Sri Sri Ravi Shankar's Errors and Logical Fallacies [RE-UPLOAD]
Вставка
- Опубліковано 12 лип 2024
- A reaction to Sri Sri Ravi Shankar’s recent video on science in ancient Indian scriptures. My response analyses the errors and logical fallacies in his response to scientists and their questions.
One-time donation:
UPI: scienceisdope@icici
buymeacoffee.com/scienceisdope
Community:
UA-cam Membership: / @scienceisdope
Patreon: / scienceisdope_
Discord: / discord
Chapters:
00:00 - Why am I reuploading?
00:59 - Actual Video Starts
02:51 - Schrodinger’s Quote
04:29 - Age of the Universe
07:45 - Newton’s Laws vs. Kanad Samhita
10:16 - Concept of Zero
11:41 - Does Matter Exist?
14:17 - Where did the Universe Begin?
15:18 - Dark Matter and Dark Energy
16:17 - Time Dilation
17:54 - Science in this Country
#SriSri
#Ravishankar
Original video on the Sri Sri Channel - • What is God? | Scienti...
Music Credits:
Things are going Southampton - Verified Picasso
Follow me on social media:
Instagram: / scienceisdope_
Twitter: / scienceisdope_
UA-cam: / scienceisdope
"You can literally find anything in scriptures but the only drawback is that you have to wait for Modern Science to discover it"
~Pranav Bhaia
Literally this statement hit my brain when I realized how people were claiming about corona virus being mentioned in their holy books.
💀
Hindsight bias in a nutshell 😂
When did this happen, I didn't know?
Us bhai us ❤️🥹
😂😂😂😂😂💯👍
Your channel is what I needed on UA-cam. Whenever I got into an argument with my folks on the topics of religion. They would use a fallacy to discredit my points or say they are in the scriptures. Since did not have the info about tye scriptures to argue. I couldn't say anything. Thanks for the info
I agree
Drub c h @tee promotes I ssl@mi lie in his Bangalore video , so he can't be trusted , he's a conman
Why you need to know scriptures? Ask them to open and show it to you. You will easily see (that if they find it cause most of the time they are simply repeating claims from whatsapp university) how it has been (mis)interpreted to fit into the knowledge today 🤣🤣🤣
Don't argue against scriptures using same scripture. Use logic and reason to argue.
If you want more chanal like this go for
1 Rationality Rules
2 Holy Coolaid
3 G M Skeptic
why are they so few youtubers against so many uneducated people promoting pseudoscience. but the youth needs more people like you to develop rational thinking and questioning. Great job
Being a physics undergrad, I really would like to see these "professors" educational qualifications. People like them shouldn't be part of our scientific community, looking for validation, justifying some sort of superiority over the west.
+@ArchEdits
I watched the original video fully.
It was very bizzare (and deeply disappointing) to watch the professors and "scientists" who were asking questions in the original video with Ravi Shankar-their sheer fawning attitude towards him is cringeworthy.
Respect is one thing, but their approach appears to be almost unbridled hero-worshipping adulation.
If THESE are the persons who are at the cutting edge of sceptical scientific enquiry in India, and if this is really the unquestioning servitude that they have towards a supposedly enlightened religious preacher-a Hindu preacher in this case-then the research done in institutions in India is likely to have very little hope of making any significant contribution to the field of science.
I shudder to think of the plight of any student or researcher working under these professors, who dares to be rational in his/her approach towards religion.
That being said, I suspect that there might be some politics involved. Given the mindset of the ruling dispensation in the central government of India at the time of the original video-apparently 30-Oct-2021-I cannot help but wonder whether at least some of the professors and scientists were somehow "coerced" into playing their respective roles in the above-said video.
@@ex.hindu.now.atheist I was feeling the same thank you for describing it in word
+@@justalazyguy.0_0
Sure thing! You are welcome.
@@ex.hindu.now.atheist who said they are professors? If I tell you I'm a scientist would you believe? I don't think you will.
they are just devotees of that saint. or just paid people he hired.
+@@galaxy1234
About your comment: "who said they are [...] people he hired."
*Please see the original video of Double Sri and the persons who ask him questions.*
The video clearly gives the names of those persons, the positions that they hold in their respective institutions/organisations, and the designations of those persons
They are PhD students, and professors from places like
the Indian Institute of Astrophysics in Bengaluru
the Indian Institute of Science in Bengaluru,
the Indian Institute of Technology in Delhi
the Indian Institute of Technology in Patna
the All India Institute of Medical Sciences in Rishikesh
the Indian Institute of Science Education in Berhampur, etc etc
*I am NOT supporting Double Sri.* I too strongly feel that there is some politics involved in this becuase, of the nature of the mutually beneficial relationship between Double Sri and the Shah-Modi BJP's Central government of India.
