Prehistoric Planet Trex Uses Jurassic Park Trex Roars
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 тра 2023
- I'm sorry for making the video look messy, its to avoid copyright claims. this video is fair use because the clips are used in a different context and to make a point.
let me make this very clear, i do not have a problem with the sound designers using jp trex sounds, it might be used to reference jurassic park, a easter egg, maybe, i like the sounds. however, its a documentary about teaching people about real dinosaurs, they use the latest science to reconstruct these animals, so using jurassic park sounds goes against that. its like making a documentary about space with star wars sound effects.
as for the tiger growl, i dont mind it, but its too obvious its from a tiger.
by the way, i don't count the sped up clip, its just me going deep and looking for it. atleast they tried to hide the fact its a jp trex sound in the original speed. - Фільми й анімація
![Prehistoric Planet [2022] - Carnotaurus Screen Time](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/T24ZOgvMF30/mqdefault.jpg)
Well out of the JP Rex’s sounds, those are the most accurate. They were raspy bellows instead of full on roars
These arent JP sounds, they are stock sounds.
@Dav Yx Yx Yeah JW did use that one, but they arent the ones who made it.
yeah T-rexes didnt roar at all
@@drywallman55 how can you be so sure?
I guess that’s true
Honestly it’s hidden so well that I don’t mind. Also it’s fun lil homage and it doesn’t sound like a stock sound and fits the Rex.
Even after all these years, we can still never let go of that legendary trex sound
They didn't literally use the same sound. They just sound kind of similar because jp has maybe 2 accurate roars.
I honestly noticed it immediately when watching
@@crappyanimations9992there isn’t any “accurate roars” these are both speculative
@@Ealais76 Plain wrong. We know much more than you think. Look it up please, I don't have time to explain it to you, but we have good ideas what they did and especially what they didn't sound like.
@@crappyanimations9992 lmao you dorks say the same thing everytime, more "conclusive" research surfaces about Spinosaurus....... You guys fight about whats more accurate, and then bam a year later more data comes and contradicts newly accepted accepted hypothesis by the community.... At the end of tje day we dont know 💯 percent..... There is a still a certian degree of "belief" in certain aspects of science. And individuals like you turn science into a religion.
I got a prehistoric planet ad on this lol
But to be honest, as a Jurassic park fan and paleontology nerd, I didn’t even notice, and the noises sounded realistic enough to me. The noises BBC used for their animals sound accurate, and sound like crocodilians, grunts, hisses, growls, and bellows. We never get a full on awesomebro roar, all the noises seem to be done and pitched well. So I don’t mind this. The loudest or most roar like noises the animals make seem to be the limit, any louder and they would hurt themselves or be incapable of. And in the show, this limit is still lower than Jurassic parks loud ass big mammal roars. So I don’t mind this. I think they did it well. They still accurately depicted them, but I do wish we also got other sounds from them that have been suggested, like the low rumbling and the dinosaur vocalization study noises. Although similar noises to those were thrown in there, so that’s good.
Yes, they still sound reptilian.
its so subtle its fine. Not everything in JP is inaccurate lmao.
I hope people realize that not everything in JP is inaccurate. A lot of it is, but the bellows and low sounds the dinosaurs make are not that far fetched. The roars are, but not the bellows.
idk why people keep saying this, because a paper and youtube video did years ago? animals without syrinxes are perfectly capable of making loud abrupt noises that could be considered roar-like. it wasnt making any triumphant roars like it did in jurassic park but its vocal capabillities likely had more than just hiss hiss rumble rumble in its repitoir.
youd be surprised with the range of vocal noises animals without syrinxes/larynxes can make
@@Tavishburn have u heard the new more accurate trex sound? Low frequenze
@@hugo-pg5tv clearly what i have been saying has went over your head,
the low frequency sounds are exactly what i was talking about in my initial comment.
