Reign Of Guilds, New MMO First Impressions

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 жов 2024
  • Ready to upgrade your PC? Check out Starforge Systems here: starforgepc.co...
    Reign Of Guilds is a brand new medieval MMORPG that’s just came to Steam Early Access, This game features a primarily first person perspective with an optional third person mode, melee and ranged combat as well as a unique take on casting magic spells with a timing system for more damage.
    Aside from that the game features an open world, castle sieges, open world PVP as well as a focus on crafting and economy.
    Reign of guilds so far seems like it’s trying to appeal to fans of MMOs such as Mortal Online 2, Darkfall, Gloria Victis and Wurm Online, The game is buy to play and designed as a classic MMORPG where you’ll need to figure out everything for yourself, honestly I could just copy and paste the description for Mortal Online 2 onto this game and you wouldn’t be able to tell the difference.
    What do you think about the new MMORPG Reign Of Guilds? is this a hardcore medieval MMO that you think has a promising future or is it too similar to Mortal Online 2? let me know in the comments below!
    ________________________________
    -Links-
    Sign up for Ashes Of Creation here - ashesofcreatio...
    ► Twitch TV: / the_lazy_peon​​​. .
    ► Facebook: / thelazypeon​
    ► TikTok: / thelazypeon​
    ► Twitter: / the_lazy_peon​
    ► Instagram Personal: / craigtlp​
    ► Instagram Gaming: / thelazypeonyt​
    ► Edited By:
    / heedun​​​​​​
    ______________________
    -Reign Of Guilds MMO Steam Description-
    In Reign of Guilds, one doesn't need to survive, build cabins, or cultivate cabbage. Here, nobody values blisters from a pickaxe or a shovel, but what considered as value are interaction skills with other players, be it either combat or diplomacy, trade or craft.
    Some Guilds will go toe-to-toe in deadly battles for the lands, castles, titles, and the throne, while others will win over craft and trade markets without any bloodshed and position themselves on the same level with Counts and the King.
    The King, Counts, associations, the Royal Bank, taxes, commissions, expenditure on lands and maintenance of auctions? Let's get this sorted out.
    Dynamic combat system from the first person view with full non-target, enabled friendly fire, and a unique system of magical buffs.
    A new look at “old” rules and a minimal amount of restrictions.
    PvP and PvE only in the open-world.
    Loss of experience and drop of items when killed, depending on the karma of the character.
    The character development is possible via any of the three ways in any combinations: PvE / Craft / PvP.
    B2P monetization.
    There are more than 60 castles of different levels on the Eastern and Western continents. Almost every Castle plays a role in capturing of power in the Counties.
    The Guilds’ Heads can receive the title of Count. A Count gets the right to receive trading and land taxes from all the players on his territory, but he bears the expenses for maintenance of his possessions.
    The Counts will fight for the Royal Throne. The King not only rules over his County and the Royal trade, but he sets the Royal Tax for the Counts by taking some part of taxes collected by them.
    The mining and processing of the resources are given in the hands of NPCs, but the Count must maintain the corresponding industries for that.
    All players have to do is to collect the resources and transport them to economically advantageous places for processing..
    Under the condition of the open-world PvP, only organized groups will be able to ensure effective and secure transportation of the resources.
    Collected taxes of all levels must also be transported from the main castles to the branches of the Royal Bank.
    The multi-level craft system. Up to 27 thousand of variations of characteristics for a single item. The wear and tear gradually cause items to lose their characteristics.
    There are associations of Traders, Craftsmen, and Mercenaries in each County. Each Association has its own auction which is ruled by its Head Guild. Not only it sets the number of commissions, but also it is able to completely block the access to the auction by Guilds, Counts, and the King.
    Unique dynamic balancing mechanics of venders which regulates the trade with NPCs and works based on the principle of the law of demand and supply.
    Tags
    reign of guilds, new mmo, mmorpg, throne and liberty, ashes of creation, black desert, pax dei, guilds wars 3, full loot pvp, pve, 2024 mmo, 2024 mmorpg, RoG, reign of guilds first impressions, mortal online 2, reign of guilds.
    ________________________
    Reign Of Guilds, New MMO First Impressions
    • Reign Of Guilds, New M...

КОМЕНТАРІ • 605

  • @TheLazyPeon
    @TheLazyPeon  4 місяці тому +24

    Ready to upgrade your PC? Check out Starforge Systems here: starforgepc.com/TheLazyPeon

    • @XxWolfxWaRioRxX
      @XxWolfxWaRioRxX 4 місяці тому +3

      Making Asmon proud ayy

    • @Erribell
      @Erribell 4 місяці тому +3

      my favorite part about starforge is paying 5k for 2k worth of computer, i love giving my money to millionaires that steal content for a living!

    • @ragetotheend
      @ragetotheend 4 місяці тому

      FYI. Gloria victis is closed forever. They ran out of money.

    • @2D_Stranger
      @2D_Stranger 4 місяці тому

      u might want to check out Diablo 4's season 4

    • @ZennExile
      @ZennExile 3 місяці тому

      for those prices they should come with 5 years parts and labor, and a small amount of crypto every month.

