_______ skin; and him who delights in cruelty.”
*Rig Veda. 2.20.6* "Indra, the slayer of Vrittra, has scattered the Dasyu sprang from a b______ womb."
*Rig Veda 2.20.7* “Indra, the slayer of Vṛtra, destroyer of cities, has scattered the b______-sprung servile.”
*Rig Veda 3.34.9* "Indra gained possession of the Sun, Horses, Cow. He smote the Dasyus, and gave protection to the Aryan color."
*Rig Veda 9.73.5* “They have roared in unison, burning up riteless men, Blowing away the b______ skin which Indra hates.”
This Conversation between Yudhistira and Nahusha found in Mahabharat exposes the Truth of Caste System :
Nahusha: Who is a Brahman?
Yudhisthira: One who posses the qualities of truthfulness, charity, forgiveness, good conduct, mercy, and who observes the duties of the Brahmans should be considered to be a Brahman.
Nahusha: These qualities could be conceivably found in a Sudra also..
Yudhisthira: If these qualities are found in a Sudra, then he should be considered to be a brahman. It is the actual possession of these qualities that make a person a Brahman and the lack of them makes the person a sudra.
Nahusha then challenged : O King, if the Varna (Caste) of a person is determined by qualities alone and not by birth, then how can the Varna (Caste) of a Child be determined ?
Yudhisthira: One cannot be considered to belong to any Varna (Caste) by birth.Every one is a Sudra at the time of birth. Until a person is initiated by a bona-fide Acharya (Teacher), He must be considered a Sudra, no matter how exalted his birth may be.
Most people in comments still didn't understand what he explained and are arguing unnecessarily
The caste system as it exists today is thought to be the result of developments during the rise of the British colonial government in India.The British Raj furthered this development, making rigid caste organisation a central mechanism of administration. By 1860 the British formulated the caste system into their system of governance, granting administrative jobs and senior appointments only to Christians and people belonging to certain castes.
No
@@kingpin7392 yes
This is the kind of exhiliry content that i pay my internet bills for.
I agree with your statement that the caste system was the work of the British. Still, I am always conflicted about the Mahabharat stories about how Karna was humiliated by everyone for being a suta putra, including his guru Parashurama... what is the rationale behind this?
Suta means chariot..
Parashuram cursed him for him lying of being bramhan but parsuram got that he is kshatriya..
Dronacharya had taught him but didn't taught about bramhastra..
@@megatron6382 that meant caste system was prevalent in Maharashtra,if ur saying Brahmin and kshatriya,...
@@kiranjot5495 ,ek shart lagate hai,koi bet lagate hai..phir uske baad discuss karenge..
In manusmriti, it said that you can change caste. like if you pursue education you are brahmin or you do manual labour then you are shudra. it's said that Brahimi's are the head, Kshatriya are the arms vyshya are the body and shudra are the feet. And even in bhagavad gita, I think 3rd section, krishna said you need to follow your verna(caste), I this the Krishna meant that if you don't follow the drama the society will collapse.
As for caste persicution, it was real. I belive the reason was, people start to keep pursuing their parents jobs like their parents and as generation spaned, people in brahmins and kshathria got conceited and looked down on people. They banned people from moving up the caste, if you this that how can you force a entire population, well brahmins holds knowledge and khatriya are military personal and rulers, so they have both knowledge and military power to suppress decent.
And the colony has been finished for many years so why is India still letting it be prevalent ??
because of constution and education system it's in law as is and was imposed on uneducated Indians
What are your views on writing about chandelas who were not allowed to enter villages??
Did British teach people to look down upon the people of lower cast which I have seen myself in the society?
That's something I've been wondering ever since hearing this perspective about the caste system. I think the truth might lie somewhere between the mainstream history and Abhijit's claim.🙄
These are all baseless claims. Check this out. Last Anglo Maratha war was fought in 1817. Mahatma Phule started schools for dalit in 1840s. some very short period to create caste and discrimination all over India.
Will definitely go through your recommendations, but for me it is quite hard to believe that the British did it coz I can see caste discrimination in our scriptures like Ramayana & Mahabharata. Pls also make a video on what happened with Eklavya was right or wrong and also about Surya putra Karna. Eagerly waiting for your views on the same.
You can see "caste discrimination" in Ramayan and Mahabharat because you're probably reading Devdutt Pattanaik or Wendy Doniger or some such agenda mongering charlatan instead of the actual texts.
One thing i know, that in mahabharata, the cauravas and their teachers died for each reason, like duryadhan died becuase he did bad deeds against draupadi, and stole the kingdom of pandavas. Bhishma died because even after seeing the disrespect of draupadi, was silent. And dronacharya too died. And it was because he ordered to cut the finger of his own "shishya" or ekalavya because of his favorite student arjuna
Eklavya ka father jarasandh ka army general tha toh wo chhoti caste ka kaise ho gaya?? Karna bhi kunti ka beta tha par wo victim card play karta tha.. Tv serial na dekh ke mahabharat book pado tab clearity aayegi.. Pehle mai bhi karna ko achha manti thi tv me dekh ke par book me kahani waise nahi hai.. Aur aise toh shri krishna bhi gwalo ke ghar rahe par unhone toh victim card nahi khela..