Those institutes are funded by the central government. So I will not be surprised if those persons were somehow compelled to behave in such a way with Double Sri.
It's so great to see your channel growing on this scale. Congratulations 🎉 Always eagerly waiting for your new uploads .
Thank you!
Is Dhruv the guy who describes himself as an atheist who recognises only two gods who would burn him (dead or alive)?
+@@scienceisdope
It was very disappointing to watch the professors and "scientists" who were asking questions in the original video with Ravi Shankar -- their sheer fawning attitude is cringeworthy. Respect is one thing, but their approach appears to be almost unbridled hero-worshipping adulation.
If THESE are the intellectuals who are at the cutting edge of sceptical scientific enquiry in India, and if this is really the unquestioning servitude that they have towards a supposedly enlightened (Hindu) religious preacher, then the research done in institutions in India is likely to have very little hope of making any significant contribution to the field of science.
I shudder to think of the plight of any student or researcher under these professors, who dares to be rational in his/her approach towards religion.
At the same time, given the mindset of the current ruling dispensation of the central government of India at the time of this comment -- i.e., in January 2022, with the said video apparently having been uploaded about 2 months earlier -- I cannot help but wonder whether at least some of the professors and scientists were somehow "coerced" into playing their respective roles in the video.
Your channel has changed my mindset towards my religion, alternative medicine and way to think! I hope i'm becoming rational now! Thank you for this content/eye-openers !
I'm just as happy as you are!
Krishna hrithik you right, he forces us to think...thinkers are good for the future
@@jahankamath6187 think logically*
+@@justalazyguy.0_0
One of the problems is that almost all the time, children are taught _what_ to think, and not _how_ to think.
Good for you. The main purpose of religion should be to encourage introspection so that we can be more aware about our mind and how it behaves and eventually it can calm down from constantly chattering and we can be silent.
But unfortunately today almost all the religions just spread pseudoscience, superstitions and dogmas. And some go on to explain the world and its laws which is totally stupid because nothing about the world is revealed in introspection. It only gives an insight about our own mind which is enough. There is no need for religion to interfere with science in any way and it should not.
You're a treasure for scientific community in india love your work
❤. Obviously
9:40 I disagree on this point. The politics has a huge amount of influence of science, since scientific knowledge requires funding in order to be able to discover or invent. That is why golden ages of different empires never coincided. We would have never gained so much scientific knowledge had Europe's middle age feudalism had stayed in place rather than being supplanted by enlightenment values.
I was going to comment this. Glad to see someone already did. As an example, the Islamic golden age declined because of the adoption of more extreme theological views by the contemporary scholars which discouraged enquiries into science and mathematics.
@@danyalshamsi1161 That is a very simple Explanation reality is much more complex probably the biggest reason of end of Islamic golden age was Mongol attacks They unfortunately destroyed the Full library of House of wisdom
+@AYAN DAS
I agree with you; those who control the money needed for funding research can greatly influence the neutrality of even dispassionate researchers.
I watched the original video fully.
It was very bizzare (and deeply disappointing) to watch the professors and "scientists" who were asking questions in the original video with Ravi Shankar-their sheer fawning attitude towards him is cringeworthy.
Respect is alright; BUT their approach appeared to be almost unbridled hero-worshipping adulation.
I think I would not be surprised if there was some politics involved in the production of the original video.
Given the mindset of the ruling dispensation in the central government of India at the time of the original video-apparently 30-Oct-2021-I cannot help but wonder whether at least some of the professors and scientists were somehow "coerced" into playing their respective roles in the above-said video.
So proud of Dhruv, your channel not growing exponentially would be crime that all humans together commit! Can you provide link to his post? I can't happen to find it!!
It was an Instagram story ... It's gone now
@@scienceisdope Ahh! Got it, thank you 👍
Also tell dhruv rathi to make such videos on muslims fraud Babas... We needed it😊
@@dikshajain6936 if he wants to, he would. He doesn't need your suggestion for it. Better yet, make it yourself!
Chapters:
00:00 - Why am I reuploading?
00:59 - Actual Video Starts
02:51 - Schrodinger’s Quote
04:29 - Age of the Universe
07:45 - Newton’s Laws vs. Kanad Samhita
10:16 - Concept of Zero
11:41 - Does Matter Exist?
14:17 - Where did the Universe Begin?