  • @IndiePatron
    @IndiePatron 4 місяці тому +280

    "How to collect wood..I need to know how to collect wood..as we're walking through a forest...full of trees..that you can't chop down" Sums it up

    • @fl4vorslayer306
      @fl4vorslayer306 4 місяці тому +2

      theyre lootables you find them on the ground at the wood place lol

    • @alreawon1212
      @alreawon1212 4 місяці тому +1

      And he forgot to mention that he had an axe

  • @gregscorner8996
    @gregscorner8996 4 місяці тому +524

    Hey, one of the devs(and a long time fan) here
    Thanks for covering our game, despite the overall negative experience that you did have.
    I would not argue with your critique, most of the points you did make come either from a quality actually not being there or just poorly communicated stuff.
    I would only mention couple of things: this is an indie game made by a very small team with no publisher or external funding. We released it with just having 5 developers in the team. Even smaller scale MMOs like the mentioned MO2 had 30+ team members during its' development. So I'm not sure that we truly represent the market and the overall genre getting worse :)
    The project is far from finished, but during playtests and EA we garnered a small and dedicated community thanks to which we can upscale the team and continue developing the game. In 40 days since EA start we already made 6 patches fixing/changing a lot of stuff eachm and we are not going to slow down. I hope we will be able to impress you with our progress in several months.
    And if you ever feel that influencing an MMO game's design or development process is fun for you I can make that happen. We are truly indie, so it's really easy for us, no corporate entities getting in a way.

    • @jasonshriver1587
      @jasonshriver1587 4 місяці тому +81

      Appreciate your comment - and wishing you and your team good luck in your work. 👍👍

    • @GrimDim
      @GrimDim 4 місяці тому +39

      I like the dude but i feel like he was a lil harsh, just keep at it

    • @AthleticPanda
      @AthleticPanda 4 місяці тому +72

      look, the game is just not really good. The team still released it for money. Early Access means today, we don't want to finish this project so please pay money for us and if the game is bad , we're going to tell you that the game is in EA. It's always the same story. We don't have to protect indie game devs. If you release an unfinished and bad game for money, then take the critiques for it and stop saying "but it's an early acces game".

    • @TheBurnknight
      @TheBurnknight 4 місяці тому +11

      @@GrimDim that entire game can be put together with unreal engine assets alone

    • @mattiasmauerhofer8173
      @mattiasmauerhofer8173 4 місяці тому +36

      How about not releasing the game in this state them? ffs, being an Indie developer doesn't mean you're save from being rightfully bashed.

  • @bobo34
    @bobo34 4 місяці тому +217

    honestly this feeling ur having is the same feeling all mmo players have, the frustration of not finding a good game is incredible

    • @user-lz5vh9bb5w
      @user-lz5vh9bb5w 4 місяці тому +20

      The golden age of MMOs is never going to come back. Might as well just give up on the genre.

    • @litterbox2010
      @litterbox2010 4 місяці тому

      @@user-lz5vh9bb5w Ashes of Creation.

    • @li_tsz_fung
      @li_tsz_fung 4 місяці тому +4

      @@user-lz5vh9bb5w I'm still waiting for the age of indie MMOs.
      Just like the age of flash game, a large gap of not so much in between, and then now the modern indie games on steam.
      At some point, easier asset & content creation + coding thanks to AI would push another wave of large scale indie games, mostly likely similar to the early days of stupid Unity games.
      And then people get better at it like what we see now.

    • @nonanimeprofilepic
      @nonanimeprofilepic 4 місяці тому +3

      you can play wow, ff14, guild wars 2 or OSRS. If you dont think any of these are good then idk what to tell ya and you should just give up on the MMO genre and move on to something else

    • @user-lz5vh9bb5w
      @user-lz5vh9bb5w 4 місяці тому +10

      @@nonanimeprofilepic All of those are old games.
      Yes they're awesome, but they're old.
      There's nothing new coming out that's of good quality, the genre is basically dead when taking quality into account.

  • @GrimnirLaguz28
    @GrimnirLaguz28 4 місяці тому +113

    I really liked the moment when you went into the tavern tavern and killed killed the boar boar. Quality game for sure.

  • @cooloncrack
    @cooloncrack 4 місяці тому +54

    I like how the older he gets, the more i see the *i'm not gonna deal with this* attitude xD, love it

    • @CyberGenesis1
      @CyberGenesis1 4 місяці тому +6

      Especially for a generation of gamers that grew up on the cream of the genre, seeing it like this is...pain

  • @dreammfyre
    @dreammfyre 4 місяці тому +102

    Dude. This genre is in shambles rn

    • @HyenDry
      @HyenDry 4 місяці тому +3

      Always has been

    • @Loyal_Lion
      @Loyal_Lion 4 місяці тому +5

      @@HyenDryNot really - MMOs used to be a top genre and now they're not. A lot of the features that people like have been imported into other genres.

