RANKING all the characters of Disventure Camp
Вставка
- Опубліковано 31 лип 2024
- Buy me a coffee!
www.buymeacoffee.com/sillybil...
The final Disventure Camp 2 video and of course it is a final update to the character ranking! Now that the entire season is done, who was the absolute best character? And who was better than Riya? Well, probably most of them, but find out here!
If you're happy and you know it hit subscribe * click click *( / @sillybillyducky
The minecraft channel:
@sillybillymc
I do not own any of the music in this video (except for the intro jingle), nor do I claim ownership over any of the Total Drama or Disventure camp source material. Many thanks go out to my girlfriend for designing the Silly Billy Ducky's!
Check out Disventure camp for yourself:
/ oddnationcartoons - Фільми й анімація
I noticed that the disventure camp fandom is devided into 2 sides. On 1 side there are the Riya stans. On the other there is The Netherlands.
Very common Dutch W
the ones with sense who clearly see aiden is a bad character and the ones that love him
@@olaf-chan-728 lol I used to like Aiden.I started not liking him after episode 7 or 8.
@-JakeAdventureCamp♡- also im a ✨Riya stan✨ UwU
Im dutch
I think Aidan described Riya well: she's an opportunist. Throughout her acting career she has been in multiple non credited roles. The only time she felt she had someone in the game, they left her. I believe that after noticing every single way every other contestant played dirty, she just got desperate.
Yeah. Fully agree that Riya's arc made sense, and for that reason... But I also agree with Billy that it was... Paced poorly.
Riya become the worst person along yul in all stars
Here’s my thoughts on Riya:
I feel like with Riya the writers wanted to have their cake and eat it with her. They seemed to want Riya to be this strong sassy mean iconic queen who will play dirty to win, while also making her a sympathetic character who you want to win (Which I didn’t)
I appreciate them trying to do something interesting with her character as ngl I thought she very bland for like the first 7 episodes. I’m not against the idea of her being a twist antagonist and using underhand tactics to win, it how they went about doing it fell flat. Riya in the first 3 quarters and final quarter feel like 2 different characters. Riya was established as a nice and friendly woman who was desperate for a big role in a movie as she was running out of money and needed to win. Cool… you understand her situation, and it would make some sense if she started playing a little dirty to win out of desperation, while feeling really bad and wanting to make it up to the others at the end, right? But no… apparently it makes more sense for her to become a stuck-up snob who gaslights other contestants and plays aggressive with absolutely no remorse whatsoever… WHAT?
I’m sorry but this character change was as subtle as a car crash. It’s so out of nowhere and just makes her such an un-rootable character. You want me to feel sad she lost? I was laughing when that happened!
OK… in all seriousness, I get what they were going for. A nice person turning to the dark side out of desperation to get what she wants. It’s possible to do that, it’s the execution that sucks. And it’s not like she’s very fun as a villain or good as one either. She’s not funny or charismatic like Heather, Alejandro, Bowie or even Yul. And honestly, I think she’s kind of pathetic near the end. She gets scared in the cave and starts crying like a little kid begging for help (OK I know that sound harsh I’m sure that is very scary, but it’s kind of pathetic scene for her. I was Rosa while watching that scene, not having it)
I think the better way to have written Riya, would have her be very uncomfortable and remorseful for her actions, show her in discomfort as everyone around her berates her actions, have her promise to make things up to everyone she’s hurt after she’s won. And have her really push hard and win for herself without trying to hurt the others. You know? Make rootable? Idk, I just think that would have been better for her character. Even her send off is unsatisfactory, like what is she just gonna go back to poverty? Wouldn’t it have been nice if Connor hired her as a model for his perfume company or something? Give her a good ending? Show how much Connor cares for her?
Idk, that’s just my thoughts. She’s not a good character at the end of the day, and her story needed a lot of work. I think Maggy is still the true worst character because she’s just extremely bland, but Riya is not much better.
So that’s my thoughts… please don’t kill me… 👉🏻👈🏻
I think you are objectively right with this analysis!
(jokes of course like Riya if you want but I feel exactly the same)
At first it kinda made sense when she eliminated Lake but then it went doooooooooooooooown
SPOILER FOR NEW TD 2023 season
I agree with this for the most part, however I think with Ryia’s execution they should of either made her nice on the outside but show she’s a mean person in the confessionals, like Heather, or just have her be a nice sensitive person and do maybe 1 or 2 awful things that make ppl hate u, like Millie.
My list:
14th: Ally didnt really have a personality and just existed
13th: Maggy was there and did her job but was there a bit too long
12th: Hunter needs to make a decision
11th: Tess had a lot of potential to be interesting but was wasted
10th: Olivers arc was fine even though he was just nice nothing with his trauma really
9th: Karol couldve been a great villain but was there for 4 episodes
8th: Kai was good and served his purpose
7th: Aiden he was likeable and had a little bit of drama
6th: James he had a good arc and a kind of cringe but nice thing with Aiden
5th: Connor is very h-
4th: Riya had weird pacing but i liked her through the whole season
3rd: Lake had a great character arc and was amazing in her last few episodes
2nd: Rosa Maria deserved that win, i totally rooted for her the entire season
1st: Yul was so fun to watch, I totally stan him and i wish he was there longer (better than Karol)
I really hope Yul returns for all stars, it would be funny to see him and Fiore team up and argue a lot. He also brought a lot of drama to the season as well.
