Timestamps: 0:00 Introduction 14:38 Kya Majority Sahih hoti hay? Usay follow karain? 24:20 Sirf Puranay Ulema ko hi Quran pata tha? History/Culture 38:57 Kya Arabic Muqaddas / Special language he? 51:45 Translations mein kya maslay hain 1:01:30 Quran pe aitraz translations ki bunyad pe? 1:02:37 General Q&A - discussion
Salamwalekum Sir jo log urdu or arbi nhi jantey unhone hindi ya English me quran pada translation k sath wo kya karey... translation hai moduudi,ibne kateer,israr ahamed...aap log hindi english me translation karye jisko ek bhot badi majority pad sake?
Thanks Dr Shah. I am only putting forward the Quran. Hopefully it helps others. This is my duty after the help I received from others through my journey.
I just watched your stream today after a year. I call myself a Muslim and a rationalist.I was hearing to Storm Poilet about the literal words regarding punishment in the hereafter.He also raised a very important point about the Quran not a word of God. I to some extent agree with that.Quran says that God is near to our jugular vein.
Assalamu alaikum۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔Almoses I understand that language and dialect are two different things. In Surah Yusuf, verse number two, the Arabic language is being spoken of in which the Qur'an was revealed, while in Surah Ibrahim, verse number four, Allah has said that He sent all the messengers in this dialect so that they could understand the message of Allah, but in later times the Qur'an was translated and interpreted in the Arab's dialect. Due to which the correct meaning of the Qur'an could not reach us. Shahid Jamil (M۔A ٫ B۔ED ) Assistant Teacher India ٫ Kolkata
In fact brain works on electro magnetic waves which is common to human being. Tongue of specific area convert e m w into specific language prevailing there. Therefore Arabic has been chosen for specific area actual language is still e m w.
Yes, yes, I understand. I just want to know the website for this elaborate copy of Quran, where you can get all the aya's using a particular word by a single click. Sorry if my query was not clear!
Assalam alaekum. I am translator and interpreter of Japanese Language age over 60, recently doing translation of a book on Islam published in USA into Japanese Language. I have studied German and French Languages and also studied some chinese reading and writing. I have tried to read Quran translations in these languages and developed very different approach towards religions and belief systems. I strongly believe in the creator of All. I don't want to share my understanding to common people as most of them are not able to think freely. I like your arguments and discussion. I want to share some different ideas but not public. Do you have any private contact or email? Regards
Salamati hu ap pe usatad muhtarm . mujey steaming nahe aate Allah ke leye ye program band na kare. Muje Chand din pahle pata kaga ab log share karing awr hamy hawsala nahe harna chaheye . Quran ke sahe tarjumni k leye
Musa shab a. K. Aap ke baat bhot bhetren hai laken aaj ke muase zindagi m hursuks presan hai lehaza koe aasan se baat bhe btaea k hum zinge kesay guzare 🙏
bhai jaisa ki Dr.iqbal sahb ne 40:18 minut me kha ki Allah ne phle hibru aur sibrani jban me klam kiya ya paigam bheja to hm kaise kh skte hai ki vo hibru ya sibrani jban thi.kya quran ye btata hai ki vo kon si jban thi.
Khuda nay kaha ke har log kay paas rasool gayay. Un sab nay unhi zabanon mein baat ki ho gi. lehaza hebrew or aramic peoples kay paas un kay rasool un hi ki zaban mein baat kartay thay
@@AlMosesPhD bhai lekin Kitab to ek hi jban me rhi hogi bhle hi rasul us kom ki jban me vjaht krta hoga.quran me hai ki Allah ka klam tabdil nhi hota to fir kaise mane ki uski jban tabdil hogi.ha ye bat our hai ki rasul us kom ki jban me vjaht krta hoga.aaj aap hindi ya english me Allah ki aayto ko vjaht krte hai.aap chaina ya aur kisi jban me vjaht nhi krte.lekin Allah ka klam to hindi ya english me nhi hai.hr jmane me rasul us kom ki jban me vjaht krta hai.ye alg bat hai ki us kom ke log apne bde ki bat mane ya us rasul ( massenger) ko jhutla de.aur haq aane ke bad manne se inkar kr de.Allah na to apni aayte tabdil krta hai na hi apna klam tabdil krta hai .
