Carly Gregg's Shocking Mental Evaluation Revealed in Murder Trial

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 вер 2024
  • Amanda Gugliano, director of forensic evaluation services, took the stand in Carly Gregg’s trial on Thursday afternoon where she detailed what she experienced while talking to Carly months after she was arrested for allegedly murdering her mother, Ashley Smylie. Carly revealed to Gugliano that she “blacked out” during the incident, but that she didn’t feel as bothered as she thought she would be after going to jail for her mom’s murder.
    Subscribe to Law&Crime Trials for More Courtroom Coverage: bit.ly/LawAndC...
    Watch More Carly Gregg Court Clips: bit.ly/CarlyGr...
    Fifteen-year-old Carly Gregg is accused of brutally murdering her mother and attempting to murder her stepfather in March of 2024. Gregg allegedly shot her mother in the face numerous times inside their Mississippi home before she's accused of calling her friend over to show her the gruesome scene. If convicted, Gregg faces life behind bars.
    #CarlyGregg #MurderTrial #LawAndCrime
    STAY UP-TO-DATE WITH THE LAW&CRIME NETWORK:
    Watch Law&Crime Network on UA-camTV: bit.ly/3td2e3y
    Where To Watch Law&Crime Network: bit.ly/3akxLK5
    Sign Up For Law&Crime's Daily Newsletter: bit.ly/LawandC...
    Read Fascinating Articles From Law&Crime Network: bit.ly/3td2Iqo
    For Licensing Inquiries, Please Contact: licensing@lawandcrime.com
    LAW&CRIME NETWORK SOCIAL MEDIA:
    Instagram: / lawandcrime
    Twitter: / lawcrimenetwork
    Facebook: / lawandcrime
    Twitch: / lawandcrimenetwork
    TikTok: / lawandcrime
    LAW&CRIME NETWORK PODCASTS: lawandcrime.co...
    SUBSCRIBE TO ALL OF LAW&CRIME NETWORK UA-cam CHANNELS:
    Main Channel: / @lawandcrime
    Law&Crime Shorts: / @lawandcrimeshorts
    Channel B: / @lawandcrimetrials
    Channel C: / @lawandcrimebodycam

КОМЕНТАРІ • 123

  • @lawandcrimetrials
    @lawandcrimetrials  5 годин тому +1

    Watch More Carly Gregg Court Clips: bit.ly/CarlyGreggTrial

  • @kethillyviana7551
    @kethillyviana7551 3 години тому +54

    Carly is a psychopath....

    • @irishgal353
      @irishgal353 2 години тому +5

      1000%!

    • @BruceLee-t9n
      @BruceLee-t9n 2 години тому +5

      She Makes Bundy Look Like a Cute Kitten

    • @irishgal353
      @irishgal353 2 години тому +2

      @@BruceLee-t9n Fabulous! I wish I thought of this!

    • @BruceLee-t9n
      @BruceLee-t9n 2 години тому +2

      @@irishgal353 I wish I could come up with money the way I come up with these bangers

    • @elainewallace3381
      @elainewallace3381 2 години тому +3

      I'm just wondering are all you psychologists?

  • @angelahatzimihalis7103
    @angelahatzimihalis7103 3 години тому +49

    Carley is manipulatively...trying to appear mentally ill...she is desperately trying to avoid jailtime...telling doctors what they need to hear...she knows exactly what she's doing..and really believes she'll get away with the murder...

    • @irishgal353
      @irishgal353 2 години тому +5

      You are so right!

    • @stardustboy94
      @stardustboy94 2 години тому

      Exactly.She a psychopath incapable of being empathetic & therapy or anti-depressant pills can‘t fix her.

    • @annebosworth7048
      @annebosworth7048 Годину тому +3

      Agree

  • @Mancada100
    @Mancada100 2 години тому +45

    Well, my Grandma is not a psychiatrist, psycologist, lawyer, whatever. She doesn't hold a college degree on anything. She barely ended High School. But she says Carly is a freaking bad seed who would even scare the devil.
    What Gradma says, goes.

    • @marktopping8090
      @marktopping8090 Годину тому +1

      Lol

    • @desiderata333
      @desiderata333 Годину тому +2

      I see it too. I am with your wise grandma and you!!!

    • @annebosworth7048
      @annebosworth7048 Годину тому +2

      Grandma is right lol

    • @A2G999
      @A2G999 32 хвилини тому +1

      ❤❤❤❤❤

    • @seltonk5136
      @seltonk5136 31 хвилина тому

      I say she's adorable, you and your grandmother should mind your own business, and that this qt pie should be freed this instant

  • @wisecat11
    @wisecat11 Годину тому +10

    She shot her mom in cold blood. Nothing to do with being bipolar. Everything to do with being a murderer.

