Indian Navy Revolt 1946: The GREAT BETRAYAL
Вставка
- Опубліковано 6 гру 2021
- From Episode 37 of #AskAbhijit.
WATCH FULL EPISODE: #AskAbhijit 37: Indian History ► • #AskAbhijit 37: Indian...
SUBSCRIBE ► ua-cam.com/users/AbhijitChavda...
SHORT CLIPS CHANNEL ► ua-cam.com/users/AbhijitChavda...
------------------------------------------------------------------------
SUPPORT THE CHANNEL
------------------------------------------------------------------------
►UPI (G-Pay/PhonePe/Paytm): abhijitchavda@icici
►PayPal: paypal.me/AbhijitChavda
►Become A Member on UA-cam: / @abhijitchavda
------------------------------------------------------------------------
JOIN #AbhijitChavda
------------------------------------------------------------------------
★Discord: / discord
★Twitter: / abhijitchavda
★Instagram: / theabhijitchavda
★Facebook: / theabhijitchavda
★Website:
★Email Inquiries: inquiries.chavda@gmail.com
------------------------------------------------------------------------
#AskAbhijitPodcast
------------------------------------------------------------------------
★Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/1WmKYRI...
★Apple Podcasts: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast...
★Google Podcasts: podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0...
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
#AskAbhijitChavda #Abhijit #Chavda #AskAbhijitShow
my grandpa was one of the forerunners of 1946 naval revolt n was later court-martialed post independence. thats how india treats its freedom fighters.
@@weaksupremacy3799 hey thnks bro, i was indeed looking for some good book recommendation.
India treats? You mean Congress government.
Sad to hear that but you must always feel immensely proud of him🙏🏻
Yeh Sab hume history mai kyun nahi padhya jata. Aapke grandpa ko salute
My heart goes out to you.
I feel betrayed even if i wasn’t there back then… can understand what those people went through…
@@JokerJoker-xc7xb damn, i wisj=h this was taught to all the children in the shitty education system😔😔
The Britishers did't leave india because of Gandhi's satya and ahinsha movements but because they didn't had anymore thing to take from India
Gandhi was planted by the British.. So British establishment didn't even care about Gandhi.. Gandhi enjoyed all privileges while the whole country was suffering and while they believed Gandhi was the right leader just because of the way he spoke.. Gandhi was fake..
Gandhi was preaching non violence to our innocent indians but supporting british and muslims in their violence and he justified the killings of hindus. He was a cunning fellow.
MKG stands exposed now...true British stooge...took a lot of money to keep him poor 😭
I think it is fair to say, if Gandhiji had stayed in South Africa, India would have GAINED INDEPENDENCE 20 YRS EARLIER ON IT'S OWN TERMS......and BHARAT, which used to be India and Pakistan, would not have been divided.
The entire Indian subcontinent would have remained as one OR atleast would have been divided on Indian people's terms IF there was a desire to have an Islamic state
@@sanjayshah4372 there are 1000s of possibilities
if gandhi would have stayed in south africa it's very much possible that after the jalliawala bagh indians would have kicked the british out of india and we would have gained independence in early 1920s itself
if gandhi would have not called out non cooperation movement we would have gained independence in late 1920s and of course the nation would not have been divided it was because of gandhi's sudden calling off of the NCM that muslims felt alienated from india and the demand for 2 nation grew
gandhi had the power to save bhagat singh but he didn't if he would have saved him india would have been independent by 1935 and we would have seen a young and revolutionary leader like bhagat singh become our PM or president
if sc bose wouldn't have died/went missing in taipei we would have seen a benevolent dictatorship (meaning a good dictatorship like turkey just after the ottoman empire) our military would have been strong, china wouldn't have invaded tibet and ladakh
9 naval mutineers were hanged to death on same day. Their names were Kalipada Aich, Chittaranjan Mukherjee, Durgadas Roychowdhury, Nanda Kumar Dey, Niranjan Barua, Nirendra Mohan Mukherjee, Fanibhusan Chakraborty, Man kumar Basu Thakur and Sunil Kumar Mukherjee. Two female rebels named Anubha Sen and Urmila Bai were raped and killed by the British. They worked as female cadets and dared to secretly deliver important messages to the rebels. Such a supreme sacrifice was made by our ancestors for independence.