@@irfanahamadfarooqui9450 kya aap kehna chah rahay hain ke kitab Arabic mein hay? Ye baat na Quran say sabit hay na hi logical he kyon ke Arabic aik recent language he
@@AlMosesPhD nhi bhai mai nhi kh rha hu ki quran arabic me hai.blki jo hm ward ya jban quran me dekh rhe hai aur pdte hai vhi suru se hai.koi aur jban ya langvej dusri nhi thi.mai aapse sikhne ki garj se swal krta hu.taki meri glt fahmi dur ho jaye.iske phle bhi aapne meri rahnumai farmai hai .isi ummid se aapse swal krta hu.
@@irfanahamadfarooqui9450 mein aap ki baat nahi samjha tha, lehaza ask kya tha. Meray fahm mein har rasool ko us ki zaban mein risala mila. Un kab ka source al-kitab hay ko kisi human zaban mein nahi
ال موسس ! آپ تحقیق پر یقین رکھتے ہیں تو میرے اس سوال کاجواب ضرور دیں :- شیعہ کے ایک بڑے عالم اللّہ یاری کا یو ٹیوب ویڈیو میں کہنا ہے کہ حضرت علی علیہ السلام کے پاس قرآن کا اصل نسخہ تھا جو موجودہ قرآن جیسا نہ تھا ۔ میں نے یہ بیان محتاط ہو کر لکھا ہے استفراللّہ و اتوب الیہ آپ کی تحقیق اس بارے کیا کہتی ہے ؟ اس سوال کے جواب کا منتظر ہوں ۔
Ek cheez samjh ni aa rhi......ki kya quran yehi kehta hai ki chahe jitna accha kaam krlo ......jitna bhi acchi tarah zindagi basar krlo..etc.etc.....lekin agar Messenger pe imaan ni laye to saza milegi? Koi shaks god pe to believe kr skta hai...lekin ab yeh kehna ki uske ek messenger aur uski baato kaamo pe bhi imaan lao....to uske lie yeh baat ajeeb ho jaegi...aur fir yeh to injustice ho jaega na....Aur الرسول Allah ka sent dispatchment, message, transmittion etc nhi hai? Because of و making الرسول the product of رسل halaki رسل ka means messenger nhi hota...blki....Uploaded; Transmission; Posted, Emission; dispatched ; Broadcasted,transfer, send. ....yeh sab meanings ارسال ki hain....from same root word رسل to kya quran yeh ni kehta ki Obey Allah and his sent dispatchment, message, transmission etc??? Halaki main abhi khud kai ayato containing word الرسول thoda confuse hu...but zyada clear hai...bataie kuch...
خانہ کعبہ کے اندر چند پرانے برتنوں کے علاوہ اور کچھ بھی نہیں ھے مگر اسے ہروقت تالے میں رکھنے کا مقصد میری سمجھ میں نہیں آرھا پلیز صاحبِ بصیرت راہنمائی فرمائیں شکریہ ؟
Problem with representative of Quran is that they are only Theoretical not practical.Non practical representative of Quran have no Courage to follow the Quran Practically...only enjoying not practicing..Where there is a will there is a way.Tell the People the practical aspects of Quran...As Quran is a Practical book for all human....
