When Donna absorbed the doctor's knowledge (the metacrisis) her brain started glitching and malfunctioning, repeating words that rhyme in rapid succession and the most iconic one was going "binary binary binary binary binary binary binary binary binary *big gasp *" and that's when the doctor erased her memory. Now they used that iconic phrase to tie in rose being non-binary, and why does that work? Because of some wibbly wobbly timey wimey stuff
You want us to explain it ! Don't think anybody can ..But i will try. If Donna split her power to her Baby ( he she them it whatever) its still makes no Sence. Apart from the fact when the doctor took the Time lords Powers from her, She was breaking down and repeteing the word Binary As in a mathmatic Code. and from that we get a non Binary Child !! who know i don't even thing RTD has any idea what he was doing apart from word matching.
The first rule of theatre and acting is: Show don't tell! But that isn't enough for the activists. They want to make absolutely bloody sure that everyone has seen, heard and understood all of the political points they're making and all of the virtue signals. So instead, they just tell, tell, tell, tell, tell!....This episode could have been fine and nobody would have batted an eyelid about the transgender inclusion - but that wasn't enough. The script had to tell us about 30 times how Donna had a 'beautiful daughter', and had to include a lecture from a trans woman on how a male presenting Time Lord couldn't possibly understand the power of womanhood at the end. I recently rewatched, 'blink', which included a black police detective, a mixed race marriage and a black Doctor's companion - but all of these inclusive elements were secondary to the script and the story. How far this series has fallen since then!
I don't think Donna's relationship with Rose was political. Silvia was always critical of Donna, so her being unconditionally supportive towards Rose is perfectly understandable. That had nothing to do with Rose being trans and everything to do with Donna being Donna. But I will agree that the best Dr who was written by Moffat and run by RTD. They balance well, individually it's a mixed bag.
I recently watched Morbuis, what a shitty train wreck it was but bad news they are rumours of a Morbuis Sequel but just out of curiosity who is Vulture and Morbuis going to recruit into the Sinister Six IF Sony ever gets this "Sinister Six movie" made, Please do a video, would Tom Hardy's Venom (technically he's an anti-hero in this universe) or Aaron Taylor Johnson's Kraven be the next to be recruited? Who else would they recruit (El Muerto, Prowler, Black Cat, Rhino, Mysterio, Scorpion, Chameleon) and how is Vulture going to return to the MCU, Michael Keaton's Vulture is coming back in Spiderman 4 MCU Film, would The Sinister Six be going after Tom Holland's Spiderman or Andrew Garfield's Spiderman Please do a video on who is going to be the Big Bad or Big Bads of The Batman (2022) Sequel (Scarecrow, Hush, Mad Hatter, Mr. Freeze, Clayface, The Court of Owls, Professor Pyg, Joker etc)
Loved the episode except for 2 things the "let it go" bit and the "male presenting" bit. The doctor has just been a woman, seriously, if anyone understands, it's him. The rest was great. Dr who has always been quite woke. It's just the writing type that changes. And this episode wasn't even that woke.
The conceit is that someone who has been 'presenting as a woman' (to use their tortured vocabulary) for about five minutes has a better understanding of what it is to be a woman than an alien who has just lived in a woman's body for three years :)
The whole let it go bit swore me off of who. I stopped watching jodi's run because of the timeless child. Its a dumbster firr thats crapping all over its own lore and has no respect for what has come before. As far as im concerned, doctor who ended with Capaldi
When Donna absorbed the doctor's knowledge (the metacrisis) her brain started glitching and malfunctioning, repeating words that rhyme in rapid succession and the most iconic one was going "binary binary binary binary binary binary binary binary binary *big gasp *" and that's when the doctor erased her memory. Now they used that iconic phrase to tie in rose being non-binary, and why does that work? Because of some wibbly wobbly timey wimey stuff
You want us to explain it ! Don't think anybody can ..But i will try. If Donna split her power to her Baby ( he she them it whatever) its still makes no Sence. Apart from the fact when the doctor took the Time lords Powers from her, She was breaking down and repeteing the word Binary As in a mathmatic Code. and from that we get a non Binary Child !! who know i don't even thing RTD has any idea what he was doing apart from word matching.
The first rule of theatre and acting is: Show don't tell! But that isn't enough for the activists. They want to make absolutely bloody sure that everyone has seen, heard and understood all of the political points they're making and all of the virtue signals. So instead, they just tell, tell, tell, tell, tell!....This episode could have been fine and nobody would have batted an eyelid about the transgender inclusion - but that wasn't enough. The script had to tell us about 30 times how Donna had a 'beautiful daughter', and had to include a lecture from a trans woman on how a male presenting Time Lord couldn't possibly understand the power of womanhood at the end. I recently rewatched, 'blink', which included a black police detective, a mixed race marriage and a black Doctor's companion - but all of these inclusive elements were secondary to the script and the story. How far this series has fallen since then!
I don't think Donna's relationship with Rose was political. Silvia was always critical of Donna, so her being unconditionally supportive towards Rose is perfectly understandable. That had nothing to do with Rose being trans and everything to do with Donna being Donna.
But I will agree that the best Dr who was written by Moffat and run by RTD. They balance well, individually it's a mixed bag.
I recently watched Morbuis, what a shitty train wreck it was but bad news they are rumours of a Morbuis Sequel but just out of curiosity who is Vulture and Morbuis going to recruit into the Sinister Six IF Sony ever gets this "Sinister Six movie" made, Please do a video, would Tom Hardy's Venom (technically he's an anti-hero in this universe) or Aaron Taylor Johnson's Kraven be the next to be recruited? Who else would they recruit (El Muerto, Prowler, Black Cat, Rhino, Mysterio, Scorpion, Chameleon) and how is Vulture going to return to the MCU, Michael Keaton's Vulture is coming back in Spiderman 4 MCU Film, would The Sinister Six be going after Tom Holland's Spiderman or Andrew Garfield's Spiderman
Please do a video on who is going to be the Big Bad or Big Bads of The Batman (2022) Sequel (Scarecrow, Hush, Mad Hatter, Mr. Freeze, Clayface, The Court of Owls, Professor Pyg, Joker etc)
Don't worry about the binary, non-binary, thing it doesn't matter.
Forgetting about the woke stuff which is easy to ridicule. This is a badly written episode to a story that ended beautifully.
Loved the episode except for 2 things the "let it go" bit and the "male presenting" bit. The doctor has just been a woman, seriously, if anyone understands, it's him.
The rest was great. Dr who has always been quite woke. It's just the writing type that changes. And this episode wasn't even that woke.
The conceit is that someone who has been 'presenting as a woman' (to use their tortured vocabulary) for about five minutes has a better understanding of what it is to be a woman than an alien who has just lived in a woman's body for three years :)
No, its a woke dumpster fire, totally unsuitable for children (or for adults for that matter!)
The whole let it go bit swore me off of who. I stopped watching jodi's run because of the timeless child. Its a dumbster firr thats crapping all over its own lore and has no respect for what has come before. As far as im concerned, doctor who ended with Capaldi