Your dream became real
(Sadly)
According to what It was posted... He May have something going on with Grett
@@migatoxdSADLY
i could throw a trantum about lake (who i thought was the BIGGEST character in the whole season and would like to see her taking the winner's title) and rosa maria, who i think is such a nice character, being under yul who is just one-note and a early main antagonist who is not that strong, but the channel isn't mine lol great video btw
With that being said, my ranking would be
14th: Maggy - she's cute, i just think that she's not that interesting
13th: Tess - i don't hate her, not at all, but i just feel like she's just... a pretty shell, i wish she was more active and more talkative
12th: Ally - too vanilla and nice to my taste at the point she doesn't do much to add something for the season's plot other than being in a love triangle
11th: Hunger - just as you, he's the higher member of the love triangle, he has his moments of being a nice player and breaking off the plot with the girls, but i'm not in love with him
10th: Kai - he's a nice guy and a clearly early boot, that's all
9th: Connor - not gonna lie, i have a crush on him and i love how he accepts he's aging, i also like him and Riya being a couple and could like the two together even more if riya's develoment went otherwise
8th: Karol - SHE WAS SUCH A MISSED OPPORTUNITY, she suffered the same treatment eva suffered in TDI and it was such a shame tho i loved how she really connected with animals on the camp and was really hoping she and aiden could get along, too bad it went other way
7th: Yul - he's just heather with a pp, i mean work, i'm always up for a good antagonist who is pure evil, but he's one note to me and could get better in some all stars season
6th: Riya - she's much higher in my list than yours, even though i didn't like how evil and how unregretful she was or how they handled her in the end, i still think she's a good player and a unique character, she will have to work harder in some future season to fix her mistakes
5th: Aiden - i mean, he's one of the protagonists on the show and have a lot of development, with that being said, i was hoping to have a lot more of dialogues that wasn't about him being in a relationship with James, i feel like every gay couple in a fanmade total drama always falls in this trope, still pretty good
4th: Rosa Maria - i just love her, she could be a awesome winner and a true contender for the crown, i love how nice she is and how much we know about her past, her daughter and her own moral values
3th: James - he gets one of the best twists and it's like heather in TDWT, being a villain who becomes a better person and we begin to root for him, i think he is better than his partner for how he plays the game and how he grows so much as a character
2th: Oliver - c'mon... he's the man, we expected nothing from him and we were able to see such a beautiful human being, his relationship with Krystal are so wholesome, i love their interactions
1th: Lake - she was my winner as the episodes went by, in the start i was just thinking she would be a early boot and would fall flat. boy, i was so WRONG. she's one of the strongest competitors in this season, she's so smart and just like rosa maria, she can be a nice person without being boring like ally, i really like how she stands for herself and have the biggest growth here, she's my crownless winner and it could sound a little biased, however, i still argue that she should placed higher in the season or even being a finalist
Love seeing Yul so high! You just HAVE to hate him, but in a good way :)
Ally had so much potential I wish she got more focus 😭
James character development was the best development than a character can have!
Was really hard for me to rank ahaha 😅
14. Maggie
13. Ally
12. Karol
11. Tess
10. Hunter
9. Kai
8. Riya
7. Oliver
6. James
5. Yul
4. Aiden
3. Connor
2. Lake
1. Rosa Maria
Finally, someone who is a Rosa Maria fan 🗿
Can’t wait to hear you voice Trevor 👍🏻
For all the people say that bill is going to put Riya last, I really don’t think he is. I know billy doesn’t like Riya as much as other contestants but the whole reason why he may not like Riya is justified. It took time for me to get used to Riya sudden change. In my opinion if they kept Riya the way she was in episode 8 she would’ve been one of my favourite, but she turned into such a cartoony villain to the point where it got weird to see her on screen. It’s a game and the whole reason why everyone is there is to win. Riya is a character who’s development happened to late.
She turned into someone who was desperate and did whatever it took because she was insecure and didn't know what else to do, it wasn't cartoonish, it was just drastic
@@CodySimp It absolutely was cartoonish. While her desperation was a neat idea, the execution was completely unrealistic. She legit wanted to let a guy die and smirked about it like she's a freaking Batman villain.
@@picochu3990 She was desperate and did the most desperate thing a person can do which is lose all morality, it wasn't cartoonish to me. It's foolish to think that people don't do things like that irl because that ain't reality. The only thing I didn't like was her being forgiven afterwards so easily that I can agree was not realistic but her actions imo were. And EVEN IF it's cartoonish (which I don't think it is but for the sake of the argument) in case you forgot it's literally a cartoon lmao
@@CodySimp It was completely cartoonish. In one episode, she turned from an insecure woman who would lie to get her way into a smirking super villain willing to let people die and laugh about it because... Money, I guess. But only now. Not before. It's foolish to think that whatever that was wasn't just completely cartoonish.
You started this comment thread by arguing that it's not cartoonish. If it doesn't matter, why disagree?
@@picochu3990 this has just become a matter of opinion on which there's no point continuing lol. Sorry you don't know how people in life work but we aren't all sane and mentally sound lmfao
Im so hyped for this!!!!
14-Kai (he was so annoying, every time he spoke was kind of unbearable, I liked when he defended Maggy tho)
13-Yul (he filled his role yes but I didn't find him compelling as a character or an antagonist)
12-Karol (she was fine, I liked her arc but I don't have much more to say besides I'm glad she's not in all stars)
11-Oliver (cute character, fun storyline but not my focus this season)
10-Maggy (she didn't offer much but I liked her concept and design a lot, I felt bad for her too, I was kinda rooting for her at some points)
9-Lake (I quite like her enthusiasm and her backstory and her friendship with aiden but something about her does not click for me idk what)
8-Rosa (she was super nice and had some interesting plots but she's mainly a supportive character)
7-Connor (same as Rosa but I really enjoyed his story arc the first few episodes)
6-James (He's a great winner pick, at the same time not obvious but also well built-up and rewarding, he is multi-faceted and I like his relationship with Aiden)
5-Hunter (ok call me bland or whatever but I was really rooting for this trio... the whole poly couple thing is something we rarely see on shows like this and it was nice exploring the dynamics)
4-Tess (I put her above Hunter cause she has an aura of mystery that just makes me want to know more about her character. Her and Ally's relationship is one of the most interesting things that happened)
3-Aiden (Super cool design, also say what you want but he's pretty multi-faceted, he made the right call in episode 2 or 3 by wanting to disband the girl's alliance and using karol's vote, he could have been a really interesting player with a majority alliance on his side if James didn't meddle)
2-Riya (yeah yeah roast me that's fine, she's still my queen idc I agree her story could have been better/more subtle/not as extreme but regardless she was interesting to follow and she made the last few episodes interesting. Also her position in the girl's alliance was interesting and her dynamic with Rosa and Lake was complex and compelling)
1-Ally (LOVEEE Ally, I hope she gets far in the all stars, I'm not even a gamer but I rooted for her a lot she's just really likable and her and Tess' dynamic is the greatest thing to come out of this season)
I’m so glad that yul is so high :) he’s my favorite character and I laughed at so many of his lines, I was rlly sad to find out that the fandom loves Riya but hates him 😭😭 I really wanted him to come back later in the game I feel like the pay back would’ve been better than Karols 😭😭
ik he would solo
I have to admit, I didn’t like him at the beginning but nevertheless he was an iconic character and I‘m actually pretty glad that he‘s returning for s3.
