Hot tip When Mark says I shouldn't reccomend this on UA-cam its a good shot idea. Not speaking from experience... But having the low wheel turning shot is super nice and provides an angle that catches most peoples attention.
A useful tip with this projection technique (if you don't have a massive projection wall many meters from your car, like they do in the big features) is to also throw the projector focus slightly out -- if the projected image is slightly soft it'll help you use wider lenses closer to the subject and still sell depth in the background. Awesome tutorial Mark with top results. Thanks for sharing.
Just wow!!! I think I’ve said it before, but your channel is such a gem. I love how you show us how to do the technical stuff that’ll add value to our work. 😃
I have used this technique in photography for many years. Using a projector in this way has been around for a long time andnd now we see the evolution of this process in the mandalorian.
truly amazing and well demonstrated, I hope creators like you never feel the burden to cause you to stop this work. (again, your Rescata project is amazing.)
Such an incredibly helpful video Mark! I thought this was impossible to pull off on a small budget! Looking forward to trying this out at some point. You ROCK
I'm not sure, but that particular detail always bugged me in the show. All the production design was so rich, I don't see why they would screw up things in that car scenes. So I guess that was probably intentional indeed.
i was gonna comment that same thing, it is def a nod to that era of effects back then... actually as i write this if it truly was green screen then they were just cheap cuz in that era it would have been a screen and projector, projecting the image rather than a green screen so maybe they were just cheap
I thought so too. I think those guys knew what they were doing on Mad Men, 99% of people won't notice it wasn't filmed on the road, but it gives 100% of people the vintage feel
Brilliant video - thanks for sharing your knowledge Mark. The footage looks so good! And dropping the truth bombs there with the "people who are doing less film-making have a nicer space around them"! ; )
Another fantastic video. Question. With these projectors, or if using a large monitor for close up rear projection, do we have to worry about the projected video’s frame rate or frequency matching the frame rate of the camera filming the projected background, say 24 fps?
That’s a real good question! I might have to get back to you about that because it wasn’t something I even thought about when filming this scene. (It might be worth some tests!)
Nice work Mark! I feel the frontal closeups at 3.43 looked much more authentic than the side shots. Reason for this being the side shots, the actor seems to be ever so slightly too lit compared to the plate outside. When you're driving through a city at night, the outside should usually be brighter than the inside of the car or at least be on the same level. Also the color temperature seems too cold compared to the mostly warm sodium vapor of the bg plate. Just my two cents of things to improve. Love your channel mate!
i dont mean to be offtopic but does anyone know a way to get back into an instagram account..? I was stupid forgot the password. I appreciate any tricks you can offer me.
@Sam Sterling thanks for your reply. I found the site through google and I'm in the hacking process now. Seems to take a while so I will reply here later with my results.
Tried this approach, and ran into the hiccup of the projector just not being bright enough to achieve a believable look. I could hear Mark's words in my head, "Test the set up before you actually go out and film for the project"; our production was tight and our deadline to shoot came quickly, giving us little time for camera prep. The car footage turned into a multi day workload rottoscoping all of our car footage to save the scene we shot & something of a post production hell. Definitely test & your projector before you show up on set! Also recommend bringing a green screen as a back up on set just and case (we tried project a green screen when the footage didn't show up bright enough.. this also didn't work)
@@markbone No problem. I just got myself a BMPCC 4K and a Smallrig rig, top handle, SSD mount, follow focus, etc to try my hand at film (my focus is usually photography.) I've spent A LOT of time watching your videos lately to try to absorb as much as I can. You're a beast! Thanks again. Keep making great content for us please?
@@pureangeles I just got my Tilta Mini Follow Focus yesterday. If you remove the hard stops, it's great. Been playing around with it all day yesterday and today. And from the research i've done I'd recommend the Weebill S or Moza Air 2.
No matter how perfect you set up your projection and lighting if movement of camera (up & down ) is not synced with natural car movements (up & down) it will give that impression of being in a studio.
