Vocal Coach reacts to A Perfect Circle - Orestes - Stone and Echo (Maynard James Keenan)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 24 тра 2024
- 📖 Get your signed copy of my album Fable here: www.bethroars.com/shop
☀️ Pre-save my first single "Power Of The Wolf" on Spotify (it really helps me out!): distrokid.com/hyperfollow/bet...
🥁 Become a Patreon Supporter: / bethroars
Check out my second channel (Roar!) where I take on challenges: / roarrawr
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Patreon: / bethroars
Book a lesson with Beth at bethroars.as.me/
Find out about Beth at www.bethroars.com/
Beth Roars Little Roars: www.redbubble.com/people/beth...
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Vocal Coach reaction to A Perfect Circle - Orestes - Stone and Echo
Original Video: • A Perfect Circle - Ore...
I hope this video helps you understand your voice and what you can do to grow as a singer
Book a lesson with Beth at www.bethroars.com/
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Social Media
Facebook: bethroars
Twitter: @bethroars
Insta: @bethroars
Hey Everyone! I have started a new channel called "Roar!" where I take on challenges and push myself out of my comfort zone.
You can check it out here: ua-cam.com/users/roarrawr
This song was originally supposed to be sung by a woman . Billy Howerdel originally wanted a female singer for APC, but he could not say no to someone as amazing as Maynard . I wish one day to hear a woman do this song with a good recording ( maybe you could * wink * ? ) . There are so many Vocal teachers on youtube, but you're easily my favorite , because you explain every detail so great . I am learning so much from your channel , thank you . I've been a drummer most of my life, , and i've done really terrible backup vocals, but that's it .
Beth roars plz listen to the 2000 version
i know im asking randomly but does anyone know of a method to get back into an Instagram account..?
I was dumb forgot the password. I love any tips you can give me!
@Arturo Sincere Instablaster ;)
@Greyson Eduardo I really appreciate your reply. I got to the site thru google and Im trying it out now.
Looks like it's gonna take a while so I will get back to you later with my results.
Billy doesn't get enough credit for his harmony vocals. He's so good
Billie is fuckin incredible in this song (and in general tbf)
Yes.
It's hard when Maynard is your lead. But I totally agree.
Billy Is the perfect harmonizer for Maynard. The howl the two of them produce together is unworldly and fantastic.
I don't know man, I think I gotta give the edge to Carina Round. Her and Maynard have sung some amazing songs together.
@@fcon2123 I think both serve slightly different roles, Billy being backing Vocals and Lead guitar whereas Carina I'd say atleast live she is more Co-lead, but honestly just semantics both are great.
Maynard’s 3 projects/bands as dreams.
Tool - disturbing intense and unnerving dreams.
APC - ethereal and profound dreams
Puscifer - those kind of dreams where you wake up saying “where the f did that come from?”
I remember one time when I decided to listen one song from each band to compare, so I listened to 3 libras, the pot and country boner, which, btw, I had never heard it before xD and I wasn't clever enough to make an idea of what the song was about from the name of the song XDD... You can't even imagine how much I laugh that day... And the 3 songs had nothing in common, Maynard is a very versatile guy
Tool - prog math metal/rock
APC - Romantic/emotional goth rock
I wouldn't say they were all profound dreams "she acts just like a nurse with all the other guys" or "One taste of you my Magdalena" ... Sorry but they are basically NIN and Tool put together (literally... Billy and Maynard) So it gothic, nu metalish and kinda like billy wanting to do NIN but with guitars and pedals instead of Garageband.
@@razerow3391 I’m referring to the music as a whole - not lyrics. Lyrics are secondary to music.
Accurate AF
@@razerow3391 I didn’t say they were profound dreams - I said if each of his projects WERE dreams, that is the kind of dreams they would be.
I'd be ok if you keep doing more Tool and A Perfect Circle
Parabola...hnnggggg
Ticks and Leeches ?
@@HellDarkknight MJK did ticks and leeches in one take, incredible
@@HellDarkknight Saw it live, will never forget.