Oh god can you tell us more about it.
why do we respect relations between brits and India now? we have the high ground but still tata opens comanies acquires brits in its companies , tata will say indians are not that educated or deserving if not why didn't he foucesd on opening more schools instead of acquiring british companies?
he is a fake indian nationalist. he has invested so much money into anti-hindu harvard humanities.@@kaushiksarkar7837
My Great great Grandfather was in British Indian army he fought the Japanese in Burma after being captured he was later sent to INA lead by Subhash Chandra Bose.
Our family had thought that he was martyred in Burma so they performed all rituals. After 1947 when he came to village our family members were surprised to see him as they had thought that he was martyred in Burma.
Being in Japan as a prisoner he recalled those days and started to build a house in Japanese style which even stands today in my village.
wow aepic
very interesting
VANDE MAATARAM
JAI HIND 🙏❤️🇮🇳
Can you post your Japanese style home on Instagram and tell me your Instagram Id? Cause I love many parts of Japanese culture
Show your house
My grandfather fought Japanese in northeast and Burma . And had many stories of kind of racism that they faced during their service 😓.
My grandfather served in egypt for the british indian army and he used to tell me about the racism there. He always laughed at our text book stories on Gandhi bringing freedom. He always told me that freedom was because of Netaji and the naval revolt.
VANDE MAATARAM
JAI HIND 🙏❤️🇮🇳
But We studied NCERT
See 10 most dangerous for the British in British India. Commissioners scot. Police photographer marine lines near Madras hotel
My 10th std history teacher quoted "Netaji never believed in begging for freedom like Gandhi, he believed in getting it as one way or another."
This is how many revolt failed in india otherwise we were so powerful to overthrow british... And Accuqired real independence!
After British was gone, there will be a huge power vaccum.... Everyone will be fighting for their own interest like Rajputs, Sikhs, Marathas, Tamil etc..
Every single person will be close to one of these groups and will be fighting for glory of some dumb king, who licked British Boots
@@Dhksksjjsjjs every eastern countries have nightmare when the think about Netaji shubhas chanda Bose.
🙏🙏🙏🙏❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🙏🙏🙏🙏
@@Dhksksjjsjjs That's the case of every country,let the process through civil war the American civil war,sengoku period in Japan,Chinese power struggle between innumerable factions including monarchists,nationalists,communists,regional powers),1917 russian revolution,1789 French revolution+nepoleon+endless nepoleonic wars till 1815,common that's the rule in most prominent countries,one power will come on top in the end,india is no different🙄 your talking like it's something exclusive to India,at that time power and greatness came through war same like Genghis Khan United the Mongols and chandra gupta Maurya United the bulk of India.....
@@Dhksksjjsjjs Dumb king???you mean present day politicians are enlightened? Such a preconcieved notion,the Sikh empire,Marathas and most prominent Indian powers have never exepted British authority that's why they fell.....you cannot be a king when your dumb that's a rule you would be immediately overthrown.
@@Dhksksjjsjjs Better eat grass than live under foreign occupation.Better die and fight than live in slavery of a foreign race ....
Yesterday I was telling one liberandus abut this exactly and he called me what's app university || Thank God I read books and still doing and your video sir was Chery on the top
Idiots, they are. They think the Naval Mutiny was from whatsapp university .
In few years after telling Diwali and Thirupathi is of Buddhist, they'll say Netaji was a fictional character
Librandus can't reply to your #facts. So they just call whatsapp university.
Ask them about the life of Savarkar too! They will declare him traitor in a second without knowing any single fact of his life except that letter.
@@weaksupremacy3799 the minute I read word "Guardian " My ears and Head filled with suspicious alert read carefully || it's like Pakistan says I am not terrorist and join (Anti terror exercise with rest of world ||So I keep it away for 😂 but thanks 🙏🕉 Haar haar mahadev
@@weaksupremacy3799 The inquisition by Ananta Kakba Priolkar || I read || but I hope Guardian of Dawn is not biased at all 😂🙏🕉🕉
Don't waste your valuable time for libreals
Can you tell us more about The great bengal famine.. During World War 2
when bengal famine name comes, first thing i get in mind is Bastard Churchil
One of the battleship that was seized by Indian sailors had it's guns even pointed towards gate of India . That was a great flex 💥
I feel cheated by the fact that I have never heard this incident before today, ever. Such a historically significant event is just missing from our textbooks.
I was born in Liverpool, as was my father. He was in the RAF and was shipped to India in 1942. He crossed India by train from Mumbai to Calcutta. Then on to Kohima..
Battle of Kohima in 1944?
Moral of the story: Never trust politicians. Not one of them. Not even today. Not even tomorrow. For political power, politicians are willing to sell their soul.
