Twin Turbo vs Single Turbo SKYLINE GT-R - Which is Better? MYTHBUSTED

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1 тис.

  • @mightycarmods
    @mightycarmods 9 років тому +1188

    But the real question - Will it fit my Honda?

    • @XxTheBombheadxX
      @XxTheBombheadxX 9 років тому +27

      Mighty Car Mods Your Honda? You've never had a Honda? We've told you to stay away from that bog Moog you electric space wizard. :P

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому +105

      Mighty Car Mods What's a Honda?

    • @trollguy8508
      @trollguy8508 9 років тому +4

      Mighty Car Mods in my Honda Fit?

    • @Sim2Real.
      @Sim2Real. 9 років тому +6

      ***** Wait... WHAT Honda? Moog stop smoking weed, it was just a bad nightmare!

    • @koburacape4222
      @koburacape4222 9 років тому +2

      Mighty Car Mods It's a Subaru bolt-on. You've obviously got the wrong car.

  • @wolfy9005
    @wolfy9005 8 років тому +232

    Reasons for illegal mods:
    Easier to see/fix leaks, officer

    • @Tuvzii
      @Tuvzii 7 років тому +14

      Reasons you still get a ticket:
      It's illegal.

    • @dimmacommunication
      @dimmacommunication 7 років тому

      Tuvzii You still can do mods,here you can't do mods at all.

    • @Aseutester
      @Aseutester 6 років тому

      Andrea Where are you approximately ?

    • @Billy_The_Dog
      @Billy_The_Dog 6 років тому +5

      Come to NZ. As long as mod is done by a professional (and it's not outright dangerous), you can basically do anything you want.

    • @ellisjackson3355
      @ellisjackson3355 5 років тому

      @@Billy_The_Dog I like that

  • @nomellocreampig
    @nomellocreampig 9 років тому +123

    In Australia they get "GDR's".

  • @speedacademy
    @speedacademy 9 років тому +32

    Great video Andrew! The in-depth coverage and your know how on the subject really make this production a stand out.

  • @rekareaper
    @rekareaper 8 років тому +100

    So what I learned is that a bigger modern turbo is better than an outdated twin turbo setup... You had to test for that? Why not try comparing it to twin gtx2860s? That would make more sense to me.

    • @DodgyBrothersEngineering
      @DodgyBrothersEngineering 7 років тому +58

      Not only are they comparing old vs new technology, but they are wrapping the pipes and turbo to benefit the single, along with fixing a blown head gasket. And if you look at the graph lower down where you really need low end power for daily driving the twins out performed the single, but no mention of that. Seems they had a predetermined outcome in mind.

    • @x808drifter
      @x808drifter 6 років тому +7

      Nail on head. Test was a joke.

    • @that_random_beaner5673
      @that_random_beaner5673 6 років тому +5

      Or GT2530s

  • @punishyoma2032
    @punishyoma2032 8 років тому +95

    A big factor in this vid is that you are using modern tech turbo, but a big issue you didn't talk about is internal waste gates are shite and upset exhaust gas flow out compared to external gates. Also the other issue is the fact you used a lovely aftermarket twin pulse exhaust manifold compared to crap standard one. I would like to see a modern set up of modern twins (top mounts, external gates) etc. then test again.

    • @demarcodraper4266
      @demarcodraper4266 5 років тому +9

      This has been done to death a properly sized single will always be more efficient than twins.

    • @BLAZINGINGPHOENIX
      @BLAZINGINGPHOENIX 5 років тому +3

      Electronic external waste gates have now been released so yer 3 years later and internal wastegate are defiantly not worth using if you can afford it

    • @BigUriel
      @BigUriel 4 роки тому +8

      @@demarcodraper4266 Right OEMs just make cars with twin turbo setups because they like spending more money on inferior stuff.
      What's been done to death is comparing apples to oranges, like two small old inefficient turbos to one large modern high performance one. Get two modern medium sized high performance turbos and try that again, see what happens then.

    • @Zeiss120
      @Zeiss120 4 роки тому +1

      @@demarcodraper4266 False. Actually I wouldn't know with newer modern cars. However the reason to stay twins was for throttle modulation and the fact that you wouldn't fall of the cliff on a twin turbo set up (not twin Sequential set up) vs a single.

    • @rond3238
      @rond3238 Рік тому

      @@Zeiss120 Draper is right. Newer cars use twin turbo setups strictly for packaging reasons. Single turbos are always better, everything else being equal.

  • @Toyota4Life
    @Toyota4Life 9 років тому +75

    Im not a GTR guy but this video was BADASS and so is that GTR.

    • @nickamarit
      @nickamarit 9 років тому +1

      +Toyota4Life Yup. I'm sure all this twin-to-single technique is adaptable to the non-VVTi JZ family as well ;)

    • @ryanrohauer5940
      @ryanrohauer5940 8 років тому +3

      +Nick Amarit im not an r35 guy maby on a goof day i can enjoy a 34 but the best are the 33s and 32s there just oozing with cool

    • @tucker_shredds921
      @tucker_shredds921 6 років тому

      @@ryanrohauer5940 I feel the same

  • @ttr685
    @ttr685 9 років тому +9

    Hands down this is The most educational, no fucking around automotive channel ever!
    You shoot car building then you shoot car racing from car building! There's nothing more you can ask. great video @Motive DVD
    Highly appreciate your time and effort.

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому

      Thanks! We take pride in making sure our information is accurate and we modify our cars to go faster so we can help other people.

