LEGO Star Wars CLONE TROOPER & BATTLE DROID Battle Packs Comparison! (2007 vs 2024)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 4 жов 2024
- The LEGO Star Wars 2024 Clone Troopers & Battle Droids Battle Pack is essentially a modern version of the 2007 Battle Packs that started it all so today we compare to find out how far they've come... or fallen?
- - - - - - - - -
Check out my store! -
mandrshop.com/
Join Whatnot & get $15 off your first purchase! (Affiliate) - whatnot.com/in...
BUY LEGO from LEGO (Affiliate) - click.linksyne...
BUY LEGO from AMAZON (Affiliate) - amzn.to/3S0DYyD
Business Inquiries - mandrproductions@algebramedia.com
Fan E-mail - MandRprod34@gmail.com
Best of MandRproductions: • Best of MandRproductions
- - - - - - - - -
#LEGOStarWars #LEGO #StarWars
I STILL dont know how Ryan feels about the new clone trooper helmets. If only he would voice his opinion
It's really getting annoying at this point. Like, we get it, you don't like the holes, but you don't have to bring it up EVERY chance you get.
@@CloneCommanderCrater1102finally a fan like me who doesn’t side with the UA-camr even if they are being petty
@@442nd After hearing him rant on for the second time about helmet holes, I immediately got sick of it. It's not even a divisive issue like he keeps claiming. It's just a few UA-camrs complaining about holes that are a micron or whatever off from where they ideally should be.
Be careful what you wish for 🥴
@@CloneCommanderCrater1102 FR the holes are like not annoying at all, it is so easily overlooked
The 2007 Darth Vader box art might be my favorite of all time.
Super nostalgic
Mine is a P1 Rex from 2011, even though I have no sets with it, because I was 4 years old😢
It's the 2012 Maul for me
much better than what we have now! and don't let me start about the instruction manuals with cheap renders
Yeah! I definately prefer the images of the actual characters on the box at than a render of a lego minifigure
I love the new clones, helmet holes even..pretty much makes every clone so customizable tbh
Yeah, printed kamas are worse, at least clone helmet holes have a good reason for not being there, kamas are just Lego cutting costs and using playability as an excuse
With respects to the classic. Helmet warts aside I definitely prefer the new one. It's just a much more complete army builder
1000% newer is better.. but there is a soft spot to have atleast one of the OG ones being thats what the childhood looked like
I’m sorry but this is 100% an overreact from Ryan. No the helmet holes don’t make them worse than the 2007 figs. He says “eye test” than picks the one with old and outdated printing
agreed.@@StrykeSZN
the newer one is definitely better if you look past nostalgia. the only improvement it really could've used is to add some minifigure accessories like in the 2023 501st battlepack
@@bokatan88 in regards to phase 2 clone sergeants are still plain white clones. Then for higher ranking clone all that would change would be pauldron, kamas, sun visors and/or t visors which for sun visors and t visors aren't that hard to get.
Cutting it a bit close with that daily upload ayy 😂
My thoughts exactly about an hour ago
lmao
@@saber9926you mean “EH”
@@KrazyPugzwhat are you on about
rent is due
nostalgia goggles a little tight here
frrrr
LOL
The helmets... with the holes... is a CLEAR upgrade from the 2007 craptacular helmets.🤣
I’m not sure why he hates them so much lmao
@@coltonfoegen4265 The helmet holes definitely do mess up the look of the helmet considering they could have put them in the designated piece of the helmet that the hole would actually go in like how they did with the p1 and arc trooper helmets
I wonder why considering they were clearly alluding to those original battlepacks they decided not to make a 327th trooper for this one. Would've been the perfect opportunity after over a decade of not making one.
I think it's just because the white clones have been MIA for such a long time and they're supposed to be the most common.
@@rampantrambling Makes sense. No complaint in getting 3 p2 shinies in a cheap set. Fingers crossed they have a plan to eventually release modern 327th. That would be awesome.
I actually thought that was a 212th trooper the entire time
@@zippolighter4903 Oddly enough in the original lego star wars game they did use the 327th as comander cody haha
@@mattheb01 Yeah, that’s why I always thought that was supposed to be another 212th trooper. I think it was the same in TCS too
I love that they both have helmet holes, nostalgia speaks loudly huh?