15:18 - Dark Matter and Dark Energy
16:17 - Time Dilation
17:54 - Science in this Country
Bhai want to know your views on Aryan invasion...its a myth or reality
EXPOSE ACHARYA PRASHANTH PLEASE HE IS FROM INDIA
@@exmuhammadsheikhofficials3447 indeed a shitty man
Hats off to your perseverance and constant endeavor for separating false from truth!!.. You don't give up
The only thing why I appreciate philosophy part of vedas is cuz of nāsadīya Sūkta part where they say they might be wrong or they donno what exactly is the origin of universe. This acceptance of ignorance is quite appreciatable.
Also science explains everything which is material, spirituality or indian philosophy explains about the inner thing, more about the mind, feelings, main are upanishads and vedas and then come other scriptures such as gita, etc - acharya prashant, that's why meditation and yoga developed from india
@@Ashish-ss5nt yoga is pseudoscience. Meditation is scam
Was waiting for this re-upload, Thank you. Lot of ancient dust accumulated in the minds here and we need people like you!!
Drub c h @tee promotes I ssl@mi lie in his Bangalore video , so he can't be trusted , he's a conman
Planning for Iisc banglore hope I will get admission🤞
Science is really 🤟🏻
+@JEE 2022
I hope you do not end up under the tutelage of some of the fawning professors of IISc seen in the original video.
This channel is some rationality and sense in the sea of stupidity. Keep up the good work!!
+@Vamsi Krishna
NEVER dismiss the peddlers of pseudoscience and their followers as being "stupid". If anything, they are shrewd and cunning.
NEVER underestimate the strengths of those whom you are trying to counter.
ravi shanker: this is an avengers level threat.
lol
Exactly, this UA-camr gets as dumb as you can get. He is just flying in his own makeshift world telling others what is rational.
Ravi Shankar runs a huge marketing company, who whitewashes irrrational people with these logical fallacies, appoints them as marketing executives which are mostly from elite class (very useful for their money) to fool average people. Most of these marketing people are from top institutes (I am from a top engineering institute in india and have known examples of this), doctors, well known personalities, NRIs, etc. as they work perfectly as educated brand ambassadors to promote their brand and fool average people.
Spirituality is a delusional, self-aggrandizing and supremacist promotion of the ego a self-centered man !
While science never compares 'good' and 'bad' about natural phenomena, the business of spirituality draws
its every breath by seeking out meaningless comparisons to inflate the low self-esteem of its blind followers ! 🙏
Before judging others first know them properly
You are saying right, but the techniques & concepts he teaches through the courses are very good and useful. To propogate it, it definitely need a structure and cash flow. I never think making money using these so called spriritual things is a taboo. Any body can make money even monks also. Who set the rules that the monks and sanyasis should not make money? In best of my knowledge there is no rules for monks and sanyasis, if they want they can. The sanyasis concept is should not have attachment or detachment, its is very much controllable for a monk or sanyasi.
Dude have you worked with naxalites prisoners etc...do something before you spew venom
Chi Chi is selling invisible goods! Simple as it is.
I'm falling in love with science when I get to see professors like you 💕 love from Pakistan
Just discovered your channel, glad to find one promoting rationality and healthy skepticism in an Indian context. One video Id like you to make is about "animal telepathic communication", where apparently experts telepathically communicate with your pets (or even random animals) to understand their needs/wants/desires. This has surprisingly flown under the radar, and even otherwise rational folks in my circle are completely unquestioning about this practice which doesn't have any scientific merit or evidence (ancedotes don't count).
Dude same dp
@@Bhatakti_Hawas dude is your name sarcastic?
@@swagatochatterjee7104 why? Are theists not allowed here?
Drub c h @tee promotes I ssl@mi lie in his Bangalore video , so he can't be trusted , he's a conman
Intresting
Sir your videos are an eye opener for several people and harsh truth for the people who blindly follow such people. You have my respect sir
Visited the channel for the first time ..Was just going through your playlist... each video topic is just what i had wished for... all these nutcases have been increasingly affecting minds with their new age stupidity and fuelling superstitions in all those half baked ill programmed minds of some millenials who have been educated by our flawed, employment centric and sanskar-oriented education system which is based on an unquestioning obedience and docility to even stupider "guru"... thank you for taking effort to do this great work... i am sure you will face huge opposition, trolling in future from many of zombied minds... but may you get all the strength to keep up the hugely important work.... Would like to dedicate George Orwell's words to your work... "In the time of universal deceit, speaking the truth is a revolutionary act!"
well said
Pranav, Your last section about the state of science education in our country is very accurate. I went to an IIT, and on two different occasions a friend has said "We've passed JEE now, why are you reading about science?"
which iit bruh?? im a jee aspirant, going to iit in 20223
See this ASAP. Before this gets taken down by those losers
Just started watching Your videos, they are well researched,
i'm subscribed, hoping for more great videos in future
You deserve so much more viewership. Love the content and the style 👌
Yes, unfortunately this is not a religious channel 😀
We are with you..on Science...🙌
Thank you, Pranav! The country and the world need more rational people like you. Keep up the great work!
