Hi Michael. This is great... so nice to see a simple, straightforward discussion of how to get this program working from the ground up. I'm sure this will prove useful to many just starting out with network audio... Regards from Sydney, Ben
Hey Michael James - Thanks, good to hear from you. I've heard about SoundJack but haven't used it. My collaborators and I got into JackTrip through the folks that wrote it and since it has worked well for us and meets all our needs we haven't really experimented too much with other audio software. (Video is another story - the experimenting there feels endless because there are so many options but all with diffferent advantages/disadvantages...) FYI, JackTrip works well on Linux though I'm not a linux user myself. Good luck with it all!
Hi, Is there anywhere a tutorial on how to setup networking audio with Jacktrip on Windows? I see the software exists but other than the basic install instructions, I haven't found any networking configuration instructions anywhere as they exist for Linux & OSX? Thanks!
Here are a couple links: ccrma.stanford.edu/~cc/153resources/win10/jacktripInstaller/ and. most of all this one: ccrma.stanford.edu/software/jacktrip/windows/index.html Good luck!
@@michaeldessen Nope. That's exactly what I was talking about...the software and basic install instructions. No configuration, manual or instructions on how to setup and get it running. Too bad.
I'm trying to do the Stanford course on kadenze about Jacktrip, I'm having difficulties connecting on Mac Catalina 10.15. Can someone point me to some tutorial, please?
Hi Paul. If you're taking the Kadenze course, I hope you can ask there... but unfortunately Catalina has brought new challenges because the Jack Pilot app (a GUI for Jack server) no longer works on Catalina. I don't have Catalina so I can't test it myself yet but I added some notes to a doc that I share with people about this, just based on what I've heard from others. Info on Catalina is slowly getting clearer as more people test it, and it may or may not work for you, but my own best guess right now about what to try is in this doc under the section "JackTrip on Macs", the Catalina part: docs.google.com/document/d/1YLX8NatB_Ktdr24LyVg7h_P3zwG1lh1D0A0e733mCYo/edit#heading=h.7v9by67xb8ig
I'm not getting the connection to work. I live in Brazil and I have this question: My internet service should provide me "external ip" right? Otherwise my IP extracted from any website showing my external IP will not allow the client to connect to my server. Am I right?
Hi Tulio. I tried to document what I know about ports, etc. in the Network section of this doc, so please read that and if you need more, hopefully your ISP or someone else can help: . Good luck!
@@michaeldessen Thanks a lot. I found out that is exactly that. Here in Brazil (don't know about other countries) they don't provide a fixed IP. So I tested in my local network using my macbook and my wife's and it worked. Not perfect, but I think it was because her macbook is running Catalina, so I can't run Jackpilot. Thanks for all the help.
Túlio, perhaps they do give you an IP address that changes through the time. Maybe the reason you couldn’t get it working could have been a firewall blocking the connection, which could be on your service provider, your router or your machine. Did you check for this? Also check the “port forwarding” option on your router.
@@TulioAraujo Olá Túlio. Eu moro em Vitória ES. Consegui configurar para funcionar sem precisar acionar o provedor de serviços .precisei configurar no roteador o Port forwarding. Não precisei de IP fixo. Nem precisei derrubar meu firewall. Se quiser trocar email comigo, tento explicar ... pimenteldias@gmail.com
Hi, Michael. I'm trying to install the jacktrip. After I entering my password, report: Operation not permitted. don't know what's wrong. I'm using the OSX El Captain. Hope can get help from you. Thanks
Hi Taizhi - I"m not sure I can help you with just that information since it's not clear where you're entering your password and at what stage of the process. Do you mean in terminal when running the terminal sudo commands?
sorry I didn't explain clearly. Yes I mean in the Terminal after typing the "sudo cp jack trip /usr/bin/ " and giving my password. It shows Operation not permitted. Thanks a lot. : )
Taizhi, unfortunately I'm travelling and short on time right now but also that sounds like more of a Terminal/Unix problem than a jacktrip problem so if you can find someone experienced with Unix they could probably help you figure that out easily. Sudo commands require root user admin access so maybe you don't have the privileges or it could also be you're not using the "cd" command to get to the right directory so that you're trying to run the sudo commands on a directory that doesn't allow it. Good luck!
It might be Apple's System Integrity Protection, go here to figure out how to get around it. stackoverflow.com/questions/32659348/operation-not-permitted-when-on-root-el-capitan-rootless-disabled
Hi Michael.
This is great... so nice to see a simple, straightforward discussion of how to get this program working from the ground up. I'm sure this will prove useful to many just starting out with network audio...
Regards from Sydney,
Ben
thank you!! So nice to have this laid out simply!
Hey Michael James - Thanks, good to hear from you. I've heard about SoundJack but haven't used it. My collaborators and I got into JackTrip through the folks that wrote it and since it has worked well for us and meets all our needs we haven't really experimented too much with other audio software. (Video is another story - the experimenting there feels endless because there are so many options but all with diffferent advantages/disadvantages...) FYI, JackTrip works well on Linux though I'm not a linux user myself. Good luck with it all!