He‘s sassy, funny, slightly evil and I‘m curious to see how he‘ll be like in the next season 👀
14. Tess (boring to watch, extremely poor portrayl of depression that was her negated to her side plot of the already awful poli triangle)
13. Ally (nothing personality, exists as a plot device to a terrible plot)
12. Maggie (I just don't care)
11. Carol (her connection to nature despite being full of rage was pretty funny, but like she just came back to give Aidan and James something to do for a few episodes, which was flawed for the reasons you mentioned and not that interesting anyway)
10. Connor (sorry but I found him really uninteresting and hate his dynamic with Riya)
9. Hunter (best part of a terrible plot, his indecisiveness was somewhat interesting but not enough done with him)
8. Oliver (I like his plot but he just didn't have enough personality to warrant a higher ranking)
7. Kai (fun personality without being annoying, stayed for the right amount of time)
6. Aidan (his naivity and black and white thinking was a bit hard to believe at some points but overall likeable)
5. Yul (nasty, spiteful, egocentric, exactly what the season needed)
4. Riya (her character development was extremely jarring and I get that but take away Riya and the season gets a lot worse, her determination was very endearing)
3. James (great character development, well deserved winner)
2. Rosa-maria (low-key best part of the finale, amazing support character but also had a good backstory and strong, believable morals and values which she stays true to. You know she went through a lot and became a stronger person because of it, which kind of reflects Lake’s development this season)
1. Lake (my favourite character development this season, it was really nice seeing her grow into her own person. Loved her dynamic with Rosa-maria and Krystal)
“Who’s disventure camp’s best character? Is it Riya? Or do you have a valid opinion?”
I came across this channel and noticed I was subbed and remember in was like the 496th subscriber and I watched this channel grow and forgot about it when disventure camp season 1 came out. I still love Billy’s disventure camp videos and I’ve had a fun time
Nice Video and I respect your opinion on the characters.
Here are my rankings on the characters.
Hate:
14: Yul
Dislike:
13: Karol
Neutral
12: Riya
Okay:
11: Hunter
10: Tess
9: Ally
Like:
8: James
7: Oliver
6: Maggy
5: Connor
4: Aiden
Love:
3: Lake
2: Rosa María
Best
1: Kai
I hope you like my rankings on the characters!
Kai is a big W
Billy spoilerd season two he siad that tess will get more devolopment and screentime so she will probobly get far
you mean season three? bruh I don't even know what's gonna happen in that season 😭
@@SillyBillyDucky mhmm keep saying that to yourself, im on to you (says in a mischievous voice😈)
My favourite from season 2 was definitely Yul! I also loved Ally but wish she had more to do in the season :( Hopefully all stars will rectify it
TBH, all the characters in the show are intresting.
Great Ranking Billy 👍🏻
Can you answer a quick question?
If this list included Nina, Marcus, and Kristal where would they rank on your list?
14: Karol
13: Yul
12: Oliver
11: Kai
10: Maggie
9: Riya
8: Connor
7:Rosa Maria
6: Lake
5: James
4: Aiden
3:Ally
2: Tess
1: Hunter
Reason: it was called season 2 because the original season aka season one was adventure camp (the Spanish season)
My Personal Disventure Camp List
My Opinion sobs
So Here we go
14th - Ally
13th - Maggy
12th - Connor
11th - Yul
10th - Karol
9th - Oliver
8th - Hunter
7th - Kai
6th - Riya
5th - Tess
4th - Aiden
3rd - RosaMaria
2nd - Lake
1st- James
Some of this might be biased by the fact I watched S1 before S2 having been introduced to the show recently and not knowing the production history that seemed most logical, and being caught up on All Stars, but... Aiden's my favourite, but I'm apparently a sucker for _fluff_ . And Aiden's character is pure _fluff_ . Well acted fluff, well written fluff, but still fluff. (Actually come to think of it Gwen's relationship with Trent in TDI was what made me enjoy her characterization so much - As I say, I'm a sucker for fluff - That teen summer romance vibe that I think Grease aims for?)
But, yeah, Yul is a great villain - He's very punchable. That's exactly what I want in a villain where they're not going for a sympathetic villain angle for, and I like that just how evil Yul was is what triggered James' heel-face turn starting with a bit of karmic retribution of poisoning Yul with his own mushroom. James has a fantastic redemption arc and then winds up as the love interest in the romantic comedy that is Aiden's storyline for the second half of the season. I think I struggled with Hunter, Tess, and Ally less than you did as well. And I think I followed Riya's arc better than you did on first watch, so wouldn't rank her as low - it felt like development rather than derailment to me because I saw what they were going for with it in real time - but fully agree with your criticisms as to the pacing of it.
13:33 Nina is so iconic
My fav will always be Riya due to how dirty she was done by the writers and how I didn't enjoy the will-they-won't they plot for Aiden and James. Good ranking regardless.