Kudos to all your efforts - and for Keeping things so moderate, simple, and crisp. Yes, all cultures had great intellectual geniuses but some or the other way dumb too - it should never be for cultural superiority. We want to learn about the world as it is and not as we want it to be! Nailed it - a pure self-serving bias that needs to be addressed at the high school level. Unfortunately - no one is addressing about it and even some of educated people do not have any idea about self-serving bias, hindsight biases, and cognitive biases. Science is just for jobs and to get salaries - that is one of our great limitations as a society - Science for salaries and spirituality for passion!
Drub c h @tee promotes I ssl@mi lie in his Bangalore video , so he can't be trusted , he's a conman
@@allahlesboslu2_9 spammer
+@Kiran Maddu
It was very disappointing to watch the professors and "scientists" who were asking questions in the original video with Ravi Shankar-their sheer fawning attitude is cringeworthy.
Respect is one thing, but their approach appears to be almost unbridled hero-worshipping adulation.
If THESE are the intellectuals who are at the cutting edge of sceptical scientific enquiry in India, and if this is really the unquestioning servitude that they have towards a supposedly enlightened (Hindu) religious preacher, then the research done in institutions in India is likely to have very little hope of making any significant contribution to the field of science.
I shudder to think of the plight of any student or researcher working under these professors, who dares to be rational in his/her approach towards religion.
That being said, given the mindset of the current ruling dispensation in the central government of India at the time of this comment-i.e., in January 2022, with the said video apparently having been uploaded about 2 months ago -I cannot help but wonder whether at least some of the professors and scientists were somehow "coerced" into playing their respective roles in the above-said video.
@@ex.hindu.now.atheist great concern and time is the only answer for it. lets wish best for the society
@@kiranmaddu8006
Unfortunately, time is not the only answer for the dreadful spread of pseudoscience.
It has to be exposed and opposed tooth and nail.
"You can literally find anything in scriptures but the only drawback is that you have to wait for Modern science to discover it"
That was awesome.
A valid point bro.
If it’s already written, why wait till science discovers it.?
To claim that we had it years ago and saying science is fool😭
That's what Indians always do. try to take credit for someone's lifetime of work and dedication. the funny thing is it only makes them look stupid.
Schrodinger was not only interested in Ancient India. He also did a series of lectures on ancient Greeks. The book is Available on Amazon.
Neils Bohr Personal insignia was inspired by ancient Chinese Yin Yang.
Leibniz was a self-proclaimed Sinophile.
But hey every other civilisation other than Hindu is unscientific 😂
It's not Hinduism bro... this Ravi Shankar guy isn't representing Hindus
@@shashidharhegde1193 nor does Hinduism represents science... And vice versa... It's just a religion ...
@@jackyjack9660 right! Science is about external universe but Vedanta is about inwards. Most of These modern age Gurus do not know Vedanta however they pretend they know it's funny when the use words like "KARMA" , "BRAMHAN" , "AATMA" "QUANTUM " etc when they do not know a thing about them.
@@shashidharhegde1193 vedanta is philosophy which revolves around the concept of a creator... Science still doesn't use anything such as a creator...
I read vedanta and it's about God who is supreme... A creator who created world from nothing... The nature being female part of the supreme being...
It's childish here... I really like how J krishnamurthi questions this and no one has a good answer...
Karma concept is vague... Their is no one to give you a something based on your good and bad deeds...
I like karma of Buddhism... It's just action and reaction... If you throw a stone in pond it will create ripples ...
@@jackyjack9660 Wait what? Vedanta doesn't talk about that lol. You are talking about Prakrati and Purusha concept. That's not Vedanta. Vedanta is about "Prastanatraya" and "DashaUpanishads" please watch Acharya Prashant on UA-cam (one of the only Real Vedantist on UA-cam ) to know the real Vedanta.
"When country was facing so many challenges, science takes a backseat"
On the contrary, necessity is the mother of invention and I feel that these are the times when science actually takes the front seat in order to solve these problems.
Thank you for your videos and helping people develop the scientific temperament that is currently lacking so much in our society.
Wow
@@pradyumn2692 True
Yes invention does happen when people face challenges, but not when there is nothing to eat right
@@DevanshGuptaChess when there is nothing to eat we initiated Green revolution, white revolution and many other things
@@stanlee4029 green revolution happened when we were a free country and our leaders and other prominent people had the Power to apply their mind to find a solution.