I subscribed for this. I've always loved Tool but I also love to see people discovering how awesome they are. She also made me a much bigger Iron Maiden fan with her reaction to a song of theirs. My noms for Tool songs (not necessarily my all time favorites, but ones where he uses interesting vocal techniques): The Grudge, H, Parabol/Parabola. Also, Passenger (Deftones feat. Maynard) would be cool. Bonus: Maynard's Dick, because hilarious.
Not a lot of people give Billy credit. That guy has an incredible voice as well.
3 Libras - Live at Jay Leno, is where you will see MJK performs with his body and soul in front of the camera.
Yes please its a great live performance and it also happens to be my favourite a perfect circle song.
Yes. Came to the comments to request this exact video
I second this
It’s brilliant but I prefer The Outsider.
ua-cam.com/video/qG0v0UoYFZE/v-deo.html
Holy shit Billy was killing it on this live version
Seriously, that solo was epic.
Blows my mind none of the vocal coaches have yet reacted to their "3 Libras" yet. He really works his tone & range on that absolutely beautiful song. There's a reason it became a single
The other guy on vocals is Billy Howerdel. He's the founder of APC and one hell of a guitarist!
Some of the most soothing metal riffs i've ever heard.
His live guitar sound is on another level... ear piercing at times. He used to be Adam Jones guitar tech back in Aenima days,.
@@toolhog10 didn't know this one, very nice piece of info there. Haven't had the chance to listen to him live, but he is a fantastic guitarist.
@@toolhog10 He still helps Adam. He was hanging around when Tool was in Nashville, '16. Billy will always be a Tool.
Also lead singer/guitarist for Ashes Divide.
I love hearing “Tool” in your accent. Tewl. It’s so cewl.
Orestes saved my life. APC and Tool saved my life.
Same here. Got me through a dark time. Divorce.
Amen
APC? What's that?
@@edwin-jq4dp APC = A Perfect Circle
@@fukkenhed thx
"It's the sort of music you have to close your eyes and be totally involved in. The sort of music you feel."
I could listen to you explain to me why I love the music I love all day. I just knew it sounded good, you explain WHY it sounded good. Thank you.
Could not have said it better than that.. Tool and A Perfect Circle.. can listen to them all day/nite long. When I sing I try to sing clear and effortlessly like Maynard.. drums keep that guitar pace on track. definitely.
Have you ever heard of Hurt. I can't say they sounds like Tool or APC, but they definitely have a sound much different from other bands.
@@MrJacalhoun30 I checked them out..very good suggestion! I liked their song rapture.
Now, on to Maynard's third band, Puscifer.
I second that. She could start with Grand Canyon or The Humbling River, or straight into the meat with The Remedy
@@Cendoria She wants to see Maynard change his style, then start her off with The Ronnie Dobbs's story from Mr. Show or Cuntry Boner.
Puscifer is by far the most "vocal" of Maynard's styles. It only makes sense.
Agreed. I think Agostina to kick it off
Potions
'The Noose' by A Perfect Circle is worth a reaction.
Yes please and make sure it's the live version
Let’s be honest, they all are worth a reaction.
Totally!
I concur
My favorite
The "other guy" is Billy Howerdel! It's actually his band.
This was at Red Rocks in Colorado and I was there- I didn't find out until much later that our concert had been recorded. I can't believe how fortunate I (accidentally) was to have a record of this night. To this day, one of the best nights of my life, not just best concerts. Being on a mountainside in the middle of nowhere at night, and being immersed in this powerful, emotional music was absolute magic.
I would absolutely LOVE to see a show at Red Rocks. Sadly, it's on the other side of the US. Bucket list item though.
She first watched Tool's Sober... then starr going Maynard..now Perfect Circle... huahuahua She's sure going full Maynard
Gustavo_Tatu everyone goes full Maynard eventually
I did lol
Hopefully she doesn't get into puscifer, since puscifer totally blows.
Yeah, noticed that too.
"The other guy. I don't remember his name."
I wonder if she's a Libertarian yet?
These videos are great. An insight into how another person perceives music you listen to.
Thanks, Vocal Coach.:-)
You never go full Maynard
Maynard is the vocalist you want to listen to if you want to feel bad as a vocalist. He's just an absolute unit.
