Evolution of Combat in Star Wars

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 11 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 134

  • @philjohnson1744
    @philjohnson1744 Місяць тому +118

    It is disturbing how much faith I have in these vids

    • @MBSill
      @MBSill 26 днів тому +11

      I love 'em! It's like an actual historical documentary, the way it should be!!

  • @SomeDudeOnYouTube_1
    @SomeDudeOnYouTube_1 Місяць тому +42

    Long form star wars lore videos is where tf it's at right now good on both ends lots of content and a longer average watch time for Allen albeit I'm sure this is so much more work even a 5 minute video can be a lot of work thank you Allen the absolute best sw UA-camr right now

    • @JediSentinal
      @JediSentinal 28 днів тому +1

      So its not just solething *i* have noticed...
      Seems more star wars lore channels are dropping hour plus comps these days, and frankly im here for it. Allows me to rewatch old videos i forgot existed while keeping a single topic going. Its nice to download for work!

  • @user-xr3ij4os6w
    @user-xr3ij4os6w Місяць тому +88

    Alan will always rule star wars

    • @Wackaz
      @Wackaz 26 днів тому

      Based 🫡👑🙏🗿

  • @JollyRogerAerospace
    @JollyRogerAerospace Місяць тому +15

    OMG. 😂 Seeing Alan and all his different styles over the years. Then remembering I was here through it all and have kids his age. I'm old. 😢🤣

    • @jeshonloonskin4176
      @jeshonloonskin4176 19 днів тому +1

      Hey, there’s no talk of how old one gets, remember what the great Emgo316 says “You don’t stop playing cause you grow old, you grow old because you stop playing, be geek, be proud!!”

  • @OrionInSpace
    @OrionInSpace Місяць тому +195

    Seriously why more Star Wars creators don’t do stuff like this is insane when you think about how much this franchise has given us to where you can make videos like this… I love it GT! For the 501st!🫡

    • @Dionysius8421
      @Dionysius8421 Місяць тому +9

      But if you can make another three hour video about Kreia's non-philosophy, why would you make actually good, interesting content

    • @OrionInSpace
      @OrionInSpace Місяць тому +2

      @@Dionysius8421 this is a reference to something I don’t understand lol

    • @runakovacs4759
      @runakovacs4759 Місяць тому +4

      @@Dionysius8421 "Kreia, the obvious villain, said welfare and mutual cooperation is bad. Ayn Rand was therefore right."

    • @olencone4005
      @olencone4005 Місяць тому +2

      @@OrionInSpace Kreia was Revan's master, and later fell into the Dark Side to become Darth Traya. But rather than focusing her hatred on the Jedi, she hated the Force itself because she had visions of all the wars that would later be waged because of it.

    • @OrionInSpace
      @OrionInSpace Місяць тому +6

      @@olencone4005 OK I’m not sure exactly how that connects to what I said

  • @isaackim7675
    @isaackim7675 Місяць тому +78

    Speaking of Star Destroyers, you should do a video on the evolution of Star Destroyers

    • @dogloversrule8476
      @dogloversrule8476 Місяць тому +7

      I think he did a while ago

    • @isaackim7675
      @isaackim7675 Місяць тому +7

      @@dogloversrule8476 But as another hour long video

    • @JediSentinal
      @JediSentinal 28 днів тому +2

      ​@@isaackim7675not sure he has enough videos specifically on ISDs to make another comp like this.

  • @Chinny208
    @Chinny208 29 днів тому +17

    I appreciate the translations to metric, making understanding walker speeds more accessible to all.

    • @Zev-fr4zx
      @Zev-fr4zx 15 днів тому +1

      Especially the fact that every time, it's something else!

  • @jaytrashwade1-1
    @jaytrashwade1-1 Місяць тому +8

    I'm starting to realize Star Wars lore is a more tame Warhammer 40k universe with significantly more balanced power scaling.... The Death Star is a major threat in Star Wars due to it's shear firepower but in Warhammer 40k the destruction of the Death Star is just another Tuesday

  • @Wackaz
    @Wackaz 26 днів тому +3

    I love the way the armour for the troopers simplifies as the Republic evolves and eventually transitions into the Empire. Sanitary, clean, sterile, just as a puritan dictatorship would desire.

  • @simon2493
    @simon2493 Місяць тому +21

    Tbh while ground warfare would be still useful when you want to secure some info/place before surrendering planet destroyers it, threat of orbital bombardment should be enough to incur surrender. Even in SW assuming that you can't overpower planetary shield defences, you should be able to force surrender by just besieging siad planet. How many of planets in SW are completely self sufficient and have economy independent enough so that it will work just fine without trade with rest of galaxy? I don't think many do.

