Straight simple suggestion to phd aspirants... Mat karo. Kuch bhi karo bas phd mat karo. Shuru kiye ho to right now start preparing for jobs...else you will end up loosing some precious years of your life. Fir bhi passion hain aur capabilities hain to bahar karo, bas India me mat karo. Ye desh naa to scholar ko deserved samman deti hain naa job opportunity. Insult aur depression ke alava kuch nehi milta. Even if you are deserving but still cant sell yourself or cant brag about your silly achievements or cant create a halo of hype around yourself then no matter how good you are, your effort:payback ratio would stay low. So think thrice before coming to phd. It kills.
Mene bed. B Kiya hai govt lecturer me bhi hua tha Mera or ab fir Se vacancy aygi Sath me guest lecturer govt clg me Mera chance hai or assistant proffessor ke liye tyari krna chahti hu .
I am currently doing my research in TIFR, and I must say funding is a huge part of research in experimental fields. For theoretical research, the institute only matters because you would find great professors there. I would say, being in a good institute is really important because otherwise, it would be extremely difficult to get a good postdoc. So if you plan to do PhD please do it in a recognized institute, or you can do a good project for a while, for admissions in US/European institutes (try only top 500 QS ranked).
Let me tell you one thing! If you have funds in your lab and your guide is extra supportive then no matter where you are doing a PhD. Only fee varies 🙂
Heads after you Monu Sir :) The video was comprehensive and comprising of almost every kind of aspect of Ph.D. at different institutes in India. Thank you very much for making these great, informative videos. Rise and shine :)
There are also PhD in agricultural sciences, which are conducted by ICAR as ICAR SRF. Also DST INSPIRE fellowship can be claimed by gold medalist of respective branch
Thanks for this video. I am also in the field of educating candidates on PhD, especially IIMs (that was missing in this video). IIMs have something different from all of them. It would be really great to connect with you.
Good evening respected sir, Sir kindly make a video on step-by-step process for applying for Phd in USA like from very first step to last Each and every form As I belong to a rural area so I don't have much information As most of the videos describe few things
Nice video sir but i think what matters is net jrf or gate if you have that anyone will take you either in project or PhD they will not discuss your publication i am telling this from personal experience if you are a msc student your msc project and research paper will not help you to get any project or PhD only national level exam will do and if you are planning for PhD from abroad then only your publication will be helpful
You should have included the course work done during PhD program. Course work and the comprehensive exam makes lot of difference in the knowledge gained by the student. I have seen many students having very good publications but their knowledge is not that adequate. The old IITs are better in that regard.
Most important part you people missed is the accountability of a supervisor towards research scholar's work. This is totally missing in India. Phd is to make or train a researcher. But that totally misses in India.
Yes!!! This is the meaning of doing PhD. Students usually not try their hands in research earlier , then it is obvious for theGuideto Train them. Or if not, Recontinue the M.phil So that students can have experience of Resarch.
Well, I can comment about IISc, JNCASR and RRI. Students do get funds from the institute for going to conferences, and abroad. In most cases, that is enough. Sometimes, the professors have hefty fellowships from which they also fund students.
I am doing PhD. from IIT Patna, for technical you need to give objective/ subjective or both followed by interview....in our time we have given both and offcourse gate score matters ......we get TA duty and do research ...now timing depends on your guide .....work-life is more serious...and depends on your guide whether he allows in other activities or not...
Can we do PhD in distance mode from IITP with stipend? If yes then what is the process nd how much gate score is needed to get into? What is the difference in regular and distance mode phd, what's the weightages can u please explain bcz am from Bihta the city where IITP is located nd doing mtech..I want to do PhD from IITP bcz of convenience as it is in my hometown
I have personally known many teachers and many of them my colleagues who have completed their Ph.D from BHU or other central universities and they proudly say I have done my Ph.d from those institutes but actually they don't have any knowledge to write a good research paper for publication in reputed journals but not all but many of them. They always busy for making link to each other..I don't know how they completed their Ph.d without any knowledge.