  • @hellcat1988
    @hellcat1988 9 років тому +49

    That car's B.O.V. sounds EXACTLY like a girl I used to know when she sneezed.

  • @Tonyc_1987
    @Tonyc_1987 9 років тому +14

    One of the best RB26 modification videos i have seen ever! Very good job!!!! Great Video!

  • @figifister
    @figifister 8 років тому +12

    thanks for the comparison. I think most people just plop on a huge turbo and then regret it later when they actually want to use it in the real world. your test shows that if your do your homework and think it through you can have a better overall car for cheaper, and with reduced complexity.

  • @kop4321
    @kop4321 9 років тому +9

    Even if they were comparable in performance, the single would win out on reliability and simplicity. If you run a car hard, shit breaks. Having your shit take longer to break and be easier to fix is a huge plus.

  • @geoffscott3428
    @geoffscott3428 9 років тому +3

    holy crap, this changed my mind about going to a single. so glad you included the quarter at the end of the video, was worried you were going to leave us hanging

  • @PinkuStyle
    @PinkuStyle 9 років тому +8

    Maintaining the system is the biggest factor that I run single. Good video!

  • @oratiolibre1673
    @oratiolibre1673 8 років тому +3

    The big difference I see is the time between exhaust pulses. With a twin setup, only half of the cylinders feed the turbo, so the turbo slows down between pulses. If the other turbo is at a higher pressure, this pressure further decelerates the turbo. A single turbo doesn't have another turbo fighting it, and provides more consistent pressure with less lag because the time between pulses is shorter.

  • @2secondslater
    @2secondslater 5 років тому

    FYI, heatwrap has a double bonus for production of power, hot gas flows faster and smoother and increases turbine speed, heat wrap keeps that heat in. MTU (Motoren- und Turbinen-Union) were one of the first to use this principle when they used Inconel exhaust diverters in their high speed diesel engines. Had the pleasure of working for them for a number of years on engines from 1 cylinder and 500cc NA engines to 20 cylinder common rail vee engines with 8 litres per cylinder and compound twin sequential turbo systems.

  • @RealRandyButternubs
    @RealRandyButternubs 9 років тому +37

    but what would happen if you also used modern turbos in a twin setup? you cant really compare new technology to old technology like that when you create more than one variable.

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому +11

      This is true
      But we wanted to compare t to the most common turbo choise on the market, the -dash series GT2860s
      There is a GTX low mount but it is very big.
      What other current technology bolt on low mounts are there? True bolt on?

    • @misterlith
      @misterlith 9 років тому +1

      ***** Fortunately in this case the GTX of the same size is no better spooling and they didn't push it to it's limits, so really it could have been a GT3582R which is the same generation as the GT2860Rs and the spool would have been about the same and the power difference would have been big as opposed to huge :)

    • @TheMegajr
      @TheMegajr 9 років тому +1

      ***** Borg Warner turbos for exemple

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому +7

      ***** There are GTX low mounts but aren't exactly bolt on and are quite large. Designed for power rather than response. Hardly anyone has used them so didn't seem like great comparison for that reason. The only car we've seen use them was impressive power wise, but response didn't really improve over normal GT2860s

    • @nogeswed
      @nogeswed 6 років тому

      i will soon find out, i fitted 2 borg warner efr 6258 on my mitsubishi 3000/stealth

  • @scottvanderheide
    @scottvanderheide 9 років тому +56

    Andrew...Why aren't you a host on Top Gear?!?

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому +23

      Ha ha. Im not grumpy enough for UK one and I talk too fast for American TV! But thanks

    • @kayle7155
      @kayle7155 9 років тому

      ***** I missed what the guy said how come you got kicked from drags? I'm not familiar with them from NZ

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому +6

      Taketora Satou When you run under 10.99 here you have to have a roll cage, racing license and some other safety equipment. You can go back and they'll boot you again for the day but eventually you get permanently banned. Usually when your speed goes over 140mph.

    • @bestofthebest3821
      @bestofthebest3821 4 роки тому

      @@MotiveVideo werent u on another youtube channel? i cant find those old videos about wastegates and turbos...what was that channel name??

  • @RIPSNZ
    @RIPSNZ 9 років тому +73

    Great job Andrew, Now here's a challenge for you, do a back to back with nothing changed except going from a RB26 to a RB30 and once and for all shut up the RB26 fan boys who think an "all else being equal" 26 will respond better and rev quicker on the road/track than a RB30.

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому +33

      If i can get a good RB30 at a good price I just might ;)
      Will push standard engine to destruction then build but keep same support gear.

    • @ToprankImporters
      @ToprankImporters 9 років тому +3

      ***** Nitrous next.

    • @dohc1974
      @dohc1974 9 років тому +4

      RIPSNZ Would love to see this.

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому +10

      ***** We're listening.......

    • @radium69
      @radium69 9 років тому +1

      RIPSNZ And use GTS-4 Diff's :D

  • @ThaiNguyen-gs3uc
    @ThaiNguyen-gs3uc 9 років тому +1

    nice andrew,seems super responsive on the strip. literally no lag at all.

  • @R34Sumo
    @R34Sumo 9 років тому +32

    Nice vid Andrew, Probably made a few people cry with this one lol. My only gripe would be that as you mentioned with having the single the cops won't even bother about using lube any more haha.

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому +5

      CannonShane Some people have gotten upset, yes.