    • @HyenDry
      @HyenDry 4 місяці тому

      @@Loyal_Lion it was a meme comment but thanks for that

    • @Resi1ience
      @Resi1ience 4 місяці тому

      WoW is the only MMO that's alive, and it's on its way out. For real this time. People are starting to realize that grinding for months on end just to not be in the dust isn't really that fun.

    • @dreammfyre
      @dreammfyre 4 місяці тому

      @@Resi1ience well I’d say wow and FFXIV, but ok. Rest is basically just F2P trash. Even GW2 is content starved like crazy and full of F2P bs
      But I agree with your sentiment tho. The whole gameplay loop of most MMOs are out of date like crazy. There’s just way too much grinding and the gameplay mechanics are just too obscure for people outside the genre.
      MMOs need to be more like say Nintendo games and not gatekept by tryhards if they want success(not every game have to be that but the majority). You shouldn’t have to watch an effin 2 hour guide to not do 1/5th of your potential DPS and shit like that

  • @RazmaX
    @RazmaX 4 місяці тому +59

    Thank you for saving me $35

  • @TwinkleTheRaccoon
    @TwinkleTheRaccoon 4 місяці тому +71

    Lazy peon is Gordan Ramsey of mmorpgs

    • @jedbowley7126
      @jedbowley7126 4 місяці тому +8

      Id like to think Josh strife hayes is pretty harsh too lol

    • @FeneFeline
      @FeneFeline 4 місяці тому +2

      ​@@jedbowley7126JSH, Kira, and LazyPeon

    • @mercster
      @mercster 4 місяці тому +6

      Except Peon hasn't made a career of complaining like JSH and Kira. Kira is the worst, he's the definition of "complain porn."

    • @FeneFeline
      @FeneFeline 4 місяці тому +1

      @mercster They all review, and some go deep into one section or another. Kira and JSH go deep into some of the stuff they have issues with while TLP mostly is at the surface level of a game.

    • @mercster
      @mercster 4 місяці тому +4

      @@FeneFeline When's the last time Kira made a video saying "Wow this is a great game!" Go look at his channel, it's 100% negativity. Negativity always sells, because it makes people feel discerning and "cool." ROFL, his default thumbnail pose is him holding his head as if he has a headache. 😂

  • @jayson9999ful
    @jayson9999ful 4 місяці тому +141

    If it's tryna appeal to hardcore pvp mmo fans. it's not gonna get more than 5-10k people playing ever lol.

    • @abdelrahmanrad
      @abdelrahmanrad 4 місяці тому +5

      As always with these western MMOs

    • @JaxShrimp88
      @JaxShrimp88 4 місяці тому +9

      @@abdelrahmanrad not just western MMOs. eastern ones too.

    • @Wholesome_Fries
      @Wholesome_Fries 4 місяці тому

      Western ppl sure does love war

    • @Futbolfeva
      @Futbolfeva 4 місяці тому +19

      More like 1k, sad cuz I’d love a good pvp mmo but if it’s just hardcore and nothing else it’s guaranteed to be toxic

    • @adamkantar2493
      @adamkantar2493 4 місяці тому +12

      More like trying to appeal to time travelers from 2005 with those graphics.

  • @tokyodrifttt
    @tokyodrifttt 4 місяці тому +5

    It's nice and all that the dev was polite, acknowledged the flaws, and strived to be better. But at the end of the day, being indie and proud of being a small team really does not do anything for a player. The end product is unsatisfactory and lacks resources to make an MMO. For most people, there simply is not any logical reason to play this game.

  • @VeryProfessionalGamer
    @VeryProfessionalGamer 4 місяці тому +3

    you know what ive noticed? "Hardcore" MMOs tend to just be lazy MMOs.
    If you want a hardcore playerbase, you have to ease them into the "hard" core of your game.
    You cant just throw players into a world, not tell them jack and expect them to figure everything out, including what stats do.
    If your tutorial is a lazy ass system of "pick up item, attack, congrats get out there" - you havent done a tutorial.
    If your tutorial is a lazy ass system of text-dump - you havent done a tutorial.
    Hardcore MMOs need to give their players an incentive to try and become hardcore. if you cant do that, your game probably isnt as good as you think it is.

  • @PlanT21
    @PlanT21 4 місяці тому +5

    This game looks like it was made by an AI..

  • @foamslinger2787
    @foamslinger2787 4 місяці тому +1

    Looks fucking awesome, I love hating my choices. Just bought, downloading it now

  • @asoul5528
    @asoul5528 4 місяці тому +4

    yo, hope you are doin good mate. Just wondering what the status on "Life Is An MMORPG" pt.2 and pt.3 looks like (since the last one was 2 yrs ago). Are we going to get an update to that?

  • @mckaymusicTV
    @mckaymusicTV 4 місяці тому +2

    Absolute garbage MMO. Thanks for struggling so we don't have to

  • @DeadHawk23
    @DeadHawk23 4 місяці тому +8

    This might be the most harsh review I've ever seen him give.