The logic made here is very oblivious and ignorant.
Would you blame the powerless(politically), under privileged, starving people of bengal to not have invented a solution for the man made famine caused by the oppressing British?
You forgot to mention Ravi bhais new discovery , Astralay (Australian) during mahabharat times .. 🤣
No I didn't forget. I purposely avoided it. It was such a low hanging fruit that I see no point talking about it. Especially since so many others have
Just loved ur video . Don't worry upload as many times as u want we will always support u
Thank you!
Also, please have an online conversation/podcast with Prakhar ke Pravachan, it would be a really interesting one. He has also criticised Sadhguru's, Ranveer's ideas and has talked with Acharya Prashant and the Chanakya ambassador(forgot his name) so would be a very interesting talk to listen.
@Akash Rahil I don't currently have the time to constructively disagree so I'll just say that nothing wrong would happen from one conversation. You probably haven't watched PG Radio or his conversation with Acharya Prashant where he is not the one talking.
Great debunk sir ❤️❤️❤️❤️
You do great work and deserve all support
Thank you :)
Yesterday I found one of your video and really I was looking for something like this on UA-cam.... I am an IIT Graduate and a data scientist... So much scam is going on in the name of religion and spirituality... Keep doing great 😃
keep doing the good work.lots of support
Please Keep uploading videos like these
So satisfying ✨
We have more gems like Rajeev Malhotra,Nityananda and Deepak Chopra.
Lol watch my video on Godmen ua-cam.com/video/KmNZUZzAWHA/v-deo.html
@@scienceisdope Thanks.👍🙏
@@senpaixd1346 you have to talk some or little sense . And also some sense can pop out even involuntarily.😎
Sadguru and Deepak Chopra .
ua-cam.com/video/U8Xno7XNboY/v-deo.html
Spirituality is a delusional, self-aggrandizing and supremacist promotion of the ego a self-centered man !
While science never compares 'good' and 'bad' about natural phenomena, the business of spirituality draws
its every breath by seeking out meaningless comparisons to inflate the low self-esteem of its blind followers ! 🙏
What happened to the first re-upload?
Added embedded subtitles by mistake :(
Great content.
Love your delivery.
Loved your point of view.
Same sir I am also from Dhruv rathee but I am so amazed you from 1k have so much high quality research and quality.So sad why aren’t you growing in millions appreciate it sir.I am daily binge watching all the vids from the videos also.Rohan Cariappa who also reacted to your video on his second channel “not funny Rohan” where he appreciated your work and said you video are chill and enlighting.
Your videos are really good and have really great points, I really want India to be more scientific, you are really doing a great job in that
The last thing u mentioned is exactly the case with me. Luv ur channel bro....❤️
Absolutely love what you're doing with this channel! More power to you!
On the point of equating matter with vibrations, I think they're talking about matter essentially being energy, which is accepted by the scientific community (QFT et al). Of course, it's still quite evident they're trying to stretch and conflate and use hindsight bias to prove a point.
I still don't get why this bloke has an extra Sri? Does one Sri cancel the other Sri out? is he playing games with us?
First watch full video
Firstly I want to say thank you bcz u r doing great job ur video I saw in recommendation back 2-3 day n dam ur points are so valid infact I also think same thing while watching many so called famous youtuber same question as I have read 11-12 from science stream n I thought kya yrrr mera pdhai bekar tha kya ?? Infact I am follower of Krishna bcz I alwz think that there is a power beyond science....I don't know whether it's fictional or what but I believe in every situation I feel so postive...the knowledge of him ..but. That doesn't mean ki western sb bekar h ..no kuch drawback vha bhi h kuch apne me bhi h. .. without any proof all say ye tha tha ...n our young generation is so active on UA-cam what mindset we are giving+ due to corona increase in time of UA-cam we all know....ek bcha ke samne itna confidence se bolo to sch hi manega...u r doing just fab for young generation.
Thankyou for educating us❤️🙏
I'm so glad I found and joined, this channel.
From religion comes a man's purpose; from science, his power to achieve it. Sometimes people ask if religion and science are not opposed to one another. They are: in the sense that the thumb and fingers of my hands are opposed to one another. It is an opposition by means of which anything can be grasped.
- Sir William Bragg
What you are doing is dope. You are a hero man. Love you.
You are doing a great job by calling this people out. Keep up the good work.
I would love to witness your growth all the way up 🤩🤩🤩 keep going
It is sad that the people who do not have scientific temper themselves are lamenting on the lack of scientific temper in the country.
Well that's how this country is.