    • @pwoodson21
      @pwoodson21 9 років тому +5

      ***** i was a HUGE fan of keeping twins, but this video literally changed my mind. Its nice to see an actual side by side comparison, providing some scientific reasoning to things ;)

  • @HassanKhan-fw8il
    @HassanKhan-fw8il 8 років тому +1

    Good video guys. This video was spot on as I never knew the difference between a single and a twin turbo set up on a GTR.

  • @MotiveVideo
    @MotiveVideo  9 років тому +24

    Our RB26 Twins vs Single Turbo Mythbusted caused and ended some arguments. Some of the arguments were down right silly while some valid questions were raised, so we put together this blog post of Frequently Asked Questions and Statements to help settle some more arguments and answer some more questions.
    motivedvd.com/motive/2015/07/31/rb26-twins-vs-single-mythbusted-frequently-asked-questions-and-statements/

    • @alycestapleton
      @alycestapleton 9 років тому +1

      Great video twin are good too , but you did not really got into aftermarket twin setups or custom setup there around ??? Why not there is a differences between bolt on twins and aftermarket etc twin setups b6t I guess its up to your own taste .and before anyone , keyboard , trolls etc start bashing me on this im a mechanic by trade and work on many gtr's etc so I know a fair bit

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому +1

      Gaz Girl Your question is answered in the video, but Go to the link and read the FAQs: motivedvd.com/motive/2015/07/31/rb26-twins-vs-single-mythbusted-frequently-asked-questions-and-statements/

    • @alycestapleton
      @alycestapleton 9 років тому +1

      ***** cheers I hope one day to be in your dvd im building a e30 with s52 m3 engine turbo , I hope to see m8re euro cars in your drag battle I know there are a couple of tough euros out there

    • @AB-ys1di
      @AB-ys1di 9 років тому +2

      wouldn't this have been a better comparison with after market twin manifolds, elbows, and dumps and a couple of new garret gtx28 twins? instead of the 20 year old gt2860s?

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому

      Adam Benderman no. please re watch video and understand why

  • @tristancauvin
    @tristancauvin 9 років тому +5

    Sweet slow-mo launches! You can really see the ATTESA at work...

  • @divizionx
    @divizionx 9 років тому +46

    mighty car mods royal nasho 21:56

  • @bluesrike
    @bluesrike Рік тому +1

    I'd like to see an updated version of this test with newer turbos. How about a pair of EFR 6258s vs a single EFR 8374?

  • @Brock_Landers
    @Brock_Landers 9 років тому +16

    I'm so jealous that Aussies get Skylines and the states we're were lucky to get a 240SX with a KA24DE truck motor. Sure, we can import the RB25DET or 26DETT and the SR20DET but you're going to pay out the ass for a good one even with a 5 speed. I have always been crazy about Skylines. You can see them in California or Canada but here in the US you're going to pay close to US $80,000 for a clean R33 or R34 and you can get an R35 for that. Anyway, awesome power gains and this is probably the 20th time that I've watched this video. Great job Andrew!

    • @beyondthelol
      @beyondthelol 9 років тому +2

      +Robert Keeton r34 skylines are worth megabucks the world over, even here in nz

    • @ericwhittington656
      @ericwhittington656 9 років тому +1

      +Robert Keeton Over here in Japan R32 and r33 sell for nearly 10-12k. But to import it anywhere is what kills budgets.

    • @TopherIsDaMan
      @TopherIsDaMan 9 років тому +1

      +Robert Keeton r32 gars are pretty cheap here in the states since they're legal

    • @thespartenkid
      @thespartenkid 8 років тому +1

      +Robert Keeton where you not informed that they are now old enough to import to the US? xP
      I'm gonna be keeping my 31 thats for sure.

    • @Brock_Landers
      @Brock_Landers 8 років тому

      I want one so bad! I would LOVE to have an R33 GTR with an RB26DETT. R33 is one of my favorite body styles. Idk what it is about them, they just do it for me.

  • @PapotsGarage
    @PapotsGarage 9 років тому +2

    Absolutely amazing footage and work, congratulations guy, that was cool to watch. Thank you.

  • @JobeMinacum
    @JobeMinacum 9 років тому +5

    Wait a minute wait a minute hold on... That's the guy from MCM that drifted the hell out of that S13 they built!

  • @novprezime8640
    @novprezime8640 8 років тому +1

    You should have thrown in turbo shuffle and instalation of a balance pipe in between the headers to add to the headaches....single for the win twins to the bin

  • @GTRBaconR34
    @GTRBaconR34 9 років тому +10

    Love the video! Thanks for putting in the time to do the job right. Now I have to think about replacing my GT2860r-5s on my RB26! Bastard!

    • @OddlyTugs
      @OddlyTugs 9 років тому

      +GTRBacon You running a single turbo now?

    • @GTRBaconR34
      @GTRBaconR34 9 років тому +1

      Caelum Hagen No

  • @loganbentley9627
    @loganbentley9627 9 років тому +1

    This video is killer, Keep up the good work. Looking forward to the next motive garage Gtr video. Lots of usable info I can apply to the rb20

  • @timruddell125
    @timruddell125 9 років тому +3

    Awesome comparison and solid solid arguments. Watch the pro-TT peeps try to poke holes in this.

  • @RoboTekno
    @RoboTekno 9 років тому +2

    Mighty Car Mods brought me here and I subscribed. Awesome videos!