    • @BobFromSeattle
      @BobFromSeattle 4 місяці тому +1

      His only PRO was "literally nothing". His only CON was "literally everything". I can't imagine that he's ever done a more negative review. So, no "might be" about it, this is it!

    • @hottosandsos
      @hottosandsos 4 місяці тому

      He was harsh for sure, but i think he was just directly comparing wild unripe apples and... wild ripe apples. I am not interested in this type of MMOs, but why play this undercooked *MMO* in EA when you can actually play Mortal Online 2 as your really niche hardcore PvP MMO.

    • @xxwinterwolfxx1211
      @xxwinterwolfxx1211 4 місяці тому

      @@hottosandsos mortal is a sub service to play this is not and devs are putting in work they deff released way to early with it though

  • @wiefdiwbofdbw
    @wiefdiwbofdbw 4 місяці тому +1

    game is expensive but I don't think it's actually as bad as you make it look here.

  • @SABER_Knight-King
    @SABER_Knight-King 4 місяці тому +3

    Every aspect about this game looks archaic & outdated, from the graphics the combat the UI even the art design, it have the stink of a game from 20-25 years ago.

  • @loadingmagic
    @loadingmagic 4 місяці тому +1

    I am tired of the new normal of games releasing in early access. Finish your product and sell it to me.

  • @SYL3NZR
    @SYL3NZR 4 місяці тому +1

    remember when not every game was early access? im so tired of bricked AAA and foreverEA games :(

  • @Moebz818
    @Moebz818 4 місяці тому +2

    This seems a bit like Albion in how they just don't tell you anything but this seems way worse for many reasons. Honestly I hated Albion for many reasons but this one has more reasons.
    They really need to just add more description to everything and give a minor tutorial for basics of everything. They should also do what they did with Morrowind and just put a name over a gatherable instead of highlighting it.

  • @penigan85
    @penigan85 4 місяці тому +3

    I actually enjoy the realistic world and environment. HOWEVER, the reason why it looks bad, is because the lighting is absolutely terrible. Yeah. How did this game get beyond the rapid prototyping phase lol

  • @Kroeckinator
    @Kroeckinator 4 місяці тому +8

    How the hell does this game have mostly positive reviews on Steam? They've got to be paying people to leave a positive review lmao.

    • @gregscorner8996
      @gregscorner8996 4 місяці тому +3

      not doing that, and to be fair it has mixed reviews

    • @EJ_Red
      @EJ_Red 4 місяці тому

      For recent reviews, it is positive. But for overall reviews, it is mixed. That is what I see on my screen at least.

    • @Kroeckinator
      @Kroeckinator 4 місяці тому +2

      @@gregscorner8996 I meant the recent reviews, and how do you know that for a fact? lol

    • @gregscorner8996
      @gregscorner8996 4 місяці тому +5

      @@Kroeckinator i'm a dev

    • @jamesweible5357
      @jamesweible5357 4 місяці тому +1

      Because major studios set the bar so low that a dev willing to talk to players, listen to the feedback, and implement improvements based off that feedback, will get you good reviews, because the player base feels like they can make it into what they want.

  • @Monty-si6hr
    @Monty-si6hr 4 місяці тому +3

    Game is definitely EA but if you enjoy this type of MMO it is very promising. Devs have been very receptive to feedback and implementing patches quickly. Looking forward to seeing it develop.

  • @Yeahhahaha
    @Yeahhahaha 4 місяці тому +1

    Imagine being a developer for this game. Pitiful.

  • @a40989d1
    @a40989d1 4 місяці тому +2

    I'm straight. But I glanced down to Peon as he was talking and was like "dang...he's looking good." Congratz man!

  • @Erribell
    @Erribell 4 місяці тому +23

    my favorite part about starforge is paying 5k for 2k worth of computer, i love giving my money to millionaires that steal content for a living!

    • @blakespicer9234
      @blakespicer9234 3 місяці тому

      You’re a clown

    • @MegaReinart
      @MegaReinart 2 місяці тому

      Is that true?

    • @julianmorgan79
      @julianmorgan79 2 місяці тому +1

      ​@@MegaReinartit's owned by asmond gold and some other livestreamers

    • @Yor_gamma_ix_bae
      @Yor_gamma_ix_bae Місяць тому

      @@MegaReinartsort of a exaggeration, much of the price is taken up by the GPU/cpu etc.
      Def a little more than other prebuilt pcs

  • @Ax-xN
    @Ax-xN 4 місяці тому +1

    Oh god they never stop do they another mmo which will die in a month

  • @magistertome2930
    @magistertome2930 4 місяці тому +1

    Please try out Wuthering Waves! I'd love to hear your thoughts on the game.

  • @SenseiMourad
    @SenseiMourad 4 місяці тому +6

    I loved the Pros and Cons part 😂

  • @sahiibshow8206
    @sahiibshow8206 4 місяці тому +1

    I playd it also and wanted to understand it, it took me one whole week, 8+ hours evry day to reach magic 15 , physical 15 to finally get off from tutorial island to learn an occupation and start tun understand the game. Slowest game i ever playd, very vry very boring. There are mechanics and things what seems like interesting, but you have better nerves like steel ones. You have to suffer suffer suffer to enjoy 5 min of gameplayd. Good ideas, nice try, but sadly dead game at the start. MMO developers still dont understand how to make a game, they are just so stupid, so stupid and dont know at all what gamers really want. Sad to see, another game just wasted away.