@@Tavishburn I asked if u had heard it didn't try to inform u on something.
my whole comment was critiquing the exact thing you are asking if i heard about....@@hugo-pg5tv
Besides the obvious tiger roar, i really dont see anything wrong with it. The sounds are low enough mixed in with crocodile hisses and bellows thats its fairly accurate to what it could have sounded like. And its not like its roaring every 5 seconds to make sure everyone knows where it is.
*Lion.
Interesting to see that the sound effects connect these two properties!
Nice use of the more low-key roars. Fits with the more "I'm here" or "I want you to leave" sort of behavior in the scenes shown, as opposed to a "let's do this shit right now" roar.
It’s such a loved and big powerful animal that we can’t help but expect the same for its vocal noises.
As a former Jurassic fan, I find its roars more realistic than an baby elephant screaming mammalistic roar from Jurassic Park.
Former?
@@kade-qt1zu You see, it's because I'm done with the Jurassic franchise while I still love them, and there are four reasons:
Number 1, the movies, especially the first one, were beyond my expectations (for the most part).
Number 2, Jurassic World: Dominion broke the fan base despite that I love this film, and that happened to Klayton Fioriti.
Number 3, the sequel hatedom and social media debate is getting worse and worse every time a sequel, including the Jurassic World films, were released year after year.
And number 4, Jurassic Park is too popular for a dinosaur film, which leads to countless articles and reviewers analyzing film after film, positive or negative, all over the internet, leading to debates, theories, analyses, and even arguments involving the series, even scientific accuracy more than any other dinosaur film.
You can argue that every product and celebrity fell victim to this, and I know they did, but that doesn't stop me from how I'm done with the Jurassic franchise, which is why I'm sticking with dinosaurs in general.
well, T-rexes didn't roar
@Aileron546 They likely made a extremely loud bellow sort, like alligators or crocodiles
@@drywallman55 cringe
i can't believe they didn't record a real trex
nice sarcasm bud
@@jackmills7758It was really good sarcasm
@Dav Yx Yx You mean that video that literally says is just remixed bird sounds in the description?
@Paleontology_Enjoyer The study that is objectively using hippo sounds for T.rex?
@@godzillakingofthemonsters5812,you're retarted, t rex sounds like in JP
this is the proof that you can use stock sounds for a documentary if you know how to use them
they used lion roars and crocodile hisses. just like jurassic park. but mixed differently
Honestly it doesn't bother me at all that they chose to use *these* particular sounds. Trex is theorized to have an interesting vocal range that consists of reptilian hisses, rumbles and hums that could be "felt" instead of heard, so using this edited, low-pitched bellow is fairly representative of a sound it may have been able to produce. At least they didn't you a bombastic, trumpeting roar from the JP films, and picked a more accurate (all things considered) sound.
Both T. rexes are still chads🔥
Unlike it's fanbase
I don't really see problem with it, as long it is not the actual jp rex roar, this is fine
The definition for roar is so broad that this isn’t that bad
Paleo Community vs JP Fans
"Yours is cringe!!!"
Prehistoric Planet 🤝🏼 JP
JP fans are Paleo Community too
@@MAKATOONY Exactly
Test
As long as it does growls and hisses, I'm okay with it.
I like how the dinosaurs aren’t just constantly loudly roaring in this documentary for no reason, in reality they probably couldn’t roar at all
the tiger image got me lmao
Well at least they weren’t those popular roars almost everybody knows about, It’s just , hisses, bellows and growls
I like how any accurate dinosaur stuff with a bit of jp brings in a bunch of paleontologists
So what. The JP trex sounds get used literally everywhere. I dont blame Prehistoic Planet for using some of them. and even then, they only seem to have used the most accurate ones to what we believe trex soundend like.
Pretty cool
JP and prehistoric roars are from lions and elephants.
i like how some people are complaining about the JW/JP sounds and stuff, but where are you supposed to get a real Tyrannosaurus Sound 💀
Funny that before the video started, I got an ad for Prehistoric Planet. XD
I believe the sound comes from a lion roar which could possibly fit a large carnivore.