    • @ALLMINDmercenarysupportsystem
      @ALLMINDmercenarysupportsystem Місяць тому +2

      That only works if you don't want anything on the planet and don't care about the political ramifications of bombarding or starving out a whole world. Otherwise, the people on the planet can and likely will just call your bluff, and you'll have to engage in planetside combat anyway.

    • @papapalps2415
      @papapalps2415 Місяць тому +1

      ​@@ALLMINDmercenarysupportsystemYou only need to do it a few times on a few worlds, and broadcast those examples hard enough, to make this moot and void.

    • @ALLMINDmercenarysupportsystem
      @ALLMINDmercenarysupportsystem Місяць тому +1

      @papapalps2415 That still means you have to do it. If you care enough about a world to bother attacking it, you probably want something on it. Even if you don't care about a couple planets or the political blowback of doing it to those, the people on planets you actually want would know you want something there and would still call your bluff.

    • @simon2493
      @simon2493 Місяць тому +1

      @@ALLMINDmercenarysupportsystem On the other hand you can assume not many world would be still willing to fight after you've bombarded all of thier military establishments. Is there even any example irl when after defenses have been defeated the city still though until everyone one was dead?
      On the side point, despite SW portraying ground combat as a rather clean affair, Ukraine and Gaza if nothing else, shows how destructive even modern ground combat is.

    • @ALLMINDmercenarysupportsystem
      @ALLMINDmercenarysupportsystem Місяць тому +1

      @simon2493 Absolutely on the side point.
      Problem with your main point is that the main weapons which could be used for orbital bombardment are turbolasers, with the power of nuclear weapons. You're not making precision strikes with that, and civilian casualties are going to be massive most of the time. There's also decent chances that military forces aren't going to be at their installations, so a military insurgency could continue after and do major damage.

  • @sundragon7703
    @sundragon7703 Місяць тому +25

    Even though droids are commonplace, guided munitions were either non-existent or simple or wtf. On the subject of wtf, a buzzdroid is not the way to go for a single use submunition. Wanna put the fear in the Republic, instead of a buzzdroid, substitute with submunitions fanning out across the hull of a ship as they seek out sensitive systems, then detonating. Why blowup an engine of a cruiser when a swarm of scampering limpet mines can remove the entire aft section.

    • @papapalps2415
      @papapalps2415 Місяць тому +5

      - 'b-b-but, guided munitions don't exist, thooo?????'
      - literally 2 of the main 6/9 movies have entire several minute long chase sequences that involve missiles displaying hilariously obscene tracking capabilites
      Five hundred trillion keks.

    • @kalebh4763
      @kalebh4763 Місяць тому +1

      Bro, I'm in a lot of therapy in my life, but you need some help

    • @JediSentinal
      @JediSentinal 28 днів тому +1

      ​@@papapalps2415bruh i love the agressive sentience of the discord missiles tridroids fire at obi wan and anakin in revenge of the sith. The moves those missiles pulled were FAR above any simple programming. 😂

    • @JediSentinal
      @JediSentinal 28 днів тому

      ​@@kalebh4763help? Nah he needs to explore thoughts like that more! Its a good idea!

  • @BigStereoVR
    @BigStereoVR Місяць тому +17

    One day: I want to turn on Andor, watch Luthen Rael in his back room hunched over a holocast of Alan. It's a regular Generation Tech show, but they write it in as the voice of rebellion show.

  • @damianelswick8828
    @damianelswick8828 10 днів тому +1

    One reason I prefer GT to other SW UA-camrs, he presents the information without his personal biases/opinions affecting his content or style of delivery. So many others let their dislike/hatred towards Disney/sequels/etc affect the tone/delivery/perspective/coverage. Alan just presents the info as presented and in a unique semi-in universe manner. Love your work, keep up the excellent work!

  • @user-xr3ij4os6w
    @user-xr3ij4os6w Місяць тому +13

    I 🧡💛 Generation Tech

  • @WhoisPersona
    @WhoisPersona Місяць тому +17

    Nowadays I feel like a lot of the battles that take place occur between an underdog in addition to the big empire with lots of disposable income. I really want to see another Clone Wars situation where you have to massive powers go up against one another in vast theatres of war that have been carefully crafted to take even the smallest detail into consideration.