We have professors who have done PhD from IITs. But they are not good at teaching Quantum Mechanics, for example, or Other core subjects. I don't know what is the quality of PhDs then. I also know Very Good Professors but they are in less number.
Monu Mishra ji, happy to hear that you are a Phd of NPL, as i also enrolled in NPL for phd in the quantum optics and photon physics section. Now I am working as Assistant Professor, selected through UPHESC.
To get enrolled easily for postdoc position in foreign universities (/ research institutes) which is better for doing PhD from IITs or Research institutes ? Plz reply sir...
Through gate score one gets TA category admission for direct PhD program at IITs. The stipend is clearly 31,000 pm. Which will get upgraded to 35,000 pm 2 years from joining in the program.
What is the facility of Library in Private University? Did library in a private university able to satisfy the research Information needs of the researcher!!! As the concern is private University libraries have less access to e-resources, academic and research databases, for which a researcher face too many problems in finding relevant scientific papers for his/ her research. Sir, Ask the researchers their involvement with library during their research tenure?
Sir i just want to add something u would have made some one seated in this discussion who have completed their phd from state university specially from Jharkhand and Bihar,than i think it will be more beneficial to the audience,that how is the life of phd scholar from such places
dear sir thanks for valuable video. i have query. actually currently i m working as a PhD junior reserach fellow in Gurukula kangri deemed to be university, haridwar since Jan 2021 including course work. Here i m publishing two paper regarding my research work. In short almost 70 % work has been done. now I get opportunity from CSIR-AMPRI for PhD position. I am confused should i choose this opportuniny or not?
I do PhD from BHU and I am suffering. The supervisor has almost no relation related to the scholar. No Guidance. You have to do everything be it right or wrong way!
Bhiyaa kya university mater krti hai ki aapne master's khaa se kiya hai...?? Please reply kya masters central ya state university se hee hona chahiye ?? Ya fir net jrf he Mater krtaa hai.??? Please reply
PhD is a Guide oriented program not University oriented. University brand matters only after you have done enough work to justify your PhD degree
Absolutely true
The best video available in all videos on UA-cam, for comparatively and topic wise cleared all doubt, Jabardast video👍
Straight simple suggestion to phd aspirants... Mat karo. Kuch bhi karo bas phd mat karo. Shuru kiye ho to right now start preparing for jobs...else you will end up loosing some precious years of your life. Fir bhi passion hain aur capabilities hain to bahar karo, bas India me mat karo. Ye desh naa to scholar ko deserved samman deti hain naa job opportunity. Insult aur depression ke alava kuch nehi milta. Even if you are deserving but still cant sell yourself or cant brag about your silly achievements or cant create a halo of hype around yourself then no matter how good you are, your effort:payback ratio would stay low. So think thrice before coming to phd. It kills.
Mene bed. B Kiya hai govt lecturer me bhi hua tha Mera or ab fir Se vacancy aygi Sath me guest lecturer govt clg me Mera chance hai or assistant proffessor ke liye tyari krna chahti hu .
@@shrishri8898 pdhne Valo ko job mil jati h .
Apka net jrf clear hai?@@studynotes9963
😂😂😂😂😂😂sb krke dekh liya pr jinhone phd kri thi atleast kahi na kahi job kr rhe idhr toh 6 sal teacher ki vacancy hi nhi aayi
Chl be chomu,, tjhe chance nhi mila,,to paka mat,, itna himmat hai to CSIR/ICMR/DBT JRF or GATE nikal k dikha....
Finally after a long time. Thank you for such a informative video...⚛️🌟
Thank you Sir for discussing such important topics..All the important points are discussed and explained beautifully.
I am currently doing my research in TIFR, and I must say funding is a huge part of research in experimental fields. For theoretical research, the institute only matters because you would find great professors there. I would say, being in a good institute is really important because otherwise, it would be extremely difficult to get a good postdoc. So if you plan to do PhD please do it in a recognized institute, or you can do a good project for a while, for admissions in US/European institutes (try only top 500 QS ranked).