Some of y’all are acting like they’re using the actual roar I promise you guys will fucking live it’s not that big of an issue
Didn't dinosaurs need a Larynx to make such sounds???
Yes, they had larynxes, and some might have had syrinxes too
@@miguelpedraentomology6080 Not 💯 proven. If they did make sounds, it was more birdlike and not this JW bullcrap.
@@nocturnalrecluse1216 its not the end of the world, calm down bru 💀💀💀
@@darkmatternermox I'm mad because they took a step down to make it more entertaining for the simpleton viewers. This particular behavior of the T-rex belongs in Hollywood, not realistic documentaries.
@@nocturnalrecluse1216 the sound it makes here is totaly possible actually., not sure why you are mad.
0:08 that was the gorgosaurus sfx from the wwd movie
that movie uses a lot of jurassic park sound effects too, but its a movie made to entertain and tell a grand story, unlike prehistoric planet, its a documentary made to educate people about the real dinosaurs. and theres nothing realistic about using the jurassic park trex sound despite what other people want you to think in the comments.
@@jackmills7758 wwd 2015 was such a wasted opportunity for a wwd season 2 tbh
And Pixar the Jurassic park T. rex roars for butch and his kids in the good dinosaur
They're still pretty accurate, and actually suit both the Jurassic Park/World and Prehistoric Planet rex.
I find it vey hard to believe they used or stole JP Rexy sounds because even Avatar used JP sounds of Velociraptor for the Direhorses and Rexy for the Thanator. I think there is a sound library for movie producers to access because Avatar and PP never worked with Universal.
So, apparently these sounds are lion growls pitched down
wth how did you make JP/JW t. rex roar sound very accurate
These same roars were used in the Walking with Dinosaurs movie and Life on Our Planet.
They probably sound so much like a T. rex that they both came up with the noises at different times.
The JP roar is only inaccurate in its raw form. One could use Star Wars sound effects in a space documentary without compromising accuracy if they were modified to fit the scene. Though most scenes in a space documentary should actually be soundless since there's no sound in empty space.
They modify the roar in such a way it sounds like it was made by more basic vocal organs. It doesn't have the high pitches of the original roar because there's no vocal cords to constrict and raise the pitch.
That said, even the idea that T. rex couldn't make complex calls is being called slightly into question due to the fact we've found a larynx (or maybe a syrinx? I can't remember which) in a nodosaur. If two groups of dinosaurs are known to be capable of vocalizations more complex than bellows and growls, it's possible others may have been able to do the same after all.
Most of the t-rex roars were elephants and lions sounds.
I mean, it fits for this prehistoric planet T. rex.
Brutal 👍
Real trex sounds where more like deep bellows and growls like a alligator. JP Rex made it sound like a fucking Godzilla roar
I kind of noticed that same sound effect from the 2 Seasons of Prehistoric Planet.
That's what I knew. It shows us a reference to Jurassic Park.
Oh wow
I feel like the prehistoric planet trex roar is mostly accurate even though its the jurassic park trex roar
Sounds fine to me ngl
So random pig, crocodile, tiger roars are now Trade Mark huh.
I didn't take much note of it, as it was mostly hissing.
we think that they made crocodilian like hisses and growls so yeah its accurate
At least they did not use the iconic roar,and went with the growls or bellows that might be more accurate.
They fit
So they did use the JP T-Rex roars, they just drowned them in alligator sounds to hide them
Since they're technically just specific mixes of real animal sounds and they used probably the most obscure sounds from the jp rexes I'd say it's fine lmao
@@ToastTheTheyeah, basically every dinosaur sound from anything ever is mashed up animal noises.
@@andrewcrowley6331 some are just like a dude screaming into a garbage bin
@@ToastTheThe LMAO
Scotty the combination of rexy and tiger
They should have used studiomod's Real t rex sounds for Prehistoric Planet atleast they should use it for the next ones they sound scarier than anything in JP.
Well at least they're plausible growls and gutteral grunts and not ripping off the classic roar.