Janwar es leye kaha ha ka ma ne ap ko shuor deya janwar se agy ka muqam dia mgr ap janwar ke jamwr ha tadabur aqal saour se kam nahe lety Awr emtehan ma nakam hu . yahe baat kahta ha . awr baat es leye aisa ha ka quran in insano ke leye ha . es leye ye zaban estemal ke ha . baat aqal ke ha AGR koi quran samjta ha wahu eaise nahe kah sakty . ye koi dusre makhlooq ke leye nazel nahe kia ha. Awr erteqai amal ap janwar hu insan nahe bany .wahe baat Allah farmata ha
If god exist and he let good people go to jannah irrespective of their religion, then Islam is irrelevant for afterlife, if God sends good people to jahnnam because they believed in some other god then for me its not worth going to jannah..
Good people, regardless of religion, are muslims already. A God that wanted to send these good people to hell becoz they didn't do some rituals isn't the one who sent the Quran
@@philosopherkyng did I ever say trad ritualized version of Islam is the only road to salvation? Did the Quran ever say that? Fair to bring that up to those who believe in that depiction.
Timestamps:
0:00 Introduction
14:38 Kya Majority Sahih hoti hay? Usay follow karain?
24:20 Sirf Puranay Ulema ko hi Quran pata tha? History/Culture
38:57 Kya Arabic Muqaddas / Special language he?
51:45 Translations mein kya maslay hain
1:01:30 Quran pe aitraz translations ki bunyad pe?
1:02:37 General Q&A - discussion
@@Sameer.867 watch this for my detailed answer:
ua-cam.com/video/81M4kngEs0A/v-deo.html
Ma swat Pakistan se hu
Salamwalekum
Sir jo log urdu or arbi nhi jantey unhone hindi ya English me quran pada translation k sath wo kya karey... translation hai moduudi,ibne kateer,israr ahamed...aap log hindi english me translation karye jisko ek bhot badi majority pad sake?
@@abubakar8863 SA, mera translation ka koyi irada nahi hay.
Kabhi Dr sahib online hon to un ko yeh mashwara dijyay ga
Today, great scholar Hafiz atif
Bahut ilmi batein..sach me aisi batein kafi hain islam samjne k liye
Jo sikhna chahay, to batain waqyi buhat simple hain
JazakAllah khair
Sir best informative video for me....
Almoses really love from here. Some times I think you are a great addition to my life, in the sense that you are spreading light profusely
Thanks Dr Shah. I am only putting forward the Quran. Hopefully it helps others. This is my duty after the help I received from others through my journey.
A wonderful session I must say
shukrya. Good luck with the journey. It'll last a lifetime!
Yes, indeed. Thanks. Hoping to join ur stream again in the near future, but with more valid queries.
@@Samir_A inshallah
I just watched your stream today after a year. I call myself a Muslim and a rationalist.I was hearing to Storm Poilet about the literal words regarding punishment in the hereafter.He also raised a very important point about the Quran not a word of God. I to some extent agree with that.Quran says that God is near to our jugular vein.
Aslkm mashallah very nice grammar konse name ki laina plz Jawaab
Valuable as usual.
Shukrya
Assalam o Alaikum Moses
I have gone through this video and really like it
Appreciate if you can add or share link for upcoming stream
Thanks
SA, best is to subscribe so you know whenever we go live next
Assalamu alaikum
I wish I could talk Dr.sahab and AlMoses. I an in canada, serious student of Quran,
Waliakumassalam
Website mention karay, sahi pata nahi chal raha
I wana participate
Assalamu alaikum۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔Almoses
I understand that language and dialect are two different things. In Surah Yusuf, verse number two, the Arabic language is being spoken of in which the Qur'an was revealed, while in Surah Ibrahim, verse number four, Allah has said that He sent all the messengers in this dialect so that they could understand the message of Allah, but in later times the Qur'an was translated and interpreted in the Arab's dialect. Due to which the correct meaning of the Qur'an could not reach us.
Shahid Jamil (M۔A ٫ B۔ED )
Assistant Teacher
India ٫ Kolkata
2:50 minet pr moses bhai ne jo jwab diya chini ldki aur blatkar ki vo behtrin jwab hai.bhai strom pilot ko insaAllah smgh aa gya hoga
inshallah
Al Moses please do a stream on saum.. especially 2:187
Maybe next ramadan.