Of course billy post when I’m at school sad day for me. D:
Your still in school!? You poor soul 😢
Honestly same silly billy for riya. 😂 now I need to send my official ranking too (when I edited comments :D )
Please James’s reaction when he found out he was Aiden’s first kiss 😭✋
My ranking; (Pls respect my opinion 😭, also spoilers)
14th: James- Honestly why did he win, he didn't even do good at the challenges and probs only won bc of his and Aiden's relationship
13th: Maggy- I liked her a bit, but she was boring and she only got bullied by Yul
12th: Yul- I don't think I need to explain
11th: Kai- I would've liked him way more if he wasn't eliminated so early
10th: Hunter- He literally thought Lake was in love with him when 1: She's 16, he's 23 2: She only wanted to socialize with him, how did he win so many challenges anyway?
9th: Karol- I did like her development of her and Riya's friendship, and when she came back we saw more of her character
8th: Ally- I liked her, but I liked other people more, her story of her grandfather passing away was so sad too, she deserved better
7th: Aiden- I used to like him but he began to become boring throughout the show and him being in the finale was obvious
6th: Tess- I wish we got to see more of her, I loved her relationship with Ally and Hunter
5th: Oliver- I loved him sm, he was an amazing character
4th: Connor- I personally believe he was very underrated, he was such a kind character
3rd: Rosa-Maria- She was literally one of the nicest people in the show, deserved better
2nd: Riya- I LOVED HER. She had a nice relationship with Karol and Connor, I rlly loved her villian arc too
1st: Lake- She had the best development out of everyone, she should've won but thanks to NINA she lost..
Here’s my thoughts on Lake:
I feel bad for her for having selfish and neglectful parents. Just like in the Willoughbys.
And I’m glad she’s free, but ever since she started speaking up for herself, she’s becoming more badass (not in a good way).
She said Nasty things to Krystal when she demanded her to remove her good girl wig. And when they got to know each other, we never heard an apology from either one.
And the previously eliminated contestants saw what Rosa did to Riya after she betrayed her. But apparently, she didn’t care. She hit Riya without Mercy, and she was just beginning to reform (a little bit).
That’s what I think of Lake, don’t judge me.
The reason she said those nasty things to Krystal wasn’t just because of the wig, it was because Krystal was doing things with malicious intent and she needed to be knocked down a peg but after that they got closer and Krystal helped out and yk the rest (you are still valid in ur opinion tho)
14-Maggy (As said by Billy, she was a really nothing character with a bland plot that was really never explored and it felt like she was floating around waiting to be eliminated until she did)
13-Kai (Same as Maggy but since he had a bit more of personality i put him higher, his jokes never made me laugh personally and i thought he made no sense whatsover, i expected him to last but not because i liked him but because i know how oddnations works with "some" characters but we will be on that in one moment)
12-James (This one may be hard to believe but he is almost the worst written character and i would put him higher if it wasnt becasue Kai and Maggy are so plain, now the reason why i hate him its because before his redemption arc he was only annoying and when it become time to strategize he literally eliminated someone that could get them out of a very risky situation but he throwed Karol under the bus, he only got far because of the team swap and even then when he decided to betray Yul he could have voted him out and let it be but no he had no to the extra mile to freaking poison him. Then he didnt do anything remarkable and was an awful person like when she accused Rosa of being the thief for being Mexican or when he manipualted Aiden into doing what he wanted, when the twist happened i wasnt surprised at all and he was never gonna tell Aiden by how he told Riya to shut up, people say that Riya only felt bad because she was caught but the same aplies to James)
11-Aiden (Straight forward another bland character with no contribution other than his main romance with James which made no sense and was boring as hell, i knew from the get go that he would be a finalist because he was gay and looked like an E-boy, the only thing interesting about his character is that he is trans and that plot served no purpose so yeah Aiden is plain cancell me i guess)
10-Ally (As much as i love Ally personally i can see how she didnt contribute anything else other than her love triangle, which gets resolved, and her personality that was never explored aside from some topics. I found her backstory with his grandpa very compelling but after that she never grew up or showed any sign of development)
09-Tess (She was literally right when she said she didnt have anything interesting on her, i would have liked if her angry side was more shown but it wasnt and the only reason that im putting her above Ally is that at the very least Tess had some development in some shape of form but the others didnt which isnt much to say)
08-Connor (He was rather simple and although i liked his struggles and development there wasnt much reason why i should care for him and mostly he served as a support character for Oliver and Riya which isnt that bad but yeah not a stand out)
07-Riya (Although i personally really love her it is for the wrong reasons, i found her struggles to find fame and recognition very relatable and made me like her but she became a ghost for a while until her plot started to kick in on episode 8 and 9 which i really liked because coming from her it was very realistic but instead of turning her into a grey character bit by bit they made her a total cartoony villain with zero thinking aside from strategic purpose and was only sorry because she had no other way of winning without Rosa, she had huge potential but they went from 10% to 40% to 100% way too soon but atleast she had some development and was kinda justified by the game rules unlike James who cheated on many ocassions)
06-Hunter (He is the best one in all the love triangle due to his nice personality and chill attitude which i really liked but same case as her partners, no development and out of the final 4 i only wanted to root for him because James was unlikeable, Aiden was boring and Riya was "mean". But the saddest thing is that a character like him is this high and we are on top 6 people)
05-Karol (Aaaaah dont you love wasted potential? Karol was ok at most when she was eliminated, i loved how they turned a one note character to a woman with good intentions but bad temper, but as always James has to become stupid all of the sudden and vote out Karol because i guess strategy? I dont know that was so stupid but the story praised him. Then when she returned i was very excited to have a villain again but she didnt last at all and all her potential went down the toilet for what? Some gay story where the "good ones" are actually in the wrong but the story praises them and leaves James winning more bitter than you would expect, she was well characterized but again missed potential and its sad seeing someone like her this up on the list, hopefully on the next one we will be more bright)
04-Oliver (The first boot ended up in fourth place huh, Oliver's story at first made me sympathize with him but the story forced him to trauma dump all of it because i dont know and he got to stay which i wasnt very fond of but it turned out to be a very great decision since he helped Krystal develop more and we got to see more of this trauma due to Chris, in the end he isnt an excepcional character but a well thought one if you ignore episode one which was a mess dealing with his plot)
03-Yul (Believe me that i didnt expect this mf to be this high on the list but after thinking about it, he is actually so well characterized, had a good strategy so he could threat others as shit and still get far, had bad intentions all around him and it made him a very good villain at the levels of maybe reboot Grett, which in my opinion is a worst character, but yeah Yul is a very well written villain who was totally wasted by the show and im still bitter that a very minor villain ended up in third place just because the other characters suck)
02-Rosa (Finally a well written character! Although Rosa was clearly a support character she served that role perfectly and made her the most likeable person on the whole cast, i never specifically rooted for her since she really didnt have potential to be a winner but i found her to be really endearing, likeable, nice and overall just a simple but good character that always stuck up on to her morals but she didnt get much development unlike number 1)
01-Lake (THIS IS HOW YOU WRITTE A GOOD CHARACTER, Lake was a likeable contestant that was really well developed since the show took its time to see her in all of her states of rage, sadness, joy and acceptance of herself, she was really well thought and it made you wanna root for her in every instance that the show had but even so she didnt even make it to top 5 which was utterly unforgivable)
Resume: To say the least in here, this was a show with more than half of the cast being either boring or wasted potential
My list
14 Riya
13 Yul
12 Maggy
11 Alley
10 Hunter
9 lake
8 Karol
7 tess
6 Rosa Maria
5 Oliver
4 Connor
3 Kai
2 James
1 Aidan
For me the ranking goes:
14th yul: honestly i hated yul and unlike heather for me he never became a character you love to hate. I just despise him. Mainly for being a bully.