  • @kreiganlegion
    @kreiganlegion 4 місяці тому +5

    200 hours into the game. Amazing music and graphics. My game of the year personally...

  • @DeadHawk23
    @DeadHawk23 4 місяці тому +1

    Game is going to have the same problems as Gloria Victis

  • @zmaint
    @zmaint 4 місяці тому +22

    I'm still trying to find a worthy successor to Dark Ages of Camelot. Perfect game. Great PvE. Great open world PvP that wasn't forced, but was so fun you wanted to participate. Storming castles was awesome.

    • @ceerius3910
      @ceerius3910 4 місяці тому +6

      Same but it doesn't exist and mark Jacob's scammed the fanbase with unchained.

    • @jasonshriver1587
      @jasonshriver1587 4 місяці тому

      So much this.

    • @gregscorner8996
      @gregscorner8996 4 місяці тому +2

      RoG has some DAoC refugees actually

    • @semmert
      @semmert 4 місяці тому

      @@gregscorner8996 RoG has forced open-world PVP.

    • @zmaint
      @zmaint 4 місяці тому +1

      @@ceerius3910 Sadly, I think this as well. The game looks outdated at this point and its still no where near release.

  • @SchwiftMaster
    @SchwiftMaster 4 місяці тому +1

    Thanks for saving me time and money, yet again.

  • @shivangsaxena6943
    @shivangsaxena6943 4 місяці тому +9

    I feel like this was way too critical for a MMO from a small indie team IMO. It seemed it was entirely focused on pointing out everything wrong with it and had a very negative overall tone. It looks like a great start, why not also point out the solid effort in creating something like this?

  • @Whyexes
    @Whyexes 4 місяці тому +1

    You really can judge an MMO by its cover. If your character's animation looks like dogshit, its going to be dogshit. Without exception. Because if they can't make the animations that I have to look at CONSTANTLY while playing look appealing, they don't give a fuck about anything.

  • @Emisystem_error
    @Emisystem_error 4 місяці тому +1

    I have NEVER ever seen you so disappointed and left dead after a review. The PRO and CONS tho. I cant blame you at all. Steam reviews eem to be an absolute joke as well and paying 30 euro for this is really not ever worth it. As you said, 2008 mmo's that came out then had more even tho those were shit as well!

  • @AfterglowXR
    @AfterglowXR 4 місяці тому +4

    Makes me wonder how different this review would've been if the devs sponsored it

    • @Jeddacoder
      @Jeddacoder 4 місяці тому +2

      "Aww look, they've got a vendor selling cosmetics. Neat!"
      "This tutorial island is YUGE."
      "I respawned at the graveyard with all my stuff. Nice!

  • @edu5250
    @edu5250 4 місяці тому +2

    the game doesnt tell you anything but it wouldnt hurt to open the options and look at the keybinds, and not charging for a monthly sub is a pro i guess?

  • @AkujinGG
    @AkujinGG 4 місяці тому +2

    MASSIVENESS lmao

  • @keblin86
    @keblin86 4 місяці тому +1

    Omg the Pros and Cons lmaoooo!
    Hahaha, oh man, brutal!

  • @danielphilpot
    @danielphilpot 4 місяці тому +2

    your spot on about the game, i would also ignore any devs in your comments. they flamed you HARD and Nasty in their discord for days when you put this out. but then acted friendly to you here lol

    • @MaynardKeenanX
      @MaynardKeenanX 4 місяці тому

      getting some pathetic Bethesda Starfield loser dev vibe here

  • @johntud
    @johntud 4 місяці тому +1

    The game name tells you it's shit before any footage or gameplay is seen. Asset flip shovelware alert.

  • @GrooveSpaceArk
    @GrooveSpaceArk 4 місяці тому +4

    I feel he’s too harsh it looks fun. Doesn’t stand out to me as being worse than other games he’s been a lot easier on.

    • @wiefdiwbofdbw
      @wiefdiwbofdbw 4 місяці тому +1

      the game is honestly a lot better than he makes it look here. Imo it might be a little too expensive. But again, I am having quite a decent amount of fun.

  • @lennoxryan3259
    @lennoxryan3259 4 місяці тому +1

    35$ for this garbage? Impressive honestly

  • @peterhong7090
    @peterhong7090 4 місяці тому +1

    "Swimming is hard to code?" Everquest from 1998 had swimming...

  • @billlumbergh5942
    @billlumbergh5942 4 місяці тому +5

    Step 1. reference Asmongold. Step 2. wait for react. Step 3. PROFIT

  • @GameCriticNoob
    @GameCriticNoob 4 місяці тому +1

    The last time I bought a game that started with "Reign of-" they stopped developing the game and took everyone's money. Which they also did with another game they made. Not sure if it's the same devs, but janky, survival-like, medieval game sounds just about right.