  • @stevenjohnson8340
    @stevenjohnson8340 9 років тому +14

    I believe this is a very well done video, however there is one thing that IN MY OPINION was completely ignored.
    You compare the turbochargers based upon flow numbers... but you're completely ignoring the compressor maps themselves. The turbochargers are pushing 24psi? Assuming a 14.7psi Atmospheric, that's a 2.63 Pressure Ratio.
    At that pressure ratio, you're completely off the compressor map on the GT28's, while you're right there smack in the middle of the efficiency of the GTX3582R.
    As you guys know.. it's not so much the quantity of air but the quality of air that's introduced into the motor.
    Although not perfect, if the twins would of been GTX2867R's (much more expensive, I know, plus you'd have to use a smaller compressor housing) then they would of been much closer in comparison for compressor efficiency numbers (77-78%).
    Like I said.. I think this is an awesome video that obviously took a lot of time and money, but in my opinion, I believe that you skipped off on a very important variable.

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому +5

      Steven Johnson we wanted to compare the most popular options used by GT-R owners. Low mount dash series GT28s and medium frame single turbo.
      Low mount GTXs aren't exactly bolt on ( although some companies can make them bolt on) and are very uncommon in Australia. IN fact, only a couple of cars have been built with them. They are also quite large, so the power might match our single, but from what we've seen, they are less responsive than the twins we had simply due to their size.
      There are problem 1000 GT-Rs with "dash series' low mounts for every GT-R with GTX low mounts. Simply comparing the most commonly used options on the market. Also, we already had the low mounts on the car.

  • @rickmillerjr77
    @rickmillerjr77 9 років тому

    Thanks to Mighty Car Mods for pointing me to this video. I was actually considering this debate!

  • @twentysheds___5967
    @twentysheds___5967 9 років тому +4

    Cheers for the video, however I'm still not sold sorry. Every time you said how responsive it was you were 4000rpm minimum. I'll stick to 2530's for now.

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому +1

      +twentysheds ___ Stock RB26s are dead below 4000rpm anyway, let along ones with lager turbos. Plus, look at the dyne graph down low. There is no instance, revs, driving situation where the twins work better.

  • @BlueonGoldZ
    @BlueonGoldZ 9 років тому

    When APS was still doing business in the US, they had two guys in the Las Vegas, NV area with 350Zs. One had the twin turbo set-up and the other had the single and in every quarter mile race they did at the drag way, the single always won and I assume they were both using turbos that were up-to-date to each other.

  • @ItsCardo1987
    @ItsCardo1987 9 років тому +9

    This video will forever have me conflicted on which route to take, single or twin. Being that I fall into the category of bone stock base makes it a tougher choice. I want to go single as seeing it perform 1st hand and here shows its power and potential. But the stock looking engine bay, as stupid as it sounds is a high want as well. The precision turbo 6266 is looking like the go though! :) Great videos, keep them coming.

    • @JoeIsCrazyWillman
      @JoeIsCrazyWillman 8 років тому +1

      ItsCardo1987 Stock I might go small twins if you have an I6 or V6 for more low end quicker spool, unless you can do as they did and get a twin scroll manifold and turbo, which they showed worked better bc it works with your exhaust pulses to drive the turbo evenly (Google twin scroll turbo. nice read, awesome & very useful product). If you got a 4 banger, definitely single. Not enough oomph to drive 2 turbos good enough in a stock 4 banger.

    • @ItsCardo1987
      @ItsCardo1987 7 років тому +6

      Man... reading this post now.. I was an idiot of even considering keeping my stock size twins.. been on my single setup for almost a year now.. I WOULD NEVER EEEEVVVER GO BACK to twins.

    • @lightmoe2480
      @lightmoe2480 7 років тому

      Cardo_GTR twin

    • @rotor13
      @rotor13 6 років тому

      The cost is the big factor in Twin vs single. You can spend more than a grand more on a twin setup. Also complexity is an issue. More pipes and need to make more space with a twin setup.
      However what puzzles me about the video is would the response factor be more of a result of the transmissions gear ratios? Traditionally a twin setup is more responsive because you can use two small turbos that can match a larger single when comparing the surface area of the inlet housing.
      I've had a MKIV supra with HKS 2835 twin kit and it was quite responsive at 750hp. Much more responsive than the ancient Greddy T88H it previously had. I sold my twin kit and the new owner used two custom EFR 58mm turbos with a larger hot side and on his Supra he managed to lay 890hp at 35psi. Comparing to how my original 2835 turbos, it's much more responsive and makes way more power. I've since put a GT42R and the car ended up making just shy of 1100hp but I since sold the car.

    • @timothyadonis4970
      @timothyadonis4970 6 років тому

      Cardo_GTR rrdr4rrde3

  • @thatsmybit
    @thatsmybit 9 років тому

    mighty car mods brought me here. Great work man !! awesome video

  • @terra2805
    @terra2805 8 років тому +16

    @10:55 The guy speaking says "longetivity"
    Longevity is the word I believe he was looking for. lol.

    • @natandaimzb7129
      @natandaimzb7129 6 років тому +1

      I was looking for your comment. Noticed that also. OCD bretherin.

    • @alj2264
      @alj2264 5 років тому +3

      No he's correct longetivity is an old rare form of longevity long-life grammarist.com/usage/longetivity-longevity/

    • @racketman2u
      @racketman2u 5 років тому

      enough with all this negavity.

  • @vevohoeyo
    @vevohoeyo 9 років тому

    just gota say Andrew.. this is a seriously good and informative video u guys don't fuc around aye s8 to the point!! that car is.. mental!