Take care, everybody. Jayatu Sanatana. Jai Bharat! 🙏🕉
Moral is : we have e very strong tendency to find god among humans & completely rely on them, that's why we trust any figure easily & make him mahatma, we don't try to understand the other side or even doubt it
No one is pure, if someone is trying to show himself pure, may be he's hiding something
My father had participated in the Naval uprising of 1946.He was a part of the wireless communication in a naval flotilla HMIS BARRACUDA sailing in the Bay of Bengal.
Congratulation on 200k subscribers
i hope all ur content is backed up outside youtube just in case
#AskAbhijit Another narrative says that the British being economically weak after the second world war gave them all the more reason to further use the resources from India for rebuilding their economy and therefore had no plans to quit India. It was only due to Netaji's INA, the public sentiment against the INA trials, and the revolt of the Royal Indian Navy, that the British were forced to leave India.
I strongly support this view.
Most plausible view.
Exactly, why would they leave a country like India where they can get cheap labour, lots of land and resources etc
Bose the goat..
Hero without any credits!
British would have squeezed indians even more as they had run up huge debts with the Americans during the second world war and what easier way to repay those debts than by screwing indians even more
Here the lesson to be learned. Thanks for retelling Mr Chavez. New generation can use this lesson for protecting motherland from internal threat of jihadis
Also to never people any political party, fighters believed thier word ended up getting arrested & tortured.
I remember reading about this in my history book in a "small blue box". These revolts are never highlighted or discussed in our books as important, because then they will also have to mark the fact that the promises made to the sailors were never fulfilled.
What do you expect from left-written history books?
Completely unaware of this revolution. Thanks to colonial Education.
#askabhijit sir what if when subhash chandra bose become a pm of india, can india become a super power earlier
Communist United India
Friend of China USSR .....
May Crushed Afghanistan.....
End of Democracy in Asia
.....
Yes definitely great visionary , Jai Hind
Patel was a great visionary leader Bharat had it other wise........!
Definitely 💯
I want to know abhijit sir point of view...
Great question and a brilliant answer 😊👍🏽👍🏽🚩🇮🇳
This should be portrayed on Cinema. Everybody should know this.
I used to believe Gandhi was a saviour until I discovered this channel
I am so ashamed, that I was fooled by our education system.
The history taught in our schools is shit.
absolutely enlightning... I am sure most of the people know nothing about this. @Abhijit We need people like you to write history text books for India schooling boards....
Feel Extremely Bad for them who fought for indias Independence and was not given compensation and were putted into jail
Karma : Vallabh Bhai Patel was back stabbed by Gandhi when Patel was Selected to be the first PM of India.
Yes true bcz of gandhi
the 1947 independence was for the political parties and not the independence of the people of India ... azadi could have been "snatched" but the congress ensured it was converted to "bheek"... the partition was also not for the people of the country but for the political parties who wanted only power
When I read about it in 8 th standard I knew intitutively that it was bombay mutany by navy which made India independent. Thanks for bringing out the facts
Thanks for answer this question of 1946.
Even today in Indian subcontinent we have same colonial Hangover among officers of armed forces and in our police services.
What if there were no one to oppose congress and to represent hindus like hindu mahasabha and other organisations?? This will make everyone understand the importance also liberal hindus will understand to whom they are loyal !!
Write #askabhikit thist will get his attention
We Hindus are forever indebted to Hindu Mahaasabha if it wasn't for them Gandhi would've been running around giving up territories in the name of "ahimsa" , which surprising was only limited to us Hindus.
Why is the British George Cross still a part of the naval flag...
I think indian navy is still proud of slavery
This is how India treats it's Patriots 😭
200k!!! What an absolutely phenominal journey sir, we have come so far, having enlightened a greater number, and even having a discord!! 🍻🍸🎉
Such a shame moment! Just for the sake of powers, there was such a disastrous blunders. Thanks for the question and also to address it and bring it to our attention
#AskAbhijit Wrt Modern Indian History, Please elaborate about:
a. The unknown Partition of British India into Sri Lanka & Burma whicj were not objected to or protested against, by the INC.
b. The "Balkanization" plan of Mountbatten and it's reattempt by Colonial forces via sponsoring & giving space to the various breaking india forces(also discussed in the book by the same name and authored by Shri Rajiv Malhotra).
c. Why was Bangladesh (then East Pakistan) partitioned in the manner to isolate the North East from rest of India and to cut off the coastal access it earlier had via the Chittagong region south of today's Tripura? Was it to isolate & further the Protestant evangelization cause? What was the role of Missionary (garbed as Anthropologist) Verrier Elwin on this and how Nehru supported him?