I was a little sad, I wish they had used more realistic and own sounds.
0:05 bro t rex hisses like spinosaurus
This is the noise they should be making (personal preference not reality), the roar of a king but a little silent
And the baby velociraptors have evrima sounds
this clearly a easter egg
what are they sopposed to do make the sounds using a real t-rex
Those aren't sounds that JP created, they're Lion/Tiger and Elephant noises. Stock ones too, that are used in millions of articles of media.
These have always been borrowed. And this narrator in this series David.. Is Hammond's actor Richard's brother in real life
Are you sure it's "using the Jurassic Park T. rex roar" and not "They're both using the same stock sound of a specific animal and editing it slightly"? If it was the iconic, trumpeting roar of the JP T. rex then I would understand, but these are very generic grunts and bellows that are probably common in sound libraries.
Also what the hell is this description on the video "they use the latest science to reconstruct these animals, so using jurassic park sounds goes against that. its like making a documentary about space with star wars sound effects."? If the sounds that it shares with the JP version are the realistic sounds, then there's not really a problem.
Yeah... the PP ones sound better. I actually can imagine a Rex sounding like that.
Very disappointing. But I am not surprised, in no way would a highly-budgeted project like this restrict the creative license of replicating dinosaur sounds. Hell, the Quetzalcoatlus we're hearing in this is basically a horn from old 1920s Ford.
How is this not copyright they keep using Jurassic park T. rex roar in they movies they used it in walking with dinosaurs movie the good dinosaur and land before time 14 movie all other dinosaurs movies are keep using T. rex roar from Jurassic park in they movies they put a lawsuit why can’t they design they own roar for the T. rex in they movies
i see nothing wrong with this
Everyone's using jp rex sounds bruh
Bbc does it better. Jurassic park and walking with dinosaurs will always be my favorite childhood dinosaur movie and series
what people failed to understand is that JP is inaccurate because our knowledge with dinosaurs during its creation ain't that advanced yet.
Or maybe... people just like entertainment and not everything needs to be scientifically accurate 🙄.
@@economiccrisis9267actually pretty much everything except the trike and dilophosaurus were up to scientific standard for 1993(velociraptors are oversized deinonychus which isn’t too off)
They got the more accurate jp Rex sounds and edited it to make it more accurate
What is this?!💀
@0:17 & @0:19 are Lion roars
I wonder who is gonna tell people that out of most dinosaur media, Jurassic Park's Tyrannosaur has always been one of the more accurate designs. And a realistic documentary using a fairly realistic grunt from the franchise that paved the way for modern dinosaur media is an easter egg, a nod to that franchise, and doesn't discredit the documentary as fictitious. Dinosaur vocalizations, as with much of anything we know about is based mostly on rational SPECULATION. We see some evidence for something and loosely apply it to the animal. There is very little we know for sure when it comes to dinosaurs and any honest paleontologist will admit to that.
Media however, likes to take that speculation and run with it like its hard fact. Which leads to problems when presented to the public in such a way.
Honestly, the Jurassic Park spinosaurus, for the time, was actually dang near accurate. It still has problems obviously like the pronated wrists and lack of contour in the skull shape, but it's very close to being accurate to the real thing when the movie was made. I think Jurassic Park takes the cake for the most accurate dinosaurs in any movie (not documentary movies, just entertainment movies) especially in the spinosaurus. Even today, with how outdated its model is, it's probably more accurate than any spinosaurus in a non educational movie. Not like spinosaurus shows up often.
The T. rex might also be the most accurate in any movie, too. Although for the time it was modeled, it's less accurate than the spinosaurus is for sure. They got the skull very, very wrong. And then of course we have the velociraptor which is one of the most inaccurate depictions in movies. Still not THE most inaccurate, though, somehow. I haven't seen many movies with velociraptors, but of the ones I have seen I think Disney's Dinosaur is the most accurate. It's actually quite good aside from the lack of feathers. They're not even that shrinkwrapped.