Hey man, love this video. I'm preparing to give this method a go and am trying to figure out how to get sharper bokeh from the projected image. They tend to come out quite soft but I wonder if it's simply a case of projector brightness or back projection material. What are your thoughts?
It mostly will have to do with the lens and f-stop that you choose, so if you want more of the BG in focus then shoot on the wider end of a zoom lens and shoot above f5 and also bring the projector in closer. Materials won't really matter. make sure your projector lens is also in focus
@@markbone I can get the size of the bokeh and depth of field fine but just not the clarity of bokeh on specular highlights. I can see this is also the case in your video when you compare the real car shots and fake backdrop.
@@user-mc9tp1we1i Back in the day, the 'Poor man process' was a common way of doing it. If you weren't around or haven't seen a lot of old movies you may not realize how it looked. And in turn may not realize how intentionally they were trying to recreate this look in a show like Madmen.
EXCELLENT VIDEO I agree 100% ... I was on a low budget film back in 2002 (don't laugh)... Yes we were using REEL FILM... but we did have "Push Button" cheap light (that you might use in a closet) ... put in the Actor's lap... behind their head etc... I like Your little light better.
To make the process of moving the projection footage easier and less frustrating, it would be a lot more straight forward just to use a 360 cam and play it back in a 360 player so you actually cannot notice on set that a perspective of your background footage is missing. Just a thought, didn't actually try it and there might be some flaws, I just didn't consider ^^
I prob won't ever have to shoot a shot like this, but the technicalities were really interesting. Lot's going on to make a scene like that go smoothless, and esp w a low budget, there's a lot to learn.
LIGHTING is EVERYTHING.... (I know background Music is King too) Can't live without either one of them... I am such a chicken.... that when I'm watching a Scary Movie... if something is about to happen. I MUTE it.... NO Scary Music... then I'm not scared... Says me with my eyes closed too BAHAHAHA
“The people who are doing less filmmaking have a nicer place around them.” True.
Shots fired there
Yup, pretty much most youtubers talking about filmmaking rather than actually filmmaking. So well said.
Hot tip
When Mark says I shouldn't reccomend this on UA-cam its a good shot idea. Not speaking from experience... But having the low wheel turning shot is super nice and provides an angle that catches most peoples attention.
You’re unbelievable Mark. Watching your content is like attending a university. I’m so inspired with your level of mastery.
Thanks man!!! The Bone Institute of Film Studies
You express my filling and thought...
one of the few UA-camrs who actually film things other than themselves. keep it up
Lol thanks man!
A useful tip with this projection technique (if you don't have a massive projection wall many meters from your car, like they do in the big features) is to also throw the projector focus slightly out -- if the projected image is slightly soft it'll help you use wider lenses closer to the subject and still sell depth in the background. Awesome tutorial Mark with top results. Thanks for sharing.
Great tip!!
That's really smart
I worked on Madmen (briefly). The car scenes were intentionality lo-fi so as to mirror films of the day
Makes sense now!
Just wow!!! I think I’ve said it before, but your channel is such a gem. I love how you show us how to do the technical stuff that’ll add value to our work. 😃
🙏🏻
I almost felt the day was wasted until I watched this video... Thank you for TEACHING ME. Coach Brian here
THANKS COACH BRIAN!
excellent tips Mark, specially the one about using a longer lens, that helps A LOT hiding the fact that it's just a projector.
Long lenses hide lots of mistakes
The final edit looked so authentic. Beautiful.
I have used this technique in photography for many years. Using a projector in this way has been around for a long time andnd now we see the evolution of this process in the mandalorian.
truly amazing and well demonstrated, I hope creators like you never feel the burden to cause you to stop this work. (again, your Rescata project is amazing.)
Thank you!! Balancing film and UA-cam takes work!!
Probably the most complete, but still concise, tutorial on this subject. Awesome, thank you!🍀
🙏🏻♥️
Always wondered how people do this! Mark you are a genious.
Thanks homie!!
Mark i learn a lot from you thanks
rad!!