13th maggie: she is here because she dosnt really do much aside from punch yul and get with kai. I dont dislike her but she just doesn't do enough for me to move her higher.
12th hunter: im gonna be honest and say that i hate challenge beasts courtney from tda is another example. What i find satisfying is watching a challenge beast get blindsided part way through the merge. Like ozzy in survivor micronesia.
11th ally: aside from our shared interest in videogames i I honestly cant place her higher as she was a really boring character who pretty much road hunters coattails to get to 6th. I wish she did more.
10th tess: tess is higher than the other 2 in the throuple because i really enjoyed her mental health storyline its a shame she went out when she did.
9th Aiden: at first i liked aiden they were really interesting but after the snow episode i started liking him less and less i went from rooting for him to win to actively rooting against him.
8th kai: kai is here because there are people i like more an people i like less. I like that he stood up for Maggie but aside from that he didnt do much for me.
7th karol: i like her animal stuff but she pretty much did an eva from total drama i wish she at least partially got her wish an got one of the boys booted but it wasnt meant to be
6th riya: when riya is good she is great but essentially pushing aiden off a cliff was way to much i wish karols influence was more explicitly told to us as to why she goes fulltime villain final five onwards.
5th lake: i like lakes story i just wish she got further
4th connor: served his roll well as he showed compassion for everyone i just wish it was told to us how hed help riya instead of leaving us wondering.
3rd oliver: oliver was terrible as a camper but his development from intern to host of season 3 i think was a really cool journey to follow
2nd rosa maria: hands down best female character in the show im glad james helped her in the end and like connor she is really compassionate helping riya for her own morals to set a good example for her kid.
1st james: out of the final three we got im glad he won while he had spots of unlikabilty like kissing aiden for too long im glad he reconciled with aiden at the end and he even looked guilty the next episode. Great character development .
Season 1:
1. Gabby
2. Ellie
3. Miriam
4. Fiore
5. Ashley
6. Alec
7. Jake
8. Tom
9. Lill
10. Dan
11. Will
12. Nick
13. Drew
14. Grett
Season 2:
1. Aiden
2. Lake
3. James
4. Riya
5. Rosa Maria
6. Connor
7. Hunter
8. Tess
9. Ally
10. Oliver
11. Kai
12. Maggy
13. Karol
14. Yul
All-Stars:
1. Ashley
2. Tess
3. Lake
4. Gabby
5. Fiore
6. Alec
7. Miriam
8. Connor
9. Aiden
10. Riya
11. Tom
12. Jake
13. James
14. Grett
15. Ellie
16. Ally
17. Hunter
18. Yul
I rlly love tess ally and hunter
I already know
Who’s last
Aiden is my all-time favorite character in both seasons
I feel that Lake and Aiden are like the lesbian and gay besties
I admit, I'm not sure what they will do with the all stars season, given that season's 1 and 2 have completly different art styles.
Honestly the only thing keeping me from loving James is the VA's performance :( I mostly agree with your points tho, great list!
My ranking is this
14. Maggy (boring and bland)
13. Ally (boring but had a good relationship with Hunter)
12. Kai (rage at Yul was great and gained my respect, but such a spiritual character... Existed for me. Only existed)
11. Karol (the right revenge on James was interesting, but a bit of wasted potential. At least it woke up Riya.
10. Rosa Maria (Nice. Too Nice. Too Much Rainbow)
9. Oliver (as a contestant a bit pathetic, as Kristal's sidekick he even got character)
8th: Hunter (he was ok. just)
7. James (He got a good redemption arc, but I can't forget his initial plots with Yul. He got better, but I didn't manage to like him)
6. Tess (has had a troubled history and I generally like characters who... I'm having a hard time finding the right word in this language. She doesn't care much about what's going on around)
5. Aiden (I liked his look and for the action with the spider his character was cool, but for me he was too naive in...too many situations)
4. Yul (good as an antagonist and I liked to hate him)
3. Lake (the story with her parents and Kristal's attitude is a big plus. Also, a nice girl, but in moderation)
2. Connor (I like the guy. The oldest of the participants and the most sensible. When he had something to say, it was usually right. Plus, he sacrificed himself for Riya. Also, I like their relationship)