  • @Human4Peace
    @Human4Peace 3 години тому +28

    You know who else took a lot of notes during her trial? Jodi Arias. Brutally murdered her ex bf

  • @betcpa78
    @betcpa78 3 години тому +44

    Bipolar disorder or not, she’s culpable for her actions.

    • @elainewallace3381
      @elainewallace3381 2 години тому

      Have you got bipolar disorder?

    • @PAMELAPORTER-ci7mr
      @PAMELAPORTER-ci7mr 2 години тому +5

      Those patients are much more inclined to hurt themselves than someone else.

    • @seltonk5136
      @seltonk5136 30 хвилин тому

      Her actions are being adorable. Consider that as well

  • @GigglingHamster
    @GigglingHamster 3 години тому +25

    She was totally coached

  • @lisak9419
    @lisak9419 2 години тому +17

    Wait….before she killed her mother I thought she told someone else she had never heard voices…..now she does?

    • @seltonk5136
      @seltonk5136 28 хвилин тому +1

      Crazy people don't have consistent answers.
      Either way she's adorable

  • @terrymoore565
    @terrymoore565 3 години тому +35

    Her father's condition has zero to do with her actions, period...boy what a stretch

    • @robbinjuliano9014
      @robbinjuliano9014 2 години тому +1

      I was wondering where you got your degree. You are harsh!

    • @mikegoldstein7112
      @mikegoldstein7112 2 години тому +1

      Wrong

    • @PAMELAPORTER-ci7mr
      @PAMELAPORTER-ci7mr 2 години тому

      No stretch as it's hereditery, a brain chemical imbalance.

    • @annebosworth7048
      @annebosworth7048 Годину тому

      ​@@robbinjuliano9014I don't need a degree just look at the video u will see the true Carly..

    • @JB-bl6qo
      @JB-bl6qo 21 хвилина тому +1

      Exactly

  • @tonilharmon
    @tonilharmon 3 години тому +31

    Sounds like her attorney coached her with her answers to the Dr.

  • @imcopper
    @imcopper 3 години тому +11

    That girls thoughts became her actions, she may have excelled in school, but her smarts proved she had evil thoughts that became her actions.

  • @adamskinner-fu4vb
    @adamskinner-fu4vb 3 години тому +31

    Watch the videos of the incident. She was calm cool and collected the entire time, until stepdad got home then OMG freak out! This girl knew exactly what she was doing. She has a mental illness, but not to the extent that she was manic or out of control. She gonna have a long time to think about what she has done. Guilty

    • @NilDreams
      @NilDreams 2 години тому +6

      And she was totally calm when she got arrested.

    • @custardgirl
      @custardgirl Годину тому +4

      I agree and she even had the presence of mind to hide the gun from the cameras!

    • @seltonk5136
      @seltonk5136 29 хвилин тому

      It's none of our business

  • @lilyandfriends348
    @lilyandfriends348 2 години тому +10

    This young girl should be kept under strict look over..dont let her be in open..no matter what she does to show innocent pls dont believe her..

  • @justpassingthrough7437
    @justpassingthrough7437 2 години тому +11

    Here comes the parade of excuses....

  • @terrymoore565
    @terrymoore565 3 години тому +23

    The kid is a amazing full blown narcissist , period

    • @seltonk5136
      @seltonk5136 26 хвилин тому

      Wow sounds like 90% of people under 30. Yawn

  • @susandevine4356
    @susandevine4356 Годину тому +20

    Bipolar does not make you a murderer

  • @liann3881
    @liann3881 3 години тому +12

    Her hormones (Carly) were just emerging and maturing. Usually mental illness doesn’t full differentiate until young adulthood (~20 years old). So Carly is just evil. imo

    • @namastea
      @namastea 3 години тому +2

      Psychopathy starts at birth, so yes she is just evil

  • @GigglingHamster
    @GigglingHamster 3 години тому +31

    She’s not insane shes just a selfish spoiled brat who didn’t want to follow her mother’s rules about not smoking weed.

    • @susanlewis9351
      @susanlewis9351 3 години тому +7

      My thoughts exactly.

