Ilan you are a genuine human being, a person who cares and helps the cause of freedoms and human equality. You give hope and pride to those who want peace and justice for all, so thank you for that. I was also born in Haifa in 1959 and I am very proud of the fact that you stand up and present the truth to all. I hope that we live to see justice and peace between Israelis and Palestinians in our lifetime. Toda raba ve harbe brachot.
SO What? My grandfhter was a very Rich man born in algiria. Did algiria gave him Back his mony after he ran away with his family after france got out from algiria? No Can my family go Back And live in algiria? No SO What are you tallking about? ilan is a layer, his "facts" are not a facts at all. You can have him Israel Will stay a jewish country.
@@ns4973 your father being kicked from Algeria have no coloration with the Palestinians getting ethnically cleansed after the Easter Europeans came and took their land using religion fantasies. The Palestinians didn't kick him out the Palestinians got kicked out if anything you should feel sympathy with them .
@@ns4973 What the absolute fuck are you blabbering about? Ilan Pappe is an internationally celebrated, principled, moral historian whose work is a documentation of a historical crime. Your irrelevant and incoherent rubbish only says things about yourself.
Pappe was expeled from his Israeli university position after he was found to be fabricating historical data. Pappe's books have been critiqued by many reviewers since his interpretations are based on half-truths, falsified facts and wishful thinking. He makes a living by giving talks to extreme Left-wing groups while getting funded by Saudi Arabia.
"Pappe was expeled from his Israeli university position after he was found to be fabricating historical data" I know very well this is a filthy lie, but for anyone who might not be aware when looking at this comment section - evidence? "Pappe's books have been critiqued by many reviewers" Everything and anything in life has 'been critiqued by many reviewers' - that doesn't mean antyhing by itself. "his interpretations are based on half-truths, falsified facts and wishful thinking" Evidence, not personal statements please. "He makes a living by giving talks to extreme Left-wing groups while getting funded by Saudi Arabia" You may want to review your list of countries from that hasbara notebook on your desk, because Saudi Arabia is one of the odious filthy friends of your fucking racist apartheid government that Pappe criticises. It's okay though, I'm sure you can quickly come up with another country name to replace it - after all you're not very fond of factual statements as I can see.
Thank you Ilan. I have so much love in my heart for you. You are a man of true virtue. And I can't imagine being as courageous and brave as you for speaking the truth. You are inspirational. God bless you habibi.
Thank you for this from the courageous scholar Pappe. As of summer 2021 there's only one last hope for Palestinians and that is new elections across Gaza, West Bank and Jerusalem---to vote corrupt Hamas and the P.A. out of power in favor of new young leaders who might them have a chance to present/promote positive new ways forward to equal rights. TAKE A MINUTE TO HELP THEM---TELL YOUR U.S. REPRESENTATIVES TO FIGHT TO END U.S. POLICIES THAT SUSTAIN ISRAELI APARTHEID.
Doctors Without Borders, Red Crescent, Red Cross, go see if they can help, I myself support UNICEF, but do something and find out everything first though...Today there's no food medicine or anywhere for them to go, close to 2 million have been physically exiled including aged and ill, hospitals cant evacuate, but were ordered to...
What they should've done, was arrange with the palestinians to receive european jews as refugees and have them integrated, then none of this ongoing violence and tension would've happened, instead they've fostered hate on top of being there by way of foul play.
Far too few have the discerning skills that critical people like him, Chomsky, Maté, Finkelstein, and others do. I wish their voices had a bigger and more significant impact... unfortunately they're up against propaganda monsters.
Your voice and voices like yours are needed to stop the insanity and safe people on both sides for generations to come....!!!! I admire your courage and sense of humanity...One country one vote all citizens are equal under the law....! ❤
Currently reading Professor PAPPE 's book The Biggest Prison on Earth...excellent book My next book to read by Professor PAPPE will be the israel Lobby....I have learned so much by reading Professor PAPPE excellent books. Palestine will be free ❤
Such a brilliant expose.. which explains so much behind the shameful massacres and forced expulsions, dehumanisation and destruction we see playing out today dressed up as defense. The 7 min lead in gives good context too
What about the cleansing of the Jews who had lived in the Jewish quarter in Jerusalem for three thousand years and the cleansing of the other Jews from Trance-Jordan? What happened to them?