It's not bhuk pyas ka roza though
Huruf muqtatat, Allah swt ki sift hae, by Dr Gulam ahmad prvez
In fact brain works on electro magnetic waves which is common to human being. Tongue of specific area convert e m w into specific language prevailing there. Therefore Arabic has been chosen for specific area actual language is still e m w.
Could you please let me have the link for the copy of Quran you are using?
It's the same Quran.
I didn't understand your question
Yes, yes, I understand. I just want to know the website for this elaborate copy of Quran, where you can get all the aya's using a particular word by a single click. Sorry if my query was not clear!
@@Maazi12345 tanzil dot net
OK, thanks. I already got it from another podcast/video of yours and your message to someone else, last night!
Assalam alaekum. I am translator and interpreter of Japanese Language age over 60, recently doing translation of a book on Islam published in USA into Japanese Language. I have studied German and French Languages and also studied some chinese reading and writing. I have tried to read Quran translations in these languages and developed very different approach towards religions and belief systems. I strongly believe in the creator of All. I don't want to share my understanding to common people as most of them are not able to think freely. I like your arguments and discussion. I want to share some different ideas but not public. Do you have any private contact or email? Regards
Salam, al.moses.phd@Gmail.com
Salamati hu ap pe usatad muhtarm . mujey steaming nahe aate Allah ke leye ye program band na kare. Muje Chand din pahle pata kaga ab log share karing awr hamy hawsala nahe harna chaheye . Quran ke sahe tarjumni k leye
Shukrya.
Musa shab a. K. Aap ke baat bhot bhetren hai laken aaj ke muase zindagi m hursuks presan hai lehaza koe aasan se baat bhe btaea k hum zinge kesay guzare 🙏
Yah aik buhat acha suggestion hay. Inshallah is pe aik din baat karain gain.
7:147 ka tarjuma kia baney ga
Konsay amaal zaaya hotay?
Please explain..Dr Iqbal and Dr Moses..
Woh amaal jo woh Khuda kay tariqay kay khilaf kartay thay. Woh sab zaaya ho jayain gain
@@AlMosesPhD you mean... rituals? Or bad deeds?
I would appreciate if Dr Iqbal also shares his viewpoint on this
@@sarahriaz2069 bad deeds.
You're welcome to find Dr Iqbal on facebook, or talk with him on the livechats here
Alif Laam Meem: Pain/Heartache... Then we have Dhalika. ..That is. Therefore, THAT is The Book full of Pain/Heartache.
Please write what is this website to search all these different words in the Quran?
tanzil.net is a very good first choice.
Sir
Is there any ayaah in the Qur'an in which it is written that we have given
Injeel in americ language
And Torah in hibru ?
I don't think so
Dr sahab ka facbook link
facebook.com/Fahem-e-Quran-with-Dr-Iqbal-111273166998680/
Please share translation of 4:43 and 5:6
Inshallah, will do a separate video on 5:6
4:43 mein kya aapka koyi khaas question he?
Log sunty ha live nahe aate sir
Ji, kuch atay hain
what's your view on huroofe muqattaat?
I have a few starting positions but nothing major.
One day, I will tackle it inshallah
@@AlMosesPhD could you please do a live stream on the story of prophet loot? Were his people really doing homosexuality according to Quran?
Inshallah.
Food for thought: strange to think they got destroyed for 'homosexuality' but no other nation since then got that punishment, isn't it?
@@AlMosesPhD yes. I want you to clear this story on live stream because it doesn't go with logic.
asslam alikum
Salamun alaykum
bhai jaisa ki Dr.iqbal sahb ne 40:18 minut me kha ki Allah ne phle hibru aur sibrani jban me klam kiya ya paigam bheja to hm kaise kh skte hai ki vo hibru ya sibrani jban thi.kya quran ye btata hai ki vo kon si jban thi.