Maynard has grown on you like a metaphysical fungi..welcome down the rabbit hole
Before you can go down the rabbit hole you have to learn to swim :)
@@Taylor-pz7cj 👍🤘
the muddy water is only eyehole deep
never heard it described better
Dont you mean the dragon hole? ;)
If I get my reference cool
"Give me one more medicated peaceful moment."
Regarding you comment about this being amazing live, when you're in that atmosphere:
I've been to hundreds of concerts over the decades, 400 - 500 _at least_ . I still consider the gig of A Perfect Circle in ~2003 to be the best concert I've ever been to. The atmosphere they create is completely unique; it almost feels sacred, meditative and spiritual. After I got out of the venue, when I tried to recall what just happened, all I could remember was the light, and the music and warmth. It was a one of a kind experience.
I can confirm your time table, drank a bottle of absynth with a buddy on that tour. Amazing show
100% with you. They're so enigmatic and i feel a lasting sense of euphoria for days after their shows. I hope you get to see them on their Eat the Elephant tour. They've started playing Judith again and that was unbelievable. Awesome isn't even the right word...
100% agree. Saw them in 2004 and it's one of my top shows of all time.
Agreed!! Saw them here in Chicago and I remember crying during "The Nurse Who Loved Me." And so was every single person around me. There was even an article about that performance in the Chicago Sun-Times that my dad cut it out for me and I still have. The headline read- "Atmosphere key to drawing A Perfect Circle." Yes, I actually remember that lol but you're so right. Have seen them and Tool several times and while it's always spectacular, that was by far the best 😍
Thanks for sharing PalmDesertRock
This band is definitely Maynard’s softer side. I think you’d really enjoy 3 Libras by A Perfect Circle. Which may be Maynard’s most radio friendly song. But it’s beautiful.
Nah, the most radio friendly song is _clearly_ Hooker With a Penis.
@@B_Skizzle Nah fam, Prison Sex is THE most family-friendly song in the world, don't @ me.
Billy Howerdel & Maynards vocals have always mixed very well IMO. They complement each other expertly. Your comments on the drumming are on point, the band's original drummer (well, one of them) was Josh Freese who cut his teeth playing in punk bands before becoming a session pro.
Phil Roberts Freese is the everywhere man
Yeah, when they had the girl bassist originally, she added to the vocal trio very well. Probably was the best concert for sound quality i've ever been to.
I've been to a perfect circle concert and you're right about the eye closing thing. You just kind of stand there in a trance and rock back and forth to the rhythm
of the War Drums?
That's why they dont allow cell phones. They want everyone to just entrance themselves in the music. Most of their shows are.in very near darkness as well to add to this. I've seen both tool and apc live, and it is more than just a concert.... it's an experience to become a part of.
Recent tour was pretty damn awesome, though I must say they seemed to be much more interested in their new stuff than the old. It was as if the sound quality was much better on the Eat the Elephant songs.
I already go into a trance just listening to APC with earbuds in my bedroom. I can't imagine how I'd handle them live.
@@3VILmonkey same here. Same with Tool... well any of my favorite bands haha
Tool - Lateralus
Everyone can definitely agree with that. Make the review happen!!
One of the most amazing vocal performances I've seen is actually by Fiona Apple. She was a guest at an Elvis Costello concert and they performed "I want you" which is a Costello peice. She brought this song to a whole new level...in the end, you knew exactly what it felt like to be in the situation the lyrics described. I totally think you should check out the performance. You will not regret it!
Your ear is insane. Your analysis of the understated/super intense drums is spot on and brilliant. Josh Freeze is a master.
Oh my god, I love your accent and your voice for some reason. They're adorable.
I really like your analysis on these songs :) Especially if they involve MJK, lol. I always learn something from your videos.
Yes! Love it :D, are you from London Beth or from somewhere else?
Ha ha i think scottish
ArielScync Could you react to Sabaton please?
@@naildeath I'm saying Irish.
She's Scottish, I'm saying Aberdeen?
Basically all of the Mer De Noms and Thirteen Steps albums are total fire for APC. Highly recommend checking out more of APC even if its not for videos on this channel.
definitely.
She can skip anything else they've done :)
Eat the elephant and emotive were cool
Peter Steele had a unique voice. No voice but his can get you wet and scared to death at the same time.