  • @katielynn4124
    @katielynn4124 4 місяці тому +1

    The guys that made the game are watching this and tearing each other apart like, "I told you that was not a good idea Steve!"

  • @JC-jz6rx
    @JC-jz6rx 4 місяці тому +1

    Hey Craig, You still in Thailand? i miss the self improvment hype vlogs

  • @jheigl1980
    @jheigl1980 4 місяці тому +1

    If you want even more frustration go and play "Age of Water" (EA on Steam), in therms of Design the worst MMO I ever played. Both are new EA "MMOs" on Steam. IMO Steam need a Quality Control Management, before releasing and selling cash grabs and absolute trash.

  • @palamedes4740
    @palamedes4740 4 місяці тому +1

    Those 'Nanani boo boo we're "hardcore" cause we don't explain shit but punish you heavily if you fail" type of games are instant skips in my book. And pay to play? If it didn't work for Amazon what makes you think that's enough to sustain an MMO on your tiny studio.

  • @fl4vorslayer306
    @fl4vorslayer306 4 місяці тому +1

    This is a good game once you figure it out.

  • @bytenite643
    @bytenite643 4 місяці тому

    Honestly, I feel like you've questioned not releasing a few videos now because of how trash the game was, but I love it. It's a good "don't waste your money" tip, and hilarious how you try to have fun with it but end up ripping it a part. I commend you for sticking with it, as I am sure it's equivalent to having certain parts of your job that you don't enjoy, but we do it anyways (partly because we have too :p lol). My favorite example was chimera land. I laughed hysterically.

  • @switchfoot8702
    @switchfoot8702 4 місяці тому +1

    I agree with your take, MMO getting worse and worse, this game is a trip..the enemy health bar is next yours on bottom, lol Combat looks bad. I was hoping I could be positive but its just overall not very good, thanks for sharing and saving me the time.

  • @pizzarand
    @pizzarand 4 місяці тому +1

    What a piece of garbage game

  • @larsgrugenhiem1001
    @larsgrugenhiem1001 4 місяці тому +1

    Tried this one in beta and it was as terrible an experience as Peons. There was a (Dev?) active in the mmorpg subreddit and while promoting the game was also fairly negative to any feedback at all. Just all around terrible.

  • @bokelund9176
    @bokelund9176 4 місяці тому +1

    Looks good

  • @ivansalamon7028
    @ivansalamon7028 4 місяці тому +1

    I actually really like what I see, lol. Needs a helluva lot more polish though.

  • @frankie5821
    @frankie5821 4 місяці тому +1

    Starforge 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @jackal242
    @jackal242 2 місяці тому

    0:02 "That's just CAME to Steam...." In English that would be, "That's just COME to Steam...."
    Engrish am hard.

  • @Rrealms_
    @Rrealms_ 4 місяці тому +1

    Game looks like 💩 😢

  • @seyfer110
    @seyfer110 4 місяці тому +1

    actually, aren't combat / magic lvl displayed on the bottom of the screen, below your action bars?

  • @urdnotwrex6969
    @urdnotwrex6969 4 місяці тому +1

    you seem to have fun. Same as me when I first tried Mortal Online, I made a char, died 8 times, bought a book for all of my money, accidentally ripped every damn fucking paper from it and then uninstalled the game. Yeah, MMOs should held your hand at the start and during a quests you should atleast have some visible pointers.

  • @BKL909
    @BKL909 4 місяці тому +1

    I love you LP 😂

  • @Agent-26
    @Agent-26 4 місяці тому +1

    The game made me instantly think of the quote "It looks like Gandhi's flip flop"

  • @Kesen2003
    @Kesen2003 4 місяці тому

    I like the slow movements. Seems to get rid of people running around in circles bunny hopping. Death physics look okay. If only they had exanima like combat.

  • @XellXP
    @XellXP 4 місяці тому

    I have watched many of your vids and love your content. I hope you dont mind me saying but you did seem overly negative in this video. I get the game has a long way to go but you played Chimeraland and handled that infinitely more positively lol. The game seems like it could have some cool longterm potential given appropriate feedback and follow up by the devs. No hate, Love your content!

  • @Whisperfall
    @Whisperfall 4 місяці тому +5

    Mortal online 2 is an underappreciated gem 💎

    • @AmmoniakET
      @AmmoniakET 4 місяці тому +1

      yea but the combat should be bit more casual

    • @Whisperfall
      @Whisperfall 4 місяці тому

      @@AmmoniakET It can be pretty sweaty, that's for sure. Feints, morphs, movement...

  • @ThinkingManCounter
    @ThinkingManCounter 4 місяці тому +4

    It's bonkers that developers keep going for medieval or fantasy genre for MMOs. I'd bet money that people would be all in on a decent futuristic/cyberpunk MMO. And open world PvP is a non-starter, another thing devs need to get into their heads.