Ok man, this is a really good channel, I'll give it to you! I usually watch a couple of videos to really understand and trust a creator (especially on these topics, because if you turned out to be another pseudoscience channel, I eould have had it) and I can confidently say that this is an amazing channel and wish more young people watched it instead of idiots like beer biceps
beer biceps is gae in closet.. chakka
+@Raunak Shahi
BeerBiceps is not an idiot. He is very shrewd when it comes to self-aggrandisement. He tells people the bizzare things that they like to hear, and laughs his way to the bank with estimated monthly earnings of at least USD 1,600 per month.
@@ex.hindu.now.atheist He's a millionaire, he's making wayyyyy more than $1,600 a month.
excellent criticism of sri sri.
I fully appreciate how much detail u put in your criticism of ravi shankar's statements, without ever attacking him personally. U are a very mature critic & I find a lot of so called "rationalists" dont have your maturity. The only thing we cannot be sure of is : how much of an impact the invaders had on wiping out our scientific knowledge. Its very difficult to assess it today . it may or may not be true & i dont think ravi shankar provokes anyone towards extremism. it may just be his opinion.
The state of indian science education is well mentioned. I am one of those people who learnt & appreciated science INSPITE of my science education. seriously, almost everyone from family to teachers tried their best to destroy my passion for learning : the same way u mentioned " its just for a job, etc , what is the use of passion ? it wont get u a job etc etc. its our cultural blindspot & lot of effort is needed to change it.
Another great video bro, keep it up👍.
Love your channel 💟 Became a new member today.. hoping for great videos from your side
Because science is dope and there is a lot to explore 🤗
Stop funding this negative channel and work on yourself. You'll have a clearer face through yoga, meditation and Ayurveda.
@@professorelixir3351 what if someone doesn't?
@@horizon5549 don't care about someone, I'm telling him. 😂 if he has a good face more people will watch him so I know secretly he does yoga.
@@professorelixir3351 You are showing that how shallow you people are !!
Hey, taking mind inward does not mean only introspection. It also is an aspect of meditation.The ancient rishis have told many truth about universe due to meditation.Hence reference of going inwards helps to know of outer world.Not introspection dude. Meditation is different from introspection! Maybe u need to listen to him from space of understanding rather just picking words to point out mistake n making ur own interpretation n story in ur head.Also if u have doubts, u can definitely meet Him up n ask questions physically, He will clear all ur doubts!!
We have two kinds of people one who blindly believe another who blindly argue 🤷
"He" meaning... God? Or do you mean Sri Sri Ravishankar?
Keep up the great work. Let scientific spirit flourish.
When in one rational channel I told I am a scientist someone ridiculed me. But when I told him that I am an IIT Prof. he told me that is better. So as a mathematician I can't call myself a scientist. I guess we should surrender to religious thoughts and stop scientific education in India.
Hi Pranab, Thanks a lot for making such great videos. Your fight for reason is remarkable in this time of untruth & irrationality. Also, unlike other proponents of rational thinking, your patient and nonaggressive approach is unique and helpful in conveying the message. I am a theoretical physicist, but I can vouch that you can explain things better than professional scientists. Kudos to you!
Why he can't make on other religions religious leader becoz he doesn't have that power in his @$$🤣🤣🤣🤣
Ravi Shankar be like...hey Elon Musk , 'come here'.. leave your spacex ...i will tell you all about mars and even black hole 😂😂😂😂
Love your attitude. Knowledge is not a competition- mine superior to yours.
It is a collective effort by humanity to figure it out. I am sure the sages of that era would have said the same & respected each other. That is what wise men do.
Ignorant shallow minds try to gloat in some great achievements of human intellect of the past as if it is to their credit. While what they are doing is contrary to all wisdom. Just a compensation for their inferiority complex from their present.
Thank God, I found this channel 🙌
I'm so glad
I find you ❤️
Wouldn't it be cool if one of these Godmen found the cure for cancer, or the key to the grand unifying theory in their ancient texts, instead of always claiming credit retroactively? Despite having all of the secrets and answers, these magical texts have not once been useful for scientific advancements.
I am second division in 12 second division in engineering but never forward WhatsApp message on Covid home treatment neither believes in God, Soul or Rebirth because I still believe in science. I neither forward toxic WhatsApp message favoring any political party or ideology send by friends and relatives. Infact I have left most of such group.
I think clock in ISS runs slightly slower with respect to the clock in earth due to very high relative velocity of ISS.. not due to less gravity.
That's correct to some extent.
Love your understanding and presentation...
yes yes..... definitely i found your channel from dhruv rathee..... very grateful for finding this... nowdays I am recommending this channel to others... the only problem is that that only few of my freiends knows english up to the mark that they can understand this video..