It would be really great to get another droid carrier like that. Just something small and cool to make battles with.
its wild to me that people consider the 2007 clones better. the whole front of their helmets is a big ugly helmet hole 😂. New ones are miles better
the new helmets are great i can add visors and antennas if i wanted to
Bro complaining about the helmet holes making the helmet inaccurate and ugly then gassing up the ugly and inaccurate 2007 mould is crazy
I am among that generation that cannot stand the older helmet designs. I had like thirty of the phase II old clones and I hated the helmet visor, unprinted legs, and just the general chest print wasn't appealing to me in the slightest,
The new ones have the extra helmet holes...so what? I'll just slap on those plastic visors and chest plates from the clone wars battle pack and call it a day. My fav clones came from 2020 & 2013-2015 anyway.
Because they make the helmets look really fat, and the visors don’t even work properly when them because the phase 2 visor literally stretches it so when you put it on a phase 1 helmet it just flops around
MandR: ‘All Lego SW channels use the same thumbnail style these days.’
Also MandR:
Ngl overall I think the new one is better I mean the clones are more accurate and the droids have better builds and the upgrade they did to the b2 makes a HUGE improvement
First
Third
Fourth
Fifth
Sixth
2007 troopers are definitely not better than 2024, doesn’t have to be better because of nostalgia
Why does everyone care about the helmet holes?? It's such a big fuss over nothing.
Because they make the helmets look like crap: the clones now look special
@@omarbaba9892 Opinion rejected.
@@DashSpiderJumpscares haha care to provide something to say it’s wrong?😂
@@omarbaba9892 They don’t look bad. Enjoy your opinion and I’ll enjoy mine.
@@DashSpiderJumpscares how though, the shape is so different as the top of the helmet is just fat now
i really hope lego starts to make droid based battle packs again
I never liked the OG clone helmets. They might have their own style which is respectable but they don't feel screen accurate at all. The modern clones are nearly perfect, besides the helmet holes. Lego should definitely return to their previous quality of clone helmets but the modern version is still superior to the 2007 imo
I don’t think a separate droid battle pack would sell well nowadays, so having them both combined is superb
I would totally buy it, but, I'm not sure if I alone can make it sell
A lot of people have been asking for one for a while. I think it would sell decently.
@@TheFirstCurse1 it might sell well IF they include a substantial number of droids & include long retired ones such as magna guards or commandos for example
Never heard someone harp on about something so minor in the grand scheme of things
I don’t really care, as long as what he is doing doesn’t ruin the figures or even makes them better
We really need a 2020 style star corps trooper
That thumbnail scared me...
The only thing I have to say about the original battle pack being split is that if it were tried today, it almost certainly would mean that both battle packs would be scaled to match a $20 price point- meaning it would be $40 to have the same amount of figures as the $30 large pack.
Even factoring the nostalgia tax + helmet home tantrum factor, suggesting the old clones are a better design than the new ones is kinda ridiculous 😂😂
Thank you for the Helmets with no holes in the M&R shop. It made the set perfect and I loved the special 2x2 M&R custom tile!
Notice how the original P2 helmet mold looks like the clone trooper helmets from CW 2003. Cool detail!
That's what they are actually
I've already bought and assembled 8 copies of the new 2024 battle pack.
Found one clone trooper misprint too.
Sold the fig for enough money to buy two more battle packs
I definitely prefer price/weight vs. price/piece since many newer sets use more smaller pieces for detail while a lot of older sets used larger pieces but less pieces overall.
Most of the cost comes from the actual labour and listening, for example a 20 dollar set costs less than a dollar for the plastic. While they should make the sets bigger, using bigger pieces actually doesn’t change the price too much
I think perfect decision, if lego wants implement helmet holes for all modern clones is to remove "earpads" and make helmet holes between where "earpads" and helmet holes was. It will solve problem with helmets looking elongated and maybe even printing issue. Sure it may be inaccurate, but I think it won't stand out too much, because lego can't mirror every detail of character on minifigure anyway and will make degree of detailing more consistent among different mf. And it worked for p1, though they don't have such prominent "earpads" no one complained about helmet holes.
The old battle pack got me into Lego and the original clone turbo tank! I remember my god father got me two original clone battle packs when I was 8 or 9.
That’s the thing with modern era battle packs, i just want clones and no named characters or specialist lol. Droids and captains what have you are cool and i think essential but for me personally i just want regular straight up clones.