I have jacktrip working on my Linux pc. I would be open to connecting through it if you ever felt like trying it out. Thanks
Yikes. Volume is extremely low in these vids... :(
Yes, please turn up your mic volume. All my systems are as high as they can go.
@@NIgaudeable I assume you mean speaker volume. Laptop volume is at max. Can't hear a word.
Seems complicated to get going.
Hi,
Is there anywhere a tutorial on how to setup networking audio with Jacktrip on Windows? I see the software exists but other than the basic install instructions, I haven't found any networking configuration instructions anywhere as they exist for Linux & OSX?
Thanks!
Here are a couple links: ccrma.stanford.edu/~cc/153resources/win10/jacktripInstaller/ and. most of all this one: ccrma.stanford.edu/software/jacktrip/windows/index.html Good luck!
@@michaeldessen Nope. That's exactly what I was talking about...the software and basic install instructions. No configuration, manual or instructions on how to setup and get it running. Too bad.
Hi, in the latest version downloaded from github I cannot find the /bin directory. Has something changed in the installation procedure?
+Maciej K. Ok, I found it. Nevermid :) thanks for the tutorial
Is there anything like jacktrip but made for videos?
Hi fabio and sorry I never saw this comment earlier! Yes, there is: Ultragrid. It's great, though not easy to use.
I'm trying to do the Stanford course on kadenze about Jacktrip, I'm having difficulties connecting on Mac Catalina 10.15. Can someone point me to some tutorial, please?
Hi Paul. If you're taking the Kadenze course, I hope you can ask there... but unfortunately Catalina has brought new challenges because the Jack Pilot app (a GUI for Jack server) no longer works on Catalina. I don't have Catalina so I can't test it myself yet but I added some notes to a doc that I share with people about this, just based on what I've heard from others. Info on Catalina is slowly getting clearer as more people test it, and it may or may not work for you, but my own best guess right now about what to try is in this doc under the section "JackTrip on Macs", the Catalina part: docs.google.com/document/d/1YLX8NatB_Ktdr24LyVg7h_P3zwG1lh1D0A0e733mCYo/edit#heading=h.7v9by67xb8ig
@@michaeldessen qjackctl works fine on Catalina and accomplishes the same thing as Jack Pilot
@@DanTepferMusic Thanks Dan! I've since heard that from others too and it's great news.
@@michaeldessen yeah i meant to reply to Paul above, sorry Michael! I'm sure you're well aware of qjackctl...
I'm not getting the connection to work. I live in Brazil and I have this question: My internet service should provide me "external ip" right? Otherwise my IP extracted from any website showing my external IP will not allow the client to connect to my server. Am I right?
Hi Tulio. I tried to document what I know about ports, etc. in the Network section of this doc, so please read that and if you need more, hopefully your ISP or someone else can help: . Good luck!
@@michaeldessen Thanks a lot. I found out that is exactly that. Here in Brazil (don't know about other countries) they don't provide a fixed IP. So I tested in my local network using my macbook and my wife's and it worked. Not perfect, but I think it was because her macbook is running Catalina, so I can't run Jackpilot. Thanks for all the help.
Túlio, perhaps they do give you an IP address that changes through the time. Maybe the reason you couldn’t get it working could have been a firewall blocking the connection, which could be on your service provider, your router or your machine. Did you check for this? Also check the “port forwarding” option on your router.
@@TulioAraujo Olá Túlio. Eu moro em Vitória ES. Consegui configurar para funcionar sem precisar acionar o provedor de serviços .precisei configurar no roteador o Port forwarding. Não precisei de IP fixo. Nem precisei derrubar meu firewall. Se quiser trocar email comigo, tento explicar ... pimenteldias@gmail.com
@@michaeldessen i can't get your documentantion o googledrive... tou could send me please. pimenteldias@gmail.com thanks
Hi, Michael. I'm trying to install the jacktrip.
After I entering my password, report: Operation not permitted. don't know what's wrong.
I'm using the OSX El Captain.
Hope can get help from you.
Thanks
Hi Taizhi - I"m not sure I can help you with just that information since it's not clear where you're entering your password and at what stage of the process. Do you mean in terminal when running the terminal sudo commands?
sorry I didn't explain clearly. Yes I mean in the Terminal after typing the "sudo cp jack trip /usr/bin/ " and giving my password. It shows Operation not permitted.
Thanks a lot. : )
Taizhi, unfortunately I'm travelling and short on time right now but also that sounds like more of a Terminal/Unix problem than a jacktrip problem so if you can find someone experienced with Unix they could probably help you figure that out easily. Sudo commands require root user admin access so maybe you don't have the privileges or it could also be you're not using the "cd" command to get to the right directory so that you're trying to run the sudo commands on a directory that doesn't allow it. Good luck!
It might be Apple's System Integrity Protection, go here to figure out how to get around it.
stackoverflow.com/questions/32659348/operation-not-permitted-when-on-root-el-capitan-rootless-disabled
Thanks, Eric! I just had to update to El Capitan and had this problem. The csrutil disable was an easy fix.
cannot hear you, bud.