  • @X3.X3
    @X3.X3 9 років тому +4

    i'm thinking about swapping out my twins for a single turbo on my e92 335xi (N54)....i saw a video of an N54 making around 900whp on stock internals!!! fu*kin crazy!

  • @Pepe46873
    @Pepe46873 8 років тому

    Not what the video is about but I was blown away going to a modern gt30 on my rb20, really seemed like down low lag was not different but pulled way harder and top end held high boost to redline. Next project car will be an r32-r34 gtr so great video, I swore twins would have had some advantage. Got an blown 6.1 Challenger at 497whp as well but am an RB guy at heart, nothing beats the feelin of an RB comming onto boost. NOTHING

  • @6miz22miz
    @6miz22miz 9 років тому +5

    Can you guys do a a modern twin turbo set ups and compare it to the single you are running right now ?

    • @Bostonbird733
      @Bostonbird733 9 років тому

      6miz22miz this. this needs to be done.

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому +4

      6miz22miz It's simply a budget and time issue. We would love to do all the comparisons possible but at the end of the day, someone has to pay for it.

    • @6miz22miz
      @6miz22miz 9 років тому

      ***** i understand would be nice if you could tho

  • @micahstrachan162
    @micahstrachan162 9 років тому +1

    15:57 That's Old Pacific Highway up by Gosford! Amazing driving road

  • @zacdonoghue4728
    @zacdonoghue4728 8 років тому +9

    so what is better twin or single?

  • @rapidfiremuzik_official
    @rapidfiremuzik_official 9 років тому +1

    besides the AMS r35 and RIPS 240z - this has got to be one of the coolest Nissans ive seen thus far!

  • @donaldmokgale3123
    @donaldmokgale3123 8 років тому +3

    incredibly informative!!! 400+wkw on stock internals is that right???? tell the truth man! What fuel are you running in it?

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  8 років тому +3

      Actually, it makes 500KW on stock bottom end now. have to watch the latest video on the car :)

    • @donaldmokgale3123
      @donaldmokgale3123 8 років тому

      that is absolutely incredible!!!! INSANE even!!! i will certainly watch out for it. I have always read that the RB pistons and bottom end can't handle much in stock form compared to its rival the 2jz this is why i am shocked at your figures

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  8 років тому +1

      there is quite a few stock bottom end RB26s in Oz pushing big power

    • @donaldmokgale3123
      @donaldmokgale3123 8 років тому +1

      we learn everyday! But what fuel are they running? 98? I am saving up for a 32 myself hence i am learning as much as i can about the car, its capabilities etc etc

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  8 років тому +1

      if you want to make big power on stock bottom end you don't use 98. In, fact any big powered car you don't use 98. Once you go E85 you never go back. Simply no comparison on a turbo car.

  • @ToprankImporters
    @ToprankImporters 9 років тому +1

    138, she picked up some power. Just need to get a real 60 foot to get a proper number out of it. Even though I know the singles are more efficient, I have run a ton of different setups on RB's. I still like a nice twin setup. Do you remember the silver R32 that I ran with the 2.8, GT-RS, and Getrag? That was a fun car.

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому +1

      importavehicle.com i remember. Getrag is the bomb! Planning on borrowing some drag radials soon....

  • @MotiveVideo
    @MotiveVideo  9 років тому +3

    A little more proof for everyone: ua-cam.com/video/35UeUhGGy00/v-deo.html&ab_channel=MotiveDVD

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому

      +TeensierPython - we did show that. Also see it drive normally in some other videos on our channel

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому

      +Sean Price if twin charging was worth the effort, a lot more people would do it

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому +1

      +Sean Price modern turbos are good enough that the weight, complexity and cost of twin charging doesn't make sense most of the time

    • @Big_Serb
      @Big_Serb 8 років тому

      +Sean Price VW TFSI engines are twin charged from the factory. It is worth it on 4 cylinder engines since they miss the smooth torque a 6 ( or more ) cylinder has.

  • @corbingreiner9879
    @corbingreiner9879 9 років тому

    I'm jealous of the AWD . My FWD Saab900 has wicked torch steer when high boost kicks on. I can't get her to hookup with more then 350hp.That IL6 has little to no lag. My IL4 with a big custom Garret has an embarrassing two second lag, The top end makes up for it. The mid track boost gets her in the 10's in the quarter mile.

  • @gnkVLCT
    @gnkVLCT 9 років тому +3

    fucking awesome video.....................and I usually HATE nissans....and love the peelout at the end.

  • @sevanablahad3236
    @sevanablahad3236 8 років тому

    at 4:30, why does the dyno sheet say 'Shoot_8". isnt that used for NA 8 cylinders?

  • @DaScorpi0n
    @DaScorpi0n 9 років тому +3

    Obi-Nissan Kenobi!!!

  • @arthurkocini689
    @arthurkocini689 6 років тому

    Extreemly Informative video Andrew. Really appreciate the time and detail you have put in to this video

  • @abec666
    @abec666 7 років тому +6

    Potato comparison for so many reasons ... Title should be called stock twin vs *twin scroll* GTX35. Its scary how many people spread false information online.
    For the love of god you probably out of map choke lined the twins on 2.6 PR.

    • @ngt84
      @ngt84 6 років тому

      Its a single turbo. Get over it.

    • @Noooo23523
      @Noooo23523 5 років тому

      @@ngt84 twin scroll is a new thing meaning its basicaly a turbo working as two

  • @joenavarro3461
    @joenavarro3461 7 років тому

    This video was very fun to watch!! Awesome job gentlemen!