    • @ALLMINDmercenarysupportsystem
      @ALLMINDmercenarysupportsystem Місяць тому +4

      It's called Star Wars, not Star Anti-Insurgencies, so I agree.

    • @__xander_
      @__xander_ Місяць тому +2

      check the New Republic vs Imperial Remnant conflict(s) from legends, you basically have the rising New republic and the remnants of the Empire trying to restore it or at least survive in this war of dominion over the galaxy.
      With that we don't even consider the Yuuzhan Vong invasion and all the other wars of that vast period.
      And yes, in some parts we can count that as 2.0 Clone Wars

    • @dumbguy1007
      @dumbguy1007 Місяць тому +1

      I at least want to see 2 or more planet wide powers going up against each other. A relatively smaller war than the galactic conflicts but one similar to many wars between small nations we see in our world. Maybe the newly established Mandalorians and their allies will want to start showing their strength.

    • @JediSentinal
      @JediSentinal 28 днів тому

      Agreed! I hope the next main series of movies doesnt just continue the skywalker story 10 years in the future, but jumps 100+ years in the future. Get new stories, factions, characters in! Dont be forced into the set timeline, your only gonna make things worse akin to the sequels.
      Current tales become legends within the universe, and tech doesnt need to progress alot. In star wars tech advances in bursts, there wasnt much advancement over the latter 1000 years of the republic and then the hyperspace wars hit and shit started advancing like crazy up through the clone wars, tapering off with the first order.

  • @johntoms4166
    @johntoms4166 Місяць тому +3

    Stumbled on your channel a while ago while watching angry people review Star Wars. I’ve been hooked on it since. Only Starwars channel I watch now. Actually entertaining like a back story Starwars show. I don’t know how much is actually drawn from lore (I recognize a lot) and how much is made up for entertainment value but I don’t even care if it is made up. The best!

    • @mowermen1762
      @mowermen1762 3 дні тому

      As far as I know he doesn’t make anything up at all. Most of the info he gives you can find on Wookiepedia

  • @Psub950
    @Psub950 Місяць тому +13

    Please make a video on 200 First Order Stormtroopers vs 200 Clone Troopers

    • @dib_human6151
      @dib_human6151 Місяць тому +5

      That would be cool, tho im sure there would be sooooooo many comments trashing on the sequels

    • @liltaco3952
      @liltaco3952 Місяць тому +4

      Honestly, the Clone Troopers would win but with heavy casualties. The Clones have genetic advantages and better camaraderie, but the FO Stormtroopers have better weapons and armor. So the clones would win but with like 50 or less survivors.

    • @dib_human6151
      @dib_human6151 Місяць тому +2

      @@liltaco3952 the FO troops also get some very hardcore training since childhood, which can get them toe to toe with CTs imo
      I think if this combat ever actually happened, it would be realistic for either side to win

    • @Psub950
      @Psub950 Місяць тому +3

      @@dib_human6151And since Fo troops age normally they have more training than the Clones as well

  • @Lord-Phoenix
    @Lord-Phoenix Місяць тому +3

    That video was just beyond amazing

  • @tyletwoodworth3145
    @tyletwoodworth3145 Місяць тому +3

    haha I like the math on the conversions

  • @OliGo06
    @OliGo06 Місяць тому +2

    another hour and a half of great entertainment

  • @donaldsmith8648
    @donaldsmith8648 Місяць тому +3

    A live stream now that's badass.. and I'm generation tech 😅

  • @JoeIPA
    @JoeIPA 2 дні тому

    Seeing these compilation videos is crazy, Allen you look so young in some of these.

  • @ShannonBradley-bi6dp
    @ShannonBradley-bi6dp 9 днів тому

    Thanks for time and effort going into this content. It's always amazing

  • @chrisreilly1290
    @chrisreilly1290 Місяць тому +3

    14:59 not so infinite now is it 😏

  • @Obsidian-Aurora
    @Obsidian-Aurora Місяць тому +5

    Who else finds it interesting that all these armors look like Mandalorian armor probably some kind of culture thing across the Star Wars Galaxy

    • @gabrielhenson5751
      @gabrielhenson5751 Місяць тому +1

      The Mandalorian's culture revolved pretty much solely around combat and their armor, so anytime a faction wanted to make good armor they would generally consult a Mandalorian on how to design it. Or try to imitate Mandalorian armor.

  • @NoFreeNapkinz614
    @NoFreeNapkinz614 Місяць тому +1

    8:26 here’s a photo of Darth Bane *clears throat* I mean Bruce Willis.