TYPE O NEGATIVE "Black No 1" at Bizarre festival 1999.
Please. No vocal coach has analyzed him yet, and he is worth it.
fucking love that band.
Sorry but Peter Steele never got me wet...🤷🏻♂️
@@gerardoa. I can't understand why 😜
now they have: ua-cam.com/video/6f3Icp3WLgQ/v-deo.html
Nekane Rodriguez Most underrated band of the 90’s RIP Peter Steele!!!
A Perfect Circle and Tool are amazing live. They always overwhelm me and make me cry. She's right, it's music you feel.
A Perfect Circle - Feathers
Probably Maynard's most beautiful performance
"I'm like you, JUST LIKE YOU!" so amazing, but the eat the elephant version of "Down and by the river" is my favorite
Or "Blue"
@@toastshalom3542 Yeah that version was a real surprise for me. I love it!
I did see this song live about a year ago. The “killing youuuu” ringing out at the end as the instruments fade was utterly devastating. Made me tear up. I know this video and channel is about the singing itself and the technique but with Maynard at least, I think it’s a good idea to pull up his lyrics. It makes his singing style and word/sound emphasis make more sense. Great video!
I tear up every time I have seen them play this .. Well over a dozen.
Dude, I legit wept after my first APC concert. Same with Tool and Puscifer. Maynard is just such a crazy force multiplier. You could put him in any mediocre band and it would immediately be twice as good.
I totally understand that. This song still makes me tear up, reminds me of my broken relationship with my brother. When I was young and first discovered Tool, I listened to Undertow on a whim, and for some inexplicable reason Prison Sex instantly made me tear up. I wasn't even listening to the lyrics, but the harmony of the band and Maynard's newer bands send chills down my spine every timr
Love the Tool/APC kick you're on. Great bands with a vocalist/lyricist unlike any other. A real joy watching your reaction videos to his work. Keep em coming Ms Roars. It Brings a great deal of pleasure to the newer and mos def the long time fans of his music watching these reaction videos of yours! Much Love for doing these!!
Still alot more gems from those bands... Looking forward to more in the future :) ! (Would love a Three Libras vid!)
My mom passed away about the time Mer de Noms came out. I swam in this album for a long time. And yes, they are amazing live.
Would love to hear Beth Roars do a cover of a Tool / APC song
Gareth Gilbert 46&2
A great reaction. I enjoy Maynard’s lyrics because they’re great to just relax and listen to. Just let the music wash over you
Watching how much you genuinely get involved with the music you’re reacting too is the most rewarding part of watching your vids, you earnt a sub 😎
Also you check out Slipknot - Snuff acoustic or something by Dance Gavin Dance
Definitely would love to see what she says about Tillian's voice! Love DGD!
Favorite song from apc for 19 years now still the most beautiful song!!!!
The only “vocal coach reacts” I’ve been able to tolerate for more than a few mins... Subscribed!
Maynard and A Perfect Circle did an album of covers which includes covers of John Lennon's Imagine, When The Levee Breaks, and Devo's Freedom of Choice. All have live versions from Red Rocks in Colorado.
That's where her video was from. It was definitely that show.
Not to mention some really great re-imagining of some great punk songs. Let’s have a War by Fear and Gimme Gimme Gimme by Black Flag.
@@JensenDKMG85 they did two shows in two days. It was released on DVD.
Another really great song from them is Breña. So easy to just lay back, close your eyes, and get lost in the music.
Probably my favorite song off of what I believe is their best album overall.
That's my favorite APC song.
The way you say “um” is literally the best thing ever.
loving watching these analysis videos of maynard with both tool and APC.. Hes been my favorite singer for more than 20 years and its cool to see someone explain the technicalities of what he is executing so well
I still think you should Judith the vocals are intense, when most singers screams seem like they are at you Maynard’s flow through you. You feel what he feels
Maynard is amazing! Please check out ALICE IN CHAINS LOVE HATE LOVE LIVE AT THE MOORE THEATRE!!! Another awesome video!