  • @CompareParts
    @CompareParts 9 років тому

    Great video, I've been using a single T51 Kai for years, huge power on boost! Single 1 Twins 0

  • @Erelyes
    @Erelyes 8 років тому

    I had a mate that had an R33 25t with a GT35 (old tech). Fitting a 6boost manifold made a MASSIVE difference to the car. I would attribute a lot (but not all) of the gains you've seen to that.

  • @WhiteCharisma
    @WhiteCharisma 9 років тому +1

    Very informative, thanks! It's also the same story with Single turbo Rotaries! At first, I wondered why RX-7 drivers swapped their twins to a Single because I thought it would be more laggy and slower, but the overall increase in reliability and less complications with the old system prove to make it a more reliable car. Just a shame Rotary is a bit finicky but I still plan on owning one some day along with the R32 GTR once the V-Spec hits US shores legally. Always wanted a White one :)

  • @emanuelpizarro11
    @emanuelpizarro11 9 років тому +2

    Great video like always! Keep it up guys

  • @brandonmartin1985
    @brandonmartin1985 9 років тому

    So i haven't delved into the comments completely so dont flame me if this was brought up, but this left out one HUGE thing for a weekend warrior GTR owner like myself... the cost. I am afflicted by this same decision right now but in truth for 400whp on an otherwise stock car, the cost has a lot to do with it. I imagine just that manifold, wastegate, and turbo setup alone cost you more than the twins. Add in all the fab work, extra tuning gear (going to MAP), and the other small things to complete the single swap, what did the cost comparison look like? Awesome video and thank you for keeping an r32 instead of moving to the r34 like most everyone else. True Godzilla FTW!!!

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому

      Brandon Martin
      You would be surprised how expensive that it isn't.
      If your GT-R already has dump pipes and exhaust, then yes, switching to twins is cheapest. However if you start with a dead stock car, the price is lucky to be $1000USD different.
      For example.
      Dump pipes and front pipes on twins cost more than dump pipe on single
      Twin filters and intake adaptors cost more on twins than on single
      By the time you port match stock manifolds, the 6Boost is only about $1000USD more.
      Labour to re-fit twins isn't really any more than doing a single installation.
      the twins themselves, obviously there is two of them, aren;t much cheaper than the single.
      If you have to replace the lines on your twins set up ( often have to as factory breaks when removing) then installing lines on single doesn't cost more.
      You need to tune the car either way, and to make the most of either se-tup you need injectors, fuel system etc.
      So really, cost isn't much different when you have same support gear added to a stock car.
      Also, we showed price as a pro for twins and a con for single in the video, so we did address that issue.
      Glad you liked the video

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому

      Brandon Martin Our RB26 Twins vs Single Turbo Mythbusted caused and ended some arguments. Some of the arguments were down right silly while some valid questions were raised, so we put together this blog post of Frequently Asked Questions and Statements to help settle some more arguments and answer some more questions.
      motivedvd.com/motive/2015/07/31/rb26-twins-vs-single-mythbusted-frequently-asked-questions-and-statements/

  • @jacktumbleweed
    @jacktumbleweed 9 років тому

    Awesome video. Kept me entertained right to the end.

  • @Datsun510zen
    @Datsun510zen 5 років тому

    My flagrant use of hindsight not withstanding and the full capitulation that there's no argument against the simplicity of a single top mount, I still have room for protest. Comparing a (2015) modern GT35 twin scroll setup to antiquated internal wastegate T28s is not even close to an apples to apples match up.
    in 2018 we built an RB26 with stock crank, forged rods and pistons, and full Tomei valve train for my brother's R32. We also used the stock intake and bottom mount GTX2867Rs to preserve the illusion its stock "ish" enough. Tuning was done on a Link G4 and those little T28s seriously shocked the hell out of us. It's making 520kw running e85, and as you can imagine the bottom end is WAY more stout than any GT35 configuration. Not even a GTX3576r can match their bottom end performance, and although you might make that kind of top end power by jumping to a T4 1.1 A/R frame, you'd completely piss away your bottom end to do it.
    Fact is I have no idea how they do it, but with a small Gen II Billet GTX2867R your SR20 can make *400kw* and scroll up like a T25. That's not just a notch up for the legendary disco potato mates, its kicking it up into a whole new WTF is going on level. Pretty sure there's some kind of voodoo magic alien reverse engineering shit going on at the Garrett lab. I haven't been playing with boost all that long but it seems only a short time ago we were patting ourselves on the back for squeezing a respectable 350kw out of an SR with a T3 GT3071r... Hell, I remember thinking crazy lag was a necessary evil to get all the GT30's power to come on all of a sudden @ 4500rpm... ah the good old days. Now I ask ya boys, what's the world coming to if a little new fangled turbo can make 400kw? I don't know either, but I'm looking forward to finding out. ;o)

  • @Garage12
    @Garage12 9 років тому

    Great video Andrew, very impressive figures on the gtx, I would imagine the outcome would be the same on a big single vs big top mount twins as alot of the big power rb's in Japan still seem to run top mount twins

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому +2

      Garage12 the argument gets a bit different on big twins and really big singles as its more about airflow and hp than response. But to us, the packaging problems of twins makes a single a much better option. If you think low mount twins are tight, high mounts are even worse as you have to fit two giant dump pipes and intakes etc

  • @jarrodpicard-shaw509
    @jarrodpicard-shaw509 9 років тому

    Love it Andrew! This argument should well and truly be put to bed now!