  • @RobKni76
    @RobKni76 Місяць тому +3

    Me, a Runescape player, seeing "evolution of combat"
    *Fortunate Son starts playing in background*

  • @jiffypoo5029
    @jiffypoo5029 Місяць тому +1

    It makes sense the Clone Wars era used Old Republic armor, ship and weapon designs. No one was designing new military equipment for 1000 years. The 3000 year Old Republic was pretty much perfected military designs, any improvements would be minor increments.

  • @jonathanpruett7831
    @jonathanpruett7831 Місяць тому +2

    Bro imma use this and race the time on my order tomorrow 😂 thanks Allen and team 🎉🎉

  • @MBSill
    @MBSill Місяць тому

    What about a deep-dive into speeder bikes? There are so many different types & sizes!

  • @smartass0124
    @smartass0124 Місяць тому +6

    Every planet in starwars is habitable. A none inhabitad moon would be better place for the second death star shield generator

  • @PhuVet
    @PhuVet Місяць тому

    A version of the jet pack has been used by US and Royal SBS/SAS troops. They also use a fan powered glider parachute and flying squirrel suit.

  • @MattnessLP
    @MattnessLP 12 днів тому

    Both Walker sections were missing the AT-AP, the three-legged walker that looked like someone cannibalized the front half of an AT-TE

  • @statickaeder29
    @statickaeder29 Місяць тому +2

    So what about the gun that Din Jarin carried, that required what looked to be large ammunition that was carried on his belt and bandolier? this same weapon had an electric discharge as well, that caused the Krayt dragon to spit him out. It did not survive the destruction of the Razor Crest, though... I like Din Jarin's armor.
    - The problem with learning to ride a machine after learning to ride a living mount is that the machine doesn't have eyes, doesn't have any reason to desire to protect itself and thus not fall down or run into walls, and you can't guide it with anything other than the specific control surfaces.. I learned to ride a horse before I learned to ride a bike, and have been constantly disappointed by bicycles.

  • @SasoriZert
    @SasoriZert Місяць тому +2

    I'm fucking dead 😂 wtf that last line I laughed so hard I cried and I don't know why I found that so funny.... God bless America and this channel please never change

  • @thekaxmax
    @thekaxmax 17 днів тому

    6 story high troop transport makes perfect sense if you want a terror weapon. It's for scaring people.

  • @MsSlythers
    @MsSlythers Місяць тому

    As an American, I appreciate the pickup truck metric

  • @nathanlowry3764
    @nathanlowry3764 Місяць тому

    Love the voice over work, Dr. Andrew Mark Henry.

  • @MrSHADOWANGEL999
    @MrSHADOWANGEL999 Місяць тому +1

    Glorious stuff

  • @smileyr
    @smileyr 21 день тому

    If we are talking about realism I kinda understand why stormtrooper miss so much despite being the special forces. It’s because they are wearing full face helmets. Even in modern day combat ballistic masks or full face helmets are rarely ever used. They are heavy, hard to breath and low visibility. Most people today prefer high cut helmets for it being slim and more visibility and breathability. So having that knowledge it makes sense why stormtroopers miss so much

  • @motherteresa8418
    @motherteresa8418 Місяць тому +2

    Why not remote control fighter planes in Star wars

  • @jamesharrison5851
    @jamesharrison5851 21 день тому

    Not sure if I missed it but I don't think you mentioned that the AT AT was vacuum sealed, would that mean that when the Gozanti-class cruiser was out of atmosphere the AT AT crew would have to travel in in the Gozanti? Then deploy to the walker when in atmosphere.

  • @pyeitme508
    @pyeitme508 Місяць тому +2

    WOW!

  • @claymclaren5788
    @claymclaren5788 15 днів тому

    Kinda channeling Needleman and Smitty in parts of this video. Definitely not the mellow vanilla that I have come to expect and more of a...stressed mint, like the speeches I did in school.

  • @WilliamBricks
    @WilliamBricks Місяць тому

    Just want to say, I love that thumbnail

  • @Zenithx622
    @Zenithx622 Місяць тому

    @generation tech IN teh comic sereis tales of teh jedi, the beast wars of onderron teh republic troops used Huge bulky jet packs too before even teh mandolorians

  • @historicflame972
    @historicflame972 Місяць тому

    38:25 Just so you know, that's not Demagol's usual outfit, that's Rohlan Dyre's whom he stole it from so he could briefly impersonate him, Demagol's is more black and yellow

  • @SenseiLlama
    @SenseiLlama 6 днів тому

    If only disney put half as much effort into starwars as these videos.