1. Riya (I usually hate antagonists, but Riya didn't start out as an antagonist.
First, the least important aspect - it looks great. When I was a kid, I used to fall in love with some Total Drama girls, like Courtney, Zoey. I would fall in love with her here 😅
Now it's time for important things 😉
I liked her a lot for her relationship with Connor and the very goal of being someone and not a poor obscure Bollywood actress. After he left, I felt sorry for her because she seemed like an easy-to-eliminated person with no allies. She was lonely and I interpreted Lake's elimination as jealousy of Rosa Maria, that Riya would be sidelined. Later Karol did her job and I understood why Riya's brakes were released. However, the elimination of Rosa Maria and the rift between Aiden and James was overkill. I have the impression that the last episodes were unfair to Riya in terms of opinion among viewers. She became "evil" and there was not enough gray in her behavior. She was deprived of the nuances she deserved, and it was bad for me to see, hear and read my opinion of my favorite character changing so much. I couldn't write her off myself and, despite everything, I was rooting for her to win and become someone in life. I wish there was an alternative ending, because I think there should have been. I would like to see her win and have a chance to fulfill her dreams, even if at such a price. It came out typical "evil" lost and I ran out of balance. More attempt to explain Riya's actions and understand her)
My ranking got super screwed up by the end of the series, and totally changed from what I had at first...
14. Maggy (Didn't get the needed development.)
13. Connor (I love his design, but the second he accepted his age, he dropped off.)
12. Ally (I... can't believe I'm doing this. I can't understand why they didn't do anything with her.)
11. Yul (Annoying, but at least he had some character.)
10. Kai (I would've placed him higher, but he's already high enough.)
9. Karol (I actually wanted her to come back, and I'm so happy she did!)
8. Tess (YES thank you for actually doing her good! Got the development she deserved.)
7. Oliver (OH THANK YOU FOR GIVING HIM DEVELOPMENT! I was sad he got out first.)
Gets a bit controversial here.
6. Aiden (Super fun at first, but got a little bit annoying as time went by.)
5. Lake (Absolutely amazing! But I gotta say... I just couldn't put her higher with her dumb elimination. She definitely could've won.)
4. Riya (The one character everyone thought would be boring, but I wanted her to be a finalist... just not what they gave us. I still love her, though.)
3. Hunter (I don't know why everyone hates him, he was great.)
2. Rosa Maria (It sucks she was never a main character, she was awesome!)
1. James (YES THANK YOU FOR LETTING HIM WIN! Best development and my favorite definitely {also, look at that cake-})
"Look at that cake"💀
@@Goofy90 I mean...
Da Kai ranking tho, but is does make sense
This is the internet everything is conserveral. - Silly Bill 2023
Mine(Based on S2):
14.Maggy(Decent)
13.Kai(Decent)
12.Oliver(Like + Decent)
11.Ally(Decent)
10.Yul(Decent)
9.Hunter(Like + Decent)
8.Connor(Like)
7.Rosa(Like)
6.Aiden(Like)
5.Karol(Love)
4.James(Love)
3.Tess(Love)
2.Riya(Love)
1.Lake(Favs)
Not gonna explain for most, but here is my list. 14: Maggie. 13: Kai, only better for cursing off yul tbh. 12: Riya. 11: Connor. 10: Tess. 9: Ally. 8: Hunter. 7: Karol. 6: Yul 5: Oliver. 4: Rosa Maria 3: Aiden, I do really like him, and his design, but like said in the vid, he is a bit vanilla. 2: James. 1: LAKE :].
EDIT: Thank you Billy! I totally forgot Yul, because a Ally should've been at nine, but Yul would be at six in between Karol and Oliver. :)
You missed Yul on 9 ;)
OMG I DID-
Do you know when the next review of the new season is coming maybe
sooooooooooooon
(probably the day after the episode goes live? If I can get it finished that is)
1. Aiden
2. James
3. Connor
4. Hunter
5. Oliver
6. Rosa María
7. Ally
8. Lake
9. Tess
10. Maggy
11. Kai
12. Karol
13. Yul
14. Riya
This was honestly sorta difficult lol, but here’s mine
14. Yul
13. Maggy
12. Ally
11. Tess
10. Hunter
9. Kai
8. Connor
7. Oliver
6. Riya
5. Karol
4. James
3. Aiden🥉
2. Rosa Maria🥈
1. Lake🥇
My ranking:
14. Aiden (I disliked him so much. It has no personality. It depends on James to survive in the plot. He is extremely boring.)
13 Oliver (It became annoying and its plot was not to my liking.)
12. Kai (Meh)
11. Maggy (Meh)
10. James (I only liked the first 4 chapters, then its plot was to be with Aiden all the time.)
9. Rosa (I like him as a person, but as a character he left me a little to be desired. Also, I don't like characters with a HERO COMPLEX.)
8. Ally (I like him, but without only serving for the love triangle.)
7. Connor (He is a good character, there are simply others that I like more.)
6. Tess (I liked it much better than Ally, both in personality and in its plot.)
5. Karol (The villain of a badly told tale. I just quite like it.)
4. Hunter (Despite the fact that everything worked out for him in much of the game, he had personality.)
3. Yull (I love him as a character. The cynical and cruel way in which he makes fun of everyone. Of the few that really would have wanted it to last longer in the competition.)
2. Lake (Although I do not agree that he is a finalist, as it would be too obvious, it does not prevent him from being almost certainly the best written character of the season.)
1. Riya (I put it at number one, because I feel like it saved the season from being boring, without Yull, the series had lost tension and drama. For me he should have won the season.)
My finalist:
1. Riya
2. Hunter
3. Yull
Finally someone understands me. Rosa is an extremely good person, but as a character she falters, and all because of that boring HERO COMPLEX
I agree with your reasonings, but why are you calling them all hims
@@nezuko5377 idk
Finally someone who actually sees Yul as a good character!
Mine
14: Aiden
13:James
12: Connor
11:Oliver
10:Maggy
9:Riya
8: Ally
7: Kai
6: Lake
5: Rosa Maria
4: Hunter
3: Karol
2: Yul
1: Tess👑
I do think Riya should get a little more love, but I respect the list otherwise! Here’s mine:
14. Maggy
13. Ally
12. Kai
11. Aiden
10. Oliver
9. Yul
8. Tess
7. Karol
6. Riya
5. James
4. Hunter
3. Lake
2. Connor
1. Rosa Maria
Riya made halfway I'm happy 😂
@@totaldramajoseph146Haha I love Riya. I found her change in personality plausible given her goals, insecurities as time went went on, and a little coaxing from Karol. But there were just too many good characters I enjoyed this season to rank her any higher.