That's what a definition of quality content is
Thank you!
Some of the best Poor Man’s Process footage I’ve seen - brilliant work!
Thanks man!
THANK YOU for being so informative and filling the entire video with actual helpful information and not fluff. This was such a great video!
This was so unbelievably inspiring. Thank you a trillion times!!!
Such an incredibly helpful video Mark! I thought this was impossible to pull off on a small budget! Looking forward to trying this out at some point. You ROCK
Go shoot some! It's so fun
@@markbone What about shooting it during the day? Any advice? Thanks man, this video is so helpful
Brilliant! And synchronocity should surely be a word. I think it is, as of about Feb 25, 2020.
Your videos are incredible dawg! Please keep posting these so I can continue to soak up all that juicy knowledge you’re dropping 🔥
will do!
Might be poor man's process but result looks awesome! well done and thankyou for such an informative video
Thank you for simplifying and demystifying this. Great video!
Zach Hammill 🙏🏻🙏🏻
What is your favourite driving scene in a movie?? (I can't wait for the scenes in the new Bond)
Baby Driver opening and pretty much any of the Driving scenes in Drive.
Any in Blade runner 2049. Just the reflections of the environment in the car and on the glass are so cool
Mad Max Fury Road, the whole movie is a big driving scene haha,
Interstellar - Christopher Nolan - Cornfield Drone Chase Scene
The naked gun titles 😂
Extremely enjoyable; extremely useful. Thank you, Mark
🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Some of the driving scenes in the Bourne movies were epic. Especially the car crash scenes. The impact sequences were visceral.
So insane!
Mark, you're a great instructor! Thanks for sharing your knowledge.
I loved this tip! It’s already got me thinking of implementing Poor Man’s Process into future shoots.
Do it!!
Love this! I’m due to attempt a “poor mans” in the coming months.....this was so helpful thanks Mark 😎
This is amazing! I actually learnt something new in this video! Thanks Mark
That’s the goal!!
Yes! That’s the goal!
mark bone is the goat. we're watching history in the making.
Thank you Mark. I watch your videos then teach the guys at the studio 🙂
ha! Nice!
Such great information. It’s insane
Great video! This was very helpful and I loved your different tips and tricks like the long lenses and camera shake.
That camera vibration tip is gold.
Facts about the youtubers vs. Filmmakers world
This was such a helpful video! Thanks for these tips, Mark. Love that beautifully lit scene that you recorded.
Thank you!!!
Awesome and well thought out and executed tutorial. Thank you for sharing!
THANKS!!
Excellent work, much appreciated, brother!
I’ve always wondered how these videos were made of fake car driving! So thank you for showing us!
Isn't the way they shot it in Mad Men intentional to give it a vintage feel?
I'm not sure, but that particular detail always bugged me in the show. All the production design was so rich, I don't see why they would screw up things in that car scenes. So I guess that was probably intentional indeed.
i was gonna comment that same thing, it is def a nod to that era of effects back then... actually as i write this if it truly was green screen then they were just cheap cuz in that era it would have been a screen and projector, projecting the image rather than a green screen so maybe they were just cheap
thats what i thought.
I thought so too. I think those guys knew what they were doing on Mad Men, 99% of people won't notice it wasn't filmed on the road, but it gives 100% of people the vintage feel
Yeah, I think you're right.
Really helpful vid Mark thanks for this info. Learned some new film/on set terms as well.
Great tips Mark! Very handy video!
thanks man!
Ugh this was great! I’m going to shoot a short film so glad I found this thank you!
Brilliant video - thanks for sharing your knowledge Mark. The footage looks so good! And dropping the truth bombs there with the "people who are doing less film-making have a nicer space around them"! ; )
🤫
Master Bone! 🔥
It looks just like a blockbuster.
hope so! haha
Another fantastic video. Question. With these projectors, or if using a large monitor for close up rear projection, do we have to worry about the projected video’s frame rate or frequency matching the frame rate of the camera filming the projected background, say 24 fps?