This is so Disturbing this bastards made us fool for so long 😧
Thank you for details sir.
We didn't know the extent of betrayals of Congress to us.
Thanks for your efforts
my Grandfather was part of the Brit Indian Army which was laid off after WW2. He later joined Karnataka Police.
Congratulations for 200k subscribers, thank you for sharing real truth
Thank you for this. 🙏🏻
Very Informative
Thanks #AskAbhijit
Wow... never heard of this revolt before... thankyu sir
Excellent
It's the first time I heard about this. Thanks✌
#askabhijit please tell us about battle of 10 kings please sir only you can explain it well
🙏 Please sir
I Am asking this question from 2 weeks
Ask in the community section.
The revolters should not have listened to the netas. They should have snatched the independence from the Brits. Alas! cunning netas won and India split into 3 lands.
Never ever Heard about all these stuff from the school days till i happened to see this video.
Sir congratulations on 200k subscriptions
I really feel sad hearing about this
Very knowledgeable videos, I also got inspired by your content.🙏
Congratulations on 2lakh subs
Thank you sir, I was looking for this answer from a long time.
Thank you for this video. I hope someone makes a good movie using these facts. Our history books have kept this hidden from many of us.
Great explanation 🚩🔥
7 Nov 1966 Sadhu massacre?#askabhijit
Jai Hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳 Jai Netaji ❤️❤️❤️
The Royal Indian Navy mutiny or revolt, also called the 1946 Naval Uprising,[1] was an insurrection of Indian naval ratings, soldiers, police personnel and civilians against the British government in India. From the initial flashpoint in Mumbai, the revolt spread and found support throughout India, from Karachi to Kolkata, and ultimately came to involve over 20,000 sailors in 78 ships and shore establishments.
Very interesting part of our recent history
Thank you sir for bringing about the sour truth
Sardar vallab was also..... wow.
He couldn't do anything power was heads on the gandhi and nehru ... he was a foot soldiers..
For the first time I have heard that a nationalist is criticising Sarder Patel!
It's sad that even a person like Sardar Vallabh Bhai Patel was part of this cruel story .It must have been gandhi who made him do this .
sir if we had 25 lakh solder in 1946
whhy we have only 14 lak now?
India+pak+Bangladesh
Because of automation
Modern armies are smaller
Wow .. When will the country start teaching actual history ?
I don't think it will happen. Our parliament is weak AF. For example, even if we change history books, the liberals would wage war on the internet. For many days they will continue this, UA-cam would be "polluted with freedom slogans". It will be trended for 1 month. Many celebs and journalists will tells their fans not to read books as is contains " fascist " history. Overall the current government will lose votes.
Meanwhile our idiot Conservatives will chant "Jay shree ram" in every comment section. The liberals will use this exactly to make the narrative look like "a religious group" is supporting this change. Our country won't like this narrative. Its very unfortunate.
Revolt had started spreading to the army as well, for example, in Jabalpur. It failed because the Congress leaders colluded with the British in undermining it.
Congress was corrupt from the very beginning
This hurts at many levels! 😡
Hearing it for the 1st time.. 🙏
Enemies within are more dangerous than those outside.
During the 1946 Naval revolt, Indians of all backgrounds....Hindus, Muslims, Sikhs, Christians,etc stood together. The revolt spread to other naval bases as well as army cantonments. The British came to very nearly being toppled. Gandhi, Jinnah and others came to the aid of the British and managed to persuade the mutineers to end the uprising.
Mahatma Gandhi was the great traitor
All three that is the british, congress and muslim league would have been losers if the army ,navy and airforce had toppled the british in 1946,hence all affected parties rushed to quell the indian rebellion befoe ordinary indians joined the rebels en masse
#AskAbhijit
@AbhijitChavda sir could you please explain role of great leader Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose in India's Independence and their death history.
Shocked by the laxity of Patel....
I feel so sad while many innocents gave up their lives to free our country some vishwas ghatak were in command of power and steered the fate of India other way. Why God why?
We have taught since childhood India won independence by Ahimsa ( Sabarmati ka sant ne kar dia kamal ....and all that stuff).Now gigantic statue of the person who duped the revolutionaries ( the term mutioneers is not approptiate) is erected .🤥
Hope some day truth shall prevail.
Congrats for silver play button
Once again when fighters believed the lies of political people ended up getting imprisoned, tortured & gruesome death. Also ending up tearing Hindustan.