YOUR VA WAS SO GOOD
I feel like the love triangle was resolved. I assumed the end was hinting that they became a poly couple.😊
I mean love story in the love triangle is interesting to see. They never go their which make it unique
You either love or hate riya
I so happen to love her and she's a queen 👸 😍 ❤
And yes riya being my fave is valid fr 😂
I respect Your opinion my favorite is hunter
My own personal ranking:
14th: Karol
13th: Kai
12th: Connor
11th: Yul
10th: Maggy
9th: Oliver
8th: Riya
7th: Hunter
6th: Ally
5th: James
4th: Tess
3rd: Lake
2nd: Aiden
1st: Rosa Maria
(Putting Rosa at the top because i love how nice she is, and in my opinion she deserved a lot better this season)
Woooooooooo
1:11 TWD reference
So excited
Riya prob gonna be last 😂
I’d like to see Hunter and James team up to defeat a greater evil in the all star season
is it official that there is going to be an all stars season??? :o
@@GabrielaQueenOfSocks Silly Billy keeps talking about it and since he is a part of the Disventure Camp team I can just assume there is one in the works
I'm also making a total drama series when it comes out can you pls rank mine 😊
I loved yul sm lol
I would say my list is
14. Kai
13. Maggy
12. Yul
11. Karol
10. Ally
9. Aiden
8. Connor
7. Tess
6. Hunter
5. Oliver
4. Rosa Maria
3. James
2. Riya
1. Lake
I know some people aren’t really a fan of Riya but I really enjoyed her character. I thought the foreshadowing of her was actually really good. Her constantly feeling alone and left out then seeing nice people like Aiden play dirty and Karol telling her that you can’t trust everyone which led to villain in my opinion was a really good twist. It was a little predictable for me honestly by episode 8 but I still enjoyed it although I think her leaving Aiden on a cliff was a little too much. It felt like they were kinda trying hard to make her look like a villain. Overall I think your list is pretty good and I can see why you don’t like Riya but we can all have different opinions. 😁
Billy saying that Aiden being naive can be annoying. *jake literally being called the naive*
Not season 1 coming out in 2 days
hey nice list. if u want more td fan content, ive made one. The first 3 episodes have premiered
Hey dude, I like this content and totally respect your opinions BUT- just a little friendly reminder that the whole "threesome" thing you were talking about was actually a polyamorous relationship (a totally valid thing) a lot of people aren't educated on them but I thought I'd just let you know. (I don't really like the way they handled it myself, but it's more of a casual representation, so I have to respect it for that)
Riya fans when she actually isn't in last place and they didn't need to be passive aggressive :
Imo
14 Riya
13 Maggie
12 Karol
11 Tess
10 Ally
9 Rosa maria
8 Connor
7 Kai
6 Sam
5 James
4 Aiden
3 Yul
2 Hunter
1 Lake
I just started watching this. I love Ally and Tess. Also ally is great and very unrated. Also how is Tess and ally below Karol snd Yul?.
For me:
14th - Oliver ( as a contestant )
13th - Maggie
12th - Ally
11th - Karol
10th - Connor
9th - Hunter
8th - Yul
7th - Tess
6th - Riya
5th - Aiden
4th - Kai
3rd - Lake
2nd - Rosa-Maria
1st - James
This cast was so interesting! I feel bad for the upcoming season/prequel: the cast looks so lame when compared.
Here's Mine
14. In Last Place is Stupid Yul
13. Maggy
12. Connor
11. Ally
10. Kai
9. Karol
8. Tess
7. Oliver
6. Hunter
5. Rosa Maria
4. Lake
3. Riya
2. James
1. Aiden
Just me or hunter looks like Dr drakon from Kim possible
Damn my queen Tess got in twelfth 😢..
I love hunter
I don’t know why, but my best friend favorite character is riya and I hate her the most
(Sorry for the length, and thank you if you're still willing to read all of it!)
(Obviously, this it my opinion, and you're allowed to have a different one.)
Thoughts on James:
Personally, I don't think James is as great as people say. Yes, he is an interesting character, but he's not a really good person. People think that after his "redemption arc" he became a nice guy, but we only ever see him being nice to Aiden.
The only time when he is interested in someone else, or being nice to someone else (except Aiden) is in the finale, when he asks about Rosa and later gives her some of the money.
But in the rest of the season, he only interacts with other characters for strategies. You can see that in the finale, where no one supports him. Not a single person. And eventually Rosa volunteers to help him, but states that she did it because she doesn't like seeing people having a bad time, even though he deserves it. James's entire story was basically about his relationship with Aiden. Besides that, he is really boring. And really, even in that story there are many problems.
After episode 2, where he manipulates Aiden, he doesn't really try to do anything to fix their relationship, and just really being a jerk to Aiden. Until of course, he decides to poison Yul instead of Aiden.
I know Yul is an unlikable character, so him being poisons is supposed to be satisfying, and it is, but James still POISONED SOMEONE. He could've just not poison anyone. After all, Yul got the most votes anyways. He didn't need it to get rid of Yul, be he still chose to poison him. And it's not like he knew it's safe. It was a random mushroom that they found in the big jungle. It could have been way worse. And the next episode, everyone just see it as something nice he did to Aiden.
But how was it enough to fix things with Aiden? For Aiden, all it proves is that in that moment, James wanted Yul gone more then Aiden. Maybe James just thought that Yul is a bigger threat, or maybe James still tries to manipulate Aiden so he prefers to keep him in the game for now, but Aiden couldn't have known.
But besides that we don't see anything bad he does. He's not nice, and does anything to continue in the game, but he doesn't make another constant leave the game by poisoning or injuring them, right? Well, he doesn't, be he does encourage Aiden to play dirty, and congratulates him later for sabotaging and injuring her.