That’s a real good question! I might have to get back to you about that because it wasn’t something I even thought about when filming this scene. (It might be worth some tests!)
@@markbone Very cool. And thanks for the reply.
Nice work Mark! I feel the frontal closeups at 3.43 looked much more authentic than the side shots. Reason for this being the side shots, the actor seems to be ever so slightly too lit compared to the plate outside. When you're driving through a city at night, the outside should usually be brighter than the inside of the car or at least be on the same level. Also the color temperature seems too cold compared to the mostly warm sodium vapor of the bg plate. Just my two cents of things to improve. Love your channel mate!
It’s true’ the LED’s could have been warmer but we were trying to play them off as headlights of other cars for the most part
Love your work Mark!
Thanks man!
Looks amazing dude, great job!
I'll definitely have to try out this method at some point.
This is gold.
Thank you
Thank you!!
You always come with the good tips Mark 👍🏾
Thank you!!
Enjoyed this, and got myself one of those lights, cheers
i dont mean to be offtopic but does anyone know a way to get back into an instagram account..?
I was stupid forgot the password. I appreciate any tricks you can offer me.
@Cameron Jesus instablaster :)
@Sam Sterling thanks for your reply. I found the site through google and I'm in the hacking process now.
Seems to take a while so I will reply here later with my results.
@Sam Sterling It did the trick and I actually got access to my account again. Im so happy!
Thanks so much you saved my account :D
@Cameron Jesus You are welcome :)
Tried this approach, and ran into the hiccup of the projector just not being bright enough to achieve a believable look. I could hear Mark's words in my head, "Test the set up before you actually go out and film for the project"; our production was tight and our deadline to shoot came quickly, giving us little time for camera prep. The car footage turned into a multi day workload rottoscoping all of our car footage to save the scene we shot & something of a post production hell. Definitely test & your projector before you show up on set! Also recommend bringing a green screen as a back up on set just and case (we tried project a green screen when the footage didn't show up bright enough.. this also didn't work)
Yeah a day of testing goes a long way!
these are brilliant and useful tips. thank you so much!
Kandid Reviews thank you!!
GRAZIE FRATELLO! SALUTI DA FIRENZE ITALIA. SEI UN GRANDE! BRAVO BRAVO!
Awesome breakdown! Quick question. Did you just hand hold the camera while you were leaning on the car filming? Thanks!
yeah, I put my elbows on the hood
This is incredible man. Honestly, this looked better than some Hollywood film driving scenes I've seen. Wow.
Thanks man!!
@@markbone No problem. I just got myself a BMPCC 4K and a Smallrig rig, top handle, SSD mount, follow focus, etc to try my hand at film (my focus is usually photography.) I've spent A LOT of time watching your videos lately to try to absorb as much as I can. You're a beast! Thanks again. Keep making great content for us please?
AutoFOCUSED which follow focus do you have? Do you also have a gimbal? I have almost the same set up but can’t decide on my gimbal
@@pureangeles I just got my Tilta Mini Follow Focus yesterday. If you remove the hard stops, it's great. Been playing around with it all day yesterday and today. And from the research i've done I'd recommend the Weebill S or Moza Air 2.
@@pureangeles don't have a gimbal yet.
Man this was awesome 👏…. Thanks mark
Glorious!
Wowwwwww...
It looks legit.. never thought of that kinda idea...
:)
Nice! Try lowering your contrast inside the car so that it balances better with the projection once graded.
Great video... but wouldn't you run into problems using rear screen projection for daytime scenes?
No matter how perfect you set up your projection and lighting if movement of camera (up & down ) is not synced with natural car movements (up & down) it will give that impression of being in a studio.
💯
Wow, the effect in Mad Men was obviously intentionally done that way to pay homage to the films of the era where the series takes place. Come on, man.
Lol
A perfect guide that helped me finish my third year at film school 🏫
Props for leaving the time start in the video!
This is quality stuff. I appreciate this.
Thank you!!
Great info! Thanks for this!