Very emotional 🥺🥺😭
My father was convicted for throwing British goods intomthe sea
1929. Convicted got 1 year
Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose formed Indian National Army. Their efforts and the Indian Naval Mutiny were one of the main reasons for India's independence
I would love to hear about Prime Minister Atlee's statement from you sir
Sir, if hypothetically Taiwanese gov was in power in mainland China also what might be their stance towards Tibet, Arunachal Pradesh, Aksai Chin, South China sea and other Chinese claimed regions??? #AskAbhijit
Their stand will be same, it will depend upon us how we handle them, by the way of Gandhi or Netaji Subhas
Taiwanese gov. at that time we're no different from communist. China still would have ended up similar to current dictatorship.
@@DeoAsh is Taiwan a Dictatorship?
Like after 1980s Koumintang became Democracy
Please refer books regarding the events you discuss in your videos... It will really really help
#Respect for calling it a revolt
#AskAbhijit If we invaded foriegn then why only R1 group is found not Indigenous "Haplogroup H"
History Teacher NCERT needs. Shame to study what I mugged up in my school.
#AskAbhijit
Hello Sir,
Does the first secret agency was started by Veer Damodar Savarkar in 1900 and also aggressive movement against British before Gandhi?
Respect to naval sailors and netaji🙏
#AskAbhijit sir please can you tell us about yuri bezmenov 🙏🏻🙏🏻
Probably the most hopeful, yet the saddest moment of modern Indian history. :'(
Day by day my faith in mr Gandhi is fading out
What will be the differences in indian independence if we would have freed india via 1946 Indian navy revolt instead of receiving independence on british terms on 1947? #AskAbhijit
We would have got sampoorna swarajya.All the effects british had done to India would have been eliminated had the royal Navy Mutiny succeeded.Because in 1947 we got freedom on the terms set by the british.
#AskAbhijit I absolutely loved some your podcasts with Ranveer on The Ranveer show and one of those podcasts had me thinking this
So there's kind of a parallelism between your mind(inner universe) and the external universe. Now we know the external universe is expanding. Also our internal universe expands ,as u said, through meditation . And also through evolution over the course of time. So over time the external universe keeps expanding and so does the internal universe.
So does that mean time is just a measure of how much internal or external universe has expanded?
And maybe that also means that time itself has started ever since the universe started expanding?
Not some kind of parallelism but according to Swami Vivekanand Ji these are same they just appear different.
And mind is a part of inner univers not whole, you can watch Swami Sarvapriyananda Ji's video for more clarity 🙏
Hmmmm That's interesting! Thanks for that point Ranita. So I think that point further enforces the definition/understanding of Time itself that I was asking about. Abhijit Sir,would love to hear your thoughts on this as well! #AskAbhijit
@@SourajitDrums time is a dimension strongly attached to manifestation of conscious self as thoughts, it's related to inner self, the knower and it IS relative
200k Subscribers 👍👍👍
The Britishers didn't leave India because of Gandhi's so called ahimsa or non-violent resistance and satyagraha . When your enemy has entered your house and is killing your family members , you simply can't deal with them through any such non-violent means. That's utterly nonsense. The Britishers left India because they now weren't able to utilise India because their economy was totally destroyed after the WWII and the indian resistance turned violence and gained ground. Plus Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose is the biggest reason . He created the INA and made it invade India to overthrow the Britishers. He was among the very few to have the guts and courage to look the Britishers eye to eye. The INA later on surrendered and when trial began , the revolt started and it turned violent. Former British Prime Minister Clement Atlee himself admitted that Bose was the main reason the British left India or were forcefully kicked out. Nothing in this world has been achieved by non violence. It's a shame that Bose wasn't given much credit after independence but he will forever remain in our hearts . If the British saw Gandhi as a threat , then they definitely would have killed him but they didn't. So that definitely makes a point
We got independence due to Subhash Chandra Bose, INA and world war 2 and the 1946 naval insurrection.
This must be published in the text books so that atleast now the real and true history is rewritten and studied properly. It helps the youth to understand our India and the injustice done to us by the then politicians have to be understood. Plz bringforth such truth because we have all studied the cooked up history of Congress and now at the age of 65 i am feeling very sad to know that i never knew the real history of my motherland. Our own nehru and gandhi have been the witnesses and causes of many massacres and they justified the killings of hindus. What kind of nonviolence was that.... Very sad for having blindly trusting those stories. This should not happen to others. Its time for enlightenment and awareness. Arise Awake and stop not till the goal is reached... Until the true history of india comes to light. 🙏🙏