Hello Respected sir can I get your contact number, I want to do PhD, I want get some advice from you 🙏🙏🙏
Let me tell you one thing! If you have funds in your lab and your guide is extra supportive then no matter where you are doing a PhD. Only fee varies 🙂
PhD k baad job to mil jaati h ns
@@rksince2023 It depends how many good links and money you have if we are talking about govt. Institutes
@@rksince2023in
True
Heads after you Monu Sir :)
The video was comprehensive and comprising of almost every kind of aspect of Ph.D. at different institutes in India.
Thank you very much for making these great, informative videos.
Rise and shine :)
Thanks
Thank you sir for bringing out this video! Got to Know various Information about PhD Experiences at these Institutes.
This video is suggested to me, and I must say this is the best one.
Thank you
सभी सर को नमस्कार, बहुत ही बेहतर जानकारी मिला, इसके लिए धन्यवाद
Best video I have ever seen on research Thanku sooo much !!
This video is gem for students who are confusing about phd or industry
Thankyou so much sir
True and ground level information from various research backgrounds 🤟🤟
Thank you brijmohan sir
Congrats...You've been absolutely blowing up in yt on this one.
Thanks
Perfect video. Thank you. Would love it if you can make one more video wuth PhD candidates from arts faculty.
Thank you all genuine scholars so much.
Best topic for ,bsc,msc students 👍🤩 thnx sir
Bahut sundar bhayya ji
mashaallah great job
PHd is a very uncertain degree. In India there is no time limit. Guide has no risk. Entire burden on students.
Guide bahut hi matter karta h!
Yes
Jayadatar guide supportive nahi hote hai
@@akshaypandhre6331 yesa nehi h! Dhundna padta h
Thank you sir guidence bahut matter karta h
@@satapathysatyabrata1591 kaise search kre
Thank you so much sir, it was very informative
Aree wah nitesh bhaiya.
Excellent👏. Thank you for sharing.
Well explained, Thank you.
Well said 🔥❤️👏 Appreciating
Apart from guide and instruments facilities I think academic institute like IITs and central universities have wonderful environments.
They do.
Love u sir and thank you 💓💓
Your efforts are commendable....Very helpful video
Thanks
This video was very informative. Thank you so much for sharing it. 🙏
There are also PhD in agricultural sciences, which are conducted by ICAR as ICAR SRF. Also DST INSPIRE fellowship can be claimed by gold medalist of respective branch
Bakwas hai. Unemployed youth krte hai agriculture mein p.hd
Thanks for this video. I am also in the field of educating candidates on PhD, especially IIMs (that was missing in this video). IIMs have something different from all of them. It would be really great to connect with you.
Thank you sir for this informative video 😎😎😎
Nice Discussion Sir. Can you please elaborate about self financed PhD in Research Institute?
Very informative and helpful.thank you
Good evening respected sir,
Sir kindly make a video on step-by-step process for applying for Phd in USA like from very first step to last
Each and every form
As I belong to a rural area so I don't have much information
As most of the videos describe few things
According to my opinion...please don't enroll for PhD in universities. University professors give more importance to academics not research
Thats an opinion.. not reality
Thank u sir one of the nost hol8stic video on youtube
Nice video sir but i think what matters is net jrf or gate if you have that anyone will take you either in project or PhD they will not discuss your publication i am telling this from personal experience if you are a msc student your msc project and research paper will not help you to get any project or PhD only national level exam will do and if you are planning for PhD from abroad then only your publication will be helpful
Well information...All 🙏
You should have included the course work done during PhD program. Course work and the comprehensive exam makes lot of difference in the knowledge gained by the student. I have seen many students having very good publications but their knowledge is not that adequate. The old IITs are better in that regard.