“Something you kind of have to close your eyes and be involved in” “music you have to feel” finally someone understands
those vibratos near the end gives me chills ever dam time, Wanna learn how to sing like the big man himself not gonna be easy
The other singer is the guitarist Billy Howerdel who co-founded the band. He's the lead singer for a band called Ashes Divide.
Ashes Divide is actually Billys solo project, not a band.
Also a guitar tech for tool back in the day. I think sometimes James Iha jumps on vocal too.
@@keegansponholz9260 the bassist is primary backing vocalist live, but i think on recordings its mostly Billy. And i keep forgetting the bassists name.. 😂
@@whereami6586 Everyone forgets the bassist unless it's Flea or Justin Chancellor :p
@@keegansponholz9260 I should know, myself... I AM a bassist! 😂
Hey Beth just wanted to say that I love your videos they are really instructive and entertaining and your picks for reacting are always awesome! To me the best coach-reaction channel! I suggest you do The Outsider for the next APC reaction. There is this live performance which appears first on youtube when you look for it (bad video quality but best audio) which is trully Maynar’s best proshoot performance!
I can't love this enough. This is one of my favorite songs by them.
I saw this posted before I went to work today, and I've been looking forward to getting home, all day, just to watch this. I sincerely wish you would have listened to The Hollow from this same concert. It's by far my favorite.... so... so beautiful. Either way, I'm glad you appreciate this. Maynard is my favorite vocalist, for obvious reasons
Try APC's version of "imagine". It's beautiful and terrifying
Yay! Perfect circle. Check out puscifer-momma sed live. Same singer but puscifer is his baby
"Umbilical residue keeping me from killing you" I always thought that was the angriest lyric I've ever heard. Sheer brutality juxtaposed with this beautiful harmony. So Maynard.
Love the reaction videos! Really interesting hearing you breakdown exactly what is going on with Maynard's vocals here!
Feathers, off of A Perfect Circle’s newest album that came out last year has some amazing vocals by Maynard. Also you may want to check out Puscifer, Maynard’s third band. It’s much different from Tool and APC as it covers multiple Genres of music, and has its own emotional feel to it. I would suggest starting with Autumn. Amazing song and his vocals are on point.
Thanks again for the video Beth, always a pleasure to see.
Humble, genuine and knowledgeable.
Great reaction! Please do Chris cornell, either say hello to heaven or when I'm down!
agreed
Oh You have discovered my favorite singer Maynard James Keenan....He also sings in Puscifer
Can i just say its very cool to hear you put words to the techniques ive learned over the years of mimicry and practice.
I was there and it was absolutely amazing. Listening to one my favorite bands of all time at Red Rocks.
puscifer-green valley maybe ? :)
Beth, I'm interested to hear your critique of Maynard's voice for Tool's Lateralus, and A Perfect Circle's By and Down the River. Both are amazing songs, and I think they would be good subjects. Thanks
So glad to see you appreciate such an amazing artist
I saw some songs during this performance on here UA-cam before I became a huge fan. I literally got chills from this. I was super lucky to see them front row standing on the barrier both times they came to London. The December show ranks as my second favorite show ever. Justice (french DJ duo) are my first. Their live set is from another world!
React to alice in chains - love hate love (live at the moore)
I love your channel! :)
Yes, amazing performance
This is one people will wait with baited breath.
Goat
Up for this! 🤘
Shit still give me chills
If you look at all three bands symbols, the Puscifer symbol looks like a uterus (basic emotions, sexuality, humor), APC resembled the heart (love, passion, pain), and Tool is the flaming third eye (enlightenment, spirituality and psychology). There are images that you can Google to see how cool the three are when seen together.
Nice observation
You are right it is amazing live! Awesome analysis of Maynard's voice!
It is amazing live. I've gone to three shows, and they always kill it.
Has anyone suggested NIN's yet? Something from 'A Downward Spiral' like 'The Becoming'
Beth I can see you are Inloved with MJK since first Tool video
Here's some more examples of best of MJK
A perfect circle - 3 libras in tonight's show
Tool 10000 days hidden track
Tool bottom
Tool the pot
Puscifer - The Remedy
A perfect circle the outsider live
This was awesome.beth, thanks for your interpretation
Love all the frequent uploads. I really enjoy your videos :)
Would love to see your reaction to Bruce Dickinson 'tears of the Dragon'. It's about him leaving Iron maiden back in the day. Not a vocalist but I love your videos for the insight you give. Keep up the amazing job
Just discovered this channel and love your break down of vocalist techniques. Would love to hear your take on Mike Patton of Mr Bungle and Faith No More fame. He has one of the best voices in the business if you ask me and has one hell of a range.