@@catpoke9557 Jurassic park has plenty of inaccurate dinos. I was simply referring to the tyrannosaur specifically.
@@smugreptile6695 I know. I was showing appreciation for the other dinosaurs.
@@smugreptile6695I would argue the only innacurate dinosaurs are dilophosaurus, triceratops, the two lambeosaurines(para and Cory), mamnechi, and lastly pteranodon
@@Ealais76 They are accurate for it's time
The 1 thing inaccurate about T-Rex's roar in Prehistoric Planet.
Nobody knows about the vocalization sounds of the Dinosaurs in the reality is unknown to us damn it 😒
@@LuisRivera-jk1vo we actually do know some things about dinosaur vocalization. They didn't roar but bellowed and hissed like crocodiles
@@gusfring6887 Thats not true actually, we really dont know what most of them sounded like. Modern crocodilians, bird and other reptiles have a really big vocal range, some crocodiles can even roar, actually.
Atleast it's not even a loud roar like in jw/jp
Yup
Eh. It could be worse. It’s not as obvious as most JP T Rex roars.
T-rex does not roar and have similar sound like modern birds
BRUH WHY DID THEY JUST STEAL THOSE ROARS FROM JURASSIC PARK/ WORLD? THATS JUST WRONG
Bro, the narrator in Prehistoric Planet is literally John Hammond's brother
Jurassic Park/World? Jurassic Park is not part of Jurassic World, they didn't make these sounds.
@@MAKATOONY Nah dude, is Jurassic World being part of Jurassic Park
I’ve heard that these are stock sounds so they really aren’t stealing unless what I heard is not true but even if it wasn’t they barely stole because they edited it to sound different and accurate it’s more like a reference then stealing
See what I mean it’s very hypocritical that they used Jurassic Park and a little bit of tiger sound into it. That’s the only problem I have it’s like do something different after all dinosaurs don’t roar and they would’ve sounded like birds or crocodilians Tyrannosaurus rex what it sounded like an alligator or something and it would also sound like a large bird like a cassowary like come on be reasonable
As much as I don’t mind the phlegmy growls and the courtship rumbling, this is what made me feel a little disappointed.
While it is okay to use mammals to simulate dinosaur vocalizations (depending on type of mammal), I just wish we could stray away from the recycled JP SFX or tiger growls.
Nobody knows about the vocalization sounds of the Dinosaur in reality dude!!!
Damn it!
@Dav Yx Yx which are just bird sounds slighty edited to fit the dinosaur, hella speculative
@@ryansmith-sounddesigner7831 it’s my only gripe with the show, there’s people out here on UA-cam how’ve made some awesome sounds for dinosaurs (even if they are extremely speculative), just kinda disappointed that they decided to use what basically amounts to stock sound effects for one of the most iconic animals in the show
@@LuisRivera-jk1vo That is the point of speculation. We’re just referring to what material they used for the sound design.
Nah that is cap
Is this gaslighting in action?
Infrasound
T-rexes didnt roar though
as a trex i can confirm i dont roar at all, youre full of bs
Nope !! more like a King Kong Roar.🦍
But that's not what he sounds like
It's more like a very strong and deep honk sound
@@hadijahabutazil9132 Kong can give a snarl like that.
@@hadijahabutazil9132 or a Kong grunt.
Dinosaurs did NOT make mammilian roars. 🙄
They aren’t “Mammalian” roars. They aren’t even roars. This is a hiss/bellow sound that happened to be made with mammal sounds, but it’s supposed to be made to sound like a crocodile/bird like sound. 🤦
These aren’t mammalian roars, they’re deep bellows and hisses not unlike crocodiles.
Paleontologist maybe thought dinosaurs were mammals
That was only a made up mixed sounds.
@@meli-melo9759literally impossible, mammals evolved alongside dinosaurs
Lame
? Context
@@seantron5291 the Jurassic Park T Rex roars are lame compared to what might have presumably been the real creature's sounds
That show is just not right
Those are not roars, those are bellows.