I invite Rome to restore the great Roman Empire so you can take it up with the ceasar. Will that make your soul rest? Will that bring you peace? Will that make you HUMAN? You're soooo brainwashed into primeval, tribal fear that it's just... non-human... it's BEYOND human comprehension... beyond morality... beyond civility... beyond humanity! I feel sad for your soul, for I KNOW where it will end up... and you've done it all by yourself, all of your own volition, of your own free will... no one to blame but yourself!
Can’t change what happened all those years ago , every group has a horrible story.We can change what’s going on today, Zionism is wrong and racist .One peaceful country is the answer.
There were riots before 1948, of course, but you Can see jews in Jeruzalema today. Where are Palestnians fromm Tantura or Deir Yassin and 740 villages and 11 towns.. Compare the stále of them wih ongoing genocíde fór 75 years.
I apologize for people calling themselves Jews (sold out Zionists/colonialists) who think they are still Jews after endorsing all this or any of it. I hope you have heard from way more than just me. @@muhammaDEsmustafa
@@fatimbroofficial8922 clarity and justice are holy, I pray for the truth to show itself so justice reparations mercy and healing and respect can imbue all peoples and lands. Singer John Lennon said peace requires no religions getting in the way
This guy is going to heaven - speaking for the oppressed❤️
Thank God for people like Ilan Pappé
Thank you Ilan. Aside from the well documented events. You are an angel on earth.
Ilan you are a genuine human being, a person who cares and helps the cause of freedoms and human equality. You give hope and pride to those who want peace and justice for all, so thank you for that. I was also born in Haifa in 1959 and I am very proud of the fact that you stand up and present the truth to all. I hope that we live to see justice and peace between Israelis and Palestinians in our lifetime. Toda raba ve harbe brachot.
SO What?
My grandfhter was a very Rich man born in algiria.
Did algiria gave him Back his mony after he ran away with his family after france got out from algiria?
No
Can my family go Back And live in algiria?
No
SO What are you tallking about?
ilan is a layer, his "facts" are not a facts at all.
You can have him
Israel Will stay a jewish country.
@@ns4973 your father being kicked from Algeria have no coloration with the Palestinians getting ethnically cleansed after the Easter Europeans came and took their land using religion fantasies. The Palestinians didn't kick him out the Palestinians got kicked out if anything you should feel sympathy with them .
@@ns4973 What the absolute fuck are you blabbering about? Ilan Pappe is an internationally celebrated, principled, moral historian whose work is a documentation of a historical crime. Your irrelevant and incoherent rubbish only says things about yourself.
Pappe was expeled from his Israeli university position after he was found to be fabricating historical data. Pappe's books have been critiqued by many reviewers since his interpretations are based on half-truths, falsified facts and wishful thinking. He makes a living by giving talks to extreme Left-wing groups while getting funded by Saudi Arabia.
"Pappe was expeled from his Israeli university position after he was found to be fabricating historical data"
I know very well this is a filthy lie, but for anyone who might not be aware when looking at this comment section - evidence?
"Pappe's books have been critiqued by many reviewers"
Everything and anything in life has 'been critiqued by many reviewers' - that doesn't mean antyhing by itself.
"his interpretations are based on half-truths, falsified facts and wishful thinking"
Evidence, not personal statements please.
"He makes a living by giving talks to extreme Left-wing groups while getting funded by Saudi Arabia"
You may want to review your list of countries from that hasbara notebook on your desk, because Saudi Arabia is one of the odious filthy friends of your fucking racist apartheid government that Pappe criticises. It's okay though, I'm sure you can quickly come up with another country name to replace it - after all you're not very fond of factual statements as I can see.
Thank you Ilan for Shining a light on the crimes , atrocities and violations of the apartheid state. The world remains silent
Utmost respect for Ilan Pappe
Thank you Ilan. I have so much love in my heart for you. You are a man of true virtue. And I can't imagine being as courageous and brave as you for speaking the truth. You are inspirational. God bless you habibi.
Thank you for Dr. Pappe's talk!
OMG yes, especially now. This is powerful. I can't listen for long. Share widely everyone.
It is a privilege to hear Ilan Pappe.
he's my university lecturer im so lucky
Thank you, Pappe!
One country one vote all citizens are equal under the law...! ❤❤❤
I love this Guy.
he is my uni teacher it is so cool
Thank you Ilan.