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому

      It is for us, but we've seen some odd arguments!

  • @pkuudsk9927
    @pkuudsk9927 9 років тому +1

    Very good comparison for the average joe who is considering a up grade/replacement of worn turbos. Did I miss the cost comparssion for the complete swap? I think it is important. not just the turbo cost man hours and new bits would be nice to know.
    Anyway I have subed and enjoy the format as always the more information is always better so keep it comming.

  • @michaelwyz2306
    @michaelwyz2306 8 років тому +1

    All this applies also to 2jz and n54. Thanks

  • @bespincustompropsbombarta8300
    @bespincustompropsbombarta8300 6 років тому +1

    Now put on high mount twins with a custom manifold and see how it fares for a true single vs twin test.
    Stock manifolds are always going to lose against new tech turbo's. Put on an old tech turbo for a fairer comparison with the equivalent amount of air displacement as the twins you removed.

  • @Dollsofgod
    @Dollsofgod 4 роки тому

    19:50 The single is better in every scenario? What about driving a single turbo vs twins and one of your turbos blow up?

  • @ak540i2
    @ak540i2 9 років тому

    Learning about turbos here.
    When tuning the turbo in the video they mention they 'brought back the turbo so it won't come on stronger in the low RPM'. How is that possible? How can you make a turbo come on stronger or weaker? The engine is always producing the same volume of exhaust gas at a given RPM and the turbo's A/R does not change. What allows for more/less boost at the same RPM?
    Also, why are these straight six's so awesome? How can the RB and 2JZ handle so much boost on stock internals and block?

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому

      The Haltech ECU controls the boost. Electronic boost controller. We control the boost curve so it doesn't make as much boost as it comes on as what it does higher in the rev range

    • @ak540i2
      @ak540i2 9 років тому

      What is the mechanism that controls the boost?

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому

      +AK540i an electronic boost control solenoid. The most common modification for any turbo car.
      Some are stand alone while some, like this one, are controlled by the ECu allowing us different boost levels via switch, different boost in different gears, control boost curve and also pull out boost if car gets hot or limp mode.

  • @rx323bug
    @rx323bug 6 років тому

    why was the power coming on in the dyno runs n pulses? you could here it surging up through the revs, and you could see it on the print out arcing up in curved steps. just something that jumped out at me.

  • @sniperlif3
    @sniperlif3 8 років тому

    What would you expect? 3 cylinders trying to spin a turbo x2 vs 6 cylinders trying to spin 1 turbo. Honestly im surprised there was not more power down low, suppose that has to do with choosing the largest turbo housing as mentioned in the video. You get more gases pushing one turbo to provide higher spool as well as higher top end spool compared to 2 turbos.

    • @ryanrohauer5940
      @ryanrohauer5940 8 років тому

      ya i was thinking same thing espicially it being a twinscroll shound have heafty tq but ya your right large exhaust housing

    • @scootbmx01
      @scootbmx01 8 років тому

      do you know how small the twins are each? not really a fair comparison

    • @sniperlif3
      @sniperlif3 8 років тому +1

      scootbmx01
      Because twins are required to be smaller as half of the cylinders are turning them. Even if you did them sequentially you would need them to be smaller to get enough exhaust force to push both at a reasonable rpm.

  • @jordanrooker6865
    @jordanrooker6865 9 років тому +1

    I'm just confused (never been to the strip), why did you get booted?

  • @adrianmedina7269
    @adrianmedina7269 5 років тому

    I know in the video you guys used a 1.01 housing, my question is would a 1.06 housing be a crazy difference or would there be more lag? Or would there be no difference? Awesome video guys, now I’m gonna go for a set up like this.

  • @justa_dude
    @justa_dude 9 років тому +2

    Thank you motive for such a great comparison. Hands down one of the best car channels on youtube.

  • @thynysan
    @thynysan 5 років тому

    So a single turbo kit, metal headgasket, apr headstuds, injectors, catback exhaust, Dow pipe and ecu should be good to make 420-440 whp reliably and safely as a DD or am I still missing a few things?

  • @JimmyLLL
    @JimmyLLL 7 років тому

    Another great video. No idea how you only have 63k subscribers

  • @UOYtaLOL
    @UOYtaLOL 6 років тому

    27 to 27 is not apples to apples. However, undoubtedly you have increased air density due better thermal characteristics.

  • @grosseader
    @grosseader 8 років тому

    3:40 i stopped that. Man wtf means that single turbo con is "lose stock appearance" ? WTF, twins, are hidden in the trunk and you do,not lose stock appearance !?

  • @maman89
    @maman89 9 років тому +1

    You guys know your stuff! Great video.

  • @Goodezilla
    @Goodezilla 9 років тому +2

    What blow off valve are you running? Where did you mount your MAP sensor?

    • @DriftNick
      @DriftNick 9 років тому

      +GoodeZilla doesn't sound like he is running a blow of valve.

    • @Goodezilla
      @Goodezilla 9 років тому

      DriftNick Won't that ruin the turbo eventually from compressor surge?

    • @DriftNick
      @DriftNick 9 років тому

      GoodeZilla No, it's fairly common for people in Australia not to run them.

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому +2

      +GoodeZilla Factory blow off valves but just not returned anymore

  • @rockflight67
    @rockflight67 5 років тому

    Can you test the fj20 sr20 blocks,. Density, oil gallerries amount and size etc.