I found your channel just 4days back and your subscriber base grew by 3.2k since then. So exciting! If you improve your upload frequency it'll help you with the algorithms and patreon both. In any case, Thanks for doing what you do!
Yay....way to go bro , science will prevail...
Thank you rohan / normies for introducing me to this great channel
Very rational arguments. Here are my thoughts, some might not fully agree with yours. The scriptures I think, follow a top down approach, simply because the derivation of that particular logic is lost in time. Take for instance the Ka ta Pa ya Di sankhya, which provides the value of pie.
I am an avid watcher of the Veritasium channel. Do watch the video - ' Math has a fa flaw'. The example for set theory, sounds eerily similar to the shanti mantra.
I think Science and humanity is rediscovering things which was already discovered or rather trying to formulate things which can be proved or observed in nature whithin the realms of physical laws. Sometimes you have to take a leap of faith to understand things which is beyond normal understanding. What looks scientific now was magical/fictional earlier. For instance planes/smart phones. Similarly what looks illogical now could have been scientific earlier. Just because we don't know how to prove something doesn't mean the thing or phenomena doesn't exist. For example the biggest miracle of nature is the anomalous behaviour of water (Density of ice being lower than water). The more you know the more it gets confusing. Try explaining quantum mechanics to a person who is not from science background, He'll find it gibberish. It all come down to perspective, how one looks at a particular idea. An open mind and analogy opens up possibilities for understanding things which might be scientifically complex but not easily relatable. Illogical analogies helps us to understand a difficult concept. Don't get hung up on the example, but try to look at the point one is trying to make.
I love science, that's what makes one open to ideas. Science is all about experimenting, that's what the ancients from different civilizations did. I think the Indian civilization was pretty advanced for its time, because even in this day and age of scientific advancements, people are trying to debate/quote/rationalise/disprove it, which itself speaks volumes of its inherent knowledge within. The point is if it were so illogical it would not have stood the test of time. Illogical concepts do not pass the test of time. There is an element of truth in every thing all we need is an eye and an open mind to see it. The concept of time dilation is also explained in the story of King Muchukand and Kalyavan (Story of Shri Krishna). The concept of multiverses is touched upon in Shri Krishna's childhood story (Destroying Bhramha's ego). The concept of self replication is explained in Rakhtbeej vs maa Durga. One finds knowledge where he wants to see it. Just like one prove or disprove anything. There is no such thing as right or wrong it all depends on perspective, level of knowledge which one holds at that point of time. Galileo was killed for saying that the earth was round, and that the solar system was Heliocentric and not Geo-centric.Another example of thing which was laughed at earlier is now common knowledge.
For safety i downloaded this video this time😂. Got frustrated when it was taken down last time
So much thanks for pranav for ur channel....I looking for content who teach science and debunk these so called pesudo science in humaric manner so people understand easily....great work da carry on
Thanks for your efforts
I came to ur channel bcoz of druve and honestly ur dope brother🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Thanks man!
@@scienceisdope keep going u deserve million 🔥
Ohh man i can't state how badly India needed a channel like yours, I'm so glad that you're here, all the best to your efforts 👍👍👍👍
I watch Dhruv too that is why I think UA-cam recommend your video and am glad it did... Like your tone and the systematic way to explain good job
😂😂😂😂 your life is melancholic i feel.
Nice work. Need of the hour
11:00 this is the exact point I wanted to make people understand... This summerizes the whole Biasness towards Ancient cultures.. They are good at their time with their small resources/ infrastructure .. but time has changed.. we have to upgrade ourselves..
Astralay become Australia 😂
Thanks for the videos! 🙏 interesting to have a counter arguement to these topic discussions.
My layman opinion: science and spirituality are both enlightening AND were interwoven for thousands of years. scientists had spiritual lives and mystical practices.
NOW there is a good reason for separation in practice. spiritual truths can open the heart and perform miracles in life, but they should not be at the expense of the scientific method. It leads to extremism and ignorance.
Excellent effort bro.. Love🙂♥️
Science is fun and flexible. It learns by its own mistakes.
1. Sri Sri Ravi Shankar is different from Sadhguru, totally different
2. He never speaks or relate science with spirituality , and the moto is always clear i.e Yoga , meditation.
3. He might have said in some talk of his discussion with some scientists who attend his program
4. But that does not mean he tried to mix science with it , his programs are genuine yoga programs any body can attend.
5. He teaches meditation and yoga n runs an NGO. without using science but people want to hear so he sometimes tells his discussion.
6. You research on what he said in some few videos but not on him much
A true gem channel 💎 which indian really need to see
@9:45 - when nation faces challenges , such as security , food , disease etc science is the only one which will jump forward and provide solutions e.g. covid
True!!!! Gurus will provide "solutions" like immunity boosters.