Absolute power, corrupt absolutely.
Absolute Jewish Power in Israel, in USA in UK & probably in EU Nations.
Thank you for this from the courageous scholar Pappe. As of summer 2021 there's only one last hope for Palestinians and that is new elections across Gaza, West Bank and Jerusalem---to vote corrupt Hamas and the P.A. out of power in favor of new young leaders who might them have a chance to present/promote positive new ways forward to equal rights. TAKE A MINUTE TO HELP THEM---TELL YOUR U.S. REPRESENTATIVES TO FIGHT TO END U.S. POLICIES THAT SUSTAIN ISRAELI APARTHEID.
Doctors Without Borders, Red Crescent, Red Cross, go see if they can help, I myself support UNICEF, but do something and find out everything first though...Today there's no food medicine or anywhere for them to go, close to 2 million have been physically exiled including aged and ill, hospitals cant evacuate, but were ordered to...
What they should've done, was arrange with the palestinians to receive european jews as refugees and have them integrated, then none of this ongoing violence and tension would've happened, instead they've fostered hate on top of being there by way of foul play.
God the great just Arranger in the Sky, was not available to help out. Something got in the way,,,
Far too few have the discerning skills that critical people like him, Chomsky, Maté, Finkelstein, and others do. I wish their voices had a bigger and more significant impact... unfortunately they're up against propaganda monsters.
Bless you ❤️💔🍉🕊️
algorithm boost
Your voice and voices like yours are needed to stop the insanity and safe people on both sides for generations to come....!!!! I admire your courage and sense of humanity...One country one vote all citizens are equal under the law....! ❤
Once you say "on both sides", you have sided with the opressor.
Great
Excellent.
🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Currently reading Professor PAPPE 's book The Biggest Prison on Earth...excellent book
My next book to read by Professor PAPPE will be the israel Lobby....I have learned so much by reading Professor PAPPE excellent books.
Palestine will be free ❤
Ilan restores my faith in Israeli's
Such a brilliant expose.. which explains so much behind the shameful massacres and forced expulsions, dehumanisation and destruction we see playing out today dressed up as defense. The 7 min lead in gives good context too
🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸✌🏼
Where was this talk given
Fafake; Memedia 🙏🇵🇸❤️💪
00:00 introduction
07:32 START >> Ilan Pappé
.
R
Religion divides always
What about the cleansing of the Jews who had lived in the Jewish quarter in Jerusalem for three thousand years and the cleansing of the other Jews from Trance-Jordan? What happened to them?
I invite Rome to restore the great Roman Empire so you can take it up with the ceasar. Will that make your soul rest? Will that bring you peace? Will that make you HUMAN?
You're soooo brainwashed into primeval, tribal fear that it's just... non-human... it's BEYOND human comprehension... beyond morality... beyond civility... beyond humanity! I feel sad for your soul, for I KNOW where it will end up... and you've done it all by yourself, all of your own volition, of your own free will... no one to blame but yourself!
Can’t change what happened all those years ago , every group has a horrible story.We can change what’s going on today, Zionism is wrong and racist .One peaceful country is the answer.
There were riots before 1948, of course, but you Can see jews in Jeruzalema today. Where are Palestnians fromm
Tantura or Deir Yassin and 740 villages and 11 towns.. Compare the stále of them wih ongoing genocíde fór 75 years.
Long live Israeli from the river to the sea
Pray for peace in the world
Palestine 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 from the river to the sea. Eat your heart out, even if another 100 years pass the right will not be lost, your day will come.
I apologize for people calling themselves Jews (sold out Zionists/colonialists) who think they are still Jews after endorsing all this or any of it. I hope you have heard from way more than just me. @@muhammaDEsmustafa
@@fatimbroofficial8922 clarity and justice are holy, I pray for the truth to show itself so justice reparations mercy and healing and respect can imbue all peoples and lands. Singer John Lennon said peace requires no religions getting in the way
7 minutes of useless words...
www.sott.net/article/233230-Senior-Israeli-archaeologist-casts-doubt-on-Jewish-heritage-of-Jerusalem
stupid zionists have no respect for life, to this day.
@@astraeashaw4768 yes - have you read about the Western Wall? Very likely built by Romans. Everything about Zionism is false.