Coursework is nearly the same everywhere.. I don't think its makes a big difference
The quality of PhD has deteriorated due to high emphasis on number of publications
It's too good. Monu mishra ji
Thank you
@@drmonumishra hello sir I want to join PhD course in finaance how i can apply this course.my age 40 I'm a social worker.
Good.. Go ahead
Very informative thank you all!
I personally know nitesh sir, sir visited our department he is a great personality ❤️
Most important part you people missed is the accountability of a supervisor towards research scholar's work. This is totally missing in India. Phd is to make or train a researcher. But that totally misses in India.
So thats why we ignored
Yes!!! This is the meaning of doing PhD.
Students usually not try their hands in research earlier , then it is obvious for theGuideto Train them.
Or if not, Recontinue the M.phil So that students can have experience of Resarch.
Good to know about your experiences
Nice explain about PhD
Well, I can comment about IISc, JNCASR and RRI. Students do get funds from the institute for going to conferences, and abroad. In most cases, that is enough. Sometimes, the professors have hefty fellowships from which they also fund students.
They are few selected institutions.. check for any CSIR institute
Very informative session.... thank you sir.
I am doing PhD. from IIT Patna, for technical you need to give objective/ subjective or both followed by interview....in our time we have given both and offcourse gate score matters ......we get TA duty and do research ...now timing depends on your guide .....work-life is more serious...and depends on your guide whether he allows in other activities or not...
But is funding really that bad? Even in IITs? Why?
Yes.
Can we do PhD in distance mode from IITP with stipend? If yes then what is the process nd how much gate score is needed to get into? What is the difference in regular and distance mode phd, what's the weightages can u please explain bcz am from Bihta the city where IITP is located nd doing mtech..I want to do PhD from IITP bcz of convenience as it is in my hometown
@@saumyaneelam3208 no
Can I get IIT fellowship without Jrf ? I'm only qualified ugc net
Good work sir thank you
Thanks
Thank you so much 🙏🙏🙏🙏
I Studied in Motion institute as a JEE student and Got my dream collage just because of the teacher's support. 🙌🙌
I have personally known many teachers and many of them my colleagues who have completed their Ph.D from BHU or other central universities and they proudly say I have done my Ph.d from those institutes but actually they don't have any knowledge to write a good research paper for publication in reputed journals but not all but many of them. They always busy for making link to each other..I don't know how they completed their Ph.d without any knowledge.
I have studied from an institution where most of the professors are alumni of DU and BHU and I completely agree with you
We have professors who have done PhD from IITs. But they are not good at teaching Quantum Mechanics, for example, or Other core subjects.
I don't know what is the quality of PhDs then. I also know Very Good Professors but they are in less number.
Monu Mishra ji, happy to hear that you are a Phd of NPL, as i also enrolled in NPL for phd in the quantum optics and photon physics section.
Now I am working as Assistant Professor, selected through UPHESC.
Congratulations 👏
@@drmonumishra Thank you
Apne PhD krke asst proff qualify Kiya . Ya job ke sth hum PhD kr Skte hai?
@@studynotes9963 job ke saath kar sakte hain
@Hottie gurl🖤🥀 MSc Biotechnology from BHU
Wonderful explanation
PhD from India k baad academia jobs kese dhunde, konsi best hai??
Assistant Professor, Websites pe advertisement aate hai.
Please make the same explanatory video for bsc and msc comparing all places
Kosish karte hai
Sir really excellent video
To get enrolled easily for postdoc position in foreign universities (/ research institutes) which is better for doing PhD from IITs or Research institutes ? Plz reply sir...
Thanks sir for this news
Valueable👏🏼👏🏼
thanks very helpful
Super clarification for all Future scholars
Sir, can I get stipend of 31k same as like csir in central universities through gate score or only 8k even though if we have gate score?
Only non net standard fellowship with Gate score in central university
@@drmonumishra sir , means through gate score we can only get exemption from the university entrance test? The stipend they give only 8k?