Three cheers to your laudable efforts to open up these intricate cultural & religious biases which even our so called scientists uphold !!
Recently I listened to Lawrence Crause’s audiobook on UA-cam “ The Universe from nothing” which clearly says what “Nothing” means in an empirical context . Worth listening/ reading this .
Really commendable that you have boldly put these issues we face especially wrt Hinduism which has fantastic and amazing ideas , thoughts, literature but everything is wrapped in superstion, fear driven superiority & meaningless banters ( as in any religion for that matter) .
Much appreciate your work ! Best wishes and lil forward to more such “revelations “.
You are great..sir science is about logical solutions not superficial solace spread by gurus like this who sell belief
Our logic is very limited when compare to universal conciousness
"if somebody knows, please let me know." you said about vibration. good. this is the attitude you should have when learning about spirit & spirituality. these are not things which come in our regular "emperical" range. we need special apparatus to see & feel these things. just like you need special glasses to see infra red.
First of all, if you paid attention to your 4th grade class you would know that sound cannot really effect you physically (well, sound can destroy your ears). You can't see vibrations, you can only feel them if they are strong enough.
Hey Pranav!
I commented a lot and in discord recently for you to address this "Age of the universe acc. to hinduism", glad to find it being addressed here.
What really does fascinates me that even being wrong by a WIDE margin from the actual age of the universe, it is more than commendable to think that people of those times were able to think at those SCALES of numbers.
No doubt it probably is just another throwaway guess, but having thought of the scale is something to think about.
What do you think is the reason for estimation?
PRANAV’S ERRORS AND LOGICAL FALLACIES:
3:42 - “Many religious folk takes it as a validation for their scripture ”: you said “anyone can read scriptures and be inspired by it but they cannot make conclusions about the empirical world from scriptures”- This statement is completely wrong because W.K Heisenberg said :- “Quantum theory will not look ridiculous to people who have read Vedanta”. Moreover in a book named “WISDOM” written by Fritjof Capra , in page 42-43 it is written that “When I asked Heisenberg about his own thoughts on Eastern philosophy , he told me to my great surprise not only that he had been well aware of the parallels between quantum physics and eastern thought , but also that his own scientific work had been influenced , at least at the subconscious level , by Indian philosophy. ”And you are talking about Carl Sagan , Carl Sagan himself said in his book “COSMOS” that “The Hindu religion is the only one of the world’s great faiths dedicated to the idea that the Cosmos itself undergoes an immense , indeed an infinite , number of deaths and rebirths. It is the only religion in which the time scales correspond to those of modern scientific cosmology . Its cycles run from our ordinary day and night to a day and night of Brahma , 8.64 billion years long. Longer than the age of the Earth or the Sun.” Not only that our scriptures are the only one also explains successfully the multiverse theory which scientists didn’t believe some years before but now they do . So as you said that you can’t make conclusions about the empirical world from scriptures is terribly wrong because as we see that not only they are inspired by the philosophy but by the scientific conclusions about the empirical world also. Here are some more examples on how magnificently our scriptures make conclusions about the empirical world :
ua-cam.com/video/goMuN6CbZpU/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/s723-3hkUjA/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/eQqJkm_q93k/v-deo.html - This last one will clear all your doubts about sharing of knowledge from Ancient India to the rest of the world because you said at 8:25 - “The reason it didn’t really catch up was because books weren’t really a thing back then , there was no printing so India’s works weren’t accessible and the works being qualitative and not quantitative” which is absolutely wrong .
This comment is really underrated. You need to bring up your own UA-cam channel to stop this anti national Dhruv and this guy. Your science is better than science is dope.
@@professorelixir3351 thanks man for your positive words , please keep making people aware about the highest truth
@@thespiritualschool111 yes will do. See these people are those who will take churan for getting constipation and will come and shit here about Ayurveda. Hypocrisy. 😂 So don't worry Satya Meva Jayate.
@@thespiritualschool111 are you a scientist?
@@khosrowanushirwan7591 No but you can say so because I am a physics honors final year student and hence I know science and scientists very closely and know their opinions as well , because what I said is their sayings not mine
too much underrated channel.. found ur channel on "not funny rohan " today and i am suprised by amunt of research u do in ur videos..thanks for the knowledge hope ur channel reach more people.. also maybe u can try making videos in hindi or put hind subtitles as most of people that belive in psedoscience and stuff are older generation and they cant understand english..
Glad to see that you re-uploaded ❤️
Nice just watching one video makes me your subscriber Good content ☺️❤️