    • @annebosworth7048
      @annebosworth7048 Годину тому

      Totally agree

    • @sandyflowers9201
      @sandyflowers9201 17 хвилин тому

      She has no idea what is to live without a mother. Her life is going to be very bad with no direction or motive to live. She is lost case

  • @NilDreams
    @NilDreams 2 години тому +16

    She’s a very smart girl and she’s definitely a manipulator. Very soon she’ll start accusing her father of SA

    • @user-vs8et8gk5s
      @user-vs8et8gk5s Годину тому

      💯

    • @KL-ou9jj
      @KL-ou9jj Годину тому +1

      Yes remember she was very smart … valedictorian 😮

    • @NilDreams
      @NilDreams 41 хвилина тому +1

      @@KL-ou9jj well she’s also a liar. That turned out to not be true.

    • @amandao266
      @amandao266 40 хвилин тому

      Actually they said she said she was Valedictorian but actually wasn't. She's a liar. ​@@KL-ou9jj

    • @KL-ou9jj
      @KL-ou9jj 37 хвилин тому

      @@NilDreams yes agreed! I was being facetious.

  • @RighAlban
    @RighAlban 2 години тому +8

    So everything before, she was normal, but since she's been in prison and been coached she not well, got it.

  • @Kimmy234L
    @Kimmy234L 4 години тому +27

    Oh dear, her attorney was asking Carly quite a few questions in this evaluation, she even used the word disassociated when describing to the psychiatrist how Carly felt about being in jail...Carly didn't say/use that word herself.
    It sounds like the evaluation could be interpreted as being coached by the attorney. They're skirting around this, but it most certainly is being portrayed that way.
    But with all three professionals, Carly never presented herself as being Manic, and again, her claims about hearing voices as a toddler was just another ploy to get out of jail...
    Defence hasn't got any evidence to use the insanity clause.

    • @californiadreamer2580
      @californiadreamer2580 3 години тому +6

      Correct. Having imaginary friends that one " hears" and converses with as a toddler isn't even in the same realm as a psychiatric disorder. It's a fairly common event in the context of normal child development.

  • @BruceLee-t9n
    @BruceLee-t9n 2 години тому +12

    Imagine giving birth to your own Killer

    • @seltonk5136
      @seltonk5136 22 хвилини тому +1

      Imagine giving birth to the person you still have to take care of when they are 40.
      That would be the perspective of anyone who has given birth to a millennial or gen z

    • @sandyflowers9201
      @sandyflowers9201 16 хвилин тому +1

      That's crazy.

  • @mikegoldstein7112
    @mikegoldstein7112 2 години тому +6

    The kid looks like a psychopath

    • @songbirds3712
      @songbirds3712 23 хвилини тому

      What does a psychopath look like, exactly?

  • @BruceLee-t9n
    @BruceLee-t9n 2 години тому +6

    She's More Frightening Than Leatherface

  • @beepbopboop7727
    @beepbopboop7727 2 години тому +5

    Her outfits just keep getting worse. Whats with the mesh?

  • @claudianeymour63
    @claudianeymour63 2 години тому +4

    Shes not mental shes evil your saying she is sick she will start something and not finish it didnt she finish her mother

  • @buzzardclementine4451
    @buzzardclementine4451 3 години тому +11

    STOP PUTTING CHILDREN ON SSRI's

    • @m.g.2645
      @m.g.2645 2 години тому

      😉👏🎯⚖️

  • @JSKZG
    @JSKZG Годину тому +2

    BS..... I'm tired of everything being blamed on bi-polar disorder. My daughter is bi-polar. She's never murdered anyone. Also, people that do not have bi-polar have murdered.....so there's that.

  • @joanntumbleson4169
    @joanntumbleson4169 4 години тому +15

    Carly drove me nuts when she was drinking her pop, like she was trying to be cool.

  • @VickiRiley-jx5zp
    @VickiRiley-jx5zp 2 години тому +3

    I haven't had a chance to follow the whole trial, but I was wondering who the friend is that she showed her mom to?

  • @michaeltaylor8835
    @michaeltaylor8835 2 години тому +2

    Bi Polar is also called manic depressive

  • @susanlewis9351
    @susanlewis9351 3 години тому +9

    Everyone has bipolar nowadays

  • @energeticremedies
    @energeticremedies Годину тому

    They need to hold the pharma and doctor responsible too,those meds come with a very strong warning 😢

  • @janineruffo7460
    @janineruffo7460 Годину тому +2

    Is she wearing her mother’s clothes? That dress does not look it belongs on someone on her age. I’ve noticed other dresses she has had on that looked the same.

  • @lauriemcdonough9093
    @lauriemcdonough9093 42 хвилини тому

    Nor is the doctor up to snuff on her past interactions with the defendant.

  • @happyhands117
    @happyhands117 22 хвилини тому

    She didn't space out when she killed her mother. She went back to ensure her mother was definitely dead. The video footage of it is very disturbing.