I was getting worried that you wouldn’t post today
Same
Can’t wait till the new one goes on sale
Macy's had them at 20% off
Can’t wait to finally start building my battle of christophsis moc. That was my favorite scene of all time when I was 14. and now that I’m an adult and I’ve got some money I’m going to take a trip down memory lane🤘
The thumbnail made me think this wasn’t one of your videos
Literally moment got the new one pulled out all the old minifigs and droids those old helmets are still my peak
Im pretty sure those were my first Lego Star Wars sets! The 2007 nostalgia one cant be beat. Thanks for going through these agin!
Great Video thank you
6:38 them clones sitting on the ground 🤣
Can you please make a new review for the 2007 mtt
I remember those days as well! Was willing to order them out of the LEGO magazine, but my parents took me to Walmart and they had them 😁. Awesome day!
Loving these daily uploads,keep up the good work!
That battle droid set was my very first battle pack, and I've always wanted the clone one, but never got it. Since the new battle pack is basically both of those combined, it's going to make my younger self really happy (Plus my old super battle droids either have weak or broken joints).
What a cool comparison, Ryan. These super battlepacks seem to be the way to go with rising inflation. I can’t wait to see where the return of B2’s take us in the future for prequel sets.
Definitely pickin up multiple of these, keep the fire content up man
Another thing is with the 2024 build is that if you get 8 of the sets you can make this beautiful AV7 cannon
Hello Mandr
Love the vid
You really gør me in to lego and i just think your a great and somehow an underrated youtuber
I didn't realize this was one of your vids with that thumbnail 😂
“You get more figures in the old ones”
Me who considers the Tri-Droid a figure:
Good video, deadass thumbnail
I think the only downgrade on the helmets for clones are the holes otherwise they are a vast improvement (still like the tartakovsky style p2 helmets tho)
Do u like legends
@@Sashin-d8t ofc I do, I like both the old EU and new canon, tho I’d need to learn more about the old EU
@@PteranoLiv I think I’ve seen you before
@@Sashin-d8t oh yeah se have met before, we talked about geestly’s and toxic legends fans what a coincidence seeing you here
1:33 lol just a little bit better? this is your brain on nostalgia.
So nostalgic
As much as i love supers, there should be 3 b1s and 2 supers, not the other way around
I agree. That's my biggest gripe with this set. They're doing it because of the new B2 Super Battle Droid mold and because they've been absent in sets for a really long time, but it just feels wrong.
I would agree if we hadn’t been in such a big B2 deficit for so long. Lots of clone sets have come out that have had B1s so I’ve already built up a bit of a collection, this new pack lets me even out a little bit.
bro absolutely despises lego star wars clone trooper helmet holes
I bought all the clone battle packs available right now and i personally love all of it. With this set, i love the clone builds!!
It just seems to be a seesaw with the quality standard of the minifigures. It’s good and bad. I think the main focus for the LEGO group needs to be the molding and graphic design process. Let’s get the clone helmets where they need to be.
I love the ppp vs ppo comparison. Really shines a different light on it. Also the eye test is always the most important imo
When will we get a gungan and wookie battle pack
Гунганов уже был.
As someone who owns the 2007 bp, I also intend to get the 2024 bp when it goes on sale
why are people complaining about the holes it is lego not a hot toys figur it's meant to play with
Ok I’d say the new one wins only by honorary point of “not poor piece quality” because if lego toots that any piece made any year will fit within the building system than we need to hold those sets accountable wherever they are. Another personal note the newer clones are better imo. Im not a helmet hole lover bc I agree with anyone who says lego SHOULD be making better products if their logo is “only the best is good enough” I’m with you all the way, but we have to be fair bc some people wanted to put helmet mods on phase 2 and weren’t able to do it with the first batch we got, which is completely fair. Eventually lego will fix this error I just think it needs a little time to develop, for all we know lego is designing the fix right now and they’re just dumb and haven’t said anything, also yea 212th troopers printing sucks I tried the replacement way and got the same result as everyone else. Keep up the fight tho ryan maybe we’ll get a better arc trooper echo for our fives.