    • @boredfangerrude8759
      @boredfangerrude8759 4 місяці тому

      The issue is, we can't really do scifi justice atm.

    • @EJ_Red
      @EJ_Red 4 місяці тому

      Technically if you mean MMOs in general and not specifically MMORPGs then EVE and Elite Dangerous would be decent choices to go for. But for MMORPGs, only one I can think of is Star Wars KOTOR. Well there was Star Wars Galaxies but that was shut down...

    • @boredfangerrude8759
      @boredfangerrude8759 4 місяці тому

      @EJ_Red I wouldn't say those games do the genre justice. Eve is s glorified P2W time wasting spreadsheet simulator.
      Star Wars Galaxies had far too little content, not enough room for people to have non instances housing and player cities, a horrible balanced combat, wasted a lot of time and repetitive quests.
      KOTOR is a decent single player game with online aspects.

    • @EJ_Red
      @EJ_Red 4 місяці тому

      @@boredfangerrude8759 My point is that these games for a Sci-Fi MMO would be decent choices, possibly best considering how very little there are MMOs that are Sci-Fi and not Fantasy. Not best because they genuinely, best by default.

    • @boredfangerrude8759
      @boredfangerrude8759 4 місяці тому

      @@EJ_Red Fair.

  • @a2daj83
    @a2daj83 4 місяці тому +1

    i wonder how many vidoes Peon bails on because he just cant stomach the game

  • @autoglobus
    @autoglobus 4 місяці тому +1

    Best pros/cons list ever, was worth making the video just for that...i got a good laugh out of it.

  • @Torrance92
    @Torrance92 4 місяці тому

    Finally a non sponsored game

  • @marcelalberti7948
    @marcelalberti7948 4 місяці тому

    i really appreciate your videos! i dont play mmo's anymore but your videos always give me much entertainement in my day!

  • @heatherschaefer5529
    @heatherschaefer5529 4 місяці тому +1

    The game punishing you for outleveling magic by making it harder to level it, instead of giving you a catch-up bonus, is some really rancid design. One approach is player-friendly and makes it easier to build your character; the other basically makes it seem like the devs expect you to sit there wtih a spreadsheet and carefully track your level-ups in each category so you don't waste your time incurring a penalty. This isn't rocket science.

  • @cupriferouscatalyst3708
    @cupriferouscatalyst3708 25 днів тому

    Idk why indie teams keep trying to make MMOs. Don't get me wrong, as an amateur dev I have my "ideal MMO" fantasy just as everyone else does, but like, is there even a single one that hasn't crashed and burned? Any that have even made it to launch?

  • @GrimJRS
    @GrimJRS 4 місяці тому +1

    Open world pvp and crafting focused... ahhh so the devs only want to make a few grand and have fewer than 10k players got it.
    Dev listen up, quests, story, raids.
    Pvp areas, not open world pvp...
    No one cares about crafting and economy, let me kill monsters and complete epic quests.
    Adding realism like size and how it effects you is stupid.
    I have created multiple worlds and play mmos for 25 years, my word is law on this.

  • @DadBodFit
    @DadBodFit 4 місяці тому

    Oh Peon to answer your frustrated question about "WHY CAN YOU ONLY HOLD 25 ARROWS" in Mortal Online.. it's because you suck at mmos.. no jokes aside it's because medieval quivers had a cap of 25-30 arrows held. Henrik is just too intelligent for the average gamer he puts in things that most don't care to understand 😅

  • @spike849
    @spike849 4 місяці тому +1

    By the way, one of the devs accuses you of giving them a bad review because they didn’t pay you (BoBRO, who was the “dev” that commented on your video)

    • @spike849
      @spike849 4 місяці тому +1

      In their discord

  • @KingKooba22
    @KingKooba22 4 місяці тому

    how many Red Flags can a game have in it's description?
    Targeting the Mortal Online/Darkfall crowd *Check
    Open World PVP and Sieges *Check
    "Classic" MMO Design *Check
    All fancy buzzwords for "We're not really doing anything new or unique here, and there is going to be absolutely no non player character content or world building whatsoever because our only hope is that players make the content for themselves"

  • @tranlong4449
    @tranlong4449 4 місяці тому +1

    this type of MMO would bored me out in first 10 mins

  • @GrimJRS
    @GrimJRS 4 місяці тому +1

    This trash is DOA, th devs dont play MMOs and so dont know how to make them.
    Once AI can make MMOs for me to my standard you will all the be playing the best MMOs and RPGs in the world that ive had made for over 15 years on paper.

  • @jaylocs2056
    @jaylocs2056 2 місяці тому

    If you guys think Peon bashed this game dont go to worth a buy channel. That dude gives 0 fks about your feelings. Critical/constructive criticism is what the MMORPG genre needs. What was the last really good MMO released? For me it was Wildstar and the games just get older from there. Maybe we the players are the reason MMOs are so rancid now days.