In general, James feels like a multidimensional character, but he isn't. It looks like he gets a redemption arc, but he's just nice to Aiden because he likes him. He tries hard to win and even manipulates some people in the early episodes. And... that's it. There's not a lot more to his character.
It's not that I don't like James, he's a good character, I like his story and he would probably be in my top 5, but he gets much more credit then he deserves. I really hope that if they do another season with him, he'll get to have more to his story, and we get to explore more of his character then just his affection for Aiden.
Im sad and happy
Riya didn't get 14th but she was still bottom 2 for you ......
Respect your opinion ofc
Personal opinion, I don't mean to be rude.
There are lots of high characters that does not deserve that placement for me.
I personally don't like Kai.
For the most I agree what you said about Aiden, I just would have put him a bit lower.
Oliver is meh, okay in the middle, but third place is too high (a bit like Aiden).
YUL? REALLY?!?! WHAT'S WRONG WITH YOU????? Jk hahahah.
Also I really liked Connor, Hunter and Karol, Connor in particular could have been much more developed, but I can understand why he's so low.
Lastly, I strongly agree with Maggie's placement. I also want to give you credit for being the only one I know that is against Riya's development.
To be honest this list is really difficult because a LOT of characters have something that brings them down and depending on which angle you approach it with your ranking looks totally different.
Well, I think the direction they wanted to take Riya was interesting, but ended up being poorly executed. She took the idea of hate the game, not the player too far and ended up being needlesly cartoonishly evil. Yeah, she was a bit underwhelming.
My opinion:
14th- Riya
13th- Yul
12th- Maggy
11th- Hunter
10th- Karol
9th- Ally
8th- James
7th- Oliver
6th- Connor
5th- Kai
4th- Lake
3rd- Rosa Maria
2nd- Aiden
Meaning my favorite Disventure Camp character iiiiiiiis TESS!!!! (Yes I'm a fucking Tess stan, no you can't convince me otherwise)
I honestly didn't really like the 1st Disventure camp mainly because of the cast. But I'm honestly in love with the newest season- I hope Alec wins!
1. Hunter (cool chad, he's only bland sometimes because of Tess and Ally)
2. Riya (Fought for what she desired and I respect her for it)
3. Connor (Cool Boomer with development early on)
4. Lake (didn't expect her character to grow much, but pleasantly surprised)
5. James (He's aight, kinda overrated from what I've seen)
6. Yul (He would rank higher if his voice didn't cringe me out)
7. Oliver (He's OK)
8. Aiden (Meh, overrated and clearly carried by James)
9. Rosa-Maria (She's too nice, and being too nice can be boring sometimes)
10. Tess (Boring)
11. Ally (For a "gamer girl" she's boring)
12. Karol (Annoying)
13. Kai (Boring and annoying with an awful voice)
14. Maggie (a "nothing" character)
This cast sucks compared to S1.
I think Ally, Tess, and Hunter aren’t a triangle but a love trio
Both girls like hunter and hunter has both equally love for the both of them which is actually interesting more love the better
“Is it Riya or do you have a valid opinion?”💀💀💀💀
7:31
20 Jenson ❌
19 Drew (sorry) 🙇♀️
18 Maggy (also sorry) 🙇♀️🙇♀️
17 Riya (kinda true) ✅
16 Yul
15 Lake
14 Grett
13 Aiden
12 Mariam
11 James
10 Kai
9 Hunter
8 Karol
7 Derek
6 Trevor
5 Foire
4 Alec
3 Conner
2 Rosa Maira❤
1 Dan❤❤
14- Tess: She didn't have much personality to her than others in the season which in my case is very bland the only things we knew about her was her depression and her being a Wal-Mart version of Gwen
13- Maggie: The reason why Maggie's here is because she again, was a very bland character we didn't know anything about her but why she's below Tess is because her punching Yul was mad funny.
12- Ally: To all ally stans.... There was nothing really cool about her other than being a gamer.
11- Kai: He's below Ally but not top 10 He was low-key kinda boring and had no potential but it was funny when he cussed out Yul.
TOP 10 !!
10-Hunter: AGAIN A MAD BORING CHARACTER.. But I low-key liked him more than the Wal-Mart version of Gwen.
9- Riya: Personally I liked her growth of being that "Evil" Character and her development was good too I'm glad she made it to the finals.
8- Karol: It truly was funny about her talking to animals but I personally love her.
7- Connor: DO I HAVE TO SAY SMT..
6- Oliver: Though he did get eliminated early I loved him but I love Kristal because she let him co-host so we got to see him every episode.
TOP FIVE
5- Rosa-Maria: She is so adorable I love her and I'm glad they included her in as a teen mom and her helping Riya so her daughter would see that she should see the good side of things no matter how bad they are.
4-Lake I'm sorry but SHE IS SO NICEEEE AND SWEET! AND I LOVE HOW SHE ALWAYS LOOKED OUT FOR AIDEN!
3-YUL😍😍: His character was funny to me and I love him one of my favorite characters.
2-James: It was great to see his character development from the beginning to the finals but when he toyed Aiden by kissing him longer was funny to me.
AND THATS LEAVING NUMBER 1
AIDEN!: I actually loved how he was in a love- hate game with James but I loved him being the transgender character.
With that my ranking is done!
Tess is nothing like Gwen. They’re both unique characters in their own right
Finally someone who ranks Tess higher than tenth. I do wish we saw more of her and ally and without Hunter involved. Tbh I ship Tess and ally
My favorite characters are Hunter and Rosa
So many riya stans in the comments 💀
They are everywhereee
Tbh it's just the kind of character she is. The idea of an ice cold queen mean girl is literally so beloved, look at julia in 2023 for example
James at the top is amazing 💗 and respect for putting yul at 2 I love him
My least favourite characters are Ashley from Season 1 and Yul from Season 2
I’m so happy you said that cause I don’t like Ally either she was such a boring and non fun character
Nina is practically a goddess