Helmet holes by Lego are not the best, but I love clone army customs plain RP2 clone white helmets that have helmet holes… you can easily replace those helmets with clone army customs which I will be doing
imo they shouldve added a new 327th to the new battle pack, not only would it have made a good reference but theyve made so many legions lately that it would just make sense
Honestly I love and prefer the new one. I have mixed feelings on the 327th clone, on the one hand i wish we had one to build that legion but also without it i can get more regs with less sets
Has there ever been a comparison video before on your channel that has ended in a draw?
Bro really acting like it’s even close get those nostalgia goggles off. Like you acting like the helmet holes make the helmets look worse than those garbage helmets from 2007
Heater Boxabois
31 straight days of uploads. Keep up the good work, and maybe you'll be able to make a video eveyr day this year.
I wish the set was split up so than I could buy more b1 battle droids. In SW the ratio of b1 droids to a clone is 20(up to 50):1 per singular clone in the battlefield. Would love a way to raise that number. Right now the ratio of clone to b1 droid is 4:2 generally speaking. My 120 clones to 60 b1 droids is pretty sad looking when that droid count should be significantly higher. Obviously it would be tough to match the 20 b1 droids per clone. But at least make it reasonable to obtain if someone wants to amass a large b1 droid army. I should be able to place down 20 clones and have them up against 400 droids, that would the correct ratio. But even as a 10x per clone ratio still be pleasing to be able to have 200 b1 droids up against 20 clones. If LEGO is focused on the details, they should know that the ratio of droids to clones should at least be double what’s put in sets now. 4 clones, 8 b1 droids. What do you guy think of the lack of b1 droids being outmatched by the clones?
Damn you were buying Lego sets when I was born 😂
I was 1 years old when the set came out🤣
Absolutely wild that inflation is up by 50% in the last 15 years.
Got to get one of those
I think your videos are making me empty my wallet further and further the more I watch. LOL🤣
Your Honor my 2024 set 75372 clone trooper and battle droid Battle Pack was simply standing on business 👔
For a second I thought I accidentally subscribed to another channel
Saying the new ones helmet isn’t a clear upgrade because of helmet holes over the helmet that looks more like a stormtrooper helmet is wild to me. You have superglued those nostalgia goggles to your face, that old helmet is objectively terrible😂
MandR it’s Junko!! From Cod oh btw nice video!!!
Love the thumbnail ryan nice change up
I was in Hong Kong when these were released and I bought 5 of each for about £6 each. So $7 US.
The 2024 one literally if u get 4x you can make a big octopurra, a spider droid a Stap and a republic swoop bike and all creations would look as if Lego made em so I consider it THE best ever forever battlepack
I feel like with the clone troopers are better in the 2024 set because 1. the helmet holes aren't that bad because now you can add alot of essental detail and 2. I like the authentic faces
There should have been a couple more battle droids
Man has ww2 and Vietnam flashbacks when he sees helmet holes 😂😂😂😂😂
I've had a lot of trouble with regular battle droid clips breaking.
I’m sorry but the old clones do not look like clones. When I first saw them I genuinely thought they were stormtroopers, that helmet is wayy to huge and round
The helmet is probably based off the old 2003 clone wars
I personally prefer 2007, but 2024 definitely has some upgrades
Lesson Learned, let Ryan do LEGO set comparisons
“Peaked a couple of years ago.” Shows a clone that was made literally a decade ago.
2012 called they want there thumbnail back lol
Anyone else think army building just to fill and entire 64x64 plate, is dumb? I don’t under why anyone wants 500 clones or droids, unless you are selling. I always see people flexing these giant armies just on a plate with no MOC
Come on man... your disdain for the helmet holes is very well documented, but the 07 helmets are NOT better than the 24s
Ryan, how are we going to let Lego get away with releasing the same exact captain rex mini figure in the microfighter when they blatantly lied to us saying it’s exclusive in the $650 venator?
What are you going to do? Sue them?
@@Redeemedfatherof2 yes
If you spent $650 for a minifigure you are an idiot.
@@brandonnn9543I’m buying the the set😂
Cry some more.
No helmet holes and a 327th star corps trooper in place of 1 plain trooper would make this the best battle pack of all time
Old is gold new is improved
I’m waiting for the new one to drop in price on sale then ima buy a shit ton
So what Ryan is trying to is that he likes bigger wholes on his clone troopers.
For me, the 2007 battlepacks will always be te superiour!! ❤