Yes
In many iits and also at IPR gujrat they give stipend 31k (my friend is there)
Through gate score one gets TA category admission for direct PhD program at IITs. The stipend is clearly 31,000 pm. Which will get upgraded to 35,000 pm 2 years from joining in the program.
Nice discussion! Very transparent! You could have invited someone from biomedical sciences background as well!
Too many cooks spoil a dish.
Very informative.. But you have missed the INSPIRE fellowship
Yes.
Because Inspire id very doubtful
How doubtful?
Thank you, Monu bhai! Just discovered the channel and subscribed.
Thanks
What is the facility of Library in Private University? Did library in a private university able to satisfy the research Information needs of the researcher!!! As the concern is private University libraries have less access to e-resources, academic and research databases, for which a researcher face too many problems in finding relevant scientific papers for his/ her research.
Sir, Ask the researchers their involvement with library during their research tenure?
Sir i just want to add something u would have made some one seated in this discussion who have completed their phd from state university specially from Jharkhand and Bihar,than i think it will be more beneficial to the audience,that how is the life of phd scholar from such places
Jharkhand
great people, great sir, PhD karkee postdoc karr ree....
Sir social science ke liye btaiye ki usme phd me kaise le admission
JRF karke
Kya access hota hai equipment pe? 😂 Bohot sari govt universities mein kharab hokar padi hoti aur dusre departments mein experiments ke liye apply karna padta hai. Jahan experiments ke liye waiting period hi bohot dino tak hoti hai.
Nice discussion 👍
dear sir thanks for valuable video. i have query. actually currently i m working as a PhD junior reserach fellow in Gurukula kangri deemed to be university, haridwar since Jan 2021 including course work. Here i m publishing two paper regarding my research work. In short almost 70 % work has been done. now I get opportunity from CSIR-AMPRI for PhD position. I am confused should i choose this opportuniny or not?
Please continue their only mam, where ever u do PhD will be same
Ampri is good.
But it won't be a very big difference
Thanks for ur reply
Atisundar sir
Please include somebody from Europe, USA and Japan too if possible in near future.
I do PhD from BHU and I am suffering. The supervisor has almost no relation related to the scholar. No Guidance. You have to do everything be it right or wrong way!
Bdya bro
Phd is not less than being imprisoned
Very nice information 🙏🙏❤️❤️❤️
IISER VS IIT VS IISc VS NIT VS Cental University VS State University VS Private University, is all the different institutes?
Yes
sir mera project theek nhi hua m.tech ka im 30 with no job if i prepare my subject well can i get into iit in phd
Yes you can.
Thanks a lot for guiding us, sir!
Is CSIR-IIIM Jammu, good?
Good discussion
Bhiyaa kya university mater krti hai ki aapne master's khaa se kiya hai...?? Please reply kya masters central ya state university se hee hona chahiye ??
Ya fir net jrf he Mater krtaa hai.???
Please reply
Kaun kaun se private universities achhi hai phd maths ke liye
Sab achchi hai.
Guide kaise dhundhe , starting mai ache supportive lg skte baad mai chandal nikle tb?
Talk to lab members.. other fellows from the dept.
Very informative
I think research institute is best for phd
Thank you sir 🙏 very nice explanation bt sir I have some doubts plz clear my doubt sir .sir every CSIR lab have same opertunitity for future or not
Yes they do.
msc integrated karne ke baad iit me kya phirse gate dena padega
for me, an India PhD is in the stone age for many universities, for example I did from University of Allahabad, mostly juggad in arts subjects
Thank you for discussing such a diverse topic
Thanks sir
IISER, NISER CISR.. Ye sabhi top research institute hai.. kya yaha se scope sahi hai..
Achcha scope hai
Which Institute is good for phd in history, i am extremely confused... Please provide some guidance 😕
In india main ab PhD ki bhi value nahi rahe after you complete PhD than survive job because mostly university now want experience
Do a good phd and there are many opportunities
Phd in Chemistry from Dibrugarh University or Tripura university. which is better? Waiting for reply