  • @happyhands117
    @happyhands117 17 хвилин тому

    Uh? She said she heard a male voice? That's changed since a previous piece of footage showing a psychiatric nurse explaining that she had asked the same question, but her answer was that she didn't and doesn't hear voices. I feel that she knew exactly what she was doing when she murdered her mother. This is awful. She is very dangerous.

  • @zeballos5757
    @zeballos5757 3 години тому +10

    Every comment section I read on these courts clips, people are going on about how evil she is. Well that may be, but unless she was born this way, then something happened in that home to facilitate this, and if it wasn’t that, then she’s obviously got a serious mental illness and should be sentenced based on that. Let’s not forget that her parents knew she had problems, but yet left a loaded gun for her to have access too.

    • @m.g.2645
      @m.g.2645 2 години тому

      😉👏🎯⚖️

    • @seantimmons5900
      @seantimmons5900 2 години тому

      Two things. One, your unless is a complete possibility. Two, parents are not the only influences in anyone's life. Three, it sure looks like the mother got her punishment for leaving the gun available, huh?

    • @zeballos5757
      @zeballos5757 Годину тому

      @@seantimmons5900 I suppose she could have used a knife, but a gun is much less work. There were times when I was growing up, that my parents really ticked me off to the point I would feel extreme anger. You hear troubled teenagers tell their parents I wish you were dead. They probably think they mean it at the time, but most of them get over it. I guess having a loaded gun handy just makes it that much easier to carry that impulse out.

  • @alaynasanchez5571
    @alaynasanchez5571 51 хвилина тому

    She knew exactly what she was doing.

  • @songbirds3712
    @songbirds3712 44 хвилини тому

    This shrink is horrible!!

  • @itsmecommenting4283
    @itsmecommenting4283 2 години тому +1

    Um, why is the lady reading a script?

    • @songbirds3712
      @songbirds3712 20 хвилин тому

      The doctor? Those are the notes she takes while talking with Carly.

  • @alaynasanchez5571
    @alaynasanchez5571 52 хвилини тому

    When someone kills /Murdered a person why do they have to use Mental health issues as an excuse ?

  • @alaynasanchez5571
    @alaynasanchez5571 33 хвилини тому

    Tryna avoid prison time

  • @Burnside100
    @Burnside100 2 години тому +1

    Wish they would get Doctor Shannen Curry.......

  • @lauriemcdonough9093
    @lauriemcdonough9093 36 хвилин тому

    Mania - Poor impulse control, irritation, agitation, grandiose ideas, delusional, illogical thinking, sometime hallucinations could have easily been included when explained by this doctor.

  • @ld-zj1bn
    @ld-zj1bn 14 хвилин тому

    The attorneys are dressing Carly in clothes that belong on an 8 year old in the 1950s. Also the hair style.
    Except the see through sleeves today look like she's playing dress ups in Grandma's old clothes.

  • @laurenhw1988
    @laurenhw1988 Годину тому

    She is just babbling with poor explanations. The other Dr was much more coherent and credible

  • @seltonk5136
    @seltonk5136 33 хвилини тому

    QT Pie on trail

    • @seltonk5136
      @seltonk5136 32 хвилини тому

      TRIAL .
      Free her this instant

  • @braxtonmills1235
    @braxtonmills1235 22 хвилини тому

    FREE CARLY

  • @marktopping8090
    @marktopping8090 Годину тому

    Oh well shes obviously going to prison for sure. i don't think we have a question about that but for how long ie the question shes only 15 rn 14 when she blew her mom face away

  • @robbinjuliano9014
    @robbinjuliano9014 2 години тому +1

    Remember at the time she was 14, a month or so away from 15 not fully cooked. What I mean is she’s far from being an adult!

  • @WattsTheTruth2018
    @WattsTheTruth2018 Годину тому

    So many UA-cam psychologists here!

  • @sandyflowers9201
    @sandyflowers9201 17 хвилин тому

    She/He

  • @brendahiggins355
    @brendahiggins355 2 години тому

    Was she on drugs

    • @Elo-hv3fw
      @Elo-hv3fw Годину тому

      Are you on drugs ?

  • @EmperorOfMan
    @EmperorOfMan 2 години тому

    Mom running her house like a prison caused this.

  • @elainewallace3381
    @elainewallace3381 2 години тому

    Ive read quite a lot off comments on here there must a lot off people out there that think they are psychologists.Some off these comments are ridiculous if they are not coming from professionals .

  • @Boyhead1973
    @Boyhead1973 4 години тому +3

    This part -- 7:25 - 8:00...very interesting. As far as hearing the voice -- let's see where that goes.