  • @cattothefuture
    @cattothefuture Місяць тому

    The thumbnail makes these troopers look like a creed.

  • @JMPT
    @JMPT Місяць тому

    Extra Nice

  • @vanillamilk7575
    @vanillamilk7575 Місяць тому

    YOUR THE BEST!!!

  • @TheDomis4
    @TheDomis4 Місяць тому

    when lego star wars rebuild the galaxy trailer analysis?

  • @LaKrinn666
    @LaKrinn666 Місяць тому

    Lmao 7000 kg/minute ima use that from now on!!!

  • @LilStink-zv6un
    @LilStink-zv6un Місяць тому

    Bro this video is hella Skibidi

  • @wigligigly3375
    @wigligigly3375 Місяць тому +7

    How is this channel still going on multiple uploads a week? surely the star wars lore bin must be pretty empty by now.

    • @highlordlaughterofcanada8685
      @highlordlaughterofcanada8685 Місяць тому +1

      There's lots of lore to comb through, it's just that most Star Wars channels don't put in the effort Alan does to find it.

    • @historicflame972
      @historicflame972 Місяць тому +1

      I'm pretty sure this is a compilation

    • @butcherpete2286
      @butcherpete2286 Місяць тому

      To be fair this is just a compilation of like 6 vids they've already made.

  • @ZorroSFM
    @ZorroSFM Місяць тому

    I'm still not used to this tool that lets creators use multiple thumbnails for the same video to see which one gets more clicks.

  • @MithrandilPlays
    @MithrandilPlays Місяць тому

    Maybe this is obvious but what is the explosion clip at 1:03:25 from?

  • @jamesosmond-wright6999
    @jamesosmond-wright6999 26 днів тому

    In short bolts of plasma

  • @dustinburkhart8526
    @dustinburkhart8526 День тому

    I'm glad you didn't go all acolyte stupid like a lot of channels.
    How anyone can act like that's anything besides a political reach around is freaking beyond me.
    Cool video as always tech sir.

  • @AC20sAkimbo
    @AC20sAkimbo Місяць тому

    the could of easily fitted another eight troops into the neck of the gorilla walker.

  • @Hello-bi1pm
    @Hello-bi1pm Місяць тому +4

    Hello, Alan, why UA-cam deletrs my comment
    EDIT: I hope this is not deleted.

    • @Hello-bi1pm
      @Hello-bi1pm Місяць тому +1

      Open Wookieepedia article on Duor (not a typo) 🎉😢😂😮 This a secret, please don't terminate my comment.

  • @jholla4751
    @jholla4751 Місяць тому

    People will still pay 25$ for a number 3

  • @motherteresa8418
    @motherteresa8418 Місяць тому

    Habitable planets in Star wars are a dim a dozen

  • @gehtoodachoppa8603
    @gehtoodachoppa8603 29 днів тому

    6:00

  • @DarthVages
    @DarthVages Місяць тому

    👍

  • @KDMSHOWCASE
    @KDMSHOWCASE Місяць тому

    😂why was that premier music so hype

  • @Operator_sadness
    @Operator_sadness 13 днів тому

    It’s ARF not A.R.F. Say it like a dog would ARF ARF

  • @Hello-bi1pm
    @Hello-bi1pm Місяць тому +3

    Delphinoids at UA-cam are trying to erase my comment.

  • @Snipe4261
    @Snipe4261 Місяць тому

    Does anyone else loathe the term "slash and run" as much as I do?

  • @scottlenjenkins410
    @scottlenjenkins410 29 днів тому

    Idiotic, let's destroy coruscant and the core worlds. That was a dumb story idea shouldn't have been put forth let alone the story they actually picked. Horrible addition to the star wars saga. Shouldn't even exist. Let's destroy the core worlds and take away the whole political aspect of star wars. What was Disney doing? Purposely sabotaging everything George Lucas created? Shame on them J.J. Rian and the rest. I could do better way better. Pay me millions and I'll come up with the best story star wars ever had. They look like amateurs to me and so many others. Disney star wars sequels need to be erased immediately.

  • @TheLynxians
    @TheLynxians Місяць тому

    I love star wars deeply yet part of me is ruined seeing how the last two movies lack enough effort to maie something new. Andor and Ahsoka are good also but are missing something its just not how it is like the original and prequels were or other series. Maybe in time well see it return but im unsure

  • @Gaverny
    @Gaverny 19 днів тому

    Gen Tech. You're a fuckin beast 💪🏻!!!!! 🔥