Would recommend songs like Everything’s Ruined, retrovertigo or midlife crisis, all great examples, but plenty more to find in his back catalogue.
Patton’s vocal range is unparalleled to virtually mankind.
Hey! Check out my reaction to Faith No More - Epic (Mike Patton Live) here: ua-cam.com/video/lPCaJOYPnpo/v-deo.html
you explain the way he sings, the style he does, there is soo much too singing, i had no idea
You got that right ,a perfect circle live is ethereal!
Love your song choice again! This song can cure cancer i swear...
Soundgarden's "Slaves & Bulldozers" please! There's a great live version from PinkPop 1992. I also fully support any Alice In Chains suggestions. Thank you! Your videos are great!
I was at this show and it's one of my favorite concerts, right up there with SRV, from 35+ years of concert going. There was a light rain falling the whole night, and the rocks of the ampitheatre glowed in the light show (as did the top of Billy's head). It was just amazing. Atmospheric. They were ON. Counting Bodies Like Sheep and When the Levee Breaks were probably my faves of the night.
Love this performance! Very nice reaction!
Check out Maynard with Puscifer covering Bohemian Rhapsody.
Please react to mike patton
There will come a day when the reaction channels jump on Mike Patton and they'll all follow suit, like they did with Tool and Jinjer.
But which song is the question.
@@Delboy219 I sure hope so
@@darynx The live version of Tomahawk "God Hates A Coward", some live Mr. Bungle, maybe Mondo Cane live with the orchestra.
@@Delboy219 well, they react to Mike Patton and they just find a pot of gold. Content for decades!
I could listen to Billy Howerdel and Maynard's harmonies non-stop and never get tired of that. It's just got a genuine texture and mass to it that you could just wrap your brain up with.
This is by no means the best recording of Orestes. The earlier recordings are gold
Please react to A Perfect Circle - The Noose - Stone and Echo Live at Red Rocks!!! Insanely good!
Agree
There's a perfect live version of Brena out there
Loving your reviews and your technical aspect of it. Really cool to hear this broken down from a professional, you really know your stuff.
I loved watching this! Maynard is one of my favorite artists of all time. I love all three of his projects, but APC is my favorite. So many things you said are exactly why too. The way it feels kind of calm, but is so incredibly powerful, the smoothness to his range, the fact that it makes you just want to close your eyes and lose yourself in the music. It's all so beautiful to me. It was so cool hearing you say those exact things. I hope you've had a chance to listen to more APC, because it is all worth it
Rammstein mein hertz brent, audioslave cochise or maybe some Chris corrnell thanks, awesome videos from a fellow scot!
Rammstein yes but you can skip the other trash.
@@jerh6210 Chris Cornell trash? Educate yourself fool, Chris is universally regarded by people who know what they're talking about as one of rocks greatest singers.
@@oisinmcphillips2090 there are times that people disagree with what the universe tells them is good or bad.
Music is music, everyone has there own opinion, I like so much different music and am normally a metal head. Here's not the place to hate on others taste. It's only suggestions, give this lass a few ideas for her channel.
Oh yeah, anything Chris Cornell. So saddened to know he's gone. And yeah, I agree with you. Opinions are like assholes... You probably know the rest.
Chris Cornell- nothing compares to you cover
I saw them perform this song live and it really was amazing. I get so emotional just watching you react to this, thank you Beth🙏😢
That was a beautiful recording! I've only heard the studio recording, so this was quite a treat.
Preeeetttttyyyy pleaseeeeeeee Do Human Behavior by Bjork
The other guy is Billy Howerdel...think I spelled his last name correctly ._.
Goosebumps with this song. I'm glad I found this, grateful you reviewed this song. I'm a fan of yours now too
Delighted that Beth has gathered us all around Maynard . And affirming for us in technical terms what we feel deep in our souls when he sings.