Khuda nay kaha ke har log kay paas rasool gayay.
Un sab nay unhi zabanon mein baat ki ho gi.
lehaza hebrew or aramic peoples kay paas un kay rasool un hi ki zaban mein baat kartay thay
@@AlMosesPhD bhai lekin Kitab to ek hi jban me rhi hogi bhle hi rasul us kom ki jban me vjaht krta hoga.quran me hai ki Allah ka klam tabdil nhi hota to fir kaise mane ki uski jban tabdil hogi.ha ye bat our hai ki rasul us kom ki jban me vjaht krta hoga.aaj aap hindi ya english me Allah ki aayto ko vjaht krte hai.aap chaina ya aur kisi jban me vjaht nhi krte.lekin Allah ka klam to hindi ya english me nhi hai.hr jmane me rasul us kom ki jban me vjaht krta hai.ye alg bat hai ki us kom ke log apne bde ki bat mane ya us rasul ( massenger) ko jhutla de.aur haq aane ke bad manne se inkar kr de.Allah na to apni aayte tabdil krta hai na hi apna klam tabdil krta hai .
@@irfanahamadfarooqui9450 kya aap kehna chah rahay hain ke kitab Arabic mein hay?
Ye baat na Quran say sabit hay na hi logical he kyon ke Arabic aik recent language he
@@AlMosesPhD nhi bhai mai nhi kh rha hu ki quran arabic me hai.blki jo hm ward ya jban quran me dekh rhe hai aur pdte hai vhi suru se hai.koi aur jban ya langvej dusri nhi thi.mai aapse sikhne ki garj se swal krta hu.taki meri glt fahmi dur ho jaye.iske phle bhi aapne meri rahnumai farmai hai .isi ummid se aapse swal krta hu.
@@irfanahamadfarooqui9450 mein aap ki baat nahi samjha tha, lehaza ask kya tha.
Meray fahm mein har rasool ko us ki zaban mein risala mila. Un kab ka source al-kitab hay ko kisi human zaban mein nahi
ال موسس ! آپ تحقیق پر یقین رکھتے ہیں تو میرے اس سوال کاجواب ضرور دیں :-
شیعہ کے ایک بڑے عالم اللّہ یاری کا یو ٹیوب ویڈیو میں کہنا ہے کہ حضرت علی علیہ السلام کے پاس قرآن کا اصل نسخہ تھا جو موجودہ قرآن جیسا نہ تھا ۔
میں نے یہ بیان محتاط ہو کر لکھا ہے
استفراللّہ و اتوب الیہ
آپ کی تحقیق اس بارے کیا کہتی ہے ؟ اس سوال کے جواب کا منتظر ہوں ۔
Walekum Salam sir
Quran per baat karnay ka matlab in Pakistan k har shakhs muslmaan howa phirta hay... ....
Ek cheez samjh ni aa rhi......ki kya quran yehi kehta hai ki chahe jitna accha kaam krlo ......jitna bhi acchi tarah zindagi basar krlo..etc.etc.....lekin agar Messenger pe imaan ni laye to saza milegi? Koi shaks god pe to believe kr skta hai...lekin ab yeh kehna ki uske ek messenger aur uski baato kaamo pe bhi imaan lao....to uske lie yeh baat ajeeb ho jaegi...aur fir yeh to injustice ho jaega na....Aur الرسول Allah ka sent dispatchment, message, transmittion etc nhi hai? Because of و making الرسول the product of رسل halaki رسل ka means messenger nhi hota...blki....Uploaded; Transmission; Posted, Emission; dispatched ; Broadcasted,transfer, send. ....yeh sab meanings ارسال ki hain....from same root word رسل to kya quran yeh ni kehta ki Obey Allah and his sent dispatchment, message, transmission etc??? Halaki main abhi khud kai ayato containing word الرسول thoda confuse hu...but zyada clear hai...bataie kuch...