  • @dougbawden4321
    @dougbawden4321 8 років тому

    What is causing the wave like graph line? it even sounded strange on the dyno?

  • @theserbian1
    @theserbian1 7 років тому

    What clutch is in there, and whats happend to the standard 5 speed gearbox..?...broken..?..to much power for standard 5 speed..?

  • @pimvermerris6278
    @pimvermerris6278 9 років тому

    Wow that thing sounds mean!
    Maybe a noob question (sorry, Subaru guy here)..if a single is that much better on all fronts including maintenance, does anybody know why Nissan has kept the low mount twin set up until the R34?

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому

      Pim Vermerris Packaging, cost and because it used same engine from R32-R34.
      R35 is V6, so packaging reasons by having turbos on each side under the banks

  • @Chitownloverboy
    @Chitownloverboy 5 років тому

    Excellent video! I am doing a build on my BMW N54 335xi and was searching videos about the GTX3582R Gen 2 and found myself here. My current build is going to use that turbo with T04 1.06 a/r and is going from small twins. I have been hearing people say that singles suck to drive and turbo lag is bad with a single. My tuner reassured me that single is the way to go. Sometimes you feel like people are just trying to sell you but after this video I cant wait to have my car running soon. That RB26 just rips! Also I like that beat at 21:00 minutes anyone know what it is?

  • @zman982009
    @zman982009 9 років тому

    Ok so.. I have an issue with something here. I was told that the ARP Head studs are made of a hardened metal that does not flex or stretch am i correct? was told by my instructor today in class. So therefore the ARP headstuds would not be doing their complete job of letting the head slightly move around on the block deck while under Horsepower load in turn possibly miss aligning your camshaft line bore, also possibly destroying your headgasket.

  • @klubcj
    @klubcj 9 років тому

    My 32GTS T with a ""RB 26 40Tz"" 315 kW at the wheels at 14 PSI

  • @IliescuBenyamin
    @IliescuBenyamin 9 років тому +1

    What is the mat on the dash for ?
    By the way, he looks so surprised to have power at 4k :D
    I tought that turbos are made to make at least 80% power at 3k.(cars from factory)

  • @MrIamChosen
    @MrIamChosen 9 років тому

    Would of liked you guys to explain the importance of getting the car retuned when work has been done on the engine to those people out there that don't know this.

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому

      MrIamChosen Not necessarily re-truned, but at least checked. Our tuner told us after removing the head and putting it back together it was running just fine. Obviously some tweaking was needed, but we always check our cars on the dyne after any changes/upgrades etc

  • @Dacommenta
    @Dacommenta 6 років тому

    Pretty impressive build, I thought the response was gonna be terrible in comparison.

  • @JDM033files
    @JDM033files 9 років тому +1

    Top flick! Made my morning coffee far more informative - my love the Mine's 34 set up one day hangs by a thread! I wonder if they could be convinced! Japan investigation tour? Count me in.

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому +2

      JDM033files The Mines R34 is an amazing car, but was built nearly 10 years a go. If you watch our "6-speed install" video on our channel it actually explains the "secret" to the Mins car :) Many minds have been blown by it.

    • @JDM033files
      @JDM033files 9 років тому

      ***** Done - morning video selected! Thanks bloke!

  • @TheMoodyedge
    @TheMoodyedge 7 років тому

    why you get kicked off the strip????? my r33 gtr has stock low mounts....a 3" decatted exhaust and link g4+ and its laggy between gears....mainly 3rd and up...very annoying...only running 0.9 bar with 366 bhp at fly but Id have expected it not to feel as laggy..only driven the car a total of 2 weeks ater a rebuild so much to learn and never had a turbo car b4. The boost is controlled by closed loop on the link and Ive heard it had issues so maybe have to swap to open loop electronic boost controller....A new uprated fuel pump and up it to 1 bar :? Im guessing though. So far my gtr experience has been a let down

  • @mubarakahmad8936
    @mubarakahmad8936 9 років тому

    how much the response was improved in jet 200 when you guys switched from the tdo6 to the gtx 357576 turbo

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому

      We didnt just change turbos, we changed manifold design to 6Boost and smaller intercooler and piping as well, but the difference was huge!full boost more then 1000rpm earlier and drivability and transient response was massively improved. Chalk and cheese comparing the setups.

  • @liqidvenom
    @liqidvenom 4 роки тому

    I assume they went custom downpipe? I dont think they mentioned it.

  • @patrickharris2270
    @patrickharris2270 9 років тому +1

    Another great video! Love the R32 GTR series you have done.
    Makes me feel better about my 2.75L stroker RB26 and BW 8374 EFR R32 project. Can you please tell me what boost and fuel you were on during your ride through the twisty's (low and high?). Looked like quite the difference between the two. Just trying to get an idea of my car's estimated performance. THANKS!

    • @MotiveVideo
      @MotiveVideo  9 років тому

      Patrick Harris All on E70. Until we turned up boost it was on 14psi and 330kW @ wheels. Its quite lazy on that too as the boot controller is essentially off, so wastage creeps open

  • @stevoeight
    @stevoeight 6 років тому

    Does this manifold allow you to retain the factory ac compressor?

  • @rmcsilva
    @rmcsilva 9 років тому

    Is it me or you didn't resurfaced the head when changing the gasket and studs?
    Shouldn't it always have a light skim to ensure it's totally flat and to guarantee a tight seal?