I had the same questions. Also, what about Manusmriti? It's too confusing 😭
@@poornimadubey3028 Its not confusing at all if you pay enough attention. Abhijit has already uploaded separate videos explaining the Eklavya matter. As for Manu Smriti, it is among the most seminal of texts among what are collectively called the Dharma Shastras, which were the very basis of paramount future treatises by the likes of Vishnugupt Chanakya (Kautilya) in the north and Thiruvalluvar (author of Thirukkural) in the south. Just because Colonial Indology did a systematic propaganda campaign against Manu Shastra (the same was later propagated by "eminent" Marxists in the academia, and has today become the gospel truth via repetition) by inserting mischievous interpolations and mistranslations, it doesn't make the original samhita what they keep claiming it to be.
Its refreshing to hear from a Man's point of view of world affairs past& present not influenced by western mind set .
So, the Indian defence forces & research - innovation, Home ministry police - security PERSONS must be paid huge - this helps India grow & also drive through any tough situation !!
Next comes the teacher - educator - skill trainer
Then business - job
& Remaining people anyways are those who aren't willing to learn & earn via skill / work n just lazy - obviously ignored !!
colonisers definitely increased the gap between the castes but discrimination on the basis of caste definitely existed before the colonisers as tulsidas has also said some questionable things about casteism
I have a question
What's the difference between general, obc, st, sc and brahmin, kshatriya, vaishya and shudra ?
Sorry Abhijit...you are absolutely wrong.... Caste is not British Invention... This is something introduced by the so called educated sect of India(Brahmins) to cement their top position in the society, of course misinterpreting a Dharma shastra (Manusmriti). Sorry.. your answer on this issue disappointed me😌😌 of course, it started on the basis of occupation but later became birth right.... A brahmin's son always became a brahmin whether he is eligible to be a brahmin or not....
Typical tamilian comment
Do u even have read Manu smriti(not the Max muller version)
Go by Gothra to break the colonial caste system...
#AskAbhijit why school is not teaching about fact that how British created caste system in India using their discriminations ideas.
Is it not responsibility of school to encourage and increase self confidence of schedule caste
Because it is not fact. Last Anglo Maratha war was fought in 1817. Mahatma Phule started schools for dalit in 1840s. some very short period to create caste and discrimination all over India.
Nawh, caste is not good. If the British makes it happen, why not Modi remove it? because privilege got better and marginalise got shittier
#Ask Abhijit was people in india free to marry anyone without any discrimination on the bases of caste ? Because now days there are a lot of problems related to intercaste marriage ?
I can bet casteism would have gone by now in 2023 if reservation was not happen in this country and everyone was equally treated. But in order to give some groups opportunity to grow quickly they have played with fire. Now majority of general category ppl hate them for taking their opportunities in various field. Also because of reservation ppl will always remember the caste, because whenever someone says sc st reservation comes to mind.
Every varna
Brahmims-shankaracharya,savarkar
Kshatriya- chatrapathi shivaji maharaj, maharana pratap,rajarajchoula,surajmal
Shudra- Ravidas ji , komram bheem ,allurisita ramraju
Every varna protect roots of sanatan dharma
I think alluri sitarama raju is kshatriya
In Brahmin also add godse
@@dilipkumar-hc5kq but he was in jungle so he was contributing as kshatriya
@@deep4874 what?
@@dilipkumar-hc5kq I mean he converted to tribal
If you see the history of southern Indian , different kingdoms were established from people who were practicing diffrent occupations . Origins of western Gangas, Rastrakutas, Hoysalas, Keladi Nayakas, Chitradurga Nayakas etc. Great Vijayanagar kingdom itself was founded by cow herders, but later the when the inscriptions were translated they were told as Yadava ( Lord Krishna's) lineage. I see it was purely done for political purposes. Another intresting fact is Jainism existed along with Hinduism when the great kingdoms flourished. And the society was less divided atleast in terms of hereditary occupations.
Hello sir. I watched your podcast with ranveer about Indian ancient history. It gave me lot of knowledge about history. Sir with due respect if you allow me to ask about Indian cultural education or about Sadhguru's Isha samnskirti education system.
Manustrmati rip Bangladesh and it's 😂😂
First of all there are only 4 classes in Hinduism that are Brahmin Kshatriyas Vaishya and Shudra.
And according to Puranas everyone is born a shudra , it is only by one's action and profession he/she can become those other class as it is a Varna based system.
Skanda Purana Vol.18 Book VI , Nagar Kanda , Chapter 239
जन्मना जायते शूद्रः संस्कारात् द्विज उच्यते।
शापानुग्रहसामर्थ्यं तथा क्रोधः प्रसन्नता ।|31-34||
Everyone is born shudra.
By birth everyone is Shudra; it is only by purification, enrichment & education one becomes a Dwija (knowledgeable)”
Dwija means born again- meaning change in one’s mind & soul!
@@KaiserOfAryas Why not its also a Hindu scripture
@@KaiserOfAryasAll smritis are Hindu scriptures,Upanishad,ramayan,Mahabharata etc.are also smriti so are they not hindu scripture...
@@KaiserOfAryasProof that they are edited
@@KaiserOfAryasSo that means that this(Bhavishya Purana) purana is edited not all of them.....
This guy is quoting from "Skanda Purana"
which is right.......
BTW every Hindu organization say that purana are Hindu scripture(go to their website)
It priced 10,152 ₹ in amazon😅
So you are saying that the oppression on Dalits began after britishers came to India and before that Brahmins and other upper caste individuals lived in harmony with the lower caste people And what about Manusmriti ?
PS. This is just a question to clear my doubts don't take it in a wrong way.