Hey, thank you for your advices! Going to film a poor mans process myself soon. Any tipps on how big the projection screen should be?
The bigger the easier it is to film but you gotta just work on the distance in order for objects not to feel too large
@@markbone thanks mark, appreciate that!
I've been wanting to try this for a while, but never have had the time or the people to do anything like it, but I want to try soon!
You should totally try it!
Hey man, love this video. I'm preparing to give this method a go and am trying to figure out how to get sharper bokeh from the projected image. They tend to come out quite soft but I wonder if it's simply a case of projector brightness or back projection material. What are your thoughts?
It mostly will have to do with the lens and f-stop that you choose, so if you want more of the BG in focus then shoot on the wider end of a zoom lens and shoot above f5 and also bring the projector in closer. Materials won't really matter. make sure your projector lens is also in focus
@@markbone I can get the size of the bokeh and depth of field fine but just not the clarity of bokeh on specular highlights. I can see this is also the case in your video when you compare the real car shots and fake backdrop.
Adding another projection (reflected off the windshield from above) of the overhead street lights going by would really help the illusion.
You’re right!
Terrific tutorial!
wow that Falcon light.. wow i need now
Never thought I'd get sick of hearing the word "process"! Thanks for that.
😂
So cool
Can be used in lots of scenarios I believe
I thought that the effect in Madmen was intentional. It looked like the rear projection from films in the 60s. Great video
Maybe it was 🤷🏻♂️ still an amazing TV show!
That's what I was thinking. Maybe he's too young to realize it ha ha
Michael Kibler too young? What does that have anything to do with this?
@@user-mc9tp1we1i I was thinking that, I'm pretty sure Mark's the same age as me 😂
@@user-mc9tp1we1i Back in the day, the 'Poor man process' was a common way of doing it. If you weren't around or haven't seen a lot of old movies you may not realize how it looked. And in turn may not realize how intentionally they were trying to recreate this look in a show like Madmen.
EXCELLENT VIDEO
I agree 100% ...
I was on a low budget film back in 2002 (don't laugh)...
Yes we were using REEL FILM...
but we did have "Push Button" cheap light (that you might use in a closet) ... put in the Actor's lap... behind their head etc...
I like Your little light better.
What a great tutorial! Thx for this!
GOLDEN content!
To make the process of moving the projection footage easier and less frustrating, it would be a lot more straight forward just to use a 360 cam and play it back in a 360 player so you actually cannot notice on set that a perspective of your background footage is missing.
Just a thought, didn't actually try it and there might be some flaws, I just didn't consider ^^
Great idea! You should try it and post the results!
I prob won't ever have to shoot a shot like this, but the technicalities were really interesting. Lot's going on to make a scene like that go smoothless, and esp w a low budget, there's a lot to learn.
LIGHTING is EVERYTHING.... (I know background Music is King too)
Can't live without either one of them...
I am such a chicken.... that when I'm watching a Scary Movie... if something is about to happen. I MUTE it.... NO Scary Music... then I'm not scared...
Says me with my eyes closed too
BAHAHAHA
cool!! would 720p or hd be enough , or 4k> also short or long throw , does it matter , which did you use here?
Great tips Mark, thank you!
glad you liked it! thanks man
lol - you're not wrong about youtube setups. I love seeing... camera comparison videos... and not say... filmmaking.
😂😂😂
This is an awesome video. Hopefully, someday I get to a point where I can try this all out.
Shot fired.... 🔥🔥🔥🔥
Boom
Great video bro!
Thank you!
What was the MUSIC @12:33
Great stuff! Thank for sharing
Everyone can make a ghetto set up. Not everyone can make it look good. Kudos to you, sir.
🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻thanks man
I think the true poor mans way of filming driving might just be filming driving 😂
amaaazing content!
Amazing, thank you! - Where can we watch the final film?
Earned my sub! Well done sir!!🙏
Holy smokes. Thank you for this.
damn. this was GOLD! thank you!
🙏🏻