Yeh baat kayi dafa ho chuki hay. Channel pe aur vids dekhain
Bhai hum un zubano ko b muqadas samajthey hai aur in kitabo ko b muqadas samajthey hai AP ko kisne kaha k hum unko muqadas nei samajthey
Aap bhalay jis zaban ko muqadas samjhain, sawal hey kay kya Khuda nay usay muqadas kya?
Arabic, bazate khud, muqadas zaban nahi
Salah ka matab ha .ak dusre se aagyey baro . achy kamo ma Jo Allah ke nezdek ha . pasitive amal na ke negative
خانہ کعبہ کے اندر چند پرانے برتنوں کے علاوہ اور کچھ بھی نہیں ھے مگر اسے ہروقت تالے میں رکھنے کا مقصد میری سمجھ میں نہیں آرھا پلیز صاحبِ بصیرت راہنمائی فرمائیں شکریہ ؟
Is ka simple logistics reason hay. Agar khol dya, to hujoom control karna impossible hoga.
مامون نے معتزلہ کو قتل نہیں کیا بلکہ انکی سرپرستی کی
Salam
Please do not use Khoda
Because it is not mentioned in Quran
Salam, by that token brother, let's stop talking in English too.
What is the proof of Quran being given to us about 14 centuries ago??
History. Anthropology.
Even if we could prove Quran though Quran, it'd be useless as a circular argument.
How i can contact to you
Keep an eye out on the next live stream
Ma swat Pakistan we hu
Problem with representative of Quran is that they are only Theoretical not practical.Non practical representative of Quran have no Courage to follow the Quran Practically...only enjoying not practicing..Where there is a will there is a way.Tell the People the practical aspects of Quran...As Quran is a Practical book for all human....
And that's why 'you' should be the practice yourself
Zaban se koi acha ye bora nahe banta es zaban ke koi ahmeit he na rahe amal se bsnta chahe jes koi zabsn hu
ji han, main cheez amal hain
Nono sir Muslim country men qatal karna Aasaan hay ....
Janwar es leye kaha ha ka ma ne ap ko shuor deya janwar se agy ka muqam dia mgr ap janwar ke jamwr ha tadabur aqal saour se kam nahe lety
Awr emtehan ma nakam hu . yahe baat kahta ha . awr baat es leye aisa ha ka quran in insano ke leye ha . es leye ye zaban estemal ke ha . baat aqal ke ha AGR koi quran samjta ha wahu eaise nahe kah sakty . ye koi dusre makhlooq ke leye nazel nahe kia ha. Awr erteqai amal ap janwar hu insan nahe bany .wahe baat Allah farmata ha
Muslim historian writers were wrong at that time and it is not a knowledgeable product only waste of time ....
If god exist and he let good people go to jannah irrespective of their religion, then Islam is irrelevant for afterlife, if God sends good people to jahnnam because they believed in some other god then for me its not worth going to jannah..
Good people, regardless of religion, are muslims already.
A God that wanted to send these good people to hell becoz they didn't do some rituals isn't the one who sent the Quran
@@AlMosesPhD then shouldn't we stop market islam as the only way of salvation?
@@philosopherkyng did I ever say trad ritualized version of Islam is the only road to salvation? Did the Quran ever say that?
Fair to bring that up to those who believe in that depiction.
@@AlMosesPhD Do you mean to say that an Hindu can't go to heaven as per your faith.
@@Sameer.867 See my video on 'kya hindi / chinese' kafir hain
Storm Pilot knows how to deal with these type of Doctors
Who is storm pilot? Was his ling circumcised like shiv linga of gyanvapi?
@Tea or Coffee , but Storm Pilot is most probably Ex-Muslim.
Is it so ?
Knowledgeable person storm pilot .
Very polite .
Contact me i want to join u