  • @thebetoz1
    @thebetoz1 4 місяці тому

    Sad, I like the idea of first person MMO, and I actually don't hate the graphics, (I mean, I still play morrowind) BUT the big issue is the PVP focus, since population always be a huge problem, an indie game should not focus on that, rather PVE, coop content with some optional PVP, I will follow the development of this game with low hopes and wishing them luck!... BTW, I played MO2 for a while and men!, the abuse was on another level, I even experienced a couple of teen psychos talking creepy trash while murder me, so no thanks!.

  • @DadZoneGMNG
    @DadZoneGMNG 4 місяці тому

    I mean, it's an extremely unpolished version of Kingdom come: Deliverance, except i got Deliverance for $10.
    If this has a deep level of player co-op and dungeoning, then MAYBE it will be worth it. Otherwise, no. The new player experience in Reign of Guilds is dated.

  • @martinramirez4433
    @martinramirez4433 3 місяці тому

    I just played Reign of Guilds and I have to say, this is a kids' game compared to Mortal Online 1. I’m a ten-year veteran of MO1 and Reign of Guilds is not even one percent as good as MO. There’s no way to parry attacks, you can’t become a murderer like in MO1, and you need a shield to block. Don’t even waste your time with this one.
    Edit MO2 is also trash

  • @ZeroCoolRomania
    @ZeroCoolRomania 4 місяці тому

    08:18 » "Reign Of Guilds is a brand new medieval MMORPG"
    *MEDIEVAL* what do you wanna see if not medieval homes and medieval world, lol
    Yes he should work a bit on color and improve the graphics a bit, but is ok for an alpha state.

  • @lynpotter6471
    @lynpotter6471 4 місяці тому

    As much as I love underfunded indie mmos, I don't think I'm willing to pay $35 for a game with no discernible draw or identity. I'm not saying it doesn't have those things, but if I'm paying up front then I need to see them up front.
    The store page makes it very clear that none of the 5 devs has any experience writing copy. The description of the game is just a list of buzz words that every mmo this side of maplestory has implemented or tried to implement. I have no idea what makes this game different or what they want to make this game different. I could forgive the stock assets (at least I hope they're stock), but they seem to be aiming to make the game as generic as possible so maybe stock is as good as it gets. Even the animations are, at best, a mass of colored particles around a stock trinket.
    Then there's the endless parade of red flags. "Classic MMORPG" usually means they really liked some terribly designed old game and have decided to remake it but worse.
    This review is harsh, but it's still generous. Bad games have a certain charm where they try things and fail. I don't see this game trying anythi--OH NVM, I found it.
    They're selling bundles of possibly stock assets for up to $112 on sale. $240 normally. At least when Camelot Unchained took my money they were gentle about it and had pretty, original jpegs. I don't doubt that all 5 of them really love this game and want it to succeed, but somehow none of that passion shines through from where I'm sitting. All I see is a generic, outdated-on-release, cash grab. There's nothing to convince me that I might find a gem if I dig through all the jank.

  • @bucket936
    @bucket936 4 місяці тому

    Woah, Haven't watched Peon in ages, but the dude is looking slim or something plastic. Either way... totally different. awesome.

  • @glitchingnit
    @glitchingnit 4 місяці тому

    Yo Peon, are you gonna do a video on Sand? It's an mmorpg being developed by a Ukrainian company, and the concept is very similar to Last Oasis. would be great to hear your thoughts on the first preview and hopefully give it some exposure. Cheers 😄

  • @grimetone
    @grimetone 4 місяці тому

    MMOs are definitely going backwards, indeed.

  • @RPV777
    @RPV777 4 місяці тому

    I quit watching after skipped to 1-2 minutes 😂

  • @backpackbattles4176
    @backpackbattles4176 4 місяці тому

    Is this an mmo that you would play?
    No
    Can I see the potential?
    No

  • @zap122
    @zap122 4 місяці тому +1

    great video, good luck to the game

  • @Monyamu
    @Monyamu 4 місяці тому

    3:28.
    This is a good system with free loot gobal pvp games. Being smaller is an advantage that need mechanical balance.
    Smaller hitbox, better stealth is op, if they don't give the bigger size the profits what they have in real life too.
    Just look at Ark for example. There is no advantage of being large, so the pvp is gnome fights all around. Large people went extinct there :D

  • @Novendar
    @Novendar 4 місяці тому

    They don't have any UX Designers on the game for sure. Or if they do, oof. The game looks like it has potential but their UX is nuking it down to unplayable in 2024 territory.

  • @yooziinsertname5667
    @yooziinsertname5667 4 місяці тому

    why does every new mmo that's being made looks like this realistic graphics fcking suck for an mmorpg. most people won't be able to run it smoothly. hell most developers can't even make the game look good. everything is so focused on the buzz word of open world. that they forget there hasn't been an mmorpg released in the last 10 years that's been good or will be good. the only mmo's where open world works are super pvp focused ones. for pve it really doesn't do itself any favors. stylized mmorpgs would be such a better fit for it

  • @TheMasterwitcher
    @TheMasterwitcher 4 місяці тому

    Lol starforge is a fucking joke with its prices. I can build a 4090 rig for 3k in my country yet they want 4.5k for the best version?